Selective ion-permeation through strained and charged graphene membranes

Ion-Ion Selectivity of Synthetic Membranes with Confined Nanostructures

Synthetic membranes featuring confined nanostructures have emerged as a prominent category of leading materials that can selectively separate target ions from complex water matrices. Further advancements in these membranes will pressingly rely on the ability to elucidate the inherent connection between transmembrane ion permeation behaviors and the ion-selective nanostructures. In this review, we first abstract state-of-the-art nanostructures with a diversity of spatial confinements in current synthetic membranes. Next, the underlying mechanisms that govern ion permeation under the spatial nanoconfinement are analyzed. We then proceed to assess ion-selective membrane materials with a focus on their structural merits that allow ultrahigh selectivity for a wide range of monovalent and divalent ions. We also highlight recent advancements in experimental methodologies for measuring ionic permeability, hydration numbers, and energy barriers to transport. We conclude by putting forth the future research prospects and challenges in the realm of high-performance ion-selective membranes.

A New Strategy for Highly Efficient Separation between Monovalent Cations by Applying Opposite-Oriented Pressure and Electric Fields

Biological ion channels exhibit excellent ion selectivity, but it has been challenging to design their artificial counterparts, especially for highly efficient separation of similar ions. Here, a new strategy to achieve high selectivity between alkali metal ions with artificial nanostructures is reported. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and experiments are combined to study the transportation of monovalent cations through graphene oxide (GO) nanoslits by applying pressure or/and electric fields. It is found that the ionic transport selectivity under the pressure driving reverses compared with that under the electric field driving. Moreover, MD simulations show that different monovalent cations can be separated with unprecedentedly high selectivity by applying opposite-oriented pressure and electric fields. This highly efficient separation originates from two distinctive ionic transporting modes, that is, hydration shells drive ions under pressure, but drag ions under the electric field. Hence, ions with different hydration strengths can be efficiently separated by tuning the net mobility induced by the two types of driving forces when the selected ions are kept moving while the other ones are immobilized. And nanoconfinement is confirmed to enhance the separation efficacy. This discovery paves a new avenue for separating similar ions without elaborately designing biomimetic nanostructures.

Selectivity of ion transport in narrow carbon nanotubes depends on the driving force due to drag or drive nature of their active hydration shells

Molecular dynamics simulations have revealed the important roles of hydration shells of ions transported through ultrathin carbon nanotubes (CNTs). In particular, ions driven by electric fields tend to drag their hydration shells behind them, while for ions transported by pressure, their hydration shells can actively drive them. Given the different binding strengths of hydration shells to ions of different sizes, these active roles of hydration shells affect the relative entry rates and driving speeds of ions in CNTs.

Controlling ion transport in a C2N-based nanochannel with tunable interlayer spacing

Selective ion transport through a nanochannel formed by stacked two-dimensional materials plays a key role in water desalination, nanofiltration, and ion separation. Although there have been many functional nanomaterials used in these applications, how to well control ion transport in a laminar structure so as to obtain the desired selectivity still remains a challenging problem. In the present work, the transport of ions through a C₂N-based nanochannel is investigated by using all-atom molecular dynamics simulation. It is found that C₂N-based nanochannels with different interlayer spacing posses diverse ion selectivity, which is mainly attributed to the distinct loading capability among ions and the different velocity of ions inside the nanochannel. Moreover, we also find that the ion selectivity is dependent on the electric field, but nearly independent of the salt concentration. The present study may provide some physical insights into the experimental design of C₂N-based nanodevices in nanofiltration.

Nanoconfinement-Mediated Water Treatment: From Fundamental to Application

Safe and clean water is of pivotal importance to all living species and the ecosystem on earth. However, the accelerating economy and industrialization of mankind generate water pollutants with much larger quantity and higher complexity than ever before, challenging the efficacy of traditional water treatment technologies. The flourishing researches on nanomaterials and nanotechnologies in the past decade have generated new understandings on many fundamental processes and brought revolutionary upgrades to various traditional technologies in almost all areas, including water treatment. An indispensable step toward the real application of nanomaterials in water treatment is to confine them in large processable substrate to address various inherent issues, such as spontaneous aggregation, difficult operation and potential environmental risks. Strikingly, when the size of the spatial restriction provided by the substrate is on the order of only one or several nanometers, referred to as nanoconfinement, the phase behavior of matter and the energy diagram of a chemical reaction could be utterly changed. Nevertheless, the relationship between such changes under nanoconfinement and their implications for water treatment is rarely elucidated systematically. In this Critical Review, we will briefly summarize the current state-of-the-art of the nanomaterials, as well as the nanoconfined analogues (i.e., nanocomposites) developed for water treatment. Afterward, we will put emphasis on the effects of nanoconfinement from three aspects, that is, on the structure and behavior of water molecules, on the formation (e.g., crystallization) of confined nanomaterials, and on the nanoenabled chemical reactions. For each aspect, we will build the correlation between the nanoconfinement effects and the current studies for water treatment. More importantly, we will make proposals for future studies based on the missing links between some of the nanoconfinement effects and the water treatment technologies. Through this Critical Review, we aim to raise the research attention on using nanoconfinement as a fundamental guide or even tool to advance water treatment technologies.

Dehydration-Determined Ion Selectivity of Graphene Subnanopores

Graphene membranes with subnanopores are considered to be the next-generation materials for water desalination and ion separation, while their performance is mainly determined by the relative ion selectivity of the pores. However, the origin of this phenomenon has been controversial in the past few years, which strongly limits the development of related applications. Here, using direct Au ion bombardment, we fabricated the desired subnanopores with average diameters of 0.8 ± 0.16 nm in monolayer graphene. The pores showed the ability to sieve K⁺, Na⁺, Li⁺, Cs⁺, Mg²⁺, and Ca²⁺ cations, and the observed K⁺/Mg²⁺ selectivity ratio was over 4. With further molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrated that the ion selectivity is primarily attributed to the dehydration process of ions that can be quantitatively described by the ion-dependent free-energy barriers. Hopefully, this work is helpful in further enhancing the ion selectivity of graphene nanopores and also presenting a new paradigm for improving the performance of other nanoporous atomically thin membranes, such as MXenes and MoS₂.

Ionic Coulomb blockade and the determinants of selectivity in the NaChBac bacterial sodium channel

Mutation-induced transformations of conductivity and selectivity in NaChBac bacterial channels are studied experimentally and interpreted within the framework of ionic Coulomb blockade (ICB), while also taking account of resonant quantised dehydration (QD) and site protonation. Site-directed mutagenesis and whole-cell patch-clamp experiments are used to investigate how the fixed charge Q_f at the selectivity filter (SF) affects both valence selectivity and same-charge selectivity. The new ICB/QD model predicts that increasing ∣Q_f∣ should lead to a shift in selectivity sequences toward larger ion sizes, in agreement with the present experiments and with earlier work. Comparison of the model with experimental data leads to the introduction of an effective charge Q_f^∗ at the SF, which was found to differ between Aspartate and Glutamate charged rings, and also to depend on position within the SF. It is suggested that protonation of the residues within the restricted space of the SF is important in significantly reducing the effective charge of the EEEE ring. Values of Q_f^∗ derived from experiments on divalent blockade agree well with expectations based on the ICB/QD model and have led to the first demonstration of ICB oscillations in Ca²⁺ conduction as a function of the fixed charge. Preliminary studies of the dependence of Ca²⁺ conduction on pH are qualitatively consistent with the predictions of the model.

Exploring the pore charge dependence of K+ and Cl- permeation across a graphene monolayer: a molecular dynamics study

Selective permeation through graphene nanopores is attracting increasing interest as an efficient and cost-effective technique for water desalination and purification. In this work, using umbrella sampling and molecular dynamics simulations with constant electric field, we analyze the influence of pore charge on potassium and chloride ion permeation. As pore charge is increased, the barrier of the potential of mean force (PMF) gradually decreases until it turns into a well split in two subminima. While in the case of K+ this pattern can be explained as an increasing electrostatic compensation of the desolvation cost, in the case of Cl- the pattern can be attributed to the accumulation of a concentration polarization layer of potassium ions screening pore charge. The analysis of potassium PMFs in terms of forces revealed a conflicting influence on permeation of van der Waals and electrostatic forces that both undergo an inversion of their direction as pore charge is increased. Even if the most important transition involves the interplay between the electrostatic forces exerted by graphene and water, the simulations also revealed an important role of the changing distribution of potassium and chloride ions. The influence of pore charge on the orientation of water molecules was also found to affect the van der Waals forces they exert on potassium.

Ion transport through a nanoporous C2N membrane: the effect of electric field and layer number

Using all-atom molecular dynamic simulations, we show that a monolayer C₂N membrane possesses higher permeability and excellent ion selectivity, and that multilayer C₂N membranes have promising potential for water desalination.