Distinguishable spatial-spectral feature learning neural network framework for motor imagery-based brain-computer interface

Review of deep representation learning techniques for brain-computer interfaces

In the field of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), the potential for leveraging deep learning techniques for representing electroencephalogram (EEG) signals has gained substantial interest.Objective: This review synthesizes empirical findings from a collection of articles using deep representation learning techniques for BCI decoding, to provide a comprehensive analysis of the current state-of-the-art.Approach: Each article was scrutinized based on three criteria: (1) the deep representation learning technique employed, (2) the underlying motivation for its utilization, and (3) the approaches adopted for characterizing the learned representations.Main results: Among the 81 articles finally reviewed in depth, our analysis reveals a predominance of 31 articles using autoencoders. We identified 13 studies employing self-supervised learning (SSL) techniques, among which ten were published in 2022 or later, attesting to the relative youth of the field. However, at the time being, none of these have led to standard foundation models that are picked up by the BCI community. Likewise, only a few studies have introspected their learned representations. We observed that the motivation in most studies for using representation learning techniques is for solving transfer learning tasks, but we also found more specific motivations such as to learn robustness or invariances, as an algorithmic bridge, or finally to uncover the structure of the data.Significance: Given the potential of foundation models to effectively tackle these challenges, we advocate for a continued dedication to the advancement of foundation models specifically designed for EEG signal decoding by using SSL techniques. We also underline the imperative of establishing specialized benchmarks and datasets to facilitate the development and continuous improvement of such foundation models.

Efficient Multi-View Graph Convolutional Network with Self-Attention for Multi-Class Motor Imagery Decoding

Research on electroencephalogram-based motor imagery (MI-EEG) can identify the limbs of subjects that generate motor imagination by decoding EEG signals, which is an important issue in the field of brain-computer interface (BCI). Existing deep-learning-based classification methods have not been able to entirely employ the topological information among brain regions, and thus, the classification performance needs further improving. In this paper, we propose a multi-view graph convolutional attention network (MGCANet) with residual learning structure for multi-class MI decoding. Specifically, we design a multi-view graph convolution spatial feature extraction method based on the topological relationship of brain regions to achieve more comprehensive information aggregation. During the modeling, we build an adaptive weight fusion (Awf) module to adaptively merge feature from different brain views to improve classification accuracy. In addition, the self-attention mechanism is introduced for feature selection to expand the receptive field of EEG signals to global dependence and enhance the expression of important features. The proposed model is experimentally evaluated on two public MI datasets and achieved a mean accuracy of 78.26% (BCIC IV 2a dataset) and 73.68% (OpenBMI dataset), which significantly outperforms representative comparative methods in classification accuracy. Comprehensive experiment results verify the effectiveness of our proposed method, which can provide novel perspectives for MI decoding.

An in-depth survey on Deep Learning-based Motor Imagery Electroencephalogram (EEG) classification

Electroencephalogram (EEG)-based Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs) build a communication path between human brain and external devices. Among EEG-based BCI paradigms, the most commonly used one is motor imagery (MI). As a hot research topic, MI EEG-based BCI has largely contributed to medical fields and smart home industry. However, because of the low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and the non-stationary characteristic of EEG data, it is difficult to correctly classify different types of MI-EEG signals. Recently, the advances in Deep Learning (DL) significantly facilitate the development of MI EEG-based BCIs. In this paper, we provide a systematic survey of DL-based MI-EEG classification methods. Specifically, we first comprehensively discuss several important aspects of DL-based MI-EEG classification, covering input formulations, network architectures, public datasets, etc. Then, we summarize problems in model performance comparison and give guidelines to future studies for fair performance comparison. Next, we fairly evaluate the representative DL-based models using source code released by the authors and meticulously analyse the evaluation results. By performing ablation study on the network architecture, we found that (1) effective feature fusion is indispensable for multi-stream CNN-based models. (2) LSTM should be combined with spatial feature extraction techniques to obtain good classification performance. (3) the use of dropout contributes little to improving the model performance, and that (4) adding fully connected layers to the models significantly increases their parameters but it might not improve their performance. Finally, we raise several open issues in MI-EEG classification and provide possible future research directions.

Filter bank sinc-convolutional network with channel self-attention for high performance motor imagery decoding

Objective.Motor Imagery Brain-Computer Interface (MI-BCI) is an active Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) paradigm focusing on the identification of motor intention, which is one of the most important non-invasive BCI paradigms. In MI-BCI studies, deep learning-based methods (especially lightweight networks) have attracted more attention in recent years, but the decoding performance still needs further improving.Approach.To solve this problem, we designed a filter bank structure with sinc-convolutional layers for spatio-temporal feature extraction of MI-electroencephalography in four motor rhythms. The Channel Self-Attention method was introduced for feature selection based on both global and local information, so as to build a model called Filter Bank Sinc-convolutional Network with Channel Self-Attention for high performance MI-decoding. Also, we proposed a data augmentation method based on multivariate empirical mode decomposition to improve the generalization capability of the model.Main results.We performed an intra-subject evaluation experiment on unseen data of three open MI datasets. The proposed method achieved mean accuracy of 78.20% (4-class scenario) on BCI Competition IV IIa, 87.34% (2-class scenario) on BCI Competition IV IIb, and 72.03% (2-class scenario) on Open Brain Machine Interface (OpenBMI) dataset, which are significantly higher than those of compared deep learning-based methods by at least 3.05% (p= 0.0469), 3.18% (p= 0.0371), and 2.27% (p= 0.0024) respectively.Significance.This work provides a new option for deep learning-based MI decoding, which can be employed for building BCI systems for motor rehabilitation.

A Model Combining Multi Branch Spectral-Temporal CNN, Efficient Channel Attention, and LightGBM for MI-BCI Classification

Accurately decoding motor imagery (MI) brain-computer interface (BCI) tasks has remained a challenge for both neuroscience research and clinical diagnosis. Unfortunately, less subject information and low signal-to-noise ratio of MI electroencephalography (EEG) signals make it difficult to decode the movement intentions of users. In this study, we proposed an end-to-end deep learning model, a multi-branch spectral-temporal convolutional neural network with channel attention and LightGBM model (MBSTCNN-ECA-LightGBM), to decode MI-EEG tasks. We first constructed a multi branch CNN module to learn spectral-temporal domain features. Subsequently, we added an efficient channel attention mechanism module to obtain more discriminative features. Finally, LightGBM was applied to decode the MI multi-classification tasks. The within-subject cross-session training strategy was used to validate classification results. The experimental results showed that the model achieved an average accuracy of 86% on the two-class MI-BCI data and an average accuracy of 74% on the four-class MI-BCI data, which outperformed current state-of-the-art methods. The proposed MBSTCNN-ECA-LightGBM can efficiently decode the spectral and temporal domain information of EEG, improving the performance of MI-based BCIs.

SincNet-based Hybrid Neural Network for Motor Imagery EEG Decoding

It is difficult to identify optimal cut-off frequencies for filters used with the common spatial pattern (CSP) method in motor imagery (MI)-based brain-computer interfaces (BCIs). Most current studies choose filter cut-frequencies based on experience or intuition, resulting in sub-optimal use of MI-related spectral information in the electroencephalography (EEG). To improve information utilization, we propose a SincNet-based hybrid neural network (SHNN) for MI-based BCIs. First, raw EEG is segmented into different time windows and mapped into the CSP feature space. Then, SincNets are used as filter bank band-pass filters to automatically filter the data. Next, we used squeeze-and-excitation modules to learn a sparse representation of the filtered data. The resulting sparse data were fed into convolutional neural networks to learn deep feature representations. Finally, these deep features were fed into a gated recurrent unit module to seek sequential relations, and a fully connected layer was used for classification. We used the BCI competition IV datasets 2a and 2b to verify the effectiveness of our SHNN method. The mean classification accuracies (kappa values) of our SHNN method are 0.7426 (0.6648) on dataset 2a and 0.8349 (0.6697) on dataset 2b, respectively. The statistical test results demonstrate that our SHNN can significantly outperform other state-of-the-art methods on these datasets.

FB-CGANet: filter bank Channel Group Attention network for multi-class motor imagery classification

OBJECTIVE

Motor imagery-based brain computer interface (MI-BCI) is one of the most important BCI paradigms and can identify the target limb of subjects from the feature of MI-based Electroencephalography (EEG) signals. Deep learning methods, especially lightweight neural networks, provide an efficient technique for MI decoding, but the performance of lightweight neural networks is still limited and need further improving. This paper aimed to design a novel lightweight neural network for improving the performance of multi-class MI decoding.

APPROACH

A hybrid filter bank structure that can extract information in both time and frequency domain was proposed and combined with a novel channel attention method Channel Group Attention (CGA) to build a lightweight neural network Filter Bank Channel Group Attention Network (FB-CGANet). Accompanied with FB-CGANet, the Band Exchange data augmentation method was proposed to generate training data for networks with filter bank structure.

MAIN RESULTS

The proposed method can achieve higher 4-class average accuracy (79.4%) than compared methods on the BCI Competition IV IIa dataset in the experiment on the unseen evaluation data. Also, higher average accuracy (93.5%) than compared methods can be obtained in the cross-validation experiment.

SIGNIFICANCE

This work implies the effectiveness of channel attention and filter bank structure in lightweight neural networks and provides a novel option for multi-class motor imagery classification.