Estimation of pulmonary deposition of aerosol using gamma scintigraphy

Insights on animal models to investigate inhalation therapy: Relevance for biotherapeutics

Acute and chronic respiratory diseases account for major causes of illness and deaths worldwide. Recent developments of biotherapeutics opened a new era in the treatment and management of patients with respiratory diseases. When considering the delivery of therapeutics, the inhaled route offers great promises with a direct, non-invasive access to the diseased organ and has already proven efficient for several molecules. To assist in the future development of inhaled biotherapeutics, experimental models are crucial to assess lung deposition, pharmacokinetics, pharmacodynamics and safety. This review describes the animal models used in pulmonary research for aerosol drug delivery, highlighting their advantages and limitations for inhaled biologics. Overall, non-clinical species must be selected with relevant scientific arguments while taking into account their complexities and interspecies differences, to help in the development of inhaled medicines and ensure their successful transposition in the clinics.

Optimization and Dose Estimation of Aerosol Delivery to Non-Human Primates

BACKGROUND

In pre-clinical animal studies, the uniformity of dosing across subjects and routes of administration is a crucial requirement. In preparation for a study in which aerosolized live-attenuated measles virus vaccine was administered to cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis) by inhalation, we assessed the percentage of a nebulized dose inhaled under varying conditions.

METHODS

Drug delivery varies with breathing parameters. Therefore we determined macaque breathing patterns (tidal volume, breathing frequency, and inspiratory to expiratory (I:E) ratio) across a range of 3.3-6.5 kg body weight, using a pediatric pneumotachometer interfaced either with an endotracheal tube or a facemask. Subsequently, these breathing patterns were reproduced using a breathing simulator attached to a filter to collect the inhaled dose. Albuterol was nebulized using a vibrating mesh nebulizer and the percentage inhaled dose was determined by extraction of drug from the filter and subsequent quantification.

RESULTS

Tidal volumes ranged from 24 to 46 mL, breathing frequencies from 19 to 31 breaths per minute and I:E ratios from 0.7 to 1.6. A small pediatric resuscitation mask was identified as the best fitting interface between animal and pneumotachometer. The average efficiency of inhaled dose delivery was 32.1% (standard deviation 7.5, range 24%-48%), with variation in tidal volumes as the most important determinant.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies in non-human primates aimed at comparing aerosol delivery with other routes of administration should take both the inter-subject variation and relatively low efficiency of delivery to these low body weight mammals into account.

Deposition, imaging, and clearance: what remains to be done?

Deposition and clearance studies are used during product development and in fundamental research. These studies mostly involve radionuclide imaging, but pharmacokinetic methods are also used to assess the amount of drug absorbed through the lungs, which is closely related to lung deposition. Radionuclide imaging may be two-dimensional (gamma scintigraphy or planar imaging), or three-dimensional (single photon emission computed tomography and positron emission tomography). In October 2009, a group of scientists met at the "Thousand Years of Pharmaceutical Aerosols" conference in Reykjavik, Iceland, to discuss future research in key areas of pulmonary drug delivery. This article reports the session on "Deposition, imaging and clearance." The objective was partly to review our current understanding, but more importantly to assess "what remains to be done?" A need to standardize methodology and provide a regulatory framework by which data from radionuclide imaging methods could be compared between centers and used in the drug approval process was recognized. There is also a requirement for novel radiolabeling methods that are more representative of production processes for dry powder inhalers and pressurized metered dose inhalers. A need was identified for studies to aid our understanding of the relationship between clinical effects and regional deposition patterns of inhaled drugs. A robust methodology to assess clearance from small conducting airways should be developed, as a potential biomarker for therapies in cystic fibrosis and other diseases. The mechanisms by which inhaled nanoparticles are removed from the lungs, and the factors on which their removal depends, require further investigation. Last, and by no means least, we need a better understanding of patient-related factors, including how to reduce the variability in pulmonary drug delivery, in order to improve the precision of deposition and clearance measurements.

Inspiratory flow rates and volumes with the Aerolizer dry powder inhaler in asthmatic children and adults

OBJECTIVE

To assess the peak inspiratory flow rate (PIFR) and forced inspiratory vital capacity (FIVC) through the formoterol (Foradil*) Aerolizer* in patients with mild, moderate and severe asthma.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

PIFR and FIVC were assessed in 33 adults and 32 children using a spirometer alone (baseline), a spirometer with an adaptor, and a spirometer with an adaptor and the Aerolizer inhaler (placebo loaded).

RESULTS

Of adult patients using the Aerolizer inhaler, 73% had PIFR values of >100 l/min and 91% had values of >60 l/min. PIFR in adults was reduced from a mean baseline of 283 l/min to 118 l/min through the loaded Aerolizer inhaler. Similarly, 75% of children using the Aerolizer inhaler had PIFR values >80 l/min and 91% had values of > 60 l/min. The mean PIFR in children was reduced from a baseline of 154 l/min to 100 l/min through the loaded Aerolizer inhaler. Only small mean decreases from baseline were observed in FIVC through the loaded Aerolizer inhaler: 8.4% in adults and 3.8% in children. FIVC values of > 2.0 litre were achieved in 82% of adults, and 81% of children achieved FIVC values of >1.5 litre.

CONCLUSIONS

This study, albeit in a relatively small patient population, suggests that most children and adults with asthma can generate PIFRs of > 60 l/min and FIVCs of > 1.5 litre through the Aerolizer inhaler regardless of their disease severity. Such findings compare extremely favourably with other dry powder inhalers.

Distribution of intranasal instillations in mice: effects of volume, time, body position, and anesthesia

Intranasal instillation techniques are used to deliver various substances to the upper and lower respiratory tract (URT and LRT) in mice. Here, we quantify the relative distribution achieved with intranasal delivery of a nonabsorbable tracer, (99m)Tc-labeled sulfide-colloid. Relative distribution was determined by killing mice after instillation and quantifying the radioactivity in dissected tissues using gamma scintigraphy. A significant effect of delivery volume on relative distribution was observed when animals were killed 5 min after instillation delivered under gas anesthesia. With a delivery volume of 5 microl, no radiation was detected in the LRT; this increased to a maximum of 55.7 +/- 2.5% distribution to the LRT when 50 microl were delivered. The majority of radiation not detected in the LRT was found in the URT. Over the course of the following 1 h, radiation in the LRT remained constant, while that in the URT decreased and appeared in the gastrointestinal tract. Instillation of 25 microl into anesthetized mice resulted in 30.1 +/- 6.9% distribution to the LRT, while only 5.3 +/- 1.5% (P < 0.05) of the same volume was detected in the LRT of awake mice. Varying the body position of mice did not affect relative distribution. When using intranasal instillation, the relative distribution between the URT and LRT and the gastrointestinal tract is heavily influenced by delivery volume and level of anesthesia.

The effect of scatter and attenuation on aerosol deposition as determined by gamma scintigraphy

Gamma scintigraphy is often used to quantify deposition patterns from aerosol inhalers. The errors caused by scatter and tissue attenuation in planar Tc-99m gamma scintigraphy were investigated based on the data collected from four subjects in this study. Several error correction methods were tested. The results from two scatter correction methods, Jaszczak's method and factor analysis of dynamic sequences (FADS), were similar. Scatter accounted for 20% of raw data in the whole lung, 20% in the oropharynx, and 43% in the central airways and esophagus. Three attenuation correction methods were investigated and compared. These were: uniform attenuation correction (UAC), a known method used for inhalation drug imaging work; the broad-beam attenuation correction used for organ imaging in nuclear medicine; and a narrow-beam inhomogeneous tissue attenuation correction proposed in this study. The three methods differed significantly (p < 0.05), but all indicated that attenuation is a severe quantification problem. The narrow beam attenuation correction with scatter correction, showed that raw data underestimated tracer deposition by 44% in the lung, 137% in the oropharynx, and 153% in the trachea/esophageal region. To quantify aerosol lung deposition using planar scintigraphy even in relative terms, corrections are necessary. Much of the literature concerning quantified aerosol dose distributions measured by gamma scintigraphy needs to be interpreted carefully.

Scintigraphic Assessment of the Regional Distribution and Kinetics of Pharmaceuticals

A lesser known use of imaging studies in drug development is to determine the patterns of deposition, biodistribution, and regional kinetics of drugs in the body. This kind of study is of most interest when the drug is intended for local action following topical administration by inhalation. Imaging provides a convenient noninvasive method for observing initial deposition patterns and their variations caused by variables of the drug’s formulation and delivery method. Though planar gamma imaging is the method that has most often been used, recent years have seen promising demonstrations of SPECT and PET imaging to provide three-dimensional and quantitative measurements of drug deposition. When the goal of a drug is direct local treatment of diseased tissue, delivery of that drug is an important therapeutic variable. Imaging studies allow the drug delivery to be measured and optimized before a drug formulation is committed to clinical trials.

Gene therapy for cystic fibrosis with aerosolized adenovirus-CFTR: characterization of the aerosol and scintigraphic determination of lung deposition in baboons

For cystic fibrosis (CF) gene therapy using an aerosolized adenovirus expressing the CFTR gene, optimization of the inhalation conditions is a prerequisite to obtain sufficient amount of CFTR protein expression in the target areas of the respiratory tract. For such a purpose, in vivo radioisotopic imaging of the radiolabeled virus is a unique strategy for a quantitative assessment of the actual deposition. In the present study, an adenovirus CFTR (AdCFTR) was labeled with 99m Technetium gamma emitting isotope in such conditions that its bioactivity was preserved. The 99mTc-AdCFTR aerosol was characterized using both laser diffraction and cascade impaction for sizing with further determination of nebulized and inhalable fractions. After administration to baboons, scintigraphic quantitation of the regional lung distribution was performed and the actual dose deposited in the target area was estimated and expressed as an equivalent viral titer. Since a virus scintigraphy is not realistic in a hospital setting, we have developed an approach using 99mTc-DTPA (diethylene triamino pentaacetic acid) that could be used to predict the virus deposition. Indeed, similarities observed between 99mTc-DTPA and 99mTc-adenovirus aerosol imaging patterns validates the use of the 99mTc-DTPA scintigraphy that we propose as a pretherapeutic test for each patient prior to gene transfer.