Multistep phosphorylation systems: tunable components of biological signaling circuits

Phosphate-binding pocket on cyclin B governs CDK substrate phosphorylation and mitotic timing

Cell cycle progression is governed by complexes of the cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) and their regulatory subunits cyclin and Cks1. CDKs phosphorylate hundreds of substrates, often at multiple sites. Multisite phosphorylation depends on Cks1, which binds initial priming phosphorylation sites to promote secondary phosphorylation at other sites. Here, we describe a similar role for a recently discovered phosphate-binding pocket (PP) on B-type cyclins. Mutation of the PP in Clb2, the major mitotic cyclin of budding yeast, alters bud morphology and delays the onset of anaphase. Mutation of the PP reduces multi-site phosphorylation of CDK substrates in vitro, including the Cdc16 and Cdc27 subunits of the anaphase-promoting complex/cyclosome and the Bud6 and Spa2 subunits of the polarisome. We conclude that the cyclin PP, like Cks1, controls the pattern of multisite phosphorylation on CDK substrates, thereby helping to establish the robust timing of cell-cycle events.

Phosphate-binding pocket on cyclin B governs CDK substrate phosphorylation and mitotic timing

Cell cycle progression is governed by complexes of the cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) and their regulatory subunits cyclin and Cks1. CDKs phosphorylate hundreds of substrates, often at multiple sites. Multisite phosphorylation depends on Cks1, which binds initial priming phosphorylation sites to promote secondary phosphorylation at other sites. Here, we describe a similar role for a recently discovered phosphate-binding pocket (PP) on B-type cyclins. Mutation of the PP in Clb2, the major mitotic cyclin of budding yeast, alters bud morphology and delays the onset of anaphase. Mutation of the PP reduces multi-site phosphorylation of CDK substrates in vitro, including the Cdc16 and Cdc27 subunits of the anaphase-promoting complex/cyclosome and the Bud6 and Spa2 subunits of the polarisome. We conclude that the cyclin PP, like Cks1, controls the pattern of multisite phosphorylation on CDK substrates, thereby helping to establish the robust timing of cell-cycle events.

Mitogen signaling strength and duration can control cell cycle decisions

Decades ago, mitogen-promoted signaling duration and strength were observed to be sensed by the cell and to be critical for its decisions: to proliferate or differentiate. Landmark publications established the importance of mitogen signaling not only in the G1 cell cycle phase but also through the S and the G2/M transition. Despite these early milestones, how mitogen signal duration and strength, short and strong or weaker and sustained, control cell fate has been largely unheeded. Here, we center on cardinal signaling-related questions, including (i) how fluctuating mitogenic signals are converted into cell proliferation-differentiation decisions and (ii) why extended duration of weak signaling is associated with differentiation, while bursts of strong and short induce proliferation but, if too strong and long, induce irreversible senescence. Our innovative broad outlook harnesses cell biology and protein conformational ensembles, helping us to define signaling strength, clarify cell cycle decisions, and thus cell fate.

A unified approach to dissecting biphasic responses in cell signaling

Biphasic responses are encountered at all levels in biological systems. At the cellular level, biphasic dose-responses are widely encountered in cell signaling and post-translational modification systems and represent safeguards against overactivation or overexpression of species. In this paper, we provide a unified theoretical synthesis of biphasic responses in cell signaling systems, by assessing signaling systems ranging from basic biochemical building blocks to canonical network structures to well-characterized exemplars on one hand, and examining different types of doses on the other. By using analytical and computational approaches applied to a range of systems across levels (described by broadly employed models), we reveal (i) design principles enabling the presence of biphasic responses, including in almost all instances, an explicit characterization of the parameter space (ii) structural factors which preclude the possibility of biphasic responses (iii) different combinations of the presence or absence of enzyme-biphasic and substrate-biphasic responses, representing safeguards against overactivation and overexpression, respectively (iv) the possibility of broadly robust biphasic responses (v) the complete alteration of signaling behavior in a network due to biphasic interactions between species (biphasic regulation) (vi) the propensity of different co-existing biphasic responses in the Erk signaling network. These results both individually and in totality have a number of important consequences for systems and synthetic biology.

Engineering synthetic phosphorylation signaling networks in human cells

Protein phosphorylation signaling networks play a central role in how cells sense and respond to their environment. Here, we describe the engineering of artificial phosphorylation networks in which "push-pull" motifs-reversible enzymatic phosphorylation cycles consisting of opposing kinase and phosphatase activities-are assembled from modular protein domain parts and then wired together to create synthetic phosphorylation circuits in human cells. We demonstrate that the composability of our design scheme enables model-guided tuning of circuit function and the ability to make diverse network connections; synthetic phosphorylation circuits can be coupled to upstream cell surface receptors to enable fast-timescale sensing of extracellular ligands, while downstream connections can regulate gene expression. We leverage these capabilities to engineer cell-based cytokine controllers that dynamically sense and suppress activated T cells. Our work introduces a generalizable approach for designing and building phosphorylation signaling circuits that enable user-defined sense-and-respond function for diverse biosensing and therapeutic applications.

Network regulation meets substrate modification chemistry

Biochemical networks are at the heart of cellular information processing. These networks contain distinct facets: (i) processing of information from the environment via cascades/pathways along with network regulation and (ii) modification of substrates in different ways, to confer protein functionality, stability and processing. While many studies focus on these factors individually, how they interact and the consequences for cellular systems behaviour are poorly understood. We develop a systems framework for this purpose by examining the interplay of network regulation (canonical feedback and feed-forward circuits) and multisite modification, as an exemplar of substrate modification. Using computational, analytical and semi-analytical approaches, we reveal distinct and unexpected ways in which the substrate modification and network levels combine and the emergent behaviour arising therefrom. This has important consequences for dissecting the behaviour of specific signalling networks, tracing the origins of systems behaviour, inference of networks from data, robustness/evolvability and multi-level engineering of biomolecular networks. Overall, we repeatedly demonstrate how focusing on only one level (say network regulation) can lead to profoundly misleading conclusions about all these aspects, and reveal a number of important consequences for experimental/theoretical/data-driven interrogations of cellular signalling systems.

Sec61 channel subunit Sbh1/Sec61β promotes ER translocation of proteins with suboptimal targeting sequences and is fine-tuned by phosphorylation

The highly conserved endoplasmic reticulum (ER) protein translocation channel contains one nonessential subunit, Sec61β/Sbh1, whose function is poorly understood so far. Its intrinsically unstructured cytosolic domain makes transient contact with ER-targeting sequences in the cytosolic channel vestibule and contains multiple phosphorylation sites suggesting a potential for regulating ER protein import. In a microscopic screen, we show that 12% of a GFP-tagged secretory protein library depends on Sbh1 for translocation into the ER. Sbh1-dependent proteins had targeting sequences with less pronounced hydrophobicity and often no charge bias or an inverse charge bias which reduces their insertion efficiency into the Sec61 channel. We determined that mutating two N-terminal, proline-flanked phosphorylation sites in the Sbh1 cytosolic domain to alanine phenocopied the temperature-sensitivity of a yeast strain lacking SBH1 and its ortholog SBH2. The phosphorylation site mutations reduced translocation into the ER of a subset of Sbh1-dependent proteins, including enzymes whose concentration in the ER lumen is critical for ER proteostasis. In addition, we found that ER import of these proteins depended on the activity of the phospho-S/T-specific proline isomerase Ess1 (PIN1 in mammals). We conclude that Sbh1 promotes ER translocation of substrates with suboptimal targeting sequences and that its activity can be regulated by a conformational change induced by N-terminal phosphorylation.

Distinct phosphorylation states of mammalian CaMKIIβ control the induction and maintenance of sleep

The reduced sleep duration previously observed in Camk2b knockout mice revealed a role for Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII)β as a sleep-promoting kinase. However, the underlying mechanism by which CaMKIIβ supports sleep regulation is largely unknown. Here, we demonstrate that activation or inhibition of CaMKIIβ can increase or decrease sleep duration in mice by almost 2-fold, supporting the role of CaMKIIβ as a core sleep regulator in mammals. Importantly, we show that this sleep regulation depends on the kinase activity of CaMKIIβ. A CaMKIIβ mutant mimicking the constitutive-active (auto)phosphorylation state promotes the transition from awake state to sleep state, while mutants mimicking subsequent multisite (auto)phosphorylation states suppress the transition from sleep state to awake state. These results suggest that the phosphorylation states of CaMKIIβ differently control sleep induction and maintenance processes, leading us to propose a "phosphorylation hypothesis of sleep" for the molecular control of sleep in mammals.

Accelerated Multiphosphorylated Peptide Synthesis

Preparing phosphorylated peptides with multiple adjacent phosphorylations is synthetically difficult, leads to β-elimination, results in low yields, and is extremely slow. We combined synthetic chemical methodologies with computational studies and engineering approaches to develop a strategy that takes advantage of fast stirring, high temperature, and a very low concentration of 1,8-diazabicyclo[5.4.0]undec-7-ene (DBU) to produce multiphosphorylated peptides at an extremely rapid time and high purity.

Panoramic Perspective on Human Phosphosites

Protein phosphorylation is the most common reversible post-translational modification of proteins and is key in the regulation of many cellular processes. Due to this importance, phosphorylation is extensively studied, resulting in the availability of a large amount of mass spectrometry-based phospho-proteomics data. Here, we leverage the information in these large-scale phospho-proteomics data sets, as contained in Scop3P, to analyze and characterize proteome-wide protein phosphorylation sites (P-sites). First, we set out to differentiate correctly observed P-sites from false-positive sites using five complementary site properties. We then describe the context of these P-sites in terms of the protein structure, solvent accessibility, structural transitions and disorder, and biophysical properties. We also investigate the relative prevalence of disease-linked mutations on and around P-sites. Moreover, we assess the structural dynamics of P-sites in their phosphorylated and unphosphorylated states. As a result, we show how large-scale reprocessing of available proteomics experiments can enable a more reliable view on proteome-wide P-sites. Furthermore, adding the structural context of proteins around P-sites helps uncover possible conformational switches upon phosphorylation. Moreover, by placing sites in different biophysical contexts, we show the differential preference in protein dynamics at phosphorylated sites when compared to the nonphosphorylated counterparts.

What's new in protein kinase/phosphatase signalling in the control of plant immunity?

Plant immunity is crucial to plant health but comes at an expense. For optimal plant growth, tight immune regulation is required to prevent unnecessary rechannelling of valuable resources. Pattern- and effector-triggered immunity (PTI/ETI) represent the two tiers of immunity initiated after sensing microbial patterns at the cell surface or pathogen effectors secreted into plant cells, respectively. Recent evidence of PTI-ETI cross-potentiation suggests a close interplay of signalling pathways and defense responses downstream of perception that is still poorly understood. This review will focus on controls on plant immunity through phosphorylation, a universal and key cellular regulatory mechanism. Rather than a complete overview, we highlight “what’s new in protein kinase/phosphatase signalling” in the immunity field. In addition to phosphoregulation of components in the pattern recognition receptor (PRR) complex, we will cover the actions of the major immunity-relevant intracellular protein kinases/phosphatases in the ‘signal relay’, namely calcium-regulated kinases (e.g. calcium-dependent protein kinases, CDPKs), mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPKs), and various protein phosphatases. We discuss how these factors define a phosphocode that generates cellular decision-making ‘logic gates’, which contribute to signalling fidelity, amplitude, and duration. To underscore the importance of phosphorylation, we summarize strategies employed by pathogens to subvert plant immune phosphopathways. In view of recent game-changing discoveries of ETI-derived resistosomes organizing into calcium-permeable pores, we speculate on a possible calcium-regulated phosphocode as the mechanistic control of the PTI-ETI continuum.

Is DNA repair controlled by a biological logic circuit?

The possible utilization of biological logic circuit(s) in the integration and regulation of DNA repair is discussed. The author believes this mode of regulation likely applies to many other areas of cell biology; however, there are currently more experimental data to support its involvement in the control of DNA repair. Sequential logic processes always require a clock to orchestrate the orderly processing of events. In the proposed hypothesis, the pulses in the expression of p53 serve this function. Given the many advantages of logic type control, one would expect that in the course of ~ 3 billion years of evolution, where single cell life forms were likely the only forms of life, a biological logic type control system would have evolved to control at least some biological processes. Several other required components in addition to the 'clock' have been identified, such as; a method to temporarily inactivate repair processes when they are not required (e.g. the reversible inactivation of MGMT, a suicide repair protein, by phosphorylation); this prevents complex DNA repair systems with potentially overlapping repair functions from interfering with each other.

Symmetry breaking meets multisite modification

Multisite modification is a basic way of conferring functionality to proteins and a key component of post-translational modification networks. Additional interest in multisite modification stems from its capability of acting as complex information processors. In this paper, we connect two seemingly disparate themes: symmetry and multisite modification. We examine different classes of random modification networks of substrates involving separate or common enzymes. We demonstrate that under different instances of symmetry of the modification network (invoked explicitly or implicitly and discussed in the literature), the biochemistry of multisite modification can lead to the symmetry being broken. This is shown computationally and consolidated analytically, revealing parameter regions where this can (and in fact does) happen, and characteristics of the symmetry-broken state. We discuss the relevance of these results in situations where exact symmetry is not present. Overall, through our study we show how symmetry breaking (i) can confer new capabilities to protein networks, including concentration robustness of different combinations of species (in conjunction with multiple steady states); (ii) could have been the basis for ordering of multisite modification, which is widely observed in cells; (iii) can significantly impact information processing in multisite modification and in cell signalling networks/pathways where multisite modification is present; and (iv) can be a fruitful new angle for engineering in synthetic biology and chemistry. All in all, the emerging conceptual synthesis provides a new vantage point for the elucidation and the engineering of molecular systems at the junction of chemical and biological systems.

Proteins help our cells perform the chemical reactions necessary for life. Once proteins are made, they can also be modified in different ways. This can simply change their activity, or otherwise make them better suited for their specific jobs within the cell. Biological ‘catalysts’ called enzymes carry out protein modifications by reversibly adding (or removing) chemical groups, such as phosphate groups.

‘Multisite modifications’ occur when a protein has two or more modifications in different areas, which can be added randomly or in a specific sequence. The combination of all the modifications attached to a protein acts like a chemical barcode and confers a specific function to the protein.

Modification networks add levels of complexity above individual proteins. These encompass not only the proteins in a cell or tissue, but also the different enzymes that can modify them, and how they all interact with each other. Although our knowledge of these networks is substantial, basic aspects, such as how the ordering of multisite modification systems emerges, is still not well understood.

Using a simple set of multisite modifications, Ramesh and Krishnan set out to study the potential mechanisms allowing the creation of order in this context. Symmetry is a pervasive theme across the sciences. In biology, symmetry and how it may be broken, is important to understand, for example, how organism develop. Ramesh and Krishnan used the perspective of symmetry in protein networks to uncover the origins of ordering.

First, mathematical models of simple modification networks were created based on their basic descriptions. This system centred on proteins that could have phosphate modifications at two possible sites. The network was ‘symmetric’, meaning that the rate of different sets of chemical reactions was identical, as were the amounts of all the enzymes involved.

Dissecting the simulated network using a variety of mathematical approaches showed that its initial symmetry could break, giving rise to sets of ordered multisite modifications. Breaking symmetry did not require any additional features or factors; the basic chemical ‘ingredients’ of protein modification were all that was needed. The prism of symmetry also revealed other aspects of these multisite modification networks, such as robustness and oscillations.

This study sheds new light on the mechanism behind ordering of protein modifications. In the future, Ramesh and Krishnan hope that this approach can be applied to the study of not just proteins but also a wider range of biochemical networks.

Protein self-assembly: A new frontier in cell signaling

Long viewed as paradigm-shifting, but rare, prions have recently been discovered in all domains of life. Protein sequences that can drive this form of self-assembly are strikingly common in eukaryotic proteomes, where they are enriched in proteins involved in information flow and signal transduction. Although prions were thought to be a consequence of random errors in protein folding, recent studies suggest that prion formation can be a controlled process initiated by defined cellular signals. Many are present in normal biological contexts, yet are invisible to most technologies used to interrogate the proteome. Here, we review mechanisms by which protein self-assembly can create a stable record of past stimuli, altering adaptive responses, and how prion behavior is controlled by signaling processes. We touch on the diverse implications that this has for normal biological function and regulation, ranging from drug resistance in fungi to the innate immune response in humans. Finally, we discuss the potential for prion domains in transcription factors and RNA-binding proteins to orchestrate heritable gene expression changes in response to transient signals, such as during development.

A design principle for posttranslational chaotic oscillators

Chaos behavior has been observed in various cellular and molecular processes. Here, we modeled reversible phosphorylation dynamics to elucidate a design principle for autonomous chaos generation that may arise from generic enzymatic reactions. A comprehensive parameter search demonstrated that the reaction system composed of a set of kinases and phosphatases and two substrates with two modification sites exhibits chaos behavior. All reactions are described according to the Michaelis-Menten reaction scheme without exotic functions being applied to enzymes and substrates. Clustering analysis of parameter sets that can generate chaos behavior revealed the existence of motif structures. These chaos motifs allow the two-substrate species to interact via enzyme availability and constrain the two substrates' dynamic changes in phosphorylation status so that they occur at different timescales. This chaos motif structure is found in several enzymatic reactions, suggesting that chaos behavior may underlie cellular autonomy in a variety of biochemical systems.

•

Two substrates with reversible two-site phosphorylation can exhibit chaos behavior

•

The chaos does not require autocatalysis or allosteric regulation of enzymes

•

The chaos is a result of the coupling of two substrates via enzyme availability

Cdk1 phosphorylation negatively regulates the activity of Net1 towards RhoA during mitosis

The Neuroepithelial transforming gene 1 (Net1) is a RhoA subfamily guanine nucleotide exchange factor that is overexpressed in a number of cancers and contributes to cancer cell motility and proliferation. Net1 also plays a Rho GTPase independent role in mitotic progression, where it promotes centrosomal activation of Aurora A and Pak2, and aids in chromosome alignment during prometaphase. To understand regulatory mechanisms controlling the mitotic function of Net1, we examined whether it was phosphorylated by the mitotic kinase Cdk1. We observed that Cdk1 phosphorylated Net1 on multiple sites in its N-terminal regulatory domain and C-terminus in vitro. By raising phospho-specific antibodies to two of these sites, we also demonstrated that both endogenous and transfected Net1 were phosphorylated by Cdk1 in cells. Substitution of the major Cdk1 phosphorylation sites with aliphatic or acidic residues inhibited the interaction of Net1 with RhoA, and treatment of metaphase cells with a Cdk1 inhibitor increased Net1 activity. Cdk1 inhibition also increased Net1 localization to the plasma membrane and stimulated cortical F-actin accumulation. Moreover, Net1 overexpression caused spindle polarity defects that were reduced in frequency by acidic substitution of the major Cdk1 phosphorylation sites. These data indicate that Cdk1 phosphorylates Net1 during mitosis and suggest that this negatively regulates its ability to signal to RhoA and alter actin cytoskeletal organization.

Exploring cyclic networks of multisite modification reveals origins of information processing characteristics

Multisite phosphorylation (and generally multisite modification) is a basic way of encoding substrate function and circuits/networks of post-translational modifications (PTM) are ubiquitous in cell signalling. The information processing characteristics of PTM systems are a focal point of broad interest. The ordering of modifications is a key aspect of multisite modification, and a broad synthesis of the impact of ordering of modifications is still missing. We focus on a basic class of multisite modification circuits: the cyclic mechanism, which corresponds to the same ordering of phosphorylation and dephosphorylation, and examine multiple variants involving common/separate kinases and common/separate phosphatases. This is of interest both because it is encountered in concrete cellular contexts, and because it serves as a bridge between ordered (sequential) mechanisms (representing one type of ordering) and random mechanisms (which have no ordering). We show that bistability and biphasic dose response curves of the maximally modified phosphoform are ruled out for basic structural reasons independent of parameters, while oscillations can result with even just one shared enzyme. We then examine the effect of relaxing some basic assumptions about the ordering of modification. We show computationally and analytically how bistability, biphasic responses and oscillations can be generated by minimal augmentations to the cyclic mechanism even when these augmentations involved reactions operating in the unsaturated limit. All in all, using this approach we demonstrate (1) how the cyclic mechanism (with single augmentations) represents a modification circuit using minimal ingredients (in terms of shared enzymes and sequestration of enzymes) to generate bistability and oscillations, when compared to other mechanisms, (2) new design principles for rationally designing PTM systems for a variety of behaviour, (3) a basis and a necessary step for understanding the origins and robustness of behaviour observed in basic multisite modification systems.

Hidden dynamic signatures drive substrate selectivity in the disordered phosphoproteome

The discovery that more than 40% of the eukaryotic proteome is intrinsically disordered, and that these disordered segments are enriched in phosphorylation sites, suggests that conformational heterogeneity may be important to kinase selectivity. Indeed, phosphorylation prediction programs reliant on classic notions of conserved sequence information (i.e., “vertical information”) are only partially effective. We find that the conformational equilibrium of the phosphorylatable site, whose information is embedded in sequence-averaged energetic and structural properties of the protein (i.e., “horizontal information”), plays a major role in distinguishing phosphorylatable versus nonphosphorylatable sites. In fact, employing both horizontal and vertical information produces a state-of-the-art phosphorylation predictor, wherein the conformational equilibrium of the disordered chain is the dominant contributor.

Phosphorylation sites are hyperabundant in the eukaryotic disordered proteome, suggesting that conformational fluctuations play a major role in determining to what extent a kinase interacts with a particular substrate. In biophysical terms, substrate selectivity may be determined not just by the structural–chemical complementarity between the kinase and its protein substrates but also by the free energy difference between the conformational ensembles that are, or are not, recognized by the kinase. To test this hypothesis, we developed a statistical-thermodynamics-based informatics framework, which allows us to probe for the contribution of equilibrium fluctuations to phosphorylation, as evaluated by the ability to predict Ser/Thr/Tyr phosphorylation sites in the disordered proteome. Essential to this framework is a decomposition of substrate sequence information into two types: vertical information encoding conserved kinase specificity motifs and horizontal information encoding substrate conformational equilibrium that is embedded, but often not apparent, within position-specific conservation patterns. We find not only that conformational fluctuations play a major role but also that they are the dominant contribution to substrate selectivity. In fact, the main substrate classifier distinguishing selectivity is the magnitude of change in local compaction of the disordered chain upon phosphorylation of these mostly singly phosphorylated sites. In addition to providing fundamental insights into the consequences of phosphorylation across the proteome, our approach provides a statistical-thermodynamic strategy for partitioning any sequence-based search into contributions from structural–chemical complementarity and those from changes in conformational equilibrium.

A processive phosphorylation circuit with multiple kinase inputs and mutually diversional routes controls G1/S decision

Studies on multisite phosphorylation networks of cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) targets have opened a new level of signaling complexity by revealing signal processing routes encoded into disordered proteins. A model target, the CDK inhibitor Sic1, contains linear phosphorylation motifs, docking sites, and phosphodegrons to empower an N-to-C terminally directed phosphorylation process. Here, we uncover a signal processing mechanism involving multi-step competition between mutually diversional phosphorylation routes within the S-CDK-Sic1 inhibitory complex. Intracomplex phosphorylation plays a direct role in controlling Sic1 degradation, and provides a mechanism to sequentially integrate both the G1- and S-CDK activities while keeping S-CDK inhibited towards other targets. The competing phosphorylation routes prevent premature Sic1 degradation and demonstrate how integration of MAPK from the pheromone pathway allows one to tune the competition of alternative phosphorylation paths. The mutually diversional phosphorylation circuits may be a general way for processing multiple kinase signals to coordinate cellular decisions in eukaryotes.

The decision of whether and when a cell divides is tightly controlled. Here, the authors show in yeast that there is a multi-step competition between different phosphorylation states and sites in the S phase CDK-Sic1 complex, which controls Sic1 degradation and coordinates the precise timing of the G1/S transition.

Exploring the intrinsic behaviour of multisite phosphorylation systems as part of signalling pathways

Multisite phosphorylation is a basic way of chemically encoding substrate function and a recurring feature of cell signalling pathways. A number of studies have explored information processing characteristics of multisite phosphorylation, through studies of the intrinsic kinetics. Many of these studies focus on the module in isolation. In this paper, we build a bridge to connect the behaviour of multisite modification in isolation to that as part of pathways. We study the effect of activation of the enzymes (which are basic ways in which the module may be regulated), as well the effects of the modified substrates being involved in further modifications or exiting reaction compartments. We find that these effects can induce multiple kinds of transitions, including to behaviour not seen intrinsically in the multisite modification module. We then build on these insights to investigate how these multisite modification systems can be tuned by enzyme activation to realize a range of information processing outcomes for the design of synthetic phosphorylation circuits. Connecting the complexity of multisite modification kinetics, with the pathways in which they are embedded, serves as a basis for teasing out many aspects of their interaction, providing insights of relevance in systems biology, synthetic biology/chemistry and chemical information processing.

Multisite phosphorylation code of CDK

The quantitative model of cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) function states that cyclins temporally order cell cycle events at different CDK activity levels, or thresholds. The model lacks a mechanistic explanation, as it is not understood how different thresholds are encoded into substrates. We show that a multisite phosphorylation code governs the phosphorylation of CDK targets and that phosphorylation clusters act as timing tags that trigger specific events at different CDK thresholds. Using phospho-degradable CDK threshold sensors with rationally encoded phosphorylation patterns, we were able to predictably program thresholds over the entire range of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell cycle. We defined three levels of CDK multisite phosphorylation encoding: (i) Ser-Thr swapping in phosphorylation sites, (ii) patterning of phosphorylation sites, and (iii) cyclin-specific docking combined with modulation of CDK activity. Thus, CDK can signal via hundreds of differentially encoded targets at precise times to provide a temporally ordered phosphorylation pattern required for cell division.

How the cell cycle clock ticks

Eukaryotic cell division has been studied thoroughly and is understood in great mechanistic detail. Paradoxically, however, we lack an understanding of its core control process, in which the master regulator of the cell cycle, cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK), temporally coordinates an array of complex molecular events. The core elements of the CDK control system are conserved in eukaryotic cells, which contain multiple cyclin–CDK forms that have poorly defined and partially overlapping responsibilities in the cell cycle. However, a single CDK can drive all events of cell division in both mammalian and yeast cells, and in fission yeast a single mitotic cyclin can drive the cell cycle without major problems. But how can the same CDK induce different events when activated at different times during the cell cycle? This question, which has bewildered cell cycle researchers for decades, now has a sufficiently clear mechanistic answer. This Perspective aims to provide a synthesis of recent data to facilitate a better understanding of this central cellular control system.

Spontaneous Switching among Conformational Ensembles in Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

The common conception of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) is that they stochastically sample all possible configurations driven by thermal fluctuations. This is certainly true for many IDPs, which behave as swollen random coils that can be described using polymer models developed for homopolymers. However, the variability in interaction energy between different amino acid sequences provides the possibility that some configurations may be strongly preferred while others are forbidden. In compact globular IDPs, core hydration and packing density can vary between segments of the polypeptide chain leading to complex conformational dynamics. Here, we describe a growing number of proteins that appear intrinsically disordered by biochemical and bioinformatic characterization but switch between restricted regions of conformational space. In some cases, spontaneous switching between conformational ensembles was directly observed, but few methods can identify when an IDP is acting as a restricted chain. Such switching between disparate corners of conformational space could bias ligand binding and regulate the volume of IDPs acting as structural or entropic elements. Thus, mapping the accessible energy landscape and capturing dynamics across a wide range of timescales are essential to recognize when an IDP is acting as such a switch.

Single Molecule FRET: A Powerful Tool to Study Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) are often modeled using ideas from polymer physics that suggest they smoothly explore all corners of configuration space. Experimental verification of this random, dynamic behavior is difficult as random fluctuations of IDPs cannot be synchronized across an ensemble. Single molecule fluorescence (or Förster) resonance energy transfer (smFRET) is one of the few approaches that are sensitive to transient populations of sub-states within molecular ensembles. In some implementations, smFRET has sufficient time resolution to resolve transitions in IDP behaviors. Here we present experimental issues to consider when applying smFRET to study IDP configuration. We illustrate the power of applying smFRET to IDPs by discussing two cases in the literature of protein systems for which smFRET has successfully reported phosphorylation-induced modification (but not elimination) of the disordered properties that have been connected to impacts on the related biological function. The examples we discuss, PAGE4 and a disordered segment of the GluN2B subunit of the NMDA receptor, illustrate the great potential of smFRET to inform how IDP function can be regulated by controlling the detailed ensemble of disordered states within biological networks.

Sequential S232/S235/S238 Phosphorylation of the Hepatitis C Virus Nonstructural Protein 5A

The hepatitis C virus (HCV) protein NS5A is a phosphorylated protein with crucial roles in viral replication and assembly. NS5A was thought to undergo sequential phosphorylation on a series of conserved serine residues; however, the phosphorylation cascade remained obscure. Using three phosphorylation-specific antibodies, we found that phosphorylation at S232, S235, and S238 occurred in parallel in HCV-infected Huh7.5.1 cells, suggestive of intramolecular sequential NS5A phosphorylation from S232 through S235 to S238 by casein kinase Iα (CKIα). In line with this, alanine mutation at S225, S229, or S232 reduced, whereas aspartate mutation at the same sites rescued, NS5A phosphorylation at S232, S235, and S238. In contrast, alanine or aspartate mutation at S235 or S238 had little or no effect on S232 or S235 phosphorylation. Consistent with an intramolecular sequential phosphorylation cascade, S232, S235, and S238 phosphorylation coexisted on one single NS5A molecule. Phosphorylation of NH₂-terminal serine residues in one NS5A molecule did not rescue phosphorylation of COOH-terminal serine residues in another NS5A molecule. CKIα inhibition reduced NS5A phosphorylation at S232, S235, and S238. In summary, our results are indicative of a CKIα-mediated intramolecular, sequential phosphorylation cascade from S232 through S235 to S238 of the HCV NS5A protein. S225 and S229 also contribute substantially to the above sequential phosphorylation cascade of NS5A.IMPORTANCE The nonstructural protein 5A (NS5A) of the hepatitis C virus was thought to undergo sequential intramolecular phosphorylation on a series of serine residues; however, direct evidence was missing. We offer the first direct evidence of a CKIα-mediated intramolecular sequential NS5A phosphorylation cascade from serine 232 through 235 to 238. This sequential phosphorylation cascade occurs in the disordered low-complexity sequence I region, which together with the domain I region forms an RNA-binding groove in an NS5A dimer. Sequential phosphorylation in the disordered region adds charge-charge repulsion to the RNA-binding groove and probably thereby regulates NS5A's RNA-binding ability and functions in viral RNA replication and assembly.

Design Principles of Phosphorylation-Dependent Timekeeping in Eukaryotic Circadian Clocks

The circadian clock in cyanobacteria employs a posttranslational oscillator composed of a sequential phosphorylation-dephosphorylation cycle of KaiC protein, in which the dynamics of protein structural changes driven by temperature-compensated KaiC's ATPase activity are critical for determining the period. On the other hand, circadian clocks in eukaryotes employ transcriptional feedback loops as a core mechanism. In this system, the dynamics of protein accumulation and degradation affect the circadian period. However, recent studies of eukaryotic circadian clocks reveal that the mechanism controlling the circadian period can be independent of the regulation of protein abundance. Instead, the circadian substrate is often phosphorylated at multiple sites at flexible protein regions to induce structural changes. The phosphorylation is catalyzed by kinases that induce sequential multisite phosphorylation such as casein kinase 1 (CK1) with temperature-compensated activity. We propose that the design principles of phosphorylation-dependent circadian-period determination in eukaryotes may share characteristics with the posttranslational oscillator in cyanobacteria.

A phosphorylation switch turns a positive regulator of phototropism into an inhibitor of the process

Phototropins are light-activated protein kinases, which contribute to photosynthesis optimization both through enhancement of photon absorption when light is limiting and avoidance responses in high light. This duality is in part endowed by the presence of phototropins with different photosensitivity (phot1 and phot2). Here we show that phot1, which senses low light to promote positive phototropism (growth towards the light), also limits the response in high light. This response depends in part on phot1-mediated phosphorylation of Phytochrome Kinase Substrate 4 (PKS4). This light-regulated phosphorylation switch changes PKS4 from a phototropism enhancer in low light to a factor limiting the process in high light. In such conditions phot1 and PKS4 phosphorylation prevent phototropic responses to shallow light gradients and limit phototropism in a natural high light environment. Hence, by modifying PKS4 activity in high light the phot1-PKS4 regulon enables appropriate physiological adaptations over a range of light intensities.

Light conditions modify plant growth and development via photoreceptors such as phototropins. Here the authors show that while phot1 promotes phototropism under low light, it can act to suppress phototropism in high-light environments through phosphorylation of PKS4.

Homing in: Mechanisms of Substrate Targeting by Protein Kinases

Protein phosphorylation is the most common reversible post-translational modification in eukaryotes. Humans have over 500 protein kinases, of which more than a dozen are established targets for anticancer drugs. All kinases share a structurally similar catalytic domain, yet each one is uniquely positioned within signaling networks controlling essentially all aspects of cell behavior. Kinases are distinguished from one another based on their modes of regulation and their substrate repertoires. Coupling specific inputs to the proper signaling outputs requires that kinases phosphorylate a limited number of sites to the exclusion of hundreds of thousands of off-target phosphorylation sites. Here, we review recent progress in understanding mechanisms of kinase substrate specificity and how they function to shape cellular signaling networks.

Mutations at multiple CDK phosphorylation consensus sites on Cdt2 increase the affinity of CRL4Cdt2 for PCNA and its ubiquitination activity in S phase

CRL4^Cdt2 ubiquitin ligase plays an important role maintaining genome integrity during the cell cycle. A recent report suggested that Cdk1 negatively regulates CRL4^Cdt2 activity through phosphorylation of its receptor, Cdt2, but the involvement of phosphorylation remains unclear. To address this, we mutated all CDK consensus phosphorylation sites located in the C-terminal half region of Cdt2 (Cdt2-18A) and examined the effect on substrate degradation. We show that both cyclinA/Cdk2 and cyclinB/Cdk1 phosphorylated Cdt2 in vitro and that phosphorylation was reduced by the 18A mutation both in vitro and in vivo. The 18A mutation increased the affinity of Cdt2 to PCNA, and a high amount of Cdt2-18A was colocalized with PCNA foci during S phase in comparison with Cdt2-WT. Poly-ubiquitination activity to Cdt1 was concomitantly enhanced in cells expressing Cdt2-18A. Other CRL4^Cdt2 substrates, Set8 and thymine DNA glycosylase, begin to accumulate around late S phase to G2 phase, but the accumulation was prevented in Cdt2-18A cells. Furthermore, mitotic degradation of Cdt1 after UV irradiation was induced in these cells. Our results suggest that CDK-mediated phosphorylation of Cdt2 inactivates its ubiquitin ligase activity by reducing its affinity to PCNA, an important strategy for regulating the levels of key proteins in the cell cycle.

Serine 235 Is the Primary NS5A Hyperphosphorylation Site Responsible for Hepatitis C Virus Replication

The nonstructural protein 5A (NS5A) of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) is a phosphoprotein with two phosphorylation states: hypo- and hyperphosphorylation. Genetic mutation studies have demonstrated a cluster of serine residues responsible for NS5A hyperphosphorylation and functions in viral replication and assembly; however, the phosphorylation levels and potential interactions among the serine residues are unclear. We used three specific antibodies to measure NS5A phosphorylation at S222, S235, and S238 that were identified in our previous proteomics study. In the HCV (J6/JFH-1)-infected Huh7.5.1 cells, S222 phosphorylation was barely detected, whereas S235 phosphorylation and S238 phosphorylation were always detected in parallel in time and intracellular spaces. S235A mutation eliminated S238 phosphorylation whereas S238A mutation did not affect S235 phosphorylation, indicating that S235 phosphorylation occurs independently of S238 phosphorylation while S238 phosphorylation depends on S235 phosphorylation. In line with this, immunoprecipitation coupled with immunoblotting showed that S235 phosphorylation existed alone without S238 phosphorylation, whereas S238 phosphorylation existed only when S235 was phosphorylated on the same NS5A molecule. S235-phosphorylated NS5A constituted the primary hyperphosphorylated NS5A species. S235A mutation blunted viral replication, whereas S238A mutation did not affect replication. We concluded that S235 is the primary NS5A hyperphosphorylation site required for HCV replication. S238 is likely phosphorylated by casein kinase Iα, which requires a priming phosphorylation at S235.IMPORTANCE It has been known for years that the hepatitis C virus nonstructural protein 5A (NS5A) undergoes transition between two phosphorylation states: hypo- and hyperphosphorylation. It is also known that a cluster of serine residues is responsible for NS5A hyperphosphorylation and functions; however, the primary serine residue responsible for NS5A hyperphosphorylation is not clear. Here, we show for the first time that serine 235-phosphorylated NS5A constitutes the primary hyperphosphorylated NS5A species required for viral replication. We also show that NS5A phosphorylation among the serine residues is interdependent and occurs in a directional manner, i.e., phosphorylation at serine 235 leads to phosphorylation at serine 238. Our data provide the first proof-of-principle evidence that NS5A undergoes a sequential phosphorylation cascade.

Physical Association of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Polo-like Kinase Cdc5 with Chromosomal Cohesin Facilitates DNA Damage Response

At the onset of anaphase, a protease called separase breaks the link between sister chromatids by cleaving the cohesin subunit Scc1. This irreversible step in the cell cycle is promoted by degradation of the separase inhibitor, securin, and polo-like kinase (Plk) 1-dependent phosphorylation of the Scc1 subunit. Plk could recognize substrates through interaction between its phosphopeptide interaction domain, the polo-box domain, and a phosphorylated priming site in the substrate, which has been generated by a priming kinase beforehand. However, the physiological relevance of this targeting mechanism remains to be addressed for many of the Plk1 substrates. Here, we show that budding yeast Plk1, Cdc5, is pre-deposited onto cohesin engaged in cohesion on chromosome arms in G2/M phase cells. The Cdc5-cohesin association is mediated by direct interaction between the polo-box domain of Cdc5 and Scc1 phosphorylated at multiple sites in its middle region. Alanine substitutions of the possible priming phosphorylation sites (scc1-15A) impair Cdc5 association with chromosomal cohesin, but they make only a moderate impact on mitotic cell growth even in securin-deleted cells (pds1Δ), where Scc1 phosphorylation by Cdc5 is indispensable. The same scc1-15A pds1Δ double mutant, however, exhibits marked sensitivity to the DNA-damaging agent phleomycin, suggesting that the priming phosphorylation of Scc1 poses an additional layer of regulation that enables yeast cells to adapt to genotoxic environments.

FAIMS and Phosphoproteomics of Fibroblast Growth Factor Signaling: Enhanced Identification of Multiply Phosphorylated Peptides

We have applied liquid chromatography high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry tandem mass spectrometry (LC-FAIMS-MS/MS) and liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) to the investigation of site-specific phosphorylation in fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signaling. We have combined a SILAC approach with chemical inhibition by SU5402 (an FGF receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor) and dasatinib (a Src family kinase inhibitor). The results show that incorporation of FAIMS within the workflow results in (a) an increase in the relative proportion of phosphothreonine and phosphotyrosine sites identified, (b) an increase in phosphopeptide identifications from precursors with charge states ≥ +3 (with an associated increase in peptide length), and (c) an increase in the identification of multiply phosphorylated peptides. Approximately 20% of the phosphorylation sites identified via the FAIMS workflow had not been reported previously, and over 80% of those were from multiply phosphorylated peptides. Moreover, FAIMS provided access to a distinct set of phosphorylation sites regulated in response to SU5402 and dasatinib. The enhanced identification of multiply phosphorylated peptides was particularly striking in the case of sites regulated by SU5402. In addition to providing a compelling example of the complementarity of FAIMS in phosphoproteomics, the results provide a valuable resource of phosphorylation sites for further investigation of FGF signaling and trafficking.