Genomic analysis of antimicrobial resistant Escherichia coli isolated from manure and manured agricultural grasslands

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a multifactorial issue involving an intertwining relationship between animals, humans and the environment. The environment can harbour Escherichia coli that are pathogenic or commensal. Escherichia coli is used as an indicator of environmental faecal contamination. Through culture dependent approaches this study identified 46 E. coli isolates in porcine and bovine manure, non-manured and manured soil, and manured grass. The grass isolation highlights grass as an environmental reservoir for E. coli. We also identified a diverse plasmidome with 23 different plasmid replicon types. The E. coli isolates were phenotypically antimicrobial resistant, predominantly multidrug resistant. Whole genome sequencing identified 31 antimicrobial resistance genes, and mutations in the gyrA, parC, and parE genes, conferring fluoroquinolone resistance. This study demonstrates grass as an understudied environmental niche of AMR E. coli, which directly links the environment to the grass grazing animal and vice-versa via the circular economy of manure application.

Dynamic interaction of antibiotic resistance between plant microbiome and organic fertilizers: sources, dissemination, and health risks

Antibiotic resistance is a global health problem driven by the irrational use of antibiotics in different areas (such as agriculture, animal farming, and human healthcare). Sub-lethal concentrations of antibiotic residues impose selective pressure on environmental, plant-associated, and human microbiome leading to the emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB). This review summarizes all sources of antibiotic resistance in agricultural soils (including manure, sewage sludge, wastewater, hospitals/pharmaceutical industry, and bioinoculants). The factors (such as the physicochemical properties of soil, root exudates, concentration of antibiotic exposure, and heavy metals) that facilitate the transmission of resistance in plant microbiomes are discussed. Potential solutions for effective measures and control of antibiotic resistance in the environment are also hypothesized. Manure exhibits the highest antibiotics load, followed by hospital and municipal WW. Chlortetracycline, tetracycline, and sulfadiazine have the highest concentrations in the manure. Antibiotic resistance from organic fertilizers is transmitted to the plant microbiome via horizontal gene transfer (HGT). Plant microbiomes serve as transmission routes of ARB and ARGS to humans. The ingestion of ARB leads to human health risks (such as ineffectiveness of medication, increased morbidity, and mortality).

High-generation tetracyclines shifted microbial community composition and induced the emergence of antibiotic resistant bacteria in soil

Tetracyclines (TCs) have been widely detected in agricultural soil due to their widespread use in animal husbandry. The impact of low-generation TCs, i.e., the first- and second- generations, on soil ecosystem has attracted widespread attention. However, the dynamic response of soil microbial community to high-generation TCs, i.e., the third- and fourth- generations, remains largely unknown. Herein, we characterized the variations in the composition, diversity and succession of microbial community and the proliferation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) under the stress of four generations of TCs in brown soil and red soil. The results demonstrated that the exposure of low- and high- generation TCs consistently decreased the alpha diversity and stimulated the succession rate of microbial community in soil. High-generation TCs strongly shifted microbial community composition by reducing community resilience. The complexity of microbial networks and cross-module associations were strengthened to cope with the stress of high-generation TCs in soil. The abundance of ARGs was exacerbated by 1.75 times in response to the fourth-generation TCs compared to control in brown soil. The potential bacterial hosts of ARGs were more diverse in brown soil exposed to high-generation TCs, but the dominant hosts were not changed. These results highlight the potential ecological risk of the newly developed antibiotics, which is helpful for a comprehensive risk assessment of emerging contaminants.

Priority establishment of soil bacteria in rhizosphere limited the spread of tetracycline resistance genes from pig manure to soil-plant systems based on synthetic communities approach

The spread of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in agroecosystems through the application of animal manure is a global threat to human and environmental health. However, the adaptability and colonization ability of animal manure-derived bacteria determine the spread pathways of ARG in agroecosystems, which have rarely been studied. Here, we performed an invasion experiment by creating a synthetic communities (SynCom) with ten isolates from pig manure and followed its assembly during gnotobiotic cultivation of a soil-Arabidopsis thaliana (A. thaliana) system. We found that Firmicutes in the SynCom were efficiently filtered out in the rhizosphere, thereby limiting the entry of tetracycline resistance genes (TRGs) into the plant. However, Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria in the SynCom were able to establish in all compartments of the soil-plant system thereby spreading TRGs from manure to soil and plant. The presence of native soil bacteria prevented the establishment of manure-borne bacteria and effectively reduced the spread of TRGs. Achromobacter mucicolens and Pantoea septica were the main vectors for the entry of tetA into plants. Furthermore, doxycycline stress promoted the horizontal gene transfer (HGT) of the conjugative resistance plasmid RP4 within the SynCom in A. thaliana by upregulating the expression of HGT-related mRNAs. Therefore, this study provides evidence for the dissemination pathways of ARGs in agricultural systems through the invasion of manure-derived bacteria and HGT by conjugative resistance plasmids and demonstrates that the priority establishment of soil bacteria in the rhizosphere limited the spread of TRGs from pig manure to soil-plant systems.

Community coalescence and plant host filtering determine the spread of tetracycline resistance genes from pig manure into the microbiome continuum of the soil-plant system

The spread of livestock manure-borne antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) into agroecosystems through manure application poses a potential threat to human health. However, there is still a knowledge gap concerning ARG dissemination in coalescing manure, soil and plant microbiomes. Here, we examined the fate of tetracycline resistance genes (TRGs) originating from pig manure microbiomes and spread in the soil-A thaliana system and explored the effects of microbial functions on TRGs spread at different interfaces. Our results indicate that the TRGs abundances in all microbiome continuum of the soil-A. thaliana system were significantly increased with the application of a living manure microbiome, although the addition of manure with both an active and inactive microbiome caused a shift in the microbial community composition. This was attributed to the increasing relative abundances of tetA, tetL, tetM, tetO, tetW and tolC in the system. The application of living manure with DOX residues resulted in the highest relative abundance of total TRGs (3.30×10-3 copies/16S rRNA gene copies) in the rhizosphere soil samples. Community coalescence of the manure and soil microbiomes increased the abundance of Firmicutes in the soil and root microbiome, which directly explains the increase in TRG abundance observed in these interfaces. In contrast, the leaf microbiome differed markedly from that of the remaining samples, indicating strong plant host filtering effects on Firmicutes and TRGs from pig manure. The random forest machine learning model revealed microbial functions and their significant positive correlation with TRG abundance in the microbiome continuum of the system. Our findings revealed that community coalescence is the main driver of TRG spread from manure to the soil and root microbiomes. Plant host filtering effects play a crucial role in allowing certain microbial groups to occupy ecological niches in the leaves, thereby limiting the establishment of manure-borne TRGs in aboveground plant tissues.

Manure application amplified the co-selection of quaternary ammonium disinfectant and antibiotic on soil antibiotic resistome

Disinfectants and antibiotics are widely used for the prevention and control of bacterial infectious diseases. Frequent disinfection is thought to exacerbate antibiotic resistance. However, little is known about how disinfectants and antibiotics co-induce changes in the soil antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). This study determined the ARG profiles and bacterial community dynamics between unamended soil and manure-amended soil exposed to benzalkonium chloride (C12) (BC, 10 mg kg-1) disinfectant and sulfamethazine (SMZ, 1 mg kg-1), using high-throughput quantitative PCR and 16 S rRNA gene sequencing. Manure application enriched the soil in terms of ARGs abundance and diversity, which synergistically amplified the co-selection effect of BC and SMZ on soil antibiotic resistome. Compared with the control treatment, BC and SMZ exposure had a smaller impact on the bacterial infectious diseases and antimicrobial resistance-related functions in manure-amended soil, in which bacterial communities with greater tolerance to antimicrobial substances were constructed. Manure application increased the proportion of rank I ARGs and potential human pathogenic bacteria, while BC and SMZ exposure increased the drug-resistant pathogens transmission risk. This study validated that BC and SMZ aggravated the antimicrobial resistance under manure application, providing a reference for managing the spread risk of antimicrobial resistance in agricultural activities.

Soil type and moisture content alter soil microbial responses to manure from cattle administered antibiotics

Growing concerns about the global antimicrobial resistance crisis require a better understanding of how antibiotic resistance persists in soil and how antibiotic exposure impacts soil microbial communities. In agroecosystems, these responses are complex because environmental factors may influence how soil microbial communities respond to manure and antibiotic exposure. The study aimed to determine how soil type and moisture alter responses of microbial communities to additions of manure from cattle treated with antibiotics. Soil microcosms were constructed using two soil types at 15, 30, or 45% moisture. Microcosms received biweekly additions of manure from cattle given cephapirin or pirlimycin, antibiotic-free manure, or no manure. While soil type and moisture had the largest effects on microbiome structure, impacts of manure treatments on community structure and individual ARG abundances were observed across varying soil conditions. Activity was also affected, as respiration increased in the cephapirin treatment but decreased with pirlimycin. Manure from cattle antibiotics also increased NH4+ and decreased NO3- availability in some scenarios, but the effects were heavily influenced by soil type and moisture. Overall, this work demonstrates that environmental conditions can alter how manure from cattle administered antibiotics impact the soil microbiome. A nuanced approach that considers environmental variability may benefit the long-term management of antibiotic resistance in soil systems.

Considerations for the inclusion of metabarcoding data in the plant protection product risk assessment of the soil microbiome

There is increasing interest in further developing the plant protection product (PPP) environmental risk assessment, particularly within the European Union, to include the assessment of soil microbial community composition, as measured by metabarcoding approaches. However, to date, there has been little discussion as to how this could be implemented in a standardized, reliable, and robust manner suitable for regulatory decision-making. Introduction of metabarcoding-based assessments of the soil microbiome into the PPP risk assessment would represent a significant increase in the degree of complexity of the data that needs to be processed and analyzed in comparison to the existing risk assessment on in-soil organisms. The bioinformatics procedures to process DNA sequences into community compositional data sets currently lack standardization, while little information exists on how these data should be used to generate regulatory endpoints and the ways in which these endpoints should be interpreted. Through a thorough and critical review, we explore these challenges. We conclude that currently, we do not have a sufficient degree of standardization or understanding of the required bioinformatics and data analysis procedures to consider their use in an environmental risk assessment context. However, we highlight critical knowledge gaps and the further research required to understand whether metabarcoding-based assessments of the soil microbiome can be utilized in a statistically and ecologically relevant manner within a PPP risk assessment. Only once these challenges are addressed can we consider if and how we should use metabarcoding as a tool for regulatory decision-making to assess and monitor ecotoxicological effects on soil microorganisms within an environmental risk assessment of PPPs. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2024;20:337-358. © 2023 SETAC.

Co-occurrence of antibiotic and metal resistance in long-term sewage sludge-amended soils: influence of application rates and pedo-climatic conditions

Urban sewage sludge (USS) is increasingly being used as an alternative organic amendment in agriculture. Because USS originates mostly from human excreta, partially metabolized pharmaceuticals have also been considered in risk assessment studies after reuse. In this regard, we investigated the cumulative effect of five annual USS applications on the spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) and their subsequent resistance to toxic metals in two unvegetated soils. Eventually, USS contained bacterial strains resistant to all addressed antibiotics with indices of resistance varying between 0.25 for gentamicin to 38% for ampicillin and azithromycin. Sludge-amended soils showed also the emergence of resistome for all tested antibiotics compared to non-treated controls. In this regard, the increase of sludge dose generally correlated with ARB counts, while soil texture had no influence. On the other hand, the multi-antibiotic resistance (MAR) of 52 isolates selected from USS and different soil treatments was investigated for 10 most prescribed antibiotics. Nine isolates showed significant MAR index (≥ 0.3) and co-resistance to Cd, As and Be as well. However, events including an extreme flash flood and the termination of USS applications significantly disrupted ARB communities in all soil treatments. In any case, this study highlighted the risks of ARB spread in sludge-amended soils and a greater concern with the recent exacerbation of antibiotic overuse following COVID-19 outbreak.

What is the impact of aminoglycoside exposure on soil and plant root-associated microbiota? A systematic review protocol

BACKGROUND

Aminoglycosides are potent bactericidal antibiotics naturally produced by soil microorganisms and are commonly used in agriculture. Exposure to these antibiotics has the potential to cause shifts in the microorganisms that impact plant health. The systematic review described in this protocol will compile and synthesize literature on soil and plant root-associated microbiota, with special attention to aminoglycoside exposure. The systematic review should provide insight into how the soil and plant microbiota are impacted by aminoglycoside exposure with specific attention to the changes in the overall species richness and diversity (microbial composition), changes of the resistome (i.e. the changes in the quantification of resistance genes), and maintenance of plant health through suppression of pathogenic bacteria. Moreover, the proposed contribution will provide comprehensive information about data available to guide future primary research studies. This systematic review protocol is based on the question, "What is the impact of aminoglycoside exposure on the soil and plant root-associated microbiota?".

METHODS

A boolean search of academic databases and specific websites will be used to identify research articles, conference presentations and grey literature meeting the search criteria. All search results will be compiled and duplicates removed before title and abstract screening. Two reviewers will screen all the included titles and abstracts using a set of predefined inclusion criteria. Full-texts of all titles and abstracts meeting the eligibility criteria will be screened independently by two reviewers. Inclusion criteria will describe the eligible soil and plant root-associated microbiome populations of interest and eligible aminoglycosides constituting our exposure. Study validity will be evaluated using the CEE Critical Appraisal Tool Version 0.2 (Prototype) to evaluate the risk of bias in publications. Data from studies with a low risk of bias will be extracted and compiled into a narrative synthesis and summarized into tables and figures. If sufficient evidence is available, findings will be used to perform a meta-analysis.

Short-Term Responses of Soil Microbial Communities to Changes in Air Temperature, Soil Moisture and UV Radiation

We analyzed the effects on a soil microbial community of short-term alterations in air temperature, soil moisture and ultraviolet radiation and assessed the role of invertebrates (species Enchytraeus crypticus) in modulating the community’s response to these factors. The reference soil, Lufa 2.2, was incubated for 48 h, with and without invertebrates, under the following conditions: standard (20 °C + 50% water holding capacity (WHC)); increased air temperature (15–25 °C or 20–30 °C + 50% WHC); flood (20 °C + 75% WHC); drought (20 °C + 25% WHC); and ultraviolet radiation (UV) (20 °C + 50% WHC + UV). BIOLOG EcoPlates and 16S rDNA sequencing (Illumina) were used to assess the microbial community’s physiological profile and the bacterial community’s structure, respectively. The bacterial abundance (estimated by 16S rDNA qPCR) did not change. Most of the conditions led to an increase in microbial activity and a decrease in diversity. The structure of the bacterial community was particularly affected by higher air temperatures (20–30 °C, without E. crypticus) and floods (with E. crypticus). Effects were observed at the class, genera and OTU levels. The presence of invertebrates mostly resulted in the attenuation of the observed effects, highlighting the importance of considering microbiome–invertebrate interactions. Considering future climate changes, the effects described here raise concern. This study provides fundamental knowledge to develop effective strategies to mitigate these negative outcomes. However, long-term studies integrating biotic and abiotic factors are needed.

Thermophilic Composting of Human Feces: Development of Bacterial Community Composition and Antimicrobial Resistance Gene Pool

In times of climate change, practicing sustainable, climate-resilient, and productive agriculture is of primordial importance. Compost from different resources, now treated as wastes, could be one form of sustainable fertilizer creating a resilience of agriculture to the adverse effects of climate change. However, the safety of the produced compost regarding human pathogens, pharmaceuticals, and related resistance genes must be considered. We have assessed the effect of thermophilic composting of dry toilet contents, green cuttings, and straw, with and without biochar, on fecal indicators, the bacterial community, and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Mature compost samples were analyzed regarding fecal indicator organisms, revealing low levels of Escherichia coli that are in line with German regulations for fertilizers. However, one finding of Salmonella spp. exceeded the threshold value. Cultivation of bacteria from the mature compost resulted in 200 isolates with 36.5% of biosafety level 2 (BSL-2) species. The majority is known as opportunistic pathogens that likewise occur in different environments. A quarter of the isolated BSL-2 strains exhibited multiresistance to different classes of antibiotics. Molecular analysis of total DNA before and after composting revealed changes in bacterial community composition and ARGs. 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing showed a decline of the two most abundant phyla Proteobacteria (start: 36-48%, end: 27-30%) and Firmicutes (start: 13-33%, end: 12-16%), whereas the abundance of Chloroflexi, Gemmatimonadetes, and Planctomycetes rose. Groups containing many human pathogens decreased during composting, like Pseudomonadales, Bacilli with Bacillus spp., or Staphylococcaceae and Enterococcaceae. Gene-specific PCR showed a decline in the number of detectable ARGs from 15 before to 8 after composting. The results reveal the importance of sufficiently high temperatures lasting for a sufficiently long period during the thermophilic phase of composting for reducing Salmonella to levels matching the criteria for fertilizers. However, most severe human pathogens that were targeted by isolation conditions were not detected. Cultivation-independent analyses also indicated a decline in bacterial orders comprising many pathogenic bacteria, as well as a decrease in ARGs. In summary, thermophilic composting could be a promising approach for producing hygienically safe organic fertilizer from ecological sanitation.

Targeted metagenomics reveals inferior resilience of farm soil resistome compared to soil microbiome after manure application

Application of animal manure to soils results in the introduction of manure-derived bacteria and their antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs) into soils. ResCap is a novel targeted-metagenomic approach that allows the detection of minority components of the resistome gene pool without the cost-prohibitive coverage depths and can provide a valuable tool to study the spread of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in the environment. We used high-throughput sequencing and qPCR for 16S rRNA gene fragments as well as ResCap to explore the dynamics of bacteria, and ARGs introduced to soils and adjacent water ditches, both at community and individual scale, over a period of three weeks. The soil bacteriome and resistome showed strong resilience to the input of manure, as manuring did not impact the overall structure of the bacteriome, and its effects on the resistome were transient. Initially, manure application resulted in a substantial increase of ARGs in soils and adjacent waters, while not affecting the overall bacterial community composition. Still, specific families increased after manure application, either through the input of manure (e.g., Dysgonomonadaceae) or through enrichment after manuring (e.g., Pseudomonadaceae). Depending on the type of ARG, manure application resulted mostly in an increase (e.g., aph(6)-Id), but occasionally also in a decrease (e.g., dfrB3) of the absolute abundance of ARG clusters (FPKM/kg or L). This study shows that the structures of the bacteriome and resistome are shaped by different factors, where the bacterial community composition could not explain the changes in ARG diversity or abundances. Also, it highlights the potential of applying targeted metagenomic techniques, such as ResCap, to study the fate of AMR in the environment.

The impact of manure and soil texture on antimicrobial resistance gene levels in farmlands and adjacent ditches

Manure application can spread antimicrobial resistance (AMR) from manure to soil and surface water. This study evaluated the role of the soil texture on the dynamics of antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs) in soils and surrounding surface waters. Six dairy farms with distinct soil textures (clay, sand, and peat) were sampled at different time points after the application of manure, and three representative ARGs sul1, erm(B), and tet(W) were quantified with qPCR. Manuring initially increased levels of erm(B) by 1.5 ± 0.5 log copies/kg of soil and tet(W) by 0.8 ± 0.4 log copies/kg across soil textures, after which levels gradually declined. In surface waters from clay environments, regardless of the ARG, the gene levels initially increased by 2.6 ± 1.6 log copies/L, after which levels gradually declined. The gene decay in soils was strongly dependent on the type of ARG (erm(B) < tet(W) < sul1; half-lives of 7, 11, and 75 days, respectively), while in water, the decay was primarily dependent on the soil texture adjacent to the sampled surface water (clay < peat < sand; half-lives of 2, 6, and 10 days, respectively). Finally, recovery of ARG levels was predicted after 29-42 days. The results thus showed that there was not a complete restoration of ARGs in soils between rounds of manure application. In conclusion, this study demonstrates that rather than showing similar dynamics of decay, factors such as the type of ARG and soil texture drive the ARG persistence in the environment.

Environmental dimensions of antibiotic resistance: assessment of basic science gaps

Antibiotic resistance is one of the major problems facing medical practice in the 21st century. Historical approaches to managing antibiotic resistance have often focused on individual patients, specific pathogens and particular resistance phenotypes. However, it is increasingly recognized that antibiotic resistance is a complex ecological and evolutionary problem. As such, understanding the dynamics of antibiotic resistance requires integration of data on the diverse mobile genetic elements often associated with antibiotic resistance genes, and their dissemination by various mechanisms of horizontal gene transfer between bacterial cells and environments. Most important is understanding the fate and effects of antibiotics at sub-inhibitory concentrations, and co-selection. This opinion paper identifies key knowledge gaps in our understanding of resistance phenomena, and outlines research needs that should be addressed to help us manage resistance into the future.

Manure and Doxycycline Affect the Bacterial Community and Its Resistome in Lettuce Rhizosphere and Bulk Soil

Manure application to agricultural soil introduces antibiotic residues and increases the abundance of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) carrying antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), often located on mobile genetic elements (MGEs). The rhizosphere is regarded as a hotspot of microbial activity and gene transfer, which can alter and prolong the effects of organic fertilizers containing antibiotics. However, not much is known about the influence of plants on the effects of doxycycline applied to soil via manure. In this study, the effects of manure spiked with or without doxycycline on the prokaryotic community composition as well as on the relative abundance of ARGs and MGEs in lettuce rhizosphere and bulk soil were investigated by means of a polyphasic cultivation-independent approach. Samples were taken 42 days after manure application, and total community DNA was extracted. Besides a pronounced manure effect, doxycycline spiking caused an additional enrichment of ARGs and MGEs. High-throughput quantitative PCR revealed an increase in tetracycline, aminoglycoside, and macrolide-lincosamide-streptogramin B (MLSB) resistance genes associated with the application of manure spiked with doxycycline. This effect was unexpectedly lower in the rhizosphere than in bulk soil, suggesting a faster dissipation of the antibiotic and a more resilient prokaryotic community in the rhizosphere. Interestingly, the tetracycline resistance gene tetA(P) was highly enriched in manure-treated bulk soil and rhizosphere, with highest values observed in doxycycline-treated bulk soil, concurring with an enrichment of Clostridia. Thus, the gene tetA(P) might be a suitable marker of soil contamination by ARB, ARGs, and antibiotics of manure origin. These findings illustrate that the effects of manure and doxycycline on ARGs and MGEs differ between rhizosphere and bulk soil, which needs to be considered when assessing risks for human health connected to the spread of ARGs in the environment.