Ancient interlocus exon exchange in the history of the HLA-A locus

Contrasting evolutionary histories of MHC class I and class II loci in grouse--effects of selection and gene conversion

Genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) encode receptor molecules that are responsible for recognition of intracellular and extracellular pathogens (class I and class II genes, respectively) in vertebrates. Given the different roles of class I and II MHC genes, one might expect the strength of selection to differ between these two classes. Different selective pressures may also promote different rates of gene conversion at each class. Despite these predictions, surprisingly few studies have looked at differences between class I and II genes in terms of both selection and gene conversion. Here, we investigated the molecular evolution of MHC class I and II genes in five closely related species of prairie grouse (Centrocercus and Tympanuchus) that possess one class I and two class II loci. We found striking differences in the strength of balancing selection acting on MHC class I versus class II genes. More than half of the putative antigen-binding sites (ABS) of class II were under positive or episodic diversifying selection, compared with only 10% at class I. We also found that gene conversion had a stronger role in shaping the evolution of MHC class II than class I. Overall, the combination of strong positive (balancing) selection and frequent gene conversion has maintained higher diversity of MHC class II than class I in prairie grouse. This is one of the first studies clearly demonstrating that macroevolutionary mechanisms can act differently on genes involved in the immune response against intracellular and extracellular pathogens.

Preservation of a pseudogene by gene conversion and diversifying selection

Interlocus gene conversion is considered a crucial mechanism for generating novel combinations of polymorphisms in duplicated genes. The importance of gene conversion between duplicated genes has been recognized in the major histocompatibility complex and self-incompatibility genes, which are likely subject to diversifying selection. To theoretically understand the potential role of gene conversion in such situations, forward simulations are performed in various two-locus models. The results show that gene conversion could significantly increase the number of haplotypes when diversifying selection works on both loci. We find that the tract length of gene conversion is an important factor to determine the efficacy of gene conversion: shorter tract lengths can more effectively generate novel haplotypes given the gene conversion rate per site is the same. Similar results are also obtained when one of the duplicated genes is assumed to be a pseudogene. It is suggested that a duplicated gene, even after being silenced, will contribute to increasing the variability in the other locus through gene conversion. Consequently, the fixation probability and longevity of duplicated genes increase under the presence of gene conversion. On the basis of these findings, we propose a new scenario for the preservation of a duplicated gene: when the original donor gene is under diversifying selection, a duplicated copy can be preserved by gene conversion even after it is pseudogenized.

The orthology of HLA-E and H2-Qa1 is hidden by their concerted evolution with other MHC class I molecules

BACKGROUND

Whether MHC molecules undergo concerted evolution or not has been the subject of a long-standing debate.

RESULTS

By comparing sequences of eight functional homologues of HLA-E from primates and rodents with those of MHC class Ia molecules from the same eight species, we find that different portions of MHC class I molecules undergo different patterns of evolution. By focusing our analyses sequentially on these various portions, we have obtained clear evidence for concerted evolution of MHC class I molecules, suggesting the occurrence of extensive interallelic and intergenic exchanges. Intra-species homogenisation of sequences is particularly noticeable at the level of exon 4, which codes for the alpha3 domain, but our results suggest that homogenisation also concerns certain residues of the alpha1-alpha2 codomain that lie outside the antigen recognition site.

CONCLUSION

A model is presented in which Darwinian selective pressures due to pathogens could, at the same time, favour diversification of MHC class Ia molecules and promote concerted evolution of separate loci by spreading advantageous motifs arising by mutations in individual MHC molecules to other alleles and to other loci of the MHC region. This would also allow MHC molecules to co-evolve with the proteins with which they interact to fulfil their functions of antigen presentation and regulation of NK cell activity. One of the raisons d'être of the MHC may therefore be to favour at the same time both diversification of MHC class Ia molecules and homogenisation of the whole pool of MHC class I molecules (Ia and Ib) involved in antigen presentation.

REVIEWERS

This article was reviewed by Stephan Beck, Lutz Walter and Pierre Pontarotti.

Evolution by the birth-and-death process in multigene families of the vertebrate immune system

Concerted evolution is often invoked to explain the diversity and evolution of the multigene families of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes and immunoglobulin (Ig) genes. However, this hypothesis has been controversial because the member genes of these families from the same species are not necessarily more closely related to one another than to the genes from different species. To resolve this controversy, we conducted phylogenetic analyses of several multigene families of the MHC and Ig systems. The results show that the evolutionary pattern of these families is quite different from that of concerted evolution but is in agreement with the birth-and-death model of evolution in which new genes are created by repeated gene duplication and some duplicate genes are maintained in the genome for a long time but others are deleted or become nonfunctional by deleterious mutations. We found little evidence that interlocus gene conversion plays an important role in the evolution of MHC and Ig multigene families.

Ancestral major histocompatibility complex DRB genes beget conserved patterns of localized polymorphisms

Genes within the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) are characterized by extensive polymorphism within species and also by a remarkable conservation of contemporary human allelic sequences in evolutionarily distant primates. Mechanisms proposed to account for strict nucleotide conservation in the context of highly variable genes include the suggestion that intergenic exchange generates repeated sets of MHC DRB polymorphisms [Gyllensten, U. B., Sundvall, M. & Erlich, H. A. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 3686-3690; Lundberg, A. S. & McDevitt, H. 0. (1992) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 6545-6549]. We analyzed over 50 primate MHC DRB sequences, and identified nucleotide elements within macaque and baboon DRB6-like sequences with deletions corresponding to specific exon 2 hypervariable regions, which encode a discrete alpha helical segment of the MHC antigen combining site. This precisely localized deletion provides direct evidence implicating segmental exchange of MHC-encoded DRB gene fragments as one of the evolutionary mechanisms both generating and maintaining MHC diversity. Intergenic exchange at this site may be fundamental to the diversification of immune protection in populations by permitting alteration in the specificity of the MHC that determines the repertoire of antigens bound.

Novel alleles HLA-B*7802 and B*51022: evidence for convergency in the HLA-B5 family

We have characterized two novel HLA-B alleles, B*7802 and B*51022. The Caucasian-derived variant B*7802 most resembles the African-derived variant B*7801, from which B*7802 differs by two nucleotides. Only one of these modifications, however, is translated: a tyrosine for aspartate substitution occurs at residue 74 in B*7802, while the second nucleotide difference reflects a proximal synonymous substitution in codon 23. A second variant, B*51022, differs synonymously only at codon 23 from B*51021. Comparative analysis of the B5 CREG demonstrates that other pairs of B5 alleles differ synonymously only at codon 23 or synonymously at codon 23 and non-synonymously at a second more distal location. Contrary to the genesis of like pairs of B5 alleles via introduction of coordinate yet distant mutagenic events onto a single B5 progenitor, we postulate that synonymously different B5 progenitor molecules, B5ATT and B5ATC, are evolving in convergence to generate homologous B5 allele pairs differing silently at codon 23. Our finding that B*7802 is a single amino acid away from complete convergence with B*7801 and that B*51022 and B*51021 are in complete convergence is exemplary of such evolution.

A novel coding sequence belonging to a new multicopy gene family mapping within the human MHC class I region

The human major histocompatibility complex (MHC) region is a genomic region spanning about 4000 kilobases (kb) including the class I, class II, and class III subregions. The class I subregion is larger than the two others but with fewer genes described to date. It includes a) classical human leucocyte antigen (HLA) class I genes (HLA-A, HLA-B, HLA-C) which are highly polymorphic and encode products presenting the endogenous antigenic peptides to the T-cell receptors, and b) non-classical class I genes (HLA-E, HLA-F, HLA-G) whose function is still unknown. In this study, we describe the first coding sequence which is not structurally related to the class I genes, although it is localized within the MHC class I region. This novel gene, P5-1, belongs to a multiple copy family, all members of which map within the MHC. Although the P5-1 sequence showed no similarity to sequences in different databanks, its transcription, which is restricted to lymphoid tissues, argues for an immunological function of its product.

Gene conversion in the evolution of the human and chimpanzee MHC class I loci

Sixty-five DNA sequences from human and chimpanzee major histocompatibility complex class I loci were searched for statistical evidence of past gene conversion. Twenty-four potential conversions were detected; they were distributed across both variable and conserved portions of the gene, and involved both classical and non-classical loci. The majority spanned less than 100 bp, comparable in length to the conversions observed in spontaneous mutations in mice. Both within-locus and between-locus conversions were observed. Certain areas of the antigen recognition site appear to have been the target for multiple conversion events. The implications of these findings for the evolution of the class I multigene family are discussed.

Segmental exchange between MHC class I genes in a higher primate: recombination in the gorilla between the ancestor of a human non-functional gene and an A locus gene

Classical human major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules are the products of highly diverse gene loci. It has been suggested that segmental exchange may play a role in the generation of diversity at the antigen recognition site of MHC class I molecules. Here we present the cloning, sequencing and expression of two gorilla A locus cDNAs. One of these cDNAs shows remarkable similarity to the non-functional HLA-AR locus gene (5.4-LBF) only in exon 2. The remainder of the cDNA, however, is most closely related to other classical higher primate A locus genes. This suggests that a segmental exchange may have occurred between the ancestor of the non-functional HLA-AR gene and a classical gorilla A locus gene. Furthermore, the recombination event resulting in Gogo-A3 has affected its antigen recognition site. These data, therefore, demonstrate that segmental exchange can generate diversity at the antigen recognition sites of primate MHC class I molecules and suggest that non-functional genes can contribute to the generation of diversity of classical MHC class I genes.

Independent gene duplications, not concerted evolution, explain relationships among class I MHC genes of murine rodents

It has been claimed that class I MHC loci are homogenized within species by frequent events of interlocus genetic exchange ("concerted evolution"). Evidence for this process includes the fact that certain rat class I loci (including RT1.A) located centromeric to class II and class III are more similar to each other than to the mouse K locus (also centromeric to class II/class III). However, a phylogenetic analysis showed that the rat RT1.A locus is in fact orthologous to the mouse K1 pseudogene (also centromeric to class II/class III). Thus, two independent events of translocation of genes centromeric to class II/class III have occurred in the history of the murine rodents, at least one of which (involving the ancestor of RT1.A and K1) occurred prior to the divergence of rat and mouse. It was also found that the rat nonclassical class I gene RT.BM1 is orthologous to the mouse nonclassical gene 37d. These results argue that interlocus genetic exchange does not occur at a rate sufficient to cause within-species homogenization of class I MHC loci.

Evolution of the MHC class I genes of a New World primate from ancestral homologues of human non-classical genes

The products of the classical human major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I genes (HLA-A, -B, -C) are highly polymorphic molecules that bind peptides and present them to T lymphocytes. The non-polymorphic, non-classical MHC class I gene products (HLA-E, -F, -G) are not restricting elements for the majority of T lymphocytes. The evolutionary relationship of the non-classical and classical MHC class I genes is unclear. Here we present the cloning and sequencing of the MHC class I genes of a New World primate, the cotton-top tamarin (Saguinus oedipus). The expressed MHC class I genes of this species are more closely related to the human non-classical HLA-G gene than they are to genes of the human classical HLA-A, -B, and -C loci. These observations imply that classical and non-classical genes do not necessarily constitute mutually exclusive groups over evolutionary time.

Concerted evolution of class I genes in the major histocompatibility complex of murine rodents

Full-length cDNA sequences of two class I major histocompatibility complex molecules from the DA strain of Rattus norvegicus are reported. One codes for the classical class I restriction element RT1.Aa, which maps to the locus in the rat major histocompatibility complex homologous to H-2K in the mouse. The other probably codes for a soluble nonclassical class I molecule present in DA rat serum; a short deletion in the fifth exon implies that the translated product will terminate in the membrane-spanning region. These sequences have been compared with mouse classical class I sequences as well as with three published rat class I cDNA partial sequences. The results show, first, that "locus-specific" substitutions from the H-2K, H-2D, and H-2L data set are scrambled in the RT1.Aa molecule; a majority of these substitutions have H-2D/L-specific features. Second, the data show that the four rat sequences are strikingly similar to one another regardless of locus or haplotype of origin; they share a number of apparently species-specific features that distinguish them all from mouse classical class I sequences, which likewise share distinctive features of their own. The results suggest that segmental sequence exchange plays a major role in determining the evolution of sequence in class I major histocompatibility complex molecules.