Meiotic mismatch repair quantified on the basis of segregation patterns in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

Gene conversion: a non-Mendelian process integral to meiotic recombination

Meiosis is undoubtedly the mechanism that underpins Mendelian genetics. Meiosis is a specialised, reductional cell division which generates haploid gametes (reproductive cells) carrying a single chromosome complement from diploid progenitor cells harbouring two chromosome sets. Through this process, the hereditary material is shuffled and distributed into haploid gametes such that upon fertilisation, when two haploid gametes fuse, diploidy is restored in the zygote. During meiosis the transient physical connection of two homologous chromosomes (one originally inherited from each parent) each consisting of two sister chromatids and their subsequent segregation into four meiotic products (gametes), is what enables genetic marker assortment forming the core of Mendelian laws. The initiating events of meiotic recombination are DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) which need to be repaired in a certain way to enable the homologous chromosomes to find each other. This is achieved by DSB ends searching for homologous repair templates and invading them. Ultimately, the repair of meiotic DSBs by homologous recombination physically connects homologous chromosomes through crossovers. These physical connections provided by crossovers enable faithful chromosome segregation. That being said, the DSB repair mechanism integral to meiotic recombination also produces genetic transmission distortions which manifest as postmeiotic segregation events and gene conversions. These processes are non-reciprocal genetic exchanges and thus non-Mendelian.

Genome-wide survey of post-meiotic segregation during yeast recombination

Background

When mismatches in heteroduplex DNA formed during meiotic recombination are left unrepaired, post-meiotic segregation of the two mismatched alleles occurs during the ensuing round of mitosis. This gives rise to somatic mosaicism in multicellular organisms and leads to unexpected allelic combinations among progeny. Despite its implications for inheritance, post-meiotic segregation has been studied at only a few loci.

Results

By genotyping tens of thousands of genetic markers in yeast segregants and their clonal progeny, we analyzed post-meiotic segregation at a genome-wide scale. We show that post-meiotic segregation occurs in close to 10% of recombination events. Although the overall number of markers affected in a single meiosis is small, the rate of post-meiotic segregation is more than five orders of magnitude larger than the base substitution mutation rate. Post-meiotic segregation took place with equal relative frequency in crossovers and non-crossovers, and usually at the edges of gene conversion tracts. Furthermore, post-meiotic segregation tended to occur in markers that are isolated from other heterozygosities and preferentially at polymorphism types that are relatively uncommon in the yeast species.

Conclusions

Overall, our survey reveals the genome-wide characteristics of post-meiotic segregation. The results show that post-meiotic segregation is widespread in meiotic recombination and could be a significant determinant of allelic inheritance and allele frequencies at the population level.

The meiotic recombination hot spot ura4A in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

The meiotic recombination hot spot ura4A (formerly ura4-aim) of Schizosaccharomyces pombe was observed at the insertion of the ura4+ gene 15 kb centromere-proximal to ade6 on chromosome III. Crosses heterozygous for the insertion showed frequent conversion at the heterology with preferential loss of the insertion. This report concerns the characterization of 12 spontaneous ura4A mutants. A gradient of conversion ranging from 18% at the 5' end to 6% at the 3' end was detected. A novel phenomenon also was discovered: a mating-type-related bias of conversion. The allele entering with the h+ parent acts preferentially as the acceptor for conversion (ratio of 3:2). Tetrad analysis of two-factor crosses showed that heteroduplex DNA is predominantly asymmetrical, enters from the 5' end, and more often than not covers the entire gene. Restoration repair of markers at the 5' end was inferred. Random spore analyses of two-factor crosses and normalization of prototroph-recombinant frequencies to physical distance led to the demonstration of map expansion: Crosses involving distant markers yielded recombinant frequencies higher than the sum of the frequencies measured in the subintervals. Finally, marker effects on recombination were defined for two of the ura4A mutations.

Short-patch correction of C/C mismatches in human cells

We examined whether the human nucleotide excision repair complex, which is specialized on the removal of bulky DNA adducts, also displays a correcting activity on base mismatches. The cytosine/cytosine (C/C) lesion was used as a model substrate to monitor the correction of base mismatches in human cells. Fibroblasts with different repair capabilities were transfected with shuttle vectors that contain a site-directed C/C mismatch in the replication origin, accompanied by an additional C/C mismatch in one of the flanking sequences that are not essential for replication. Analysis of the vector progeny obtained from these doubly modified substrates revealed that C/C mismatches were eliminated before DNA synthesis not only in the repair-proficient background, but also when the target cells carried a genetic defect in long-patch mismatch repair, in nucleotide excision repair, or when both pathways were deleted. Furthermore, cells deficient for long-patch mismatch repair as well as a cell line that combines mismatch and nucleotide excision repair defects were able to correct multiple C/C mispairs, placed at distances of 21-44 nt, in an independent manner, such that the removal of each lesion led to individual repair patches. These results support the existence of a concurrent short-patch mechanism that rectifies C/C mismatches.

Identification of proteins of Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae that specifically bind to C/C mismatches in DNA

The pathways leading to G:C-->C:G transversions and their repair mechanisms remain uncertain. C/C and G/G mismatches arising during DNA replication are a potential source of G:C-->C:G transversions. The Escherichia coli mutHLS mismatch repair pathway efficiently corrects G/G mismatches, whereas C/C mismatches are a poor substrate. Escherichia coli must have a more specific repair pathway to correct C/C mismatches. In this study, we performed gel-shift assays to identify C/C mismatch-binding proteins in cell extracts of E. COLI: By testing heteroduplex DNA (34mers) containing C/C mismatches, two specific band shifts were generated in the gels. The band shifts were due to mismatch-specific binding of proteins present in the extracts. Cell extracts of a mutant strain defective in MutM protein did not produce a low-mobility complex. Purified MutM protein bound efficiently to the C/C mismatch-containing heteroduplex to produce the low-mobility complex. The second protein, which produced a high-mobility complex with the C/C mismatches, was purified to homogeneity, and the amino acid sequence revealed that this protein was the FabA protein of E.COLI: The high-mobility complex was not formed in cell extracts of a fabA mutant. From these results it is possible that MutM and FabA proteins are components of repair pathways for C/C mismatches in E.COLI: Furthermore, we found that Saccharomyces cerevisiae OGG1 protein, a functional homolog of E.COLI: MutM protein, could specifically bind to the C/C mismatches in DNA.

A Uve1p-mediated mismatch repair pathway in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

UV damage endonuclease (Uve1p) from Schizosaccharomyces pombe was initially described as a DNA repair enzyme specific for the repair of UV light-induced photoproducts and proposed as the initial step in an alternative excision repair pathway. Here we present biochemical and genetic evidence demonstrating that Uve1p is also a mismatch repair endonuclease which recognizes and cleaves DNA 5' to the mispaired base in a strand-specific manner. The biochemical properties of the Uve1p-mediated mismatch endonuclease activity are similar to those of the Uve1p-mediated UV photoproduct endonuclease. Mutants lacking Uve1p display a spontaneous mutator phenotype, further confirming the notion that Uve1p plays a role in mismatch repair. These results suggest that Uve1p has a surprisingly broad substrate specificity and may function as a general type of DNA repair protein with the capacity to initiate mismatch repair in certain organisms.

Involvement of nucleotide-excision repair in msh2 pms1-independent mismatch repair

Nucleotide-excision repair (NER) and mismatch repair (MMR) are prominent examples of highly conserved DNA repair systems which recognize and replace damaged and/or mispaired nucleotides in DNA. In humans, inheritable defects in components of the NER system are associated with severe diseases such as xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) and Cockayne syndrome (CS), whereas inactivation of MMR is accompanied by predisposition to certain types of cancer. In Schizosaccharomyces pombe, the msh2- and pms1-dependent long-patch MMR system efficiently corrects small insertion/deletion loops and all base-base mismatches, except C/C. Up to 70% of C/C mismatches generated in recombination intermediates, and to a lesser extent also other base-base mismatches, are thought to undergo correction by a minor, short-patch excision repair system. We identify here the NER genes rhpl4, swi10 and rad16 as components of this repair pathway and show that they act independently of msh2 and pms1.

Recognition of DNA alterations by the mismatch repair system

Misincorporation of non-complementary bases by DNA polymerases is a major source of the occurrence of promutagenic base-pairing errors during DNA replication or repair. Base-base mismatches or loops of extra bases can arise which, if left unrepaired, will generate point or frameshift mutations respectively. To counteract this mutagenic potential, organisms have developed a number of elaborate surveillance and repair strategies which co-operate to maintain the integrity of their genomes. An important replication-associated correction function is provided by the post-replicative mismatch repair system. This system is highly conserved among species and appears to be the major pathway for strand-specific elimination of base-base mispairs and short insertion/deletion loops (IDLs), not only during DNA replication, but also in intermediates of homologous recombination. The efficiency of repair of different base-pairing errors in the DNA varies, and appears to depend on multiple factors, such as the physical structure of the mismatch and sequence context effects. These structural aspects of mismatch repair are poorly understood. In contrast, remarkable progress in understanding the biochemical role of error-recognition proteins has been made in the recent past. In eukaryotes, two heterodimers consisting of MutS-homologous proteins have been shown to share the function of mismatch recognition in vivo and in vitro. A first MutS homologue, MSH2, is present in both heterodimers, and the specificity for mismatch recognition is dictated by its association with either of two other MutS homologues: MSH6 for recognition of base-base mismatches and small IDLs, or MSH3 for recognition of IDLs only. Mismatch repair deficiency in cells can arise through mutation, transcriptional silencing or as a result of imbalanced expression of these genes.

The msh2 gene of Schizosaccharomyces pombe is involved in mismatch repair, mating-type switching, and meiotic chromosome organization

We have identified in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe a MutS homolog that shows highest homology to the Msh2 subgroup. msh2 disruption gives rise to increased mitotic mutation rates and increased levels of postmeiotic segregation of genetic markers. In bandshift assays performed with msh2Delta cell extracts, a general mismatch-binding activity is absent. By complementation assays, we showed that S. pombe msh2 is allelic with the previously identified swi8 and mut3 genes, which are involved in mating-type switching. The swi8-137 mutant has a mutation in the msh2 gene which causes a truncated Msh2 peptide lacking a putative DNA-binding domain. Cytological analysis revealed that during meiotic prophase of msh2-defective cells, chromosomal structures were frequently formed; such structures are rarely found in the wild type. Our data show that besides having a function in mismatch repair, S. pombe msh2 is required for correct termination of copy synthesis during mating-type switching as well as for proper organization of chromosomes during meiosis.

The high mobility group domain protein Cmb1 of Schizosaccharomyces pombe binds to cytosines in base mismatches and opposite chemically altered guanines

The mismatch-binding activity Cmb1 of Schizosaccharomyces pombe was enriched from wild type cells, and N-terminal sequencing enabled cloning of the respective gene. The deduced amino acid sequence of cmb1(+) contains a high mobility group domain, a motif that is common to a heterogeneous family of DNA-binding proteins. In crude protein extracts of a cmb1 gene-disruption strain, specific binding to C/T, C/A, and C/Delta was abolished. Weak binding to C/C revealed the presence of a second mismatch-binding activity, Cmb2. Cmb1, enriched from S. pombe and purified from Escherichia coli, bound specifically to C/C, C/T, C/A, T/T, and C/Delta but showed little or no affinity to other mismatches and small loops. Cmb1 recognizes 1,2 GpG intrastrand cross-links, produced by the chemotherapeutic drug cisplatin, when two cytosines are opposite the cross-linked guanines but not when other bases are present. Consistently, O6-methylguanine:C but not O6-methylguanine/T lesions were bound. Thus, cytosines in mismatches and opposite chemically modified guanines are the preferred target of Cmb1 recognition. cmb1 mutant cells are more sensitive to cisplatin than wild type cells, indicating a role of Cmb1 in repair of cisplatin-induced DNA damage.

Mismatch repair in Schizosaccharomyces pombe requires the mutL homologous gene pms1: molecular cloning and functional analysis

Homologues of the bacterial mutS and mutL genes involved in DNA mismatch repair have been found in organisms from bacteria to humans. Here, we describe the structure and function of a newly identified Schizosaccharomyces pombe that encodes a predicted amino acid sequence of 794 residues with a high degree of homology to MutL related proteins. On the basis of its closer relationship to the eukaryotic "PMS" genes than to the "MLH" genes, we have designated the S. pombe homologue pms1. Disruption of the pms1 gene causes a significant increase of spontaneous mutagenesis as documented by reversion rate measurements. Tetrad analyses of crosses homozygous for the pms1 mutation reveal a reduction of spore viability from > 92% to 80% associated with a low proportion (approximately 50%) of meioses producing four viable spores and a significant, allele-dependent increase of the level of post-meiotic segregation of genetic marker allele pairs. The mutant phenotypes are consistent with a general function of pms1 in correction of mismatched base pairs arising as a consequence of DNA polymerase errors during DNA synthesis, or of hybrid DNA formation between homologous but not perfectly complementary DNA strands during meiotic recombination.

The distance-dependence of the fission yeast ade6-M26 marker effect in two-factor crosses

Random spore analysis of crosses between a strain bearing the ade6-M26 hotspot mutation and strains bearing other ade6 mutations was performed. Recombinant prototroph frequencies increase with increasing distance from M26 for mutations both 5' and 3' of M26. Maximum prototroph frequencies are obtained for mutations lying more than 700 nucleotides downstream from M26. Similar results are obtained for crosses with the ade6-M375 control mutation, but the prototroph frequencies are lower. The factor of stimulation of recombination by M26 as compared to the M375 control (M26 marker effect) also displays distance-dependence. These results are discussed in the context of the mechanism of M26 recombination, as well as in relation to recombination initiation, hybrid DNA formation, and mismatch repair at ade6. Keywords Conversion middle dot M26 hotspot middle dot Recombination middle dot Schizosaccharomyces pombe

Hot spots of recombination in fission yeast: inactivation of the M26 hot spot by deletion of the ade6 promoter and the novel hotspot ura4-aim

The M26 mutation in the ade6 gene of Schizosaccharomyces pombe creates a hot spot of meiotic recombination. A single base substitution, the M26 mutation is situated within the open reading frame, near the 5' end. It has previously been shown that the heptanucleotide sequence 5' ATGACGT 3', which includes the M26 mutation, is required for hot spot activity. The 510-bp ade6-delXB deletion encompasses the promoter and the first 23 bp of the open reading frame, ending 112 bp upstream of M26. Deletion of the promoter in cis to M26 abolishes hot spot activity, while deletion in trans to M26 has no effect. Homozygous deletion of the promoter also eliminates M26 hot spot activity, indicating that the heterology created through deletion of the promoter per se is not responsible for the loss of hot spot activity. Thus, DNA sequences other than the heptanucleotide 5' ATGACGT 3', which must be located at the 5' end of the ade6 gene, appear to be required for hot spot activity. While the M26 hotspot stimulates crossovers associated with M26 conversion, it does not affect the crossover frequency in the intervals adjacent to ade6. The flanking marker ura4-aim, a heterology created by insertion of the ura4+ gene upstream of ade6, turned out to be a hot spot itself. It shows disparity of conversion with preferential loss of the insertion. The frequency of conversion at ura4-aim is reduced when the M26 hot spot is active 15 kb away, indicating competition for recombination factors by hot spots in close proximity.

A role for exonuclease I from S. pombe in mutation avoidance and mismatch correction

Exonuclease I (Exo I) from Schizosaccharomyces pombe, a 5'-->3' double-stranded DNA exonuclease, is induced during meiotic prophase I. The exo1 gene is a member of a family of related DNA repair genes, including RAD2/rad13/xpgc and YKL510/rad2, conserved from yeast to humans. An exo1 mutant displays a mutator phenotype and alters activity of the ade6-M387 marker effect. These results suggest that Exo I acts in a pathway that corrects mismatched base pairs.

Identification of two mismatch-binding activities in protein extracts of Schizosaccharomyces pombe

We have performed band-shift assays to identify mismatch-binding proteins in cell extracts of Schizosaccharomyces pombe. By testing heteroduplex DNA containing either a T/G or a C/C mismatch, two distinct band shifts were produced in the gels. A low mobility complex was observed with the T/G substrate, while a high mobility complex was present with C/C. Further analysis of the mismatch-binding specificities revealed that the T/G binding activity also binds to T/C, C/T, T/T, T/-, A/-, C/-, G/-, G/G, A/A, A/C, A/G, G/T, G/A, and C/A substrates with varying efficiencies, but not binds to C/C. The C/C binding activity efficiently binds to C/C, T/C, C/T, C/A, A/C, C/-, and weakly also to T/T, while all other mispairs are not recognized. Protein extracts of a mutant strain, defective in the mutS homologue swi4, displayed both mismatch-binding activities. Thus, swi4 does not encode for either one of the mismatch-binding proteins.

Homologous recombination in fission yeast: absence of crossover interference and synaptonemal complex

The study of homologous recombination in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe has recently been extended to the cytological analysis of meiotic prophase. Unlike in most eukaryotes no tripartite SC structure is detectable, but linear elements resembling axial cores of other eukaryotes are retained. They may be indispensable for meiotic recombination and proper chromosome segregation in meiosis I. In addition fission yeast shows interesting features of chromosome organization in vegetative and meiotic cells: Centromeres and telomeres cluster and associate with the spindle pole body. The special properties of fission yeast meiosis correlate with the absence of crossover interference in meiotic recombination. These findings are discussed. In addition homologous recombination in fission yeast is reviewed briefly.

M26 recombinational hotspot and physical conversion tract analysis in the ade6 gene of Schizosaccharomyces pombe

At the ade6 locus of Schizosaccharomyces pombe flanking markers have been introduced as well as five silent restriction site polymorphisms: four in the 5' upstream region and one in the middle of the gene. The mutations ade6-706, ade6-M26 (both at the 5' end) and ade6-51 (middle of the gene) were used as partners for crosses with the 3' mutation ade6-469. From these three types of crosses, wild-type recombinants were selected and analyzed genetically to assess association with crossing-over and physically to determine conversion tract lengths. The introduced restriction site polymorphisms (five vs. only one) neither influenced the pattern of recombinant types nor the distribution of conversion tracts. The hotspot mutation M26 enhances crossing-over and conversion to the same proportion. M26 not only stimulates conversion at the 5' end, but does this also (to a lower extent) at the 3' end of ade6 at a distance of more than 1 kb. The majority of meiotic conversion tracts are continuous and postmeiotic segregation of polymorphic sites is rare. Conversion tracts are slightly shorter with M26 in comparison with its control 706. The mean minimal length of tracts varies from 670 bp (M26) to 890 bp (706) to 1290 bp (51). It is concluded that M26 acts as an initiation site of recombination or enhances initiation of recombination. M26 does not act by termination of conversion. A region of recombination initiation exists at the 5' end of the ade6 gene also in the absence of the ade6-M26 hotspot mutation.

Marker effects of G to C transversions on intragenic recombination and mismatch repair in Schizosaccharomyces pombe

G to C transversion mutations show very strong allele-specific marker effects on the frequency of wild-type recombinants in intragenic two-factor crosses. Here we present a detailed study of the marker effect of one representative, the ade6-M387 mutation of Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Crosses of M387 with other mutations at varying distance reveal highly increased prototroph frequencies in comparison with the C to T transition mutation ade6-51 (control without any known marker effect) located four nucleotides from M387. The marker effect of M387 is strongest (> 40-fold) for crosses with mutations less than 15 nucleotides from M387. It decreases to an intermediate level (5-10-fold) in crosses with mutations located 25-150 base pairs from M387/51 and is very low in crosses with mutations beyond 200 base pairs. On the basis of these results and the quantitation of the low efficiency of C/C mismatch repair presented in the accompanying publication we propose the existence of at least two different types of mechanisms for base mismatch repair in fission yeast. The major system is suggested to recognize all base mismatches except C/C with high efficiency and to generate long excision tracts (approximately 100 nucleotides unidirectionally). The minor system is proposed to recognize all base mismatches including C/C with low and variable efficiency and to have short excision tracts (approximately 10 nucleotides unidirectionally). We estimate from the M387 marker effect that the minor system accounts for approximately 1-8% repair of non-C/C mismatches (depending on the nature of the mutation) in fission yeast meiosis.