C-terminal deletions can suppress temperature-sensitive mutations and change dominance in the phage Mu repressor

Muprints and Whole Genome Insertion Scans: Methods for Investigating Chromosome Accessibility and DNA Dynamics using Bacteriophage Mu

Bacteriophage Mu infects a broad range of gram-negative bacteria. After infection, Mu amplifies its DNA through a coupled transposition/replication cycle that inserts copies of Mu throughout all domains of the folded chromosome. Mu has the most relaxed target specificity of the known transposons (Manna et al., J Bacteriol 187: 3586-3588, 2005) and the Mu DNA packaging process, called "headful packaging", incorporates 50-150 bp of host sequences covalently bound to its left end and 2 kb of host DNA linked to its right end into a viral capsid. The combination of broad insertion coverage and easy phage purification makes Mu ideal for analyzing chromosome dynamics and DNA structure inside living cells. "Mu printing" (Wang and Higgins, Mol Microbiol 12: 665-677, 1994; Manna et al., J Bacteriol 183: 3328-3335, 2001) uses the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to generate a quantitative fine structure map of Mu insertion sites within specific regions of a bacterial chromosome or plasmid. A complementary technique uses microarray platforms to provide quantitative insertion patterns covering a whole bacterial genome (Manna et al., J Bacteriol 187: 3586-3588, 2005; Manna et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101: 9780-9785, 2004). These two methods provide a powerful complementary system to investigate chromosome structure inside living cells.

Activation of a dormant ClpX recognition motif of bacteriophage Mu repressor by inducing high local flexibility

The C-terminal domain (CTD) of bacteriophage Mu immunity repressor (Rep) regulates DNA binding by the N-terminal domain and degradation by ClpXP protease. Five residues at the Rep C terminus (CTD5) can serve as a ClpX recognition motif, but it is dormant unless activated, a state that can be induced by the presence of dominant-negative mutant repressors (Vir). Conversion of Rep to ClpXP-sensitive form was associated with not only increased exposure of CTD5 to solvent but also increased CTD motion or flexibility as measured by fluorescence anisotropy. CTD mutations (V183S, K193S, and V196S) promoting ClpXP resistance without destroying the recognition motif prevented increased CTD motion induced by Vir. Suppression of ClpXP protease resistance conferred by the V196S mutation also correlated with restoration of CTD motion. The temperature-sensitive R47Q mutation present in cis within the DNA-binding domain restored ClpXP protease sensitivity to the V196S mutant, and anisotropy analysis indicated that R47Q allows the V196S CTD to gain increased flexibility when Vir was present. The results indicate that the CTD functions to turn the recognition motif on and off, most likely by modulating flexibility of the domain that harbors the ClpX recognition motif, suggesting a general mechanism by which proteins can regulate their own degradation.

Growth rate toxicity phenotypes and homeostatic supercoil control differentiate Escherichia coli from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium share high degrees of DNA and amino acid identity for 65% of the homologous genes shared by the two genomes. Yet, there are different phenotypes for null mutants in several genes that contribute to DNA condensation and nucleoid formation. The mutant R436-S form of the GyrB protein has a temperature-sensitive phenotype in Salmonella, showing disruption of supercoiling near the terminus and replicon failure at 42 degrees C. But this mutation in E. coli is lethal at the permissive temperature. A unifying hypothesis for why the same mutation in highly conserved homologous genes of different species leads to different physiologies focuses on homeotic supercoil control. During rapid growth in mid-log phase, E. coli generates 15% more negative supercoils in pBR322 DNA than Salmonella. Differences in compaction and torsional strain on chromosomal DNA explain a complex set of single-gene phenotypes and provide insight into how supercoiling may modulate epigenetic effects on chromosome structure and function and on prophage behavior in vivo.

Control of Bacteriophage Mu Lysogenic Repression

The transposable and temperate phage Mu infects Escherichia coli where it can enter the lytic life-cycle or reside as a repressed and integrated prophage. The repressor protein Rep is the key element in the lysis-lysogeny decision. We have analyzed the fate of Rep in different mutants by Western blotting under two conditions that can induce a lysogen: high temperature and stationary phase. We show that, unexpectedly, Rep accumulates under all conditions where the prophage is completely derepressed, and that this accumulation is ClpX-dependent. An analysis of the degradation kinetics shows that Rep is a target of two protease systems: inactivation of either the clpP or lon gene results in a stabilization of Rep. Such a reaction scheme explains the counterintuitive observation that derepression is correlated with high repressor concentration. We conclude that under all conditions of phage induction the repressor is sequestered in a non-active form. A quantitative simulation accounts for our experimental data. It provides a model that captures the essential features of Mu induction and explains some of the mechanisms by which the physiological signals affecting the lysis-lysogeny decision converge onto Rep.

A context-dependent ClpX recognition determinant located at the C terminus of phage Mu repressor

The bacteriophage Mu immunity repressor is a conformationally sensitive sensor that can be interconverted between forms resistant to and sensitive to degradation by ClpXP protease. Protease-sensitive repressor molecules with an altered C-terminal sequence promote rapid degradation of the wild-type repressor by inducing its C-terminal end to become exposed. Here we determined that the last 5 C-terminal residues (CTD5) of the wild-type repressor contain the motif required for recognition by the ClpX molecular chaperone, a motif that is strongly dependent upon the context in which it is presented. Although attachment of the 11-residue ssrA degradation tag to the C terminus of green fluorescent protein (GFP) promoted its rapid degradation by ClpXP, attachment of 5-27 C-terminal residues of the repressor failed to promote degradation. Disordered peptides derived from 41 and 35 C-terminal residues of CcdA (CcdA41) and thioredoxin (TrxA35), respectively, activated CTD5 when placed as linkers between GFP and repressor C-terminal sequences. However, when the entire thioredoxin sequence was included as a linker to promote an ordered configuration of the TrxA35 peptide, the resulting substrate was not degraded. In addition, a hybrid tag, in which CTD5 replaced the 3-residue recognition motif of the ssrA tag, was inactive when attached directly to GFP but active when attached through the CcdA41 peptide. Thus, CTD5 is sufficient to act as a recognition motif but has requirements for its presentation not shared by the ssrA tag. We suggest that activation of CTD5 may require presentation on a disordered or flexible domain that confers ligand flexibility.

Trans-targeting of the phage Mu repressor is promoted by conformational changes that expose its ClpX recognition determinant

Dominant negative forms of the phage Mu repressor, including the mutant Vir repressors, are not only rapidly degraded by the ClpXP protease but also promote degradation of the unmodified, wild-type repressor. This trans-targeting of the wild-type repressor depends upon a determinant within its C-terminal domain, which is needed for recognition by ClpX. An environmentally sensitive fluorescent probe (2-(4'-maleimidylanilino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid (MIANS)) attached to the C terminus of the full-length repressor indicated that Vir induces the movement of this domain into a more exposed configuration. Vir also promoted attachment of MIANS to the C terminus of the repressor at an accelerated rate, and it greatly increased the rate of phosphorylation of a cAMP-dependent protein kinase motif attached to the repressor C terminus. While an excess of Vir was needed to promote repressor phosphorylation at maximal rates, the presence of ClpX could increase phosphorylation rates at lower Vir levels. trans-Targeting of the Mu repressor is therefore promoted by exposing its ClpX recognition determinant, and the action of ClpX can assist Vir in exposing these determinants.

Modulation of phage Mu repressor DNA binding and degradation by distinct determinants in its C-terminal domain

Rapid degradation of the bacteriophage Mu immunity repressor can be induced in trans by mutant, protease-hypersensitive repressors (Vir) with an altered C-terminal domain (CTD). Genetic and biochemical analysis established that distinct yet overlapping determinants in the wild-type repressor CTD modulate Vir-induced degradation by Escherichia coli ClpXP protease and DNA binding by the N-terminal DNA-binding domain (DBD). Although deletions of the repressor C-terminus resulted in both resistance to ClpXP protease and suppression of a temperature-sensitive DBD mutation (cts62), some cysteine-replacement mutations in the CTD elicited only one of the two phenotypes. Some CTD mutations prevented degradation induced by Vir and resulted in the loss of intrinsic ClpXP protease sensitivity, characteristic of wild-type repressor, and at least two mutant repressors protected Vir from proteolysis. One protease-resistant mutant became susceptible to Vir-induced degradation when it also contained the cts62 mutation, which weakens DNA binding but apparently facilitates conversion to a protease-sensitive conformation. Conversely, this CTD mutation was able to suppress temperature sensitivity of DNA binding by the cts62 repressor. The results suggest that determinants in the CTD not only provide a cryptic ClpX recognition motif but also direct CTD movement that exposes the motif and modulates DNA binding.

Characterization of the cts4 repressor mutation in transposable bacteriophage Mu

Mucts4 was isolated more than 30 years ago and was the first available thermoinducible derivative of transposable phage Mu. We have characterized the cts4 mutation and the corresponding mutant protein. Contrary to previously characterized thermoinducible Mu prophages (e.g., Mucts62), Mucts4 lysogenizes at reduced frequency even at 30 degrees C. The cts4 mutation (Leu129Val) was located in this central repressor region. The cts4 protein was thermosensitive for operator DNA binding in vitro. Temperature-dependent changes in protein-protein cross-linking patterns in the absence of DNA were detected for purified wild type, cts62 and cts4 repressor proteins. The cts4 protein exhibited a subtly different electrophoretic profile, which became more marked at higher temperatures, from both the wild type and cts62. In addition the cts4 repressor generated a significantly different pattern of binding to DNA fragments carrying the early operator region. Consistent with the predicted involvement of the central leucine-rich region of the Mu repressor in the formation of multimeric forms, the cts4 mutation thus appeared to affect protein-protein interactions.

Derepression of bacteriophage mu transposition functions by truncated forms of the immunity repressor

To trigger bacteriophage Mu transposition and replication in response to physiological signals, its immunity repressor must be synchronously inactivated. Two repressor mutants (Vir), which have an altered C-terminal domain and are highly susceptible to degradation by ClpXP protease, confer a dominant negative phenotype by promoting degradation of the wild-type repressor. To search for other modified repressors that can induce Mu derepression in vivo and to determine what part of the inducing repressor molecules are needed to target the unmodified repressor population, repressor peptides with nested deletions starting at the C-terminal end were constructed. Such peptides with a C-terminal ssrA degradation tag promoted a sharp reduction in cellular levels of full-length unmodified repressor, a process largely dependent upon the clpP protease function. Only the repressor DNA-binding domain, located at the N-terminal end, was required in tagged peptides to target unmodified repressor. In addition, some repressor peptides containing the DNA-binding domain promoted derepression without the clpP function, being able to promote repressor inactivation without promoting its degradation. None of the modified repressors could promote derepression if immunity was established by a mutant repressor lacking 18 residues at its C-terminal end. The results indicate that inducing repressor peptides influence the function of the C-terminal domain of the intact repressor, a domain that regulates its degradation and DNA binding. They suggest the possibility that tagged repressor molecules, produced by stalled ribosomes, can be inducers of transposition under starvation conditions.

Conformational dynamics of a transposition repressor in modulating DNA binding

The repressor of bacteriophage Mu functions in the establishment and maintenance of lysogeny by binding to Mu operator DNA to shut down transposition. A domain at its N terminus functions in DNA binding, and temperature-sensitive mutations in this domain can be suppressed by truncations at the C terminus. To understand the role of the C-terminal tail in DNA binding, a fluorescent probe was attached to the C terminus to examine its environment and its movement with respect to the DNA binding domain. The emission spectrum of this probe indicated that the C terminus was in a relatively hydrophobic environment, comparable to the environment of the probe attached within the DNA-binding domain. Fluorescence of two tryptophan residues located within the DNA-binding domain was quenched by the probe attached to the C terminus, indicating that the C terminus is in close proximity to this domain. Addition of DNA, even when it did not contain operator DNA, reduced quenching of tryptophan fluorescence, indicating that the tail moves away from the DNA-binding domain as it interacts with DNA. The presence of the tail also produced a trypsin hypersensitive site within the DNA-binding domain; mutant repressors with an altered or truncated C terminus were relatively resistant to cleavage at this site. Interaction of the wild-type repressor with DNA greatly reduced cleavage at the site. A repressor with a temperature-sensitive mutation in the DNA-binding domain was especially sensitive to cleavage by trypsin even in the presence of DNA, and the C-terminal tail failed to move in the presence of DNA at elevated temperatures. These results indicate that the tail sterically inhibits DNA binding and that it moves during establishment of repression. Such conformational changes are likely to be involved in communication between repressor protomers for cooperative DNA binding.

The tRNA function of SsrA contributes to controlling repression of bacteriophage Mu prophage

The small regulatory RNA SsrA has both tRNA and mRNA activities. It charges alanine and interacts with stalled ribosomes, allowing for translation to resume on the SsrA mRNA moiety. Hence, unfinished peptides carry a short amino acid tag, which serves as a signal for degradation by energy-dependent proteases. In SsrA-defective Escherichia coli strains, thermoinducible mutants of the transposable bacteriophage Mu (Mucts) are no longer induced at high temperature. Here we show that truncated forms of the key regulator of Mu lysogeny, the repressor Repc, accumulate in the absence of SsrA. These forms resemble C-terminally truncated dominant Mu repressor mutants previously isolated from Mucts, which are no longer thermoinducible and bind operator DNA with a high affinity even at high temperature. Using various ssrA alleles, we demonstrate the importance of SsrA charging on the ribosome for controlling Mu prophage repression. Our results thus substantiate the previous observation that trans-translation is not the only function of the SsrA. The alternative function of SsrA appears to influence the stability of Mu lysogens by controlling the translation of the C-terminal domain of the repressor protein, which modulates the affinity of the protein for DNA and its susceptibility to proteolytic degradation.

Transcription induces a supercoil domain barrier in bacteriophage Mu

In enteric bacteria, chromosomes are partitioned into domains that exhibit restricted supercoil movement. The most common domain barrier detected by gammadelta resolution assays is random with respect to sequence and occurs more frequently in cells growing rapidly in rich medium compared to cells in stationary phase. Transcription generates both positive and negative supercoiling movement. To address the question of whether transcription causes the appearance of new domain boundaries, a transcriptionally active MudI element was substituted for a MudJr-1 element that resides within the cobT gene of Salmonella typhimurium. Mu-specific transcription from the phage early promoter was placed under control of either the wild type (c(+)) or the temperature-sensitive (cts62) repressor. Using a resolution assay with res sites at six chromosomal locations, domain structure was normal in cells carrying the MudAr-1 prophage with a wild type Mu repressor. However, in cells with a MudAr-1 prophage harboring the cts62 repressor, a new domain barrier appeared in > 90% of the cells. Supercoil movement was restricted ahead of but not behind the transcription machinery. We conclude that the strong Mu early promoter induces the appearance of a domain barrier within the limits of a MudAr-1 prophage.

Starvation-induced Mucts62-mediated coding sequence fusion: a role for ClpXP, Lon, RpoS and Crp

The formation of araB-lacZ coding sequence fusions in Escherichia coli is a particular type of chromosomal rearrangement induced by Mucts62, a thermoinducible mutant of mutator phage Mu. Fusion formation is controlled by the host physiology. It only occurs after aerobic carbon starvation and requires the phage-encoded transposase pA, suggesting that these growth conditions trigger induction of the Mucts62 prophage. Here, we show that thermal induction of the prophage accelerated araB-lacZ fusion formation, confirming that derepression is a rate-limiting step in the fusion process. Nonetheless, starvation conditions remained essential to complete fusions, suggesting additional levels of physiological regulation. Using a transcriptional fusion indicator system in which the Mu early lytic promoter is fused to the reporter E. coli lacZ gene, we confirmed that the Mucts62 prophage was derepressed in stationary phase (S derepression) at low temperature. S derepression did not apply to prophages that expressed the Mu wild-type repressor. It depended upon the host ClpXP and Lon ATP-dependent proteases and the RpoS stationary phase-specific sigma factor, but not upon Crp. None of these four functions was required for thermal induction. Crp was required for fusion formation, but only when the Mucts62 prophage encoded the transposition/replication activating protein pB. Finally, we found that thermally induced cultures did not return to the repressed state when shifted back to low temperature and, hence, remained activated for accelerated fusion formation upon starvation. The maintenance of the derepressed state required the ClpXP and Lon host proteases and the prophage Ner-regulatory protein. These observations illustrate how the cts62 mutation in Mu repressor provides the prophage with a new way to respond to growth phase-specific regulatory signals and endows the host cell with a new potential for adaptation through the controlled use of the phage transposition machinery.

The ClpXP and ClpAP proteases degrade proteins with carboxy-terminal peptide tails added by the SsrA-tagging system

Interruption of translation in Escherichia coli can lead to the addition of an 11-residue carboxy-terminal peptide tail to the nascent chain. This modification is mediated by SsrA RNA (also called 10Sa RNA and tmRNA) and marks the tagged polypeptide for proteolysis. Degradation in vivo of lambda repressor amino-terminal domain variants bearing this carboxy-terminal SsrA peptide tag is shown here to depend on the cytoplasmic proteases ClpXP and ClpAP. Degradation in vitro of SsrA-tagged substrates was reproduced with purified components and required a substrate with a wild-type SsrA tail, the presence of both ClpP and either ClpA or ClpX, and ATP. Clp-dependent proteolysis accounts for most degradation of SsrA-tagged amino-domain substrates at 32 degrees C, but additional proteases contribute to the degradation of some of these SsrA-tagged substrates at 39 degrees C. The existence of multiple cytoplasmic proteases that function in SsrA quality-control surveillance suggests that the SsrA tag is designed to serve as a relatively promiscuous signal for proteolysis. Having diverse degradation systems able to recognize this tag may increase degradation capacity, permit degradation of a wide variety of different tagged proteins, or allow SsrA-tagged proteins to be degraded under different growth conditions.

Versatile action of Escherichia coli ClpXP as protease or molecular chaperone for bacteriophage Mu transposition

The molecular chaperone ClpX of Escherichia coli plays two distinct functions for bacteriophage Mu DNA replication by transposition. As specificity component of a chaperone-linked protease, it recognizes the Mu immunity repressor for degradation by the peptidase component ClpP, thus derepressing Mu transposition functions. After strand exchange has been promoted by MuA transposase, ClpX alone can alter the conformation of the transpososome (the complex of MuA with Mu ends), and the remodeled MuA promotes transition to replisome assembly. Although ClpXP can degrade MuA, the presence of both ClpP and ClpX in the reconstituted transposition system did not destroy MuA essential for initiation of DNA replication by specific host replication enzymes. Levels of ClpXP needed to overcome inhibition by the repressor did not prevent MuA from promoting strand transfer, and ClpP stimulated alteration of the transpososome by ClpX. Apparently intact MuA was still present in the resulting transpososome, promoting initiation of Mu DNA replication by specific replication enzymes. The results indicate that ClpXP can discriminate repressor and MuA in the transpososome as substrates of the protease or the molecular chaperone alone, degrading repressor while remodeling MuA for its next critical function.

Communication of ClpXP protease hypersensitivity to bacteriophage Mu repressor isoforms

The immunity repressor (Rep) of bacteriophage Mu establishes and maintains lysogeny by shutting down transposition functions needed for phage DNA replication. Although Rep is stable in vivo, an altered immunity repressor (Vir) encoded by virulent, trans-dominant Mu mutants is rapidly degraded by Escherichia coli ClpXP protease. Rep and Vir are degraded at approximately the same maximal velocity (Vmax) by ClpXP, but the Km for Rep (3.6 microM) is over 20-fold higher than the Km for Vir (0.15 microM). Rep is also highly resistant to degradation in the presence of DNA whereas Vir is not. Vir increases the rate of Rep degradation by reducing its Km and imparts to Rep ClpXP sensitivity in the presence of DNA. Vir can drive at an accelerated rate the complete degradation of Rep molecules that outnumber Vir by eightfold or more. So long as Vir is present at a concentration of 0.1 microM or higher, Rep is degraded with a Km that is indistinguishable from that of Vir. These characteristics of repressor may be an important means of transducing physiological signals that induce Mu transposition in response to growth conditions or environmental stress, ClpXP hypersensitivity being disseminated among Rep molecules for the induction of Mu transposition.

In vivo mutational analysis of bacteriophage Mu operators

In bacteria lysogenic for bacteriophage Mu, the phage repressor binds to a tripartite operator region, O1,O2,O3, to repress the lytic promoter pE, located in O2, and negatively autoregulate its own synthesis at the pCM promoter located in O3. We isolated and characterized operator mutations which lead to derepression of pE. Their location in the first and third repressor-consensus-binding sequences in O2 confirms the importance of these sites for repressor/operator interactions.