Genetic diagnosis, sperm phenotype and ICSI outcome in case of severe asthenozoospermia with multiple morphological abnormalities of the flagellum

Novel variants in DNAH17 cause sperm flagellar outer dynein arm defects but not total fertilization failure after ICSI

RESEARCH QUESTION

Are there novel variants in the dynein axonemal heavy chain 17 (DNAH17) gene related to male infertility? What is the relationship between total fertilization failure (TFF) and DNAH17 deficiency?

DESIGN

Whole-exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing were performed in a cohort of 75 Chinese patients with multiple morphological abnormalities of sperm flagella (MMAF) to identify potential novel gene variants. Papanicolaou staining and electron microscopy were employed to observe sperm morphology and ultrastructure. Proteomic analysis and comprehensive functional analysis were performed to elucidate the relationship between DNAH17 deficiency and TFF at the molecular level.

RESULTS

Ten novel variants in DNAH17 were identified in five unrelated families with five infertile male probands. These variants exhibited an autosomal-recessive inheritance pattern and caused deficiency of DNAH17 in spermatozoa. Typical MMAF characteristics and deformations in the flagellar ultrastructure of DNAH17-deficient spermatozoa were observed. Comprehensive functional analysis revealed that DNAH17 deficiency impaired the assembly and docking of outer dynein arms, affected the acrosome reaction, and disrupted mitochondrial function. Fertilization-related proteins, such as actin-like protein 7A and PRKCA-binding protein, were normal, while reduced yet ≥30% concentrations of phospholipase C zeta were detected, implying an indirect relationship between DNAH17 deficiency and TFF. Four of the affected couples obtained transferable embryos following intracytoplasmic sperm injection without artificial oocyte activation.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings broaden the variant spectrum of DNAH17, and illuminate the complex molecular basis of male infertility associated with DNAH17 deficiency, particularly its heterogeneous impact on fertilization. The study provided vital insights for genetic diagnosis and counselling in males affected by MMAF.

Novel variants of FSIP2 and SPEF2 cause varying degrees of spermatozoa damage in MMAF patients and favorable ART outcomes

PURPOSE

This study identified novel variants of the FSIP2 and SPEF2 genes in multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) patients and to investigate the potential effect of variations on male infertility and assisted reproductive outcomes.

METHODS

Whole-exome sequencing was performed in 106 Chinese MMAF patients. The discovered variants were evaluated in silico and confirmed by Sanger sequencing. A mini-gene assay and immunofluorescence staining were used to determine the effects on mRNA and protein. Assisted reproductive technology (ART) based on intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) was used for MMAF patients carrying novel variants.

RESULTS

Biallelic variants in FSIP2 or SPEF2 involving nineteen novel variations were found in eleven MMAF patients. These variations included fourteen missense variants, two nonsense variants, two frameshift variants, and a splicing variant. The FSIP2 protein was markedly reduced or mislocalized to the spermatozoa head. Two novel missense variants of SPEF2 reduced cell diameter. Eleven MMAF couples had 12 ICSI cycles and 2 IVF cycles. The 2PN fertilization rate, good-quality embryos rate, and clinical pregnancy rate were 80.1% (133/166), 74.4% (99/133), and 45.7% (16/35). Four of them have seven babies born.

CONCLUSION

Our work revealed that missense variations of FSIP2 or SPEF2 might cause a milder spermatozoa damage. The infertility caused by FSIP2 and SPEF2 variants can be mitigated through ICSI or even IVF. The results of this study presented signs of the correlation of phenotype/genotype for the FSIP2 and SPEF2, which might provide a reference for clinical genetic and fertility consultation.

Acupuncture mediates the "gut-testis axis" to improve asthenozoospermia

Background

Asthenozoospermia is a common cause of male infertility. Studies have shown that sperm quality and motility are affected by the gut-testis axis that can regulate testicular metabolism and function through the gut microbiota and its metabolites. Acupuncture is an important modality of complementary and alternative medicine. It can improve sperm motility, but it remains unclear whether acupuncture can enhance sperm vitality by influencing the gut-testis axis.

Methods

In this study, sperm quality, testicular pathology, and serum hormone levels were assessed using a cyclophosphamide-induced mouse model. Real-time PCR, a western blot analysis, and immunofluorescence techniques were used to assess the effects of acupuncture on the gut barrier and blood-testis barrier functions. In addition, gut microbiome and metabolomics were used to study the impact of acupuncture on the gut microbiota structure, serum, and testicular metabolites in asthenozoospermic mice. Further validation was obtained by performing a fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT).

Results

Acupuncture improved the sperm quality; ameliorated testicular pathology; increased serum testosterone (T), follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), and luteinizing hormone (LH) levels; and repaired gut and blood-testis barrier damage in asthenozoospermic mice. The abundances of Bacteroidota, Firmicutes, Faecalibaculum, and Dubosiella were associated with sperm motility, as shown by a gut microbiome analysis. Serum metabolomics revealed that differentially expressed metabolites (DEMs), such as cytosine and N-oleyl-leucine, were closely related to sperm motility. Testicular metabolomics analysis revealed DEMs, such as 5-fluorouridine and 1-acetylimidazole, were also associated with sperm motility. Furthermore, reproductive function improvements in asthenozoospermic mice through acupuncture were achieved via an FMT.

Conclusion

Acupuncture may alleviate asthenozoospermia symptoms by modulating the gut-testis axis and repairing the gut-testis barrier.

A comprehensive study of the sperm head defects in MMAF condition and their impact on embryo development in mice

Among rare cases of teratozoospermia, MMAF (multiple morphological abnormalities of the flagellum) syndrome is a complex genetic disorder involving at least 70 different genes. As the name suggests, patients with MMAF syndrome produce spermatozoa with multiple flagellar defects, rendering them immobile and non-fertilizing, leading to complete infertility in affected men. The only viable treatment option is ICSI. What is less understood is the presence of the various types of head defects in the spermatozoa, which are consistently present. Due to the involvement of numerous genes and the limited number of patients with MMAF syndrome, research on head defects and their impact on embryonic development remains insufficiently explored. To address these questions, a comparative study was conducted under controlled experimental conditions using four knockout (KO) mouse lines targeting Cfap43, Cfap44, Armc2, and Ccdc146 genes, all associated with MMAF syndrome in humans and mice. Each KO line underwent a detailed examination of nuclear defects, including morphology, DNA compaction, chromosomal architecture, and ploidy. The study revealed significant heterogeneity among the four lineages, with the extent of defects varying depending on the lineage, ranked as Ccdc146-/- > Cfap43-/- > Armc2-/- ≈ Cfap44-/-. The developmental potential of sperm from males in each lineage was assessed by injecting them into wild-type oocytes, and embryo development was monitored up to the blastocyst stage. Sperm from all KO lines exhibited a marked decrease in supporting embryo development compared to the wild-type, with developmental failure rates ranked as follows: Ccdc146 > Cfap43 > Armc2 > Cfap44-deficient sperm. The degree of developmental failure thus correlated with the severity of nuclear defects, and zygotes produced with sperm from Ccdc146-/- and Cfap43-/- mice showed the highest rates of developmental impairment. These findings from preclinical models highlight the heterogeneous nature of MMAF syndrome, both in terms of sperm nuclear defects and developmental potentials. Genetic characterization in humans is therefore crucial for improving therapeutic counselling in affected individuals.

Human asthenozoospermia: Update on genetic causes, patient management, and clinical strategies

BACKGROUND

In mammals, sperm fertilization potential relies on efficient progression within the female genital tract to reach and fertilize the oocyte. This fundamental property is supported by the flagellum, an evolutionarily conserved organelle, which contains dynein motor proteins that provide the mechanical force for sperm propulsion and motility. Primary motility of the sperm cells is acquired during their transit through the epididymis and hyperactivated motility is acquired throughout the journey in the female genital tract by a process called capacitation. These activation processes rely on the micro-environment of the genital tracts. In particular, during capacitation, a panoply of ion transporters located at the surface of the sperm cells mediate complex ion exchanges, which induce an increase in plasma membrane fluidity, the alkalinization of the cytoplasm and protein phosphorylation cascades that are compulsory for sperm hyperactivation and fertilization potential. As a consequence, both structural and functional defects of the sperm flagellum can affect sperm motility, resulting in asthenozoospermia, which constitutes the most predominant pathological condition associated with human male infertility.

OBJECTIVES

Herein, we have performed a literature review to provide a comprehensive description of the recent advances in the genetics of human asthenozoospermia.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

We describe the currently knowledge on gene mutations that affect sperm morphology and motility, namely, asthenoteratozoospermia; we also specify the gene mutations that exclusively affect sperm function and activation, resulting in functional asthenozoospermia. We discuss the benefit of this knowledge for patient and couple management, in terms of genetic counselling and diagnosis of male infertility as a sole phenotype or in association with ciliary defects. Last, we discuss the current strategies that have been initiated for the development of potential therapeutical and contraceptive strategies targeting genes that are essential for sperm function and activation.

The Molecular Basis of Multiple Morphological Abnormalities of Sperm Flagella and Its Impact on Clinical Practice

Multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) is a specific form of severe flagellar or ciliary deficiency syndrome. MMAF is characterized by primary infertility with abnormal morphology in the flagella of spermatozoa, presenting with short, absent, bent, coiled, and irregular flagella. As a rare disease first named in 2014, studies in recent years have shed light on the molecular defects of MMAF that comprise the structure and biological function of the sperm flagella. Understanding the molecular genetics of MMAF may provide opportunities for the development of diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for this rare disease. This review aims to summarize current studies regarding the molecular pathogenesis of MMAF and describe strategies of genetic counseling, clinical diagnosis, and therapy for MMAF.

Single nucleotide polymorphisms of CFAP43 and TEX14 associated with idiopathic male infertility in a Vietnamese population

Male infertility is a multifactorial disease due to spermatogenesis impairment, with etiology remaining unknown for roughly one-third of infertile cases. Several studies have demonstrated that genetic variants are male infertility risk factors. CFAP43 and TEX14 are involved in the spermatogenesis process. The present study aimed to assess the association between single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in CFAP43 (rs17116635 and rs10883979) and TEX14 (rs79813370 and rs34818467) and idiopathic male infertility in a Vietnamese population. A cohort of 206 infertile men and 195 controls were recruited for the study. CFAP43 and TEX14 SNPs were genotyped using polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP). Genotypes of randomly selected samples, accounting for 10% of the total, were confirmed using Sanger sequencing. The obtained data were analyzed using statistical methods. The results showed that 4 SNPs (rs17116635, rs10883979, rs79813370, and rs34818467) were in accordance with Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium (HWE; P > .05). CFAP43 rs10883979 and TEX14 rs79813370 were associated with male infertility. For CFAP43 rs10883979, in the recessive model, the combination AA + AG was associated with male infertility when compared to the GG genotype (OR = 0.26; 95% CI: 0.06-0.85; P = .02). For TEX14 rs79813370, a protective effect against infertility risk was identified in the presence of the T allele of rs79813370 when compared to the G allele (OR = 0.48; 95% CI: 0.32-0.72; P < .001). Our results suggest that CFAP43 rs10883979 and TEX14 rs79813370 are likely associated with male infertility in the Vietnamese population, in which the G allele of rs79813370 may be a risk factor for male infertility.

How exome sequencing improves the diagnostics and management of men with non-syndromic infertility

Male infertility affects approximately 17% of all men and represents a complex disorder in which not only semen parameters such as sperm motility, morphology, and number of sperm are highly variable, but also testicular phenotypes range from normal spermatogenesis to complete absence of germ cells. Genetic factors significantly contribute to the disease but chromosomal aberrations, mostly Klinefelter syndrome, and microdeletions of the Y-chromosome have remained the only diagnostically and clinically considered genetic causes. Monogenic causes remain understudied and, thus, often unidentified, leaving the majority of the male factor couple infertility pathomechanistically unexplained. This has been changing mostly because of the introduction of exome sequencing that allows the analysis of multiple genes in large patient cohorts. As a result, pathogenic variants in single genes have been associated with non-syndromic forms of all aetiologic sub-categories in the last decade. This review highlights the contribution of exome sequencing to the identification of novel disease genes for isolated (non-syndromic) male infertility by presenting the results of a comprehensive literature search. Both, reduced sperm count in azoospermic and oligozoospermic patients, and impaired sperm motility and/or morphology, in asthenozoospermic and/or teratozoospermic patients are highly heterogeneous diseases with well over 100 different candidate genes described for each entity. Applying the standardized evaluation criteria of the ClinGen gene curation working group, 70 genes with at least moderate evidence to contribute to the disease are highlighted. The implementation of these valid disease genes in clinical exome sequencing is important to increase the diagnostic yield in male infertility and, thus, improve clinical decision-making and appropriate genetic counseling. Future advances in androgenetics will continue to depend on large-scale exome and genome sequencing studies of comprehensive international patient cohorts, which are the most promising approaches to identify additional disease genes and provide reliable data on the gene-disease relationship.

Further evidence from DNAH12 supports favorable fertility outcomes of infertile males with dynein axonemal heavy chain gene family variants

Male infertility is a major concern affecting reproductive health. Biallelic deleterious variants of most DNAH gene family members have been linked to male infertility, with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) being an efficacious way to achieve offspring. However, the association between DNAH12 and male infertility is still limited. Here, we identified one homozygous variant and two compound heterozygous variants in DNAH12 from three infertile Chinese men. Semen analysis revealed severe asthenozoospermia, abnormal morphology, and structure of sperm flagella. Furthermore, the Dnah12 knock-out mouse revealed severe spermatogenesis failure and validated the same male infertility phenotype. Favorable fertility outcomes were achieved through ICSI in three human individuals and Dnah12 knock-out mice. Collectively, our study indicated that biallelic variants of DNAH12 can induce male infertility in both human beings and mice. Notably, evidence from DNAH12 enhanced that ICSI was an optimal intervention to achieve favorable fertility outcomes for infertile males with DNAH gene family variants.

Low human sperm motility coexists with sperm nuclear DNA damage and oxidative stress in semen

BACKGROUND

Low sperm motility, one of the common causes of male infertility, is associated with abnormal sperm quality. Currently, important sperm/semen biomarkers are sperm chromatin status and oxidation‒reduction potential (ORP) in semen. Because the association between sperm motility and these biomarkers is still not fully clarified, our study was designed to verify the distribution and risk of sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) and oxidative stress in semen in asthenozoospermic men.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study was carried out on discharged sperm cells of asthenozoospermic men (isolated asthenozoospermia or coexisted with reduced sperm number and/or morphology), nonasthenozoospermic men (reduced total sperm count and/or sperm morphology) (experimental groups) and normozoospermic men (proven and presumed fertility) (control group). Basic semen analysis was evaluated according to the 6th edition of the World Health Organization manual guidelines. SDF was assessed using the sperm chromatin dispersion test, while static(s) ORP in semen was measured by means of a MiOXSYS analyser.

RESULTS

The men from the asthenozoospermic group had lower basic semen parameters than those from the control and nonasthenozoospermic groups. In men with poor sperm motility SDF and sORP, prevalence and risk for > 20% SDF (high level of DNA damage) and for > 1.37 sORP (oxidative stress) were significantly higher than those of control and nonasthenozoospermic subjects. The risk for sperm DNA damage and oxidative stress in asthenozoospermic men was over 10-fold higher and almost 6-fold higher than those in control subjects and almost or over 3-fold higher than those in nonasthenozoospermic men.

CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION

Poor human sperm motility coexisted with low basic sperm quality. Sperm DNA damage and oxidative stress in semen were much more frequent in asthenozoospermia. These abnormalities can decrease the sperm fertilizing capability under both natural and medically assisted reproduction conditions. Thus, in asthenozoospermia, the evaluation of sperm chromatin status and oxidation-reduction potential in semen is justified and inevitable, and the appropriate antioxidant therapy can be suggested.

Identification of a novel CFAP61 homozygous splicing variant associated with multiple morphological abnormalities of the flagella

In this study, we investigated the role of a newly identified homozygous variant (c.1245 + 6T > C) in the CFAP61 gene in the development of multiple morphologically abnormal flagella (MMAF) in an infertile patient. Using exome sequencing, we identified this variant, which led to exon 12 skipping and the production of a truncated CFAP61 protein. Transmission electron microscopy analysis of the patient's spermatozoa revealed various flagellar abnormalities, including defective nuclear chromatin condensation, axoneme disorganization, and mitochondria embedded in residual cytoplasmic droplets. Despite a fertilization rate of 83.3% through ICSI, there was no successful pregnancy due to poor embryo quality.Our findings suggest a link between the identified CFAP61 variant and MMAF, indicating potential disruption in radial spokes' assembly or function crucial for normal ciliary motility. Furthermore, nearly half of the observed sperm heads displayed chromatin condensation defects, possibly contributing to the low blastulation rate. This case underscores the significance of genetic counseling and testing, particularly for couples dealing with infertility and MMAF. Early identification of such genetic variants can guide appropriate interventions and improve reproductive outcomes.

A novel homozygous nonsense variant of AK7 is associated with multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella

RESEARCH QUESTION

Is the novel homozygous nonsense variant of AK7 associated with multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF), a specific type of oligoasthenoteratozoospermia leading to male infertility?

DESIGN

Whole-exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing were performed to identify potential gene variants. Immunoblotting and immunofluorescence were applied to confirm the relationship between mutated genes and disease phenotypes. The concentration of reactive oxygen species and the rate of apoptosis were measured to evaluate the mitochondrial function of spermatozoa. Transmission electron microscopy and scanning electron microscopy were employed to observe sperm ultrastructure.

RESULTS

A novel homozygous nonsense variant of AK7, c.1153A>T (p. Lys385*), was identified in two infertile siblings with asthenoteratozoospermia through whole-exome sequencing. Both immunoblotting and immunofluorescence assays showed practically complete absence of AK7 in the patient's spermatozoa. Additionally, the individual with the novel AK7 variant exhibited a phenotype characterized by severe oxidative stress and apoptosis caused by mitochondrial metabolic dysfunction of spermatozoa. Notably, remarkable flagellar defects with multiple axonemes in uniflagellate spermatozoa, accompanied by mitochondrial vacuolization, were observed; this has not been reported previously in patients with other AK7 variants.

CONCLUSIONS

This study found that a novel identified homozygous nonsense variant of AK7 may be associated with MMAF-related asthenoteratozoospermia. The observed functional associations between mitochondria and sperm flagellar assembly provide evidence for potential mutual regulation between AK7 and flagella-associated proteins during spermatogenesis.

Decreased embryo developmental potential and lower cumulative pregnancy rate in men with multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella

Objective

Multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) is characterized by abnormal flagellar phenotypes, which is a particular kind of asthenoteratozoospermia. Previous studies have reported a comparable intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) outcome in terms of fertilization rate and clinical pregnancy rate in patients with MMAF compared with those with no MMAF; however, others have conflicting opinions. Assisted reproductive technology (ART) outcomes in individuals with MMAF are still controversial and open to debate.

Methods

A total of 38 patients with MMAF treated at an academic reproductive center between January 2014 and July 2022 were evaluated in the current retrospective cohort study and followed up until January 2023. Propensity score matching was used to adjust for the baseline clinical characteristics of the patients and to create a comparable control group. The genetic pathogenesis of MMAF was confirmed by whole exome sequencing. The main outcomes were the embryo developmental potential, the cumulative pregnancy rate (CLPR), and the cumulative live birth rate (CLBR).

Results

Pathogenic variants in known genes of DNAH1, DNAH11, CFAP43, FSIP2, and SPEF2 were identified in patients with MMAF. Laboratory outcomes, including the fertilization rate, 2PN cleavage rate, blastocyst formation rate, and available blastocyst rate, followed a trend of decline in the MMAF group (p < 0.05). Moreover, according to the embryo transfer times and complete cycles, the CLPR in the cohort of MMAF was lower compared with the oligoasthenospermia pool (p = 0.033 and p = 0.020, respectively), while no statistical differences were observed in the neonatal outcomes.

Conclusion

The current study presented decreased embryo developmental potential and compromised clinical outcomes in the MMAF cohort. These findings may provide clinicians with evidence to support genetic counseling and clinical guidance in specific patients with MMAF.

Melatonin ameliorates PM2.5-induced spermatogenesis disorder by preserving H3K9 methylation and SIRT3

There was a link between exposure to PM2.5 and male infertility. Melatonin has beneficial effects on the male reproductive processes. How PM2.5 caused spermatogenesis disturbance and whether melatonin could prevent PM2.5-induced reproductive toxicity have remained unclear. The results showed that PM2.5 could inhibit the Nrf2-mediated antioxidant pathway and distinctly increase the cell apoptosis in testes. Moreover, PM2.5 also perturbed the process of meiosis by modulating meiosis-associated proteins such as γ-H2AX and Stra8. Mechanistically, PM2.5 inhibited G9a-dependent H3K9 methylation and SIRT3-mediated p53 deacetylation, which consistent with decreased sperm count and motility rate in ApoE-/- mice. Further investigation revealed melatonin effectively alleviated PM2.5-induced meiosis inhibition by preserving H3K9 methylation. Melatonin also alleviated PM2.5-induced apoptosis by regulating SIRT3-mediated p53 deacetylation. Overall, our study revealed PM2.5 resulted in spermatogenesis disorder by perturbing meiosis via G9a-dependent H3K9 di-methylation and causing cell apoptosis via SIRT3/p53 deacetylation pathway and provided promising insights into the protective role of melatonin in air pollution associated with male infertility.

CCDC65, encoding a component of the axonemal Nexin-Dynein regulatory complex, is required for sperm flagellum structure in humans

Sperm flagella share an evolutionary conserved microtubule-based structure with motile cilia expressed at the surface of several cell types, such as the airways epithelial cells. As a result, male infertility can be observed as an isolated condition or a syndromic trait, illustrated by Primary Cilia Dyskinesia (PCD). We report two unrelated patients showing multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) and carrying distinct homozygous truncating variants in the PCD-associated gene CCDC65. We characterized one of the identified variants (c.1208del; p.Asn403Ilefs*9), which induces the near absence of CCDC65 protein in patient sperm. In Chlamydomonas, CCDC65 ortholog (DRC2, FAP250) is a component of the Nexin-Dynein Regulatory complex (N-DRC), which interconnects microtubule doublets and coordinates dynein arms activity. In sperm cells from the patient, we also show the loss of GAS8, another component of the N-DRC, supporting a structural/functional link between the two proteins. Our work indicates that, similarly to ciliary axoneme, CCDC65 is required for sperm flagellum structure. Importantly, our work provides first evidence that mutations in the PCD-associated gene CCDC65 also cause asthenozoospermia.

Genetics of infertility: a paradigm shift for medically assisted reproduction

The field of reproductive genetics has undergone significant advancements with the completion of the Human Genome Project and the development of high-throughput sequencing techniques. This has led to the identification of numerous genes involved in both male and female infertility, revolutionizing the diagnosis and management of infertility patients. Genetic investigations, including karyotyping, specific genetic tests, and high-throughput sequencing, have become essential in determining the genetic causes of infertility. Moreover, the integration of genetics into reproductive medicine has expanded the scope of care to include not only affected individuals or couples but also their family members. Genetic consultations and counselling play a crucial role in identifying potentially affected relatives and offering tailored therapy and the possibility of fertility preservation. Despite the current limited therapeutic options, an increasing understanding of genotype-phenotype correlations in infertility genes holds promise for improved treatment outcomes. The availability of genetic diagnostic tools has reduced the number of idiopathic infertility cases by providing accurate aetiological diagnoses. The transition from research to clinical practice in reproductive genetics requires the establishment of genetic consultations and data warehousing systems to provide up-to-date information on gene-disease relationships. Overall, the integration of genetics into reproductive medicine has brought about a paradigm shift, emphasizing the familial dimension of infertility and offering new possibilities for personalized care and family planning.

Nuclear sperm integrity and ICSI prognosis in Tunisian patients with MMAF syndrome (multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella)

Multiple Morphological Abnormalities of the Sperm Flagella (MMAF) is a severe form of teratozoospermia associated with several sperm flagellar abnormalities. The study included 52 patients with MMAF syndrome and a control group of 25 fertile men. The impact of nuclear sperm quality on intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) results was studied in 20 couples. TUNEL assay was used to assess sperm DNA fragmentation and aniline-blue staining was used to assess chromatin condensation. To investigate chromosomal meiotic segregation, we used fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Semen morphology analysis revealed a mosaic of multiple flagella morphological abnormalities, including 46.73% short flagella, 16.22% bent flagella, 22.07% coiled flagella, and 10.90% absent flagella, all of which were associated with a high percentage of sperm head abnormalities. The mean DNA fragmentation index was substantially higher in patients compared to controls (p = 0.001), whereas the rate of aniline blue-reacted spermatozoa was not significantly different. There was a significant difference in aneuploidy frequencies between the two groups (p < 0.05). Infertile males with MMAF syndrome had lower sperm nuclear quality, which affected ICSI results. As a result, better sperm selection procedures are being employed to increase the success rate of assisted reproductive technologies (ART).

Results and perinatal outcomes from 189 ICSI cycles of couples with asthenozoospermic men and flagellar defects assessed by transmission electron microscopy

RESEARCH QUESTION

Do patients presenting with flagella ultrastructural defects as assessed by electron microscopy, and defined within three phenotypes (dysplasia of the fibrous sheath [DFS], primary flagellar dyskinesia [PFD] and non-specific flagellar abnormalities [NSFA]), have decreased chances of success in intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) or adverse obstetric and neonatal outcomes?

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of 189 ICSI cycles from 80 men with spermatozoa flagellum ultrastructural defects (DFS [n = 16]; PFD [n = 14]; NSFA [n = 50] compared with a control group (n = 97). Cycles were cumulatively analysed. All fresh and frozen embryo transfers resulting from each ICSI attempt were included. The effect of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) phenotype on the main ICSI outcomes was assessed by a multivariate logistic regression combined with a generalized linear mixed model to account for the non-independence of the observations.

RESULTS

No predictive value of TEM phenotype was found on the main outcomes of ICSI, namely fertilization rates, pregnancy and delivery rates, and cumulative pregnancy and delivery rates. Cumulative pregnancy rates ranged from 29.0-43.3% in the different TEM phenotype subgroups compared with 36.8% in the control group. Cumulative live birth rates ranged from 24.6-36.7% compared with 31.4% in the control group. No increase was found in miscarriages, preterm births, low birth weights or birth abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

Data on the cumulative chances of success in ICSI of patients with ultrastructural flagellar defects, a rare cause of male infertility often associated with an underlying genetic cause, are reassuring, as are obstetrical and neonatal outcomes in this population.

Novel mutations in DNAH17 cause sperm flagellum defects and their influence on ICSI outcome

PURPOSE

To identify new mutations in DNAH17 that cause male infertility and analyze intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) outcomes in patients with DNAH17 mutations.

METHODS

A total of five cases of new DNAH17 mutations exhibiting the multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) phenotype were identified through semen analysis and genetic testing. They were recruited at our reproductive medicine center from September 2018 to July 2022. Information on DNAH17 genetic mutations and ICSI outcomes was systematically explored following a literature review.

RESULTS

Three novel compound mutations in DNAH17 were identified in patients with male infertility caused by MMAF. This study and previous publications included 21 patients with DNAH17 mutations. DNAH17 has been associated with asthenozoospermia and male infertility, but different types of DNAH17 variants appear to be involved in different sperm phenotypes. In 11 couples of infertile patients with DNAH17 mutations, there were 17 ICSI cycles and 13 embryo transplantation cycles. Only three men with DNAH17 variants ultimately achieved clinical pregnancy with their partners through ICSI combined with assisted oocyte activation (AOA).

CONCLUSIONS

Loss-of-function mutations in DNAH17 can lead to severe sperm flagellum defects and male infertility. Patients with MMAF-harboring DNAH17 mutations generally have worse pregnancy outcomes following ICSI. ICSI combined with AOA may improve the outcome of assisted reproductive techniques (ARTs) for men with DNAH17 variants.

OUP accepted manuscript

Over the past half-century, the world has witnessed a steep decline in fertility rates in virtually every country on Earth. This universal decline in fertility is being driven by increasing prosperity largely through the mediation of social factors, the most powerful of which are the education of women and an accompanying shift in life’s purpose away from procreation. In addition, it is clear that environmental and lifestyle factors are also having a profound impact on our reproductive competence particularly in the male where increasing prosperity is associated with a significant rise in the incidence of testicular cancer and a secular decline in semen quality and testosterone levels. On a different timescale, we should also recognize that the increased prosperity associated with the demographic transition greatly reduces the selection pressure on high fertility genes by lowering the rates of infant and childhood mortality. The retention of poor fertility genes within the human population is also being exacerbated by the increased uptake of ART. It is arguable that all of these elements are colluding to drive our species into an infertility trap. If we are to avoid the latter, it will be important to recognize the factors contributing to this phenomenon and adopt the social, political, environmental and lifestyle changes needed to bring this situation under control.