Multiplex real-time PCR assays for the prediction of cephalosporin, ciprofloxacin and azithromycin antimicrobial susceptibility of positive Neisseria gonorrhoeae nucleic acid amplification test samples

Antimicrobial Resistance in Curable Sexually Transmitted Infections

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Antimicrobial resistance in sexually transmitted infections (STIs) has become an urgent global public health threat, raising the specter of untreatable infections. This review summarizes the determinants of resistance among the five most common curable STIs Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Chlamydia trachomatis, Mycoplasma genitalium, Treponema pallidum, and Trichomonas vaginalis, as well as strategies to mitigate the spread of resistance.

RECENT FINDINGS

Genetic mutations are key drivers of resistance for N. gonorrhoeae and M. genitalium. Resistance in T. vaginalis can also occur because of genetic mutations, yet differential regulation of genes critical in antibiotic metabolism as well as co-infection with organisms that inactivate therapy play important roles. While resistance in C. trachomatis and T. pallidum has not been a substantial clinical concern, resistance selection via the continued widespread use of antimicrobials remains possible. While resistance determinants are diverse and differ by pathogen, the strategies required to mitigate the continued emergence of resistance are similar: prevention of infection and treatment diversification. Underpinning those strategies, surveillance remains essential for monitoring and responding to the threat of drug-resistant infections.

Advances in genotypic antimicrobialresistance testing: a comprehensive review

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) represents a substantial threat to global public health, complicating the treatment of common infections and leading to prolonged illness and escalated healthcare expenses. To effectively combat AMR, timely and accurate detection is crucial for AMR surveillance and individual-based therapy. Phenotypic antibiotic resistance testing (AST) has long been considered the gold standard in clinical applications, serving as the foundation for clinical AMR diagnosis and optimized therapy. It has significantly contributed to ensuring patients' health and the development of novel antimicrobials. Despite advancements in automated culture-based AST technologies, inherent limitations impede the widespread use of phenotypic AST in AMR surveillance. Genotypic AST technologies offer a promising alternative option, exhibiting advantages of rapidity, high sensitivity, and specificity. With the continuous advancement and expanding applications of genotypic AST technologies, such as microfluidics, mass spectrometry, and high-resolution melting curve analysis, new vigor has been injected into the development and clinical implementation of genotypic AST technologies. In this narrative review, we discuss the principles, applications, and advancements of emerging genotypic AST methods in clinical settings. The comprehensive review aims to highlight the significant scientific potential of emerging genotypic AST technologies in clinical AMR diagnosis, providing insights to enhance existing methods and explore novel approaches.

Emerging Antimicrobial Resistance

The burden of emerging antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in the United States is significant and even greater worldwide. Mitigation efforts have decreased the incidence and deaths from antimicrobial-resistant organisms in the United States. Yet more than 2.8 million antimicrobial-resistant infections occur every year and more than 35,000 patients die as a result. Infection prevention and control, data tracking, antimicrobial stewardship, vaccines, therapeutics, diagnostics, and sanitation are all required to decrease AMR threats. In 2019, in the second version of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) report on antibiotic-resistant threats, the agency categorized AMR threats as urgent, serious, concerning, or to be watched. This review will discuss the following aspects of each bacterium in the CDC report: estimated numbers of cases and deaths, identify the better known and impactful mechanisms of resistance, diagnostic testing and its limitations, and current and possible future therapies. This review also presents anatomical pathology case examples that highlight the altered morphology of antibiotic partially treated bacteria in tissues.

Diagnosis of Neisseria Gonorrhoeae by Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Neisseria gonorrhoeae (gonococci) is the pathogen of gonorrhea. At present, there is no robust statistical analysis targeting the detection accuracy for N.gonorrhoeae of loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP). We performed a full search of five databases for studies using the LAMP method to detect N.gonorrhoeae in this study. Nine datasets derived from eight studies satisfying the inclusion requirement were collected for this study. The pooled sensitivity rate and specificity were calculated as 98.53 and 99.49%. The pooled positive likelihood ratio (PLR), negative likelihood ratio (NLR) and diagnostic odds ratio (DOR) were 66.0, 0.04 and 1863.8. After plotting the summary receiver operating characteristic (sROC), the area under the curve (AUC) and Q* index was calculated as 0.99 and 0.9774. Subgroup analyses based on the type of samples, location, and gold standard did not find sources of significant heterogeneity. In conclusion, the LAMP method could be an effective and convenient method with high accuracy for the clinical detection of N.gonorrhoeae. Moreover, the confirmation of this finding needs more high-quality studies with regional data and large samples.

Resistance-Guided Therapy for Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Antimicrobial-resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae infections are a threat to public health. Novel strategies for combating such resistance include the development of molecular assays to facilitate real-time prediction of antimicrobial susceptibility. Resistance to ciprofloxacin is determined by the presence of a single mutation at codon 91 of the gyrase A gene; molecular assays to guide therapy are commercially available. Resistance to cefixime is conferred via 1 of 6 critical mutations in either the mosaic penA gene or specific loci in the nonmosaic region. Resistance to ceftriaxone is conferred through mutations in 1 of 4 genes: penA, ponA, penB, and mtr; however, the ability to predict reduced susceptibility based on those genes varies by geographic region. Here, we highlight the work done toward the development of 3 such assays for ciprofloxacin, cefixime, and ceftriaxone, discuss the status of our current understanding and ongoing challenges, and suggest future directions.

Molecular Surveillance and Prediction of Antimicrobial Resistance of Neisseria gonorrhoeae in Northern Alberta, Canada, 2015 to 2018

BACKGROUND

The aims of this study was to describe molecular surveillance of Neisseria gonorrhoeae in the North Zone of Alberta (NZ) and to determine its value in predicting antimicrobial resistance.

METHODS

Sequence types (STs) and single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) assays were performed on nucleic acid amplification testing (NAAT) samples. Sequence types of NAATs were matched to ST of cultures from across Alberta. Antimicrobial resistance prediction of NAATs for cephalosporins, azithromycin, and ciprofloxacin using SNP was compared with matching ST culture results using agar dilution and whole-genome sequencing.

RESULTS

Of 2755 eligible specimens (2492 cases), 61.9% (1646 specimens) were sent for sequence typing, identifying 196 unique ST. Antimicrobial resistance data for 1307 additional cases were available using matching cultures. Decreased susceptibility (DS) to antimicrobials used for gonorrhea treatment was rare in the NZ; according to the SNP assay, none of the specimens had predicted DS to cephalosporins or azithromycin resistance. However, of the NZ NAAT samples tested in this study, 10.7% (131 of 1220) were predicted to have intermediate cephalosporin minimum inhibitory concentrations and 9.6% (115 of 1204) were resistant to ciprofloxacin. Based on cultures, the proportions of resistance in all of Alberta were as follows: DS to cephalosporins, 0.6% (20 of 3373); DS to intermediate cephalosporin, 16.9% (570 of 3373); azithromycin resistance, 1.2% (41 of 3373); and ciprofloxacin resistance, 32.2% (1087 of 3373).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results highlight our ability to use culture-independent methods to predict antimicrobial resistance in N. gonorrhoeae.

Reliability of Genetic Alterations in Predicting Ceftriaxone Resistance in Neisseria gonorrhoeae Globally

Antimicrobial resistance in N. gonorrhoeae is increasing globally, and ceftriaxone is the recommended treatment for empirical therapy in most settings. Developing molecular assays to detect decreased ceftriaxone susceptibility is critical. Using PathogenWatch, a public database of N. gonorrhoeae genomes, antibiotic susceptibility data and DNA sequences of different genes associated with ceftriaxone resistance were extracted. That information was used to determine the sensitivity and specificity of different molecular markers and algorithms to predict decreased susceptibility to ceftriaxone. A total of 12,943 N. gonorrhoeae genomes were extracted from the PathogenWatch database, of which 9,540 genomes were used in the analysis. The sensitivity and specificity of specific molecular markers and algorithms were largely consistent with prior reports. Small variation (<10%) in either sensitivity or specificity occurred. Certain algorithms using different molecular markers at various prevalence of decreased ceftriaxone susceptibility identified a potentially clinically useful range of positive and negative predictive values. We validated previously described mutations and algorithms in a large public database containing a global collection of N. gonorrhoeae genomes. Certain mutations and algorithms resulted in sensitivity and specificity values consistent with those of prior studies. Further research is needed to integrate these markers and algorithms into the development of molecular assays to predict decreased ceftriaxone susceptibility. IMPORTANCE Antimicrobial resistance in Neisseria gonorrhoeae (N. gonorrhoeae), the causative agent of gonorrhea, is rising globally. Ceftriaxone is the last remaining antibiotic for empirical treatment of gonorrhea. Developing molecular tests to predict ceftriaxone resistance can help to improve detection and surveillance of ceftriaxone resistance. Here, we utilized PathogenWatch, a public global online database of N. gonorrhoeae genomes, to evaluate different genetic markers in predicting decreased susceptibility to ceftriaxone. We compiled MICs for ceftriaxone from the PathogenWatch database and used a computational approach to extract all the genetic markers from the genomic data. We determined the sensitivity and specificity for predicting decreased ceftriaxone susceptibility among several combinations of genetic markers. We identified several combinations of genetic markers with high predictive values for decreased susceptibility to ceftriaxone. These combinations of genetic markers might be promising candidates for future molecular tests to predict ceftriaxone resistance.

Evaluation of the Hologic Aptima Combo 2 Assay for Detection of Neisseria gonorrhoeae from Joint Fluid Specimens

Gonorrhea is a sexually transmitted bacterial infection caused by Neisseria gonorrhoeae. Nucleic acid amplification testing is the preferred method for routine diagnosis of gonorrhea from urogenital specimens, but culture is commonly used for diagnosis of disseminated infections, including gonococcal arthritis. The Hologic Aptima Combo 2 (AC2), a transcription-mediated amplification assay, is FDA and Health Canada licensed for detection of N. gonorrhoeae and Chlamydia trachomatis from urogenital, rectal, and pharyngeal specimens, but not joint fluid. In the current study, we compared the performance of microscopy, culture, and the AC2 for detection of N. gonorrhoeae from 170 joint fluid specimens. A total of five specimens were culture-positive, whereas 14 were AC2-positive. Gram-negative diplococci, characteristic of Neisseria, were observed in only two joint fluid specimens. Complementary testing confirmed the presence of N. gonorrhoeae in seven discordant (i.e., culture-negative/AC2-positive) specimens. These results indicate that the AC2 is more sensitive than culture for the diagnosis of gonococcal arthritis.

Development and application of Cas13a-based diagnostic assay for Neisseria gonorrhoeae detection and azithromycin resistance identification

BACKGROUND

Gonorrhoea, caused by Neisseria gonorrhoeae, has spread worldwide. Strains resistant to most antibiotics, including ceftriaxone and azithromycin, have emerged to an alarming level. Rapid testing for N. gonorrhoeae and its antimicrobial resistance will therefore contribute to clinical decision making for early diagnosis and rational drug use.

METHODS

A Cas13a-based assay (specific high-sensitivity enzymatic reporter unlocking; SHERLOCK) was developed for N. gonorrhoeae detection (porA gene) and azithromycin resistance identification (A2059G, C2611T). Assays were evaluated for sensitivity with purified dsDNA and specificity with 17 non-gonococcal strains. Performance of SHERLOCK (porA) was compared with Roche Cobas 4800 using 43 urine samples. Identification of azithromycin resistance mutations (A2059G, C2611T) was evaluated using a total of 84 clinical isolates and 18 urine samples. Lateral flow was tested for this assay as a readout tool. Moreover, we directly assayed 27 urethral swabs from patients with urethritis to evaluate their status in terms of N. gonorrhoeae infection and azithromycin resistance.

RESULTS

The SHERLOCK assay was successfully developed with a sensitivity of 10 copies/reaction, except 100 copies/reaction for A2059G, and no cross-reaction with other species. Comparison of the SHERLOCK assay with the Cobas 4800 revealed 100% concordance within 18 positive and 25 negative urine samples. Of the 84 isolates, 21 strains with azithromycin resistance mutations were distinguished and further verified by sequencing and MIC determination. In addition, 62.96% (17/27) strains from swab samples were detected with no mutant strains confirmed by sequencing.

CONCLUSIONS

The SHERLOCK assay for rapid N. gonorrhoeae detection combined with azithromycin resistance testing is a promising method for application in clinical practice.

Evaluation of the Accuracy of Various Disks and Strips for Rapid Culture-Based Gonococcal Antimicrobial Susceptibility Screening Tests in China

Purpose

Neisseria gonorrhoeae, resistant to the first-line treatment option ceftriaxone, is widespread in China from 2016. Nowadays, diverse reagents of disks and strips for rapid gonococcal antimicrobial susceptibility tests used in clinics are culture-based disks diffusion and gradient strips methods. This study aimed to evaluate the accuracy, quality, and availability of almost all disks and strips acquired in the Chinese market and serve as a reference for clinical selection.

Methods

We tested the performance of 15 commercial disks and 9 commercial gradient strips acquired in China, compared with traditional agar dilution method. The overall performance was evaluated by the categorical agreement. The reagent accuracy of gradient strips was assessed by the essential agreement.

Results

A total of 167 gonococcal isolates were used to evaluate antimicrobial disks from three brands. The overall categorical agreements were 71.7% to 81.8% for ceftriaxone, less than 58% for cefixime, 100% for spectinomycin, over 98% for ciprofloxacin, below 70.5% for penicillin, and 73.3% to 81.8% for tetracycline. A total of 81 isolates were tested for different gradient strips. Categorical agreements were over 96% for ceftriaxone, 86.2% for azithromycin, 62.3% to 67.1% for penicillin, 41.9% to 67.5% for tetracycline, and 95% for ciprofloxacin. Essential agreements were 57.7% to 87.3% for ceftriaxone, 70% for azithromycin, 64.9% to 68.4% for penicillin, 51.8% to 71.2% for tetracycline, and 91.3% for ciprofloxacin.

Conclusion

Rapid test reagents of disks and strips based on gonococcal culture have suboptimal performance. Disk diffusion for spectinomycin or ciprofloxacin can be recommended for clinical individualized prescription. The gradient strips are of great value to identify ceftriaxone-resistant gonococcal strains. Furthermore, abundant improvements are required for many reagents to further optimize their accuracy till the fulfillment of molecular detection.

Antimicrobial resistance prediction in Neisseria gonorrhoeae: Current status and future prospects

INTRODUCTION

Several nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs), mostly real-time PCRs, to detect antimicrobial resistance (AMR) determinants and predict AMR in Neisseria gonorrhoeae are promising, and some may be ready to apply at the point-of-care (POC), but important limitations remain with most NAATs. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) can overcome many of these limitations.Areas covered: Recent advances, with main focus on publications since 2017, in the development and use of NAATs and NGS to predict gonococcal AMR for surveillance and clinical use, and pros and cons of these tests as well as future perspectives for appropriate use of molecular AMR prediction for N. gonorrhoeae.Expert Commentary: NAATs and/or NGS for AMR prediction should supplement culture-based AMR surveillance, which will remain because it detects also AMR due to unknown AMR determinants, and translation into POC tests is imperative for the end-goal of individualized treatment, sparing ceftriaxone±azithromycin. Several challenges for direct testing of clinical, especially pharyngeal, specimens and for accurate prediction of cephalosporins and azithromycin resistance, especially using NAATs, remain. The choice of AMR prediction assay needs to carefully consider the intended use of the assay; limitations intrinsic to the AMR prediction technology, algorithms and specific to chosen methodology; specimen types analyzed; and cost-effectiveness.

Cyr SB, Town K, Nash EE, Kirkcaldy RD, SURRG Working Group. Strengthening the US Response to Resistant Gonorrhea: An Overview of a Multisite Program to Enhance Local Response Capacity for Antibiotic-Resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae

BACKGROUND

In 2016, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention initiated Strengthening the US Response to Resistant Gonorrhea (SURRG) in multiple jurisdictions to enhance antibiotic resistant gonorrhea rapid detection and response infrastructure and evaluate the impact of key strategies.

METHODS

Eight jurisdictions were funded to establish or enhance local gonococcal culture specimen collection in sexually transmitted disease and community clinics, conduct rapid antimicrobial susceptibility testing (AST) in local laboratories, modify systems for enhanced data collection and rapid communication of results, and initiate enhanced partner services among patients with gonorrhea demonstrating elevated minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) to ceftriaxone, cefixime or azithromycin.

RESULTS

Grantees incorporated genital, pharyngeal, and rectal gonococcal culture collection from all genders at participating clinics. During 2018 to 2019, grantees collected 58,441 culture specimens from 46,822 patients and performed AST on 10,814 isolates (representing 6.8% [3412] and 8.9% [4883] of local reported cases in 2018 and 2019, respectively). Of isolates that underwent AST, 11% demonstrated elevated azithromycin MICs; fewer than 0.5% demonstrated elevated ceftriaxone or cefixime MICs. Among patients whose infections demonstrated elevated MICs, 81.7% were interviewed for partner elicitation; however, limited new cases were identified among partners and contacts.

CONCLUSIONS

As a public health model to build capacity to slow the spread of emerging resistance, SURRG successfully expanded culture collection, implemented rapid AST, and implemented an enhanced partner services investigation approach in participating jurisdictions. Findings from SURRG may enhance preparedness efforts and inform a longer-term, comprehensive, and evidence-based public health response to emerging gonococcal resistance. Continued development of innovative approaches to address emerging resistance is needed.

Enhancing U.S. Local, State, and Federal Preparedness Through Simulated Interactive Tabletop Exercises of a Mock Antibiotic-Resistant Gonorrhea Outbreak, 2018-2019

BACKGROUND

Responding effectively to outbreaks of antibiotic-resistant gonorrhea (ARGC) in the future will likely prove challenging. Tabletop exercises (TTXs) may assist local, state, and federal public health officials evaluate existing ARGC outbreak response plans, strengthen preparedness and response effectiveness, and identify critical gaps to address before an outbreak.

METHODS

In 2018 to 2019, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) collaborated with state partners to develop and implement TTXs to simulate a public health emergency involving an ARGC outbreak. Before the TTXs, 2 state-local health department pairs developed ARGC outbreak response plans. During each 1-day exercise (in Indiana and Illinois), participants discussed roles, clinical management, public health response, and communication based on predeveloped response plans. Observers identified outbreak response strengths and gaps, and participants completed feedback forms.

RESULTS

Forty-one (Illinois) and 48 people (Indiana) participated in each TTX, including sexually transmitted disease clinical staff, laboratorians, public health infectious disease program staff, and CDC observers. Strengths and gaps varied by jurisdiction, but identified gaps included: (1) local access to gonorrhea culture and timely antimicrobial susceptibility testing, (2) protocols for clinical management of suspected treatment failures, (3) communication plans, and (4) clarity regarding state and local responsibilities. The CDC observers identified opportunities to provide national-level technical assistance, foster local antimicrobial susceptibility testing, and develop further response guidance. Tabletop exercises summary reports were used to guide modifications to local response plans to address gaps.

CONCLUSIONS

The TTXs allowed participants to practice responding to a simulated public health emergency and may have enhanced local response capacity. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention made TTX implementation materials publicly available.

The Accuracy of Molecular Detection Targeting the Mutation C2611T for Detecting Moderate-Level Azithromycin Resistance in Neisseria gonorrhoeae: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Neisseria gonorrhoeae (N. gonorrhoeae) is now recognized as a commonly reported sexually transmitted pathogen, and the increasing drug resistance of N. gonorrhoeae has become a serious public health problem. The accuracy of molecular detection for detecting moderate-level azithromycin resistance is not well-established. We summarized the data from studies of the N. gonorrhoeae 23S rRNA mutation at position 2611 with azithromycin resistance to determine the relationship between the mutation and resistance.

METHODS AND FINDINGS

In this systematic review and meta-analysis, two researchers independently searched six databases for studies with data for the azithromycin minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) and the 23S rRNA mutation C2611T of each N. gonorrhoeae isolate. Since the breakpoint of moderate-level resistance to azithromycin (ML-AzmR) was not determined, we divided the moderate level into two groups according to the range of MICs (moderate resistance limited to 2-128 mg/L or 4-128 mg/L) for data extraction. A random-effects model was used to calculate the pooled sensitivity rate, the specificity rate, the pooled positive likelihood ratio (PLR), the negative likelihood ratio (NLR), and the diagnostic odds ratio (DOR). Meta-regression analyses by detection method, isolates sampling (a random sample or not), location, and sample size were performed to explore the possible causes of heterogeneity. The potential publication bias of the included studies was conducted by the Deeks' test. We included 20 studies in our study: 20 studies have data of N. gonorrhoeae with MICs between 2 and 128 mg/L with mutation or without mutation at position 2611(4759 samples), and 14 studies have data of N. gonorrhoeae with MICs between 4 and 128 mg/L (3367 samples). In the group with the moderate level of 2-128 mg/L, the pooled sensitivity rate of the molecular assays was determined to be 71.9% (95% CI, 67.6-74%), the pooled specificity rate was 98.7% (95% CI, 98.2-99.0%), and the DOR ranged from 55.0 to 351.3 (mean, 139.1). In the 4-128 mg/L group, the pooled sensitivity rate was 91.9% (95% CI, 88.9-94.2%), the pooled specificity rate was 95.9% (95% CI, 95.1-96.6%), and the DOR ranged from 41.9 to 364.1 (mean, 123.6).

CONCLUSION

Through this meta-analysis, we found that the C2611T mutation of 23S rRNA is valuable for the molecular diagnostic of moderate-level azithromycin resistance (ML-AzmR) in N. gonorrhoeae, especially when the moderate level is set at 4-128 mg/L. This rapid molecular detection method can be used for the rapid identification of ML-AzmR isolates in the clinic.

Molecular Characterization and Antimicrobial Resistance in Neisseria gonorrhoeae, Nunavut Region of Inuit Nunangat, Canada, 2018-2019

We assessed antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in Neisseria gonorrhoeae in Nunavut, Canada, using remnant gonorrhea nucleic acid amplification test-positive urine specimens. This study confirms the feasibility of conducting N. gonorrhoeae AMR surveillance and highlights the diversity of gonococcal sequence types and geographic variation of AMR patterns in the territory.

Epidemiology, Treatments, and Vaccine Development for Antimicrobial-Resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae: Current Strategies and Future Directions

Neisseria gonorrhoeae is the second most common bacterial sexually transmitted infection in the world after Chlamydia trachomatis. The pathogen has developed resistance to every antibiotic currently approved for treatment, and multidrug-resistant strains have been identified globally. The current treatment recommended by the World Health Organization is ceftriaxone and azithromycin dual therapy. However, resistance to azithromycin and ceftriaxone are increasing and treatment failures have been reported. As a result, there is a critical need to develop novel strategies for mitigating the spread of antimicrobial-resistant N. gonorrhoeae through improved diagnosis and treatment of resistant infections. Strategies that are currently being pursued include developing molecular assays to predict resistance, utilizing higher doses of ceftriaxone, repurposing older antibiotics, and developing newer agents. In addition, efforts to discover a vaccine for N. gonorrhoeae have been reignited in recent years with the cross-protectivity provided by the N. meningitidis vaccine, with several new strategies and targets. Despite the significant progress that has been made, there is still much work ahead to combat antimicrobial-resistant N. gonorrhoeae globally.

Bioinformatics tools used for whole-genome sequencing analysis of Neisseria gonorrhoeae: a literature review

Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data are well established for the investigation of gonococcal transmission, antimicrobial resistance prediction, population structure determination and population dynamics. A variety of bioinformatics tools, repositories, services and platforms have been applied to manage and analyze Neisseria gonorrhoeae WGS datasets. This review provides an overview of the various bioinformatics approaches and resources used in 105 published studies (as of 30 April 2021). The challenges in the analysis of N. gonorrhoeae WGS datasets, as well as future bioinformatics requirements, are also discussed.