The ligation of pol β mismatch insertion products governs the formation of promutagenic base excision DNA repair intermediates

Nick sealing of polβ mismatch insertion products by LIG1 and LIG3α during 8-oxoG bypass leads to mutagenic or error-free base excision repair

Base excision repair (BER) requires a coordination at the downstream steps involving gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by DNA ligase (LIG) 1 or 3α. We previously reported that a failure in DNA ligase function, stemming from an impairment in nick sealing of polβ nucleotide insertion products, leads to faulty repair events. Yet, how the fidelity of 8-oxoG bypass by polβ affects the efficiency of ligation remains unclear. Here, we show that LIG1 and LIG3α seal the resulting nick repair product of polβ mutagenic insertion of dATP opposite 8-oxoG, while LIG3α exhibits an inability to ligate polβ dCTP:8-oxoG insertion product, demonstrating that the identity of BER ligase plays a critical role in repair outcomes at the final step. Furthermore, our results show that a lack of ribonucleotide insertion by polβ during 8-oxoG bypass diminishes the repair coordination with both ligases, highlighting the critical role of nucleotide selectivity in maintaining BER accuracy. Finally, our results reveal that AP-Endonuclease 1 (APE1) proofreads nick repair intermediates containing 3'-mismatches or ribonucleotides templating 8-oxoG. Overall, our findings provide a mechanistic insight into how the dual coding potential of the oxidative lesion in -anti versus -syn conformation could govern error-prone versus error-free repair outcomes, leading to deviations in the BER pathway coordination and the formation of deleterious DNA intermediates.

Repair pathway coordination from gap filling by polβ and subsequent nick sealing by LIG1 or LIG3α governs BER efficiency at the downstream steps

Base excision repair (BER) is the critical mechanism for preventing mutagenic and lethal consequences of single base lesions generated by endogenous factors or exposure to environmental hazards. BER pathway involves multi-step enzymatic reactions that require a tight coordination between repair proteins to transfer DNA intermediates in an orderly manner. Though often considered an accurate process, the BER can contribute to genome instability if normal coordination between gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) or DNA ligase 3α (LIG3α) breaks down at the downstream steps. Our studies demonstrated that an inaccurate DNA ligation by LIG1/LIG3α, stemming from an uncoordinated repair with polβ, leads to a range of deviations from canonical BER pathway, faulty repair events, and formation of deleterious DNA intermediates. Furthermore, X-ray repair cross-complementing protein 1 (XRCC1), as a scaffolding factor, enhances the processivity of downstream steps, and the DNA-end processing enzymes, Aprataxin (APTX), Flap-Endonuclease 1 (FEN1), and AP-Endonuclease 1 (APE1), play critical roles for cleaning of ligase failure products and proofreading of polβ errors in coordination with BER ligases. Overall, our studies contribute to understanding of how a multi-protein repair complex interplay at the final steps to maintain the repair efficiency.

The effect of methylation and hydroxymethylation of cytosine on activity and fidelity of Pol λ and Pol β

Сytosine methylation in CpG dinucleotides is the most common epigenetic mark in human cells. Under active demethylation process 5-methylcytosine (mC) can be converted to 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (hmC). Cytosine methylation increases the risk of adjacent nucleotide damage, including the oxidation of guanine. DNA polymerases might encounter mC and hmC during DNA repair or translesion synthesis. Here, we analyze the activity of X-family polymerases Pol β and Pol λ opposite mC and hmC as well as opposite 8-oxoG adjacent to mC in the TCG context. We demonstrate that hmC has no pronounced effect on Pol β and Pol λ activity while cytosine methylation moderately suppresses the efficiency of dGMP incorporation by Pol β but not Pol λ. Pol λ was not affected by + 2 cytosine methylation when synthesizing across 8-oxoG. In contrast, cytosine methylation slightly increased incorporation of dCMP opposite 8-oxoG adjacent to mC but reduced the extension of the 8-oxoG:C pair by Pol β.

Probing the mechanism of nick searching by LIG1 at the single-molecule level

DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) joins Okazaki fragments during the nuclear replication and completes DNA repair pathways by joining 3'-OH and 5'-PO4 ends of nick at the final step. Yet, the mechanism of how LIG1 searches for a nick at single-molecule level is unknown. Here, we combine single-molecule fluorescence microscopy approaches, C-Trap and total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF), to investigate the dynamics of LIG1-nick DNA binding. Our C-Trap data reveal that DNA binding by LIG1 full-length is enriched near the nick sites and the protein exhibits diffusive behavior to form a long-lived ligase/nick complex after binding to a non-nick region. However, LIG1 C-terminal mutant, containing the catalytic core and DNA-binding domain, predominantly binds throughout DNA non-specifically to the regions lacking nick site for shorter time. These results are further supported by TIRF data for LIG1 binding to DNA with a single nick site and demonstrate that a fraction of LIG1 full-length binds significantly longer period compared to the C-terminal mutant. Overall comparison of DNA binding modes provides a mechanistic model where the N-terminal domain promotes 1D diffusion and the enrichment of LIG1 binding at nick sites with longer binding lifetime, thereby facilitating an efficient nick search process.

Impact of DNA ligase inhibition on the nick sealing of polβ nucleotide insertion products at the downstream steps of base excision repair pathway

DNA ligase (LIG) I and IIIα finalize base excision repair (BER) by sealing a nick product after nucleotide insertion by DNA polymerase (pol) β at the downstream steps. We previously demonstrated that a functional interplay between polβ and BER ligases is critical for efficient repair, and polβ mismatch or oxidized nucleotide insertions confound the final ligation step. Yet, how targeting downstream enzymes with small molecule inhibitors could affect this coordination remains unknown. Here, we report that DNA ligase inhibitors, L67 and L82-G17, slightly enhance hypersensitivity to oxidative stress-inducing agent, KBrO3, in polβ+/+ cells more than polβ-/- null cells. We showed less efficient ligation after polβ nucleotide insertions in the presence of the DNA ligase inhibitors. Furthermore, the mutations at the ligase inhibitor binding sites (G448, R451, A455) of LIG1 significantly affect nick DNA binding affinity and nick sealing efficiency. Finally, our results demonstrated that the BER ligases seal a gap repair intermediate by the effect of polβ inhibitor that diminishes gap filling activity. Overall, our results contribute to understand how the BER inhibitors against downstream enzymes, polβ, LIG1, and LIGIIIα, could impact the efficiency of gap filling and subsequent nick sealing at the final steps leading to the formation of deleterious repair intermediates.

Mutagenic ligation of polβ mismatch insertion products during 8-oxoG bypass by LIG1 and LIG3α at the downstream steps of base excision repair pathway

Base excision repair (BER) maintains genome integrity by fixing oxidized bases that could be formed when reactive oxygen species attack directly on the DNA. We previously reported the importance of a proper coordination at the downstream steps involving gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by DNA ligase (LIG) 1 or 3α. Yet, how the fidelity of 8-oxoG bypass by polβ affects the efficiency of ligation remains unclear. Here, we show that LIG1 can seal nick products of polβ after both dATP and dCTP insertions during 8- oxoG bypass, while ribonucleotide insertions completely diminish the repair coordination with both ligases, highlighting a critical role for nucleotide selectivity in maintaining BER accuracy. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that LIG3α exhibits an inability to ligate nicks of polβ dCTP:8-oxoG insertion or with preinserted 3'-dC:8-oxoG. Finally, AP-Endonuclease 1 (APE1) proofreads nick repair intermediates containing 3'-dA/rA and 3'-dC/rC mismatches templating 8-oxoG. Overall, our findings provide a mechanistic insight into how the dual coding potential of the oxidative lesion and identity of BER ligase govern mutagenic versus error-free repair outcomes at the final steps and how the ribonucleotide challenge compromises the BER coordination leading to the formation of deleterious repair intermediates.

Structures of LIG1 uncover the mechanism of sugar discrimination against 5'-RNA-DNA junctions during ribonucleotide excision repair

Ribonucleotides in DNA cause several types of genome instability and can be removed by ribonucleotide excision repair (RER) that is finalized by DNA ligase 1 (LIG1). However, the mechanism by which LIG1 discriminates the RER intermediate containing a 5'-RNA-DNA lesion generated by RNase H2-mediated cleavage of ribonucleotides at atomic resolution remains unknown. Here, we determine X-ray structures of LIG1/5'-rG:C at the initial step of ligation where AMP is bound to the active site of the ligase and uncover a large conformational change downstream the nick resulting in a shift at Arg(R)871 residue in the Adenylation domain of the ligase. Furthermore, we demonstrate a diminished ligation of the nick DNA substrate with a 5'-ribonucleotide in comparison to an efficient end joining of the nick substrate with a 3'-ribonucleotide by LIG1. Finally, our results demonstrate that mutations at the active site residues of the ligase and LIG1 disease-associated variants significantly impact the ligation efficiency of RNA-DNA heteroduplexes harboring "wrong" sugar at 3'- or 5'-end of nick. Collectively, our findings provide a novel atomic insight into proficient sugar discrimination by LIG1 during the processing of the most abundant form of DNA damage in cells, genomic ribonucleotides, during the initial step of the RER pathway.

Impact of DNA ligase 1 and IIIα interactions with APE1 and polβ on the efficiency of base excision repair pathway at the downstream steps

Base excision repair (BER) requires a tight coordination between the repair enzymes through protein-protein interactions and involves gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by DNA ligase (LIG) 1 or LIGIIIα at the downstream steps. Apurinic/apyrimidinic-endonuclease 1 (APE1), by its exonuclease activity, proofreads 3' mismatches incorporated by polβ during BER. We previously reported that the interruptions in the functional interplay between polβ and the BER ligases result in faulty repair events. Yet, how the protein interactions of LIG1 and LIGIIIα could affect the repair pathway coordination during nick sealing at the final steps remains unknown. Here, we demonstrate that LIGIIIα interacts more tightly with polβ and APE1 than LIG1, and the N-terminal noncatalytic region of LIG1 as well as the catalytic core and BRCT domain of LIGIIIα mediate interactions with both proteins. Our results demonstrated less efficient nick sealing of polβ nucleotide insertion products in the absence of LIGIIIα zinc-finger domain and LIG1 N-terminal region. Furthermore, we showed a coordination between APE1 and LIG1/LIGIIIα during the removal of 3' mismatches from the nick repair intermediate on which both BER ligases can seal noncanonical ends or gap repair intermediate leading to products of single deletion mutagenesis. Overall results demonstrate the importance of functional coordination from gap filling by polβ coupled to nick sealing by LIG1/LIGIIIα in the presence of proofreading by APE1, which is mainly governed by protein-protein interactions and protein-DNA intermediate communications, to maintain repair efficiency at the downstream steps of the BER pathway.

Structural and biochemical characterization of LIG1 during mutagenic nick sealing of oxidatively damaged ends at the final step of DNA repair

DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) joins broken strand-breaks in the phosphodiester backbone to finalize DNA repair pathways. We previously reported that LIG1 fails on nick repair intermediate with 3'-oxidative damage incorporated by DNA polymerase (pol) β at the downstream steps of base excision repair (BER) pathway. Here, we determined X-ray structures of LIG1/nick DNA complexes containing 3'-8oxodG and 3'-8oxorG opposite either a templating Cytosine or Adenine and demonstrated that the ligase active site engages with mutagenic repair intermediates during steps 2 and 3 of the ligation reaction referring to the formation of DNA-AMP intermediate and a final phosphodiester bond, respectively. Furthermore, we showed the mutagenic nick sealing of DNA substrates with 3'-8oxodG:A and 3'-8oxorG:A by LIG1 wild-type, immunodeficiency disease-associated variants, and DNA ligase 3α (LIG3α) in vitro . Finally, we observed that LIG1 and LIG3α seal resulting nick after an incorporation of 8oxorGTP:A by polβ and AP-Endonuclease 1 (APE1) can clean oxidatively damaged ends at the final steps. Overall, our findings uncover a mechanistic insight into how LIG1 discriminates DNA or DNA/RNA junctions including oxidative damage and a functional coordination between the downstream enzymes, polβ, APE1, and BER ligases, to process mutagenic repair intermediates to maintain repair efficiency.

Structures of LIG1 provide a mechanistic basis for understanding a lack of sugar discrimination against a ribonucleotide at the 3'-end of nick DNA

Human DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) is the main replicative ligase that seals Okazaki fragments during nuclear replication and finalizes DNA repair pathways by joining DNA ends of the broken strand breaks in the three steps of the ligation reaction. LIG1 can tolerate the RNA strand upstream of the nick, yet an atomic insight into the sugar discrimination mechanism by LIG1 against a ribonucleotide at the 3'-terminus of nick DNA is unknown. Here, we determined X-ray structures of LIG1/3'-RNA-DNA hybrids and captured the ligase during pre- and post-step 3 the ligation reaction. Furthermore, the overlays of 3'-rA:T and 3'-rG:C step 3 structures with step 2 structures of canonical 3'-dA:T and 3'-dG:C uncover a network of LIG1/DNA interactions through Asp570 and Arg871 side chains with 2'-OH of the ribose at nick showing a final phosphodiester bond formation and the other ligase active site residues surrounding the AMP site. Finally, we demonstrated that LIG1 can ligate the nick DNA substrates with pre-inserted 3'-ribonucleotides as efficiently as Watson-Crick base-paired ends in vitro. Together, our findings uncover a novel atomic insight into a lack of sugar discrimination by LIG1 and the impact of improper sugar on the nick sealing of ribonucleotides at the last step of DNA replication and repair.

Unfilled gaps by polβ lead to aberrant ligation by LIG1 at the downstream steps of base excision repair pathway

Base excision repair (BER) involves the tightly coordinated function of DNA polymerase β (polβ) and DNA ligase I (LIG1) at the downstream steps. Our previous studies emphasize that defective substrate-product channeling, from gap filling by polβ to nick sealing by LIG1, can lead to interruptions in repair pathway coordination. Yet, the molecular determinants that dictate accurate BER remains largely unknown. Here, we demonstrate that a lack of gap filling by polβ leads to faulty repair events and the formation of deleterious DNA intermediates. We dissect how ribonucleotide challenge and cancer-associated mutations could adversely impact the ability of polβ to efficiently fill the one nucleotide gap repair intermediate which subsequently results in gap ligation by LIG1, leading to the formation of single-nucleotide deletion products. Moreover, we demonstrate that LIG1 is not capable of discriminating against nick DNA containing a 3'-ribonucleotide, regardless of base-pairing potential or damage. Finally, AP-Endonuclease 1 (APE1) shows distinct substrate specificity for the exonuclease removal of 3'-mismatched bases and ribonucleotides from nick repair intermediate. Overall, our results reveal that unfilled gaps result in impaired coordination between polβ and LIG1, defining a possible type of mutagenic event at the downstream steps where APE1 could provide a proofreading role to maintain BER efficiency.

Human DNA ligases I and IIIα as determinants of accuracy and efficiency of base excision DNA repair

Mammalian Base Excision Repair (BER) DNA ligases I and IIIα (LigI, LigIIIα) are major determinants of DNA repair fidelity, alongside with DNA polymerases. Here we compared activities of human LigI and LigIIIα on specific and nonspecific substrates representing intermediates of distinct BER sub-pathways. The enzymes differently discriminate mismatches in the nicked DNA, depending on their identity and position, but are both more selective against the 3'-end non-complementarity. LigIIIα is less active than LigI in premature ligation of one-nucleotide gapped DNA and more efficiently discriminates misinsertion products of DNA polymerase β-catalyzed gap filling, that reinforces a leading role of LigIIIα in the accuracy of short-patch BER. LigI and LigIIIα reseal the intermediate of long-patch BER containing an incised synthetic AP site (F) with different efficiencies, depending on the DNA sequence context, 3'-end mismatch presence and coupling of the ligation reaction with DNA repair synthesis. Processing of this intermediate in the absence of flap endonuclease 1 generates non-canonical DNAs with bulged F site, which are very inefficiently repaired by AP endonuclease 1 and represent potential mutagenic repair products. The extent of conversion of the 5'-adenylated intermediates of specific and nonspecific substrates is revealed to depend on the DNA sequence context; a higher sensitivity of LigI to the sequence is in line with the enzyme structural feature of DNA binding. LigIIIα exceeds LigI in generation of potential abortive ligation products, justifying importance of XRCC1-mediated coordination of LigIIIα and aprataxin activities for the efficient DNA repair.

Uncovering nick DNA binding by LIG1 at the single-molecule level

DNA ligases repair the strand breaks are made continually and naturally throughout the genome, if left unrepaired and allowed to persist, they can lead to genome instability in the forms of lethal double-strand (ds) breaks, deletions, and duplications. DNA ligase 1 (LIG1) joins Okazaki fragments during the replication machinery and seals nicks at the end of most DNA repair pathways. Yet, how LIG1 recognizes its target substrate is entirely missing. Here, we uncover the dynamics of nick DNA binding by LIG1 at the single-molecule level. Our findings reveal that LIG1 binds to dsDNA both specifically and non-specifically and exhibits diffusive behavior to form a stable complex at the nick. Furthermore, by comparing with the LIG1 C-terminal protein, we demonstrate that the N-terminal non-catalytic region promotes binding enriched at nick sites and facilitates an efficient nick search process by promoting 1D diffusion along the DNA. Our findings provide a novel single-molecule insight into the nick binding by LIG1, which is critical to repair broken phosphodiester bonds in the DNA backbone to maintain genome integrity.

Molecular editing of enabling discovery of benzodithiazinedioxide-guanidines as anticancer agents

DNA polymerase β (Polβ) is crucial for the base excision repair (BER) pathway of DNA damage repair and is an attractive target for suppressing tumorigenesis as well as chemotherapeutic intervention of cancer. In this study, a unique strategy of scaffold-hopping-based molecular editing of a bioactive agent NSC-666719 was investigated, which led to the development of new molecular motifs with Polβ inhibitory activity. NSC compound and its analogs (two series) were prepared, focusing on pharmacophore-based molecular diversity. Most compounds showed higher activities than the parent NSC-666719 and exhibited effects on apoptosis. The inhibitory activity of Polβ was evaluated in both in vitro reconstituted and in vivo intact cell systems. Compound 10e demonstrated significant Polβ interaction and inhibition characteristics, including direct, non-covalent, reversible, and comparable binding affinity. The investigated approach is useful, and the discovered novel analogs have a high potential for developing as anticancer therapeutics.

Impact of polβ/XRCC1 Interaction Variants on the Efficiency of Nick Sealing by DNA Ligase IIIα in the Base Excision Repair Pathway

Base excision repair (BER) requires a coordination from gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β to subsequent nick sealing by DNA ligase (LIG) IIIα at downstream steps of the repair pathway. X-ray cross-complementing protein 1 (XRCC1), a non-enzymatic scaffolding protein, forms repair complexes with polβ and LIGIIIα. Yet, the impact of the polβ mutations that affect XRCC1 interaction and protein stability on the repair pathway coordination during nick sealing by LIGIIIα remains unknown. Our results show that the polβ colon cancer-associated variant T304 exhibits a reduced interaction with XRCC1 and the mutations in the interaction interface of V303 loop (L301R/V303R/V306R) and at the lysine residues (K206A/K244A) that prevent ubiquitin-mediated degradation of the protein exhibit a diminished repair protein complex formation with XRCC1. Furthermore, we demonstrate no significant effect on gap and nick DNA binding affinity of wild-type polβ by these mutations. Finally, our results reveal that XRCC1 leads to an efficient channeling of nick repair products after nucleotide incorporation by polβ variants to LIGIIIα, which is compromised by the L301R/V303R/V306R and K206A/K244A mutations. Overall, our findings provide insight into how the mutations in the polβ/XRCC1 interface and the regions affecting protein stability could dictate accurate BER pathway coordination at the downstream steps involving nick sealing by LIGIIIα.

Structures of LIG1 active site mutants reveal the importance of DNA end rigidity for mismatch discrimination

ATP-dependent DNA ligases catalyze phosphodiester bond formation in the conserved three-step chemical reaction of nick sealing. Human DNA ligase I (LIG1) finalizes almost all DNA repair pathways following DNA polymerase-mediated nucleotide insertion. We previously reported that LIG1 discriminates mismatches depending on the architecture of the 3'-terminus at a nick, however the contribution of conserved active site residues to faithful ligation remains unknown. Here, we comprehensively dissect the nick DNA substrate specificity of LIG1 active site mutants carrying Ala(A) and Leu(L) substitutions at Phe(F)635 and Phe(F)F872 residues and show completely abolished ligation of nick DNA substrates with all 12 non-canonical mismatches. LIG1 ^EE/AA structures of F635A and F872A mutants in complex with nick DNA containing A:C and G:T mismatches demonstrate the importance of DNA end rigidity, as well as uncover a shift in a flexible loop near 5'-end of the nick, which causes an increased barrier to adenylate transfer from LIG1 to the 5'-end of the nick. Furthermore, LIG1 ^EE/AA /8oxoG:A structures of both mutants demonstrated that F635 and F872 play critical roles during steps 1 or 2 of the ligation reaction depending on the position of the active site residue near the DNA ends. Overall, our study contributes towards a better understanding of the substrate discrimination mechanism of LIG1 against mutagenic repair intermediates with mismatched or damaged ends and reveals the importance of conserved ligase active site residues to maintain ligation fidelity.

Structures of LIG1 that engage with mutagenic mismatches inserted by polβ in base excision repair

DNA ligase I (LIG1) catalyzes the ligation of the nick repair intermediate after gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β during downstream steps of the base excision repair (BER) pathway. However, how LIG1 discriminates against the mutagenic 3'-mismatches incorporated by polβ at atomic resolution remains undefined. Here, we determine the X-ray structures of LIG1/nick DNA complexes with G:T and A:C mismatches and uncover the ligase strategies that favor or deter the ligation of base substitution errors. Our structures reveal that the LIG1 active site can accommodate a G:T mismatch in the wobble conformation, where an adenylate (AMP) is transferred to the 5'-phosphate of a nick (DNA-AMP), while it stays in the LIG1-AMP intermediate during the initial step of the ligation reaction in the presence of an A:C mismatch at the 3'-strand. Moreover, we show mutagenic ligation and aberrant nick sealing of dG:T and dA:C mismatches, respectively. Finally, we demonstrate that AP-endonuclease 1 (APE1), as a compensatory proofreading enzyme, removes the mismatched bases and interacts with LIG1 at the final BER steps. Our overall findings provide the features of accurate versus mutagenic outcomes coordinated by a multiprotein complex including polβ, LIG1, and APE1 to maintain efficient repair.

The scaffold protein XRCC1 stabilizes the formation of polβ/gap DNA and ligase IIIα/nick DNA complexes in base excision repair

The base excision repair (BER) pathway involves gap filling by DNA polymerase (pol) β and subsequent nick sealing by ligase IIIα. X-ray cross-complementing protein 1 (XRCC1), a nonenzymatic scaffold protein, assembles multiprotein complexes, although the mechanism by which XRCC1 orchestrates the final steps of coordinated BER remains incompletely defined. Here, using a combination of biochemical and biophysical approaches, we revealed that the polβ/XRCC1 complex increases the processivity of BER reactions after correct nucleotide insertion into gaps in DNA and enhances the handoff of nicked repair products to the final ligation step. Moreover, the mutagenic ligation of nicked repair intermediate following polβ 8-oxodGTP insertion is enhanced in the presence of XRCC1. Our results demonstrated a stabilizing effect of XRCC1 on the formation of polβ/dNTP/gap DNA and ligase IIIα/ATP/nick DNA catalytic ternary complexes. Real-time monitoring of protein–protein interactions and DNA-binding kinetics showed stronger binding of XRCC1 to polβ than to ligase IIIα or aprataxin, and higher affinity for nick DNA with undamaged or damaged ends than for one nucleotide gap repair intermediate. Finally, we demonstrated slight differences in stable polβ/XRCC1 complex formation, polβ and ligase IIIα protein interaction kinetics, and handoff process as a result of cancer-associated (P161L, R194W, R280H, R399Q, Y576S) and cerebellar ataxia-related (K431N) XRCC1 variants. Overall, our findings provide novel insights into the coordinating role of XRCC1 and the effect of its disease-associated variants on substrate-product channeling in multiprotein/DNA complexes for efficient BER.

DNA ligase I fidelity mediates the mutagenic ligation of pol β oxidized and mismatch nucleotide insertion products in base excision repair

DNA ligase I (LIG1) completes the base excision repair (BER) pathway at the last nick-sealing step after DNA polymerase (pol) β gap-filling DNA synthesis. However, the mechanism by which LIG1 fidelity mediates the faithful substrate-product channeling and ligation of repair intermediates at the final steps of the BER pathway remains unclear. We previously reported that pol β 8-oxo-2'-deoxyribonucleoside 5'-triphosphate insertion confounds LIG1, leading to the formation of ligation failure products with a 5'-adenylate block. Here, using reconstituted BER assays in vitro, we report the mutagenic ligation of pol β 8-oxo-2'-deoxyribonucleoside 5'-triphosphate insertion products and an inefficient ligation of pol β Watson-Crick-like dG:T mismatch insertion by the LIG1 mutant with a perturbed fidelity (E346A/E592A). Moreover, our results reveal that the substrate discrimination of LIG1 for the nicked repair intermediates with preinserted 3'-8-oxodG or mismatches is governed by mutations at both E346 and E592 residues. Finally, we found that aprataxin and flap endonuclease 1, as compensatory DNA-end processing enzymes, can remove the 5'-adenylate block from the abortive ligation products harboring 3'-8-oxodG or the 12 possible noncanonical base pairs. These findings contribute to the understanding of the role of LIG1 as an important determinant in faithful BER and how a multiprotein complex (LIG1, pol β, aprataxin, and flap endonuclease 1) can coordinate to prevent the formation of mutagenic repair intermediates with damaged or mismatched ends at the downstream steps of the BER pathway.

DNA ligase I variants fail in the ligation of mutagenic repair intermediates with mismatches and oxidative DNA damage

DNA ligase I (LIG1) joins DNA strand breaks during DNA replication and repair transactions and contributes to genome integrity. The mutations (P529L, E566K, R641L and R771W) in LIG1 gene are described in patients with LIG1-deficiency syndrome that exhibit immunodeficiency. LIG1 senses 3'-DNA ends with a mismatch or oxidative DNA base inserted by a repair DNA polymerase. However, the ligation efficiency of the LIG1 variants for DNA polymerase-promoted mutagenesis products with 3'-DNA mismatches or 8-oxo-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxodG) remains undefined. Here, we report that R641L and R771W fail in the ligation of nicked DNA with 3'-8-oxodG, leading to an accumulation of 5'-AMP-DNA intermediates in vitro. Moreover, we found that the presence of all possible 12 non-canonical base pairs variously impacts the ligation efficiency by P529L and R771W depending on the architecture at the DNA end, whereas E566K exhibits no activity against all substrates tested. Our results contribute to the understanding of the substrate specificity and mismatch discrimination of LIG1 for mutagenic repair intermediates and the effect of non-synonymous mutations on ligase fidelity.

Alterations of DNA damage repair in cancer: from mechanisms to applications

DNA damage repair (DDR) pathways are essential to ensure the accurate transmission of genetic material. However, different endogenous and exogenous factors challenge genomic integrity. Mechanisms involved in the alterations of DDR pathways mainly include genetic inactivation and epigenetic mechanisms. The development and progression of carcinomas are closely associated with DDR pathway aberrations, including the epigenetic silencing of gene O6-alkylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT); deficiencies of mismatch repair (MMR) genes, including MutL homolog 1 (MLH1), MutS protein homologue (MSH)-2 (MSH2), MSH6, and PMS1 homolog 2; the mismatch repair system component (PMS2); and mutations of homologous recombination repair (HRR) genes, such as the breast cancer susceptibility gene 1/2 (BRCA1/2). Understanding the underlying mechanisms and the correlations between alterations to DDR pathways and cancer could improve the efficacy of antitumor therapies. Emerging evidence suggests that survival is higher in patients with DDR-deficient tumors than in those with DDR-proficient tumors. Thus, DDR alterations play a predictive and prognostic role in anticancer therapies. Theoretical studies on the co-administration of DDR inhibitors and other anticancer therapies, including chemotherapy, radiotherapy, immunotherapy, endocrine therapy, and epigenetic drugs, hold promise for cancer treatments. In this review, we focus on the basic mechanisms, characteristics, current applications, and combination strategies of DDR pathways in the anticancer field.

Pol β gap filling, DNA ligation and substrate-product channeling during base excision repair opposite oxidized 5-methylcytosine modifications

DNA methylation on cytosine in CpG islands generates 5-methylcytosine (5mC), and further modification of 5mC can result in the oxidized variants 5-hydroxymethyl (5hmC), 5-formyl (5fC), and 5-carboxy (5caC). Base excision repair (BER) is crucial for both genome maintenance and active DNA demethylation of modified cytosine products and involves substrate-product channeling from nucleotide insertion by DNA polymerase (pol) β to the subsequent ligation step. Here, we report that, in contrast to the pol β mismatch insertion products (dCTP, dATP, and dTTP), the nicked products after pol β dGTP insertion can be ligated by DNA ligase I or DNA ligase III/XRCC1 complex when a 5mC oxidation modification is present opposite in the template position in vitro. A Pol β K280A mutation, which perturbates the stabilization of these base modifications within the active site, hinders the BER ligases. Moreover, the nicked repair intermediates that mimic pol β mismatch insertion products, i.e., with 3'-preinserted dGMP or dTMP opposite templating 5hmC, 5fC or 5caC, can be efficiently ligated, whereas preinserted 3'-dAMP or dCMP mismatches result in failed ligation reactions. These findings herein contribute to our understanding of the insertion tendencies of pol β opposite different cytosine base forms, the ligation properties of DNA ligase I and DNA ligase III/XRCC1 complex in the context of gapped and nicked damage-containing repair intermediates, and the efficiency and fidelity of substrate channeling during the final steps of BER in situations involving oxidative 5mC base modifications in the template strand.

Base Excision Repair in the Immune System: Small DNA Lesions With Big Consequences

The integrity of the genome is under constant threat of environmental and endogenous agents that cause DNA damage. Endogenous damage is particularly pervasive, occurring at an estimated rate of 10,000–30,000 per cell/per day, and mostly involves chemical DNA base lesions caused by oxidation, depurination, alkylation, and deamination. The base excision repair (BER) pathway is primary responsible for removing and repairing these small base lesions that would otherwise lead to mutations or DNA breaks during replication. Next to preventing DNA mutations and damage, the BER pathway is also involved in mutagenic processes in B cells during immunoglobulin (Ig) class switch recombination (CSR) and somatic hypermutation (SHM), which are instigated by uracil (U) lesions derived from activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) activity. BER is required for the processing of AID-induced lesions into DNA double strand breaks (DSB) that are required for CSR, and is of pivotal importance for determining the mutagenic outcome of uracil lesions during SHM. Although uracils are generally efficiently repaired by error-free BER, this process is surprisingly error-prone at the Ig loci in proliferating B cells. Breakdown of this high-fidelity process outside of the Ig loci has been linked to mutations observed in B-cell tumors and DNA breaks and chromosomal translocations in activated B cells. Next to its role in preventing cancer, BER has also been implicated in immune tolerance. Several defects in BER components have been associated with autoimmune diseases, and animal models have shown that BER defects can cause autoimmunity in a B-cell intrinsic and extrinsic fashion. In this review we discuss the contribution of BER to genomic integrity in the context of immune receptor diversification, cancer and autoimmune diseases.