DELTEX E3 ligases ubiquitylate ADP-ribosyl modification on nucleic acids

The RBR E3 ubiquitin ligase HOIL-1 can ubiquitinate diverse non-protein substrates in vitro

HOIL-1 is a RING-between-RING-family E3 ubiquitin ligase and a component of the linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex. Although most E3 ubiquitin ligases conjugate ubiquitin to protein lysine sidechains, HOIL-1 has also been reported to ubiquitinate hydroxyl groups in protein serine and threonine sidechains and glucosaccharides, such as glycogen and its building block maltose, in vitro. However, HOIL-1 substrate specificity is currently poorly defined. Here, we show that HOIL-1 is unable to ubiquitinate lysine but can efficiently ubiquitinate serine and a variety of model and physiologically relevant di- and monosaccharides in vitro. We identify a critical catalytic histidine residue, His510, in the flexible catalytic site of HOIL-1 that enables this O-linked ubiquitination and prohibits ubiquitin discharge onto lysine sidechains. We use HOIL-1's in vitro non-proteinaceous ubiquitination activity to produce preparative amounts of different ubiquitinated saccharides that can be used as tool compounds and standards in the rapidly emerging field of non-proteinaceous ubiquitination. Finally, we report an engineered, constitutively active HOIL-1 variant that simplifies in vitro generation of ubiquitinated saccharides.

Shigella flexneri evades LPS ubiquitylation through IpaH1.4-mediated degradation of RNF213

Pathogens have evolved diverse strategies to counteract host immunity. Ubiquitylation of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) on cytosol-invading bacteria by the E3 ligase RNF213 creates 'eat me' signals for antibacterial autophagy, but whether and how cytosol-adapted bacteria avoid LPS ubiquitylation remains poorly understood. Here, we show that the enterobacterium Shigella flexneri actively antagonizes LPS ubiquitylation through IpaH1.4, a secreted effector protein with ubiquitin E3 ligase activity. IpaH1.4 binds to RNF213, ubiquitylates it and targets it for proteasomal degradation, thus counteracting host-protective LPS ubiquitylation. To understand how IpaH1.4 recognizes RNF213, we determined the cryogenic electron microscopy structure of the IpaH1.4-RNF213 complex. The specificity of the interaction is achieved through the leucine-rich repeat of IpaH1.4, which binds the RING domain of RNF213 by hijacking the conserved RING interface required for binding to ubiquitin-charged E2 enzymes. IpaH1.4 also targets other E3 ligases involved in inflammation and immunity through binding to the E2-interacting face of their RING domains, including the E3 ligase LUBAC that is required for the synthesis of M1-linked ubiquitin chains on cytosol-invading bacteria downstream of RNF213. We conclude that IpaH1.4 has evolved to antagonize multiple antibacterial and proinflammatory host E3 ligases.

Insights into non-proteinaceous ubiquitination

Ubiquitination plays a key role in the regulation of numerous diverse cellular functions. This process involves the covalent attachment of ubiquitin to protein substrates by a cascade of enzymes. In recent years, various non-proteinaceous substrates of ubiquitination have been discovered, expanding the potential for the functions of ubiquitination beyond its conventional role as a post-translational modification. Here, we profile the non-proteinaceous substrates of ubiquitination reported to date, the enzymes that regulate these activities, and the mechanistic details of substrate modification. The biological functions linked to these modifications are discussed, and finally, we highlight the challenges hindering further progress in the identification and functional characterization of non-proteinaceous substrates of ubiquitination within cellular contexts.

Ubiquitin is directly linked via an ester to protein-conjugated mono-ADP-ribose

The prevailing view on post-translational modifications (PTMs) is that a single amino acid is modified with a single PTM at any given time. However, recent work has demonstrated crosstalk between different PTMs, some occurring on the same residue. Such interplay is seen with ADP-ribosylation and ubiquitylation. For example, DELTEX E3 ligases were reported to ubiquitylate a hydroxyl group on free NAD+ and ADP-ribose in vitro, generating a noncanonical ubiquitin ester-linked species. In this report, we show, for the first time, that this dual PTM occurs in cells on mono-ADP-ribosylated (MARylated) PARP10 on Glu/Asp sites to form a MAR ubiquitin ester. We call this process mono-ADP-ribosyl ubiquitylation or MARUbylation. Using chemical and enzymatic treatments, including a newly characterized bacterial deubiquitinase with esterase-specific activity, we discovered that multiple PARPs are MARUbylated and extended with K11-linked polyubiquitin chains when exogenously expressed. Finally, we show that in response to type I interferon stimulation, MARUbylation can occur endogenously on PARP targets. Thus, MARUbylation represents a new dual PTM that broadens our understanding of the function of PARP-mediated ADP-ribosylation in cells.

RING dimerisation drives higher-order organisation of SINA/SIAH E3 ubiquitin ligases

RING-type E3 ubiquitin ligases promote ubiquitylation by stabilising an active complex between a ubiquitin-loaded E2-conjugating enzyme and a protein substrate. To fulfil this function, the E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase SIAH1 and other SINA/SIAH subfamily RING-type E3 ligases employ an N-terminal catalytic RING domain and a C-terminal substrate-binding domain (SBD), separated by two zinc fingers. Here, we present the first crystal structure of the RING domain of human SIAH1, together with an adjacent zinc finger, revealing a potential RING dimer, which was validated in solution using static light scattering. RING dimerisation contributes to the E3 ligase activity of SIAH1 both in vitro and in cells. Moreover, as the RING domain is the second element, after the SBD, to independently favour homodimerisation within SINA/SIAH E3 ligases, we propose that alternating RING:RING and SBD:SBD interactions organise multiple copies of a SINA/SIAH protein into a higher-order homomultimer. In line with this hypothesis, fluorescently tagged full-length human SIAH1, human SIAH2 and fruit fly SINA show cytoplasmic clusters in human cells, whereas their distribution becomes more diffuse when RING dimerisation is disabled. The wild-type (WT) form of SIAH1, but not its RING dimerisation mutant, colocalises with aggregated synphilin-1A under proteasomal inhibition, suggesting that SIAH1 multimerisation might contribute to its reported preference for aggregated or multimeric substrates.

Ubiquitin-A structural perspective

The modification of proteins and other biomolecules with the small protein ubiquitin has enthralled scientists from many disciplines for decades, creating a broad research field. Ubiquitin research is particularly rich in molecular and mechanistic understanding due to a plethora of (poly)ubiquitin structures alone and in complex with ubiquitin machineries. Furthermore, due to its favorable properties, ubiquitin serves as a model system for many biophysical and computational techniques. Here, we review the current knowledge of ubiquitin signals through a ubiquitin-centric, structural biology lens. We amalgamate the information from 240 structures in the Protein Data Bank (PDB), combined with single-molecule, molecular dynamics, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies, to provide a comprehensive picture of ubiquitin and polyubiquitin structures and dynamics. We close with a discussion of the latest frontiers in ubiquitin research, namely the modification of ubiquitin by other post-translational modifications (PTMs) and the notion that ubiquitin is attached to biomolecules beyond proteins.

Understanding ubiquitination in neurodevelopment by integrating insights across space and time

Ubiquitination regulates a myriad of eukaryotic signaling cascades by modifying substrate proteins, thereby determining their functions and fates. In this perspective, we discuss current challenges in investigating the ubiquitin system in the developing brain. We foster the concept that ubiquitination pathways are spatiotemporally regulated and tightly intertwined with molecular and cellular transitions during neurogenesis and neural circuit assembly. Focusing on the neurologically highly relevant class of homologous to E6AP C-terminus (HECT) ubiquitin ligases, we propose cross-disciplinary translational approaches bridging state-of-the-art cell biology, proteomics, biochemistry, structural biology and neuroscience to dissect ubiquitination in neurodevelopment and its specific perturbations in brain diseases. We highlight that a comprehensive understanding of ubiquitin signaling in the brain may reveal new horizons in basic neuroscience and clinical applications.

Insights into mechanisms of ubiquitin ADP-ribosylation reversal

Ubiquitination and ADP-ribosylation are two types of post-translational modification (PTM) involved in regulating various cellular activities. In a striking example of direct interplay between ubiquitination and ADP-ribosylation, the bacterial pathogen Legionella pneumophila uses its SidE family of secreted effectors to catalyze an NAD+-dependent phosphoribosyl ubiquitination of host substrates in a process involving the intermediary formation of ADP-ribosylated ubiquitin (ADPR-Ub). This noncanonical ubiquitination pathway is finely regulated by multiple Legionella effectors to ensure a balanced host subjugation. Among the various regulatory effectors, the macrodomain effector MavL has been recently shown to reverse the Ub ADP-ribosylation and regenerate intact Ub. Here, we briefly outline emerging knowledge on ubiquitination and ADP-ribosylation and tap into cases of direct cross-talk between these two PTMs. The chemistry of ADP-ribose in the context of the PTM and the reversal mechanisms of ADP-ribosylation are then highlighted. Lastly, focusing on recent structural studies on the MavL-mediated reversal of Ub ADP-ribosylation, we strive to deduce distinct mechanisms regarding the catalysis and product release of this reaction.

DTX3L ubiquitin ligase ubiquitinates single-stranded nucleic acids

Ubiquitination typically involves covalent linking of ubiquitin (Ub) to a lysine residue on a protein substrate. Recently, new facets of this process have emerged, including Ub modification of non-proteinaceous substrates like ADP-ribose by the DELTEX E3 ligase family. Here, we show that the DELTEX family member DTX3L expands this non-proteinaceous substrate repertoire to include single-stranded DNA and RNA. Although the N-terminal region of DTX3L contains single-stranded nucleic acid binding domains and motifs, the minimal catalytically competent fragment comprises the C-terminal RING and DTC domains (RD). DTX3L-RD catalyses ubiquitination of the 3'-end of single-stranded DNA and RNA, as well as double-stranded DNA with a 3' overhang of two or more nucleotides. This modification is reversibly cleaved by deubiquitinases. NMR and biochemical analyses reveal that the DTC domain binds single-stranded DNA and facilitates the catalysis of Ub transfer from RING-bound E2-conjugated Ub. Our study unveils the direct ubiquitination of nucleic acids by DTX3L, laying the groundwork for understanding its functional implications.

Ubiquitylation of nucleic acids by DELTEX ubiquitin E3 ligase DTX3L

The recent discovery of non-proteinaceous ubiquitylation substrates broadened our understanding of this modification beyond conventional protein targets. However, the existence of additional types of substrates remains elusive. Here, we present evidence that nucleic acids can also be directly ubiquitylated via ester bond formation. DTX3L, a member of the DELTEX family E3 ubiquitin ligases, ubiquitylates DNA and RNA in vitro and that this activity is shared with DTX3, but not with the other DELTEX family members DTX1, DTX2 and DTX4. DTX3L shows preference for the 3'-terminal adenosine over other nucleotides. In addition, we demonstrate that ubiquitylation of nucleic acids is reversible by DUBs such as USP2, JOSD1 and SARS-CoV-2 PLpro. Overall, our study proposes reversible ubiquitylation of nucleic acids in vitro and discusses its potential functional implications.

Deltex family E3 ligases specifically ubiquitinate the terminal ADP-ribose of poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation

Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerases (PARPs) are critical to regulating cellular activities, such as the response to DNA damage and cell death. PARPs catalyze a reversible post-translational modification (PTM) in the form of mono- or poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation. This type of modification is known to form a ubiquitin-ADP-ribose (Ub-ADPR) conjugate that depends on the actions of Deltex family of E3 ubiquitin ligases (DTXs). In particular, DTXs add ubiquitin to the 3'-OH of adenosine ribose' in ADP-ribose, which effectively sequesters ubiquitin and impedes ubiquitin-dependent signaling. Previous work demonstrates DTX function for ubiquitination of protein-free ADPR, mono-ADP-ribosylated peptides, and ADP-ribosylated nucleic acids. However, the dynamics of DTX-mediated ubiquitination of poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation remains to be defined. Here we show that the ADPR ubiquitination function is not found in other PAR-binding E3 ligases and is conserved across DTX family members. Importantly, DTXs specifically target poly(ADP-ribose) chains for ubiquitination that can be cleaved by PARG, the primary eraser of poly(ADP-ribose), leaving the adenosine-terminal ADPR unit conjugated to ubiquitin. Our collective results demonstrate the DTXs' specific ubiquitination of the adenosine terminus of poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation and suggest the unique Ub-ADPR conjugation process as a basis for PARP-DTX control of cellular activities.

Capturing Legionella pneumophila effector enzymes using a ubiquitin derived photo-activatable probe

Upon infection of host cells the Legionella pneumophila bacterium releases a multitude of effector enzymes into the host's cytoplasm that manipulate cellular host pathways, including the host-ubiquitination pathways. The effectors belonging to the SidE-family are involved in non-canonical phosphoribosyl serine ubiquitination (PR-ubiquitination) of host substrate proteins. This results in the recruitment of ER-remodeling proteins and the formation of a Legionella-containing vacuole which is crucial in the onset of legionnaires disease. PR-ubiquitination is a dynamic process reversed by other Legionella effectors called Dups. During PR-Ubiquitin phosphodiester hydrolysis Dups form a covalent intermediate with the phosphoribosyl ubiquitylated protein using its active site His67 residue. We envisioned that covalent probes to target Legionella effectors could be of value to study these effectors and contribute to deciphering the complex biology of Legionella infection. Hence we effectively installed a photo-activatable pyridinium warhead on the 5'-OH of triazole-linked ribosylated ubiquitin allowing crosslinking of the probe to the catalytic histidine residues in Legionella SidE or Dup enzymes. In vitro tests on recombinantly expressed DupA and SdeAPDE revealed that the probe was able to capture the enzymes covalently upon photo-activation.

PARP14 and PARP9/DTX3L regulate interferon-induced ADP-ribosylation

PARP-catalysed ADP-ribosylation (ADPr) is important in regulating various cellular pathways. Until recently, PARP-dependent mono-ADP-ribosylation has been poorly understood due to the lack of sensitive detection methods. Here, we utilised an improved antibody to detect mono-ADP-ribosylation. We visualised endogenous interferon (IFN)-induced ADP-ribosylation and show that PARP14 is a major enzyme responsible for this modification. Fittingly, this signalling is reversed by the macrodomain from SARS-CoV-2 (Mac1), providing a possible mechanism by which Mac1 counteracts the activity of antiviral PARPs. Our data also elucidate a major role of PARP9 and its binding partner, the E3 ubiquitin ligase DTX3L, in regulating PARP14 activity through protein-protein interactions and by the hydrolytic activity of PARP9 macrodomain 1. Finally, we also present the first visualisation of ADPr-dependent ubiquitylation in the IFN response. These approaches should further advance our understanding of IFN-induced ADPr and ubiquitin signalling processes and could shed light on how different pathogens avoid such defence pathways.

Discovery of ester-linked ubiquitylation of PARP10 mono-ADP-ribosylation in cells: a dual post-translational modification on Glu/Asp side chains

The prevailing view on post-translational modifications (PTMs) is that amino acid side chains in proteins are modified with a single PTM at any given time. However, a growing body of work has demonstrated crosstalk between different PTMs, some occurring on the same residue. Such interplay is seen with ADP-ribosylation and ubiquitylation, where specialized E3 ligases ubiquitylate targets for proteasomal degradation in an ADP-ribosylation-dependent manner. More recently, the DELTEX family of E3 ligases was reported to catalyze ubiquitylation of the 3'- hydroxy group of the adenine-proximal ribose of free NAD + and ADP-ribose in vitro , generating a non-canonical ubiquitin ester-linked species. In this report, we show, for the first time, that this dual PTM occurs in cells on mono-ADP-ribosylated (MARylated) PARP10 on Glu/Asp sites to form a MAR ubiquitin ester (MARUbe). We term this process m ono- A DP-ribosyl ub iquit ylation or MARUbylation. Using chemical and enzymatic treatments, including a newly characterized bacterial deubiquitinase with esterase-specific activity, we discovered that PARP10 MARUbylation is extended with K11-linked polyubiquitin chains. Finally, mechanistic studies using proteasomal and ubiquitin-activating enzyme inhibitors demonstrated that PARP10 MARUbylation leads to its proteasomal degradation, providing a functional role for this new PTM in regulating protein turnover.

Mono-ADP-ribosylation, a MARylationmultifaced modification of protein, DNA and RNA: characterizations, functions and mechanisms

The functional alterations of proteins and nucleic acids mainly rely on their modifications. ADP-ribosylation is a NAD+-dependent modification of proteins and, in some cases, of nucleic acids. This modification is broadly categorized as Mono(ADP-ribosyl)ation (MARylation) or poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation (PARylation). MARylation catalyzed by mono(ADP-ribosyl) transferases (MARTs) is more common in cells and the number of MARTs is much larger than poly(ADP-ribosyl) transferases. Unlike PARylation is well-characterized, research on MARylation is at the starting stage. However, growing evidence demonstrate the cellular functions of MARylation, supporting its potential roles in human health and diseases. In this review, we outlined MARylation-associated proteins including MARTs, the ADP-ribosyl hydrolyses and ADP-ribose binding domains. We summarized up-to-date findings about MARylation onto newly identified substrates including protein, DNA and RNA, and focused on the functions of these reactions in pathophysiological conditions as well as speculated the potential mechanisms. Furthermore, new strategies of MARylation detection and the current state of MARTs inhibitors were discussed. We also provided an outlook for future study, aiming to revealing the unknown biological properties of MARylation and its relevant mechanisms, and establish a novel therapeutic perspective in human diseases.