Why are Hoogsteen base pairs energetically disfavored in A-RNA compared to B-DNA?

An A-T Hoogsteen base pair in a naked DNA hairpin motif: A Protein-Recognized Conformation

In duplex DNA, A-T and G-C form Watson-Crick base pairs, and Hoogsteen pairing only dominates upon protein binding or DNA damage. Using NMR, we show that an A-T Hoogsteen base pair previously observed in crystal structures of transposon DNA hairpins bound to TnpA protein forms in solution even in the absence of TnpA. This Hoogsteen base pair, located adjacent to a dinucleotide apical loop, exists in dynamic equilibrium with a minor Watson-Crick conformation (population ∼11% and lifetime ∼55 µs). Extending the apical loop to three residues inverted the equilibrium, making Watson-Crick the dominant state and the Hoogsteen conformation recognized by TnpA a minor state (population ∼14% and lifetime ∼28 µs). The propensity for Hoogsteen pairing depended on apical loop residues, which form contacts directly or indirectly stabilizing the Hoogsteen conformation. A structure survey did not reveal Hoogsteen pairing near RNA apical loops making them unique to DNA. Our results demonstrate that Hoogsteen can be the dominant state even in naked unmodified duplex DNA and identify 5'-CTT(T/C)AG-3' as a DNA-specific apical loop motif stabilized by Hoogsteen pairing. Hoogsteen base pairs may be prevalent in DNA hairpins forming during replication and transcription, with broad implications for the genomic landscape.

High-Order Quantum-Mechanical Analysis of Hydrogen Bonding in Hachimoji and Natural DNA Base Pairs

High-order quantum chemistry is applied to hydrogen-bonded natural DNA nucleobase pairs [adenine:thymine (A:T) and guanine:cytosine (G:C)] and non-natural Hachimoji nucleobase pairs [isoguanine:1-methylcytosine (B:S) and 2-aminoimidazo[1,2a][1,3,5]triazin-4(1H)-one:6-amino-5-nitropyridin-2-one (P:Z)] to see how the intermolecular interaction energies and their energetic components (electrostatics, exchange-repulsion, induction/polarization, and London dispersion interactions) vary among the base pairs. We examined the Hoogsteen (HG) geometries in addition to the traditional Watson-Crick (WC) geometries. Coupled-cluster theory through perturbative triples [CCSD(T)] extrapolated to the complete basis set (CBS) limit and high-order symmetry-adapted perturbation theory (SAPT) at the SAPT2+(3)(CCD)δMP2/aug-cc-pVTZ level are used to estimate highly accurate noncovalent interaction energies. Electrostatic interactions are the most attractive component of the interaction energies, but the sum of induction/polarization and London dispersion is nearly as large, for all base pairs and geometries considered. Interestingly, the non-natural Hachimoji base pairs interact more strongly than the corresponding natural base pairs, by -21.8 (B:S) and -0.3 (P:Z) kcal mol^-1 in the WC geometries, according to CCSD(T)/CBS. This is consistent with the H-bond distances being generally shorter in the non-natural base pairs. The natural base pairs are energetically more stabilized in their Hoogsteen geometries than in their WC geometries. The Hoogsteen geometry makes the A:T base pair slightly more stable, by -0.8 kcal mol^-1, and it greatly stabilizes the G:C⁺ base pair, by -15.3 kcal mol^-1. The G:C⁺ stabilization is mainly due to the fact that C has typically added a proton when found in Hoogsteen geometries. By contrast, Hoogsteen geometries are substantially less favorable than WC geometries for non-natural Hachimoji base pairs, by 17.3 (B:S) and 13.8 (P:Z) kcal mol^-1.

Nucleobases in Meteorites to Nucleobases in RNA and DNA?

Nucleic acids likely played a foundational role in the origin of life. However, the prebiotic chemistry of nucleoside and nucleotide synthesis has proved challenging on a number of fronts. The recent discovery of both pyrimidine and purine nucleobases in carbonaceous chondrite meteorites has garnered much attention from both the popular press and the scientific community. Here, we discuss these findings in the context of nucleoside/nucleotide prebiotic chemistry. We consider that the main challenge of prebiotic nucleoside synthesis, that of nucleosidic bond formation, is not addressed by the identification nucleobases in meteorites. We further discuss issues of selection that arise from the observation that such meteorites contain both canonical and non-canonical nucleobases. In sum, we argue that, despite the major analytical achievement of identifying and characterizing nucleobases in meteorites, this observation does little to advance our understanding of the prebiotic chemistry that could have led to the first genetic molecules that gave rise to us.

1-Deazaguanosine-Modified RNA: The Missing Piece for Functional RNA Atomic Mutagenesis

Atomic mutagenesis is the key to advance our understanding of RNA recognition and RNA catalysis. To this end, deazanucleosides are utilized to evaluate the participation of specific atoms in these processes. One of the remaining challenges is access to RNA-containing 1-deazaguanosine (c1G). Here, we present the synthesis of this nucleoside and its phosphoramidite, allowing first time access to c1G-modified RNA. Thermodynamic analyses revealed the base pairing parameters for c1G-modified RNA. Furthermore, by NMR spectroscopy, a c1G-triggered switch of Watson-Crick into Hoogsteen pairing in HIV-2 TAR RNA was identified. Additionally, using X-ray structure analysis, a guanine-phosphate backbone interaction affecting RNA fold stability was characterized, and finally, the critical impact of an active-site guanine in twister ribozyme on the phosphodiester cleavage was revealed. Taken together, our study lays the synthetic basis for c1G-modified RNA and demonstrates the power of the completed deazanucleoside toolbox for RNA atomic mutagenesis needed to achieve in-depth understanding of RNA recognition and catalysis.

Structural Insights Into Tautomeric Dynamics in Nucleic Acids and in Antiviral Nucleoside Analogs

DNA (2'-deoxyribonucleic acid) and RNA (ribonucleic acid) play diverse functional roles in biology and disease. Despite being comprised primarily of only four cognate nucleobases, nucleic acids can adopt complex three-dimensional structures, and RNA in particular, can catalyze biochemical reactions to regulate a wide variety of biological processes. Such chemical versatility is due in part to the phenomenon of nucleobase tautomerism, whereby the bases can adopt multiple, yet distinct isomeric forms, known as tautomers. For nucleobases, tautomers refer to structural isomers that differ from one another by the position of protons. By altering the position of protons on nucleobases, many of which play critical roles for hydrogen bonding and base pairing interactions, tautomerism has profound effects on the biochemical processes involving nucleic acids. For example, the transient formation of minor tautomers during replication could generate spontaneous mutations. These mutations could arise from the stabilization of mismatches, in the active site of polymerases, in conformations involving minor tautomers that are indistinguishable from canonical base pairs. In this review, we discuss the evidence for tautomerism in DNA, and its consequences to the fidelity of DNA replication. Also reviewed are RNA systems, such as the riboswitches and self-cleaving ribozymes, in which tautomerism plays a functional role in ligand recognition and catalysis, respectively. We also discuss tautomeric nucleoside analogs that are efficacious as antiviral drug candidates such as molnupiravir for coronaviruses and KP1212 for HIV. The antiviral efficacy of these analogs is due, in part, to their ability to exist in multiple tautomeric forms and induce mutations in the replicating viral genomes. From a technical standpoint, minor tautomers of nucleobases are challenging to identify directly because they are rare and interconvert on a fast, millisecond to nanosecond, time scale. Nevertheless, many approaches including biochemical, structural, computational and spectroscopic methods have been developed to study tautomeric dynamics in RNA and DNA systems, and in antiviral nucleoside analogs. An overview of these methods and their applications is included here.

Revealing A-T and G-C Hoogsteen base pairs in stressed protein-bound duplex DNA

Watson–Crick base pairs (bps) are the fundamental unit of genetic information and the building blocks of the DNA double helix. However, A-T and G-C can also form alternative ‘Hoogsteen’ bps, expanding the functional complexity of DNA. We developed ‘Hoog-finder’, which uses structural fingerprints to rapidly screen Hoogsteen bps, which may have been mismodeled as Watson–Crick in crystal structures of protein–DNA complexes. We uncovered 17 Hoogsteen bps, 7 of which were in complex with 6 proteins never before shown to bind Hoogsteen bps. The Hoogsteen bps occur near mismatches, nicks and lesions and some appear to participate in recognition and damage repair. Our results suggest a potentially broad role for Hoogsteen bps in stressed regions of the genome and call for a community-wide effort to identify these bps in current and future crystal structures of DNA and its complexes.

Rapid assessment of Watson-Crick to Hoogsteen exchange in unlabeled DNA duplexes using high-power SELOPE imino 1H CEST

In duplex DNA, Watson-Crick A-T and G-C base pairs (bp's) exist in dynamic equilibrium with an alternative Hoogsteen conformation, which is low in abundance and short-lived. Measuring how the Hoogsteen dynamics varies across different DNA sequences, structural contexts and physiological conditions is key for identifying potential Hoogsteen hot spots and for understanding the potential roles of Hoogsteen base pairs in DNA recognition and repair. However, such studies are hampered by the need to prepare 13 C or 15 N isotopically enriched DNA samples for NMR relaxation dispersion (RD) experiments. Here, using SELective Optimized Proton Experiments (SELOPE) 1 H CEST experiments employing high-power radiofrequency fields (B 1  >  250 Hz) targeting imino protons, we demonstrate accurate and robust characterization of Watson-Crick to Hoogsteen exchange, without the need for isotopic enrichment of the DNA. For 13 residues in three DNA duplexes under different temperature and pH conditions, the exchange parameters deduced from high-power imino 1 H CEST were in very good agreement with counterparts measured using off-resonance 13 C /  15 N spin relaxation in the rotating frame (R 1 ρ ). It is shown that 1 H-1 H NOE effects which typically introduce artifacts in 1 H-based measurements of chemical exchange can be effectively suppressed by selective excitation, provided that the relaxation delay is short (≤  100 ms). The 1 H CEST experiment can be performed with ∼  10× higher throughput and ∼  100× lower cost relative to 13 C /  15 N R 1 ρ and enabled Hoogsteen chemical exchange measurements undetectable by R 1 ρ . The results reveal an increased propensity to form Hoogsteen bp's near terminal ends and a diminished propensity within A-tract motifs. The 1 H CEST experiment provides a basis for rapidly screening Hoogsteen breathing in duplex DNA, enabling identification of unusual motifs for more in-depth characterization.

A quantitative model predicts how m6A reshapes the kinetic landscape of nucleic acid hybridization and conformational transitions

N6-methyladenosine (m6A) is a post-transcriptional modification that controls gene expression by recruiting proteins to RNA sites. The modification also slows biochemical processes through mechanisms that are not understood. Using temperature-dependent (20°C-65°C) NMR relaxation dispersion, we show that m6A pairs with uridine with the methylamino group in the anti conformation to form a Watson-Crick base pair that transiently exchanges on the millisecond timescale with a singly hydrogen-bonded low-populated (1%) mismatch-like conformation in which the methylamino group is syn. This ability to rapidly interchange between Watson-Crick or mismatch-like forms, combined with different syn:anti isomer preferences when paired (~1:100) versus unpaired (~10:1), explains how m6A robustly slows duplex annealing without affecting melting at elevated temperatures via two pathways in which isomerization occurs before or after duplex annealing. Our model quantitatively predicts how m6A reshapes the kinetic landscape of nucleic acid hybridization and conformational transitions, and provides an explanation for why the modification robustly slows diverse cellular processes.

Unnatural bases for recognition of noncoding nucleic acid interfaces

The notion of using synthetic heterocycles instead of the native bases to interface with DNA and RNA has been explored for nearly 60 years. Unnatural bases compatible with the DNA/RNA coding interface have the potential to expand the genetic code and co-opt the machinery of biology to access new macromolecular function; accordingly, this body of research is core to synthetic biology. While much of the literature on artificial bases focuses on code expansion, there is a significant and growing effort on docking synthetic heterocycles to noncoding nucleic acid interfaces; this approach seeks to illuminate major processes of nucleic acids, including regulation of transcription, translation, transport, and transcript lifetimes. These major avenues of research at the coding and noncoding interfaces have in common fundamental principles in molecular recognition. Herein, we provide an overview of foundational literature in biophysics of base recognition and unnatural bases in coding to provide context for the developing area of targeting noncoding nucleic acid interfaces with synthetic bases, with a focus on systems developed through iterative design and biophysical study.

Rapid and accurate determination of atomistic RNA dynamic ensemble models using NMR and structure prediction

Biomolecules form dynamic ensembles of many inter-converting conformations which are key for understanding how they fold and function. However, determining ensembles is challenging because the information required to specify atomic structures for thousands of conformations far exceeds that of experimental measurements. We addressed this data gap and dramatically simplified and accelerated RNA ensemble determination by using structure prediction tools that leverage the growing database of RNA structures to generate a conformation library. Refinement of this library with NMR residual dipolar couplings provided an atomistic ensemble model for HIV-1 TAR, and the model accuracy was independently supported by comparisons to quantum-mechanical calculations of NMR chemical shifts, comparison to a crystal structure of a substate, and through designed ensemble redistribution via atomic mutagenesis. Applications to TAR bulge variants and more complex tertiary RNAs support the generality of this approach and the potential to make the determination of atomic-resolution RNA ensembles routine.

Determining dynamic ensembles of biomolecules is still challenging. Here the authors present an approach for rapid RNA ensemble determination that combines RNA structure prediction tools and NMR residual dipolar coupling data and use it to determine atomistic ensemble models for a variety of RNAs.

DNA mismatches reveal conformational penalties in protein-DNA recognition

Transcription factors recognize specific genomic sequences to regulate complex gene-expression programs. Although it is well-established that transcription factors bind to specific DNA sequences using a combination of base readout and shape recognition, some fundamental aspects of protein-DNA binding remain poorly understood1,2. Many DNA-binding proteins induce changes in the structure of the DNA outside the intrinsic B-DNA envelope. However, how the energetic cost that is associated with distorting the DNA contributes to recognition has proven difficult to study, because the distorted DNA exists in low abundance in the unbound ensemble3-9. Here we use a high-throughput assay that we term SaMBA (saturation mismatch-binding assay) to investigate the role of DNA conformational penalties in transcription factor-DNA recognition. In SaMBA, mismatched base pairs are introduced to pre-induce structural distortions in the DNA that are much larger than those induced by changes in the Watson-Crick sequence. Notably, approximately 10% of mismatches increased transcription factor binding, and for each of the 22 transcription factors that were examined, at least one mismatch was found that increased the binding affinity. Mismatches also converted non-specific sites into high-affinity sites, and high-affinity sites into 'super sites' that exhibit stronger affinity than any known canonical binding site. Determination of high-resolution X-ray structures, combined with nuclear magnetic resonance measurements and structural analyses, showed that many of the DNA mismatches that increase binding induce distortions that are similar to those induced by protein binding-thus prepaying some of the energetic cost incurred from deforming the DNA. Our work indicates that conformational penalties are a major determinant of protein-DNA recognition, and reveals mechanisms by which mismatches can recruit transcription factors and thus modulate replication and repair activities in the cell10,11.

Free Energy Landscape and Conformational Kinetics of Hoogsteen Base Pairing in DNA vs. RNA

Genetic information is encoded in the DNA double helix, which, in its physiological milieu, is characterized by the iconical Watson-Crick nucleo-base pairing. Recent NMR relaxation experiments revealed the transient presence of an alternative, Hoogsteen (HG) base pairing pattern in naked DNA duplexes, and estimated its relative stability and lifetime. In contrast with DNA, such structures were not observed in RNA duplexes. Understanding HG base pairing is important because the underlying "breathing" motion between the two conformations can significantly modulate protein binding. However, a detailed mechanistic insight into the transition pathways and kinetics is still missing. We performed enhanced sampling simulation (with combined metadynamics and adaptive force-bias method) and Markov state modeling to obtain accurate free energy, kinetics, and the intermediates in the transition pathway between Watson-Crick and HG base pairs for both naked B-DNA and A-RNA duplexes. The Markov state model constructed from our unbiased MD simulation data revealed previously unknown complex extrahelical intermediates in the seemingly simple process of base flipping in B-DNA. Extending our calculation to A-RNA, for which HG base pairing is not observed experimentally, resulted in relatively unstable, single-hydrogen-bonded, distorted Hoogsteen-like bases. Unlike B-DNA, the transition pathway primarily involved base paired and intrahelical intermediates with transition timescales much longer than that of B-DNA. The seemingly obvious flip-over reaction coordinate (i.e., the glycosidic torsion angle) is unable to resolve the intermediates. Instead, a multidimensional picture involving backbone dihedral angles and distance between hydrogen bond donor and acceptor atoms is required to gain insight into the molecular mechanism.

Hoogsteen base pairs increase the susceptibility of double-stranded DNA to cytotoxic damage

As the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases are protected in dsDNA, it is commonly assumed that deleterious alkylation damage to the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases predominantly occurs when DNA becomes single-stranded during replication and transcription. However, damage to the Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases has been reported in dsDNA in vitro through mechanisms that are not understood. In addition, the extent of protection from methylation damage conferred by dsDNA relative to ssDNA has not been quantified. Watson-Crick base pairs in dsDNA exist in dynamic equilibrium with Hoogsteen base pairs that expose the Watson-Crick faces of purine nucleobases to solvent. Whether this can influence the damage susceptibility of dsDNA remains unknown. Using dot-blot and primer extension assays, we measured the susceptibility of adenine-N1 to methylation by dimethyl sulfate (DMS) when in an A-T Watson-Crick versus Hoogsteen conformation. Relative to unpaired adenines in a bulge, Watson-Crick A-T base pairs in dsDNA only conferred ∼130-fold protection against adenine-N1 methylation, and this protection was reduced to ∼40-fold for A(syn)-T Hoogsteen base pairs embedded in a DNA-drug complex. Our results indicate that Watson-Crick faces of nucleobases are accessible to alkylating agents in canonical dsDNA and that Hoogsteen base pairs increase this accessibility. Given the higher abundance of dsDNA relative to ssDNA, these results suggest that dsDNA could be a substantial source of cytotoxic damage. The work establishes DMS probing as a method for characterizing A(syn)-T Hoogsteen base pairs in vitro and also lays the foundation for a sequencing approach to map A(syn)-T Hoogsteen and unpaired adenines genome-wide in vivo.

Probing conformational transitions towards mutagenic Watson-Crick-like G·T mismatches using off-resonance sugar carbon R1ρ relaxation dispersion

NMR off-resonance R_1ρ relaxation dispersion measurements on base carbon and nitrogen nuclei have revealed that wobble G·T/U mismatches in DNA and RNA duplexes exist in dynamic equilibrium with short-lived, low-abundance, and mutagenic Watson-Crick-like conformations. As Watson-Crick-like G·T mismatches have base pairing geometries similar to Watson-Crick base pairs, we hypothesized that they would mimic Watson-Crick base pairs with respect to the sugar-backbone conformation as well. Using off-resonance R_1ρ measurements targeting the sugar C3' and C4' nuclei, a structure survey, and molecular dynamics simulations, we show that wobble G·T mismatches adopt sugar-backbone conformations that deviate from the canonical Watson-Crick conformation and that transitions toward tautomeric and anionic Watson-Crick-like G·T mismatches restore the canonical Watson-Crick sugar-backbone. These measurements also reveal kinetic isotope effects for tautomerization in D₂O versus H₂O, which provide experimental evidence in support of a transition state involving proton transfer. The results provide additional evidence in support of mutagenic Watson-Crick-like G·T mismatches, help rule out alternative inverted wobble conformations in the case of anionic G·T^-, and also establish sugar carbons as new non-exchangeable probes of this exchange process.

In silico survey of the central conserved regions in viroids of the Pospiviroidae family for conserved asymmetric loop structures

Viroids are the smallest replicative pathogens, consisting of RNA circles (∼300 nucleotides) that require host machinery to replicate. Structural RNA elements recruit these host factors. Currently, many of these structural elements and the nature of their interactions are unknown. All Pospiviroidae have homology in the central conserved region (CCR). The CCR of potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) contains a sarcin/ricin domain (SRD), the only viroid structural element with an unequivocal replication role. We assumed that every member of this family uses this region to recruit host factors, and that each CCR has an SRD-like asymmetric loop within it. Potential SRD or SRD-like motifs were sought in the CCR of each Pospiviroidae member as follows. Motif location in each CCR was predicted with MUSCLE alignment and Vienna RNAfold. Viroid-specific models of SRD-like motifs were built by superimposing noncanonical base pairs and nucleotides on a model of an SRD. The RNA geometry search engine FR3D was then used to find nucleotide groups close to the geometry suggested by this superimposition. Atomic resolution structures were assembled using the molecular visualization program Chimera, and the stability of each motif was assessed with molecular dynamics (MD). Some models required a protonated cytosine. To be stable within a cell, the pK_a of that cytosine must be shifted up. Constant pH-replica exchange MD analysis showed such a shift in the proposed structures. These data show that every Pospiviroidae member could form a motif that resembles an SRD in its CCR, and imply there could be undiscovered mimics of other RNA domains.

Characterizing micro-to-millisecond chemical exchange in nucleic acids using off-resonance R1ρ relaxation dispersion

This review describes off-resonance R1ρ relaxation dispersion NMR methods for characterizing microsecond-to-millisecond chemical exchange in uniformly 13C/15N labeled nucleic acids in solution. The review opens with a historical account of key developments that formed the basis for modern R1ρ techniques used to study chemical exchange in biomolecules. A vector model is then used to describe the R1ρ relaxation dispersion experiment, and how the exchange contribution to relaxation varies with the amplitude and frequency offset of an applied spin-locking field, as well as the population, exchange rate, and differences in chemical shifts of two exchanging species. Mathematical treatment of chemical exchange based on the Bloch-McConnell equations is then presented and used to examine relaxation dispersion profiles for more complex exchange scenarios including three-state exchange. Pulse sequences that employ selective Hartmann-Hahn cross-polarization transfers to excite individual 13C or 15N spins are then described for measuring off-resonance R1ρ(13C) and R1ρ(15N) in uniformly 13C/15N labeled DNA and RNA samples prepared using commercially available 13C/15N labeled nucleotide triphosphates. Approaches for analyzing R1ρ data measured at a single static magnetic field to extract a full set of exchange parameters are then presented that rely on numerical integration of the Bloch-McConnell equations or the use of algebraic expressions. Methods for determining structures of nucleic acid excited states are then reviewed that rely on mutations and chemical modifications to bias conformational equilibria, as well as structure-based approaches to calculate chemical shifts. Applications of the methodology to the study of DNA and RNA conformational dynamics are reviewed and the biological significance of the exchange processes is briefly discussed.