Comparative Efficacy of Surgical Strategies for Drug-Resistant Epilepsy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated the therapeutic effects of open and minimally invasive surgeries in patients with drug-resistant epilepsy.

METHODS

This study systematically searched electronic databases, including PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, and the Cochrane Library, for randomized controlled trials, subsequent open-label expansion studies, prospective studies and retrospective studies on surgical procedures for patients with drug-resistant epilepsy. The main outcome was seizure-free status. A one-arm meta-analysis integrating data from all studies was performed to evaluate the treatment outcomes at multiple time points.

RESULTS

A total of 62 studies were included, representing 5958 individuals who received five treatment regimens. The analysis results indicate that anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) and selective amygdalohippocampectomy is still the best choice for treating drug-resistant mesial temporal lobe epilepsy in adult epilepsy patients. During the overall follow-up period, the seizure free rates for ATL, selective amygdalohippocampectomy, laser interstitial thermal therapy, radiofrequency thermocoagulation, and gamma knife surgery were 62%, 70%, 58%, 47%, and 57%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Among the five surgical methods included in this study, ATL and selective amygdala hippocampal resection seem to have more advantages in postoperative epilepsy control compared to laser interstitial hyperthermia, radiofrequency thermocoagulation, and gamma knife surgery. Each surgical treatment method has its unique focus, and when choosing a specific method, it is necessary to consider the patient's specific situation, the type and location of epileptic seizures, and possible side effects. Treating physician will develop personalized treatment plans based on these factors to maximize treatment effectiveness and reduce risks.

Laser Interstitial Thermal Therapy versus Open Surgery for Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Epilepsy surgery offers a vital treatment option for drug-resistant mesial temporal lobe epilepsy, with temporal lobe resection (TLR) and magnetic resonance-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (MRgLITT) being fundamental interventions. This meta-analysis specifically examines seizure outcomes at extended follow-up periods exceeding 24 months, visual field deficits as measured by perimetry, and complication rates both overall and categorized based on duration as minor (transient <6 months) or major (persistent >6 months) to inform clinical decision-making. For seizure freedom, TLR was superior, with 72.5% [65.6%, 78.5%] of patients achieving postoperative seizure freedom compared to 57.1% [51.2%, 62.7%] for MRgLITT (P value <0.01). Visual field deficits were observed in 79.4% [59.5%, 91.0%] of TLR patients and 49.8% [23.6%, 76.0%] of MRgLITT patients, a difference not reaching statistical significance (P value: 0.08). Overall complication rates were 11.4% [7.4%, 17.2%] for TLR and 6.5% [3.3%, 12.3%] for MRgLITT (P value 0.15). Major complications occurred in 2.0% [1.1%, 3.09%] of TLR cases and 2.7% [1.4%, 5.2%] of MRgLITT cases (P value 0.54), while minor complications were significantly more frequent with TLR at 9.9% [6.4%, 15.0%] versus MRgLITT's 4.1% [1.9%, 8.4%] (P value 0.04). MRgLITT had a more favorable outcome regarding confrontation naming, while more studies are needed regarding verbal memory to be able to draw firm conclusions. TLR provides superior seizure freedom but comes with an increased risk of transient complications. Although there was no statistical significance in visual field deficits, the trend suggests a higher frequency with TLR. The study's extensive data analysis, including rigorous sensitivity checks, ensures the robustness of these conclusions, reflecting a comprehensive analysis of the available data at this time point.

An examination of seizure-free outcome and visual field deficits: Anterior temporal lobectomy versus selective amygdalohippocampectomy for temporal lobe epilepsy-a systematic review and meta-analysis for comprehensive understanding

BACKGROUND

This study compares Selective Amygdalohippocampectomy (SAHE) and Anterior Temporal Lobectomy (ATL) for temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), focusing on seizure control and visual field deficits (VFD). While previous research suggests potential benefits of SAHE, this meta-analysis aims to clarify the comparative effectiveness of bothprocedures.

METHODS

This study adhered to PRISMA guidelines, comparing seizure outcomes and VFDs between SAHE and ATL for temporal lobe epilepsy. Comprehensive data extraction and meta-analysis revealed comparable efficacy, with SAHE potentially offering advantages in VFD risk reduction. Quality assessment ensured methodological rigor.

RESULTS

29 studies comparing SAHE and ATL for TLE. Seizure freedom analysis encompassed 23 studies (n = 3238), showing no significant difference between SAHE and ATL (RR = 0.96, 95% CI = 0.89-1.03, P = 0.26). SAHE exhibited significantly lower visual field deficits (RR = 0.87, 95% CI = 0.78-0.97, P = 0.01). Subgroup analyses highlighted differences between transsylvian SAHE and ATL but not transcortical SAHE. No significant difference was found in seizure freedom between SAHE and ATL in patients with hippocampal sclerosis.

CONCLUSIONS

ATL is more effective than transsylvian SAHE in achieving seizure freedom. However, no significant difference in seizure freedom was observed between transcortical SAHE and ATL. There were no notable differences in seizure outcomes between the two techniques in patients with hippocampal sclerosis. In contrast, SAHE carries a lower risk of postoperative visual field deficits compared to ATL.

Which parameters influence cognitive, psychiatric and long-term seizure outcome in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy after selective amygdalohippocampectomy?

BACKGROUND

We aimed to analyze potentially prognostic factors which could have influence on postoperative seizure, neuropsychological and psychiatric outcome in a cohort of patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) due to hippocampal sclerosis (HS) after selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAHE) via transsylvian approach.

METHODS

Clinical variables of 171 patients with drug-resistant MTLE with HS (88 females) who underwent SAHE between 1994 and 2019 were evaluated using univariable and multivariable logistic regression models, to investigate which of the explanatory parameters can best predict the outcome.

RESULTS

At the last available follow-up visit 12.3 ± 6.3 years after surgery 114 patients (67.9%) were seizure-free. Left hemispheric MTLE was associated with worse postoperative seizure outcome at first year after surgery (OR = 0.54, p = 0.01), female sex-with seizure recurrence at years 2 (OR = 0.52, p = 0.01) and 5 (OR = 0.53, p = 0.025) and higher number of preoperative antiseizure medication trials-with seizure recurrence at year 2 (OR = 0.77, p = 0.0064), whereas patients without history of traumatic brain injury had better postoperative seizure outcome at first year (OR = 2.08, p = 0.0091). All predictors lost their predictive value in long-term course. HS types had no prognostic influence on outcome. Patients operated on right side performed better in verbal memory compared to left (VLMT 1-5 p < 0.001, VLMT 7 p = 0.001). Depression occurred less frequently in seizure-free patients compared to non-seizure-free patients (BDI-II Z = - 2.341, p = 0.019).

CONCLUSIONS

SAHE gives an improved chance of achieving good postoperative seizure, psychiatric and neuropsychological outcome in patients with in MTLE due to HS. Predictors of short-term outcome don't predict long-term outcome.

The impact of referring patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy to an epilepsy center for presurgical diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy surgery is an established treatment for drug-resistant focal epilepsy (DRFE) that results in seizure freedom in about 60% of patients. Correctly identifying an epileptogenic lesion in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is challenging but highly relevant since it improves the likelihood of being referred for presurgical diagnosis. The epileptogenic lesion's etiology directly relates to the surgical intervention's indication and outcome. Therefore, it is vital to correctly identify epileptogenic lesions and their etiology presurgically.

METHODS

We compared the final histopathological diagnoses of all patients with DRFE undergoing epilepsy surgery at our center between 2015 and 2021 with their MRI diagnoses before and after presurgical diagnosis at our epilepsy center, including MRI evaluations by expert epilepsy neuroradiologists. Additionally, we analyzed the outcome of different subgroups.

RESULTS

This study included 132 patients. The discordance between histopathology and MRI diagnoses significantly decreased from 61.3% for non-expert MRI evaluations (NEMRIs) to 22.1% for epilepsy center MRI evaluations (ECMRIs; p < 0.0001). The MRI-sensitivity improved significantly from 68.6% for NEMRIs to 97.7% for ECMRIs (p < 0.0001). Identifying focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) and amygdala dysplasia was the most challenging for both subgroups. 65.5% of patients with negative NEMRI were seizure-free 12 months postoperatively, no patient with negative ECMRI achieved seizure-freedom. The mean duration of epilepsy until surgical intervention was 13.6 years in patients with an initial negative NEMRI and 9.5 years in patients with a recognized lesion in NEMRI.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides evidence that for patients with DRFE-especially those with initial negative findings in a non-expert MRI-an early consultation at an epilepsy center, including an ECMRI, is important for identifying candidates for epilepsy surgery. NEMRI-negative findings preoperatively do not preclude seizure freedom postoperatively. Therefore, patients with DRFE that remain MRI-negative after initial NEMRI should be referred to an epilepsy center for presurgical evaluation. Nonreferral based on NEMRI negativity may harm such patients and delay surgical intervention. However, ECMRI-negative patients have a reduced chance of becoming seizure-free after epilepsy surgery. Further improvements in MRI technique and evaluation are needed and should be directed towards improving sensitivity for FCDs and amygdala dysplasias.

Trends in referral patterns to presurgical evaluation at a European reference center

PURPOSE

To determine if growing evidence for epilepsy surgery as an early treatment option is reflected in the decrease of latencies between epilepsy onset and referral for presurgical evaluation METHODS: Retrospective analysis of latencies in 1646 patients (children and adults) from the time of epilepsy diagnosis to first presurgical workup in the period from 1999 to 2019 based on electronic patient charts at a tertiary epilepsy center. Time spans 1999-2009 and 2010-2019, prior to and following the ILAE definition of pharmacoresistance, and the role of etiological factors were assessed.

RESULTS

Over the whole period, the mean latency between diagnosis and a presurgical workup was 15.3 y. There was a significant reduction in the latencies between the periods 1999-2009 (16.9 y) and 2010-2019 (13.4 y), (p < 0.0001). In a linear regression analysis, the latency decreased by 2.6 months/year from 17.4 in 1999 to 13.1 y in 2019 (p < 0.001). Subgroup analyses showed significant decreases in latency to presurgical evaluation in patients with hippocampal sclerosis from 24.4 to 19.5 y, in malformations of cortical development from 16.4 to 13.2 y, and in nonlesional patients from 18.1 to 12.8 y, in contrast to patients with MR evidence for brain tumors with similar latencies across time (10.5 vs. 9.5 y, n.s.).

CONCLUSION

The reduction of the time span to a first presurgical evaluation was highly significant over time, yet moderate in its degree. Overall, the aim of early diagnostic evaluation for epilepsy surgery options after established pharmacoresistance was only achieved for a minority of patients.

Extent of piriform cortex resection in children with temporal lobe epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

A greater extent of resection of the temporal portion of the piriform cortex (PC) has been shown to be associated with higher likelihood of seizure freedom in adults undergoing anterior temporal lobe resection (ATLR) for drug-resistant temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). There have been no such studies in children, therefore this study aimed to investigate this association in a pediatric cohort.

METHODS

A retrospective, neuroimaging cohort study of children with TLE who underwent ATLR between 2012 and 2021 was undertaken. The PC, hippocampal and amygdala volumes were measured on the preoperative and postoperative T1-weighted MRI. Using these volumes, the extent of resection per region was compared between the seizure-free and not seizure-free groups.

RESULTS

In 50 children (median age 9.5 years) there was no significant difference between the extent of resection of the temporal PC in the seizure-free (median = 50%, n = 33/50) versus not seizure-free (median = 40%, n = 17/50) groups (p = 0.26). In a sub-group of 19 with ipsilateral hippocampal atrophy (quantitatively defined by ipsilateral-to-contralateral asymmetry), the median extent of temporal PC resection was greater in children who were seizure-free (53%) versus those not seizure-free (19%) (p = 0.009).

INTERPRETATION

This is the first study demonstrating that, in children with TLE and hippocampal atrophy, more extensive temporal PC resection is associated with a greater chance of seizure freedom-compatible with an adult series in which 85% of patients had hippocampal sclerosis. In a combined group of children with and without hippocampal atrophy, the extent of PC resection was not associated with seizure outcome, suggesting different epileptogenic networks within this cohort.

Burr hole microsurgical subtemporal selective amygdalohippocampectomy

INTRODUCTION

At present, selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAH) has become popular in the treatment of drug-resistant mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). However, there is still an ongoing discussion about the advantages and disadvantages of this approach.

METHODS

The study included a consecutive series of 43 adult patients with drug-resistant TLE, involving 24 women and 19 men (1.8/1). Surgeries were performed at the Burdenko Neurosurgery Center from 2016 to 2019. To perform subtemporal SAH through the burr hole with the diameter of 14 mm, we used two types of approaches: preauricular, 25 cases, and supra-auricular, 18 cases. The follow-up ranged from 36 to 78 months (median 59 months). One patient died 16 months after surgery (accident).

RESULTS

By the third year after surgery, Engel I outcome was achieved in 80.9% (34 cases) of cases and Engel II in 4 (9.5%) and Engel III and Engel IV in 4 (9.6%) cases. Among the patients with Engel I outcomes, anticonvulsant therapy was completed in 15 (44.1%), and doses were reduced in 17 (50%) cases. Verbal and delayed verbal memory decreased after surgery in 38.5% and 46.1%, respectively. Verbal memory was mainly affected by preauricular approach in comparison with supra-auricular (p = 0.041). In 15 (51.7%) cases, minimal visual field defects were detected in the upper quadrant. At the same time, visual field defects did not extend into the lower quadrant and inside the 20° of the upper affected quadrant in any case.

CONCLUSIONS

Burr hole microsurgical subtemporal SAH is an effective surgical procedure for drug-resistant TLE. It involves minimal risks of loss of visual field within the 20° of the upper quadrant. Supra-auricular approach, compared to preauricular, results in a reduction in the incidence of upper quadrant hemianopia and is associated with a lower risk of verbal memory impairment.

Implantation of Intracranial Electrodes Predicts Worse Outcome in Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

Anteromesial resection is an effective method for treating seizures arising from the medial temporal lobe, as these cases are often the most straightforward and have the best outcomes. Nevertheless, some patients who go on to have a mesial resection are recommended to have an implantation of electrodes before surgery. Whether the need for such an implant alters the rate of seizure freedom is not well-studied in this particular subgroup of epilepsy patients.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review of consecutive anteromesial surgeries for medial temporal lobe epilepsy performed between 2005 and 2020. Of a total of 39 patients, 19 required electrode implantation (electrode group) and 20 did not (no-electrode group). The primary outcomes assessed were reduction in seizure frequency and Engel score. Complication rates were also compared.

RESULTS

Postresection seizure frequency reduction was nonsignificantly higher in the no-electrode group (97.0 ± 10.3%) than in the electrode group (88.5 ± 23.7%, P = 0.15). The rate of Engel I outcome was nonsignificantly higher in the no-electrode group (84.2%) than in the electrode group (65.0%, P = 0.17). Major complication rates were nonsignificantly higher in the no-electrode group (15.8 ± 1.9%) than in the electrode group (5.0 ± 1.1%, P = 0.26). Power analysis revealed that 74 patients would need to be included in each group to reach statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

Although not statistically significant, our study showed a trend for improved seizure control if a decision was made not to implant electrodes prior to potentially curative anteromesial resection. Engel I outcome in this group reached approximately 85%. A larger multi-instiutional study may be required to reach statistical significance.

One-year neuropsychological outcome after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery in large Czech sample: Search for factors contributing to memory decline

Background:

Assessment of cognitive functions is an integral part of the evaluation the efficacy of temporal resections. We studied postoperative neuropsychological changes and factors contributing to worse memory outcomes in patients who experienced a significant decline using reliable change indices.

Methods:

We prospectively studied 110 patients in whom we indicated anteromesial temporal resection (AMTR) and 46 patients who underwent selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAHE). We administrated Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised, Wechsler Memory Scale-Revised, and the Verbal Fluency Test before and 1 year after the operation.

Results:

At a group level, we did not observe any statistically significant changes in global, verbal, and visual MQ in either the AMTR or the SAHE group. At an individual level, we found a mean decrease of verbal MQ after left-sided AMTR by −4.43 points (P = 0.01). We detected no significant differences between the left and right side of surgery in the SAHE group. In patients with significant postoperative memory decline, we found either pre-existing extrahippocampal deficits/postoperative complications or incomplete hippocampal resection or a combination of these factors.

Conclusion:

In addition to the side of surgery, structural integrity and functional adequacy of resected hippocampus and volume of resected tissue and preoperative extrahippocampal lesions/postoperative complications also contribute to postoperative memory decline after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery.

Prediction of the clinical and naming status after anterior temporal lobe resection in patients with epilepsy

By assessing the cognitive capital, neuropsychological evaluation (NPE) plays a vital role in the perioperative workup of patients with refractory focal epilepsy. In this retrospective study, we used cutting-edge statistical approaches to examine a group of 47 patients with refractory temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), who underwent standard anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL). Our objective was to determine whether NPE may represent a robust predictor of the postoperative status, two years after surgery. Specifically, based on pre- and postsurgical neuropsychological data, we estimated the sensitivity of cognitive indicators to predict and to disentangle phenotypes associated with more or less favorable outcomes. Engel (ENG) scores were used to assess clinical outcome, and picture naming (NAM) performance to estimate naming status. Two methods were applied: (a) machine learning (ML) to explore cognitive sensitivity to postoperative outcomes; and (b) graph theory (GT) to assess network properties reflecting favorable vs. less favorable phenotypes after surgery. Specific neuropsychological indices assessing language, memory, and executive functions can globally predict outcomes. Interestingly, preoperative cognitive networks associated with poor postsurgical outcome already exhibit an atypical, highly modular and less densely interconnected configuration. We provide statistical and clinical tools to anticipate the condition after surgery and achieve a more personalized clinical management. Our results also shed light on possible mechanisms put in place for cognitive adaptation after acute injury of central nervous system in relation with surgery.

White Fiber Correlates of Amygdalohippocampectomy Through the Middle Temporal Gyrus Approach

OBJECTIVE

The white fiber and gross anatomy relevant for performing amygdalohippocampectomy through the middle temporal gyrus approach for mesial temporal sclerosis has been depicted by white fiber dissection.

METHODS

Three previously frozen and formalin fixed cerebral hemispheres were studied. The Klingler method of fiber dissection was used to study the anatomy. The primary tools used were hand-made wooden spatulas, forceps, and microscissors. The anatomy of the amygdala and hippocampus and the landmarks for performing the disconnection during epilepsy surgery are presented. The white fibers at risk during the middle temporal gyrus approach were studied.

RESULTS

The white fiber tracts at risk during the middle temporal gyrus approach for epilepsy surgery are the fibers of the inferior frontooccipital fasciculus, temporal extension of the anterior commissure, Meyer loop of the optic radiation, and uncinate fasciculus. On the basis of our anatomic dissections, we present a novel entry point into the temporal horn, potentially minimizing injury to the fibers of the sagittal stratum. We also propose novel landmarks to perform the amygdala disconnection in mesial temporal sclerosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The middle temporal gyrus is a commonly used approach to perform temporal lobectomy and amygdalohippocampectomy for patients with mesial temporal sclerosis. The anatomy relevant to the approach as presented will aid while performing epilepsy surgery.

Gray-White Matter Blurring of the Temporal Pole Associated With Hippocampal Sclerosis: A Microstructural Study Involving 3 T MRI and Ultrastructural Histopathology

Hippocampal sclerosis (HS) is often associated with gray-white matter blurring (GMB) of the anterior temporal lobe. In this study, twenty patients with unilateral temporal lobe epilepsy and HS were studied with 3 T MRI including T1 MP2RAGE and DTI/DMI sequences. Anterior temporal lobe white matter T1 relaxation times and diffusion measures were analyzed on the HS side, on the contralateral side, and in 10 normal controls. Resected brain tissue of three patients without GMB and four patients with GMB was evaluated ultrastructurally regarding axon density and diameter, the relation of the axon diameter to the total fiber diameter (G-ratio), and the thickness of the myelin sheath. Hippocampal sclerosis GMB of the anterior temporal lobe was related to prolonged T1 relaxation and axonal loss. A less pronounced reduction in axonal fraction was also found on imaging in GMB-negative temporal poles compared with normal controls. Contralateral values did not differ significantly between patients and normal controls. Reduced axonal density and axonal diameter were histopathologically confirmed in the temporopolar white matter with GMB compared to temporal poles without. These results confirm that GMB can be considered an imaging correlate for disturbed axonal maturation that can be quantified with advanced diffusion imaging.

Resective temporal lobe surgery in refractory temporal lobe epilepsy: prognostic factors of postoperative seizure outcome

OBJECTIVE

Temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) is one of the most common forms of epilepsy. In approximately 30% of patients, seizures are refractory to drug treatment. Despite the achievements of modern presurgical evaluation in recent years, the presurgical prediction of seizure outcome remains difficult. The aim of this study was to evaluate the seizure outcome in patients with drug-refractory TLE who underwent resective temporal lobe surgery (rTLS) and to determine features associated with unfavorable postsurgical seizure outcome.

METHODS

Patients with medically refractory TLE who underwent rTLS between 2012 and 2017 were reviewed from the prospectively collected epilepsy surgery database. A retrospective analysis of clinical, radiological, neuropsychological, histopathological, and perioperative findings of 161 patients was performed. The patients were divided into two groups according to seizure outcome (group I, International League Against Epilepsy [ILAE] class 1; group II, ILAE class ≥ 2). For identification of independent risk factors for unfavorable postoperative seizure outcome (ILAE class ≥ 2), a multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed.

RESULTS

Seizure freedom (ILAE class 1) was achieved in 121 patients (75.2%). The neuropsychological evaluation demonstrated that losses in cognitive performance were more pronounced in verbal memory after resections in the left temporal lobe and in nonverbal memory after right-sided resections, whereas attention improved after surgery. Overall, postoperative visual field deficits (VFDs) were common and occurred in 51% of patients. There was no statistically significant difference in the incidence of VFD in patients with selective surgical procedures compared to the patients with nonselective procedures. The lack of MRI lesions and placement of depth electrodes were preoperatively identified as predictors for unfavorable seizure outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

rTLS is an effective treatment method in patients with refractory TLE. However, patients with a lack of MRI lesions and placement of depth electrodes prior to rTLS are at higher risk for an unfavorable postsurgical seizure outcome.

Classification of complications of epilepsy surgery and invasive diagnostic procedures: A proposed protocol and feasibility study

OBJECTIVE

In epilepsy surgery, which aims to treat seizures and thereby to improve the lives of persons with drug-resistant epilepsy, the chances of attaining seizure relief must be carefully weighed against the risks of complications and expected adverse events. The interpretation of data regarding complications of epilepsy surgery and invasive diagnostic procedures is hampered by a lack of uniform definitions and method of data collection.

METHODS

Based on a review of previous definitions and classifications of complications, we developed a proposal for a new classification. This proposal was then subject to revisions after expert opinion within E-pilepsy, an EU-funded European pilot network of reference centers in refractory epilepsy and epilepsy surgery, later incorporated into the ERN (European Reference Network) EpiCARE. This version was discussed with recognized experts, and a final protocol was agreed to after further revision. The final protocol was evaluated in practical use over 1 year in three of the participating centers. One hundred seventy-four consecutive procedures were included with 35 reported complications.

RESULTS

This report presents a multidimensional classification of complications in epilepsy surgery and invasive diagnostic procedures, where complications are characterized in terms of their immediate effects, resulting permanent symptoms, and consequences on activities of daily living.

SIGNIFICANCE

We propose that the protocol will be helpful in the work to promote safety in epilepsy surgery and for future studies designed to identify risk factors for complications. Further work is needed to address the reporting of outcomes as regards neuropsychological function, activities of daily living, and quality of life.

Operative variations in temporal lobe epilepsy surgery and seizure and memory outcome in 226 patients suffering from hippocampal sclerosis

Objective: The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to assess seizure and memory outcomes following temporal lobe surgery in patients suffering from medically refractory temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and hippocampal sclerosis (HS).Methods: A retrospective monocentric data analysis was performed in consecutive patients who were operated on during 2002-2018. In the first decennium, standard temporal lobe resections (TLR) were predominately performed, and later, antero-temporal lobe resections (ATLR) were mainly performed. Seizure and memory outcomes over time were assessed according to ILAE/Engel classification and the Berlin Amnesia Test (BTA), respectively.Results: Altogether, 231 surgeries were performed on 226 patients (mean age, 40 years [range, 10-68 years]; male: female, 1:1.4; mean seizure duration, 25 years; and mean follow-up duration, 4.75 years [range, 1-16]). Recently, outcomes of 78.3% of the patients in the total cohort were classified as Engel class I, with 54.9% of patients being completely seizure free. The recent cohort of ATLR since 2012 showed significant more completely seizure-free patients than before 2012 (Engel IA 46.6% versus 67.7%, p < 0.0025, χ²), although the Kaplan Meier analysis of all patients favors TLR for better seizure outcome (61% ATLR vs 73% TLR seizure free after 5 yrs, log rank p < 0.001). Verbal memory improved significantly in non-dominant patients. Minor neurological complications were noted (permanent severe complications, 0.4%; temporary severe complications, 4.8%).Conclusion: Significant improvements in seizure and memory outcomes were observed over time, with surgical technique and seizure duration as important prognostic factors. Early admittance for surgery may favor an excellent seizure outcome in patients undergoing temporal lobe resection for HS.

Seizure and neuropsychological outcomes in a large series of selective amygdalohippocampectomies with a minimally invasive subtemporal approach

OBJECTIVE

Debate continues over proper surgical treatment for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE). Few large comprehensive studies exist that have examined outcomes for the subtemporal selective amygdalohippocampectomy (sSAH) approach. This study describes a minimally invasive technique for sSAH and examines seizure and neuropsychological outcomes in a large series of patients who underwent sSAH for MTLE.

METHODS

Data for 152 patients (94 women, 61.8%; 58 men, 38.2%) who underwent sSAH performed by a single surgeon were retrospectively reviewed. The sSAH technique involves a small, minimally invasive opening and preserves the anterolateral temporal lobe and the temporal stem.

RESULTS

All patients in the study had at least 1 year of follow-up (mean [SD] 4.52 [2.57] years), of whom 57.9% (88/152) had Engel class I seizure outcomes. Of the patients with at least 2 years of follow-up (mean [SD] 5.2 [2.36] years), 56.5% (70/124) had Engel class I seizure outcomes. Preoperative and postoperative neuropsychological test results indicated no significant change in intelligence, verbal comprehension, perceptual reasoning, attention and processing, cognitive flexibility, visuospatial memory, or mood. There was a significant change in word retrieval regardless of the side of surgery and a significant change in verbal memory in patients who underwent dominant-side resection (p < 0.05). Complication rates were low, with a 1.3% (2/152) permanent morbidity rate and 0.0% mortality rate.

CONCLUSIONS

This study reports a large series of patients who have undergone sSAH, with a comprehensive presentation of a minimally invasive technique. The sSAH approach described in this study appears to be a safe, effective, minimally invasive technique for the treatment of MTLE.

Comparison of minimally invasive and traditional surgical approaches for refractory mesial temporal lobe epilepsy: A systematic review and meta-analysis of outcomes

Magnetic resonance-guided laser interstitial laser therapy (MRgLITT) and radiofrequency ablation (RFA) represent two minimally invasive methods for the treatment of drug-refractory mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (mTLE). We performed a systematic review and a meta-analysis to compare outcomes and complications between MRgLITT, RFA, and conventional surgical approaches to the temporal lobe (i.e., anterior temporal lobe resection [ATL] or selective amygdalohippocampectomy [sAHE]). Forty-three studies (13 MRgLITT, 6 RFA, and 24 surgery studies) involved 554, 123, 1504, and 1326 patients treated by MRgLITT, RFA, ATL, or sAHE, respectively. Engel Class I (Engel-I) outcomes were achieved after MRgLITT in 57% (315/554, range = 33.3%-67.4%), RFA in 44% (54/123, range = 0%-67.2%), ATL in 69% (1032/1504, range = 40%-92.9%), and sAHE in 66% (887/1326, range = 21.4%-93.3%). Meta-analysis revealed no significant difference in seizure outcome between MRgLITT and RFA (Q = 2.74, p = .098), whereas ATL and sAHE were both superior to MRgLITT (ATL: Q = 8.92, p = .002; sAHE: Q = 4.33, p = .037) and RFA (ATL: Q = 6.42, p = .0113; sAHE: Q = 5.04, p = .0247), with better outcome in patients at follow-up of 60 months or more. Mesial hippocampal sclerosis (mTLE + hippocampal sclerosis) was associated with significantly better outcome after MRgLITT (Engel-I outcome in 64%; Q = 8.55, p = .0035). The rate of major complications was 3.8% for MRgLITT, 3.7% for RFA, 10.9% for ATL, and 7.4% for sAHE; the differences did not show statistical significance. Neuropsychological deficits occurred after all procedures, with left-sided surgeries having a higher rate of verbal memory impairment. Lateral functions such as naming or object recognition may be more preserved in MRgLITT. Thermal therapies are effective techniques but show a significantly lower rate of Engel-I outcome in comparison to ATL and sAHE. Between MRgLITT and RFA there were no significant differences in Engel-I outcome, whereby the success of treatment seems to depend on the approach used (e.g., occipital approach). MRgLITT shows a similar rate of complications compared to RFA, whereas patients undergoing MRgLITT may experience fewer major complications compared to ATL or sAHE and might have a more beneficial neuropsychological outcome.

Safety of the paramedian supracerebellar-transtentorial approach for selective amygdalohippocampectomy

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to assess the reproducibility and safety of the recently introduced paramedian supracerebellar-transtentorial (PST) approach for selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SA).

METHODS

The authors performed a retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data originating from their surgical register of patients undergoing SA via a PST approach for lesional medial temporal lobe epilepsy. All patients received thorough pre- and postoperative clinical (neurological, neuropsychological, psychiatric) and instrumental (ictal and long-term EEG, invasive EEG if needed, MRI) workup. Surgery-induced complications were assessed at discharge and at every follow-up thereafter and were classified according to Clavien-Dindo grade (CDG). Epilepsy outcome was defined according to Engel classification. Data were reported according to common descriptive statistical methods.

RESULTS

Between May 2015 and May 2018, 17 patients underwent SA via a PST approach at the authors' institution (hippocampal sclerosis in 13 cases, WHO grade II glioma in 2 cases, and reactive gliosis in 2 cases). The median postoperative follow-up was 7 months (mean 9 months, range 3-19 months). There was no surgery-related mortality and no complication (CDG ≥ 2) in the whole series. Transitory CDG 1 surgical complications occurred in 4 patients and had resolved in all of them by the first postoperative follow-up. One patient showed a deterioration of neuropsychological performance with new slight mnestic deficits. No patient experienced a clinically relevant postoperative visual field defect. No morbidity due to semisitting position was recorded. At last follow-up 13/17 (76.4%) patients were in Engel class I (9/17 [52.9%] were in class IA).

CONCLUSIONS

The PST approach is a reproducible and safe surgical route for SA. The achievable complication rate is in line with the best results in the literature. Visual function outcome particularly benefits from this highly selective, neocortex-sparing approach. A larger patient sample and longer follow-up will show in the future if the seizure control rate and neuropsychological outcome also compare better than those achieved with current common surgical techniques.

The basal turning point of optic radiation (bTPOR): The location of optic radiation in the cerebral basal surface

BACKGROUNDS

Optic radiation protection is crucial in the basal temporal approach to the mesial temporal lobe. Clear description of the optic radiation in the basal brain surface is lacking. Our aim is to describe the anatomy of optic radiation in the basal cerebral surface and define safety zone of basal temporal approach avoiding of optic radiation injury.

METHODS

Five brain specimens (10 hemispheres) were dissected using Klingler method to observe the course of the optic radiation. Diffusion tensor imaging data of 25 volunteers were used to verify the fiber dissection results. The relationship of the optic radiation to nearby structures were illustrated and measured.

RESULTS

The optic radiation bends from the lateral wall of the lateral ventricle to its bottom at a basal turning point of optic radiation (bTPOR). The bTPOR is at the plane crossing the center point of the splenium of corpus callosum. MRI measurements showed no significant difference in the distance from the center of the splenium of corpus callosum and the bTPOR to the occipital pole (59.46 ± 4.338 mm vs 59.54 ± 3.805 mm, p = 0.95). Anterior to bTPOR, no optic radiation fibers were found at the basal brain surface.

CONCLUSIONS

The bTPOR was found as a landmark of the optic radiation in the cerebral basal surface. With neuronavigation, the splenium of corpus callosum can be a landmark of the bTPOR. By approaching mesial temporal lesions using the basal temporal approach anterior to bTPOR, optic radiation injury can be prevented.

Physiological Ripples Associated With Sleep Spindles Can Be Identified in Patients With Refractory Epilepsy Beyond Mesio-Temporal Structures

Introduction: High frequency oscillations (HFO) are promising biomarkers of epileptic tissue. While group analysis suggested a correlation between surgical removal of HFO generating tissue and seizure free outcome, HFO could not predict seizure outcome on an individual patient level. One possible explanation is the lack of differentiation between physiological and epileptic HFO. In the mesio-temporal lobe, a proportion of physiological ripples can be identified by their association with scalp sleep spindles. Spike associated ripples in contrast can be considered epileptic. This study investigated whether categorizing ripples by the co-occurrence with sleep spindles or spikes improves outcome prediction after surgery. Additionally, it aimed to investigate whether spindle-ripple association is limited to the mesio-temporal lobe structures or visible across the whole brain. Methods: We retrospectively analyzed EEG of 31 patients with chronic intracranial EEG. Sleep spindles in scalp EEG and ripples and epileptic spikes in iEEG were automatically detected. Three ripple subtypes were obtained: SpindleR, Non-SpindleR, and SpikeR. Rate ratios between removed and non-removed brain areas were calculated. We compared the distinct ripple subtypes and their rates in different brain regions, inside and outside seizure onset areas and between patients with good and poor seizure outcome. Results: SpindleR were found across all brain regions. SpikeR had significantly higher rates in the SOZ than in Non-SOZ channels. A significant positive correlation between removal of ripple-events and good outcome was found for the mixed ripple group (r_s = 0.43, p = 0.017) and for ripples not associated with spindles (r_s=0.40, p = 0.044). Also, a significantly high proportion of spikes associated with ripples were removed in seizure free patients (p = 0.036). Discussion: SpindleR are found in mesio-temporal and neocortical structures, indicating that ripple-spindle-coupling might have functional importance beyond mesio-temporal structures. Overall, the proportion of SpindleR was low and separating spindle and spike associated ripples did not improve outcome prediction in our patient group. SpindleR analysis therefore can be a tool to identify physiological events but needs to be used in combination with other methods to have clinical relevance.

Extreme Lateral Supracerebellar Infratentorial Approach: Surgical Anatomy and Review of the Literature

OBJECTIVE

The extreme lateral supracerebellar infratentorial (ELSI) approach has the potential to access several distinct anatomical regions that are otherwise difficult to reach. We have illustrated the surgical anatomy through cadaveric dissections and provided an extensive review of the literature to highlight the versatility of this approach, its limits, and comparisons with alternative approaches.

METHODS

The surgical anatomy of the ELSI has been described using 1 adult-injected cadaveric head. Formalized noninjected brain specimens were also dissected to describe the brain parenchymal anatomy of the region. An extensive review of the literature was performed according to each targeted anatomical region. Illustrative cases are also presented.

RESULTS

The ELSI approach allows for wide exposure of the middle and posterolateral incisural spaces with direct access to centrally located intra-axial structures such as the splenium, pulvinar, brainstem, and mesial temporal lobe. In addition, for skull base extra-axial tumors such as petroclival meningiomas, the ELSI approach represents a rapid and adequate method of access without the use of extensive skull base approaches.

CONCLUSIONS

The ELSI approach represents one of the most versatile approaches with respect to its ability to address several anatomical regions centered at the posterior and middle incisural spaces. For intra-axial pathologies, the approach allows for access to the central core of the brain with several advantages compared with alternate approaches that frequently involve significant brain retraction and cortical incisions. In specific cases of skull base lesions, the ELSI approach is an elegant alternative to traditionally used skull base approaches, thereby avoiding approach-related morbidity.

Assessing the connectional anatomy of superior and lateral surgical approaches for medial temporal lobe epilepsy

The most common approaches in the treatment of epilepsy, the trans-sylvian selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAH) and the anterior temporal lobe resection (ATLR) reach the medial temporal lobe through different surgical routes. Our aim was to delineate the white matter (WM) fiber tracts at risk in relation to trans-sylvian SAH and ATLR by defining each fascicle en route to medial temporal lobe during each approach. ATLR and trans-sylvian SAH were performedand related WM tracts en route to medial temporal region were presented in relation to the relevant approaches and surrounding neurovascular structures. The WM tracts most likely to be disrupted during trans-sylvian SAH along the roof of the temporal horn were the UF - and less commonly IFOF - at the layer of the external capsule, anterior commissure, anterior bend of optic radiations, and sublenticular internal capsule. Amygdaloid projections to the claustrum, putamen and globus pallidus, the tail of caudate and the peduncle of the lentiform nucleus were also in close proximity to the resection cavity. Fiber tracts most likely to be impaired during ATLR included the UF, ILF, IFOF, anterior commissure, optic radiations, and, less likely, the vertical ventral segment of the arcuate fascicle. Both ATLR and trans-sylvian SAH carry the risk of injury to WM pathways, which may result in unpredictable functional loss. A detailed 3-D knowledge of the related connectional anatomy will help subside neurocognitive, neuroophtalmologic, neurolinguistic complications of epilepsy surgery, providing an opportunity to tailor the surgery according to patient's unique connectional and functional anatomy.

Subtemporal selective amygdalohippocampectomy in patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy: Systematic review of seizure and neuropsychological outcomes

In addition to standard anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL), subtemporal selective amygdalohippocampectomy (sSAH) is also a common technique for the treatment of medically intractable mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE). We conducted a systematic literature review to determine the seizure and neuropsychological outcomes in patients with MTLE who underwent sSAH. We searched PubMed and Embase using Medical Subject Headings and keywords related to sSAH, seizure outcome, and neuropsychological outcome. Titles, abstracts, and full-texts were screened in light of inclusion and exclusion criteria that were established a priori. Potential papers were reviewed by 3 reviewers, who reached a consensus on the final papers to be included. Literature review identified 208 abstracts from which a total of 29 full-text articles were reviewed. Six studies containing data from 4 countries (3 continents) met our inclusion criteria. The seizure-free rates at 12 months after sSAH ranged from 59.1% to 61.5% in 4 studies. Four studies showed that seizure-free rates ranged from 56% to 82.6% at 24 months after surgery. Six studies evaluated the neuropsychological changes of patients with MTLE after sSAH, including intelligence, verbal memory, nonverbal memory, language function, and so on. In terms of neuropsychological outcomes, there are some differences among the 6 studies. Taken together, sSAH can provide a considerable rate of seizure freedom. In addition, the neuropsychological outcomes of patients who underwent sSAH were slightly different among 6 studies. Therefore, large-scale case series or randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are needed to clarify the advantages and disadvantages of the sSAH.

Distinguishing Dependent-Stage Secondary Epileptogenesis in a Complex Case of Giant Hypothalamic Hamartoma With Assistance of a Computational Method

Besides gelastic seizures, hypothalamic hamartoma (HH) is also noted for its susceptibility to remote secondary epileptogenesis. Although clinical observations have demonstrated its existence, and a three-stage theory has been proposed, how to determine whether a remote symptom is spontaneous or dependent on epileptic activities of HH is difficult in some cases. Herein, we report a case of new non-gelastic seizures in a 9-year-old female associated with a postoperatively remaining HH. Electrophysiological examinations and stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) demonstrated seizure onsets with slow-wave and fast activities on the outside of the HH. By using computational methodologies to calculate the network dynamic effective connectivities, the importance of HH in the epileptic network was revealed. After SEEG-guided thermal coagulation of the remaining HH, the patient finally was seizure-free at the 2-year follow-up. This case showed the ability of computational methods to reveal information underlying complex SEEG signals, and further demonstrated the dependent-stage secondary epileptogenesis, which has been rarely reported.

Procedure-Related Temporal Infarct After Retractorless Transsylvian Selective Amygdalohippocampectomy and Impact on 2-Year Epilepsy Outcome

BACKGROUND

Selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAH) is designed to treat patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE).

OBJECTIVE

To determine the volume and impact of temporal lobe infarction after retractorless transsylvian SAH (en bloc resection of the hippocampus) that have not been reported.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of patients treated with retractorless transsylvian SAH. Infarctions were detected by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) within the first week after the operation. Neuropsychological testing was performed preoperatively and 6 mo later. Seizure outcome was evaluated 2 yr after epilepsy surgery.

RESULTS

Between 2010 and 2014, a total of 30 patients were included in this study. Analysis of postoperative MRI showed the following: (1) mean removal volume of the hippocampus-parahippocampus was 5.72 cm3, and (2) mean volumes of temporal and insular infarctions were 1.71 and 0.25 cm3, respectively. Twenty-five patients (83.3%) were free of disabling seizures (Engel class I) at 2 yr of outcome. Neuropsychological testing revealed improvement in Perceptual Organization Index (P = .036) and verbal paired associates II (P = .014) after the operation. Neither infarction volume nor removal volume was related to epilepsy outcome in linear regression model.

CONCLUSION

Transsylvian SAH has comparable seizure outcomes but bears inherent risks of vasospasm/vascular injury. Immediate postoperative small infarction volume around resection cavity or along surgical corridor was noticed after retractorless transsylvian SAH, which did not cause neuropsychological deteriorations, in contrast to previous study with the use of self-sustaining rigid retraction system. Further study should be performed to compare procedure-related infarctions and their impacts on neuropsychological outcomes in different selective approaches.

Temporal Horn Choroid Plexus Papilloma Presenting with Seizures in Adulthood: Clinical Case Report and Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Choroid plexus papillomas (CPPs) are benign World Health Organization grade I tumors that comprise 2%-4% of all brain tumors among children and less than 1% of brain tumors in adults. Most adult cases occur in the fourth ventricle, with only 1 previous report describing an adult patient with a temporal horn CPP.

CASE DESCRIPTION

We report a rare case of a temporal horn CPP presenting in an adult with seizures. We performed a minimally invasive subtemporal approach for gross total resection of the lesion.

CONCLUSIONS

CPP presenting in the temporal horn is rare among adults. We discuss the surgical nuances of the subtemporal approach for resection and review the literature regarding adult presentation of CPP and the treatment strategies for adult CPP.

Systematic review and network meta-analysis of resective surgery for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) versus selective amygdalohippocampectomy (SAH) on seizure-free outcome in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy, using both direct and indirect evidence from the literature.

METHODS

MEDLINE, Embase and Cochrane databases were searched for original research articles and systematic reviews comparing ATL versus SAH, and ATL or SAH versus medical management (MM). The outcome was seizure freedom at 12 months of follow-up or longer. Direct pairwise meta-analyses were conducted, followed by a random-effect Bayesian network meta-analysis (NMA) combining direct and indirect evidence.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight articles were included (18 compared ATL vs SAH, 1 compared ATL vs SAH vs MM, 8 compared ATL vs MM, and 1 compared SAH vs MM). Direct pairwise meta-analyses showed no significant differences in seizure-free outcome of ATL versus SAH (OR 1.14, 95% CI 0.93 to 1.39; p=0.201), but the odds of seizure-free outcome were higher for ATL versus MM (OR 29.16, 95% CI 10.44 to 81.50; p<0.00001), and SAH versus MM (OR 28.42, 95% CI 10.17 to 79.39; p<0.00001). NMA also showed that the odds of seizure-free outcome were no different in ATL versus SAH (OR 1.15, 95% credible interval (CrI) 0.84-1.15), but higher for ATL versus MM (OR 27.22, 95% CrI 15.38-27.22), and SAH versus MM (OR 23.57, 95% CrI 12.67-23.57). There were no significant differences between direct and indirect comparisons (all p>0.05).

CONCLUSION

Direct evidence, indirect evidence and NMA did not identify a difference in seizure-free outcome of ATL versus SAH.

Surgical Considerations of Intractable Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

Surgery of temporal lobe epilepsy is the best opportunity for seizure freedom in medically intractable patients. The surgical approach has evolved to recognize the paramount importance of the mesial temporal structures in the majority of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy who have a seizure origin in the mesial temporal structures. For those individuals with medically intractable mesial temporal lobe epilepsy, a selective amygdalohippocampectomy surgery can be done that provides an excellent opportunity for seizure freedom and limits the resection to temporal lobe structures primarily involved in seizure genesis.

Visual field defects following different resective procedures for mesiotemporal lobe epilepsy

INTRODUCTION

One of the most common side effects of mesiotemporal lobe resection in patients with medically intractable epilepsy are visual field defects (VFD). While peripheral defects usually remain unnoticed by patients, extended VFD influence daily life activities and can, in particular, affect driving regulations. This study had been designed to evaluate frequency and extent of VFD following different surgical approaches to the mesiotemporal area with respect to the ability to drive.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study comprises a consecutive series of 366 patients operated at the Epilepsy Center in Freiburg for intractable mesiotemporal lobe epilepsy from 1998 to 2016. The following procedures were performed: standard anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL: n=134; 37%), anterior temporal or keyhole resection (KH: n=53; 15%), and selective amygdalohippocampectomy via the transsylvian (tsAHE: n=145; 40%) and the subtemporal (ssAHE: n=34; 9%) approach. Frequency and extent of postoperative VFD were evaluated in relation to different surgical procedures. According to the German driving guidelines, postoperative VFD were classified as driving-relevant VFD with the involvement of absolute, homonymous central scotoma within 20° and driving-irrelevant VFD with either none or exclusively minor VFD sparing the center.

RESULTS

Postoperative visual field examinations were available in 276 of 366 cases. Postoperative VFD were observed in 202 of 276 patients (73%) and were found to be driving-relevant in 133 of 276 patients (48%), whereas 69 patients (25%) showed VFD irrelevant for driving. Visual field defects were significantly less likely following ssAHE compared with other temporal resections, and if present, they were less frequently driving-relevant (p<0.05), irrespective of the side of surgery.

CONCLUSION

Subtemporal sAHE (ssAHE) caused significantly less frequently and less severely driving-relevant VFD compared with all other approaches to the temporal lobe, irrespective of the side of surgery.