The influence of patient characteristics on the appropriateness of surgical treatment for breast cancer patients. Progetto Oncologia Femminile

Non Clinical Factors as Determinants of the Use of Breast Conservative Surgery in Italy

The aims of the study were to evaluate the trend of breast conservative surgery (BCS) in Italian breast cancer patients and to identify its nonclinical determinants. Data of 2062 patients surgically treated patients for primary breast cancer were evaluated; 788 (38.0%) had been submitted to breast conservative surgery. A different percentage of breast conservative surgery was found with respect to geographic patient's residence (North, 41.1%; Central, 37.6%; South, 33.0%). Multifactorial analysis showed that time since diagnosis, age at diagnosis and nonclinical factors, such as geographic area of residence and level of education, were significantly associated with breast conservative surgery.

The impact of comorbidity on the survival of postmenopausal women with breast cancer

PURPOSE

The aim was to assess the impact of comorbidity on survival of postmenopausal women with breast cancer diagnosis in the period 1995-1997.

METHODS

The level of comorbidity was described by the methods suggested by Satariano and Charlson. Cox's proportional hazard models were used to explore the impact of comorbidity on all-cause mortality.

RESULTS

After a median follow-up time of 52 months, an increasing level of comorbidity was associated with a higher all-cause mortality. Compared to patients with-out comorbid conditions, the hazard ration of death (HR) was 1.2 (95% CI: 0.8-1.7) for Satariano index 1 and HR 2.3 (95% CI: 1.5-3.5) for Satariano index >or=2, and HR 1.6 and 2.1 for the Charlson comorbidity index, respectively. Independent of comorbidity, the treatment pattern had a strong impact on survival. The level of comorbidity has an influence on the 3-year survival of postmenopausal women with breast cancer.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term follow-up is required to appraise these findings in relation to treatment strategies.

The consistency of panelists’ appropriateness ratings: do experts produce clinically logical scores for rectal cancer treatment?

OBJECTIVE

To quantify the clinical consistency of expert panelists' ratings of appropriateness of pre-operative and post-operative chemotherapy plus radiation for rectal cancer.

METHODS

A panel of nine physicians (two surgeons, four medical oncologists, three radiation oncologists) rated the appropriateness of providing pre-operative and post-operative treatments for rectal cancer, utilizing a modified-Delphi (RAND/UCLA) approach. Clinical scenarios were paired so that each component of a pair differed by only one clinical feature (e.g. tumor stage). A pair of appropriateness ratings was defined as inconsistent when the clinical scenario that should have had the higher (or at least equal) appropriateness rating was given a lower rating. The rate of inconsistency was analyzed for panelists' ratings of pre- and post-operative chemotherapy plus radiation.

RESULTS

The final panel rating was inconsistent for 1.19% of pre-operative scenario pairs, and 0.77% of post-operative scenario pairs. Using the conventional RAND/UCLA definition of appropriateness, the magnitude of the inconsistency would produce inconsistent appropriateness ratings in 0.43% of pre-operative and 0.11% of post-operative scenario pairs. There was significant variation in the rate of inconsistency among individual panelists' final ratings of both pre-operative (range: 0.43-5.17%, P < 0.001) and post-operative (range: 0.51-2.34%, P < 0.001) scenarios. Panelists' overall average rate of inconsistency improved significantly after the panel meeting and discussion (from 5.62 to 2.25% for pre-operative scenarios, and from 1.47 to 1.24% for post-operative scenarios, both P < 0.05). There was no clear difference between specialty groups. Inconsistency was related to the structure of the rating manual: in the second round there were no inconsistent ratings when scenario pairs occurred on the same page of the manual.

CONCLUSIONS

The RAND/UCLA appropriateness method can produce ratings for cancer treatment that are highly clinically consistent. Modifications to the structure of rating manuals to facilitate direct assessment of consistency at the time of rating may reduce inconsistency further.

Differences in stage and therapy for breast cancer across Europe

We examined variations in stage, diagnostic workup and therapy for breast cancer across Europe. Seventeen cancer registries in six European countries contributed 4,480 cases diagnosed in 1990-91. The clinical records of these cases were examined, and the distribution of stage, diagnostic examinations and therapy were analyzed. Stage was earliest in the French registries, followed by those of Italy and Eindhoven (Netherlands). The proportion of stage I cancers was highest in the French areas with screening in place. Estonia, the English registries and Granada (Spain) had the most advanced stage at diagnosis. Use of liver ultrasonography varied from 84% (Italian registries) to 18% (Granada). Bone scan use varied from 81% (Italian registries) to 15% (Mersey, UK). The highest proportions treated by breast-conserving surgery were in the French (57%) and English registries (63%); the lowest were in Estonia (6%) and Granada (11%). The highest proportions of Halsted mastectomies were in Italy (19%) and Granada (8%). In all countries except England, 90% of operations included axillary lymphadenectomy. Medical treatment only was given to 8% of (mostly advanced) cases overall. Estonia (21%) and the English registries (14%) had the highest proportions of patients given medication only. Chemotherapy was given to low proportions of node-positive cases in the Italian (76%) and English (74%) areas; breast-conserving surgery for stage I tumors varied from 24% in Granada to 84% in England. These wide differences in breast cancer care across Europe in the early 1990s indicate a need for continual monitoring of past treatments to help ensure application of the most effective protocols.

Causes and consequences of comorbidity: a review

A literature search was carried out to identify and summarize the existing information on causes and consequences of comorbidity of chronic somatic diseases. A selection of 82 articles met our inclusion criteria. Very little work has been done on the causes of comorbidity. On the other hand, much work has been done on consequences of comorbidity, although comorbidity is seldom the main subject of study. We found comorbidity in general to be associated with mortality, quality of life, and health care. The consequences of specific disease combinations, however, depended on many factors. We recommend more etiological studies on shared risk factors, especially for those comorbidities that occur at a higher rate than expected. New insights in this field can lead to better prevention strategies. Health care workers need to take comorbid diseases into account in monitoring and treating patients. Future studies on consequences of comorbidity should investigate specific disease combinations.

Increasing trends in the use of breast-conserving surgery in California

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine temporal trends in breast-conserving surgery in California from 1988 through 1995.

METHODS

Logistic regression was used to analyze data on 104,466 cases of early-stage breast cancer reported to the California Cancer Registry.

RESULTS

A monotonically increasing trend in breast-conserving surgery was detected after adjustment for age, race/ethnicity, stage at diagnosis, and neighborhood education level. Breast-conserving surgery increased at similar rates among all racial/ethnic groups. Older age, Asian or Hispanic race/ethnicity, late-stage diagnosis, and residence in an undereducated neighborhood were factors associated with lower use of breast-conserving surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Although disparities are evident, use of breast-conserving surgery increased steadily in all groups examined in this study.

Comparison of breast-conserving therapy with mastectomy for treatment of early breast cancer in community hospitals

Although the results of clinical trials support breast-conserving therapy as a replacement for mastectomy in early breast cancer, the question remains whether these results apply in routine clinical practice. In the present analysis the breast cancer-specific survival and recurrence-free survival of 464 consecutive patients with breast tumors < or = 3 cm across undergoing breast-conserving therapy were compared with a group of 459 patients with similar extent of disease and period of diagnosis undergoing mastectomy. All patients were treated in community hospitals in the south-eastern Netherlands. Median follow-up of both treatment groups was 6.2 years. After adjustment for the prognostic effects of age, tumour size, axillary nodal status and adjuvant systemic therapy, neither breast cancer-specific survival nor recurrence-free survival differed significantly between the breast-conserving therapy group and the mastectomy group. This finding indicates that in routine clinical practice breast-conserving therapy may be as effective as mastectomy.

Sociodemographic factors associated with the diagnostic staging of breast cancer in southern Italy

BACKGROUND

There are marked regional differences in breast cancer mortality rates in Italy, probably linked to factors such as diagnostic delay, therapeutic strategies, and biologic and sociodemographic differences. To investigate a possible link between sociodemographic factors (e.g. age, education, and residence) and delay in the diagnosis of breast cancer, data were evaluated from all such patients from our Institute living in the Campania Region of Southern Italy for 1991-1993.

METHODS

Patients were grouped into Tis-T1/N0-N+ versus T2-4/N0-N+ and the variables examined were age (< 40, 41-50, 51-60, > 60 years), education (< or = 5 vs. > 5 school years) and residence (urban vs. rural). An analysis was made using the Pearson's Chi-square test and the multiple logistic regression.

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences were found for both residence (P = 0.04) and education level (P = 0.03) in the older than 60 years age group, but only for residence (P = 0.03) in the 51-60 years age group. The risks according to Mantel-Haenszel were 1.28 for education (P = 0.08) and 1.32 for residence in rural municipalities (P = 0.05). The odds ratio for residence in rural municipalities, adjusted by education and by the education-residence interaction, was 2.26 (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.12-4.54) in the 51-60 years age group and 1.74 (95% CI, 1.01-3.00) in the older than 60 years age group.

CONCLUSIONS

These data clearly indicate that residents of rural municipalities, as well as poorly educated subjects, are more likely than their respective counter-parts to have a delayed diagnosis of breast cancer.

Variation in use of breast-conserving surgery in Lombardia, Italy

The extent of variation in the use of breast-conserving surgery was analyzed using the 1990 and 1991 hospital discharge data of Lombardia, Italy. The proportion of patients undergoing breast-conserving surgery for unilateral breast cancer was estimated for each of the 10 geographic areas (9 provinces plus metropolitan Milano) in which the region is divided. Overall, the rate of use was 41% of 3,225 patients in 1990, and 45% of 3,736 patients in 1991. In both study years, patient age was strongly correlated with the likelihood of undergoing conservative surgery, with younger women more frequently treated with this approach. In each province, patients treated at centers located in the main city had a greater probability (OR, 1.54; 95% CI, 1.37-1.69) of having conservative surgery. This procedure was also more often used in private hospitals (OR, 1.59; 95% CI, 1.20-2.08) where care is paid at the point of consumption by patients, directly or through their private insurance. The observed variation in the use of the conservative procedure across the 10 regional areas was greater than that expected by chance alone (p < .0001), with rates ranging from 29% to 60%. This pattern persisted even after adjusting for the relevant patient and hospital characteristics. Despite the relatively large body of scientific evidence, it appears that the surgical management of breast cancer is more dependent on physicians' attitudes in each geographic area than on individual patients' characteristics.

pTNM Stage Distribution in Breast Cancer: A Population-Based Survey in Northern Italy

Aims and background

The role of distribution by stage at diagnosis in breast cancer has been considered in many studies, with particular regard to evaluation of prognosis, impact of screening programs and quality of care. Nevertheless, international comparisons of descriptive data can be hampered by lack of homogeneity in staging methods. The TNM is presently the most common staging system used all over the world, although some criticism have been raised recently against its pragmatic value. The present study reports a population-based survey of pathologic TNM distribution in incident cases of female breast cancer in the Verona province, a geographical area of northern Italy covered by cancer registration.

Methods

All histologically proven incident cases of breast cancer were identified in the study period 1988-1990 and classified as for tumor size and nodal involvement according to the pathological TNM criteria. The type of surgical treatment was also registered for all cases diagnosed in 1990.

Results

one thousand two hundreds and fifty-four invasive and in situ breast cancers were observed and pT1 cases accounted for 44.4%. Nodal involvement was present in 41.5% of invasive cancers. A surgical treatment was performed in 1213 patients (96.7%). Axillary dissection was reported in 1080 cases, 820 of them (76.6%) having 10 or more lymph nodes examined. Radical mastectomy accounted for 74% of the 458 breast cancers diagnosed in 1990 and 31.6% of the eligible cases were conservatively treated.

Conclusions

Cancer registries should be encouraged to report data on stage distribution in breast cancer (and in other malignancies). This practice could improve international comparisons and give an essential contribution to studies on survival, screening programs and quality of care.

Management of early breast cancer in southeast Netherlands since 1984. A population-based study. Regional Breast Cancer Study Group

We studied changes in staging and treatment of patients with early breast cancer (TNM stage I and II) in eight community hospitals in southeast Netherlands between 1984 and 1991 and related these changes to the guidelines for the management of breast cancer drawn up by the regional Breast Cancer Study Group. Since 1984, the proportion of patients that underwent breast-conserving therapy (local tumour excision, axillary dissection, and irradiation of the breast) increased from 26% to 53%. Although the mean number of axillary lymph nodes examined by the pathologists increased significantly, the proportion of patients with positive lymph nodes remained unchanged. The proportion of patients with involved axillary nodes receiving any form of adjuvant systemic therapy increased from 49% to 82%. Therapeutic policy initially varied significantly from one hospital to another but gradually became more uniform. We conclude that, except for elderly patients, treatment of early breast cancer corresponded increasingly to the guidelines of the regional Breast Cancer Study Group.