Reflections on the ABC model of flower development

Lost in translation: What we have learned from attributes that do not translate from Arabidopsis to other plants

Research in Arabidopsis thaliana has a powerful influence on our understanding of gene functions and pathways. However, not everything translates from Arabidopsis to crops and other plants. Here, a group of experts consider instances where translation has been lost and why such translation is not possible or is challenging. First, despite great efforts, floral dip transformation has not succeeded in other species outside Brassicaceae. Second, due to gene duplications and losses throughout evolution, it can be complex to establish which genes are orthologs of Arabidopsis genes. Third, during evolution Arabidopsis has lost arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis. Fourth, other plants have evolved specialized cell types that are not present in Arabidopsis. Fifth, similarly, C4 photosynthesis cannot be studied in Arabidopsis, which is a C3 plant. Sixth, many other plant species have larger genomes, which has given rise to innovations in transcriptional regulation that are not present in Arabidopsis. Seventh, phenotypes such as acclimation to water stress can be challenging to translate due to different measurement strategies. And eighth, while the circadian oscillator is conserved, there are important nuances in the roles of circadian regulators in crop plants. A key theme emerging across these vignettes is that even when translation is lost, insights can still be gained through comparison with Arabidopsis.

Transcriptome Analysis Reveals Association of E-Class AmMADS-Box Genes with Petal Malformation in Antirrhinum majus L

Snapdragon (Antirrhinum majus) serves as a model system for dissecting floral morphogenesis mechanisms. Petal malformation in A. majus impacts ornamental value, but its genetic basis remains poorly understood. We compared transcriptomes of the wild-type (Am11) and a petal-malformed mutant (AmDP2) to identify 2303 differentially expressed genes (DEGs), including E-class MIKC-type MADS-box genes SEP3 (AmMADS25/61/20/26) and SEP2 (AmMADS85). Weighted gene co-expression network (WGCNA), protein-protein interaction (PPI), qRT-PCR and virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) analyses revealed interactions between SEP2/SEP3 and C/A/B-class MADS-box genes (AG, AP1, AP3), co-regulated MADS transcription factors (MTFs) AGL15 (AmMADS16), and auxin signaling genes (SAUR1, IAA13). qRT-PCR validated upregulation of SEP3 and downregulation of SEP2 in AmDP2. Our results suggest that E-class MADS-box genes are associated with petal malformation through coordinated interactions with hormonal pathways. These findings provide candidate targets for further functional studies in snapdragon.

Mutant analysis in a small weed reveals the blueprint of floral patterning

Under the theme "Research that Transformed Developmental Biology", this article discusses the seminal work by Bowman, Smyth, and Meyerowitz published in Development in 1991. The work laid down an elegant blueprint of flower patterning, namely the ABC model of flower development, which remains a cornerstone of plant development. In addition to summarizing key aspects of the model, the article emphasizes several noteworthy aspects, including the basic technique (mutant analysis) employed and the influence by animal development. Additionally, the article discusses significant follow-up research that confirmed key aspects of the model. Lastly, the article examines the impact of the ABC model on the field of plant EvoDevo. Collectively, the journey of how basic genetic analysis of mutants resulted in groundbreaking advancements in plant development will inspire future scientists and drive transformative research forward.

Strigolactone insensitivity affects the hormonal homeostasis in barley

In response to environmental changes, plants continuously make architectural changes in order to optimize their growth and development. The regulation of plant branching, influenced by environmental conditions and affecting hormone balance and gene expression, is crucial for agronomic purposes due to its direct correlation with yield. Strigolactones (SL), the youngest class of phytohormones, function to shape the architecture of plants by inhibiting axillary outgrowth. Barley plants harboring the mutation in the HvDWARF14 (HvD14) gene, which encodes the SL-specific receptor, produce almost twice as many tillers as wild-type (WT) Sebastian plants. Here, through hormone profiling and comparison of transcriptomic and proteomic changes between 2- and 4-week-old plants of WT and hvd14 genotypes, we elucidate a regulatory mechanism that might affect the tillering of SL-insensitive plants. The analysis showed statistically significant increased cytokinin content and decreased auxin and abscisic acid content in 'bushy' hvd14 compared to WT, which aligns with the commonly known actions of these hormones regarding branching regulation. Further, transcriptomic and proteomic analysis revealed a set of differentially expressed genes (DEG) and abundant proteins (DAP), among which 11.6% and 14.6% were associated with phytohormone-related processes, respectively. Bioinformatics analyses then identified a series of potential SL-dependent transcription factors (TF), which may control the differences observed in the hvd14 transcriptome and proteome. Comparison to available Arabidopsis thaliana data implicates a sub-selection of these TF as being involved in the transduction of SL signal in both monocotyledonous and dicotyledonous plants.

The dynamic regulatory network of stamens and pistils in papaya

BACKGROUND

Papaya exhibits three sex types: female (XX), male (XY), and hermaphrodite (XYh), making it an unusual trioecious model for studying sex determination. A critical aspect of papaya sex determination is the pistil abortion in male flowers. However, the regulatory networks that control the development of pistils and stamens in papaya remain incompletely understood.

RESULTS

In this study, we identified three organ-specific clusters involved in papaya pistils and stamens development. We found that pistil development is primarily characterized by the significant expression of auxin-related genes, while the pistil abortion genes in males is mainly associated with cytokinin, gibberellin, and auxin pathways. Additionally, we constructed expression regulatory networks for the development of female pistils, aborted pistils and stamens in male flowers, revealing key regulatory genes and signaling pathways involved in papaya organ development. Furthermore, we systematically identified 65 members of the MADS-box gene family and 10 ABCDE subfamily MADS-box genes in papaya. By constructing a phylogenetic tree of the ABCDE subfamily, we uncovered gene contraction and expansion in papaya, providing an improved understanding of the developmental mechanisms and evolutionary history of papaya floral organs.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings provide a robust framework for identifying candidate sex-determining genes and constructing the sex determination regulatory network in papaya, providing insights and genomic resources for papaya breeding.

Genome-Wide Investigation of MADS-Box Genes in Flower Development and Environmental Acclimation of Lumnitzera littorea (Jack) Voigt

Lumnitzera littorea (Jack) Voigt is an endangered mangrove species in China. Low fecundity and environmental pressure are supposed to be key factors limiting the population expansion of L. littorea. Transcription factors with the MADS-box domain are crucial regulators of plant flower development, reproduction, and stress response. In this study, we performed a comprehensive investigation into the features and functions of MADS-box genes of L. littorea. Sixty-three LlMADS genes with similar structure and motif composition were identified in the L. littorea genome, and these genes were unevenly distributed on the 11 chromosomes. Segmental duplication was suggested to make a main contribution to the expansion of the LlMADS gene family. Some LIMADS genes exhibited differential expression in different flower types or in response to cold stress. Overexpression of the B-class gene LlMADS37 had substantial effects on the flower morphology and flowering time of transgenic Arabidopsis plants, demonstrating its key role in regulating flower morphogenesis and inflorescence. These findings largely enrich our understanding of the functional importance of MADS-box genes in the inflorescence and stress acclimation of L. littorea and provide valuable resources for future genetic research to improve the conservation of this species.

Comparative Analysis of Floral Transcriptomes in Gossypium hirsutum (Malvaceae)

Organ-specific transcriptomes provide valuable insight into the genes involved in organ identity and developmental control. This study investigated transcriptomes of floral organs and subtending bracts in wild and domesticated Gossypium hirsutum, focusing on MADS-box genes critical for floral development. The expression profiles of A, B, C, D, and E class genes were analyzed, confirming their roles in floral organ differentiation. Hierarchical clustering revealed similar expression patterns between bracts and sepals, as well as between petals and stamens, while carpels clustered with developing cotton fibers, reflecting their shared characteristics. Beyond MADS-box genes, other transcription factors were analyzed to explore the genetic basis of floral development. While wild and domesticated cotton showed similar expression patterns for key genes, domesticated cotton exhibited significantly higher expression in carpels compared to wild cotton, which aligns with the increased number of ovules in the carpels of domesticated cotton. Functional enrichment analysis highlighted organ-specific roles: genes upregulated in bracts were enriched for photosynthesis-related GO terms, while diverse functions were enriched in floral organs, supporting their respective functions. Notably, A class genes were not significantly expressed in petals, deviating from the ABCDE model, which warrants further analysis. Lastly, the ABCDE class genes exhibited differential homoeolog expression bias toward each subgenome between two accessions, suggesting that the domestication process has influenced homoeolog utilization despite functional constraints in floral organogenesis.

Research Progress on Gene Regulation of Plant Floral Organogenesis

Flowers, serving as the reproductive structures of angiosperms, perform an integral role in plant biology and are fundamental to understanding plant evolution and taxonomy. The growth and organogenesis of flowers are driven by numerous factors, such as external environmental conditions and internal physiological processes, resulting in diverse traits across species or even within the same species. Among these factors, genes play a central role, governing the entire developmental process. The regulation of floral genesis by these genes has become a significant focus of research. In the AE model of floral development, the five structural whorls (calyx, corolla, stamens, pistils, and ovules) are controlled by five groups of genes: A, B, C, D, and E. These genes interact to give rise to a complex control system that governs the floral organsgenesis. The activation or suppression of specific gene categories results in structural modifications to floral organs, with variations observed across different species. The present article examines the regulatory roles of key genes, including genes within the MADS-box and AP2/ERF gene clusters, such as AP1, AP2, AP3, AG, STK, SHP, SEP, PI, and AGL6, as well as other genes, like NAP, SPL, TGA, PAN, and WOX, in shaping floral organ genesis. In addition, it analyzes the molecular-level effects of these genes on floral organ formation. The findings offer a deeper understanding of the genetic governance of floral organ genesis across plant species.

Evolution and Function of MADS-Box Transcription Factors in Plants

The MADS-box transcription factor (TF) gene family is pivotal in various aspects of plant biology, particularly in growth, development, and environmental adaptation. It comprises Type I and Type II categories, with the MIKC-type subgroups playing a crucial role in regulating genes essential for both the vegetative and reproductive stages of plant life. Notably, MADS-box proteins can influence processes such as flowering, fruit ripening, and stress tolerance. Here, we provide a comprehensive overview of the structural features, evolutionary lineage, multifaceted functions, and the role of MADS-box TFs in responding to biotic and abiotic stresses. We particularly emphasize their implications for crop enhancement, especially in light of recent advances in understanding the impact on sugarcane (Saccharum spp.), a vital tropical crop. By consolidating cutting-edge findings, we highlight potential avenues for expanding our knowledge base and enhancing the genetic traits of sugarcane through functional genomics and advanced breeding techniques. This review underscores the significance of MADS-box TFs in achieving improved yields and stress resilience in agricultural contexts, positioning them as promising targets for future research in crop science.

The overall regulatory network and contributions of ABC(D)E model genes in yellowhorn flower development

BACKGROUND

Single flowers and double flowers, exhibiting distinct flower morphologies, developmental process and regulatory networks, have garnered significant attention recently. In yellowhorn (Xanthoceras sorbifolium), the cause of double flower variation has been elucidated, yet the differences in regulatory networks between single and double flowers remain unexplored.

RESULT

Here, we investigated transcriptional changes underlying flower development among yellowhorn single- and double-flowered-trees. Transcriptome analysis and weighted gene co-expression network analysis (WGCNA) were applied to identify key genes and reveal the characteristics of single and double flower traits. The involvement of development-specific and flower-type-specific DEGs related to hormone signaling, metabolism, growth and development was identified, and ABC(D)E model genes were found to be closely associated with floral organ development. Overexpression of yellowhorn ABC(D)E model genes in Arabidopsis demonstrated their roles in floral organ development, and the interactions between different pairs of genes were also validated by yeast two-hybrid (Y2H) experiments.

CONCLUSION

Therefore we elucidated differences between yellowhorn single and double flower development, highlighting the roles of yellowhorn ABC(D)E model genes in controlling flower structures, which not only enriches the understanding of yellowhorn flower researches, but also provides insights for studying flower development in other woody species.

Rice BARENTSZ genes are required to maintain floral developmental stability against temperature fluctuations

BARENTSZ (BTZ), a core component of the exon junction complex, regulates diverse developmental processes in animals. However, its evolutionary and developmental roles in plants remain elusive. Here, we revealed that three groups of paralogous BTZ genes existed in Poaceae, and Group 2 underwent loss-of-function mutations during evolution. They showed surprisingly low (~33%) sequence identities, implying functional divergence. Two genes retained in rice, OsBTZ1 and OsBTZ3, were edited; however, the resultant osbtz1 and osbtz3 mutants showed similar floral morphological and functional defects at a low frequency. When growing under low-temperature conditions, developmental abnormalities became pronounced, and new floral variations were induced. In particular, stamen and carpel functionality was impaired in these rice btz mutants. The double-gene mutant osbtz1/3 shared these floral defects with an increased frequency, which was further induced under low-temperature conditions. OsBTZs interacted with OsMADS7 and OsMADS8, and the floral expressions of the OsTGA10 and MADS-box genes were correlatively altered in these osbtz mutants and responded to low-temperature treatment. These novel findings demonstrate that two highly diverged OsBTZs are required to maintain floral developmental stability under low-temperature conditions, and play an integral role in male and female fertility, thus providing new insights into the indispensable roles of BTZ genes in plant development and adaptive evolution.

The gynostemium: More than the sum of its parts with emerging floral complexities

Partial or complete floral organ fusion, which occurs in most angiosperm lineages, promotes integration of whorls leading to specialization and complexity. One of the most remarkable floral organ fusions occurs in the gynostemium, a highly specialized structure formed by the congenital fusion of the androecium and the upper portion of the gynoecium. Here we review the gynostemia evolution across flowering plants, the morphological requirements for the synorganization of the two fertile floral whorls, and the molecular basis most likely responsible for such intimate fusion process.

Identification of candidate genes associated with double flowers via integrating BSA-seq and RNA-seq in Brassica napus

As a Brassica crop, Brassica napus typically has single flowers that contain four petals. The double-flower phenotype of rapeseed has been a desirable trait in China because of its potential commercial value in ornamental tourism. However, few double-flowered germplasms have been documented in B. napus, and knowledge of the underlying genes is limited. Here, B. napus D376 was characterized as a double-flowered strain that presented an average of 10.92 ± 1.40 petals and other normal floral organs. F1, F2 and BC1 populations were constructed by crossing D376 with a single-flowered line reciprocally. Genetic analysis revealed that the double-flower trait was a recessive trait controlled by multiple genes. To identify the key genes controlling the double-flower trait, bulk segregant analysis sequencing (BSA-seq) and RNA-seq analyses were conducted on F2 individual bulks with opposite extreme phenotypes. Through BSA-seq, one candidate interval was mapped at the region of chromosome C05: 14.56-16.17 Mb. GO and KEGG enrichment analyses revealed that the DEGs were significantly enriched in carbohydrate metabolic processes, notably starch and sucrose metabolism. Interestingly, five and thirty-six DEGs associated with floral development were significantly up- and down-regulated, respectively, in the double-flowered plants. A combined analysis of BSA-seq and RNA-seq data revealed that five genes were candidates associated with the double flower trait, and BnaC05.ERS2 was the most promising gene. These findings provide novel insights into the breeding of double-flowered varieties and lay a theoretical foundation for unveiling the molecular mechanisms of floral development in B. napus.

Petal segmentation in CT images based on divide-and-conquer strategy

Manual segmentation of the petals of flower computed tomography (CT) images is time-consuming and labor-intensive because the flower has many petals. In this study, we aim to obtain a three-dimensional (3D) structure of Camellia japonica flowers and propose a petal segmentation method using computer vision techniques. Petal segmentation on the slice images fails by simply applying the segmentation methods because the shape of the petals in CT images differs from that of the objects targeted by the latest instance segmentation methods. To overcome these challenges, we crop two-dimensional (2D) long rectangles from each slice image and apply the segmentation method to segment the petals on the images. Thanks to cropping, it is easier to segment the shape of the petals in the cropped images using the segmentation methods. We can also use the latest segmentation method for the task because the number of images used for training is augmented by cropping. Subsequently, the results are integrated into 3D to obtain 3D segmentation volume data. The experimental results show that the proposed method can segment petals on slice images with higher accuracy than the method without cropping. The 3D segmentation results were also obtained and visualized successfully.

'Organ'ising Floral Organ Development

Flowers are plant structures characteristic of the phylum Angiosperms composed of organs thought to have emerged from homologous structures to leaves in order to specialize in a distinctive function: reproduction. Symmetric shapes, colours, and scents all play important functional roles in flower biology. The evolution of flower symmetry and the morphology of individual flower parts (sepals, petals, stamens, and carpels) has significantly contributed to the diversity of reproductive strategies across flowering plant species. This diversity facilitates attractiveness for pollination, protection of gametes, efficient fertilization, and seed production. Symmetry, the establishment of body axes, and fate determination are tightly linked. The complex genetic networks underlying the establishment of organ, tissue, and cellular identity, as well as the growth regulators acting across the body axes, are steadily being elucidated in the field. In this review, we summarise the wealth of research already at our fingertips to begin weaving together how separate processes involved in specifying organ identity within the flower may interact, providing a functional perspective on how identity determination and axial regulation may be coordinated to inform symmetrical floral organ structures.

Molecular and genetic regulation of petal number variation

Floral forms with an increased number of petals, also known as double-flower phenotypes, have been selected and conserved in many domesticated plants, particularly in ornamentals, because of their great economic value. The molecular and genetic mechanisms that control this trait are therefore of great interest, not only for scientists, but also for breeders. In this review, we summarize current knowledge of the gene regulatory networks of flower initiation and development and known mutations that lead to variation of petal number in many species. In addition to the well-accepted miR172/AP2-like module, for which many questions remain unanswered, we also discuss other pathways in which mutations also lead to the formation of extra petals, such as those involved in meristem maintenance, hormone signalling, epigenetic regulation, and responses to environmental signals. We discuss how the concept of 'natural mutants' and recent advances in genomics and genome editing make it possible to explore the molecular mechanisms underlying double-flower formation, and how such knowledge could contribute to the future breeding and selection of this trait in more crops.