Validation and Optimization of PURE Ribosome Display for Screening Synthetic Nanobody Libraries

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

PURE (Protein synthesis Using Recombinant Elements), an ideal system for ribosome display, has been successfully used for nanobody selection. However, its limitations in nanobody selection, especially for synthetic nanobody libraries, have not been clearly elucidated, thereby restricting its utilization.

METHODS

The PURE ribosome display selection process was closely monitored using RNA agarose gel electrophoresis to assess the presence of mRNA molecules in each fraction, including the flow-through, washing, and elution fractions. Additionally, a real-time validation method for monitoring each biopanning round was implemented, ensuring the successful enrichment of target protein-specific binders. The selection process was further optimized by introducing a target protein elution step prior to the EDTA-mediated disassembly, as well as by altering the immobilization surfaces. Finally, the efficiency of PURE ribosome display was enhanced by replacing the spacer gene.

RESULTS

The efficiency of PURE ribosome display was merely 4% with an unfavourable spacer gene. Using this spacer gene, EGFP- and human fatty acid-binding protein 4-specific nanobodies from a synthetic nanobody library were we successfully identified through optimizing the selection process. Choosing a spacer gene less prone to secondary structure formation increased significantly its efficiency in displaying synthetic nanobody libraries.

CONCLUSIONS

Implementing a target protein elution step prior to EDTA-mediated disassembly and modifying the immobilization surfaces effectively increase selection efficiency. For PURE ribosome display, efficiency was further improved using a suitable spacer gene, enabling the display of large libraries.

A synthetic heavy chain variable domain antibody library (VHL) provides highly functional antibodies with favorable developability

Synthetic antibody libraries have been developed as an efficient source for the discovery of the heavy chain variable (VH) domain, which exhibits low immunogenicity, high tissue penetration, and diverse binding epitopes in therapeutic biopharmaceuticals. In this study, the human IGHV3-23*04 germline gene was chosen as the scaffold with a high expression level and favorable thermal stability. Amino acid diversity was introduced into the complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) to exclude potential sequence liabilities. A library containing 2.6 × 1011 independent clones was successfully constructed. The receptor-binding domain (RBD) of the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein, interleukin-17A (IL17A), B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA), and G-protein coupled receptor family C group 5 member D (GPRC5D) were used as target antigens to screen and identify VHs. In each case, Thirty-one to fifty-five VHs were screened out. The VH-Fc antibodies showed superior affinities (as high as 4.6 nM) to the corresponding antigens but did not bind to antigen-irrelevant cell CHO-S. Furthermore, the anti-RBD and anti-IL17A VH-Fc antibodies showed strong functional activity in the receptor-blocking assays. The VH-Fc antibodies from the synthetic library exhibited favorable developability (thermal stability, colloidal stability, hydrophilicity, anti-aggregation ability, and no interaction with human IgGs). We demonstrated that high-affinity and highly functional VH domain antibodies were generated from the rationally designed library with desired physicochemical properties. This approach is generally universal to target any antigen and has significant potential to accelerate candidate selection.

Epitope-directed selection of GPCR nanobody ligands with evolvable function

Antibodies have the potential to target G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) with high receptor, cellular, and tissue selectivity; however, few antibody ligands for GPCRs exist. Here, we describe a generalizable selection method to enrich for GPCR ligands from a synthetic camelid antibody fragment (nanobody) library. Our strategy yielded multiple nanobody ligands for the angiotensin II type I receptor (AT1R), a prototypical GPCR and important drug target. We found that nanobodies readily act as allosteric modulators, encoding selectivity for both the receptor and chemical features of GPCR ligands. We then used structure-guided design to convert two nanobodies from allosteric ligands to competitive AT1R inhibitors through simple mutations. This work demonstrates that nanobodies can encode multiple pharmacological behaviors and have great potential as evolvable scaffolds for the development of next-generation GPCR therapeutics.

Development of novel humanized VHH synthetic libraries based on physicochemical analyses

Due to the high affinity and specificity of antibodies toward antigens, various antibody-based applications have been developed. Recently, variable antigen-binding domains of heavy-chain antibodies (VHH) have become an attractive alternative to conventional fragment antibodies due to their unique molecular characteristics. As an antibody-generating strategy, synthetic VHH libraries (including humanized VHH libraries) have been developed using distinct strategies to constrain the diversity of amino acid sequences. In this study, we designed and constructed several novel synthetic humanized VHH libraries based on biophysical analyses conducted using the complementarity determining region-grafting method and comprehensive sequence analyses of VHHs deposited in the protein data bank. We obtained VHHs from the libraries, and hit clones exhibited considerable thermal stability. We also found that VHHs from distinct libraries tended to have different epitopes. Based on our results, we propose a strategy for generating humanized VHHs with distinct epitopes toward various antigens by utilizing our library combinations.

Sequence-based design and construction of synthetic nanobody library

Nanobody (Nb), the smallest antibody fragments known to bind antigens, is now widely applied to various studies, including protein structure analysis, bioassay, diagnosis, and biomedicine. The traditional approach to generating specific nanobodies involves animal immunization which is time-consuming and expensive. As the understanding of the antibody repertoire accumulation, the synthetic library, which is devoid of animals, has attracted attention widely in recent years. Here, we describe a synthetic phage display library (S-Library), designed based on the systematic analysis of the next-generation sequencing (NGS) of nanobody repertoire. The library consists of a single highly conserved scaffold (IGHV3S65*01-IGHJ4*01) and complementary determining regions of constrained diversity. The S-Library containing 2.19 × 108 independent clones was constructed by the one-step assembly and rapid electro-transformation. The S-Library was screened against various targets (Nb G8, fusion protein of Nb G8 and green fluorescent protein, bovine serum albumin, ovalbumin, and acetylcholinesterase). In comparison, a naïve library (N-Library) from the source of 13 healthy animals was constructed and screened against the same targets as the S-Library. Binders were isolated from both S-Library and N-Library. The dynamic affinity was evaluated by the biolayer interferometry. The data confirms that the feature of the Nb repertoire is conducive to reducing the complexity of library design, thus allowing the S-Library to be built on conventional reagents and primers.

Development of a Human B7-H3-Specific Antibody with Activity against Colorectal Cancer Cells through a Synthetic Nanobody Library

Nanobodies have emerged as promising tools in biomedicine due to their single-chain structure and inherent stability. They generally have convex paratopes, which potentially prefer different epitope sites in an antigen compared to traditional antibodies. In this study, a synthetic phage display nanobody library was constructed and used to identify nanobodies targeting a tumor-associated antigen, the human B7-H3 protein. Combining next-generation sequencing and single-clone validation, two nanobodies were identified to specifically bind B7-H3 with medium nanomolar affinities. Further characterization revealed that these two clones targeted a different epitope compared to known B7-H3-specific antibodies, which have been explored in clinical trials. Furthermore, one of the clones, dubbed as A6, exhibited potent antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) against a colorectal cancer cell line with an EC50 of 0.67 nM, upon conversion to an Fc-enhanced IgG format. These findings underscore a cost-effective strategy that bypasses the lengthy immunization process, offering potential rapid access to nanobodies targeting unexplored antigenic sites.

Design and Construction of a Synthetic Nanobody Library: Testing Its Potential with a Single Selection Round Strategy

Nanobodies (Nbs) are single domain antibody fragments derived from heavy-chain antibodies found in members of the Camelidae family. They have become a relevant class of biomolecules for many different applications because of several important advantages such as their small size, high solubility and stability, and low production costs. On the other hand, synthetic Nb libraries are emerging as an attractive alternative to animal immunization for the selection of antigen-specific Nbs. Here, we present the design and construction of a new synthetic nanobody library using the phage display technology, following a structure-based approach in which the three hypervariable loops were subjected to position-specific randomization schemes. The constructed library has a clonal diversity of 10⁸ and an amino acid variability that matches the codon distribution set by design at each randomized position. We have explored the capabilities of the new library by selecting nanobodies specific for three antigens: vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and the glycoprotein complex (GnGc) of Andes virus. To test the potential of the library to yield a variety of antigen-specific Nbs, we introduced a biopanning strategy consisting of a single selection round using stringent conditions. Using this approach, we obtained several binders for each of the target antigens. The constructed library represents a promising nanobody source for different applications.

Studying the characteristics of nanobody CDR regions based on sequence analysis in combination with 3D structures

Background

Single-domain antibodies or nanobodies have recently attracted much attention in research and applications because of their great potential and advantage over conventional antibodies. However, isolation of candidate nanobodies in the lab has been costly and time-consuming. Screening of leading nanobody candidates through synthetic libraries is a promising alternative, but it requires prior knowledge to control the diversity of the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) while still maintaining functionality. In this work, we identified sequence characteristics that could contribute to nanobody functionality by analyzing three datasets, CDR1, CDR2, and CDR3.

Results

By classification of amino acids based on physicochemical properties, we found that two different amino acid groups were sufficient for CDRs. The nonpolar group accounted for half of the total amino acid composition in these sequences. Observation of the highest occurrence of each amino acid revealed that the usage of some important amino acids such as tyrosine and serine was highly correlated with the length of the CDR3. Amino acid repeat motifs were also under-represented and highly restricted as 3-mers. Inspecting the crystallographic data also demonstrated conservation in structural coordinates of dominant amino acids such as methionine, isoleucine, valine, threonine, and tyrosine and certain positions in the CDR1, CDR2, and CDR3 sequences.

Conclusions

We identified sequence characteristics that contributed to functional nanobodies including amino acid groups, the occurrence of each kind of amino acids, and repeat patterns. These results provide a simple set of rules to make it easier to generate desired candidates by computational means; also, they can be used as a reference to evaluate synthetic nanobodies.

Structure-based design and construction of a synthetic phage display nanobody library

OBJECTIVE

To design and construct a new synthetic nanobody library using a structure-based approach that seeks to maintain high protein stability and increase the number of functional variants within the combinatorial space of mutations.

RESULTS

Synthetic nanobody (Nb) libraries are emerging as an attractive alternative to animal immunization for the selection of stable, high affinity Nbs. Two key features define a synthetic Nb library: framework selection and CDR design. We selected the universal VHH framework from the cAbBCII10 Nb. CDR1 and CDR2 were designed with the same fixed length as in cAbBCII10, while for CDR3 we chose a 14-long loop, which creates a convex binding site topology. Based on the analysis of the cAbBCII10 crystal structure, we carefully selected the positions to be randomized and tailored the codon usage at each position, keeping at particular places amino acids that guarantee stability, favoring properties like polarity at solvent-exposed positions and avoiding destabilizing amino acids. Gene synthesis and library construction were carried out by GenScript, using our own phagemid vector. The constructed library has an estimated size of 1.75 × 108. NGS showed that the amino acid diversity and frequency at each randomized position are the expected from the codon usage.

Structural Insights into the Design of Synthetic Nanobody Libraries

Single domain antibodies from camelids, or nanobodies, are a unique class of antibody fragments with several advantageous characteristics: small monomeric size, high stability and solubility and easy tailoring for multiple applications. Nanobodies are gaining increasing acceptance as diagnostic tools and promising therapeutic agents in cancer and other diseases. While most nanobodies are obtained from immunized animals of the camelid family, a few synthetic nanobody libraries constructed in recent years have shown the capability of generating high quality nanobodies in terms of affinity and stability. Since this synthetic approach has important advantages over the use of animals, the recent advances are indeed encouraging. Here we review over a dozen synthetic nanobody libraries reported so far and discuss the different approaches followed in their construction and validation, with an emphasis on framework and hypervariable loop design as critical issues defining their potential as high-class nanobody sources.

Easily Established and Multifunctional Synthetic Nanobody Libraries as Research Tools

Nanobodies, or VHHs, refer to the antigen-binding domain of heavy-chain antibodies (HCAbs) from camelids. They have been widely used as research tools for protein purification and structure determination due to their small size, high specificity, and high stability, overcoming limitations with conventional antibody fragments. However, animal immunization and subsequent retrieval of antigen-specific nanobodies are expensive and complicated. Construction of synthetic nanobody libraries using DNA oligonucleotides is a cost-effective alternative for immunization libraries and shows great potential in identifying antigen-specific or even conformation-specific nanobodies. This review summarizes and analyses synthetic nanobody libraries in the current literature, including library design and biopanning methods, and further discusses applications of antigen-specific nanobodies obtained from synthetic libraries to research.

INDI-integrated nanobody database for immunoinformatics

Nanobodies, a subclass of antibodies found in camelids, are versatile molecular binding scaffolds composed of a single polypeptide chain. The small size of nanobodies bestows multiple therapeutic advantages (stability, tumor penetration) with the first therapeutic approval in 2018 cementing the clinical viability of this format. Structured data and sequence information of nanobodies will enable the accelerated clinical development of nanobody-based therapeutics. Though the nanobody sequence and structure data are deposited in the public domain at an accelerating pace, the heterogeneity of sources and lack of standardization hampers reliable harvesting of nanobody information. We address this issue by creating the Integrated Database of Nanobodies for Immunoinformatics (INDI, http://naturalantibody.com/nanobodies). INDI collates nanobodies from all the major public outlets of biological sequences: patents, GenBank, next-generation sequencing repositories, structures and scientific publications. We equip INDI with powerful nanobody-specific sequence and text search facilitating access to >11 million nanobody sequences. INDI should facilitate development of novel nanobody-specific computational protocols helping to deliver on the therapeutic promise of this drug format.

SYNBIP: synthetic binding proteins for research, diagnosis and therapy

The success of protein engineering and design has extensively expanded the protein space, which presents a promising strategy for creating next-generation proteins of diverse functions. Among these proteins, the synthetic binding proteins (SBPs) are smaller, more stable, less immunogenic, and better of tissue penetration than others, which make the SBP-related data attracting extensive interest from worldwide scientists. However, no database has been developed to systematically provide the valuable information of SBPs yet. In this study, a database named ‘Synthetic Binding Proteins for Research, Diagnosis, and Therapy (SYNBIP)’ was thus introduced. This database is unique in (a) comprehensively describing thousands of SBPs from the perspectives of scaffolds, biophysical & functional properties, etc.; (b) panoramically illustrating the binding targets & the broad application of each SBP and (c) enabling a similarity search against the sequences of all SBPs and their binding targets. Since SBP is a human-made protein that has not been found in nature, the discovery of novel SBPs relied heavily on experimental protein engineering and could be greatly facilitated by in-silico studies (such as AI and computational modeling). Thus, the data provided in SYNBIP could lay a solid foundation for the future development of novel SBPs. The SYNBIP is accessible without login requirement at both official (https://idrblab.org/synbip/) and mirror (http://synbip.idrblab.net/) sites.

CDR1 Composition Can Affect Nanobody Recombinant Expression Yields

The isolation of nanobodies from pre-immune libraries by means of biopanning is a straightforward process. Nevertheless, the recovered candidates often require optimization to improve some of their biophysical characteristics. In principle, CDRs are not mutated because they are likely to be part of the antibody paratope, but in this work, we describe a mutagenesis strategy that specifically addresses CDR1. Its sequence was identified as an instability hot spot by the PROSS program, and the available structural information indicated that four CDR1 residues bound directly to the antigen. We therefore modified the loop flexibility with the addition of an extra glycine rather than by mutating single amino acids. This approach significantly increased the nanobody yields but traded-off with moderate affinity loss. Accurate modeling coupled with atomistic molecular dynamics simulations enabled the modifications induced by the glycine insertion and the rationale behind the engineering design to be described in detail.