Rabbit antisera to enterobacteriaceae isolated from HLA-B27 positive patients with ankylosing spondylitis (AS) are lytic for the mononuclear cells of AS patients

HLA-B27 associated spondyloarthropathy, an autoimmune disease based on crossreactivity between bacteria and HLA-B27?

Most autoimmune diseases are associated with certain HLA types. Therefore, spondyloarthropathies (SpA) strongly associated with HLA-B27, are also often classified as autoimmune diseases. This study questions whether SpA indeed fulfils the criteria of an autoimmune disease. The Medline database was searched for all reports between 1966 and April 1998 on the presence of autoimmune reactivity in SpA patients. This search yielded 45 articles on this subject. Only eight articles study T cell reactivity. Twelve reports were found on the assessment of antibodies crossreacting between bacteria and HLA-B27. In the 45 studies demonstrating autoimmune reactions in SpA patients proper controls matched for HLA-B27, sex and age were nearly always lacking. Therefore, it is concluded that the frequency of increased autoreactivity in sera from patients and controls is not significantly different, and that this lack of autoreactivity does not justify classification of SpA as an autoimmune disease. As crossreactive antibodies against bacteria and HLA-B27 were equally present in sera from patients and controls, the pathogenetic significance of molecular mimicry between various bacteria and HLA-B27 is questionable. Furthermore, the regions of the B27 molecule that are supposed to be crossreactive with bacteria, differ in one or more amino acids among the distinct B27 subtypes. Although these differences strongly influence the binding of antibodies to the B27 molecule, there was no relation between the degree of crossreactivity of certain subtypes and the association of these subtypes with SpA. In conclusion, there is no evident proof that SpA is an autoimmune disease attributable to crossreactivity between bacteria and HLA-B27.

Dysfunction of HLA-B27

Every HLA antigen, as defined by the WHO-HLA Nomenclature, is unique. The major function of these molecules is to present antigen-peptides to the T-cell receptor, thereby contributing to the immunological defence mechanism. This function is regulated for each MHC antigen by its unique structure, with the peptide-binding pockets of the three-dimensional groove of the corresponding molecules playing the critical role. However, HLA-B27 is special by virtue of its disease association(s). Various aspects which might provide an explanation for--or at least a clue to an understanding of the specific role of--B27 in its disease associations are reviewed. Since it appears that there are no published experimental data which would support either of the alternative hypothetical possibilities, the bulk of current theories must therefore be purely speculative. The only lead to a better understanding of the function of B27 in disease associations is the postinfectious reactive arthritis. If it is the B27 molecule itself which is involved, further in vivo work on B27 transgenic animals might help solve this problem with its numerous unknown factors.

Trial and error in producing ankylosing-spondylitis-selective antisera according to Andrew Geczy

Geczy found that rabbit sera raised against Klebsiella strain K43 cross-reacted with the cells from HLA-B27 positive patients with ankylosing spondylitis (AS). Other laboratories failed to reproduce these results. After a series of unsuccessful attempts, however, we managed to prepare one selective antiserum, using E. coli, isolated from a Dutch Bechterew patient, in offspring of rabbits Geczy sent us. Ever since we obtained irreproducible results only. This paper reports about the many attempts we have made to produce a discriminating antiserum for use in a combined vital stain and dye-exclusion assay.

Theoretical models to explain the association of HLA-B27 with ankylosing spondylitis

A critical examination of the five different models proposed to explain the "AS-B27" problem, has demonstrated, that two of these, the two-gene theory and the plasmid theory are no longer considered to provide satisfactory explanations of the phenomena. The remaining three theories are molecular mimicry, chemotaxis hypothesis and the receptor theory. It is difficult at this stage to decide which of these three models provides the best solution to the "AS-B27" problem, but a majority of research workers favour the receptor theory.