Sex-related differences within sleep-wake dynamics, cataplexy, and EEG fast-delta power in a narcolepsy mouse model

Sex effect on time to diagnosis and clinical features of narcolepsy type 1 and 2

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Sex influences sleep through physiological differences and impacts the clinical presentation and quality of life in patients with sleep disorders. However, there is a paucity of evidence regarding differences between men and women affected by narcolepsy. This study aimed to explore the sex-based dissimilarities in time to diagnosis and clinical features in narcolepsy.

METHODS

This retrospective observational study included adult patients with narcolepsy type 1 (NT1) and type 2 (NT2). Clinical, polysomnographic, and biofluid parameters were compared between men and women.

RESULTS

The study analyzed 42 patients: 27 with NT1 (64.3 %) and 15 with NT2 (35.7 %). Among these, 18 were male (42.9 %; mean age 34.72 ± 12.89 years) and 24 were female (57.1 %; mean age 37.96 ± 13.2 years). No significant sex differences were observed in the age at onset of symptoms. Notably, females had significantly longer diagnostic delay compared to males (p = 0.04) and a higher rate of misdiagnosis before receiving the diagnosis of narcolepsy (p < 0.001). Male patients exhibited significantly longer stage 2 of Non-REM sleep percentage compared to females patients (p = 0.024). There were no significant differences in psychiatric comorbidities (p = 0.30).

CONCLUSIONS

Women with narcolepsy experience longer time to obtain the correct diagnosis and are more frequently misdiagnosed with other disorders compared to men. The present findings highlight a potential sex-based disparity in diagnostic practices that may negatively impact the well-being of women with narcolepsy, as their symptoms are more commonly misdiagnosed.

Probability estimation of narcolepsy type 1 in DTA mice using unlabeled EEG and EMG data

The manual evaluation of mouse sleep studies is labor-intensive and time-consuming. Although several approaches for automatic sleep stage classification have been proposed, no automatic pipeline for detecting a specific mouse phenotype has yet been developed. Here, we present a fully automated pipeline for estimating the probability of Narcolepsy Type 1 (NT1) in the hypocretin-tTA;TetO-Diphteria toxin A (DTA) mouse model using unlabeled electroencephalographic (EEG) and electromyographic (EMG) data. The pipeline is divided into three modules: (1) automatic sleep stage classification, (2) feature extraction, and (3) phenotype classification. We trained two automatic sleep stage classifiers, UsleepEEG and UsleepEMG, using data from 83 wild-type (WT) mice. We next computed features such as EEG spectral power bands, EMG root mean square, and bout metrics from 11 WT and 19 DTA mice. The features were used to train an L1-penalized logistic regression classifier in a Leave-One-Subject-Out approach, achieving an accuracy of 97%. Finally, we validated the pipeline in a held-out dataset of EEG/EMG recordings at four different timepoints during disease development in seven DTA mice, finding that the pipeline captured disease progression in all mice. While our pipeline generalizes well to data from other laboratories, it is sensitive to artifacts, which should be considered in its application. With this study, we present a pipeline that facilitates a fast assessment of NT1 probability in the DTA model and thus can accelerate large-scale evaluations of NT1 treatments.

Ageing-related modification of sleep and breathing in orexin-knockout narcoleptic mice

Narcolepsy type-1 (NT1) is a lifelong sleep disease, characterised by impairment of the orexinergic system, with a typical onset during adolescence and young adulthood. Since the wake-sleep cycle physiologically changes with ageing, this study aims to compare sleep patterns between orexin-knockout (KO) and wild type (WT) control mice at different ages. Four groups of age-matched female KO and WT mice (16 weeks of age: 8 KO-YO and 9 WT-YO mice; 87 weeks of age: 13 KO-OLD and 12 WT-OLD mice) were implanted with electrodes for discriminating wakefulness, rapid-eye-movement sleep (REMS), and non-REMS (NREMS). Mice were recorded for 48 h in their home cages and for 7 more hours into a plethysmographic chamber to characterise their sleep-breathing pattern. Regardless of orexin deficiency, OLD mice spent less time awake and had fragmentation of this behavioural state showing more bouts of shorter length than YO mice. OLD mice also had more NREMS bouts and less frequent NREMS apneas than YO mice. Regardless of age, KO mice showed cataplexy-like episodes and shorter REMS latency than WT controls and had a faster breathing rate and an increased minute ventilation during REMS. KO mice also had more wakefulness, NREMS and REMS bouts, and a shorter mean length of wakefulness bouts than WT controls. Our experiment indicated that the lack of orexins as well as ageing importantly modulate the sleep and breathing phenotype in mice. The narcoleptic phenotype caused by orexin deficiency in female mice was substantially preserved with ageing.

Sex disparities in clinical features and burden of narcolepsy type 1

To investigate potential sex-related differences in patients with narcolepsy type 1, we carried out an analysis of baseline data from 93 women and 89 men with narcolepsy type 1 who participated in the TElemedicine for NARcolepsy (TENAR) trial. The following data were considered: sociodemographics; diagnostic (disease history, polysomnography, orexin, human leukocyte antigen) and clinical features, including sleepiness (Epworth Sleepiness Scale), cataplexy and other narcolepsy symptoms; disease severity (Narcolepsy Severity Scale); pharmacological treatment; depressive symptoms (Beck Depression Inventory); and self-reported relevance of eight narcolepsy-related issues. We found that, compared with men, significantly more women reported automatic behaviours (55.4% versus 40%) and had higher Epworth Sleepiness Scale (median 10 versus 9) and Beck Depression Inventory scores (median 10.5 versus 5), and there was a trend for a higher Narcolepsy Severity Scale total score in women (median 19 versus 18, p = 0.057). More women than men were officially recognized as having a disability (38% versus 22.5%) and considered 5/8 narcolepsy-related issues investigated as a relevant problem. More severe sleepiness and a greater narcolepsy-related burden in women could mirror sex differences present in the general population, or may be related to suboptimal management of narcolepsy type 1 or to more severe depressive symptoms in women. Future studies and guidelines should address these aspects.

Sex-dimorphic functions of orexin in neuropsychiatric disorders

The orexin system regulates a variety of physiological functions, including the sleep-wake cycle, addiction, foraging behavior, stress and cognitive functioning. Orexin levels in central and peripheral are related to the pathogenesis of many diseases, most notably the narcolepsy, eating disorders, stress-related psychiatric disorders, and neurodegenerative diseases. Recently, it has been reported that the orexin system is distinctly sexually dimorphic, and is strongly associated with neuropsychiatric disorders. In this review, we analyzed advancements in the sex differences in the orexin system and their connection to psychoneurological conditions. Considering the scarcity of research in this domain, more research is imperative to reveal the underlying mechanisms.

Gender medicine and sleep disorders: from basic science to clinical research

Several pivotal differences in sleep and sleep disorders are recognized between women and men. This is not only due to changes in hormonal balance during women's reproductive life, such as in pregnancy and menopause. Women are more likely to report insomnia and non-specific symptoms of apneas, such as fatigue or mood disturbance, compared to men. Thus, it is important for clinicians and researchers to take sex and gender differences into account when addressing sleep disorders in order to acknowledge the biology unique to women. We present a narrative review that delves into the primary sleep disorders, starting from basic science, to explore the impact of gender differences on sleep and the current status of research on women's sleep health.

Non-invasive detection of narcolepsy type I phenotypical features and disease progression by continuous home-cage monitoring of activity in two mouse models: the HCRT-KO and DTA model

Narcolepsy type 1 (NT1) is a neurological disorder caused by disruption of hypocretin (HCRT; or orexin) neurotransmission leading to fragmented sleep/wake states, excessive daytime sleepiness, and cataplexy (abrupt muscle atonia during wakefulness). Electroencephalography and electromyography (EEG/EMG) monitoring is the gold standard to assess NT1 phenotypical features in both humans and mice. Here, we evaluated the digital ventilated home-cage (DVC®) activity system as an alternative to detect NT1 features in two NT1 mouse models: the genetic HCRT-knockout (-KO) model, and the inducible HCRT neuron-ablation hcrt-tTA;TetO-DTA (DTA) model, including both sexes. NT1 mice exhibited an altered dark phase activity profile and increased state transitions, compared to the wild-type (WT) phenotype. An inability to sustain activity periods >40 min represented a robust activity-based NT1 biomarker. These features were observable within the first weeks of HCRT neuron degeneration in DTA mice. We also created a nest-identification algorithm to differentiate between inactivity and activity, inside and outside the nest as a sleep and wake proxy, respectively, showing significant correlations with EEG/EMG-assessed sleep/wake behavior. Lastly, we tested the sensitivity of the activity system to detect behavioral changes in response to interventions such as repeated saline injection and chocolate. Surprisingly, daily consecutive saline injections significantly reduced activity and increased nest time of HCRT-WT mice. Chocolate increased total activity in all mice, and increased the frequency of short out-of-nest inactivity episodes in HCRT-KO mice. We conclude that the DVC® system provides a useful tool for non-invasive monitoring of NT1 phenotypical features, and has the potential to monitor drug effects in NT1 mice.

Peripheral vs. core body temperature as hypocretin/orexin neurons degenerate: Exercise mitigates increased heat loss

Hypocretins/Orexins (Hcrt/Ox) are hypothalamic neuropeptides implicated in diverse functions, including body temperature regulation through modulation of sympathetic vasoconstrictor tone. In the current study, we measured subcutaneous (Tsc) and core (Tb) body temperature as well as activity in a conditional transgenic mouse strain that allows the inducible ablation of Hcrt/Ox-containing neurons by removal of doxycycline (DOX) from their diet (orexin-DTA mice). Measurements were made during a baseline, when mice were being maintained on food containing DOX, and over 42 days while the mice were fed normal chow which resulted in Hcrt/Ox neuron degeneration. The home cages of the orexin-DTA mice were equipped with running wheels that were either locked or unlocked. In the presence of a locked running wheel, Tsc progressively decreased on days 28 and 42 in the DOX(-) condition, primarily during the dark phase (the major active period for rodents). This nocturnal reduction in Tsc was mitigated when mice had access to unlocked running wheels. In contrast to Tsc, Tb was largely maintained until day 42 in the DOX(-) condition even when the running wheel was locked. Acute changes in both Tsc and Tb were observed preceding, during, and following cataplexy. Our results suggest that ablation of Hcrt/Ox-containing neurons results in elevated heat loss, likely through reduced sympathetic vasoconstrictor tone, and that exercise may have some therapeutic benefit to patients with narcolepsy, a disorder caused by Hcrt/Ox deficiency. Acute changes in body temperature may facilitate prediction of cataplexy onset and lead to interventions to mitigate its occurrence.

Activation of the rostral nucleus accumbens shell by optogenetics induces cataplexy-like behavior in orexin neuron-ablated mice

Cataplexy is one of the symptoms of type 1 narcolepsy, characterized by a sudden loss of muscle tone. It can be seen as a behavioral index of salience, predominantly positive emotion, since it is triggered by laughter in humans and palatable foods in mice. In our previous study using chemogenetic techniques in narcoleptic mice (orexin neuron-ablated mice), we found that the rostral nucleus accumbens (NAc) shell is needed for chocolate-induced cataplexy. In this study, we investigated whether a short-lasting stimulation/inhibition of the NAc by optogenetics led to a similar result. Photo-illumination to the NAc in the channel rhodopsin-expressing mice showed a higher incidence (34.9 ± 5.1%) of cataplexy-like behavior than the control mice (17.8 ± 3.1%, P = 0.0056). Meanwhile, inactivation with archaerhodopsin did not affect incidence. The episode duration of cataplexy-like behavior was not affected by activation or inactivation. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that photo-illumination activated channel rhodopsin-expressing NAc shell neurons. Thus, activation of the NAc, whether transient (light stimulation) or longer-lasting (chemical stimulation in our previous study), facilitates cataplexy-like behaviors and contributes to the induction but not maintenance in them. On the other hand, our study's result from optogenetic inhibition of the NAc (no effect) was different from chemogenetic inhibition (reduction of cataplexy-like behavior) in our previous study. We propose that the initiation of cataplexy-like behavior is facilitated by activation of the NAc, while NAc-independent mechanisms determine the termination of the behavior.

Positive memory increases cataplexy-like behaviors in narcolepsy mice as revealed using conditioned place preference test

BACKGROUND

Cataplexy is a loss of muscle tone that can lead to postural collapse, disturbing the daily life of narcolepsy patients; it is often triggered by positive emotions such as laughter in human patients. Narcolepsy model mice also show cataplexy, and its incidence increases in response to positive emotion-inducing stimuli such as chocolate and female courtship. Although such observation indicates a positive emotion-related nature of cataplexy in narcolepsy mice, they also show cataplexy without any apparent triggering stimulus ~ (spontaneous cataplexy). Therefore, we hypothesized that some spontaneous cataplexy in narcoleptic mice might indicate the remembering of happy moments.

RESULTS

To test our hypothesis, we did a conditioned place preference test on orexin/hypocretin neuron-ablated (ORX-AB) mice, one of the animal models of human narcolepsy, and counted the number of cataplexy-like behaviors. ORX-AB mice successfully remembered the chocolate-associated chamber, and the number of cataplexy-like behaviors significantly increased in the chocolate-associated chamber but not in the control chamber. In addition, ORX-AB mice remembered the aversive odor-associated chamber and avoided entering without affecting the number of cataplexy-like behaviors. Finally, similar activation of the nucleus accumbens, a positive emotion-related nucleus, was observed during both spontaneous and chocolate-induced cataplexy behaviors.

CONCLUSIONS

These results support our hypothesis and will promote the usefulness of a narcolepsy mice model in emotion research and serve as a basis for a better understanding of cataplexy in narcolepsy patients.

John EK, Potesta CV, Gallagher MJ, Macdonald RL, Zhou C. Sleep slow-wave oscillations trigger seizures in a genetic epilepsy model of Dravet syndrome

Sleep is the preferential period when epileptic spike-wave discharges appear in human epileptic patients, including genetic epileptic seizures such as Dravet syndrome with multiple mutations including SCN1A mutation and GABAA receptor γ2 subunit Gabrg2Q390X mutation in patients, which presents more severe epileptic symptoms in female patients than male patients. However, the seizure onset mechanism during sleep still remains unknown. Our previous work has shown that the sleep-like state-dependent homeostatic synaptic potentiation can trigger epileptic spike-wave discharges in one transgenic heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mouse model.1 Here, using this heterozygous knock-in mouse model, we hypothesized that slow-wave oscillations themselves in vivo could trigger epileptic seizures. We found that epileptic spike-wave discharges in heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice exhibited preferential incidence during non-rapid eye movement sleep period, accompanied by motor immobility/facial myoclonus/vibrissal twitching and more frequent spike-wave discharge incidence appeared in female heterozygous knock-in mice than male heterozygous knock-in mice. Optogenetically induced slow-wave oscillations in vivo significantly increased epileptic spike-wave discharge incidence in heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice with longer duration of non-rapid eye movement sleep or quiet-wakeful states. Furthermore, suppression of slow-wave oscillation-related homeostatic synaptic potentiation by 4-(diethylamino)-benzaldehyde injection (i.p.) greatly attenuated spike-wave discharge incidence in heterozygous knock-in mice, suggesting that slow-wave oscillations in vivo did trigger seizure activity in heterozygous knock-in mice. Meanwhile, sleep spindle generation in wild-type littermates and heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice involved the slow-wave oscillation-related homeostatic synaptic potentiation that also contributed to epileptic spike-wave discharge generation in heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice. In addition, EEG spectral power of delta frequency (0.1-4 Hz) during non-rapid eye movement sleep was significantly larger in female heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice than that in male heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice, which likely contributes to the gender difference in seizure incidence during non-rapid eye movement sleep/quiet-wake states of human patients. Overall, all these results indicate that slow-wave oscillations in vivo trigger the seizure onset in heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice, preferentially during non-rapid eye movement sleep period and likely generate the sex difference in seizure incidence between male and female heterozygous Gabrg2+/Q390X knock-in mice.

Gender differences in narcolepsy: What are recent findings telling us?

Three papers currently published in SLEEP using two different mouse models of narcolepsy, including either Hcrt-tTa;TetO diptheria toxin-A (DTA) or Hypocretin knock-out (Hcrt-KO) mice, suggest important gender differences in narcolepsy expression. Specifically, these recent data corroborate previous findings in mice demonstrating that females show more cataplexy events and more total cataplexy expression than males. Moreover, in the neurotoxic DTA mouse model, females show earlier onset of cataplexy expression than males during active Hcrt cell loss. Finally, females show a doubling of cataplexy during estrous compared to other phases of the estrous cycle. These findings are reviewed in the broader context of prior published literature, including reported gender differences in Hcrt expression and hormonal influences on sleep and wakefulness. Although similar findings have not been reported in humans, a systematic evaluation of gender differences in human narcolepsy has yet to be performed. Taken together, these animal data suggest that more research exploring gender differences in human narcolepsy is warranted.

Central Disorders of Hypersomnolence: Association with Fatigue, Depression and Sleep Inertia Prevailing in Women

Fatigue, depression, and sleep inertia are frequently underdiagnosed manifestations in narcolepsy and idiopathic hypersomnia. Our cross-sectional study design included diagnostic interview accompanied by assessment instruments and aimed to explore how these factors influence disease severity as well as to elucidate any sex predisposition. One hundred and forty-eight subjects (female 63%) were divided into narcolepsy type 1 (NT1; n = 87, female = 61%), narcolepsy type 2 (NT2; n = 22, female = 59%), and idiopathic hypersomnia (IH; n = 39, female = 69%). All subjects completed a set of questionnaires: Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS), Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scales (HADS), Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS), and Sleep Inertia Questionnaire (SIQ). In narcoleptic subjects, questionnaire data were correlated with the Narcolepsy Severity Scale (NSS), and in subjects with idiopathic hypersomnia, with the Idiopathic Hypersomnia Severity Scale (IHSS). The highest correlation in narcoleptic subjects was found between NSS and ESS (r = 0.658; p < 0.0001), as well as FSS (r = 0.506; p < 0.0001), while in subjects with idiopathic hypersomnia, the most prominent positive correlations were found between IHSS and SIQ (r = 0.894; p < 0.0001), FSS (r = 0.812; p < 0.0001), HADS depression scale (r = 0.649; p = 0.0005), and HADS anxiety scale (r = 0.528; p < 0.0001). ESS showed an analogic correlation with disease severity (r = 0.606; p < 0.0001). HADS anxiety and depression scores were higher in females (p < 0.05 and p < 0.01), with similar results for FSS and SIQ scales (p < 0.05 for both), and a trend toward higher ESS values in females (p = 0.057). Our study illustrates that more attention should be focused on pathophysiological mechanisms and associations of fatigue, depression, as well as sleep inertia in these diseases; they influence the course of both illnesses, particularly in women.

Idling for Decades: A European Study on Risk Factors Associated with the Delay Before a Narcolepsy Diagnosis

PURPOSE

Narcolepsy type-1 (NT1) is a rare chronic neurological sleep disorder with excessive daytime sleepiness (EDS) as usual first and cataplexy as pathognomonic symptom. Shortening the NT1 diagnostic delay is the key to reduce disease burden and related low quality of life. Here we investigated the changes of diagnostic delay over the diagnostic years (1990-2018) and the factors associated with the delay in Europe.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We analyzed 580 NT1 patients (male: 325, female: 255) from 12 European countries using the European Narcolepsy Network database. We combined machine learning and linear mixed-effect regression to identify factors associated with the delay.

RESULTS

The mean age at EDS onset and diagnosis of our patients was 20.9±11.8 (mean ± standard deviation) and 30.5±14.9 years old, respectively. Their mean and median diagnostic delay was 9.7±11.5 and 5.3 (interquartile range: 1.7-13.2 years) years, respectively. We did not find significant differences in the diagnostic delay over years in either the whole dataset or in individual countries, although the delay showed significant differences in various countries. The number of patients with short (≤2-year) and long (≥13-year) diagnostic delay equally increased over decades, suggesting that subgroups of NT1 patients with variable disease progression may co-exist. Younger age at cataplexy onset, longer interval between EDS and cataplexy onsets, lower cataplexy frequency, shorter duration of irresistible daytime sleep, lower daytime REM sleep propensity, and being female are associated with longer diagnostic delay.

CONCLUSION

Our findings contrast the results of previous studies reporting shorter delay over time which is confounded by calendar year, because they characterized the changes in diagnostic delay over the symptom onset year. Our study indicates that new strategies such as increasing media attention/awareness and developing new biomarkers are needed to better detect EDS, cataplexy, and changes of nocturnal sleep in narcolepsy, in order to shorten the diagnostic interval.