Pretreatment blood concentrations of chloroquine in patients with malaria infection: relation to response to treatment

Residual antimalarials in malaria patients from Tanzania--implications on drug efficacy assessment and spread of parasite resistance

Background

Repeated antimalarial treatment for febrile episodes and self-treatment are common in malaria-endemic areas. The intake of antimalarials prior to participating in an in vivo study may alter treatment outcome and affect the interpretation of both efficacy and safety outcomes. We report the findings from baseline plasma sampling of malaria patients prior to inclusion into an in vivo study in Tanzania and discuss the implications of residual concentrations of antimalarials in this setting.

Methods and Findings

In an in vivo study conducted in a rural area of Tanzania in 2008, baseline plasma samples from patients reporting no antimalarial intake within the last 28 days were screened for the presence of 14 antimalarials (parent drugs or metabolites) using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Among the 148 patients enrolled, 110 (74.3%) had at least one antimalarial in their plasma: 80 (54.1%) had lumefantrine above the lower limit of calibration (LLC = 4 ng/mL), 7 (4.7%) desbutyl-lumefantrine (4 ng/mL), 77 (52.0%) sulfadoxine (0.5 ng/mL), 15 (10.1%) pyrimethamine (0.5 ng/mL), 16 (10.8%) quinine (2.5 ng/mL) and none chloroquine (2.5 ng/mL).

Conclusions

The proportion of patients with detectable antimalarial drug levels prior to enrollment into the study is worrying. Indeed artemether–lumefantrine was supposed to be available only at government health facilities. Although sulfadoxine–pyrimethamine is only recommended for intermittent preventive treatment in pregnancy (IPTp), it was still widely used in public and private health facilities and sold in drug shops. Self-reporting of previous drug intake is unreliable and thus screening for the presence of antimalarial drug levels should be considered in future in vivo studies to allow for accurate assessment of treatment outcome. Furthermore, persisting sub-therapeutic drug levels of antimalarials in a population could promote the spread of drug resistance. The knowledge on drug pressure in a given population is important to monitor standard treatment policy implementation.

The in-vitro susceptibilities of Ghanaian Plasmodium falciparum to antimalarial drugs

In Ghana in 2004 (when choroquine was still the nationally recommended drug for the first-line treatment of malaria), the sensitivities, to chloroquine, amodiaquine, quinine, mefloquine, artesunate and halofantrine, of 60 Plasmodium falciparum isolates from two ecologically distinct areas of the country were assessed in vitro. The aim was to make available, to policy-makers, the field-based evidence needed to review the national strategy for malaria treatment. Drug susceptibilities were explored using the standardized protocol of the Antimalarial Drug Resistance Network. Although 32 of the P. falciparum isolates evaluated (56.1% of the 57 isolates successfully investigated for their susceptibility to choroquine) showed resistance to chloroquine and two showed slightly reduced sensitivity to amodiaquine, all the isolates were sensitive to mefloquine, artesunate, quinine and halofantrine. The median inhibitory concentrations (IC(50)) of chloroquine were positively correlated with those of quinine (r=0.4528; P=0.0008) but not those of any of the other drugs investigated. The IC(50) of amodiaquine and artesunate were also positively correlated (r=0.3703; P=0.0067). These results provide evidence of the presence, in Ghana, of P. falciparum isolates that are highly resistant to chloroquine but generally sensitive to most of the other antimalarial drugs commonly used in the country. Partly in consequence of these observations, the recommended first-line treatment for malaria in Ghana was changed to an amodiaquine-artesunate combination in January 2005.

High residual chloroquine blood levels in African children with severe malaria seeking healthcare

Despite widespread resistance, chloroquine remains widely used in West Africa, particularly in home treatment. We examined chloroquine blood levels on admission to a referral hospital with respect to the manifestation of severe malaria in 290 Ghanaian children. Of the patients, 78% exhibited chloroquine concentrations (subtherapeutic, 35%; therapeutic, 37%; supratherapeutic, 6%) and 11% died. Most parasites (78%) carried the pfcrt-T76 chloroquine resistance mutation. High drug concentrations correlated with reduced parasitaemia but also with selection of resistant parasites, lower respiratory and heart rates, increased plasma lactate levels and impaired consciousness. Geometric mean chloroquine concentrations tended to be higher in children who died than in survivors (1.135 vs. 778nmol/l; P=0.09). Supratherapeutic drug levels (>5000nmol/l) were associated with fatal outcome (odds ratio 8.6; 95% CI 1.4-51.7). Residual chloroquine concentrations were found to be abundant in children with severe malaria and to be associated with alterations in the clinical manifestation of the disease and its case fatality. This may result from toxic effects of the drug and/or reflect preceding overtreatment in children with acute life-threatening disease. In areas of intense chloroquine resistance and frequent pre-treatment, additional administration of chloroquine at hospital admission is not only ineffective but may even further endanger patients.

Factors contributing to the development of anaemia in Plasmodium falciparum malaria: what about drug-resistant parasites?

A major manifestation of complicated malaria especially among children is severe anaemia, the pathogenesis of which is not well understood. Among other factors, suppression of the bone marrow's response to erythropoietin, which is rapidly reversed after successful treatment of the malaria, has been implicated in its pathogenesis. Since resolution of malaria restores erythropoiesis, we hypothesized that drug-resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum would increase the risk of severe anaemia developing from initially uncomplicated malaria. Using both in vivo and in vitro drug-sensitivity tests we compared the prevalence of drug-resistant malaria between severe malarial anaemia SA and non-anaemic malaria NAM patients. Assessment of treatment outcome using the WHO in vivo criteria showed no significant difference in parasite resistance between the two groups. The mean parasite clearance time was also comparable. Treatment failures of about 14 per cent and 12 per cent were observed between SA and NAM patients respectively. The in vitro drug susceptibility test showed overall mean IC50 values of 0.41x10(-6) mol/l and 0.32x10(-6) mol/l blood for SA and NAM groups respectively. Geometric mean pre-treatment blood levels of chloroquine did not differ much between the two groups. Findings from this study could not therefore implicate drug-resistant parasites in the pathogenesis of severe malarial anaemia.

Chloroquine-treatment failure in northern Ghana: roles of pfcrt T76 and pfmdr1 Y86

Although chloroquine (CQ) monotherapy is now generally inadequate for the treatment of Plasmodium falciparum malaria in northern Ghana--recently, 58% of 225 children failed treatment by day 14--use of the drug continues because of its low cost and wide availability. The risk factors associated with CQ-treatment failure in this region of Africa, including the T76 mutation in the chloroquine resistance transporter (pfcrt) gene and the Y86 mutation in the multidrug resistance (pfmdr1) gene of P. falciparum, have now been investigated, and genotype-failure indices (GFI) have been calculated. Treatment failure was found to be associated with young age, poor nutritional status, pfcrt T76 and pfmdr1 Y86, and early treatment failure (ETF) was also associated with high parasitaemia. The presence and concentration of 'residual' CQ in the blood of patients immediately before they were treated with CQ for the present study appeared to have no effect on outcome. Presence at recruitment of pfcrt T76 or pfmdr1 Y86 or both mutations increased the risk of treatment failure by 3.2-, 2.4- and 4.5-fold, and the risk of ETF by 9.8-, 2.7- and 10.2-fold, respectively. The pfcrt T76 GFI for clinical and all treatment failures were 2.8 and 1.4, respectively. These indices were relatively low in the younger children, those with malnutrition, and those with high parasitaemias when treated. Residual CQ did not affect the GFI substantially. Both pfcrt T76 and, to a lesser extent, pfmdr1 Y86 would be useful tools for the surveillance of CQ resistance in northern Ghana. In the current transition phase to alternative first-line treatment for P. falciparum malaria, it should be possible to provide estimates of the level of CQ resistance by monitoring the prevalences of these mutations.

Should chloroquine be laid to rest?

Chloroquine (CQ) has been the front line antimalarial drug due to its efficacy, low cost and scanty side effects, until resistance has evolved. Although its use has been officially discontinued in most malaria-affected countries, it is still widely used. Practical and pharmacological considerations indicate that it could be still used in semi-immune adults and that more efficient treatment protocols could be devised to treat even patients infected with CQ-resistant parasite strains. Since its antimalarial activity is pleiotropic, drug resistance may be due to different mechanisms, each amenable to reversal by drug combination.