Characterization and Epidemiology of Outbreaks of Impatiens necrotic spot virus on Lettuce in Coastal California

Genetic and physiological determinants of lettuce partial resistance to Impatiens necrotic spot virus

Introduction

Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV) is a major pathogen currently threatening lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) production in the coastal areas of California. The virus is transmitted by the western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis Pergande).

Methods

We have tested a diversity panel of almost 500 lettuce accessions for disease incidence (DI) in 12 field experiments performed over 7 years. This set of accessions was also assessed for thrips feeding damage (TFD), the rate of plant development (PD), and the content of chlorophyll (SPAD) and anthocyanins (ACI) to determine their effect on resistance to INSV. In addition, recombinant inbred lines from two biparental mapping populations were also evaluated for DI in field experiments.

Results

The mean DI in 14 field experiments ranged from 2.1% to 70.4%. A highly significant difference in DI was observed among the tested accessions, with the overall lowest DI detected in the red color cultivars, Outredgeous Selection, Red Splash Cos, Infantry, Sweet Valentine, Annapolis, and Velvet. Multiple linear regression models revealed a small but significant effect (p < 0.005) of the four analyzed determinants on DI. Accessions with lower DI values had slower plant development (PD, r = 0.352), higher ACI content (r = -0.284), lower TFD (r = 0.198), and lower SPAD content (r = 0.125). A genome-wide association study revealed 13 QTLs for DI located on eight out of the nine lettuce chromosomes (the exception was chr. 8). The most frequently detected QTL (qINSV2.1) was located on chr. 2. Several of the QTLs for DI were in the same genomic areas as QTLs for PD, ACI, and SPAD. Additional three QTLs for DI on chr. 5 and 8 were identified using linkage mapping performed on two biparental mapping populations.

Conclusions

The work highlights the genetic basis of partial resistance to INSV and reveals the relationship between resistance, the host physiology, and the thrips vector. Results of this study are an important steppingstone toward developing cultivars with increased resistance against INSV.

Epidemiology and Economic Impact of Impatiens Necrotic Spot Virus: A Resurging Pathogen Affecting Lettuce in the Salinas Valley of California

The Orthotospovirus impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV) is a thrips-transmitted pathogen of lettuce that has rapidly emerged as a serious threat to production in the Salinas Valley of Monterey County, California. As a first step toward understanding the severity of the virus, we utilized Spatial Analysis by Distance IndicEs (SADIE) to characterize the distribution and progression of INSV outbreaks and thrips infestations in two commercial lettuce fields. In both fields, INSV incidence rapidly increased from 15.86% ± 1.77 to 80.24% ± 2.60 over the course of 7 weeks and aggregated at specific edges in both fields as early as 3 weeks after planting (Ia = 1.63, Pa = 0.0100, and Ia = 1.53, Pa = 0.0300). In one of the fields, thrips populations aggregated in areas that also experienced the most INSV (Ia = 1.2435, Pa = 0.0400, week 3; Ia = 1.4815, Pa < 0.0001, week 6; Ia = 1.5608, Pa < 0.0001, week 9), while in the second field, thrips were distributed randomly despite the aggregated effects that were observed for INSV incidence. Economic analysis estimated that the virus accounted for over $475,000 in losses for the two fields, while stakeholder surveys documented over 750 fields that experienced INSV infection during the 2021 season in Monterey County alone. These studies enhance our knowledge on the epidemiology of thrips and INSV under current lettuce production practices in the Salinas Valley, while elucidating the economic consequences and broader challenges that are associated with managing thrips-transmitted viruses.

First Report of Impatiens Necrotic Spot Virus Infecting Lettuce in Arizona and Southern Desert Regions of California

Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV; family Tospoviridae, genus Orthotospovirus) is a thrips-borne pathogen that infects a wide range of ornamental and vegetable crops. INSV was first reported in lettuce (Lactuca sativa) in the Salinas Valley of CA (Monterey County) in 2006 (Koike et al. 2008). Since then, the pathogen has continued to impact lettuce production in the region, causing severe economic losses with increasing incidence and severity in recent years. Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), another tospovirus, also infects lettuce, but its occurrence is much less frequent than INSV (Kuo et al. 2014). While INSV has not been reported in the desert areas of CA and AZ, there are concerns that the virus could become established in this region. In early March 2021, symptoms resembling those caused by orthotospovirus infection were observed in several romaine and iceberg lettuce fields in the Yuma and Tacna regions of Yuma County, AZ. Symptoms included leaves that exhibited tan to dark brown necrotic spots, distorted leaf shapes, and stunted plant growth. Similar symptoms were also reported in romaine fields and one green leaf and iceberg lettuce field in the neighboring Imperial and Riverside Counties of CA. A total of 14 samples (5 from Tacna, 4 from Yuma, 4 from Imperial, 1 from Riverside) were tested using ImmunoStrips (Agdia, Elkhart, IN) for INSV and TSWV. Results confirmed the presence of INSV in 13 out of 14 samples, and the absence of INSV in one sample originating from Yuma. All 14 samples tested negative for TSWV. The 13 INSV positive samples were processed for RT-PCR validation. Total RNA was extracted from each sample using the RNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). RT-PCR was performed with OneStep Ahead RT-PCR Kit (Qiagen) with primers to the N gene of INSV S RNA (Accession KF745140.1; INSV F = CCAAATACTACTTTAACCGCAAGT; INSV R = ACACCCAAGACACAGGATTT). All reactions generated a single amplicon at the correct size of 524 bp. One sample each from Yuma, Tacna, and Brawley (Imperial County), as well as a romaine lettuce sample collected from the Salinas Valley in March 2021, were sent for Sanger bi-directional sequencing (Eton Biosciences, San Diego, CA). Sequence analysis revealed that all three desert samples (Yuma, Tacna, and Brawley with Accessions OK340696, OK340697, OK340698, respectively) shared 100% sequence identity and 99.43% identity to the Salinas Valley 2021 sample (SV-L2, Accession OK340699). Additionally, all desert samples shared 99.24% sequence identity to the Salinas Valley lettuce isolate previously described in 2014 (SV-L1, Accession KF745140.1; Kuo et al. 2014), while the SV-L2 and SV-L1 sequences shared 99.43% identity. By the end of the season (April 2021) a total of 43 lettuce fields in Yuma County, AZ, and 9 fields in Imperial and Riverside Counties, CA were confirmed to have INSV infection using ImmunoStrips. Impacted fields included romaine, green leaf, red leaf, and head lettuce varieties, and both direct-seeded and transplanted lettuce, under conventional and organic management regimes. In AZ, INSV incidence in fields ranged between 0.2% and 33%, while in Imperial and Riverside Counties, CA, field incidence remained low at less than 0.1%. It is possible that INSV was introduced from the Salinas Valley of CA through the movement of infected lettuce transplants and/or thrips vectors. To our knowledge, this is the first report of INSV infecting lettuce in Arizona and the southern desert region of California.

Could Broccoli and Cauliflower Influence the Dispersal Dynamics of Western Flower Thrips (Thysanoptera: Thripidae) to Lettuce in the Salinas Valley of California?

The western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis (Pergande) (Thysanoptera: Thripidae), is an important, worldwide vector of two tospoviruses (Family Bunyaviridae; Genus Tospovirus), Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV) and Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV). In the Salinas Valley of California, INSV causes severe necrosis, stunting, and crop losses to lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.). Because broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica L.) and cauliflower (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis L.) are major rotation crops with lettuce in the Salinas Valley, it is critical to understand if these Brassicas influence the dispersal dynamics of F. occidentalis. In 2013 and 2014, surveys were conducted evaluating yellow sticky cards and plant samples in lettuce, broccoli, and cauliflower fields in three regions of the Salinas Valley. F. occidentalis were collected on sticky cards from April to November and on foliage in all three regions. Two-choice oviposition assays as well as no-choice and two-choice feeding assays were conducted where F. occidentalis adults were exposed to leaves of lettuce, broccoli, and cauliflower. A significantly greater number of eggs was found on lettuce than on broccoli or cauliflower leaves in the choice assay, whereas for the broccoli and cauliflower choice assay, the number of eggs retrieved was low and not significantly different between hosts. The number of F. occidentalis feeding spots and leaf area injury ratings were similar on broccoli and lettuce leaves but were significantly lower on cauliflower than on lettuce and broccoli leaves. The implications of these results on thrips and plant virus management are discussed.

A global invasion by the thrip, Frankliniella occidentalis: Current virus vector status and its management

Western flower thrip, Frankliniella occidentalis (Pergande), is among the most economically important agricultural pests globally, attacking a wide range of vegetable and horticultural crops. In addition to causing extensive crop damage, the species is notorious for vectoring destructive plant viruses, mainly belonging to the genera Orthotospovirus, Ilarvirus, Alphacarmovirus and Machlomovirus. Once infected by orthotospoviruses, thrips can remain virulent throughout their lifespan and continue transmitting viruses to host plants when and wherever they feed. These irruptive viral outbreaks in crops will permanently disrupt functional integrated pest management systems, and typically require a remedial treatment involving insecticides, contributing to further development of insecticide resistance. To mitigate against this continuing cycle, the most effective management is early and comprehensive surveillance of the pest species and recognition of plant viruses in the field. This review provides information on the pest status of F. occidentalis, discusses the current global status of the viruses vectored by this thrip species, examines the mechanisms involved in transmitting virus-induced diseases by thrips, and reviews different management strategies, highlighting the potential management tactics developed for various cropping systems. The early surveillance and the utilization of potential methods for control of both F. occidentalis and viruses are proposed.

Sequence analysis of the medium and small RNAs of impatiens necrotic spot virus reveals segment reassortment but not recombination

The complete sequence of the medium (M) and small (S) RNA genome segments were determined for twelve isolates of impatiens necrotic spot virus from eight plant species. The M- and S-RNAs of these isolates shared 97-99% and 93-98% nucleotide sequence identity, respectively, with the corresponding full-length sequences available in public databases. Phylogenetic analysis based on the M- or S-RNA sequences showed incongruence in the phylogenetic position of some isolates, suggesting intraspecies segment reassortment. The lack of phylogenetic discordance in individual and concatenated sequences of individual genes encoded by M- or S-RNAs suggests that segment reassortment rather than recombination is driving evolution of these INSV isolates.

Characterization of the first complete genome sequence of an Impatiens necrotic spot orthotospovirus isolate from the United States and worldwide phylogenetic analyses of INSV isolates

OBJECTIVE

Impatiens necrotic spot orthotospovirus (INSV) can impact economically important ornamental plants and vegetables worldwide. Characterization studies on INSV are limited. For most INSV isolates, there are no complete genome sequences available. This lack of genomic information has a negative impact on the understanding of the INSV genetic diversity and evolution. Here we report the first complete nucleotide sequence of a US INSV isolate.

RESULTS

INSV-UP01 was isolated from an impatiens in Pennsylvania, US. RT-PCR was used to clone its full-length genome and Vector NTI to assemble overlapping sequences. Phylogenetic trees were constructed by using MEGA7 software to show the phylogenetic relationships with other available INSV sequences worldwide. This US isolate has genome and biological features classical of INSV species and clusters in the Western Hemisphere clade, but its origin appears to be recent. Furthermore, INSV-UP01 might have been involved in a recombination event with an Italian isolate belonging to the Asian clade. Our analyses support that INSV isolates infect a broad plant-host range they group by geographic origin and not by host, and are subjected to frequent recombination events. These results justify the need to generate and analyze complete genome sequences of orthotospoviruses in general and INSV in particular.

Variation within Lactuca spp. for Resistance to Impatiens necrotic spot virus

Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) production in coastal California, one of the major lettuce-producing areas of the United States, is regularly affected by outbreaks of Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV), a member of the genus Orthotospovirus. Transmission of INSV among lettuce crops in this growing region has been attributed predominantly to the western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis). INSV is acquired by first- or second-instar thrips nymphs feeding on infected host plants (not necessarily lettuce). The virus replicates within the insect vector, and is transmitted to new plants by adult thrips as they feed on epidermal and mesophyll cells of susceptible host plants. All currently grown cultivars of lettuce are susceptible to the disease. Screening lettuce for resistance to INSV under field conditions is problematic because natural infections appear sporadically and the virus is not evenly distributed across infected fields. We have developed a greenhouse-based assay that uses viruliferous thrips in combination with mechanical inoculation that allows dependable, year-round screening for resistance. In all, 89 cultivars, breeding lines, and plant introductions of cultivated lettuce, together with 53 accessions from 11 other Lactuca spp., 4 accessions from two dandelion (Taraxacum) species, and 4 tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) lines were evaluated for resistance to INSV. All tested material was susceptible to INSV to varying degrees, with the exception of two tomato lines that carry the Sw-5 gene that confers resistance to Tomato spotted wilt virus, a virus closely related to INSV. In cultivated lettuce, a partial resistance to INSV was observed in cultivars Amazona, Ancora, Antigua, Commodore, Eruption, Iceberg, La Brillante, Merlot, Telluride, and Tinto. Limited comparison of the greenhouse-based screening results with the data from opportunistic evaluations of resistance on 775 lettuce accessions from six field trials indicates consistency of results from both greenhouse and field environments. The most resistant lettuce accessions are being incorporated into our breeding program for introgression of resistance into lettuce breeding lines.