Use of the Ilizarov external fixator in the treatment of patients with Ollier's disease

New bone formation accelerates during lower limb lengthening and deformity correction in children with Ollier's disease

BACKGROUND

Ollier's disease can cause severe length discrepancy of the lower extremities and deformity in children. Osteotomy and limb lengthening with external fixation can correct the limb deformity. This study evaluated (1) whether the duration of external fixation was reduced in patients with Ollier's disease, and (2) the incidence of complications such as pin tract infection, external fixation loosening, and joint stiffness.

METHODS

Two groups were compared with respect to age, angular correction (AC), lengthening gap (LG), distraction index (DI), lengthening length (LL), lengthening length percentage (L%), lengthening index (LI), bone healing index (BHI), and external fixation index (EFI). Group 1 (Ollier's disease) comprised nine patients undergoing 11 lower limb lengthening procedures using external fixators; group 2 (control, normal lengthened bone) comprised 28 patients undergoing 29 lengthening procedures with external fixators.

RESULTS

In patients with Ollier's disease, full correction of the deformity and full restoration of length were achieved in all cases. In the femur, the mean AC (15.97° vs. 6.72°) and DI (1.11 mm/day vs. 0.78 mm/day) were significantly larger, while the LI (9.71 days/cm vs. 13.49 days/cm), BHI (27.00 days/cm vs. 42.09 days/cm), and EFI (37.86 days/cm vs. 56.97 days/cm) were all significantly shorter in group 1 than in group 2 (p < 0.05). In the tibia, the mean AC and L% were larger, while the LG, LI, BHI, and EFI were all shorter in group 1 than in group 2. There was no significant difference between the two groups in the incidence of complications.

CONCLUSION

In children with Ollier's disease, new bone formation accelerated and the healing speed of the lengthened segments was faster throughout the whole lengthening period with external fixation, and full correction of the deformity and full restoration of length could be achieved.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE III

Outcomes of intralesional osteotomy and distraction osteogenesis for limb length equalization in Ollier's disease

Limb length discrepancy and deformities resulting from Ollier's disease are challenging to treat and have increased complications. We aimed to assess the safety of intralesional osteotomy for distraction osteogenesis and report the results of guided growth as a method of deformity correction in such conditions. We retrospectively reviewed 13 patients (eight boys and five girls), 28 segments (12 femora and 16 tibias), treated using Ilizarov circular ring fixator in one center. Nine patients had an oblique plane deformity, whereas four had a coronal plane deformity. Femoral shortening ranged from three to 11 cm. Tibial shortening ranged from 3.5 to 12 cm. Intralesional osteotomy was carried out in all patients, and guided growth (hemiepiphysiodesis) was used in seven segments (25%). The median age was 11 years (6-14 years) at surgery, with a median follow-up of 4.5 years (3-18 years). The median achieved lengthening in the femur was 7 cm (5-11 cm) and in the tibia was 5 cm (3-9 cm). The average Bone Healing Index (BHI) for the femur was 32 days/cm (28-38 days/cm), and for the tibia was 36 days/cm (28-40 days/cm). Before frame removal, the mechanical axis was restored to the knee joint center in all cases. Normal radiographic bone regeneration was evident in all cases. Hemiepiphysiodesis successfully corrected the angular deformities. Intralesional osteotomy for distraction osteogenesis is well-tolerated and reliable in Ollier's disease. Radiological normal bone was formed at the distraction site. Guided growth is also a reproducible method for deformity correction in Ollier's disease, similar to other conditions.

Lengthening the Lower Extremities of Children with Ollier's and Maffucci's Enchondromatosis Using Implantable Lengthening Nails

There are multiple forms of enchondromatosis with Ollier's and Maffucci's being the most prevalent types. Limb length discrepancy is a common problem in patients with Ollier's and Maffucci's enchondromatosis. There are multiple reports about lengthening bones in patients with enchondromatosis using external fixators. However, there are no case series regarding the use of implantable lengthening technology. The purpose of this paper is to describe our experience with implantable nail lengthening in patients with enchondromatosis. A retrospective chart and radiographic review of patients with enchondromatosis who underwent implantable nail limb lengthening was performed. Seven patients with 14 bony segments were reviewed. A total of 11/14 lengthenings were completed without difficulty. There were no issues in terms of fixation location in patients with Ollier's disease. One patient with Maffucci's syndrome experienced migration of the nail during two lengthenings due to a combination of intralesional fixation and preconsolidation. One patient with Ollier's disease developed a knee extension contracture requiring manipulation under anesthesia. No other complications were recorded. The use of implantable nail lengthening to resolve limb length discrepancies in patients with Ollier's disease appears to be safe and effective.

Limb Length Discrepancy and Angular Deformity due to Benign Bone Tumors and Tumor-like Lesions

Benign bone tumors and tumor-like lesions are frequently diagnosed in children and adolescents. The immature skeleton is at risk for growth disturbances and deformity because of the effects of the lesions on normal bone architecture and the physis. The development, manifestation, and severity of the limb length inequality and deformity differs between the various bone pathologies. Distraction osteogenesis, osteotomy, and guided growth are key tools in the treatment of limb inequality and deformity using a combination of external and internal fixation devices.

Limb lengthening for deformities in Ollier's disease: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The management of limb deformity, shortening, and bone defects in treatment of Ollier's disease is a major challenge. This study aims to summarize and compare the different surgical treatments, and to evaluate the outcome and possible prognostic factors of leg lengthening in these patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic review of the literature from 1993 to 2017 was performed. Nineteen articles were found including a total of 121 patients with limb deformities because of Ollier's disease. The mean patients' age at the time of first surgery was 12 years. A total of 272 segments were surgically treated (14 segments in the upper limbs) with variable techniques including osteotomies and external fixation, intramedullary nails, as well as epiphysiodesis and lengthening over nail. We studied the bone healing index (BHI), distraction index (DI), distraction time, gained length, total treatment time, and complications.

RESULTS

Available implants and techniques allowed correction of patients' deformities (lengthening and correction of angular defects) in most cases. External fixators, circular or monolateral frames were the most commonly used technique. The Ilizarov external fixator was the most commonly used frame (196 segments). The BHI was significantly better when the external fixation was combined with intramedullary nails. Epiphysiodesis was most likely to be more associated with the past than to the present. Joint stiffness, infection, early consolidation, pathological fracture, deformity recurrence, delayed union, non-union, neurapraxia, and overlengthening were the reported complications with an overall rate of 27.9%.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no consensus for the optimal surgical technique and implants for correction of limbs deformities in patients with Ollier's disease. External fixators most commonly circular are the most commonly used implants; however, complications do occur.

Limb lengthening and deformity correction in children with abnormal bone

Flexible intramedullary nailing (FIN) provides multiple advantages in limb lengthening and progressive deformity correction in combination with external fixation. The article presents brief literature review and authors' experience in limb lengthening of abnormal bone (Ollier's disease, fibrous dysplasia, osteogenesis imperfecta). Titanium and, especially, hydroxyapatite-coated bent elastic nails in combination with external fixator are appropriate in limb lengthening of abnormal bone in children. FIN left in situ after lengthening procedure and external frame removal should be applied for long-term reinforcement of lengthened bone in patients with abnormal bone (metabolic bone disorders, skeletal dysplasias with compromised bone tissue development). The FIN respects bone biology, which is mandatory for good bone consolidation. Osteoactive properties of intramedullary elastic implants are favorable for bone formation and as well as for stable position of nails without risks of migration in long-term follow-up.

Treatment of bone tumor using external fixator

External fixation has been widely used for the treatment of limb length discrepancy, deformity correction, and bone defect using distraction osteogenesis. We have been using this technique for the treatment of obstacles due to benign bone tumor and reconstruction after malignant bone tumor resection. In this paper, we introduce the usefulness of external fixation for the treatment of various benign bone tumors and limb salvage surgery for reconstruction after tumor resection using distraction osteogenesis, according to the tumor site. The advantages of external fixation for the treatment of benign bone tumor include a possibility of complex deformity correction without treating the tumor itself and reconstruction of the aggressive benign bone tumor as well as solid fixation with wires, even for weak bone due to benign bone tumors. The advantages of treating malignant bone tumor include regeneration of living bone of sufficient strength and durability, biological affinity, resistance against infection, and lifelong restored function. The disadvantages include delayed union at the docking site and pin-or wire-tract infection, patient's psychological stress, and the procedure is time consuming. We conclude that external fixation is very efficient for the treatment of benign and malignant bone tumors.

Recurrence of a Unicameral Bone Cyst in the Femoral Diaphysis

Diaphyseal unicameral bone cysts of the long bone are generally known to originate near the growth plate and migrate from the metaphysis to the diaphysis during skeletal growth. In the case of unicameral bone cysts of diaphyseal origin, recurrence at the same location is extremely rare. We report a case of recurrence of a unicameral bone cyst in the diaphysis of the femur that developed 8 years after treatment with curettage and bone grafting. We performed bone grafting and lengthening of the affected femur with an application of the Ilizarov apparatus over an intramedullary nail to treat the cystic lesion and limb length discrepancy simultaneously.

External fixation reconstruction of the residual problems of benign bone tumours

The mechanical features of and biologic response to using distraction osteogenesis with the circular external fixator are the unique aspects of Ilizarov’s contribution that allows deformity correction and reconstruction of bone defects. We present a retrospective study of 20 patients who suffered from a variety of benign tumours for which external fixators (EF) were used to treat deformity, bone loss, and limb-length discrepancy. A total of 26 bony segments in twenty patients (10 males, 10 females; mean age 17 years; range 7–58 years) were treated with EF for residual problems from the tumour itself (primary treatment) in 8 patients and for complications related to the primary surgery (secondary treatment) in 12 patients. Histological diagnoses were Ollier’s disease (n = 4), Fibrous Dysplasia (n = 5), Congenital multiple exostosis (n = 5), giant cell tumour (n = 2) and one case for chondromyxoid fibroma, desmoid fibroma, chondroma and unicameral bone cyst. Various types of external fixators used to treat these problems. These were Ilizarov, unilateral fixator, multiaxial correction frame (Biomet, Parsippany, NJ), Taylor spatial frame (Memphis, TN) and smart correction multiaxial frame. The mean follow-up time was 69.5 months (range 35–108 months). The mean external fixation time was 159.5 days (range 27–300 days). The mean external fixation index was 67.4 days/cm (12–610) in 26 limbs who underwent distraction osteogenesis. The mean length of distraction was 4.9 cm (range 0.2–14 cm). At final follow-up, all patients had returned to normal activities. Complications were in the form of knee arthrodesis in one patient, pin tract infection in six and residual shortening in eight patients. The use of EF and the principles of distraction osteogenesis, in the management of problems associated with benign bone tumours and related surgery yields successful results especially in young patients. With this approach, the risk for recurrence of shortening and deformity may be minimized with overcorrection or over-lengthening as dictated by preoperative planning.

Ollier Disease: Pathogenesis, Diagnosis, and Management

Ollier disease (Spranger type I) is a rare bone disease that is characterized by multiple enchondromatosis with a typical asymmetrical distribution and confined to the appendicular skeleton. The pathogenesis of enchondromatosis is not clearly understood. Recently, heterozygous mutations of PTHR1, IDH1 (most common), and/or IDH2 genes have been suggested by various authors as genetic aberrations. Genomic copy number alterations and mutations controlling many vital pathways are responsible for the pathogenesis of Ollier disease. A comprehensive description of all genetic events in Ollier disease is presented in this article. Clinically, Ollier disease has a wide variety of presentations. This article describes the plethora of clinical features, both common and rare, associated with Ollier disease. Multiple enchondromas are most commonly seen in phalanges and metacarpals. Radiologically, Ollier disease presents with asymmetrical osteolytic lesions with well-defined, sclerotic margins. In this article, various radiological features of Ollier disease, including radiographs, computed tomography, and magnetic resonance imaging, are also discussed. Gross pathology, cytological, and histological features of both Ollier disease and its malignant transformation are outlined. Although treatment is conservative in most cases, different possible treatment options for difficult cases are discussed. In the literature, there is a paucity of data about the disease, including diagnosis, management, prognostication, and rehabilitation, necessitating a comprehensive review to further define all of the possible domains related to this disease.

Limb reconstruction in Ollier's disease

We present our experience of lengthening and correction of complex deformities in the management of patients with Ollier’s dysplasia (multiple enchondromatosis) from 1985 and 2002. All patients were under 18 years with a minimum follow-up time of 2 years (mean 9.6 years, range 2–15 years). There were a total of ten patients of which seven were male and three female. The mean age at presentation was 10.7 years (range 5–17 years; SD 3.7 years). The total length gain was 42.3 mm (range 30–110 mm; SD 28.9 mm). The number of days in external fixation was 164.8 days (range 76–244 days; SD 42.9 days). The bone healing index was 32.5 days/cm (18–50 days/cm; SD 10.3 days/cm). Patients with Ollier’s disease have limb length inequality and angular deformities and require multiple reconstructive procedures owing to a high incidence of recurrence. We identified a tendency for the osteotomy to prematurely consolidate and advise the latency period after surgery to be 4–5 days and for distraction to proceed at a faster rate.

Deformity correction in pediatric skeletal dysplasia: treatment challenges and solutions

We reviewed our experience with limb-deformity correction in 54 children with skeletal dysplasias. Our goal was to outline common treatment strategies developed in our hospital to overcome the challenges associated with the management of these conditions. Utilization of computer-assisted preoperative planning, intraoperative monitoring of peripheral nerve function, individualized bone segment stabilization using a modular circular external fixation system, and a flexible distraction protocol improved the precision of angular deformity correction in our practice, simplified external fixator assembly, diminished postoperative frame modifications, enhanced the stability of fixation, and reduced the rate of complications.

Ollier's disease limb lenghtening: should intramedullary nailing be combined with circular external fixation?

INTRODUCTION

During progressive lower limb lengthening in the management of Ollier's disease, the mean bone-healing index usually reported in the literature stands around 35 days/cm. One of the therapeutic objectives is to reduce the duration of the external fixation.

HYPOTHESIS

The use of an elastic stable intramedullary nailing system (ESIN) combined with a circular external fixator significantly reduces the healing index.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two groups of patients were compared. In group I, seven patients were operated on for progressive limb lengthening using a circular external fixator associated with an ESIN system: four monosegmental femoral lengthenings, one monosegmental tibial lengthening and two polysegmental femorotibial lengthenings. Nailing was performed via two intramedullary nails already used in traumatology. The date of external fixator removal coincided with that of radiographic healing. The nails were left in place. Group II included 37 patients who underwent limb lengthening by means of an external fixator only. The healing index was calculated and complications were analysed in both groups.

RESULTS

The mean healing index (HI) values were: in group I: 23.3 days/cm for the femur, 22.4 days/cm for the tibia and 11.6 days/cm for polysegmental lengthenings ; in group II: 31.6 days/cm for the femur, 35.7 days/cm for the tibia and 19.9 days/cm for polysegmental lengthenings. Group I demonstrated a statistically significant decrease in the HI for monosegmental femoral lengthenings.

CONCLUSION

A substantially reduced duration of external fixation, limited postoperative complications and prevention of later pathologic fractures are the reported advantages of the associated use of a circular external fixator with an ESIN system in the management of Ollier's disease.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, comparative retrospective study.

Humeral lengthening and deformity correction in Ollier's disease: distraction osteogenesis with a multiaxial correction frame

A case of Ollier's disease with deformity and shortening of the humerus is presented. Lengthening of 9 cm and deformity correction of 50 degrees were accomplished with excellent functional and cosmetic results. Unique features of this case were the use of a multiaxial correction monolateral frame and the formation of normal bone within the region of diseased Ollier's bone.

Treatment of lower limb deformities and limb-length discrepancies with the external fixator in Ollier's disease

BACKGROUND

In this study, we addressed two questions on the treatment for Ollier's disease: (1) how much callus formation occurs when an osteotomy is performed intralesionally and (2) how is the stability of the wires and half-pins that are inserted intralesionally.

METHODS

Four children with Ollier's disease underwent treatment of 12 lower limb segments using distraction osteogenesis until completion of their growth. All osteotomies were performed at the centers of the deformities, resulting in a total of seven osteotomies performed intralesionally.

RESULTS

Full correction of the deformity and full restoration of length were achieved in all cases, but a residual limb-length discrepancy of <10 mm remained. The mean external fixation index in the intralesional distraction osteogenesis group was 39.7 days/cm versus 30.8 days/cm in the extralesional distraction osteogenesis group. Conversion from abnormal cartilage to normal regenerate bone was seen in only one segment. Although approximately two-thirds of the wires and half-pins were inserted intralesionally, in all but one case (in which an iatrogenic fracture occurred) the wires and half-pins were well stabilized throughout the external fixation period.

CONCLUSIONS

Although deformity and limb-length discrepancies due to Ollier's disease were successfully resolved by distraction osteogenesis, enchondroma may arise in distracted calluses when osteotomized intralesionally. However, the stability of the external fixator was sufficient to lengthen limbs and correct deformities even when wires and half-pins were inserted intralesionally.

Treatment of benign bone tumours using external fixation

We present a retrospective study of patients suffering from a variety of benign tumours in whom external fixators were used to treat deformity and limb-length discrepancy, and for the reconstruction of bone defects. A total of 43 limbs in 31 patients (12 male and 19 female) with a mean age of 14 years (2 to 54) were treated.

The diagnosis was Ollier’s disease in 12 limbs, fibrous dysplasia in 11, osteochondroma in eight, giant cell tumour in five, osteofibrous dysplasia in five and non-ossifying fibroma in two. The lesions were treated in the tibia in 19 limbs, in the femur in 16, and in the forearm in eight. The Ilizarov frame was used in 25 limbs, the Taylor Spatial Frame in seven, the Orthofix fixator in six, the Monotube in four and the Heidelberg fixator in one. The mean follow-up was 72 months (22 to 221).

The mean external fixation period was 168 days (71 to 352). The mean external fixation index was 42 days/cm (22.2 to 102.0) in the 22 patients who required limb lengthening. The mean correction angle for those with angular deformity was 23° (7° to 45°).

At final follow-up all patients had returned to normal activities. Four patients required a second operation for recurrent deformity of further limb lengthening. Local recurrence occurred in one patient, requiring further surgery.

A case of Paget's disease treated by distraction osteogenesis

Paget's disease is a localized bone disorder marked by increased turnover usually associated with a deformity of the affected bone. Distraction osteogenesis may be a useful method for correcting the deformity. A 57-year-old woman with Paget's disease had a 3 cm limb-length discrepancy with a 47 degrees procurvatum deformity of the ipsilateral femur. Distraction osteogenesis using a Taylor Spatial Frame was performed, leading to complete correction of the procurvatum deformity and limb-length discrepancy. After improvement of the limb-length discrepancy, the patient felt more comfortable than she had before surgery with less low back pain. This result suggests distraction osteogenesis may be appropriate for the treatment of some severe, complex deformities of the lower limbs in patients with Paget's disease.

The use of the Ilizarov technique in the treatment of upper limb deformity in patients with Ollier's disease

Between 1997 and 2001 three children with Ollier's disease underwent treatment of five upper limb segments using the Ilizarov technique. Average length discrepancy was 8.4 cm in the arm and 4.5 cm in the forearm, but coexisting large angular deformities were the major problem in all the children. Full correction of the axial deviations was achieved in all children. Restoration of length was achieved in all arms, but residual forearm length discrepancy persisted. In four segments conversion of the abnormal cartilage into normal regenerate was observed on radiograms. The problems, obstacles, and complications are similar to those met in more usual lengthening procedures. The Ilizarov technique should be the treatment of choice in restoring the correct axis and length of a limb in patients with Ollier's disease.