Ethical dilemmas in organ donation and transplantation

Surgical Science and the Evolution of Critical Care Medicine

Surgical science has driven innovation and inquiry across adult and pediatric disciplines that provide critical care regardless of location. Surgically originated but broadly applicable knowledge has been globally shared within the pages Critical Care Medicine over the last 50 years.

Lung transplantation from out-of-hospital non-heart-beating lung donors. one-year experience and results

There is currently no method for preservation and functional evaluation of clinical out-of-hospital non-heart-beating lung donors (NHBLD) that can be applied practically and systematically in clinical lung transplantation programs. A new method of preservation and functional evaluation of the lung has been developed in NHBLD that is based on the knowledge of various experimental studies. Initially, the viability of lungs harvested this way was proved from preliminary functional and histologic tests. In November 2002, we started using lung allografts from non-heart-beating donors. Five lung transplantations (4 bipulmonary and 1 unipulmonary) were performed successfully. The short and mid-term results have been excellent and all recipients are alive. We report our initial experience, which we hope will be of help to those involved in clinical lung transplantation programs worldwide.

Solid organ procurement from burned children

BACKGROUND

Burns have constituted a traditional contraindication to solid organ procurement because of concerns that such organs may be damaged by burn shock associated splanchnic ischemia and contaminated by burn wound manipulation associated bacteremia.

METHODS

Over a 5-year period, we attempted solid organ procurement from five burned children who had suffered concurrent anoxic brain injury.

RESULTS

These four boys and one girl had an average age of 8.1 years (range, 2.5-12 years) and burn size of 29% (range, 4-70%). All were injured in house fires and four of five (80%) required prehospital external cardiac compressions. Brain death was declared an average of 35 hours (range, 2.75-77 hours) after injury. Solid organs procured and successfully transplanted from this group were 4 livers, 10 kidneys, and 2 hearts. Two of the livers and one heart were placed into pediatric recipients. Procured tissues included three sets of cardiac valves, and two corneas. All solid organs transplanted were functional at 6 months, although longer follow-up is not available.

CONCLUSION

Early identification and diagnosis of brain death during resuscitation of burn patients with anoxic brain injury, combined with careful resuscitation and support of the brain dead potential organ donor, can result in the recovery of suitable solid organs and tissues for transplantation.

Solid organ procurement from burn patients

With the increasing success or organ transplantation and the consequent increasing scarcity of suitable organs, many traditional contraindications to organ procurement are being reconsidered. One such traditional contraindication to organ procurement is burn injury. We report a case of successful multiorgan procurement from a child with an extensive burn and propose guidelines for solid organ harvest from burn patients.

[Information to relatives of organ donors. Factors of consent or refusal. Results of a multicenter study]

The French law on organ harvesting in brain dead patients allows this to be done without the family's consent, but prescribes to inform the relatives. Despite this, most teams do not harvest organs if the family is strongly opposed to the procedure. Information given to the relatives is therefore a very important point in the management of the donor. This prospective multicentre enquiry was designed to assess the conditions in which relatives were informed, and to determine the criteria which improve the rate of consent for the donation. After such information had been given, a questionnaire was filled in and sent to France-Transplant. Two hundred and seven interviews were analysed over an 18-month period. In two thirds of cases, the relatives were interviewed less than three hours after the diagnosis of brain death had been made. A written information sheet was used in only one third of interviews. Information was given by telephone in 11% of cases. Organ donation was accepted, on average, in 74% of cases. This ratio, which did not depend on the hospital, increased with the age of the donor: 66% for donors aged less than 18 years to 86% for those more than 50 years old. The aetiology of brain death was not a factor determining acceptance of the donation. The main factor was the conditions of interview: acceptance rate was the highest when there was a one hour delay between giving the information on the donor's brain death and that concerning organ donation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Care of the multiple organ donor

Successful organ transplantation offers patients with end stage organ failure the chance of a normal life. The recognition of brain death allowed the use of beating heart donors and this has enabled multiple organ procurement from a single donor. Suitable patients with severe brain injury resulting in brain death, who may be potential organ donors, are to be found on both neurosurgical and general intensive care units. The pathophysiological results of brain death are similar, irrespective of the underlying cause. Severe brain injury may result in the loss of temperature regulation, and the development of diabetes insipidus and cardiovascular instability. The management of brain injury before death often results in abnormalities of fluid balance, due to fluid restriction and diuretic therapy. Other problems such as acute endocrine failure and the impact of their correction on ultimate organ function remains to be elucidated. Good donor maintenance in the intensive care unit and operating theatre is essential if optimal function of the transplanted organ is to occur.