Helium versus oxygen for tracheal gas insufflation during mechanical ventilation

The potential of heliox as a therapy for acute respiratory distress syndrome in adults and children: a descriptive review

BACKGROUND

In neonatal respiratory distress syndrome (RDS) and acute RDS (ARDS) mechanical ventilation is often necessary to manage hypoxia, whilst protecting the lungs through lower volume ventilation and permissive hypercapnia. Mechanical ventilation can, however, induce or aggravate the lung injury caused by the respiratory distress. Helium, in a gas mixture with oxygen (heliox), has a low density and can reduce the flow in narrow airways and allow for lower driving pressures.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to review preclinical and clinical studies of the use of heliox ventilation in acute lung injury associated with respiratory failure.

METHODS

A systematic search was executed in the PubMed and EMBASE databases, with search terms referring to ARDS or an acute lung injury condition associated with respiratory failure and the corresponding intervention.

RESULTS

A total of 576 papers were retrieved. After the majority had been excluded 20 papers remained, of which 6 articles described animal models (3 paediatric; 3 adult animal models) and 14 were clinical studies, of which 12 described paediatric patient populations and 2 adult patient populations. In both paediatric and adult animal models, heliox improved gas exchange while allowing for less invasive ventilation in a wide variety of models using different ventilation modes. Clinical studies show a reduction in the work of breathing during heliox ventilation, with a concomitant increase in pH and decrease in PaCO2 levels compared to oxygen ventilation.

CONCLUSIONS

Although evidence so far is limited, there may be a rationale for heliox ventilation in ARDS as an intervention to improve ventilation and reduce the work of breathing.

Damage limitation in burn surgery

Burn injury differs from other types of trauma in the apparent lack of urgency for treatment. We argue that in order to limit physiological damage and the development of multi-organ failure, management of the burn wound must be immediate and aggressive. Supportive fluid treatment should be judicious in order to prevent excessive oedema causing wound extension. Some potential strategies utilising oral fluid resuscitation are discussed, and potential pharmacological interventions. When associated with other trauma, major burn injury has a detrimental effect on morbidity and mortality, and surgical management of both aspects of a patient's injuries are altered.

Helium-oxygen therapy for pediatric acute severe asthma requiring mechanical ventilation

OBJECTIVE

To illustrate the use of helium-oxygen gas mixtures as therapy for pediatric patients with acute severe asthma requiring conventional mechanical ventilation.

DESIGN

Retrospective review.

SETTING

Tertiary care children's teaching hospital.

PATIENTS

All mechanically ventilated patients with severe asthma admitted to the pediatric intensive care unit from August 1994 to October 2000.

INTERVENTIONS

Within 24 hrs of intubation or admission, patients were stabilized on volume ventilation, bronchodilator therapy, corticosteroids, and antibiotics when indicated. Hypercapnia was permitted while maintaining arterial blood gas pH > or =7.25. A helium-oxygen gas mixture then was begun with helium flow set at 5-7 L/min, and oxygen flow was titrated to maintain desired oxygen saturation. Only sedated, chemically paralyzed patients with adequate pre-helium-oxygen and post-helium-oxygen measurements were statistically analyzed.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Twenty-eight mechanically ventilated patients with severe asthma placed on helium-oxygen gas mixtures were identified who met study entry criteria. Mean patient age was 8.8 yrs (range, 1.1-14.6). Before helium-oxygen therapy began, mean peak inspiratory pressure was 40.5 +/- 4.2 cm H(2)O, mean arterial blood gas pH was 7.26 +/- 0.05, and mean CO(2) partial pressure was 58.2 +/- 8.5 torr. After patients were placed on helium-oxygen therapy, there was a significant decrease in mean peak inspiratory pressure to 35.3 +/- 3.0 cm H(2)O. Mean pH increased significantly to 7.32 +/- 0.06, and mean partial pressure CO(2) decreased significantly to 50.5 +/- 7.4 torr. Initial mean inspired helium was 57 +/- 4% (range, 32-74). Mechanical ventilation days ranged from 1 to 23 days (mean, 5.0). Hospital stay ranged from 4 to 29 days (mean, 10.1), with an average pediatric intensive care unit stay of 6.9 days (range, 2-24). There were two incidences of pneumothorax.

CONCLUSIONS

In the pediatric patient with severe asthma requiring conventional mechanical ventilation, helium-oxygen administration appears to be a safe therapy and may assist in lowering peak inspiratory pressure and improving blood gas pH and partial pressure CO(2).

The effect of helium on ventilator performance: study of five ventilators and a bedside Pitot tube spirometer

OBJECTIVE

To assess in vitro the performance of five mechanical ventilators-Siemens 300 and 900C (Siemens-Elma; Solna, Sweden), Puritan Bennett 7200 (Nellcor Puritan Bennett; Pleasanton, CA), Evita 4 (Dragerwerk; Lubeck, Germany), and Bear 1000 (Bear Medical Systems; Riverside CA)-and a bedside sidestream spirometer (Datex CS3 Respiratory Module; Datex-Ohmeda; Helsinki, Finland) during ventilation with helium-oxygen mixtures.

DESIGN

In vitro study.

SETTING

ICUs of two university-affiliated hospitals.

METHODS AND MEASUREMENTS

Each ventilator was connected to 100% helium through compressed air inlets and then tested at three to six different tidal volume (VT) settings using various helium-oxygen concentrations (fraction of inspired oxygen [FIO(2)] of 0.2 to 1.0). FIO(2) and VT were measured with the Datex CS3 spirometer, and VT was validated with a water-displacement spirometer.

MAIN RESULTS

The Puritan Bennett 7200 ventilator did not function with helium. With the other four ventilators, delivered FIO(2) was lower than the set FIO(2). For the Siemens 300 and 900C ventilators, this difference could be explained by the lack of 21% oxygen when helium was connected to the air supply port, while for the other two ventilators, a nonlinear relation was found. The VT of the Siemens 300 ventilator was independent of helium concentration, while for the other three ventilators, delivered VT was greater than the set VT and was dependent on helium concentration. During ventilation with 80% helium and 20% oxygen, VT increased to 125% of set VT for the Siemens 900C ventilator, and more than doubled for the Evita 4 and Bear 1000 ventilators. Under the same conditions, the Datex CS3 spirometer underestimated the delivered VT by about 33%.

CONCLUSIONS

At present, no mechanical ventilator is calibrated for use with helium. This investigation offers correction factors for four ventilators for ventilation with helium.

Heliox improves ventilation during high-frequency oscillatory ventilation in pediatric patients

OBJECTIVE: To describe improved ventilation during high-frequency oscillatory ventilation when a nitrogen-oxygen gas mixture is replaced by a helium-oxygen gas mixture. DESIGN: Case series. SETTING: A tertiary pediatric intensive care unit. PATIENTS: Five patients with hypoxemic respiratory failure who developed persistent respiratory acidosis during treatment with high-frequency oscillatory ventilation. INTERVENTIONS: Introduction of helium-oxygen into a conventional high-frequency oscillatory ventilation circuit. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Blood gas values (pH, Pco2, and Po2) were compared in these patients during treatment with high-frequency oscillatory ventilation with nitrogen-oxygen gas flow and then for several hours after a change in treatment to helium-oxygen gas flow. An initial 24% decrease in Pco2 was documented, and an ultimate 43% decrease in Pco2 was observed. The mechanism for this improved ventilation may be related to improved gas flow properties as well as increased CO2 diffusion resulting from helium's low-mass density. Oxygenation was not adversely affected in any way. CONCLUSION: In patients with hypoxemic respiratory failure and in whom respiratory acidosis develops during high-frequency oscillatory ventilation, the use of helium-oxygen rather than nitrogen-oxygen may improve ventilation and decrease ventilator-related trauma. Further investigation is needed to validate these findings and to elucidate the mechanisms of improved ventilation.

[Tracheal gas insufflation associated with mechanical ventilation for CO2 removal]

OBJECTIVE

Tracheal gas insufflation (TGI) either continuously, or at inspiration, or at expiration, is a technique associated with mechanical ventilation aimed to enhance CO2 elimination in favouring washout of anatomical dead space. This article analyses the mechanism of action, the techniques and the effects of TGI in presence of hypercapnia, especially in the fame of ARDS in adults.

DATA SOURCES

In addition to some historical or major references, the articles on TGI published over the past five years have been searched in the Medline data base.

STUDY SELECTION

Articles with data on TGI associated with mechanical ventilation were selected.

DATA EXTRACTION

Data on mechanisms of action, technical and practical aspects of TGI were extracted.

DATA SYNTHESIS

CO2 elimination is increased when the TGI catheter tip is close to the carina, when the gas jet is directed towards the latter, by a continuous gas jet, by a high washing gas volume. The effect on oxygenation is minor. The work of breathing is decreased. An increased intracranial pressure is decreased. Circulatory effects are minor. The major risk is dynamic pulmonary over distension. Local complications include dessiccation and lesion of bronchial mucosa by the gas jet.

CONCLUSION

In mechanically ventilated patients, additional TGI is a valuable technique for decreasing anatomical dead space. TGI decreases hypercapnia during mechanical ventilation with limited tidal volumes in permissive hypercapnia. Further clinical studies with large series of patients are required to assess the benefits and the effect of TGI on outcome.

Newer ventilatory strategies

Over the past year a large number of innovations in mechanical ventilation have been evaluated. Three of the most exciting are non-invasive positive pressure ventilation, tracheal gas insufflation and partial liquid ventilation. Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation is now clearly a standard of care in the management of an acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. In addition, its use in other clinical settings is being actively explored. Tracheal gas insufflation appears to be a useful adjunct to mechanical ventilation for the management of carbon dioxide but requires manufacturer-designed devices for safe application. The effects of partial liquid ventilation on lung injury have been more clearly defined in the past year as well as approaches to provide gas ventilation during partial liquid ventilation.