Reassessment of esophageal histology in normal subjects: a comparison of suction and endoscopic techniques

Histological score for cells with irregular nuclear contours for the diagnosis of reflux esophagitis in children

Histological criteria for the diagnosis of reflux esophagitis include basal zone hyperplasia, stromal papillae elongation, and inflammatory infiltrate. However, endoscopic esophageal biopsy specimens may include little or no lamina propria. Intraepithelial T lymphocytes, seen in hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections as cells with irregular nuclear contours (CINC), may have a higher density in children with esophagitis. We evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of a numerical score built up by grading the "classical" parameters and its correlation with CINC density in grasp biopsy specimens obtained from children undergoing esophagogastroduodenoscopy with and without esophagitis. We analyzed esophageal biopsy specimens from 349 children (median age, 5 years) subdivided in 4 groups according to the previous routine histology report: group 1, 144 children with esophagitis; group 2, 65 controls; group 3, 51 children with dubious esophagitis; and group 4, 75 children with esophagitis on endoscopy but a normal histology report. A numerical value was assigned to each parameter; the sum of these values represented the histological score. We also evaluated intraepithelial CINC density (ie, number of CINC per high-power field). We separately analyzed histological sections with and without lamina propria. For both total score and for CINC density, we calculated a cutoff using a receiver operating characteristic curve. Cutoffs of 6 for score and of 4 for CINC density provided the best sensitivity and specificity. Sensitivity of the histological score was better in biopsy specimens containing lamina propria (94%) than in those without lamina propria (4%). Sensitivity of CINC density was satisfactory in both specimens with (78%) and without (75%) lamina propria. Specificity was satisfactory for both parameters. In conclusion, when lamina propria was present in sections of endoscopic esophageal biopsy specimens, histological score provided a better diagnostic accuracy for the diagnosis of esophagitis. However, when no lamina propria was present, as was the case in 67% of our children, CINC density had better sensitivity. In addition, this latter parameter showed esophageal mucosa damage in 34% of previously dubious cases or cases with esophagitis at endoscopy but a previous routine histology report of normal mucosa.

Histological changes in the oesophageal squamous mucosa: correlation with ambulatory 24 hour pH monitoring

AIMS

To determine the value of squamous mucosal histology in the assessment of patients with gastro-oesophageal reflux symptoms.

METHODS

Sixty six patients with reflux symptoms underwent endoscopy with oesophageal biopsy, manometry, and 24 hour oesophageal pH testing. The following histological features were assessed in squamous mucosa: the degree of basal cell hyperplasia, the degree of papillary zone elongation, and the density of neutrophil and eosinophil infiltration. Comparisons were made between the histological findings and the oesophageal function tests.

RESULTS

The correlation between the traditionally accepted histological markers of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in squamous mucosa and 24 hour pH testing was predominantly negative, with the exception of neutrophil inflammation in the squamous mucosa of patients with complicated reflux disease.

CONCLUSIONS

This study was unable to confirm the value of the Ismail-Beigi criteria as histological markers of acid reflux. By inference, biopsy of the oesophageal squamous mucosa is of limited value in the assessment of patients with reflux symptoms.

The Yale-Affiliated Gastroenterology Program. A personal note

The Yale-Affiliated Gastroenterology Program provides an effective combination of tutorial and group dynamics and may be the model for need-based training of subspecialists in communities. If the present university centers work in partnership with quality community programs, the consequent university program may offer more pertinent education and proceed in a more appropriate direction for the field of gastroenterology than that of the currently accepted agenda.

The biopsy diagnosis of gastroesophageal reflux disease, "carditis," and Barrett's esophagus, and sequelae of therapy

Histologic changes indicative of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) are found on both sides of the squamocolumnar junction (Z-line). In the gastric cardia, inflammation is found as part of GERD in the absence of Helicobacter pylori or other causes of gastritis (carditis). The squamous mucosa is the location most likely to show inflammatory changes, such as neutrophils or eosinophils, close to the Z-line, whereas traditional reactive changes in the squamous mucosa are found only in biopsies taken at least 3 cm above the Z-line. Endoscopic criteria for GERD have a morphologic counterpart in capillary congestion and hemorrhage into the papillae, which have largely been ignored by pathologists as secondary to biopsy trauma. A biopsy protocol that maximizes the chances of detecting changes of GERD is suggested. The traditional definition of Barrett's esophagus as requiring 3 cm of glandular mucosa extending into the esophagus is no longer tenable. However, even the concept of short-segment Barrett's esophagus, in which less than 3 cm of intestinalized mucosa is present, often as tongues, is being challenged because random biopsies immediately distal to the Z-line may also show intestinal metaplasia when Barrett's esophagus is unsuspected endoscopically. Moreover, it is difficult or impossible to determine whether these changes indicate the earliest lesion of Barrett's esophagus or intestinal metaplasia in native cardiac mucosa. It is suggested that Barrett's esophagus be redefined as intestinal metaplasia in the lower esophagus. It is presently unclear whether patients with such minimal Barrett's epithelium are at increased risk for adenocarcinoma or require surveillance. Successful therapy for GERD results in healing of disease in squamous mucosa and may result in regression of Barrett's epithelium. In the stomach it may be associated with temporary regression of H. pylori and associated inflammation, migration of H. pylori into the oxyntic mucosa, hypertrophy and hyperplasia of parietal cells, and a variant of fundic gland polyps. Some patients may be at risk for accelerated atrophic gastritis if inflammation is present before therapy.

Intraepithelial cells with irregular nuclear contours as a marker of esophagitis in children with gastroesophageal reflux disease

The diagnostic usefulness of intraepithelial cells with irregular nuclear contours (CINC) (squiggle cells) in esophageal biopsies was investigated in 76 children (range age: 6 months-12 years) with gastroesophageal reflux disease. A further 20 subjects (range age: 10 months-11 years) served as controls. Based on the microscopic changes of the esophagus, according to traditional histological criteria, four groups of patients were identified; esophagitis was severe in 27, moderate in 20, mild in 21, and 8 patients had no clear-cut evidence of microscopic esophagitis. Data are given as mean +/- SD. Intraepithelial CINC had an immunohistochemical profile consistent with T lymphocytes. Patients with severe esophagitis had a CINC density (number per high-power filed) (9.0 +/- 3.5) significantly higher than patients with mild esophagitis (7.0 +/- 3.0) and those without evidence of microscopic esophagitis (6.5 +/- 1.9) (P < 0.05), but not different from those with moderate esophagitis (8.0 +/- 3.6); in all patients groups the CINC density was higher than in controls (2.2 +/- 0.3) (P < 0.01). The percentage of reflux at 24-hr intraesophageal pH monitoring was higher in severe esophagitis patients (11.4 +/- 6.0) as compared to the other groups (moderate: 7.8 +/- 6.3; mild: 6.5 +/- 3.6; no microscopic esophagitis: 6.3 +/- 2.0; P < 0.05). There was no correlation between CINC density and the amount of intraesophageal acid exposure in all patients. Furthermore, 27 of our patients had a normal intraesophageal acid exposure at the prolonged pH test (24-hr % of reflux < or = 4.5): the CINC density was significantly higher in them than in the controls.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The natural history of esophageal Crohn's disease: three patterns of evolution

We carried out a clinical and endoscopic follow-up study of 14 patients with Crohn's disease of the esophagus. The diagnosis was based on the combination of endoscopic and histologic examinations with exclusion of all other possible causes. All patients had other gastrointestinal localizations of Crohn's disease, including oral and anal disease, and the majority also had serious extra-intestinal manifestations. Complete healing of the lesions was accomplished with corticosteroids in 9/14 patients after 2 to 4 weeks. During a total follow-up of 83 years for the 14 patients, 26 "flare-ups" of intestinal and systemic symptoms having a Crohn's disease activity index greater than 200 were diagnosed, on which occasions UGI endoscopy was performed before adjusting therapy. Three patterns of evolution could be distinguished: (1) in eight patients (total 17 flare-ups), neither endoscopic esophageal lesions nor UGI symptoms were apparent during follow-up. (2) Three patients (1 flare-up each) had persistent lesions despite corticosteroid therapy. (3) Three patients (6 flare-ups, 2 each) had relapse of both symptoms and esophageal lesions on each endoscopy, although these lesions had completely disappeared initially.

Oesophagitis, signs of reflux, and gastric acid secretion in patients with symptoms of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease

In a study comprising 100 patients referred to a surgical clinic with symptoms suggestive of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease the value of different diagnostic procedures was investigated. Positive acid perfusion and 24-h pH tests were the commonest findings. Forty-nine per cent showed a normal oesophageal mucosa or diffuse oesophagitis at endoscopy. The severity of heartburn and regurgitation did not differ between patients with normal oesophageal mucosa and oesophagitis of various severities. The severity of macroscopic oesophagitis was significantly correlated to the total reflux time, the presence of reflux or a hiatal hernia at radiology, an open cardia or reflux at endoscopy, pressure transmission or reflux and low lower oesophageal sphincter pressure at manometry. Gastric hypersecretion was found in 66% of the patients. Gastric acid secretion was not correlated to the severity of oesophagitis or to the findings at 24-h pH test. In patients with severe oesophagitis the sensitivity for radiologic, manometric, and endoscopic signs of incompetence of the gastro-oesophageal junction was 94%.

Gastro-oesophageal reflux and oesophagitis before and after vagotomy for duodenal ulcer

Fifty patients undergoing elective vagotomy for the treatment of chronic duodenal ulceration have been investigated pre-operatively and again 3 months postoperatively to determine the extent and severity of associated gastro-oesophageal reflux. Pre-operatively all patients had a normal lower oesophageal sphincter pressure but 50 per cent had symptoms of gastro-oesophageal reflux, 42 per cent had excessive reflux on 24 h pH monitoring and 30 per cent had oesophagitis on endoscopy and/or oesophageal biopsy. Postoperatively, reflux symptoms were present in only 12 per cent of patients but pH studies were still abnormal in 36 per cent and oesophagitis was observed in 32 per cent. Lower oesophageal sphincter pressure was unaffected by vagotomy. Gastro-oesophageal reflux is common in pre-operative duodenal ulcer patients and is not significantly reduced by vagotomy. Careful pre-operative oesophageal assessment is necessary to determine which duodenal ulcer patients require an anti-reflux procedure in addition to vagotomy.