Ventricular fibrillation in the patient with blunt trauma: not always exsanguination

Predictors of Mortality in Blunt Cardiac Injury: A Nationwide Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Blunt thoracic injury (BTI) is one of the most common causes of trauma admission in the United States and is uncommonly associated with cardiac injuries. Blunt cardiac injury (BCI) after blunt thoracic trauma is infrequent but carries a substantial risk of morbidity and sudden mortality. Our study aims to identify predictors of concomitant cardiac contusion among BTI patients and the predictors of mortality among patients presenting with BCI on a national level.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a 1-y (2017) analysis of the American College of Surgeons Trauma Quality Improvement Program. We included all adults (aged ≥ 18 y) with the diagnosis of BTI. We excluded patients who were transferred, had a penetrating mechanism of injury, and who were dead on arrival. Our primary outcomes were the independent predictors of concomitant cardiac contusions among BTI patients and the predictors of mortality among BCI patients. Our secondary outcome measures were in-hospital complications, differences in injury patterns, and injury severity between the survivors and nonsurvivors of BCI.

RESULTS

A total of 125,696 patients with BTI were identified, of which 2368 patients had BCI. Mean age was 52 ± 20 y, 67% were male, and median injury severity score was 14 [9-21]. The most common type of cardiac injury was cardiac contusion (43%). Age ≥ 65 y, higher 4-h packed red blood cell requirements, motor vehicle collision mechanism of injury, and concomitant thoracic injuries (hemothorax, flail chest, lung contusion, sternal fracture, diaphragmatic injury, and thoracic aortic injuries) were independently associated with concomitant cardiac contusion among BTI patients (P value < 0.05). Age ≥ 65 y, thoracic aortic injury, diaphragmatic injury, hemothorax, and a history of congestive heart failure were independently associated with mortality in BCI patients (P value < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Predictors of concomitant cardiac contusion among BTI patients and mortality among BCI patients were identified. Guidelines on the management of BCI should incorporate these predictors for timely identification of high-risk patients.

Commotio cordis, therapeutic hypothermia, and evacuation from a United States military base in Iraq

BACKGROUND

Therapeutic hypothermia (TH) has been demonstrated to improve clinical outcomes after out-of-hospital ventricular fibrillation (VF) cardiac arrest. It remains unclear if TH can be safely and effectively used in the setting of traumatic arrest. Furthermore, the use of TH methods in the pre-hospital and transport environments remain poorly established and a domain of active investigation.

OBJECTIVES

To describe a case of successful TH utilization after blunt trauma with commotio cordis and pulmonary contusion, and to describe the continuation of TH during international fixed-wing aeromedical transport.

CASE REPORT

A 33-year-old active duty soldier suffered blunt chest trauma and immediate VF arrest. He was successfully resuscitated with cardiopulmonary resuscitation and defibrillation attempts. Given his ensuing comatose post-arrest state, he was therapeutically cooled and subsequently evacuated from Iraq to Germany, with cooling maintenance established in flight without the availability of training or commercial cooling equipment. The patient exhibited an eventual excellent neurologic recovery. To utilize TH for this patient, military physicians with limited local resources employed a telemedical approach to obtain a hypothermia protocol to develop a successful treatment plan.

CONCLUSIONS

The patient's successful resuscitation suggests that care should not be withheld for blunt trauma patients without vital signs in the field if VF is present, until the differential diagnosis of commotio cordis has been considered.

A case of commotio cordis caused by steering wheel injury

We report a rare case of commotio cordis caused by traffic injury. The patient was a 60-year-old female driver who suffered severe steering wheel impact to the chest during a head-on collision in which her car overturned. She had no history of cardiac disease. Emergency medical services arrived at the scene within 12 minutes of the accident. Evidence of ventricular fibrillation led the paramedics to carry out immediate defibrillation with an automated external defibrillator. Restoration of spontaneous circulation was confirmed within 2 minutes, along with establishment of sinus rhythm and normal wave form on electrocardiography. The patient was transported to our hospital in an emergency helicopter. General examination revealed chest bruising, and computed tomography of the chest showed pulmonary contusions; there was no other evidence of critical injury. We performed endotracheal intubation, as the patient had consciousness disturbance, and then initiated hypothermic therapy in the intensive care unit. Meanwhile, the hemodynamics remained stable, and there was no recurrence of arrhythmia. On day 15, the patient's consciousness improved, and she was able to communicate. Two months later, she was transported to another hospital for rehabilitation.

Blunt trauma patients with prehospital pulseless electrical activity (PEA): poor ending assured

BACKGROUND

The paucity of information on the outcome of patients experiencing prehospital pulseless electrical activity (PEA) after blunt injury led to the present study.

METHODS

A retrospective review was performed of all blunt trauma victims with prehospital PEA from 1997 to 2001 in an urban county trauma system.

RESULTS

One hundred ten patients, 78 men and 32 women, met study criteria. Seventy-nine patients had PEA at the scene, and 31 experienced PEA en route to a trauma center. All patients were transported in advanced life support ambulances. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation was initiated when PEA was detected. Vital signs were regained en route or at the trauma center by 25 patients (23%). The incidence of pupillary reactivity at the scene was higher in patients who regained vital signs (48% vs. 16%). Only one patient, who has significant residual neurologic impairment, survived. The mean Injury Severity Score of this population was 45.1.

CONCLUSION

If these grim results are corroborated by other investigators, consideration should be given to allowing paramedics to declare blunt trauma victims with PEA dead at the scene.

Termination of resuscitative efforts: medical futility for the trauma patient

Despite years of research on the resuscitation of the patient with critical traumatic injuries, controversy remains surrounding the criteria to waive initiation of resuscitation in the pre-hospital setting or to terminate such efforts in the emergency department. The decision to initiate or continue resuscitation on moribund trauma patients is associated with considerable costs. Ambulance transport using lights and sirens carries potential risk. Emergency department thoracotomy, with exposure to high risk bodily fluids, involvement of numerous staff, and usage precious blood products, is a procedure that has fewer and fewer indications. This review presents guidelines to help determine when to initiate resuscitation for the critically injured trauma patient and when to cease these efforts in the emergency department. Since there are economic, societal, and ethical implications, each system should establish their own criteria, using these guidelines as a basis.

Vasopressin improves survival after cardiac arrest in hypovolemic shock

Survival after hypovolemic shock and cardiac arrest is dismal with current therapies. We evaluated the potential benefits of vasopressin versus large-dose epinephrine in hemorrhagic shock and cardiac arrest on vital organ perfusion, and the likelihood of resuscitation. In 18 pigs, 35% of the estimated blood volume was withdrawn over 15 min and ventricular fibrillation was induced 5 min later. After 4 min of cardiac arrest and 4 min of standard cardiopulmonary resuscitation, a bolus dose of either 200 microg/kg epinephrine (n = 7), 0.8 unit/kg vasopressin (n = 7), or saline placebo (n = 4) was administered in a blinded, randomized manner. Defibrillation was attempted 2.5 min after drug administration, and all animals were subsequently observed for 1 h without further intervention. Spontaneous circulation was restored in 7 of 7 vasopressin animals, in 6 of 7 epinephrine pigs, and in 0 of 4 placebo swine. At 5 and 30 min after return of spontaneous circulation, median (minimum and maximum) renal blood flow after epinephrine was 2 (0-31), and 2 (0-48) mL. 100 g(-1). min(-1), respectively; and after vasopressin 96 (12-161), and 44 (16-105) mL. 100 g(-1). min(-1), respectively (P: <.01 between groups). Epinephrine animals developed a profound metabolic acidosis by 15 min after return of spontaneous circulation (mean arterial pH, 7.11 +/- 0.01), and by 60 min all epinephrine-treated animals had died. The vasopressin pigs had (P: = 0.015) less acidosis (pH = 7.26+/-0. 04) at corresponding time points, and all survived > or =55 min (P: < 0. 01). In conclusion, treatment of hypovolemic cardiac arrest with vasopressin, but not with large-dose epinephrine or saline placebo, resulted in sustained vital organ perfusion, less metabolic acidosis, and prolonged survival. Based on these findings, clinical evaluation of vasopressin during hypovolemic cardiac arrest may be warranted.

IMPLICATIONS

The chances of surviving cardiac arrest in hemorrhagic shock are considered dismal without adequate fluid replacement. However, treatment of hypovolemic cardiac arrest with vasopressin, but not with large-dose epinephrine or saline placebo, resulted in sustained vital organ perfusion and prolonged survival in an animal model of suspended infusion therapy.

Abdominal haemorrhage--a preventable cause of death after field stabilization?

The causes of preventable death vary in different operational settings, and the topic has not previously been explored in a fully developed central European rescue system. The factors associated with potentially preventable death were studied in a retrospective study of 430 fatal traffic accident victims (1980-96) in Lörrach County, Germany. Mission protocols could be retrieved for detailed analysis in 239 of the cases. These were studied in order to identify factors associated with preventable death. At the scene of the accident, 38% of the patients died without cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and 18% after CPR. Four patients died after a certain delay without CPR before reaching hospital. A total of 43% of the victims were admitted to hospital, 5% had received prehospital CPR and the remaining 38% had not. In a subgroup representing the experience of a single emergency physician 60 fatalities were studied. Of these, 27 (45%) patients died within the hospital; almost half of these cases (13/27) had been conscious at some time after the accident and of these, seven (7/13) died from intra-abdominal bleeding within 4 h after admission. The same cause of death was found in 3 of the 14 comatose patients. Pleural drainage was carried out in four patients and unrecognized pneumothoraces or spinal injuries did not occur. Tracheal intubation was employed in 24/27. Medical antishock trousers (MAST) were not available. The data indicate that intra-abdominal haemorrhage is an underestimated cause of death in a comprehensive rescue system, possibly as a consequence of field stabilization. The use of MAST may be a relevant therapeutic option to prevent these fatalities. The method offers the possibility of intra-abdominal compression and haemostasis after tracheal intubation has been performed. Previous controlled studies on MAST may have been biased by faulty methodology (e.g. absence of tracheal intubation) and inappropriate indications (e.g. other causes of shock). The value of MAST in comprehensive rescue systems should therefore be reassessed. The difficulties in identifying factors leading to preventable death in a retrospective analysis, are discussed and it is recommended that a permanent prospective quality control be performed in all cases of fatal accidents in order to ensure the continued improvement of prehospital emergency medical systems.

Critical analysis of two decades of experience with postinjury emergency department thoracotomy in a regional trauma center

BACKGROUND

Despite numerous studies, no clear consensus exists for the optimal use of emergency department thoracotomy (EDT). As such, we have continued to critically review our experience with EDT during the last 23 years to clarify indications for EDT and evaluate its cost-effectiveness.

METHODS

This was a retrospective review of 950 EDTs performed at our regional Level I trauma center during the last 23 years. Cost-benefit ratios were calculated using standardized models.

RESULTS

In 23 years, 950 patients underwent postinjury thoracotomy. We were able to obtain the complete medical records for 868 patients (91%). Overall survival was 4.4%, with 3.9% surviving functionally intact. All survivors of blunt trauma had either palpable pulse or recorded blood pressure in the field. Blunt trauma functional survival when field vital signs were present was 2.5%. Of note, 26.5% of our functional survivors sustained penetrating injuries and had no pulse or blood pressure in the field. Stab wounds to the chest and gunshot wounds to the abdomen were the two mechanisms of injury most likely to be survived. The benefit-charge ratio was strongly in favor of performing EDT at 5.6:1; it was 1.8:1 if adjusted for the cost of maintaining all neurologically injured survivors throughout their lifetime.

CONCLUSION

EDT is efficacious and cost-effective for select patient populations. We suggest a key clinical pathway for the use of EDT that would reduce the number of procedures by at least 32% without changing the number of neurologically intact survivors.