A comparative study of fixation techniques for type II fractures of the odontoid process

Biomechanical comparison of two different compression screws for the treatment of odontoid fractures in human dens axis specimen

BACKGROUND

Lag screw osteosynthesis for odontoid fractures has a high rate of pseudoarthrosis, especially in elderly patients. Besides biomechanical properties of the different screw types, insufficient fragment compression or unnoticed screw stripping may be the main causing factors for this adverse event. The aim of the study was to compare two screws in clinical use with different design principles in terms of compression force and stability against screw stripping.

METHODS

Twelve human cadaveric C2 vertebral bodies were considered. Bone density was determined. The specimens were matched according to bone density and randomly assigned to two experimental groups. An odontoid fracture was induced, which were fixed either with a 3.5 mm standard compression screw or with a 5 mm sleeve nut screw. Both screws are certified for the treatment of odontoid fractures. The bone samples were fixed in a measuring device. The screwdriver was driven mechanically. The tests were analyzed for peak interfragmentary compression and screw-in torque with a frequency of 20 Hz.

FINDINGS

The maximum fragment compression was significantly higher with screw with sleeve nut at 346.13(SD ±72.35) N compared with classic compression screw at 162.68(SD ±114.13) N (p = 0.025). Screw stripping occurred significantly earlier in classic compression screw at 255.5(SD ±192.0)° rotation after reaching maximum compression than in screw with sleeve nut at 1005.2(SD ±341.1)° (p = 0.0039).

INTERPRETATION

Screw with sleeve nut achieves greater fragment compression and is more robust to screw stripping compared to classic compression screw. Whether the better biomechanical properties lead to a reduction of pseudoarthrosis has to be proven in clinical studies.

Feasibility analysis of the use of anterior screw fixation in the treatment of pediatric odontoid fracture

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to determine the feasibility of using anterior percutaneous screw fixation to treat odontoid fractures in children of different ages based on computed tomography (CT) measurements.

METHODS

A total of 176 children were enrolled and divided into 3 groups: group A (<6 years of age; 18 males and 22 females), group B (6 to 12 years old; 40 males and 35 females), and group C (12 to 18 years old; 34 males and 27 females). Using 2-dimensional CT reconstruction technology, we measured the children's odontoid parameters, including the coronal external diameter of the base of the odontoid process, the sagittal external diameter of the base of the odontoid process, the length of the odontoid process, the height of the axis vertebral body, and the angle between the axial line of the odontoid process and the vertical line of the anterosuperior border of the C3 vertebral body.

RESULTS

The mean coronal external diameter of the odontoid process base in children under 6 years old was 4.21±1.62 mm, which was not sufficient to accommodate a single screw. Among children aged 6 to 12 years old, this parameter varied widely, and the mean diameter was 5.50±2.80 mm. In the 12- to 18-year-old group, the diameter was 8.64±1.68 mm, which is similar to that of adults. The values of the total height of the axis, and the angle between the axial line of the and the vertical line of the anterosuperior C3 vertebral body border were lower than those for adults.

CONCLUSIONS

The percutaneous odontoid screw fixation technique is not recommended for children under 6 years old. For children aged 6 to 18 years old, this technique is feasible, but individual differences must be considered preoperatively. Selecting the appropriate screw diameter, length, and angle according to the actual CT measurement result is critical.

Image measurements of os odontoideum in children

BACKGROUND

Conservative therapy is used for children with odontoid fracture; however, when the odontoid fracture is complicated by significant displacement and unstable, surgery is required. Anterior cervical hollow lag screw fixation has been successfully used in adult patients, but until now, there has not been any relevant image measurement research in children with os odontoideum. The aim of the present study was to identify the morphometric changes of normal os odontoideum in children of different ages and to discuss parameters for screw fixation.

METHODS

Computed tomography (CT) scanning data of normal os odontoideum in 120 children of different ages were measured. The parameters were as follows: transverse and vertical diameters of cancellous bone and cortical bone in os odontoideum basilar part, angle and distance from simulation screw insertion point (anterior mid-point of C2 vertebral body) to os odontoideum anterior angle as well as posterior angle, the optimal insertion angle, and the optimal screw length.

RESULTS

The basilar part of normal os odontoideum was roughly round, and vertical diameter was slightly larger than transverse diameter. All parameters measured in the present study increased with age. The safety screw insertion angle range was 16-36°, and the optimal insertion angle ranged from 19° to 22°. The safety screw path length ranges in the 3-5-, 6-9-, and 10-14-year groups were 8-14, 10-16, and 12-21 mm, respectively, and the optimal screw length ranges were 13-14, 15-16, and 19-20 mm, respectively. The height of the axis showed a growing dimension followed by the advancing age in all groups. In each group, the height of the axis of the male is greater than the female.

CONCLUSIONS

For children undergoing odontoid screw fixation for the treatment of type II odontoid fracture, it is important to select the appropriate screw diameter, length, and direction according to parameter changes of os odontoideum based on their age.

Fusion rates for odontoid fractures after treatment by anterior odontoid screw versus posterior C1-C2 arthrodesis: a meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

For odontoid fractures, surgical treatment approaches including anterior odontoid screw fixation approach and the posterior C1-C2 arthrodesis approach are generally adopted in practice. However, the choice of different surgical procedures remains controversial. In addition to surgical technique, the fusion rate is an important factor contributing to the clinical efficacy. Therefore, this study was aimed to investigate the discrepancy in fusion rate between these two surgical approaches through synthesizing the currently available evidence on the topic.

METHODS

A computerized search of Ovid, Medline, Embase, and the Cochrane library up to December 2017 for literature on the complication rate during odontoid fracture treatment was conducted. Risk ratio (RR) with its 95% confidence interval (CI) was pooled to assess fusion rates after surgical treatments, including anterior odontoid screw fixation approach or posterior C1-2 arthrodesis procedure, for patients with odontoid fractures.

RESULTS

Thirteen studies were enrolled in the meta-analysis. Results show that no significant difference was found in the overall fusion rate (RR = 0.96, 95% CI 0.90-1.01). There was no significant heterogeneity among the studies (p value = 0.60). As to age- and economic-level subgroups, there was no statistical evidence to suggest an association of the patient age and economy development level with the choice of surgical approach. However, it is shown that better fusion rates of patients (≥ 60 years) in developed countries received a better fusion rates after posterior fixation compared with anterior group using the fixed-effect model (RR = 0.88, 95% CI 0.79-0.98).

CONCLUSION

Elderly patients (≥ 60 years) underwent posterior C1-2 arthrodesis fixation shows higher fusion rates in developed countries comparing with patients who underwent anterior odontoid screw fixation. Overall, there is no significant discrepancy between these two surgical approaches. However, the conclusion should be verified by further study enrolling larger sample size.

Feasibility of Modified Anterior Odontoid Screw Fixation: Analysis of a New Trajectory Using 3-Dimensional Simulation Software

BACKGROUND

Anterior odontoid screw fixation (AOSF) has been suggested as the optimal treatment for type II and some shallow type III odontoid fractures. However, only the classical surgical trajectory is available; no newer entry points or trajectories have been reported.

METHODS

We evaluated the anatomic feasibility of a new trajectory for AOSF using 3-dimensional (3D) screw insertion simulation software (Mimics). Computed tomography (CT) scans of patients (65 males and 59 females) with normal cervical structures were obtained consecutively, and the axes were reconstructed in 3 dimensions by Mimics software. Then simulated operations were performed using 2 new entry points below the superior articular process using bilateral screws of different diameters (group 1: 4 mm and 4 mm; group 2: 4 mm and 3.5 mm; group 3: 3.5 mm and 3.5 mm). The success rates and the required screw lengths were recorded and analyzed.

RESULTS

The success rates were 79.03% for group 1, 95.16% for group 2, and 98.39% for group 3. The success rates for groups 2 and 3 did not differ significantly, and both were significantly better than the rate for group 1. The success rate was much higher in males than in females in group 1, but the success rate was similar in males and females in the other 2 groups. Screw lengths did not differ significantly among the 3 groups, but an effect of sex was apparent.

CONCLUSIONS

Our modified trajectory is anatomically feasible for fixation of anterior odontoid fractures, but further anatomic experiments and clinical research are needed.

Management of Odontoid Fractures in the Elderly: A Review of the Literature and an Evidence-Based Treatment Algorithm

Odontoid fractures are the most common fracture of the axis and the most common cervical spine fracture in patients over 65. Despite their frequency, there is considerable ambiguity regarding optimal management strategies for these fractures in the elderly. Poor bone health and medical comorbidities contribute to increased surgical risk in this population; however, nonoperative management is associated with a risk of nonunion or fibrous union. We provide a review of the existing literature and discuss the classification and evaluation of odontoid fractures. The merits of operative vs nonoperative management, fibrous union, and the choice of operative approach in elderly patients are discussed. A treatment algorithm is presented based on the available literature. We believe that type I and type III odontoid fractures can be managed in a collar in most cases. Type II fractures with any additonal risk factors for nonunion (displacement, comminution, etc) should be considered for surgical management. However, the risks of surgery in an elderly population must be carefully considered on a case-by-case basis. In a frail elderly patient, a fibrous nonunion with close follow-up is an acceptable outcome. If operative management is chosen, a posterior approach is should be chosen when fracture- or patient-related factors make an anterior approach challenging. The high levels of morbidity and mortality associated with odontoid fractures should encourage all providers to pursue medical co-management and optimization of bone health following diagnosis.

Computational anatomy of the dens axis evaluated by quantitative computed tomography: Implications for anterior screw fixation

The surgical fracture fixation of the odontoid process (dens) of the second cervical vertebra (C2/axis) is a challenging procedure, particularly in elderly patients affected by bone loss, and includes screw positioning close to vital structures. The aim of this study was to provide an extended anatomical knowledge of C2, the bone mass distribution and bone loss, and to understand the implications for anterior screw fixation. One hundred and twenty standard clinical quantitative computed tomography (QCT) scans of the intact cervical spine from 60 female and 60 male European patients, aged 18-90 years, were used to compute a three-dimensional statistical model and an averaged bone mass model of C2. Shape and size variability was assessed via principal component analysis (PCA), bone mass distribution by thresholding and via virtual core drilling, and the screw placement via virtual positioning of screw templates. Principal component analysis (PCA) revealed a highly variable anatomy of the dens with size as the predominant variation according to the first principal component (PC) whereas shape changes were primarily described by the remaining PCs. The bone mass distribution demonstrated a characteristic 3D pattern, and remained unchanged in the presence of bone loss. Virtual screw positioning of two 3.5 mm dens screws with a 1 mm safety zone was possible in 81.7% in a standard, parallel position and in additional 15.8% in a twisted position. The approach permitted a more detailed anatomical assessment of the dens axis. Combined with a preoperative QCT it may further improve the diagnostic procedure of odontoid fractures. © 2017 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res 35:2154-2163, 2017.

Aortic arch origin of the left vertebral artery: An Anatomical and Radiological Study with Significance for Avoiding Complications with Anterior Approaches to the Cervical Spine

Complications from anterior approaches to the cervical spine are uncommon with normal anatomy. However, variant anatomy might predispose one to an increased incidence of injury during such procedures. We hypothesized that left vertebral arteries that arise from the aortic arch instead of the subclavian artery might take a more medial path in their ascent making them more susceptible to iatrogenic injury. Fifty human adult cadavers were examined for left vertebral arteries having an aortic arch origin and these were dissected along their entire cervical course. Additionally, two radiological databases of CTA and arteriography procedures were retrospectively examined for cases of aberrant left vertebral artery origin from the aortic arch over a two-year period. Two cadaveric specimens (4%) were found to have a left vertebral artery arising from the aortic arch. The retrospective radiological database analysis identified 13 cases (0.87%) of left vertebral artery origin from the aortic arch. Of all cases, vertebral arteries that arose from the aortic arch were much more likely to not only have a more medial course (especially their preforaminal segment) over the cervical vertebral bodies but also to enter a transverse foramen that was more cranially located than the normal C6 entrance of the vertebral artery. Spine surgeons who approach the anterior cervical spine should be aware that an aortic origin of the left vertebral artery is likely to be closer to the midline and less protected above the C6 vertebral level. Clin. Anat. 30:811-816, 2017. © 2017Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

An in vitro biomechanical evaluation of an expansive double-threaded bi-directional compression screw for fixation of type II odontoid process fractures: A SQUIRE-compliant article

Odontoid process fracture accounts for 5% to 15% of all cervical spine injuries, and the rate is higher among elderly people. The anterior cannulated screw fixation has been widely used in odontoid process fracture, but the fixation strength may still be limited under some circumstances. This study aims to investigate the biomechanical fixation strength of expansive double-threaded bi-directional compression screw (EDBCS) compared with cannulated lag screw (CLS) and improved Herbert screw (IHS) for fixation of type II odontoid process fracture.Thirty fresh cadaveric C2 vertebrae specimens were harvested and randomly divided into groups A, B, and C. A type II fracture model was simulated by osteotomy. Then the specimens of the 3 groups were stabilized with a single CLS, IHS, or EDBCS, respectively. Each specimen was tested in torsion from 0° to 1.25° for 75 s in each of 5 cycles clockwise and 5 cycles anticlockwise. Shear and tensile forces were applied at the anterior-to-posterior and proximal-to-distal directions, respectively, both to a maximum load of 45 N and at a speed of 1 mm/min.The mean torsional stiffness was 0.309 N m/deg for IHS and 0.389 N m/deg for EDBCS, which were significantly greater compared with CLS, respectively (0.169 N m/deg) (P < .05 and P < .05). The mean shear stiffness for the EDBCS was 238 N/mm, which was significantly greater than CLS (150 N/mm) and IHS (132 N/mm) (P < .05 and P < .05). All 3 screws only partly restored tensile stiffness, but not significantly.Fixation with the EDBCS can improve the biomechanical strength for odontoid process fracture compared with CLS and IHS, especially in terms of torsional and shear stiffness.

Biomechanical Assessment of Stabilization of Simulated Type II Odontoid Fracture with Case Study

STUDY DESIGN

Researchers created a proper type II dens fracture (DF) and quantified a novel current posterior fixation technique with spacers at C1-C2. A clinical case study supplements this biomechanical analysis.

PURPOSE

Researchers explored their hypothesis that spacers combined with posterior instrumentation (PI) reduce range of motion significantly, possibly leading to better fusion outcomes.

OVERVIEW OF LITERATURE

Literature shows that the atlantoaxial joint is unique in allowing segmental rotary motion, enabling head turning. With no intervertebral discs at these joints, multiple ligaments bind the axis to the skull base and to the atlas; an intact odontoid (dens) enhances stability. The most common traumatic injury at these strong ligaments is a type II odontoid fracture.

METHODS

Each of seven specimens (C0-C3) was tested on a custom-built six-degrees-of-freedom spine simulator with constructs of intact state, type II DF, C1-C2 PI, PI with joint capsulotomy (PIJC), PI with spacers (PIS) at C1-C2, and spacers alone (SA). A bending moment of 2.0 Nm (1.5°/sec) was applied in flexion-extension (FE), lateral bending (LB), and axial rotation (AR). One-way analysis of variance with repeated measures was performed.

RESULTS

DF increased motion to 320%, 429%, and 120% versus intact (FE, LB, and AR, respectively). PI significantly reduced motion to 41%, 21%, and 8%. PIJC showed negligible changes from PI. PIS reduced motion to 16%, 14%, and 3%. SA decreased motion to 64%, 24%, and 54%. Reduced motion facilitated solid fusion in an 89-year-old female patient within 1 year.

CONCLUSIONS

Type II odontoid fractures can lead to acute or chronic instability. Current fixation techniques use C1-C2 PI or an anterior dens screw. Addition of spacers alongside PI led to increased biomechanical rigidity over intact motion and may offer an alternative to established surgical fixation techniques.

Anterior single odontoid screw placement for type II odontoid fractures: our modified surgical technique and initial results in a cohort study of 15 patients

Objective: Anterior odontoid screw fixation for type II odontoid fracture is the ideal management option. However in the context of unavailability of an O-arm or neuro-navigation and poor images from the available C-arm may be an obstacle to ideal trajectory and placement of the odontoid screw. We herein detail  our surgical technique so as to ensure a correct trajectory and subsequent good fusion in Type II odontoid fractures. This may be advantageous  in clinical set ups lacking state of the art facilities. 

Methods and Results: In this cohort study we included 15 consecutive patients who underwent anterior odontoid screw placement. We routinely dissect the longus colli to completely visualize the entire width of C3 body. We then perform a median C2-C3 disectomy followed by creating a gutter in the superior end of C3 body. We then guide the Kirchsner (K) wire purchasing adequate anterior cortex of C2. Rest of the procedure follows the similar steps as described for odontoid screw placement.

We achieved 100% correct trajectory and screw placement in our study. There were no instances of screw break out, pull out or nonunion. There was one patient mortality following myocardial infarction in our study.

Conclusion: Preoperative imaging details, proper patient positioning, meticulous dissection, thorough anatomical knowledge and few added surgical nuances are the cornerstones in ideal odontoid screw placement. This may be pivotal in managing  patients in developing nations having rudimentary neurosurgical set up.

Cement-augmented anterior screw fixation of Type II odontoid fractures in elderly patients with osteoporosis

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Closed reduction and internal fixation by an anterior approach is an established option for operative treatment of displaced Type II odontoid fractures. In elderly patients, however, inadequate screw purchase in osteoporotic bone can result in severe procedure-related complications.

PURPOSE

To improve the stability of odontoid fracture screw fixation in the elderly using a new technique that includes injection of polymethylmethacrylat (PMMA) cement into the C2 body.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review of hospital and outpatient records as well as radiographs of elderly patients treated in a university hospital department of orthopedic surgery.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Twenty-four elderly patients (8 males and 16 females; mean age, 81 years; range, 62-98 years) with Type II fractures of the dens.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Complications, cement leakage (symptomatic/asymptomatic), operation time, loss of reduction, pseudarthrosis and revision surgery, patient complaints, return to normal activities, and signs of neurologic complications were all documented.

METHODS

After closed reduction and anterior approach to the inferior border of C2, a guide wire is advanced to the tip of the odontoid under biplanar fluoroscopic control. Before the insertion of one cannulated, self-drilling, short thread screws, a 12 gauge Yamshidi cannula is inserted from anterior and 1 to 3 mL of high-viscosity PMMA cement is injected into the anteroinferior portion of the C2 body. During polymerization of the cement, the screws are further inserted using a lag-screw compression technique. The cervical spine then is immobilized with a soft collar for 8 weeks postoperatively.

RESULTS

Anatomical reduction of the dens was achieved in all 24 patients. Mean operative time was 64 minutes (40-90 minutes). Early loss of reduction occurred in three patients, but revision surgery was indicated in only one patient 2 days after primary surgery. One patient died within the first eight postoperative weeks, one within 3 months after surgery. In five patients, asymptomatic cement leakage was observed (into the C1-C2 joint in three patients, into the fracture in two). Conventional radiologic follow-up at 2 and 6 months confirmed anatomical healing in 16 of the 19 patients with complete follow-up. In two patients, the fractures healed in slight dorsal angulation; one patient developed a asymptomatic pseudarthrosis. All patients were able to resume their pretrauma level of activity.

CONCLUSIONS

Cement augmentation of the screw in Type II odontoid fractures in elderly patients is technically feasible in a clinical setting with a low complication rate. This technique may improve screw purchase, especially in the osteoporotic C2 body.

One-screw fixation provides similar stability to that of two-screw fixation for type II dens fractures

BACKGROUND

Anterior screw fixation has been widely adopted for the treatment of type II dens fractures. However, there is still controversy regarding whether one- or two-screw fixation is more appropriate.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We addressed three questions: (1) Do one- and two-screw fixation techniques differ regarding shear stiffness and rotational stiffness? (2) Can shear stiffness and rotational stiffness after screw fixation be restored to normal? (3) Does stiffness after screw fixation correlate with bone mineral density (BMD)?

METHODS

We randomly assigned 14 fresh axes into two groups (seven axes each): one receiving one-screw fixation and another receiving two-screw fixation. Shear and torsional stiffness were measured using a nondestructive low-load test in six directions. A transverse osteotomy then was created at the base of the dens and fixed using one or two screws. Shear and torsional stiffness were tested again under the same testing conditions.

RESULTS

Mean stiffness in all directions after screw fixation was similar in both groups. The stiffness after one- and two-screw fixation was not restored to normal: the mean shear stiffness restored ratio was less than 50% and the mean torsional stiffness restored ratio was less than 6% in both groups. BMD did not correlate with mean stiffness after screw fixation in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

One- and two-screw fixation for type II dens fractures provide similar stability but neither restores normal shear or torsional stiffness.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

One-screw fixation might be used as an alternative to two-screw fixation. Assumed BMD should not influence surgical decision making.

Surgical treatment of complex axis fractures with adjacent segment instability

This study investigates the clinical and radiographic characteristics of complex axis fractures with adjacent segment instability and describes the outcome of surgical treatment. Twenty-one patients (14 male, seven female; mean age=34 years) with complex axis fractures and adjacent segment instability who were treated between August 2003 and June 2009 were retrospectively reviewed. Treatment selection was based on fracture type and stability of the upper cervical segments. All patients were immobilized with a hard collar for three months after surgery. The mean follow-up period was 12 months (range=6-36 months). No intraoperative surgery-related complications were observed and fusion was achieved in all patients. The outcome was excellent for 17 patients, good for two patients, fair for one patient, and poor for one patient. The upper cervical segments that can become unstable due to complex axis fractures include the atlantoaxial and C2-3 joints. Recommended surgical treatments produce good results.

Direct transoral reduction of anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture during anterior odontoid screw fixation: Review of literature

Background

The anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture is treated either conservatively by halo-vest brace immobilization or surgically by posterior atlantoaxial fusion. Anterior odontoid screw fixation is not advised for this pattern of odontoid fracture because of the difficult trajectory for screw insertion despite its advantage of salvaging the upper cervical spine rotatory range of movement. This article presents a new transoral manipulation technique for reduction of anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture and review of the literature.

Methods

A 24-year-old man presented 2 weeks after a motor vehicle accident with anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture. Intraoperatively, after unsuccessful attempts to reduce the anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture, complete reduction of the odontoid process and proper screw placement were achieved by direct transoral manipulation with an army-navy hand retractor. Additional manual pressure on the spinous process of the cervical spine at the same time has resulted in better reduction. The patient was followed up neurologically and radiologically to assess the reduction and healing of the odontoid fracture.

Results

Postoperatively, the patient was neurologically intact, and his computed tomography cervical spine scan showed proper placement of the odontoid screw with adequate reduction of the odontoid process. At the 3-month follow-up, the patient was neurologically intact and had painless full range of cervical spine movement, and his computed tomography cervical spine scan showed a well-healed odontoid fracture.

Conclusions

Direct transoral manipulation with an army-navy hand retractor can be used to assist in reducing the anteriorly displaced type II odontoid fracture during anterior odontoid screw fixation.

Clinical outcomes of halo-vest immobilization and surgical fusion of odontoid fractures

OBJECTIVE

In the present study, authors retrospectively reviewed the clinical outcomes of halo-vest immobilization (HVI) versus surgical fixation in patients with odontoid fracture after either non-surgical treatment (HVI) or with surgical fixation.

METHODS

From April 1997 to December 2008, we treated a total of 60 patients with upper cervical spine injuries. This study included 31 (51.7%) patients (22 men, 9 women; mean age, 39.3 years) with types II and III odontoid process fractures. The average follow-up was 25.1 months. We reviewed digital radiographs and analyzed images according to type of injury and treatment outcomes, following conservative treatment with HVI and surgical management with screw fixation.

RESULTS

There were a total of 31 cases of types II and III odontoid process fractures (21 odontoid type II fractures, 10 type III fractures). Fifteen patients underwent HVI (10 type II fractures, 5 type III fractures). Nine (60%) out of 15 patients who underwent HVI experienced successful healing of odontoid fractures. The mean period for bone healing was 20.2 weeks. Sixteen patients underwent surgery including anterior screw fixation (6 cases), posterior C1-2 screw fixation (8), and transarticular screw fixation (2) for healing the odontoid fractures (11 type II fractures, 5 type III fractures). Fifteen (93.8%) out of 16 patients who underwent surgery achieved healing of cervical fractures. The average bone healing time was 17.6 weeks.

CONCLUSION

The overall healing rate was 60% after HVI and 93.8% with surgical management. Patients treated with surgery showed a higher fusion rate and shorter bony healing time than patients who received HVI. However, prospective studies are needed in the future to define better optimal treatment and cost-effective perspective for the treatment of odontoid fractures.

The use of bioabsorbable screws to fix Type II odontoid fractures: a biomechanical study

OBJECT

Anterior screw fixation of the Type II odontoid fracture stabilizes the odontoid without restricting the motion of the cervical spine. The metal screw may limit bone remodeling because of stress shielding (if not placed properly) and limit imaging of the fracture. The use of bioabsorbable screws can overcome such shortcomings of the metal screws. The purpose of this study was to compare the strength of a 5-mm bioabsorbable screw with single 4-mm metal and double 3.5-mm lag screw fixation for Type II fractures of the odontoid process.

METHODS

Three different modalities of anterior screw fixation were used in 19 C-2 vertebrae. These fixation methods consisted of a single 5-mm cannulated bioabsorbable lag screw (Group A), a single 4-mm cannulated titanium lag screw (Group B), and two 3.5-mm cannulated titanium lag screws (Group C). Anteroposterior (AP) stiffness and rotational stiffness were evaluated in all constructs.

RESULTS

There was no statistical difference among the ages of the cadavers in each group (p = 0.52). The AP bending stiffness in Groups A, B, and C was 117 ± 86, 66 ± 43, and 305 ± 130 Nm/mm, respectively. The AP bending stiffness in Group C was significantly higher than that in Groups A and B (p = 0.01 and p = 0.001, respectively). The difference in AP bending stiffness values of bioabsorbable and 4-mm metal screws was not statistically significant (p = 0.23). The rotational stiffness of the double 3.5-mm metal screws was significantly greater than that of the 5-mm bioabsorbable and the 4-mm titanium screws.

CONCLUSIONS

Double screw fixation with 3.5-mm screws provides the stiffest construct in Type II odontoid fractures. Bioabsorbable lag screws (5 mm) have the same AP bending and rotational stiffness as the single titanium lag screw (4 mm) in odontoid fractures.

Efficacy of anterior odontoid screw fixation in the elderly patient: a CT-based biometrical analysis of odontoid fractures

In the elderly population, reported union rates with anterior odontoid screw fixation (AOSF) for odontoid fracture (OF) treatment vary between 23 and 93% when using plain radiographs. However, recent research revealed poor interobserver reliability for fusion assessment using plain radiographs compared to CT scans. Therefore, union rates in patients aged ≥60 years treated with AOSF have to be revisited using CT scans and factors for non-union to be analysed. Prospectively gathered consecutively treated patients using AOSF for odontoid fracture with age ≥60 years were reviewed. Medical charts were assessed for demographics, clinical outcomes and complications. Patients' preoperative radiographs and CT scans were analysed to characterize fracture morphology and type, fracture displacement, presence of atlanto-dental osteoarthritis as well as a detailed morphometric assessment of fracture surfaces (in mm(2)). CT scans performed after a minimum of 3 months postoperatively were analysed for fracture union. Those patients not showing CT-based evidence of completely fused odontoid fracture were invited for radiographic follow-up at a minimum of 6 months follow-up. Follow-up CT-scan were studied for odontoid union as well as the number of screws used and the square surface of screws used for AOSF and the related corticocancellous osseous healing surface of the odontoid fragment (in %) were calculated. Patients were stratified whether they achieved osseous union or fibrous non-union. Patients with a non-union were subjected to flexion-extension lateral radiographs and the non-union defined as stable if no motion was detected. The sample included 13 male (72%) and 5 female (18%) patients. The interval from injury to AOSF was 4.1 ± 5.3 days (0-16 days). Age at injury was 78.1 ± 7.6 years (60-87 years) and follow-up was 75.7 ± 50.8 months (4.2-150.2 months). 10 patients had dislocated fractures, 14 had Type II and 4 "shallow" Type III fractures according to the Anderson classification, 2 had stable C1-ring fractures, 8 had displayed atlanto-dental osteoarthritis. Fracture square surface was 127.1 ± 50.9 mm(2) (56.3-215.9 mm(2)) and osseous healing surface was 84.0 ± 6.8% (67.6-91.1%). CT-based analysis revealed osseous union in 9 (50%) and non-union in 9 patients (50%). Union rates correlated with increased fracture surface (P = 0.02). Statistical analysis revealed a trend that the usage of two screws with AOSF correlates with increased fusion rates (P = 0.06). Stability at C1-2 was achieved in 89% of patients. CT scans are accepted as the standard of reference to assess osseous union. The current study offers an objective insight into the union rates of odontoid fractures treated with AOSF using CT scans in consecutive series of 18 patients ≥60 years. Literature serves evidence that elderly patients with unstable OF benefit from early surgical stabilization. However, although using AOSF for unstable OF yields segmental stability at C1-2 in a high number of patients as echoed in the current study, our analysis stressed that using follow-up CT scans in comparison to biplanar radiographs dramatically reduces osseous union rates compared to those previously reported for AOSF.

Type II odontoid fractures in the elderly: an evidence-based narrative review of management

Considerable controversy exists regarding the optimal management of elderly patients with type II odontoid fractures. There is uncertainty regarding the consequences of non-union. The best treatment remains unclear because of the morbidity associated with prolonged cervical immobilisation versus the risks of surgical intervention. The objective of the study was to evaluate the published literature and determine the current evidence for the management of type II odontoid fractures in elderly. A search of the English language literature from January 1970 to date was performed using Medline and the following keywords: odontoid, fractures, cervical spine and elderly. The search was supplemented by cross-referencing between articles. Case reports and review articles were excluded although some were referred to in the discussion. Studies in patients aged 65 years with a minimum follow-up of 12 months were selected. One-hundred twenty-six articles were reviewed. No class I study was identified. There were two class II studies and the remaining were class III. Significant variability was found in the literature regarding mortality and morbidity rates in patients treated with and without halo vest immobilisation. In recent years several authors have claimed satisfactory results with anterior odontoid screw fixation while others have argued that this may lead to increased complications in this age group. Lately, the posterior cervical (Goel-Harms) construct has also gained popularity amongst surgeons. There is insufficient evidence to establish a standard or guideline for odontoid fracture management in elderly. While most authors agree that cervical immobilisation yields satisfactory results for type I and III fractures in the elderly, the optimal management for type II fractures remain unsolved. A prospective randomised controlled trial is recommended.

Anterior fixation of odontoid fractures in an elderly population

OBJECT

Fractures of the odontoid process are the most common fractures of the cervical spine in patients over the age of 70 years. The incidence of fracture nonunion in this population has been estimated to be 20-fold greater than that in patients under the age of 50 years if surgical stabilization is not used. Anterior and posterior approaches have both been advocated, with excellent results reported, but surgeons should understand the drawbacks of the various techniques before employing them in clinical practice.

METHODS

A retrospective review was undertaken to identify patients who had direct fixation of an odontoid fracture at a single institution from 1991 to 2006. Patients were followed up using flexion-extension radiographs, and stability was evaluated as bone union, fibrous union, or nonunion. Patients with bone or fibrous union were classified as stable. In addition, the incidence of procedure- and nonprocedure-related complications was extracted from the medical record.

RESULTS

Of the 57 patients over age 70 who underwent placement of an odontoid screw, 42 underwent follow-up from 3 to 62 months (mean 15 months). Stability was confirmed in 81% of these patients. In patients with fixation using 2 screws, 96% demonstrated stability on radiographs at final follow-up. Only 56% of patients with fixation using a single screw demonstrated stability on radiographs. In the immediate postoperative period, 25% of patients required a feeding tube and 19% had aspiration pneumonia that required antibiotic treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Direct fixation of Type II odontoid fractures showed stability rates > 80% in this challenging population. Significantly higher stabilization rates were achieved when 2 screws were placed. The anterior approach was associated with a relatively high dysphagia rate, and patients must be counseled about this risk before surgery.

Operative versus nonoperative management of acute odontoid Type II fractures: a meta-analysis

Object

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of the criteria described in the literature as the indications for surgery for acute Type II odontoid fractures.

Methods

The authors searched the PubMed database for studies in which the fusion rate of acute Type II odontoid fractures following external immobilization (halo vest or collar) or surgery (posterior C1–2 fusion or anterior screw fixation) was reported. The only studies included reported the fusion rate for either 1) groups of patients whose age was either more or less than a certain age range (45–55 years); or 2) groups of patients with a fracture displacement of either more or less than a certain odontoid fracture displacement (4–6 mm) or the direction of displacement (see Methods section of text for more details). A meta-analysis in which the random effect model was used was conducted to analyze the data.

Results

There was a statistically significantly higher fusion rate for operative management compared with external immobilization (85 vs 60%, p = 0.01) for the patients > 45–55 years. However, the overall fusion rate was > 80% for the patients whose age was < 45–55 years, regardless of treatment modality, and no significant differences were observed between surgically and nonsurgically treated patients (89 and 81%, respectively; p = 0.29). The result of operation (overall fusion rate 89%) was superior to external immobilization (44%) when the fracture was posteriorly displaced (p < 0.001), but for anteriorly displaced fractures, the results of operative and nonoperative management were identical (p = 0.15). The overall fusion rate of operative management of both anteriorly and posteriorly displaced fractures proved to be > 85%, and no statistically significant difference was observed (p = 0.50). For all degrees of displacement (either > or < 4–6 mm) the operation proved to provide significantly better results than conservative treatment. The fusion rate of conservatively treated fractures with < 4–6 mm displacement was significantly better than in fractures with > 4–6 mm displacement (76 vs 41%, p = 0.002).

Conclusions

Operative treatment (posterior C1–2 fixation or anterior screw fixation) provides a better fusion rate than external immobilization for acute odontoid Type II fractures, although in certain situations, such as anterior displacement of the fracture and for younger (< 45–55 years of age) patients, conservative management (halo vest or collar immobilization) can be as effective as surgery. Operative management is recommended in older patients, in cases of posterior displacement of the fracture, and when there is displacement of > 4–6 mm.

Biomechanics of halo-vest and dens screw fixation for type II odontoid fracture

STUDY DESIGN

An in vitro biomechanical study of halo-vest and odontoid screw fixation of Type II dens fracture.

OBJECTIVE

The objective were to determine upper cervical spine instability due to simulated dens fracture and investigate stability provided by the halo-vest and odontoid screw, applied individually and combined.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Previous studies have evaluated posterior fixation techniques for stabilizing dens fracture. No previous biomechanical study has investigated the halo-vest and odontoid screw for stabilizing dens fracture.

METHODS

A biofidelic skull-neck-thorax model was used with 5 osteoligamentous whole cervical spine specimens. Three-dimensional flexibility tests were performed on the specimens while intact, following simulated dens fracture, and following application of the halo-vest alone, odontoid screw alone, and halo-vest and screw combined. Average total neutral zone and total ranges of motion at C0/1 and C1/2 were computed for each experimental condition and statistically compared with physiologic motion limits, obtained from the intact flexibility test. Significance was set at P < 0.05 with a trend toward significance at P < 0.1.

RESULTS

Type II dens fracture caused trends toward increased sagittal neutral zone and lateral bending range of motion at C1/2. Spinal motions with the dens screw alone could not be differentiated from physiologic limits. Significant reductions in motion were observed at C0/1 and C1/2 in flexion-extension and axial rotation due to the halo-vest, applied individually or combined with the dens screw. At C1/2, the halo-vest combined with the dens screw generally allowed the smallest average percentages of intact motion: 3% in axial rotation, 17% in flexion-extension, and 18% in lateral bending.

CONCLUSION

The present reduction in C1/2 motion observed, due to the halo-vest and dens screw combined is similar to previously reported immobilization provided by the polyaxial screw/rod system and transarticular screw fixation combined with wiring. The present biomechanical data may be useful to clinicians when choosing an appropriate treatment for those with Type II dens fracture.

Early predictive value of supine and upright X-ray films of odontoid fractures treated with halo-vest immobilization

BACKGROUND

Although halo-vest immobilization remains a common form of treatment for type II odontoid fractures, nonunion and C1-2 instability may be the result in up to 20% to 40% of patients.

PURPOSE

Supine and upright lateral X-ray films may allow early identification of patients likely to fail halo-vest treatment and earlier surgical treatment with decreased morbidity from prolonged unsuccessful halo-vest immobilization.

STUDY DESIGN/SETTING

A prospective cohort study was performed.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Twenty patients with type II odontoid fractures.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Posttreatment nonunion and C1-2 instability as determined by plain X-ray films and computed tomography scan.

METHODS

Both supine and upright lateral X-ray films were obtained immediately after halo-vest application and at the 2-week, 6-week, and 3-month follow-up. Flexion-extension lateral X-ray films were obtained after halo-vest removal. Patients with nonunion or instability underwent computed tomography scan. Upright X-ray films were compared serially to identify loss of reduction. Pairs of supine and upright X-ray films were compared to measure any change in displacement or angulation upon transition from supine to upright position. Nonunion patients were compared with healed patients to determine any difference in fracture behavior based on serial supine and upright X-ray films.

RESULTS

Twenty patients with type II odontoid fractures were identified during the study period. Three patients with multiple trauma underwent immediate surgical stabilization. Three elderly patients with nondisplaced fractures were treated in a cervical orthosis. Fourteen patients initiated and completed 3 months of halo-vest immobilization. After halo-vest removal, 4 of 14 patients (29%) showed radiographic nonunion or instability. In all 4 nonunion patients, supine and upright radiographs at 2 weeks revealed change in fracture angulation > or =5 degrees between the supine and upright positions. In three of these patients standard serial upright lateral X-ray films failed to identify any loss of reduction. In the remaining patient, progressive angulation of 15 degrees was observed. No measurable change in angulation between supine and upright X-ray films was observed in any patient who healed successfully with halo-vest treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Obtaining both supine and upright lateral X-ray films during the follow-up period may identify patients at risk for failure of halo-vest treatment as early as 2 weeks after initiation of treatment. A change in fracture angulation > or =5 degrees suggests an increased risk of treatment failure and the potential benefit of early surgical stabilization.

Conservative treatment of a comminuted cervical fracture in a racehorse

The 'classical' or 'Hangman' neck fracture involves the odontoid peg (process) of the second cervical vertebra (C2), and is described as an axial, dens or odontoid peg fracture in both the veterinary and human literature. Possible surgical treatment in both foals and adult horses requires a technique that allows decompression, anatomical alignment and stabilisation of the odontoid fracture. A limited number of surgical cases in foals have been reported in literature, but never in an adult horse. A mature Irish Thoroughbred racehorse was diagnosed with a type 2a odontoid peg fracture. Clinical signs included reluctance to move the head and neck, a left hind limb lameness and a neurological status of grade 2. The horse was treated conservatively and raced successfully five months after the diagnosed injury.

Atlantoaxial fusion: a biomechanical analysis of two C1-C2 fusion techniques

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Different atlantoaxial fusion techniques are used for instability. Transarticular screws are biomechanically superior to wiring techniques and equivalent to C1 lateral mass to C2 pedicle (C1LM-C2P) fixation. Recently, C1 lateral mass to C2 laminar (C1LM-C2L) fixation has been shown to have flexibility similar to C1LM-C2P fixation in flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation.

PURPOSE

Compare the stiffness of C1LM-C2P with C1LM-C2L screw rod fixation.

STUDY DESIGN

In vitro biomechanical study.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Stiffness in flexion/extension, lateral bending, axial rotation, and anterior-posterior (AP) translation.

METHODS

Eight fresh-frozen human cadaveric cervical spines (C1-C3) were tested intact and, after a type II odontoid fracture, were instrumented and tested with two fixation constructs: C1LM-C2P screws and C1LM-C2L screws. The testing involved flexion, extension, lateral bending, AP translation, and axial rotation. Stiffness was measured and compared with a repeated-measures analysis.

RESULTS

C1LM-C2P was significantly stiffer than the intact in AP translation (p<.001), lateral bending (p=.001), and axial rotation (p=.002) and equivalent in flexion/extension (p=.09). C1LM-C2L was significantly stiffer than the intact in AP translation (p<.01) and axial rotation (p<.004) and equivalent in lateral bending (p<.71) and flexion/extension (p=.22). C1LM-C2P was stiffer than C1LM-C2L in right/left lateral bending (p<.001) and axial rotation (p=.009) and equivalent in AP translation (p=.06) and flexion/extension (p=.74).

CONCLUSION

C1LM-C2P fixation is equivalent to C1LM-C2L fixation in flexion/extension and AP translation and superior in lateral bending and axial rotation.

Treatment of odontoid fractures with single anterior screw fixation

We evaluate the efficacy and safety of single anterior screw fixation in the treatment of types II and III (Anderson and D'Alonzo classification) odontoid process fractures, and analyse our surgical results. From May 1996 to October 2003, 16 patients underwent single anterior screw fixation for type II (n=12) and III (n=4) odontoid process fractures and had at least 1 year follow-up. We analyzed sex, age, associated injuries, and complications. The radiographic findings, including union rate, union time, changes of fracture shape and metal migration, were evaluated and modified Robinson criteria were used for clinical assessment. Of 16 patients, 15 (94%) achieved bony union at an average of 13.8 weeks. One patient required a secondary posterior procedure after anterior screw fixation. A full range of cervical motion was maintained in 12 patients, a limitation of <25% in three, and of >25% in one. There were no major complications related to the operative technique, including neurologic deterioration or wound infection. We conclude that single anterior screw fixation is clinically and radiologically effective and safe for type II and III odontoid process fractures.

Biomechanical comparison of a fully threaded, variable pitch screw and a partially threaded lag screw for internal fixation of Type II dens fractures

STUDY DESIGN

Stiffness and load to failure were studied in a human cadaver model of Type II odontoid fractures stabilized with either a single partially threaded lag screw and washer or a headless fully threaded variable pitch screw.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether a headless fully threaded variable pitch screw provides biomechanically superior fixation of Type II odontoid fractures in comparison with a partially threaded, cannulated lag screw and washer.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Surgical treatment of Anderson and D'Alonzo Type II odontoid fractures is often performed using a partially threaded cannulated screw and washer. Reported clinical failure rates of this construct are as high as 20%. This technique requires perforation of the cortex of the tip of the dens, placing the brainstem and vertebrobasilar circulation at risk. A headless fully threaded variable pitch screw has not been described for this application.

METHODS

A transverse osteotomy was created at the base of the dens in 16 human cadaver C2 specimens and stabilized using either a headless fully threaded variable pitch screw or a partially threaded cannulated lag screw and washer. Specimens were loaded to failure under a static, posteriorly directed force applied to the surface of the dens. Stiffness and load to failure were measured and the mode of failure for each specimen was determined.

RESULTS

Stiffness and load to failure were greater for the headless, fully threaded variable pitch screw compared with the partially threaded lag screw and washer. The mode of failure for all specimens was via anterior screw cut-out at the C2 vertebral body.

CONCLUSION

A headless, fully threaded variable pitch screw was biomechanically favorable in comparison with a partially threaded lag screw and washer in this cadaver model of Type II dens fractures. The mode of failure at the C2 vertebral body may have important implications for further improvements in construct strength.

Management of odontoid fractures with percutaneous anterior odontoid screw fixation

Minimally invasive techniques have revolutionized the management of a variety of spinal disorders. The authors of this study describe a new instrument and a percutaneous technique for anterior odontoid screw fixation, and evaluate its safety and efficacy in the treatment of patients with odontoid fractures. Ten patients (6 males and 4 females) with odontoid fractures were treated by percutaneous anterior odontoid screw fixation under fluoroscopic guidance from March 2000 to May 2002. Their mean age at presentation was 37.2 years (with a range from 21 to 55 years). Six cases were Type II and four were Type III classified by the Anderson and D'Alonzo system. The operation was successfully completed without technical difficulties, and without any soft tissue complications such as esophageal injury. No neurological deterioration occurred. Satisfactory results were achieved in all patients and all of the screws were in good placement. After a mean follow-up of 15.7 months (range 10-25 months), radiographic fusion was documented for 9 of 10 patients (90%). Neither clinical symptoms nor screw loosening or breakage occurred. Our preliminary clinical results suggest that the percutaneous anterior odontoid screw fixation procedure using a new instrument and fluoroscopy is technically feasible, safe, useful, and minimally invasive.

Management of acute odontoid fractures with single anterior screw fixation

The use of anterior odontoid screw fixation has grown in popularity for the management of acute, unstable Anderson and d'Alonzo Type II and rostral Type III odontoid fractures. This study critically reviews our clinical experience of 48 patients with single odontoid screw fixation for the treatment of Type II and Type III odontoid fractures between 1997 and 2001. This series had a complication rate of 10% (malposition rate 6% and non-union rate 4%), with a satisfactory overall fusion rate of 96%. Odontoid screw fixation is technically demanding and requires strict patient selection, thorough preoperative planning and careful surgical technique. In our experience, advanced age should not be considered a contraindication to anterior odontoid screw fixation, as satisfactory results can be obtained in some of these patients. This study also emphasises that sagittally oblique type II fractures are associated with a high rate of fusion failure when treated by anterior odontoid screw fixation, and should be treated with other instrumentation methods, such as posterior atlantoaxial arthrodesis.

A new table-fixed retractor for anterior odontoid screw fixation: technical note

✓ The authors describe a unique retraction device adapted for anterior odontoid screw placement. A rigidly fixed tubular retractor system obviates the need for dissecting the longus colli muscles as well as for excessive retraction of the trachea, esophagus, and recurrent laryngeal nerve. The proper trajectory for screw placement can be determined by fine manipulation of the retractor as determined by biplanar fluoroscopy. The retractor is then rigidly fixed in position. The tubular corridor permits the odontoid screw to be placed in the usual fashion.

A new table-fixed retractor for anterior odontoid screw fixation: technical note

The authors describe a unique retraction device adapted for anterior odontoid screw placement. A rigidly fixed tubular retractor system obviates the need for dissecting the longus colli muscles as well as for excessive retraction of the trachea, esophagus, and recurrent laryngeal nerve. The proper trajectory for screw placement can be determined by fine manipulation of the retractor as determined by biplanar fluoroscopy. The retractor is then rigidly fixed in position. The tubular corridor permits the odontoid screw to be placed in the usual fashion.

Vertebral artery complications in anterior approaches to the cervical spine: report of two cases and review of literature

BACKGROUND

Cases of lesions to either the carotid artery or the vertebral artery in anterior approaches to the cervical spine are rarely found in medical literature. Two cases of vertebral artery injury in anterior approaches as well as a review of the pertinent literature are presented. In cases of arterial injury, appropriate management strategies are necessary to avoid or minimize harm to the patient.

CASE REPORTS

In the first case, the vertebral artery was injured during decompression of a cervical spinal stenosis while drilling the neuroforamen. Local compression provided sufficient control of hemorrhage. Nevertheless, rebleeding from a pseudoaneurysm occurred 2 days later. After removal of the hematoma, the pseudoaneurysm was treated successfully with coils by an endovascular approach. In the second case, misplacement of one screw in screw-fixation of a type II odontoid fracture caused a pseudoaneurysm of the vertebral artery. This led to a fatal subarachnoid hemorrhage 4 days later.

CONCLUSIONS

In ventral approaches to the cervical spine, precise preoperative planning and a detailed knowledge of the surgical anatomy are mandatory. In cases of injury to the vertebral arteries, direct surgical repair is most appropriate to prevent complications arising from fistulas, late-onset hemorrhages, pseudoaneurysms, thrombosis, and emboli. Alternatively, endovascular techniques or even clipping or ligation of the affected artery should be considered.

The traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis. A biomechanical in vitro evaluation of an instability model and clinical relevant constructs for stabilization

OBJECTIVE

Stepwise destabilization of the traumatic spondylolisthesis C2 with an increasing anterior defect of C2-C3 was investigated. The three-dimensional stabilizing capabilities of posterior transpedicle screw osteosynthesis and two anterior plate systems C2-C3, the H-plate and the titanium locking plate were tested.

DESIGN

A biomechanical in vitro study was performed using a standardized experimental protocol in a spine tester.

BACKGROUND

The extent of the instability of the traumatic spondylolisthesis of C2 within its different types remains unclear. Posterior and anterior approaches for stabilization exist for patients with isthmusfractures at C2, the stabilizing effect has not been demonstrated yet.

METHODS

The motion levels from C2-C3 in six human specimen were tested in flexion, extension, right and left lateral bending and left and right axial rotation. The specimens were tested intact, after destabilization and after stabilization.

RESULTS

In extension and axial rotation, each step of destabilization decreased the moment significantly, to achieve the range of motion of the intact specimen. In flexion a statistical significant destabilization after separation of the posterior longitudinal ligament was present. The flexibility tests showed an increasing range of motion of the posterior transpedicle screws, with increasing anterior instability markedly in flexion and extension. After H-plate and locking plate fixation, a significant decrease of the range of motion resulted in flexion. The stiffness in flexion and extension increased consecutively, while in lateral bending and axial rotation the transpedicle screw fixation showed the highest stiffness.

CONCLUSIONS/RELEVANCE

The traumatic spondylolisthesis of C2 is a significantly unstable injury in case of additional segmental damage of C2-C3. Anterior stabilization in these injuries is mandatory.

Biomechanical evaluation of occipitocervical fixation devices

Human cadaveric occipitocervical specimens were implanted with three types of instrumentation. The devices were tested biomechanically under three modes of loading to determine the stiffness of spinal constructs and the failure mechanisms of the constructs under extreme flexion. The devices tested were the AXIS Fixation System (with custom plate), the Y-Plate, and the Luque rectangle. No significant differences in stiffness among the devices were found under compression and flexion. The stiffnesses of the plate systems were statistically higher than the Luque rectangle in extension and torsion. In extreme flexion, the plate systems failed by fracture of the C2 pedicles. Modern plate systems, for occipitocervical fixation, provide more stiffness and stability than traditional wiring techniques. This study provides surgeons with information on the relative merits of modern plate and screw systems compared with traditional rod and wire constructs.

Anderson type II fracture of the odontoid process: results of anterior screw fixation

Controversy exists in the literature regarding the adequacy of one or two screws for direct fixation of the odontoid process. Proponents of the two-screw technique believe that a single screw is not adequate to stabilize the fracture. Conversely, the insertion of two 3.5-mm screws in the medullary cavity of the odontoid process is technically difficult and can jeopardize the surface area left for fracture healing. The authors conducted a prospective study of 30 cases with Anderson type II fracture of the odontoid process treated by direct anterior fixation using the two-screw technique. The screws used were 2.7-mm cortical screws manufactured from titanium. Two C-arms were used to control reduction of the displaced fracture and for its direct anterior stabilization. The operation was performed with the patients under general anesthesia. The anterolateral incision was made at the level of C4 to facilitate exposure of the C2-C3 disk and for fracture fixation. No evidence of nonunion was encountered. Spontaneous fusion of the C2-C3 segment was found in one case. Limitation of rotation of the cervical spine was a subjective description in a single case. No major complications were attributed to the surgical technique. The two 2.7-mm self-tapping titanium cortical screws provided adequate stability for fixation of type II odontoid fractures.

Efficacy of anterior odontoid screw fixation in elderly patients with Type II odontoid fractures

Object

Type II odontoid fractures are the most common trauma-related dens fracture. Although Type III odontoid fractures have a high union rate when external immobilization is applied, Type II fractures are associated with high rates of nonunion, particularly in elderly patients and those with posteriorly displaced fractures or fractures displaced by more than 6 mm. Because elderly patients may not also tolerate external immobilization in a halo vest, alternative techniques should be explored to identify a method for managing these higher-risk patients. In this study the authors examine the efficacy of anterior odontoid screw fixation in a high-risk group of 10 elderly patients (> 65 years of age) treated for Type II odontoid fractures.

Methods

A retrospective review of all patients with Type II odontoid fractures treated at two institutions between September 1997 and March 2000 was performed. Demographic data, neurological examination, fracture type and degree of displacement, treatment method, and outcome data were examined at discharge. Ten patients older than 65 years who had sustained a trauma-related odontoid fracture and had undergone an anterior odontoid screw placement procedure were retrospectively reviewed. Fracture displacement (mean 6.6 mm) was observed in all but one patient, and in seven there were posteriorly displaced fractures. Seven were successfully treated with anterior screw fixation and external orthosis alone; in one patient in whom poor intraoperative screw purchase had been observed, the fracture healed after undergoing halo vest therapy. Only one patient was shown to develop a nonunion requiring a subsequent posterior fusion procedure.

Conclusions

Odontoid screw fixation can be safely performed in elderly patients, and frequent bone union is demonstrated. However, osteopenia may preclude adequate screw fixation in some patients.

Use of an osteoconductive agent (Norian) in anterior surgical management of odontoid fractures

Odontoid fractures can be successfully treated with anterior screw fixation. Odontoid fractures commonly occur in older patients who may have significant osteopenia. The authors examined the use of a bone substitute to overcome limitations encountered during a procedure in which anterior odontoid screw fixation is performed.

Two elderly patients with displaced, reducible acute odontoid fractures underwent anterior odontoid screw fixation. The intraoperative failure of the anterior vertebral cortex from osteopenic bone and failure to achieve complete contact between the dens and axis were encountered. The defects were supplemented by using the osteoconductive agent Norian. Outcome was evaluated to determine the utility of this method.

Occasional intraoperative failure of anterior odontoid screw fixation may be encountered. Supplementation of bone defects with this osteoconductive agent may facilitate successful bone union in selected patients.

Management of acute odontoid fractures: operative techniques and complication avoidance

In this article the authors describe the management of Type II odontoid fractures with special attention to operative technique and avoidance of complication. Anterior odontoid screw fixation is a procedure the authors have performed over the last 8 years in cases with acute Type II and rostral Type III odontoid fractures. In cases of Chronic Type II odontoid fractures and in patients with transverse ligament disruption, the authors prefer to undertake posterior transarticular facet screw fixation supplemented by bone graft and interspinous C1–2 wiring.

The technical aspects of these procedures are described with a focus on operative nuances. Selection criteria and techniques that the authors have refined over the years have helped them to optimize success rates and minimize complications.

Introduction to odontoid fractures: controversies in the management of odontoid fractures

Although odontoid fractures were first classified more than 25 years ago,5 the management of these fractures remains controversial. Whereas the nonoperative management with external immobilization devices often leads to successful healing, certain fracture features and patient characteristics have been associated with an increased risk of bone nonunion.6,17 Recent technological advances in cervical spine instrumentation techniques have provided additional options for the management of these common fractures.1,12,13,24,27,28 However, an absence of rigorous studies in which the investigators compare management methods may contribute to the varying methods used by spine surgeons when approaching similar injuries.

In this issue of Neurosurgical Focus, various aspects of the management of odontoid fractures are examined. In an evidence-based analysis of methods for treating odontoid fractures the authors examine the best available published data to determine the level of scientific data supporting the use of various treatment options.3 In epidemiological studies the investigators examine factors contributing to the unusual incidence of spinal cord injury with odontoid fractures as well as the unique considerations that may be attendant on the management of posteriorly displaced fractures. In two other studies the authors discuss the application of specific surgical techniques in treating odontoid fractures, whereas in an additional two reports the authors evaluate the difficulties in managing elderly patients with these injuries. Finally, the use of newer osteoinductive agents is examined as a potential adjunct in the surgical management of bony defects in the dens.

Management of acute odontoid fractures with single-screw anterior fixation

OBJECTIVE

Accepted management strategies for odontoid fractures include external immobilization and surgical stabilization using anterior or posterior approaches. Displaced Type II fractures and rostral Type III fractures are at high risk for nonunion. Anterior fixation of odontoid fractures with a single cortical lag screw is a relatively new technique that combines rigid internal stabilization with preservation of intrinsic C1-C2 motion. We retrospectively reviewed our series of 26 consecutive patients who underwent odontoid screw fixation, to further define the safety and efficacy of the technique.

METHODS

During a 5-year period, 26 patients presented with acute traumatic Type II odontoid fractures. Ten patients were female and 16 were male, with a mean age of 35 years. All patients underwent anterior odontoid screw fixation by the senior surgeon (RWH), within a mean of 3 days after injury. All patients were postoperatively maintained in external orthoses, for a mean of 7.2 weeks, and were monitored with serial clinical and radiographic examinations.

RESULTS

With a mean follow-up period of 30 months, radiographic fusion was documented for 25 of 26 patients (96%). No complications related to the surgical approach were identified, and all patients remained in neurologically stable condition. Two complications (8%) were related to the instrumentation; one patient required external immobilization because of suboptimal screw placement, and one patient required posterior atlantoaxial arthrodesis because of inadequate fracture reduction.

CONCLUSION

Single-screw anterior odontoid fixation was associated with a relatively low complication rate and a high fusion rate in this study. We think that this should be the preferred treatment method for acute Type II odontoid fractures.

Biomechanical study of atlantoaxial arthrodesis: transarticular screw fixation versus modified Brooks posterior wiring

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the present study was to compare the biomechanical stability of C1 and C2 vertebrae after treatment of ligamentous instability by either modified Brooks posterior wiring (MB) or transarticular screw (TAS) techniques. We hypothesized that the TAS technique would be more stable because of direct fixation through the facet joints.

STUDY DESIGN

We studied the in vitro stability (arthrodesis) of TAS fixation of C1 and C2 versus that of MB. TAS fixation involves placing screws across the facets from posteriorly at C2 to the anterior surface of C1, plus a bone graft and posterior wiring of C1 and C2.

METHODS

Cervical spines from nine individuals with an average age of sixty-two years (range 51 to 71 years) were harvested from cadavers (six male, three female). C1 and the segment from C2 to C5 were potted to allow motion only at the C1-C2 articulation. The specimens were destabilized by cutting the transverse ligament on both sides of the odontoid and the tectorial membrane between C1 and C2. The MB and TAS techniques were performed by methods similar to those described in the literature. The stiffness of the C1-C2 articulation of each specimen was tested under rotation, lateral bending, flexion, and anterior translation in random order. Intact and destabilized specimens fixed with either MB or TAS were tested in sequence.

RESULTS

Significantly higher stiffness values in the elastic zone were obtained with the TAS technique than with the MB technique for all modes of testing (p < 0.002, t test). Values for the neutral zone (the region where minimal loads produce displacement) were not significantly different between the MB and TAS techniques (p > 0.1, t test).

CONCLUSION

We conclude that stability is significantly enhanced by use of the TAS construct for treatment of ligamentous instability at the atlantoaxial joint for all motions tested in the present study.

Anterior screw fixation of odontoid fractures

BACKGROUND

Anterior screw fixation is the best treatment for odontoid fractures when the fracture line is horizontal or oblique downward and backward, as it preserves atlantoaxial mobility, especially axial rotation. Some details regarding patient positioning and operative technique need to be stressed to obtain the best results and avoid complications.

METHODS

Between 1989 and 1997, we treated 17 cases of odontoid fracture by anterior screw fixation. Only two patients presented with motor neurologic deficit. Fracture line was horizontal in 3 cases and oblique downward and backward in 14 cases.

RESULTS

Adequate reduction and fixation was obtained in all cases except one, where posterior displacement of the screw occurred without neurologic complications. Functional result was satisfactory in all cases except two, where we noted significant limitation of cervical rotation.

CONCLUSION

Successful anterior screw fixation gives the best anatomical and functional results for odontoid fractures. Correct installation is very important for operative success.

Cervical spine models for biomechanical research

Biomechanical models have been used for the understanding of the basic normal function and dysfunction of the cervical spine and for testing implants and devices. Biomechanical models can be broadly categorized into four groups: 1) Physical models, made of nonanatomic material (e.g., plastic blocks), are often used for the testing of spinal instrumentation when only the device is to be evaluated. 2) In vitro models consisting of a cadaveric spine specimen are useful in providing basic understanding of the functioning of the spine. Human specimens are more suitable for these models than are animal specimens whenever anatomy, size (for instrumentation), and kinematics are important. Animal specimens are less costly, easier to obtain, and often have less variability but should be used with care because of the absence of anatomic fidelity with the human. 3) In vivo animal models provide the means to model living phenomena, such as fusion, development of disc degeneration, instability, and adaptive responses in segments adjacent to spinal instrumentation. Choosing the appropriate animal is important. The appropriate animal should have spinal loading, kinematics, kinetics, vertebral size, and healing-fusion rates as similar to those in humans as possible. For better interpretation of in vivo animal experimental results, in vitro biomechanical study using the same animal cadaveric specimen is useful but has not been used routinely. 4) Computer models are developed from mathematical equations that incorporate geometry and physical characteristics of the human spine and may be advantageously used for problems that are difficult to model by other means. Examples are the changes in disc and vertebral stresses in response to graded transection of facet joints and the study of changes in endplate loading caused by disc degeneration. Because these models are purely mathematical, their validation is essential. Validation is best achieved by first incorporating high-quality geometry and physical characteristics of the human spine and then comparing the model predictions with experimental observations. Sometimes an enthusiastic researcher may use a computer model beyond its validation boundary, making the model's predictions unreliable. In general, it is important to remember that a biomechanical model, similar to any other model, represents only a certain aspect of the real living human being. The aspect chosen for representation should be selected with great care. The model should be designed to answer specifically the question asked. Its predictions are valid only within the boundaries of assumptions and limitations that it incorporates.