Artificial intervertebral disc replacement using bioactive three-dimensional fabric: design, development, and preliminary animal study

Surface modifications to promote the osteoconductivity of ultra-high-molecular-weight-polyethylene fabrics for a novel biomimetic artificial disc prosthesis: An in vitro study

A novel biomimetic artificial intervertebral disc (bioAID) for the cervical spine was developed, containing a hydrogel core representing the nucleus pulposus, an UHMWPE fiber jacket as annulus fibrosis, and titanium endplates with pins for mechanical fixation. Osseointegration of the UHMWPE fibers to adjacent bone structures is required to achieve proper biomimetic behavior and to provide long-term stability. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess the osteoconductivity of several surface modifications of UHMWPE fabrics, 2D weft-knitted, using non-treated UHMWPE fibers (N), plasma treated UHMWPE fibers (PT), 10% hydroxy apatite (HA) loaded UHMWPE fibers (10%HA), plasma treated 10%HA UHMWPE fibers (PT-10%HA), 15%HA loaded UHMWPE fibers (15%HA) and plasma treated 15%HA UHMWPE fibers (PT-15%HA). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used for surface characterization. Biological effects were assessed by evaluating initial cell attachment (SEM, DNA content), metabolic activity (PrestoBlue assay), proliferation, differentiation (alkaline phosphatase activity) and mineralization (energy dispersive x-ray, EDX analysis) using human bone marrow stromal cells. Plasma treated samples showed increased initial cell attachment, indicating the importance of hydrophilicity for cell attachment. However, incorporation only of HA or plasma treatment alone was not sufficient to result in upregulated alkaline phosphatase activity (ALP) activity. Combining HA loaded fibers with plasma treatment showed a combined effect, leading to increased cell attachment and upregulated ALP activity. Based on these results, combination of HA loaded UHMWPE fibers and plasma treatment provided the most promising fabric surface for facilitating bone ingrowth.

Cervical subtotal discectomy prosthesis validated in non-human primate model: A novel artificial cervical disc replacement concept?

Objective: To evaluate the biological function of cervical subtotal discectomy prosthesis (CSDP) implantation in a non-human primate model.

Methods: A CSDP was tested for cytocompatibility and osseointegration capacity before implantation in non-human primates. Subsequently, the CSDP was improved based on three-dimensional CT measurements of the non-human primate cervical spine. Eight cynomolgus monkeys were selected for removal of the intervertebral disc and lower endplate of the C5/6 segment to complete the model construction for CSDP implantation. In 18-month follow-up, physiological indices, radiology, and kinematics were assessed to estimate the biological function of the CSDP in non-human primates, including biosafety, osseointegration, and biomechanics.

Results: Co-cultured with the CSDP constituent titanium alloy (Ti6Al4V-AO), the mouse embryo osteoblast precursor cell MC3T3-E1 obtained extended adhesion, remarkable viability status, and cell proliferation. After implantation in the mouse femur for 28 days, the surface of Ti6Al4V-AO was covered by a large amount of new cancellous bone, which formed further connections with the femur cortical bone, and no toxicity was detected by blood physiology indices or histopathology. After completing implantation in primate models, no infection or osteolysis was observed, nor was any subsidence or displacement of the CSDP observed in CT scans in the 18-month follow-up. In particular, the interior of the cervical vertebra fixation structure was gradually filled with new trabecular bone, and the CSDP had achieved fixation and bony fusion in the vertebral body at 1 year post-operation. Meanwhile, no signs of inflammation, spinal cord compression, adjacent segment degeneration, or force line changes were observed in subsequent MRI observations. Moreover, there were no pathological changes of the joint trajectory, joint motion range, stride length, or the stance phase ratio revealed in the kinematics analysis at 3, 6, 12, or 18 months after CSDP implantation.

Conclusion: We successfully designed a new cervical subtotal discectomy prosthesis and constructed an excellent non-human primate implantation model for the evaluation of subtotal disc replacement arthroplasty. Furthermore, we demonstrated that CSDP had outstanding safety, osseointegration capacity, and biomechanical stability in a non-human primate model, which might be a new choice in the treatment of cervical disc diseases and potentially change future outcomes of degenerative cervical diseases.

In-vitro models of disc degeneration - A review of methods and clinical relevance

The intervertebral disc (IVD) provides flexibility, acts as a shock absorber, and transmits load. Degeneration of the IVD includes alterations in the biomechanics, extracellular matrix (ECM), and cellular activity. These changes are not always perceived, however, IVD degeneration can lead to severe health problems including long-term disability. To understand the pathogenesis of IVD degeneration and suitable testing methods for emerging treatments and therapies, this review documents in-vitro models of IVD degeneration including physical disruption, hyperphysiological loading, ECM degradation by enzyme digestion, or a combination of these methods. This paper reviews and critically analyses the models of degeneration published since the year 2000 in either in human or animal specimens. The results are categorised in terms of the IVD biomechanics, physical attributes, ECM composition, tissue damage and cellularity to evaluate the models with respect to natural human degeneration, and to provide recommendations for clinically relevant models for the various stages of degeneration. There is no one model that replicates the wide range of degenerative changes that occur as part of normal degeneration. However, cyclic overloading replicates many aspects of degeneration, with the advantage of a dose-response allowing the tuning of damage initiated. Models of severe degeneration are currently lacking, but there is potential that combining cyclic overloading and enzymatic digestion will provide model that closely resembles human IVD degeneration. This will provide an effective way to investigate the effects of severe degeneration, and the evaluation of treatments for the IVD, which would generally be indicated at this advanced stage of degeneration.

3D kinematic characteristics of lumbar facet joints in sitting position

BACKGROUND

Recognizing the kinematic characteristics of lumbar facet joints is important for the prevention and treatment of lumbar degenerative diseases. Previous studies have been conducted in either the supine or standing position, and there are no measurements regarding the kinematic characteristics of the lumbar facet joints while sitting. The aim of this study was to measure and analyze lumbar facet joint motion characteristics while sitting.

METHODS

Ten subjects (5 males and 5 females) performed the movements of flexion-extension, left bending-right bending, and left rotation-right rotation in a sitting position. Dual Fluoroscopic Image System and computed tomography technique were used to measure the displacement and rotation angle of the lumbar facet joints of the subjects for analysis. The movement characteristics of L3-S1 were measured.

RESULTS

When the subjects were in sitting position, the lumbar vertebra mainly changed in Z-axis and α, β angle when they performed flexion-extension activities. The displacement of the left facet joint was 4.65 ± 1.99 mm at L3-4, 1.89 ± 2.99 mm at L4-5, and 0.80 ± 2.27 mm at L5-S1 in the Z-axis, and the displacement of the right facet joint was 3.20 ± 2.61 mm at L3-4, 1.71 ± 3.00 mm at L4-5, and 0.31 ± 1.69 mm at L5-S1 in the Z-axis. The rotation in the α angle was 6.00 ± 4.49° at L3-4, 3.51 ± 5.24° at L4-5, and 0.97 ± 4.13° at L5-S1, which was significant different. The rotation in the β angle was 2.30 ± 2.94°at L3-4, 0.16 ± 2.06° at L4-5, and 0.35 ± 1.74°at L5-S1, which was significant different. When the lumbar spine performed the activity of left bending-right bending, there were changes in rotation mainly in the Z-axis and β angle. The displacement of left facet joint in the Z-axis was 1.34 ± 2.84 mm at L3-4, 2.11 ± 0.88 mm at L4-5, and 0.72 ± 0.81 mm at L5-S1; the rotation in the β angle was 5.66 ± 2.70°at L3-4, 7.89 ± 2.59° at L4-5, and 1.28 ± 2.07° at L5-S1; when the lumbar spine performed the activity of left rotation-right rotation, there were changes in the β angle. The rotation of β angle was 4.09 ± 2.86° at L3-4, 2.14 ± 3.38° at L4-5, and 0.63 ± 1.85° at L5-S1.

CONCLUSION

The lumbar facet joint motion in sitting position is different in each mode of motion. The horizontal displacement and rotation are predominant during flexion and extension activities, while there are different rotation in bending and rotation. The study shows the coupled motion of the lumbar facet joints while sitting, providing a new perspective on the kinematics of the lumbar spine and the etiology of lumbar degenerative diseases.

Viscoelastic cervical total disc replacement devices: Design concepts

Cervical disc replacement (CDR) is a motion-preserving surgical procedure for treating patients with degenerative disorders. Numerous reports of first generation CDR "ball-and-socket" articulating devices have shown satisfactory clinical results. As a result, CDR devices have been safely implemented in the surgeon's armamentarium on a global scale. However, only minor design improvements have been made over the last few years, as first generation CDRs devices were based on traditional synovial joint arthroplasty designs. As a consequence, these articulating designs have limited resemblance to the complex kinematic behavior of a natural disc. This has driven the development of deformable viscoelastic CDR devices to better mimic the biomechanical behavior of a natural disc. As a result, several viscoelastic CDR devices have been developed in recent years that vary in terms of materials, design and clinical outcomes. Since these viscoelastic CDR devices are fairly new, their weaknesses and strengths, which are related to their design characteristics, have not been well described. Therefore, this literature review discusses design related advantages and disadvantages of deformable viscoelastic CDR devices. As such, this paper can provide insight for surgeons and engineers on specific design characteristics of several viscoelastic devices and could potentially help to develop and design future implants. Eleven viscoelastic CDR devices were identified. An extensive database search on the devices' tradenames in Medline and PubMed was performed next. The devices were categorized based on common design characteristics to give an overview of both category and device specific complications and advantages. Overall, literature shows that most of these viscoelastic CDR devices can provide motion in all six degrees-of-freedom and have a variable center of rotation. Nevertheless, the viscoelastic materials used do not have an extensive history in orthopedics, so the long-term material behavior in vivo is still unknown. Although the viscoelastic devices have common benefits and risks, each specific design and category also has its own design related advantages and drawbacks that are described in this review. Altogether, viscoelastic total disc replacements seem to be a promising option for the future of cervical arthroplasty, but long-term clinical outcome is needed to confirm the advantages of mimicking the viscoelasticity of a natural disc.

Biomechanical analysis of a novel height-adjustable nano-hydroxyapatite/polyamide-66 vertebral body: a finite element study

Background

To compare the biomechanical properties of a novel height-adjustable nano-hydroxyapatite/polyamide-66 vertebral body (HAVB) with the titanium mesh cage (TMC) and artificial vertebral body (AVB), and evaluate its biomechanical efficacy in spinal stability reconstruction.

Methods

A 3D nonliner FE model of the intact L1-sacrum was established and validated. Three FE models which instrumented HAVB, TMC, and AVB were constructed for surgical simulation. A pure moment of 7.5 Nm and a 400-N preload were applied to the three FE models in 3D motion. The peak von Mises stress upon each prosthesis and the interfaced endplate was recorded for analysis. In addition, the overall and intersegmental range of motion (ROM) of each model was investigated to assess the efficacy of each model in spinal stability reconstruction.

Results

AVB had the greatest stress concentration compared with TMC and HAVB in all motions (25.6–101.8 times of HAVB, 0.8–8.1 times of TMC). The peak stress on HAVB was 3.1–10.3% of TMC and 1.6–3.9% of AVB. The maximum stress values on L2 caudal and L4 cranial endplates are different between the three FE models: 0.9–1.9, 1.3–12.1, and 31.3–117.9 times of the intact model on L2 caudal endplates and 0.9–3.5, 7.2–31.5, and 10.3–56.4 times of the intact model on L4 cranial endplates in HAVB, TMC, and AVB, respectively, while the overall and segmental ROM reduction was similar between the three models, with AVB providing a relatively higher ROM reduction in all loading conditions (88.1–84.7% of intact model for overall ROM and 69.5–82.1% for L1/2, 87.0–91.7% for L2/4, and 71.1–87.2% for L4/5, respectively).

Conclusions

HAVB had similar biomechanical efficacy in spinal stability reconstruction as compared with TMC and AVB. The material used and the anatomic design of HAVB can help avoid stress concentration and the stress shielding effect, thus greatly reducing the implant-associated complications. HAVB exhibited some advantageous biomechanical properties over TMC and AVB and may prove to be a potentially viable option for spinal stability reconstruction. Further in vivo and vitro studies are still required to validate our findings and conclusions.

Mechanical and Cytocompatibility Evaluation of UHMWPE/PCL/Bioglass® Fibrous Composite for Acetabular Labrum Implant

In this study, a fibrous composite was developed as synthetic graft for labral reconstruction treatment, comprised of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) fabric, ultrafine fibre of polycaprolactone (PCL), and 45S5 Bioglass®. This experiment aimed to examine the mechanical performance and cytocompatibility of the composite. Electrospinning and a slurry dipping technique were applied for composite fabrication. To assess the mechanical performance of UHMWPE, tensile cyclic loading test was carried out. Meanwhile, cytocompatibility of the composite on fibroblastic cells was examined through a viability assay, as well as SEM images to observe cell attachment and proliferation. The mechanical test showed that the UHMWPE fabric had a mean displacement of 1.038 mm after 600 cycles, approximately 4.5 times greater resistance compared to that of natural labrum, based on data obtained from literature. A viability assay demonstrated the predominant occupation of live cells on the material surface, suggesting that the composite was able to provide a viable environment for cell growth. Meanwhile, SEM images exhibited cell adhesion and the formation of cell colonies on the material surface. These results indicated that the UHMWPE/PCL/Bioglass® composite could be a promising material for labrum implants.

A Novel Height-Adjustable Nano-Hydroxyapatite/Polyamide-66 Vertebral Body for Reconstruction of Thoracolumbar Structural Stability After Spinal Tumor Resection

BACKGROUND

Reconstruction of thoracolumbar structural stability is a formidable challenge for spine surgeons after vertebral body tumor resection. Various disadvantages of the currently used expandable or nonexpandable cages have limited their clinical applications. We sought to develop a novel prosthesis for clinical use and assess its preliminary clinical outcome in reconstruction of thoracolumbar structural stability after spinal tumor resection.

METHODS

Using data obtained from a retrospective analysis of the morphological characteristics of the thoracolumbar vertebrae and endplates in previously reported studies, we modified the nano-hydroxyapatite/polyamide-66 (n-HA/PA66) strut into a novel height-adjustable vertebral body. A retrospective study was performed of 7 patients who had undergone reconstruction of thoracolumbar structural stability with this novel prosthesis from August 2016 to January 2017.

RESULTS

A novel height-adjustable vertebral body (AHVB) composed of n-HA/PA66 with 2 separate components with a 163° contact surface at each end was manufactured. The height-adjustable range was 28-37 mm. No significant implant-related complications were observed in the process of operation. All patients experienced a significant reduction in pain, with the visual analog scale score decreasing from 7.9 to 4.0. Neurological improvement was assessed using the Frankel grading system after surgery. Postoperative radiographic and computed tomography/magnetic resonance imaging findings indicated that the operated segment was stable, the outcome of kyphosis correction was good, and no prosthesis subsidence or dislocation was observed.

CONCLUSION

This novel prosthesis has many advantages in the reconstruction of height, lordosis, and alignment after thoracolumbar spinal tumor resection and has a favorable prospect for clinical application.

ISASS Policy Statement - Lumbar Artificial Disc

PURPOSE

The primary goal of this Policy Statement is to educate patients, physicians, medical providers, reviewers, adjustors, case managers, insurers, and all others involved or affected by insurance coverage decisions regarding lumbar disc replacement surgery.

PROCEDURES

This Policy Statement was developed by a panel of physicians selected by the Board of Directors of ISASS for their expertise and experience with lumbar TDR. The panel's recommendation was entirely based on the best evidence-based scientific research available regarding the safety and effectiveness of lumbar TDR.

Lateral surgical approach to lumbar intervertebral discs in an ovine model

The sheep is becoming increasingly used as a large animal model for preclinical spine surgery studies. Access to the ovine lumbar intervertebral discs has traditionally been via an anterior or anterolateral approach, which requires larger wound incisions and, at times, significant abdominal retraction. We present a new minimally invasive operative technique for a far-lateral approach to the ovine lumbar spine that allows for smaller incisions, excellent visualisation of intervertebral discs, and minimal abdominal retraction and is well tolerated by animals with minimal morbidity.

Biomechanical behavior of a biomimetic artificial intervertebral disc

STUDY DESIGN

The biomechanical behavior of a biomimetic artificial intervertebral disc (AID) was characterized in vitro in axial compression and compared with natural disc behavior.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the strength and durability of a novel biomimetic AID and to demonstrate whether its axial deformation behavior is similar to that of a natural disc.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Current clinically used AIDs have reasonable success rates. However, because of their nonphysiological design, spinal mechanics are altered. To avoid long-term complications, a novel biomimetic AID, with a nucleus-annulus structure and osmotic swelling properties has been developed.

METHODS

Eighteen AIDs in total were tested in axial compression. Six were loaded monotonically to determine strength. Six were tested in fatigue (600-6000 N). Another 6 were used to characterize the axial creep and dynamic behavior (0.01-10 Hz). Creep and dynamic response were also determined for 4 AIDs after fatigue loading.

RESULTS

The AIDs remained intact up to 15 kN and 10 million cycles. The creep and dynamic behavior were similar to the natural disc behavior, except for hysteresis, which was 20% to 30% higher. After fatigue, creep decreased from 4% to 1%, stiffness increased 2-fold, and hysteresis was reduced to that for a normal disc.

CONCLUSION

A strong and durable AID design was introduced. Compared with current clinical articulating AIDs, this biomimetic AID introduces the natural disc annulus-nucleus structure, resulting in axial behavior closer to that of the natural disc.

Design of next generation total disk replacements

To improve the treatments for low back pain, new designs of total disk replacement have been proposed. The question is how well these designs can act as a functional replacement of the intervertebral disk. Four finite element models were made, for four different design concepts, to determine how well they can mimic the physiological intervertebral disk mechanical function. The four designs were a homogenous elastomer, a multi-stiffness elastomer, an elastomer with fiber jacket, and a hydrogel with fiber jacket. The best material properties of the four models were determined by optimizing the model behavior to match the behavior of the intervertebral disk in flexion-extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending. It was shown that neither a homogeneous elastomer nor a multi-stiffness elastomer could mimic the non-linear behavior within the physiological range of motion. Including a fiber jacket around an elastomer allowed for physiological motion in all degrees of freedom. Replacing the elastomer by a hydrogel yielded similar good behavior. Mimicking the non-linear behavior of the intervertebral disk, in the physiological range of motion is essential in maintaining and restoring spinal motion and in protecting surrounding tissues like the facet joints or adjacent segments. This was accomplished with designs mimicking the function of the annulus fibrosus.

Operated and adjacent segment motions for fusion versus cervical arthroplasty: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) represent the standard treatment for cervical spondylolytic radiculopathy and myelopathy. To achieve solid fusion, appropriate compressive loading of the graft and stability are essential. Fusion may lead to adjacent segment degeneration. Artificial discs have been introduced as motion-preserving devices to reduce the risk of fusion-related complications.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We therefore asked: (1) Does the use of a plate reduce motion at the operated level and bone graft compression compared to fusion with bone graft alone; and (2) is adjacent-segment motion higher after fusion with a plate?

METHODS

Motions and compressive loads in the graft were quantified for intact, C4-C5 ACDF without and with a plate, and total disc arthroplasty in human cadaver spines.

RESULTS

At the surgery level all motions decreased for ACDF with a plate. The motions were similar to intact motions after total disc arthroplasty. The motions across the adjacent segment increased after fusion in all loading modes except lateral bending and were closer to the intact for the total disc arthroplasty case. The plate maintained a compressive load on the graft with a maximum increase in extension.

CONCLUSIONS

Unlike fusion, the arthroplasty can restore motion to normal at the surgery and adjacent segments, compared to fusion cases. A cervical plate with a precompression of the graft provides enhanced stability and fusion due to improved compression.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Our findings support the clinical observations that fusion may lead to the degeneration of the adjacent segments. Disc arthroplasty may be able to circumvent the adjacent segment degeneration.

Segmental in vivo vertebral motion during functional human lumbar spine activities

Quantitative data on the range of in vivo vertebral motion is critical to enhance our understanding of spinal pathology and to improve the current surgical treatment methods for spinal diseases. Little data have been reported on the range of lumbar vertebral motion during functional body activities. In this study, we measured in vivo 6 degrees-of-freedom (DOF) vertebral motion during unrestricted weightbearing functional body activities using a combined MR and dual fluoroscopic imaging technique. Eight asymptomatic living subjects were recruited and underwent MRI scans in order to create 3D vertebral models from L2 to L5 for each subject. The lumbar spine was then imaged using two fluoroscopes while the subject performed primary flexion-extension, left-right bending, and left-right twisting. The range of vertebral motion during each activity was determined through a previously described imaging-model matching technique at L2-3, L3-4, and L4-5 levels. Our data revealed that the upper vertebrae had a higher range of flexion than the lower vertebrae during flexion-extension of the body (L2-3, 5.4 +/- 3.8 degrees ; L3-4, 4.3 +/- 3.4 degrees ; L4-5, 1.9 +/- 1.1 degrees , respectively). During bending activity, the L4-5 had a higher (but not significant) range of left-right bending motion (4.7 +/- 2.4 degrees ) than both L2-3 (2.9 +/- 2.4 degrees ) and L3-4 (3.4 +/- 2.1 degrees ), while no statistical difference was observed in left-right twisting among the three vertebral levels (L2-3, 2.5 +/- 2.3 degrees ; L3-4, 2.4 +/- 2.6 degrees ; and L4-5, 2.9 +/- 2.1 degrees , respectively). Besides the primary rotations reported, coupled motions were quantified in all DOFs. The coupled translation in left-right and anterior-posterior directions, on average, reached greater than 1 mm, while in the proximal-distal direction this was less than 1 mm. Overall, each vertebral level responds differently to flexion-extension and left-right bending, but similarly to the left-right twisting. This data may provide new insight into the in vivo function of human spines and can be used as baseline data for investigation of pathological spine kinematics.

Design concepts in lumbar total disc arthroplasty

The implantation of lumbar disc prostheses based on different design concepts is widely accepted. This paper reviews currently available literature studies on the biomechanics of TDA in the lumbar spine, and is targeted at the evaluation of possible relationships between the aims of TDA and the geometrical, mechanical and material properties of the various available disc prostheses. Both theoretical and experimental studies were analyzed, by a PUBMED search (performed in February 2007, revised in January 2008), focusing on single level TDA. Both semi-constrained and unconstrained lumbar discs seem to be able to restore nearly physiological IAR locations and ROM values. However, both increased and decreased ROM was stated in some papers, unrelated to the clinical outcome. Segmental lordosis alterations after TDA were reported in most cases, for both constrained and unconstrained disc prostheses. An increase in the load through the facet joints was documented, for both semi-constrained and unconstrained artificial discs, but with some contrasting results. Semi-constrained devices may be able to share a greater part of the load, thus protecting the surrounding biological structure from overloading and possible early degeneration, but may be more susceptible to wear. The next level of development will be the biomechanical integration of compression across the motion segment. All these findings need to be supported by long-term clinical outcome studies.

Biomechanical and radiographic evaluation of an ovine model for the human lumbar spine

While various species of animal models have been used in preclinical investigations of spinal implant devices to assess their biological adaptation and biomechanical performance, few studies have made comprehensive comparisons to validate their suitability of modelling the human spine. The purpose of this study was to assess essential biomechanical behaviours and disc morphology of the ovine lumbar model. Flexibility testing was conducted on the spines (L3—L4 and L4—L5) of nine skeletally matured sheep. Segmental rotation and intradiscal pressure were measured and load sharing between the intervertebral disc and posterior elements were calculated on the basis of a simplified parallel spring model. Following the tests, the spinal segments were sectioned into a series of sagittal slabs, and transverse radiographs of these slabs were taken to evaluate the variation in the disc height and end-plate curvature. Comparing the biomechanical and radiographic results with published data on the human lumbar spine, good comparability between the ovine and cadaveric lumbar spines was found in terms of the general disc shape and in most of the biomechanical parameters including the range of motion, neutral zone, and load sharing between the intervertebral disc and posterior elements. A few distinctive differences were also found between the two, including flatter sagittal alignment, smaller disc dimensions, and greater lateral bending motion in the ovine model.

Hybrid multidirectional test method to evaluate spinal adjacent-level effects

BACKGROUND

Several clinical studies have documented long-term adjacent-level effects of spinal fusion, due to stress concentration and motion loss at the fused segment. Non-fusion motion preservation devices are designed to eliminate or slow down such adverse effects. Therefore, appropriate biomechanical evaluation of the adjacent-level effects in spine is important and timely. Although many biomechanical studies are available and have provided some understanding of the adjacent-level effects, results have large variation and are conflicting, mostly due to the use of inappropriate and ill-defined methods. A new test method especially designed to study spinal adjacent-level effects is needed.

METHODS

The proposed Hybrid method uses unconstrained pure moment to provide rotation-input for multi-directional testing. The new method has four steps: (1) Intact spine specimen with entire mobile region is used. The specimen is prepared to measure various biomechanical parameters, e.g., disc pressures, ligament strains, and facet loads. (2) Appropriate unconstrained pure moment is applied to the intact specimen and total range of motion is determined. (3) Unconstrained pure moment is applied to the spinal construct (specimen with an implant) until the total range of motion of the construct equals that of the intact. (4) Statistical comparison of the biomechanical parameters between the construct and intact quantifies the adjacent-level effects.

FINDINGS

The uniqueness of the proposed method, to study the adjacent level effects due to fusion and non-fusion devices, is that it applies the needed rotation-input to the spine specimen, using available methodology with minimal modification.

INTERPRETATION

Previous studies have lacked appropriate and well-defined methodologies to evaluate spinal adjacent-level effects. The proposed method uses well-known methodology and yields high quality, and laboratory-independent results for the fusion and non-fusion devices.

Tissue-engineered intervertebral disc and chondrogenesis using human nucleus pulposus regulated through TGF-beta1 in platelet-rich plasma

Human intervertebral disc (IVD) degeneration often initiated from the human nucleus pulposus (hNP) with aging leading to IVD destruction and extracellular matrix (ECM) depletion. Previously, we have successfully employed transforming growth factor-beta1 (TGF-beta1) to promote chondrogenesis of mesenchymal progenitor cells (MPCs) and immortalized human mesenchymal stem cells. In this study, we examine the role of TGF-beta1 in platelet-rich plasma (PRP) on disc regeneration, including proliferation, redifferentiation, and the reconstitution of tissue-engineered NP. hNP cells were isolated from volunteers with different ages and cultured in the presence of PRP. We found that the most effective concentration for hNP proliferation was 1 ng/ml TGF-beta1 in PRP, which was further applied in the following experiments. hNP cell proliferation in all age groups were increased time-dependently by PRP and cell morphologies showed aggregation. The mRNA of Sox9, type II collagen, and aggrecan were all significantly upregulated by PRP through RT-PCR. Glycosaminoglycan (GAG) accumulation reached the highest value at day 7 and continued to day 9 culture. PRP promoted NP regeneration via the Smad pathway was also determined and highly activated p-Smad2/3 at 30 min and continuously sustained to 120 min. Immunostaining of type II collagen indicates that PRP participates in chondrogenesis of tissue-engineered NP with collagen scaffolds. We concluded that growth factors in PRP can effectively react as a growth factor cocktail to induce hNP proliferation and differentiation, and also promote tissue-engineered NP formation. These findings are the first to demonstrate that PRP might be a therapeutic candidate for prevention of disc degeneration.

Multidirectional flexibility analysis of anterior and posterior lumbar artificial disc reconstruction: in vitro human cadaveric spine model

The in vitro multidirectional flexibility analysis was conducted to investigate the initial biomechanical effect of biomimetic artificial intervertebral disc replacement from either anterior or posterior approach in a cadaveric lumbosacral spine model. Two designs of anterior total and posterior subtotal artificial discs were developed using bioactive three-dimensional fabric and bioresorbable hydroxyapatite/poly-l-lactide material (3DF disc). Both models were designed to obtain the stable interface bonding to vertebral endplates with maximum surface area occupation. Using seven cadaveric lumbosacral spines, the following three anterior reconstruction methods were sequentially performed at L4-5 level: anterior 3DF disc replacement; anterior BAK cages (BAK); and posterior pedicle screw fixation and anterior BAK cages combined (BAK + PS). The L2-3 level received two methods of posterior reconstructions: subtotal 3DF disc replacement (two implants), and posterior interbody cages and pedicle screw fixation (PLIF). Six unconstrained pure moments were applied and three-dimensional segmental motions were measured with an optoelectronic motion measurement system. The center of rotation (COR) calculation was conducted radiographically using flexion-extension films. Both anterior and posterior 3DF replacements statistically demonstrated equivalent range of motions (ROMs) in all loading modes compared to intact segment. Anterior BAK, BAK + PS, and PLIF demonstrated significantly lower ROMs when compared to intact and 3DF groups (P<0.05). The 3DF reconstruction tended to realign the COR to the posterior third or surrounding position at the operative disc level. The stand-alone lumbar 3DF disc replacement demonstrated biomechanical characteristics nearly equivalent to the intact spinal segments even through anterior or posterior approach in vitro, suggesting an excellent clinical potential.

Enhanced repair of large osteochondral defects using a combination of artificial cartilage and basic fibroblast growth factor

The purpose of this study was to examine the efficacy of a combination of artificial cartilage and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) for the repair of large osteochondral defects. The artificial cartilage was a three-dimensional fabric (3-DF) composed of an ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene fiber with a triaxial three-dimensional structure. We implanted 3-DF impregnated with type I collagen gel containing 500 ng of bFGF (bFGF-treated group) or 3-DF impregnated with type I collagen gel alone (non-treated group) into a large full-thickness osteochondral defect (6 x 6 x 3 mm) of the patellar groove of rabbits. The defect area was examined grossly, histologically and biomechanically 4-48 weeks after surgery. Bone ingrowth into and around the 3-DF was evaluated with micro-computed tomography (micro-CT). Addition of bFGF to the 3-DF greatly accelerated cartilage formation on the articular surface and subchondral bone formation into and around the 3-DF, and improved biomechanical properties. These findings suggest that a combination of artificial cartilage and bFGF is clinically useful in cases involving large osteochondral defects.

Intradiscal Electrothermal Annuloplasty

Low back pain is a common problem, and although the majority of cases of low back pain resolve, a subset of patients will continue to have intractable pain despite appropriate conservative treatments. Intradiscal electrothermal annuloplasty is a minimally invasive spinal procedure that has been proposed to treat provocation discography-proven internal disk disruption syndrome. The early uncontrolled and nonrandomized intradiscal electrothermal annuloplasty literature suggests it may provide some relief in a small proportion of strictly defined patients; however, more recent randomized, placebo-controlled trials have not substantiated these initial findings. This article will review the published literature, indications, contraindications, safety, and efficacy of the intradiscal electrothermal annuloplasty procedure for the treatment of chronic, intractable, axial back pain.

A biomechanical and histological evaluation of a bioresorbable lumbar interbody fusion cage

Novel spinal interbody fusion cages made of bioactive and bioresorbable composites by a unique forging process were developed. Previous in vitro study demonstrated that these cages marked excellent biomechanical values. The purpose of the present in vivo study was to evaluate the viability and advantage of this forged composite of uncalcined hydroxyapatite/poly L-Lactide (F-u-HA/PLLA) cage radiographically, biomechanically, and histologically, when compared to conventional autologous iliac bone (AIB) and carbon fiber cage (CFC). Twenty-five mature sheep underwent posterior lumbar interbody fusion at L2-3 level with pedicle screws system made of titanium. Three types of interbody fusion implants were grafted: AIB (n = 7), CFCs (n = 9), F-u-HA/PLLA cages (n = 9). Two types of cages were packed with autologous fragmented cancellous bone harvested locally. All animals were euthanized at 120 days after surgery. The fusion scoring using the coronal view CT scans was designed to three-dimensionally evaluate fusion quality within and around cages. The mean CT scores of three groups were 33.3 points, 35.0 points, and 33.6 points in AIB, CFC, and F-u-HA/PLLA cage groups, respectively (full-score: 56 points). Statistical differences were not detected among the three groups. The mean range of motion values among fused groups had no significant difference under all pure loadings. The range of motion showed strong and significant correlation with the CT fusion scores. Histologic results demonstrated that F-u-HA/PLLA cages contacted with the surrounding bone directly, and CFC was encircled with thick fibrous tissue layers without any sign of inflammation around cages. The fusion quality of fused spinal segment using F-u-HA/PLLA cages was equal to that of AIB or CFCs both radiographically and biomechanically. In the histological observation, biocompatibility of F-u-HA/PLLA cage was obviously superior to CFC. It has been confirmed that the novel bioactive and bioresorbable cages had valuable advantages over existing CFC for use in spinal reconstructive surgery.

Multidirectional flexibility analysis of cervical artificial disc reconstruction: in vitro human cadaveric spine model

OBJECT

This in vitro experimental study was conducted to investigate the initial biomechanical effect of artificial intervertebral disc replacement in the cervical spine. The multidirectional flexibility of replaced and adjacent spinal segments were analyzed using a cadaveric cervical spine model.

METHODS

The following three cervical reconstructions were sequentially performed at the C5-6 level after anterior discectomy in seven human cadaveric occipitocervical spines: anterior artificial disc replacement with a bioactive three-dimensional (3D) fabric disc (FD); anterior iliac bone graft; and anterior plate fixation with iliac bone graft. Six unconstrained pure moments were applied with a 6-df spine simulator, and 3D segmental motions at the operative and adjacent segments were measured with an optoelectronic motion measurement system. The 3D FD group demonstrated statistically equivalent ranges of motion (ROMs) when compared with intact values in axial rotation and lateral bending. The 45% increase in flexion-extension ROM was demonstrated in 3D FD group; however, neutral zone analysis did not reach statistical significance between the intact spine and 3D FD. The anterior iliac bone graft and iliac bone graft reconstructions demonstrated statistically lower ROMs when compared with 3D FD in all loading modes (p < 0.05). The adjacent-level ROMs of the 3D FD group demonstrated nearly physiological characteristics at upper and lower adjacent levels. Excellent stability at the interface was maintained during the whole testing without any device displacement and dislodgment.

CONCLUSIONS

The stand-alone cervical 3D FD demonstrated nearly physiological biomechanical characteristics at both operative and adjacent spinal segments in vitro, indicating an excellent clinical potential for cervical artificial disc replacement.

Neurological complications of lumbar artificial disc replacement and comparison of clinical results with those related to lumbar arthrodesis in the literature: results of a multicenter, prospective, randomized investigational device exemption study of Charité intervertebral disc

Object. Arthrodesis is the gold standard for surgical treatment of lumbar degenerative disc disease (DDD). Solid fusion, however, can cause stress and increased motion in the segments adjacent to the fused level. This may initiate and/or accelerate the adjacent-segment disease process. Artificial discs are designed to restore and maintain normal motion of the lumbar intervertebral segment. Restoring and maintaining normal motion of the segment reduces stresses and loads on adjacent level segments. A US Food and Drug Administration Investigational Device Exemptions multicentered study of the Charité artificial disc was completed. The control group consisted of individuals who underwent anterior lumbar interbody fusion involving BAK cages and iliac crest bone graft. This is the first report of Class I data in which a lumbar artificial disc is compared with lumbar fusion.

Methods. Of 304 individuals enrolled in the study, 205 were randomized to the Charité disc-treated group and 99 to the BAK fusion—treated (control) group. Neurological status was equivalent between the two groups at 6, 12, and 24 months postoperatively. The number of patients with major, minor, or other neurological complications was equivalent. There was a greater incidence of both major and minor complications in the BAK fusion group at 0 to 42 days postoperatively. Compared with data reported in the lumbar fusion literature, the Charité disc—treated patients had equivalent or better mean changes in visual analog scale and Oswestry Disability Index scores.

Conclusions. The Charité artificial disc is safe and effective for the treatment of single-level lumbar DDD, resulting in no higher incidence of neurological complications compared with BAK-assisted fusion and leading to equivalent or better outcomes compared with those obtained in the control group and those reported in the lumbar fusion literature.

Tissue engineered nucleus pulposus tissue formed on a porous calcium polyphosphate substrate

STUDY DESIGN

This study describes the formation of nucleus pulposus tissue using a novel tissue engineering approach.

OBJECTIVES

To determine if a construct composed of nucleus pulposus tissue on the surface of a calcium polyphosphate substrate could be formed in vitro with properties similar to native nucleus pulposus tissue.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

There is no optimal treatment for the persistent pain associated with intervertebral disc degeneration. Disc replacement using artificial intervertebral discs has met with some success, and biologic transplantation is limited by the availability of donor tissues.

METHODS

Nucleus pulposus cells were isolated from bovine caudal intervertebral discs. Cells were seeded at high density on the upper surface of a porous bone substitute material (calcium polyphosphate) and maintained up to 6 weeks in culture. In vitro formed tissue was compared to native nucleus pulposus for histologic appearance, biochemical composition (tissue cellularity, proteoglycan and collagen accumulation), and compressive mechanical properties.

RESULTS

When maintained on the surface of a three-dimensional substrate, nucleus pulposus cells formed a continuous layer of tissue with a proteoglycan content equivalent to the native tissue. Although collagen accumulation attained only 26% than that of the native tissue, there was no difference in tissue stiffness, viscosity, or weight-bearing capacity of the in vitro formed tissue when compared with the native tissue.

CONCLUSION

Nucleus pulposus-like tissue formed in vitro on the surface of a calcium polyphosphate substrate resembles the native tissue in terms of proteoglycan content and compressive mechanical properties. These studies are the first step toward developing a functional spinal unit in vitro.

Two-year observation of artificial intervertebral disc replacement: results after supplemental ultra—high strength bioresorbable spinal stabilization

Object. This 2-year experimental study was conducted to investigate the efficacy of a bioactive three-dimensional (3D) fabric disc for lumbar intervertebral disc replacement. The authors used a bioresorbable spinal fixation rod consisting of a forged composite of particulate unsintered hydroxyapatite/poly-l-lactide acid (HA/PLLA) for stability augmentation. The biomechanical and histological alterations as well as possible device-related loosening were examined at 2 years postoperatively.

Methods. Two lumbar intervertebral discs (L2–3 and L4–5) were replaced with the 3D fabric discs, which were augmented by two titanium screws and a spanning bioresorbable rod (HA/PLLA). The segmental biomechanics and interface bone ingrowth were investigated at 6, 15, and 24 months postoperatively, and results were compared with the other two surgical groups (3D fabric disc alone; 3D fabric disc with additional anterior instrumentation stabilization). The 3D fabric disc and HA/PLLA—spinal segments demonstrated segmental mobility at 15 and 24 months; however, the range of motion (ROM) in flexion—extension decreased to 49 and 40%, respectively, despite statistically equivalent preserved torsional ROM. Histologically there was excellent osseous fusion at the 3D fabric disc surface—vertebral body interface. At 2 years posttreatment, no adverse tissue reaction nor aseptic loosening of the device was observed.

Conclusions. Intervertebral disc replacement with the 3D fabric disc was viable and when used in conjunction with the bioresorbable HA/PLLA spinal augmentation. Further refinements of device design to create a stand-alone type are necessary to obviate the need for additional spinal stabilization.

Intervertebral disc prostheses

STUDY DESIGN

This article is based on a comprehensive review of the literature related to intervertebral disc prostheses.

OBJECTIVE

To compile an overview of the results and complications related to various types of lumbar and cervical disc replacements.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

A functional disc prosthesis has been sought since the 1950s. Although there were a few early attempts, disc replacement did not become a viable therapy until the late 1980s. Devices that were used in Europe at that time are now being evaluated in the United States in clinical trials. Cervical disc replacements are currently in the early stages of development and evaluation.

METHODS

A thorough literature search was conducted to identify articles published on intervertebral disc prostheses. Proceedings from conferences were reviewed as well. Articles were classified by topics, including lumbar total disc replacement, disc nucleus replacement, and cervical disc replacement.

RESULTS

Results of total disc replacement are favorable, with 63-85% of patients having a good outcome. As with any procedure, issues related to patient selection, operative technique, and device size selection were learned from the early experiences with these devices. There has been only one disc nucleus replacement used in an appreciable number of patients. This has yielded good results, but there have been problems related to device displacement. There are increasing reports on the use of cervical disc replacements, but they are still in the early evaluation phases. However, as with the lumbar counterparts, new designs are being evaluated.

DISCUSSION

Although still in the early phases of development, functional disc replacement will become a part of the spine surgeon's armamentarium for the treatment of patients with disc-related pain unresponsive to nonoperative care. The future in this area is exciting and bright with the introduction of new materials and new designs for implants. However, as with any new technology, there must be careful consideration of the safety of the devices, and their effectiveness will only be determined in long-term follow-up studies.

Bone ingrowth fixation of artificial intervertebral disc consisting of bioceramic-coated three-dimensional fabric

STUDY DESIGN

The bone-bonding characteristic of the new artificial intervertebral disc consisting of bioceramic-coated three-dimensional fabric was evaluated mechanically and histologically in an in vivo sheep model.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the mechanical properties and the histologic appearance of the interface between the three-dimensional fabric disc and the vertebral body, and to evaluate these alterations in vivo under a spinal segmentally mobile condition.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Bone ingrowth to the bioceramic-coated three-dimensional fabric surface had been demonstrated already under a stable environment in preliminary animal studies.

METHODS

For this study, 20 sheep underwent two-level lumbar intervertebral disc replacement with three-dimensional fabric discs (Group I) or bioceramic spacers as a comparative material (Group II). All operative segments were stabilized temporarily with spinal instrumentation for the initial ingrown phase. Four animals each were killed at 4, 6, 15, and 24 months in Group I and at 6 months in Group II, and the operative segments were subjected to either a detachment test or histologic evaluation.

RESULTS

The interfacial tensile strength at 6 months was significantly higher in Group I than in Group II. No significant decrease in tensile strength was detected until 24 months after surgery in Group I. Histologically, bone ingrowth to the three-dimensional fabric surface was observed 4 months after surgery, and no aseptic loosening occurred until 24 months after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings show that the three-dimensional fabric disc was firmly fixed to the vertebral body by bone ingrowth, and that this biologic fixation was preserved even under the spinal segmentally mobile condition.

Advances in surgical management of lumbar degenerative disease

The past several years have seen many advances in spine technology. Some of these advances have improved the quality of life of patients suffering from disabling low back pain from degenerative disk disease. Traditional fusion procedures are trending toward less invasive approaches with less iatrogenic soft-tissue morbidity. The diversity of bone graft substitutes is increasing with the potential for significant improvements in fusion success with the future introduction of several well tested bone morphogenic proteins to the spinal market. Biologic solutions to modify the natural history of disk degeneration are being investigated. Recently, electrothermal modulation of the posterior annulus fibrosis has been published as a semi-invasive technique to relieve low back pain generated by fissures in the outer annulus and ingrowing nociceptors (intradiskal electrothermal therapy, and intradiskal electrothermal annuloplasty). Initial results are promising, however, prospective randomized studies comparing this technique with conservative therapy are still lacking. The same is true for artificial nucleus pulposus replacement using hydrogel cushions implanted in the intervertebral space after removal of the nucleus pulposus posterior or through an anterior approach. Intervertebral disk prostheses are presently being studied in small prospective patient cohorts. As with all new developments, careful prospective, long-term trials are needed to fully define the role of these technologies in the management of symptomatic lumbar degenerative disk disease.