The biology of allograft rejection

The effect of a first kidney transplant on a subsequent transplant outcome: An experimental and clinical study

BACKGROUND

Second kidney transplantations have a roughly similar clinical outcome to first transplantations. Nevertheless, the effect of the presence of the first, nonfunctional transplant at the time of the second transplantation may also influence its outcome and has not yet been specifically studied.

METHODS

We analyzed the effect of the presence of a first graft on the outcome of a second graft in a rodent allograft model and in a cohort of 240 human second kidney allograft recipients.

RESULTS

In rodents, 100 days subsequent to the rejection of the first graft, we observed an increase in blood but not spleen CD4(+)CD25(+) T cells, whereas no differences were observed in transcriptional patterns. Adoptive transfer of day 100 splenocytes did not prolong graft survival. Moreover, the presence of a first rejected graft does not prolong the survival of a second graft performed at a later date. In the human context, a higher incidence of patients with anti-HLA immunization and a higher % of PRA were observed in retransplant recipients with primary allograft nephrectomy. Despite a relatively low statistical power, our data do not suggest significant differences in graft outcome between recipients of second transplants with primary allograft nephrectomy and those without.

CONCLUSION

Collectively, the data from both an experimental model and a large cohort of human recipients of a second graft do not suggest a beneficial effect of the presence of a first rejected graft at the time of a second transplantation.

T-cell-mediated rejection of vascularized xenografts in the absence of induced anti-donor antibody response

T cells are considered to play a major indirect role in the pathogenesis of xenograft vascular rejection, by promoting the induction of anti-donor antibodies that trigger complement- and antibody-dependent cell cytotoxicity. However, how vigorous the T cell xenoresponse is in vivo, and whether, besides their helper function, T cells are capable of directly affecting the graft is still unclear. We have previously shown that cyclosporine A (CsA) withdrawal in accommodated cardiac xenograft recipient allows for a rapid and dense T-cell infiltration, concomitant to an acute graft rejection. In this paper we further characterize the role of T cells in this rejection process and we demonstrate that adoptive transfer of CD4+ T cells in irradiated recipients of long-term cardiac xenografts is sufficient to trigger acute rejection, in the absence of any detectable induced anti-hamster antibody response. Therefore, our data suggest that unusually strong T-cell response will be another major barrier to xenotransplantation, even if antibody-mediated vascular rejection is controlled.

Sequential monitoring of peripheral T-lymphocyte cytokine gene expression in the early post renal allograft period

BACKGROUND

Despite numerous studies, the precise role of cytokines in acute renal allograft rejection remains unclear. In this study we have monitored sequential changes in peripheral T cell cytokine gene expression, correlating the changes with clinical events after adult renal transplantation, to provide a deeper insight of the role of cytokines in allograft rejection.

METHODS

Sequential changes in peripheral Th-1 [interleukin- (IL) 2 and interferon-gamma] and Th-2 (IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, and IL-13) cytokine gene expression in 43 patients with (n=15) and without (n=28) episodes of biopsy-proven rejection was monitored in the first 6 weeks after renal transplantation using a sensitive, semi-quantitative reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction ELISA approach.

RESULTS

Th-2 cytokines: IL-5 and IL13 expression increased before and during acute rejection, and decreased after successful antirejection therapy. A significant fall in IL-4 expression after transplantation and subsequent return to its baseline level of expression was observed in both nonrejectors and rejectors. IL-10 showed persistently high expression in nonrejectors, but in rejectors the expression fell during acute rejection, with a subsequent rise after antirejection therapy. Th-1 cytokines: IL-2 and IFN-gamma decreased in expression in the first week posttransplant in the rejectors, at the time of acute rejection (IL-2 only) and immediately after completion of antirejection therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Sequential monitoring of peripheral T cell cytokine gene expression after renal transplantation detected changes in expression that correlated with episodes of acute rejection and response to antirejection therapy. This approach may be applicable in the clinical laboratory for monitoring posttransplant changes in T cell alloreactivity and immunosuppression.

Highly altered V beta repertoire of T cells infiltrating long-term rejected kidney allografts

Chronic rejection represents a major cause of long-term kidney graft loss. T cells that are predominant in long-term rejected kidney allografts (35 +/- 10% of area infiltrate) may thus be instrumental in this phenomenon, which is likely to be dependent on the indirect pathway of allorecognition only. We have analyzed the variations in T cell repertoire usage of the V beta chain at the complementary determining region 3 (CDR3) level in 18 human kidney grafts lost due to chronic rejection. We observed a strongly biased intragraft TCR V beta usage for the majority of V beta families and also a very high percentage (55%) of V beta families exhibiting common and oligoclonal V beta-C beta rearrangements in the grafts of patients with chronic rejection associated with superimposed histologically acute lesions. Furthermore, V beta 8 and V beta 23 families exhibited common and oligoclonal V beta-J beta rearrangements in 4 of 18 patients (22%). Several CDR3 amino acid sequences were found for the common and oligoclonal V beta 8-J beta 1.4 rearrangement. Quantitative PCR showed that biased V beta transcripts were also overexpressed in chronically rejected kidneys with superimposed acute lesions. In contrast, T lymphocytes infiltrating rejected allografts with chronic rejection only showed an unaltered Gaussian-type CDR3 length distribution. This pattern suggests that late graft failure associated with histological lesions restricted to Banff-defined chronic rejection does not involve T cell-mediated injury. Thus, our observation suggests that a limited number of determinants stimulates the recipient immune system in long-term allograft failure. The possibility of a local response against viral or parenchymatous cell-derived determinants is discussed.

Gene therapy in transplantation in the year 2000: moving towards clinical applications?

Transplantation faces several major obstacles that could be overcome by expression of immunomodulatory proteins through application of gene therapy techniques. Gene therapy strategies to prolong graft survival involve gene transfer of immunosuppressive or graft-protecting molecules. Very promising results have been obtained in small animal experimental models with inhibitors of co-stimulatory signals on T cells, immunosuppressive cytokines, donor major histocompatibility antigens and regulators of cell apoptosis or oxidative stress. The application of gene therapy techniques to transplantation offers a great experimental and therapeutic potential. Local production of immunosuppressive molecules may increase their therapeutic efficiency and reduce their systemic effects. When compared with other clinical situations, gene therapy in transplantation offers several potential advantages. Gene transfer into the graft can be performed ex vivo, during the transit between the donor and the recipient, thus avoiding many of the hurdles encountered with in vivo gene transfer. Furthermore, the difficulties associated with immune responses to the gene transfer vectors and transient gene expression may be easier to overcome when gene therapy protocols are applied to transplantation than when applied to other clinical situations. The next century should witness a rapid increase in the application of gene therapy techniques to large animal pre-clinical models of transplantation and later to clinical trials. Gene Therapy (2000) 7, 14-19.

The contribution of Na+/H+ exchange to postreperfusion injury and recovery of transplanted kidney

Acute kidney injury soon after reperfusion seems to anticipate short- and long-term graft prognosis. Sodium-hydrogen exchanger (NHE) is involved in several steps of kidney graft function recovery, such as the restoration of intracellular pH, acute postreperfusion inflammation, and tubular epithelium repair and proliferation. We studied 20 first kidney transplantations by measuring the erythrocyte NHE of both recipient and donor as well as recipient serum and urine indices of renal structural and functional integrity every day since grafting. Heightened exchange activity in the donor-recipient couple resulted, which was associated to a prompt graft recovery together with a short stay for the donor in the intensive care unit, brief cold ischemia time, and a nonatherogenic lipoprotein profile for the recipient. Additional positive prognostic indices were time-zero diuresis and urinary excretion rates of N-acetyl-beta-D-glucosaminidase (NAG) and albumin. Over the one-year follow-up period, a long post-transplantation hospital stay was associated with a significantly increased risk of rejection, and the urinary alanine-aminopeptide (AAP) excretion rate was confirmed as a useful criterion for evaluating the clinical course of kidney graft.

Acute cellular rejection of human renal tissue by adoptive transfer of allogeneic human peripheral blood mononuclear cells into chimeric rats: sequential gene expression of cytokines, chemokines and cytolytic effector molecules, and their regulation by CTLA-4-Ig

T(h)1- and T(h)2-related cytokines (IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4, IL-10), beta-chemokines (RANTES, macrophage inflammatory protein-1beta) and their receptor [chemotatic cytokine receptor (CCR) 5], and the cytolytic effector molecule [Fas ligand (FasL)] play an essential role in regulating and co-ordinating acute renal allograft rejection. A chimeric model of acute cellular rejection which involves subcapsular grafting of human renal tissue in the kidneys of immunodeficient rats and subsequent i.p. infusion of allogeneic human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) was used to study cellular infiltration patterns and sequential intragraft gene expression of these key inflammatory mediators. We found that while all molecules are expressed within the human renal implant at specific time points following infusion of allogeneic human PBMC, peak mRNA expression of IFN-gamma, IL-2, RANTES and CCR5 is associated with a phase of human mononuclear infiltration and accumulation, prior to graft destruction (induction phase). A short burst of FasL gene expression is found at the end of induction and at the onset of graft deterioration. IL-4 mRNA, which is hardly detectable, and IL-10 mRNA, which appears early and persists throughout follow-up at high levels, both peak after the induction phase with the advent of graft destruction. Furthermore, treatment with CTLA-4-Ig, which hardly affects migration of human effector cells into graft tissue, is associated with a temporary reduction in gene transcript levels for all inflammatory mediators, especially IL-2 and IL-4, reduced apoptosis in the graft and amelioration of tissue injury. Thus, development of acute cellular rejection in our chimeric model involves a co-ordinated pattern of gene expression, in which CTLA-4-Ig promotes its effects by transient inactivation of infiltrating human cells.

Down-modulation of host reactivity by anti-CD44 in skin transplantation

BACKGROUND

A major goal in transplantation medicine is to achieve donor-specific tolerance while sustaining unaltered immunoreactivity toward donor-independent stimuli. Pretransplant immunization and concomitant blockade of costimulatory molecules may be one way to achieve this goal. We investigated whether transplant acceptance could be achieved by sensitization with semiallogeneic blood and blockade of CD44s (standard isoform) or CD44v6 (variant exon 6), since the adhesion molecule CD44 is known to function as a costimulatory molecule in T-cell activation.

METHODS

Immunoregulatory regimens were examined in BDX rats that had received full-thickness (DA x BDX)F1 skin grafts by controlling graft acceptance and immunoreactivity.

RESULTS

When BDX rats received full-thickness (DA x BDX)F1 skin grafts together with either anti-CD44s or anti-CD44v6, graft rejection was delayed, but none of the animals accepted the graft. An analysis of immunoreactivity revealed reduced numbers of infiltrating lymphocytes in anti-CD44s- as well as anti-CD44v6-treated rats. Expansion of donor-specific helper and cytotoxic T cells was particularly impaired in anti-CD44v6-treated rats. The effect of anti-CD44s could not be intensified by presensitization with donor-derived blood. However, when rats received anti-CD44v6 concomitantly with presensitization, 75% permanently accepted the graft and 50% accepted a second graft provided they were continuously treated with anti-CD44v6 and received a low dose of cyclosporine (CsA) during the first weeks after grafting. The frequency of graft-reactive helper T cells was reduced to less than 10% of the level in controls, and cytotoxic T cells could hardly be detected.

CONCLUSION

According to the in vivo and the vitro analyses of the graft and the draining lymph nodes, anti-CD44s blocked homing of activated lymphocytes into the graft, while anti-CD44v6 inhibited clonal expansion of donor-specific T cells. Suppression by anti-CD44v6 apparently functioned distinctly to cyclosporine and was most effective in combination with presensitization. Since expression of CD44v6 on lymphocytes is restricted to a short period during lymphocyte activation, anti-CD44v6 treatment could lead to a quite specific immunosuppression during a limited time period.

Predominant Th1 cell infiltration in acute rejection episodes of human kidney grafts

T-cells and their cytokines are thought to play a major role in the genesis of cellular infiltration and rejection in human kidney allografts. Production of Th1 (IFN-gamma) and Th2-type (IL-4 and IL-5) cytokines was assessed in a large series of T-cell clones, derived from core biopsies of kidney grafts in 10 patients with acute interstitial grade I/II rejection (AIR), 6 patients with a histology of "borderline rejection" (BLR) and 3 with cyclosporine A (CsA) toxicity, all receiving standard maintenance immunosuppression. Biopsies were pre-cultured in IL-2 in order to preferentially expand T-cells activated in vivo, and T-cell blasts were cloned with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and IL-2 using a highly efficient (23 to 98%) cloning technique. A total of 483 T-cell clones obtained from AIR episodes were compared with 346 and 132 clones derived from patients with BLR episodes and CsA toxicity, respectively. In two series of 22 AIR and 77 BLR T-cell clones, alloreactivity against donor cells was shown by 25 and 14% of CD8+ and 21 and 4% of CD4+ clones, respectively. When stimulated by donor-derived EBV B-cells, all these alloreactive clones produced IFN-gamma, but not IL-4 or IL-5 (Th1 clones). Upon stimulation with PHA, the principal qualitative and quantitative differences between AIR- and BLR-derived T-cell clones were that cells derived from AIR patients: (i) showed significantly higher proportions (80 +/- 15 vs. 55 +/- 13%) of Th1 clones in their progeny; (ii) included smaller proportions (3 +/- 4 vs. 20 +/- 17%) of clones incapable of producing IFN-gamma, IL-4 or IL-5 ('null' clones); and (iii) produced significantly higher quantities of IFN-gamma (100 +/- 50 vs. 36 +/- 7 U/10(6) cells/ml), these quantities also being significantly correlated (r = 0.83) with the degree of interstitial graft infiltration (item 'i' in the Banff histological grading). The clones derived from CsA toxicity biopsies exhibited a pattern very similar to that found in BIR cases. These data lead us to conclude that the powerful inflammatory response elicited in acute rejection of a kidney graft recruits and activates both allospecific and non-specific Th1 effector cells, which are primed to high IFN-gamma production. Our results also suggest that IFN-gamma could contribute, at least in part, to the degree of graft infiltration and to the severity of the rejection episode.

Interleukin-8 expression in patients after renal transplantation

Cellular invasion and cytokine release are important steps in the initiation of rejection. We studied the release of interleukin-8 (IL-8), a potent proinflammatory and chemotactic cytokine, and its prognostic significance in predicting rejection after renal transplantation. Serum and urine samples were analyzed with an IL-8-specific sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Biopsy tissue specimens (n = 20) were snap-frozen and examined with immunohistochemistry using two monoclonal antibodies against human IL-8 (4G9 and 2A8). Serum IL-8 measurements were of no value in predicting rejection due to low sensitivity (24%). In 45 biopsy-proven acute rejections (< 2 months after transplantation), urinary IL-8 concentrations were elevated in 62% (298 +/- 54 pg/mL; P < 0.01), preceding clinical diagnosis of rejection. After treatment, the IL-8 concentration in urine decreased back to normal (33 +/- 4 pg/mL; P < 0.01). The highest urinary IL-8 concentrations were seen in patients with biopsy-proven rejection in combination with acute tubular necrosis (610 +/- 150 pg/mL). This finding was independent of renal function and urinary volume. Only three of 15 rejection episodes in patients more than 2 months after transplantation showed an elevated IL-8 concentration in urine (94 +/- 60 pg/mL). In 10 of 23 patients with infection, a significant increase of IL-8 in urine was observed as well (157 +/- 67 pg/mL; P < 0.05). IL-8-positive staining was found within interstitial mononuclear cells of all biopsy specimens showing rejection. Additionally, the antibody 4G9 stained arteriolar smooth muscle and tubular cells. Interestingly, a few IL-8-positive cells were present in two donor kidneys before transplantation was performed; control tissue was negative. Further investigations are necessary to determine the clinical value of urinary IL-8 determinations in the diagnosis of rejection and to evaluate the role of IL-8 in the pathogenesis of acute allograft rejection.

Decreased cytotoxic activity of natural killer cells in kidney allograft recipients treated with human HLA-derived peptide

Peptides derived from a conserved region (aa 75-84) of HLA class I, overlapping the supertypic HLA-BW4/BW6 antigen region, have been shown to exhibit nonallele restricted immunosuppressive properties in rats and mice, prolonging survival of major histocompatibility complex-mismatched allografts. Furthermore, HLA-B7 peptides inhibit alloreactive cytotoxic cells, and both HLA-B7 and HLA-B2702 peptides inhibit natural killer (NK) cytotoxicity in vivo. In this article, we report on a randomized, controlled study of the safety and pharmacokinetics of HLA-B2702-derived peptide in human recipients of a first kidney allograft. Escalating doses of HLA-B2702 were compared with doses of placebo controls. No toxicity and no immunization against the peptide were noted. Although the study was not designed as an efficacy trial, patients who received the high-dose protocol (7 mg/kg) did experience more rejection episodes, but this was not statistically significant when compared with control patients. Interestingly, in human recipients, as previously observed in rodents, administration of the peptide was associated with a statistically significant decrease in the cytotoxicity of NK cells against K562 targets (P<0.001). As these peptides correspond to a region of the HLA class I molecule that interacts with the newly described NK receptors for class I, their mode of action through interaction with such receptors is discussed. As a peptide of the same sequence from HLA-B7 blocks both NK and alloreactive T cell cytotoxicity, it is possible that, in humans too, both types of cytotoxic cells are affected by this peptide. The biological significance of these observations should be confirmed in future controlled studies with a larger patient population.

Intragraft expression of IL-10 messenger RNA: a novel correlate of renal allograft rejection

A major conceptual advance is the formulation that type I cytokines (such as IL-2 and IFN-gamma) enhance cellular immunity and are host-protective, and that type II cytokines (such as IL-4 and IL-10) dampen cellular immunity and facilitate the progression of infection. We have explored the intragraft expression of type I and type II cytokines during human renal allograft rejection. RNA was isolated from 98 allograft biopsies, and reverse transcription-PCR was used to amplify and identify intragraft expression of mRNA encoding IL-2, IFN-gamma, IL-4, or IL-10. Intragraft expression of IL-7 mRNA and TGF-beta 1 mRNA was also investigated. Our investigation demonstrated that: (a) intragraft expression of IL-10 mRNA and IL-2 mRNA are significant correlates of acute rejection; (b) IL-4, IL-7, IFN-gamma and TGF-beta 1 mRNA expression do not correlate with acute rejection; and (c) IL-10 does not prevent in vivo expression of IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-7, or TGF-beta 1. Our studies identify, for the first time, a significant association between intragraft IL-10 mRNA expression and acute rejection, and suggest that treatment strategies capable of constraining IL-10 expression might be of value in the prevention of acute rejection.