Fassier-Duval Rod Failure: Is It Related to Positioning in the Distal Epiphysis?

Long-term Outcomes of Intramedullary Nails in Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Fewer Surgeries and Longer Survival Times With Telescoping Rods in Patients With Over Ten Years Follow-up

OBJECTIVE

Intramedullary rodding of lower extremity long bones in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a widely accepted technique for fracture treatment and prevention. Previous small studies with short to medium-term follow-up have shown that telescoping rods have longer survival times compared with static rods. However, there are no long-term studies (10 or more years) longitudinally evaluating the results of these procedures. The purpose of this study was to compare the rod survival duration and number of procedures in patients treated with static versus telescoping rods with 10 years minimum follow-up.

METHODS

This was a multicenter retrospective comparative study of patients with a diagnosis of OI who had intramedullary nailing of the femur and/or tibia. Each bone included in the study had a 10-year minimum follow-up, only one type of rod utilized over the follow-up period, and no rod replacement surgeries outside of the primary hospital system. Patient demographics, clinical data, and details of each procedure were obtained. Groups were compared using univariate analysis with a 2-independent samples t test for continuous variables, χ 2 for categorical variables, and the Kaplan-Meier method for survival analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 119 bones in 52 patients met inclusion criteria. Average follow up was 13.1 (range: 10.2 to 18.4) years. There were no differences between groups in follow-up length, Sillence type, bisphosphonate use, or age at first-rod placement. There were significantly more tibias treated in the static rod group compared with the telescopic rod group. The average survival length was significantly longer for telescopic rods, 5.8 ± 3.9 years versus 4.0±3.6 years for static rods. On average, bones treated with telescopic rods had significantly fewer surgeries compared with static rods (2.2 ± 0.8 vs 3.3 ± 1.6).

CONCLUSION

At long term follow up, bone segments in patients with OI treated with telescopic rods required fewer surgeries and had longer implant survival times compared with those treated with static rods. When available, surgeons should consider telescopic rods as the initial implant choice in this patient population.

Impact of telescopic intramedullary rodding on the growth of tibia: Comparative experimental study in dogs

INTRODUCTION

The most commonly accepted method of long bone deformity correction in children with osteogenesis imperfecta is surgical realignment with transphyseal telescopic intramedullary rodding. This approach ensures reinforcement of the bone throughout the growth period. Although longitudinal growth does occur with these implants there has been very little work carried out to calculate the effect of such factors as rod position or implant material on growth. We carried out a prospective comparative study on 12 puppies using titanium alloy telescopic tibial rods with and without hydroxyl-apatite coating. The aim of this non-randomized controlled experimental study was to assess the impact of telescopic intramedullary rodding on spontaneous growth of the tibia.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Twelve mongrel puppies aged of 5 months underwent intramedullary transphyseal rodding of the right tibia. In group I (6 dogs) a titanium telescopic rod was used, in group II (6 dogs) a titanium rod with hydroxyapatite (HA)-coated threaded end was used. The following radiological criteria were assessed before surgery and every month until age of 12 months (natural fusion of physes in dogs): length of tibia, amount of superposition of inner (male) rod into external (female) rod; alteration of anatomy in terms of joint angles (mMPTA, mLDTA, mPPTA, mADTA); positioning of threaded ends in proximal and distal epiphyses and evidence of premature growth arrest. Parameters were compared with left tibia serving as control segment. The null hypothesis was that neither rod position nor implant material altered growth.

RESULTS

The transphyseal rods did not lead to irreversible epiphysiodesis in either group. In group II (HA-coated) some loss of residual length was found in all six dogs, over 7mm (5.9%) in comparison to left intact tibia. In contrast to that, in group I (titanium nail) only one animal (16.7%) demonstrated a tibia length discrepancy of 8mm (4.8%). Eccentric ( posterior) positioning of the rod in the distal epiphysis resulted in a procurvatum deformity (increased anterior distal tibial angle) in both groups. We found no failure of telescoping and no loss of fixation of threaded parts in either epiphyses.

DISCUSSION

The presence of telescopic rods with HA-coated threads parts clearly contributes to inhibition of spontaneous longitudinal growth. We hypothesize that HA stimulates maturation of chondrocytes of growth plate. Our findings regarding the potential adverse effect of thread position in the distal physis demonstrate the importance of attempting to place the rod as central as possible.

CONCLUSION

Titanium alloy telescopic rods did not reveal significant effect on physeal growth in puppies in comparison to HA-coated implants. Transphyseal HA-coated implants did however inhibit growth plate function with mean loss of length of 5.2% compared to the other side. Eccentric positioning of rods relative to center of physis resulted in angular deformity due to irregular growth. There were no cases of mechanical failure or loss of telescopic function with either group of titanium implant.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II; prospective comparative experimental study.

Perioperative Evaluation and Management of Children with Osteoporosis and Low Bone Mineral Density

As medical and surgical treatment options for children with osteoporosis expand, multidisciplinary strategies for bone health optimization become more important. Each patient's bone mineral density and fracture history should be interpreted in context. Off-label bisphosphonate use is a standard pharmacologic intervention for children with osteoporosis for optimal bone accrual. It is possible to continue this therapy perioperatively under certain circumstances. The rare side effects (osteonecrosis of the jaw and atypical femur fractures) seem less common in children. Physical therapy, vitamin D supplementation, and other interventions are also important tools for optimal bone health perioperatively and for satisfactory surgical outcomes.

Corrosion of a Fassier-Duval Telescopic Nail Causing Pain and Osteolysis: A Case Report

CASE

A 15-year-old girl known with osteogenesis imperfecta presented with left femoral pain. She had been treated with multiple Fassier-Duval intramedullary nails, which were still in situ. Radiographic imaging demonstrated focal osteolysis and periosteal reaction at the telescopic junction of the rod in the distal femur. She underwent implant removal. Intraoperative sampling demonstrating acute sterile inflammation and presence of brownish colored particles consistent with metal debris and osteolysis. Explant analysis confirmed corrosion of the stainless-steel telescopic nail as the underlying cause.

CONCLUSION

Osteolysis and periosteal reaction because of corrosion should be considered in conjunction with other more common causes of pain, such as fracture or infection, in patients treated with telescopic intramedullary nails.

Complications After Intramedullary Fixation Treatment of Patients With Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Telescopic Versus Non-Telescopic Implants

Introduction The treatment of musculoskeletal pathologies in osteogenesis imperfecta aims to provide the maximum possible function by preventing bone fractures and progressive deformities. Despite the development of implants used in the surgical treatment of osteogenesis imperfecta, there is no consensus on the most appropriate method for the correction of skeletal deformities. The aim of this study was to compare telescopic and non-telescopic implants in terms of postoperative complications. Methods  Twenty-three patients who were operated on for the diagnosis of osteogenesis imperfecta between 2005 and 2018 were retrospectively analyzed. Demographic data, follow-up times, and the total number of surgeries and complications were recorded. The operated bones were divided into two groups according to whether the intramedullary fixation material used was telescopic or not. Results  Twenty-one of 23 patients were included in the study due to the use of intramedullary fixation material in the operation. The mean age was 10.1 ± 2.9 years, and the mean follow-up period was 8.9 ± 3.5 years. Intramedullary fixation was applied to 43 long bones in 21 patients due to fracture or deformity. At least one complication was encountered in nine of 14 bones with telescopic implants and in 27 of 29 bones with non-telescopic implants. Major complications requiring surgical treatment were seen in seven bones of the telescopic implant group and 27 bones of the non-telescopic implant group. Conclusion The use of telescopic implants relatively reduces the complication rate and the need for repetitive surgery in patients with a diagnosis of osteogenesis imperfecta. However, the number of complications is still as high as with non-telescopic implants.

"Osteogenesis Imperfecta Patients Wish Orthopedic Surgeons Had Better Strategies to Help with…"-Results of a Patient and Parent-Oriented Survey

Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) is a rare genetic disorder in Type I collagen characterized by bone fractures, fragility, and deformity. Current treatments are focused on decreasing fracture rates, improving bone strength, and improving overall global function. Recent research has focused primarily on fracture fixation and outcomes of intramedullary rodding of long bones. While surgical techniques continue to evolve, recent trends in OI research are focusing on patient quality of life and patient-reported outcomes. We created a 12-question survey seeking information regarding aspects of orthopedic care that OI patients and families feel are the most pressing to improve. The survey was electronically administered, and 341 individuals participated. A total of 75% of respondents who answered the age question (254/335) were adults. Regarding surgical intervention for long bones, only 16% of respondents recall being told they could not have surgery because they were too young. Of the 16%, 37.8% were told that <5 years was too young, 13.4% <4 years was too young, and 48.8% <3 years of age was too young for surgical intervention for fractures or deformities. Nearly 22% of respondents were told that their bones were too small for intramedullary fixation. The patient and family responses help elucidate the topics requiring focus for the improvement of OI orthopedic care. Patient concerns and insights should drive the research questions we ask to advance the orthopedic care of OI patients.

The Fate of the Bent Rod in Children With Osteogenesis Imperfecta

BACKGROUND

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a genetic disorder characterized by brittle bones and long bone deformity. Realignment and intramedullary rodding with telescopic rods are indicated for progressive deformity and can help prevent fractures. Rod bending is a reported complication of telescopic rods and a common indication for revision; however, the fate of bent lower extremity telescopic rods in the setting of OI has not been reported.

METHODS

Patients with OI at a single institution who underwent lower extremity telescopic rod placement with at least 1-year follow-up were identified. Bent rods were identified, and for these bone segments, we collected the location and angle of bend, subsequent telescoping, refracture, increasing angulation of bend, and date of revision.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty-eight telescopic rods in 43 patients were identified. Forty-six rods (27.4%) bent during follow-up, with an average angulation of 7.3 (range: 1 to 24) degrees. In patients with severe OI, 15.7% of rods bent compared with 35.7% in nonsevere OI ( P =0.003). The proportion of bent rods was different between independent and nonindependent ambulators (34.1% and 20.5%; P =0.035). Twenty-seven bent rods (58.7%) were revised, with 12 rods (26.0%) revised early (within 90 d). The angulation of rods that were revised early was significantly higher than rods not (14.6 and 4.3 degrees, P <0.001). Of the 34 bent rods not revised early, the average time to revision or final follow-up was 29.1 months. Twenty-five rods (73.5%) continued to telescope, 14 (41.2%) increased in angulation (average 3.2 degrees), and 10 bones (29.4%) refractured. None of the refractures required immediate rod revision. Two bones had multiple refractures.

CONCLUSIONS

Bending is a common complication of telescopic rods in the lower extremities of patients with OI. It is more common in independent ambulators and patients with nonsevere OI, possibly because of the increased demand placed on the rods. Rods with a small bend and maintained fixation can telescope and need not be an indication for immediate revision.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-Retrospective review.

Which is the best femoral implant in children with osteogenesis imperfecta? a retrospective cohort study of 783 procedures

BACKGROUND

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a hereditary genetic disorder characterized by bone fragility and extremity deformities. The surgical management for long-bone fractures and deformities in OI remains a challenge. We aimed to compare clinical outcomes after femoral surgery splinted with the telescopic rod, the plate and screws, the elastic nail and the non-elongating rod in setting of OI.

METHODS

 A retrospective cohort study included 783 femoral procedures (mean age 6.00 (interquartile range (IQR) 5.00) years, 335 (42.8%) females) was conducted, and individuals were categorized into four groups according to implants. After verifying comparability among the groups, revision rate and implant survival period were compared among the Sillence types and the same comparison were made among four groups within each Sillence type. The incidence of refractures, deformities, and implant-related complications were also compared among the four groups.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in demographic information among the four groups in terms of sex (p = 0.101), laterality (p = 0.587), Sillence type (p = 0.122), and postoperative follow-up period (p = 0.214). In total, children with Sillence type III had the highest revision rate and the shortest implant survival period; children with Sillence type I had the lowest revision rate and the longest implant survival period; and children with Sillence type IV had the revision rate and the implant survival period between those observed in Sillence types I and III. In Sillence types III and IV, the telescopic rod had lower revision rate (III 24.8%; IV 20.9%) compared to the plate (III 97.2%, p<0.001; IV 80.3%, p<0.001), the elastic nail (III 100.0%, p=0.019; IV 73.9%, p<0.001) and the non-elongating rod (III 65.0%, p<0.001; IV46.9%, p<0.001); the median implant survival period of the telescopic rod (III 48.00 (IQR 28.50) months; IV 43.00 (33.00) months) is longer than the plate (III 11.00 (9.00) months, p<0.001; IV 19.00 (20.00) months, p<0.001), the elastic nail (III 45.00 (37.75) months, p=1.000; IV 19.00 (35.00) months, p=0.028) and the non-elongating rod (III 39.00 (31.75) months, p=0.473; IV 38.50 (29.75) months, p=1.000).A similar trend was observed in Sillence type I (p = 0.063, p = 0.003; respectively). In addition, the incidence of refracture (15.5%), deformity (2.8%) and implant-related complications (23.1%) were also statistically lower in the telescopic rod group.

CONCLUSION

In our cohort, lower revision rate and longer implant survival period were observed in telescopic rod group. This was mainly due to the significant lower incidence of refracture, deformity and implant-related complications with the use of telescopic rod.

Preliminary Results of Bone Lengthening over Telescopic Titanium Intramedullary Rod

Background

Limb lengthening and deformity correction in patients with abnormal bone associating fragility often require an approach combining methods of external and internal fixation. This study demonstrates results of simultaneous application of external fixator, and telescopic rod for femoral lengthening and deformity correction in three children with osteogenesis imperfecta or severe form of Ollier's disease.

Materials and Methods

Three patients (two boys with Ollier's disease and a girl with osteogenesis imperfecta, type I) were operated on for femoral lengthening with combined technique associating Ilizarov frame and titanium telescopic intramedullary rodding.

Results

Planned amount of lengthening and deformity correction were achieved for all patients. We found neither rod bending nor pull out of threaded tips. There was no difficulty of expanding of telescopic intramedullary rods made of titanium alloy during distraction phase of lengthening procedure.

Conclusion

This short series proved feasibility of performing one-stage surgery with external frame and telescopic rodding in limb lengthening. The technique of telescopic rods in lengthening procedure is promising method requiring meticulous insertion of rod in centralized positioning in epiphysis. Acute alignment of the segment been elongating should be achieved at surgery. No any progressive angular deformity correction in postoperative period is authorized in order to avoid bending of telescopic rod. This combined approach does not affect bone healing.

Surgical Strategy to Decrease the Revision Rate of Fassier-Duval Nailing in the Lower Limbs of Osteogenesis Imperfecta

(1) Background: The Fassier−Duval (FD) nail was developed for the treatment of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The aim of this study was to review the results of OI patients treated with the FD nail at our institution and discuss a surgical strategy to decrease the FD nail revision rate; (2) Methods: We retrospectively reviewed OI patients treated at our institution between 2015 and 2020. OI patients treated with FD nail insertion in the long bones of the lower extremities were included, and those with a follow-up duration <1 year or incomplete radiographs were excluded. Data on the type of OI, age, sex, use of bisphosphonate treatment, and nail failure were recorded; (3) Results: The final cohort consisted of seven patients (three females and four males) with ten femurs and ten tibiae involved. Six of the patients had type III OI, and one had type IV OI. An exchange of implant was required in 11 limbs. The average interval between previous FD nail insertion and revision surgery was 2.4 years; (4) Discussion: The main reasons for revision surgery were migration of the male/female component, refracture/nail bending, and delayed union. In the femur, migration of the female component or nail bending were common reasons for failure, while migration of the male component and delayed union were common in the tibia; (5) Conclusions: Surgery for OI patients is challenging, and physicians should aim to minimize complications and the need for revision. Sufficient depth of purchase, center−center nail position, and adequate osteotomy to correct bowing are the key factors when using the FD nail.

Complications of Elongating Intramedullary Rods in the Treatment of Lower Extremity Fractures for Osteogenesis Imperfecta: A Meta-Analysis of 594 Patients in 40 Years

BACKGROUND

Osteogenesis imperfecta is a collagen mutation-related disease characterized by bone fragility and other extraskeletal manifestations. Intramedullary fixation for deformity correction or fracture is the standard care. Elongating rods are designed to accommodate growth, with the aim of preventing additional operations and/or complications associated with nonelongating rods. Although elongating rods have been in use for many years, estimates of the clinical outcomes vary. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to synthesize the literature on outcomes of elongating rods and nonelongating rods. Meta-analysis was used to compare the complication rates and reoperation rates.

METHODS

We conducted the literature search, systematic review, and meta-analysis in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Comparative cohort studies and large case series detailing complication rates and reoperation rates of elongating and nonelongating rods were included. Random effect models were used to summarize the complication rates and reoperation rates of intramedullary rod procedures.

RESULTS

A total of 397 studies were identified and 24 studies were included in the final cohort. Compared with rates from nonelongating rods, osteogenesis imperfecta Patients using elongating rods had a complication rate of 61% and a reoperation rate of 78%. Reoperation rates dropped with succeeding generations of elongating rods. Pooling data from 600 patients, we identified a 9% complication rate per rod per follow up year and 5% reoperation rate per rod and per follow up year in the cohort of elongating rod fixation. The Bailey-Dubow rod had the highest complication rate per rod per follow up year (12%), largely because of its T piece relate problems. The most popular fixator Fassier-Duval rod had a complication rate per rod per follow up year of 9%. About 68% of complications were mechanical-biological related.

CONCLUSION

Pooling data from published literature demonstrates the advantage of elongating rods over nonelongating rods. However, as high as 9% complication rate per rod per follow up year was associated with elongating fixation. Notably, most complications are both mechanical and biological related.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Mechanical Analysis of Explanted Telescopic Rods in the Management of Osteogenesis Imperfecta: A Multicenter Study

BACKGROUND

Telescopic rods in the management of osteogenesis imperfecta fail frequently. This could be attributed to technical errors, rod design, and rod structure. We aimed to analyze the mechanical properties and tribology of explanted male and female components to identify effects of in vivo telescoping that may relate to observed patterns of successful telescoping or failure.

METHODS

Recruitment took place at 3 of the 4 English centers for osteogenesis imperfecta. Twenty-five rods explanted for growth or failure during revision to a new rod were analyzed in terms of clinical indication and prerevision imaging to identify if there was a technical mode of failure. Laboratory analysis was performed using optical and scanning electrical microscopy, radiograph diffraction analysis, hardness test, bending test, and energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy.

RESULTS

All implants tested were of high-grade stainless steel. Female components had inferior strength [mean Vickers hardness property (HV0.3) at 0.3 to 313 kg] in comparison to male components (HV0.3 406) due to different techniques of manufacture. Female rods also had a higher wear coefficient (7.89×10-12 m3/N/m3) than the male rods (6.46×10-12 m3/N/m3). Abrasive wear, shear deformation, scratches, and wear debris were identified in all rods. Male and female components displayed corrosion contributing to adhesive wear. Intraoperatively cut rods, particularly the female components, had irregular ends leading to more wear.

CONCLUSIONS

Current manufacturing techniques result in inferior material strength in female components compared with males, which combined with wear patterns is likely to lead to implant failure. Intraoperative cutting of rods may increase risk of failure due to wear. Considering techniques to improve strength as well as design in new implants may lead to better outcomes.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level IV-cross-sectional study.

Osteogenesis Imperfecta-Who Needs Rodding Surgery?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this review is to precise the indications for intramedullary rodding of long bones in osteogenesis imperfecta, the classic treatment for fractures and deformities in this condition.

RECENT FINDINGS

The use of plates and screws alone is not recommended, but its use in conjunction with rodding is becoming more popular as demonstrated in recent literature. The different types of rods are reviewed and their advantages/disadvantages exposed. There is a clear advantage for telescopic rods in terms of incidence of revision surgery but complications are still to be expected. An interdisciplinary approach combining a medical treatment with a surgical correction of deformities as well as a rehabilitation program is the key for success in the treatment of osteogenesis imperfecta children.

Problems, Complications, and Factors Predisposing to Failure of Fassier-Duval Rodding in Children With Osteogenesis Imperfecta: A Double-center Study

BACKGROUND

Although Fassier-Duval (FD) rods have been used for almost 2 decades, knowledge of factors predisposing to their failure is limited. Thus, the purpose of this study was to: (1) present the most common complications of FD rodding, (2) present tips on how to avoid or overcome them, and (3) identify factors predisposing to treatment failure.

METHODS

Fifty-eight rod segments in 19 patients with osteogenesis imperfecta (mainly type III) underwent analysis with a median follow-up (FU) time of 4.4 years. We assessed the total number of complications clinically and radiographically. Next, the possible predisposing factors leading to failure were assessed using the Mann-Whitney U test. In addition, we evaluated the cutoff age for the increased rate of complications using the Youden index. A P<0.05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

The total number of complications reached 44.8%. The most common complications included: migration of the male or female implant (45.7% and 25.7% out of the total number of complications, respectively), bone fracture with bending of the rod (8.6%), and rotational deformities (8.6%). Significant differences in patients' ages at the time of surgery were found between the group with and without complications (P=0.04), while sex, segment treated, preceding surgeries, length of FU, FD rod diameter, and length of bisphosphonate treatment were not significant. The Youden index showed that the risk of complications rose significantly in patients treated when younger than 5.5 years of age (P<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

This series displays the effectiveness and utility of FD rods at a median FU of over 4 years. Complication rates were comparable with the existing literature, with a notable increase in the number of side effects observed in younger patients (below the age of 5).

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV-therapeutic study.