Pediatric Type II Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: Factors Associated With Successful Closed Reduction and Immobilization

Nonoperative Management of Gartland Type II Supracondylar Humeral Fractures: A Comprehensive Review

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This review aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of the nonoperative management of Gartland Type II fractures in pediatric patients.

RECENT FINDINGS

Supracondylar humeral fractures (SCF) are one of the most common traumatic fractures in pediatric populations, characterized as transverse fractures at the distal humerus between the medial and lateral columns. Early studies strongly opposed closed reduction and casting as an acceptable treatment modality for Gartland type II fractures as an early case series showed high rates of complications; however, more recent studies have suggested better outcomes. The optimal management of Gartland Type II supracondylar fractures has yet to be fully elucidated. This review highlights the indications, complications, and outcomes of nonoperative Gartland Type II supracondylar humeral fracture management. Additionally, it demonstrates the need for further research to inform guidelines on managing this condition.

Comparison of Surgical and Conservative Treatments for Gartland Type II Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: Evaluation of the Need for Surgical Treatment

BACKGROUND

Supracondylar humerus fractures (SHFs) are common pediatric injuries, with type II fractures being a topic of debate regarding optimal treatment. Our goals are to compare the functional and radiographic outcomes of conservative and surgical treatment of type II SHFs and their subgroups and to identify parameters for determining the optimal treatment option.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed a total of 55 patients (23 conservative, 32 surgical) between 2010 and 2020. The mean follow-up was 66 months. Neurovascular status, range of motion, complications, and functional scores (Mayo elbow, Quick DASH) were evaluated. We performed radiographic assessment on initial, postreduction, and final follow-up radiographs using the humerocondylar angle (HCA), Baumann angle, and anterior humeral line (AHL).

RESULTS

Neither groups nor subgroups showed significant differences in clinical and functional outcomes. HCA was significantly higher in the operative group than in the conservative group. The subgroup analysis revealed that the HCA difference resulted from the difference between the conservative IIb and operative IIb subgroups. None of the patients required a corrective osteotomy, but 1 patient initially treated conservatively underwent operative treatment due to loss of reduction.

CONCLUSIONS

Reconstructing the sagittal, coronal, and rotational alignment in type II SHFs led to good mid-term results in the range of motion and functional scores for the elbow joint, whether conservative or surgical treatment was used. A limited range of remodeling might be expected in the long term.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-retrospective comparative study.

Conservative versus surgical treatment of Gartland type II supracondylar humeral fractures in children

The purpose of the study was to compare the efficacy of conservative and surgical treatments for Gartland type II supracondylar humerus fractures in children. We assessed 142 patients with type II supracondylar humerus fractures treated in our hospital from February 2018 to February 2019. The patients were divided into two groups: initial conservative treatment (Group A) and initial surgical treatment (Group B). Clinical outcomes were measured by the Flynn scoring system. Variables were analyzed using a statistical approach between those groups. All patients were followed up for 6-12 months. The rate of loss reduction was 19.8% in patients treated conservatively, and the incidence of pin infections was 7.1% in patients treated surgically. Although there were no statistical differences between the three groups in fracture healing time and Flynn score, the conservative treatment was superior to surgical treatment in functional recovery times. At the last follow-up, all fractures had healed without iatrogenic vascular or nerve injury, Volkmann's contracture, or cubit varus deformity. Conservative treatment is safe and effective for the treatment of Gartland type II supracondylar fracture and represents a faster recovery time of elbow range of motion as compared with surgical treatment. Type IIB had a 41.3% risk of secondary displacement versus 5.3% for IIA, but we still prefer closed reduction. However, closed reduction of Garland type II must be followed accurately in the first 2 weeks to identify patients with loss of reduction. The patients who loss reduction can be treated with percutaneous pinning, and the clinical effect was consistent with immediate surgical treatment. Level of evidence: level III.

Analysis of risk factors for failed closed reduction in pediatric Gartland Type III supracondylar humerus fracture

BACKGROUND

Gartland Type III supracondylar humerus fractures (SCHFs) are commonly treated using closed reduction followed by percutaneous pin fixation. However, conversion to open reduction may be necessary if closed reduction fails. This study aimed to identify risk factors associated with failed closed reduction and provide a theoretical basis for clinical decision-making in the treatment of Gartland Type III fractures.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted on children with Gartland Type III SCHF who underwent surgical treatment between April 2017 and June 2018. Based on whether or not the closed reduction was successful, patients were split into the open reduction group and the closed reduction group. Within the closed reduction group, subgroup analysis based on surgery duration was carried out. Data were collected from medical records and X-ray images. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were utilized to evaluate the relationship between variables and failed closed reduction.

RESULTS

The study included 36 patients in the open reduction group and 135 patients in the closed reduction group. Multivariate analysis revealed that the presence of angle (P = .024, OR = 3.199), rotation (P = .000, OR = 6.359), skin creases (P = .013, OR = 4.077), anterior-posterior displacement ratio (P = .011, OR = 4.337), fracture angle in the anteroposterior view (P = .014, OR = 0.939), and fracture distal displacement direction (P = .002, OR = 5.384) were independent risk factors for failed closed reduction. Subgroup analysis showed that fracture distal displacement direction (P = .013), skin folds (P = .013), lateral displacement ratio (P = .016), and anterior-posterior displacement value (P = .005) significantly influenced the duration of closed reduction surgery.

CONCLUSION

The presence of sharp angle or rotation at the fracture ends, skin folds on the anterior elbow, minor anterior-posterior displacement of the fracture, higher medial inclination of the fracture plane, and distal fracture displacement toward the radial side are independent risk factors for failed closed reduction in pediatric Gartland Type III SCHF.

Value-Driven Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fracture Care: Implementing Evidence-Based Practices

Supracondylar humerus fractures are high-volume injuries in children; therefore, value-driven treatment has far-reaching implications for patients and families as well as healthcare systems. Children younger than 5 years can remodel posterior angulation. Most Type IIa fractures will maintain alignment after closed reduction. Many patients with surgical fractures can safely wait for nonemergent fixation. Outpatient surgery is associated with shorter surgical time, lower costs, and fewer return visits to the emergency department with no increase in adverse events. Type III fractures treated the following day do not have higher rates of open reduction, and patients with associated nerve injuries have no difference in recovery time compared with those treated more urgently. Pediatric-trained surgeons generally provide more efficient care (shorter surgical time and less after-hours surgery); however, their outcomes are equivalent to non-pediatric orthopaedic surgeons. Community hospitals have lower costs compared with teaching hospitals; therefore, transferring patients should be avoided when feasible. Postoperative care can be streamlined in uncomplicated cases to minimize radiographs, therapy referrals, and multiple visits. Splinting offers safer, lower cost immobilization over casting. With staffing shortages and an increasingly burdened healthcare system, it is imperative to maximize nonsurgical care, use outpatient facilities, and minimize postoperative requirements without negatively affecting patient outcomes.

Is subclassification of Gartland extension-type pediatric supracondylar fracture into types IIA and IIB necessary for treatment decision? A result of pediatric orthopedist's survey and review of literature

Extension-type pediatric supracondylar humeral fractures are very common. The Gartland classification is typically used to guide treatment. However, there is still no consensus on what factors should be used to subclassify the type II fractures and whether subclassification is needed to guide treatment. Therefore, we aim to explore the opinions of pediatric orthopedists on the treatment method of the Gartland type II supracondylar fracture. Specifically, we ask what factors are considered for their treatment decisions and whether subclassification is needed to guide treatment. An online questionnaire was developed and sent to the Thai Paediatric Orthopedics Society and Asia-Pacific Paediatric Orthopaedic Society members. The results were analyzed to explore the relationship between respondents' demographic factors and treatment decisions. Out of 113 participants reached, 57 (50.4%) responded to the questionnaire. Factors chosen by respondents are stability testing intraoperatively (73.7%), the relationship of the anterior humeral line and capitellum (66.7%), the presence of rotation (50.9%), the presence of translation (47.4%), the presence of medial comminution 42.1%), soft tissue condition(38.6%), the shaft - condylar angle (31.6%), and the Bauman angle (21.1%). Thirty-three of 57 respondents (57.9%) deemed subclassification for Gartland type II necessary for guiding treatment. About half of respondents in our study deemed the current Gartland type II subclassification necessary to guide treatment, which may indicate that the subclassification might not be sufficiently comprehensive and reliable. Therefore, better criteria for a subclassification and a prospective evaluating study might be needed.

Nonoperative Versus Operative Treatment of Type IIA Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: A Prospective Evaluation of 99 Patients

BACKGROUND

Although current clinical practice guidelines from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons suggest that Type II and III supracondylar humerus (SCH) fractures be treated by closed reduction and pin fixation, controversy remains as to whether type IIa fractures with no rotation or angular deformity require surgery. The purpose of our study was to prospectively compare radiographic and functional outcomes of type IIa SCH fractures treated with or without surgery.

METHODS

Between 2017 and 2019, 105 patients between 2 and 12 years of age presenting with type IIa SCH fractures and without prior elbow trauma, neuromuscular or metabolic conditions, were prospectively enrolled. Ten orthopaedic surgeons managed the patients with 5 preferring surgical treatment and 5 preferring an initial attempt at nonoperative treatment. Patients in the nonoperative cohort were managed with a long-arm cast and close radiographic follow-up. Patients underwent a standardized protocol, including 3 to 4 weeks of casting, bilateral radiographic follow-up 6 months postinjury, and telephone follow-up at 6, 12, and 24 months.

RESULTS

Ninety-nine patients met the inclusion criteria (45 nonoperative and 54 operatives). Of the nonoperative patients, 4 (9%) were converted to surgery up to their first clinical follow-up. No differences were identified between the cohorts with respect to demographic data, but patients undergoing surgery had on average 6 degrees more posterior angulation at the fracture site preoperatively (P<0.05). At the final clinical follow-up (mean=6 mo), the nonoperative group had more radiographic extension (176.9 vs 174.4 degrees, P=0.04) as measured by the hourglass angle, but no other clinical or radiographic differences were appreciated. Complications were similar between the nonoperative and operative groups: refracture (4.4 vs 5.6%), avascular necrosis (2.2 vs 1.9%) and infection (0 vs 1.9%) (P>0.05). Patient-reported outcomes at a mean of 24 months showed no differences between groups.

CONCLUSION

Contrary to American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons guidelines, about 90% of patients with type IIa supracondylar fractures can be treated nonoperatively and will achieve good radiographic and functional outcomes with mild residual deformity improving over time. Patients treated nonoperatively must be monitored closely to assess for early loss of reduction and the need for surgical intervention.

Predictive factors for open reduction of flexion-type supracondylar fracture of humerus in children

Objective

The incidence of open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) in flexion-type supracondylar humerus fractures (SCHF) in children is significantly higher than that of extension-type fractures. This study aimed to identify risk factors for ORIF in flexion-type SCHF.

Methods

One hundred seventy-one patients with Wilkins type III flexion-type SCHF from January 2012 to December 2021 were retrospectively enrolled in a tertiary paediatric hospital. Patients were divided into ORIF group versus closed reduction and internal fixation (CRIF) group. Then, patients data of age, sex, injury side, obesity, deviation of displacement, fracture level, rotation, nerve injury, and delay from injury to surgery were reviewed. Univariate analysis and multivariate logistic regression were used to identify independent risk factors and odds ratios (OR) of ORIF.

Results

Overall, 171 children with type III flexion-type SCHF were analyzed (average aged 7.9 ± 2.8 years). Displacement was lateral in 151 cases, medial in 20. 20 cases had combined ulnar nerve injury. The failed closed reduction rate was 20%. Univariate analysis indicated age, distal fracture fragment rotation, and ulnar nerve injury were significantly associated with ORIF. (P = 0.047, P = 0.009, and P = 0.001, respectively). Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that distal fracture fragment rotation (OR, 3.3; 95%CI:1.1–9.5; P = 0.028) and ulnar nerve injury (OR, 6.4; 95%CI:2.3–18.3; P = 0.001) were independent risk factors; however, the age was not an independent one (OR, 1.5; 95%CI:0.6–3.5; P = 0.397) for ORIF in the Wilkins type III flexion-type SCHF.

Conclusion

Distal fracture fragment malrotation on initial x-rays and ulnar nerve injury were significant risk factors for ORIF in Wilkins type III flexion-type SCHF. Surgeons should prepare tourniquets or other open reduction instruments when treating these types of fractures.

Level of evidence

Level IV

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12891-022-05798-5.

Gartland Type IIa Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: Outcomes of Attempted Nonoperative Management

BACKGROUND

The optimal treatment of Gartland type IIa supracondylar humerus fractures remains controversial. We report the results of a series of patients with type IIa fractures who underwent closed reduction and immobilization using conscious sedation in the emergency department. Our goal was to identify variables associated with fractures that were successfully managed nonoperatively.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study of pediatric patients who underwent closed reduction of Gartland type IIa supracondylar humerus fractures with the use of conscious sedation in the emergency department. Prereduction and postreduction radiographs were reviewed to determine the degree of fracture extension, anterior humeral line index, Baumann angle, and splint flexion angle. The success of closed reduction was defined as a reduction that was maintained without the need for surgical intervention.

RESULTS

A total of 54 patients (54 elbows) were included in this study. The mean overall age was 5.2±2.5 years. Following the closed reduction in the emergency department, 38 (70%) patients were successfully managed nonoperatively with casting, and 16 (30%) patients required operative intervention. The degree of fracture extension on the injury radiograph was 13.2±8.4 degrees in the nonoperative group compared with 19.8±7.5 degrees in the operative group (P=0.008). The postreduction degree of fracture extension was 3.0±3.4 degrees in the nonoperative group and 10.0±7.2 degrees in the operative group (P<0.0001). The mean anterior humeral line index on the injury radiograph was 0.34 in the nonoperative group and 0.13 in the operative group (P=0.104). The mean anterior humeral line index on the postreduction radiograph was 1.2 in the nonoperative group and 0.38 in the operative group (P=0.0002). Patient age, prereduction and postreduction Baumann angle, and the postreduction splint flexion angle did not differ significantly between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Closed reduction under conscious sedation in the emergency department is a viable treatment option for Gartland type IIa supracondylar humerus fractures. Increasing fracture extension on injury radiographs can help predict failure of nonoperative management following closed reduction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-retrospective comparative study.