Assessment of effects of multipurpose contact lens care solutions on human corneal epithelial cells

Contact lens care solutions downregulate membrane-associated mucins 1 and 16 in cultured human corneal epithelial cells and at the rat corneal surface in vivo

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was first to evaluate the effect of multipurpose contact lens care solutions (MPSs) on the expression of membrane-associated mucins (MUC1 and MUC16) in SV40-transformed human corneal epithelial (HCE-T) cells and in vivo rat cornea. The second aim of this study was to determine the role of the common MPS additive boric acid in reducing mucin expression and release.

METHODS

The HCE-T cells were exposed to different concentrations of MPS-F, MPS-G, MPS-H, MPS-I, and MPS-J with 100% treatment for 30 minutes and 10% treatment for 24 hours. MUC1 and MUC16 expressions were subsequently analyzed by Western blotting. Wister rats were also subjected to MPS-A, MPS-B, MPS-C, MPS-D, and MPS-E and received phosphate-buffered saline exposure (1 drop in the right eye every 10 minutes for 1 hour). The left eye was used as control. Cornea sections and lysates were used for the immunohistochemical assay of MUC1 and MUC16 expressions. Conditioned media from treated HCE-T cells were also analyzed using Western blotting.

RESULTS

The MPSs containing boric acid downregulated MUC1 and MUC16 in the rat cornea, whereas MPSs without boric acid had no effect as demonstrated by the Western blotting and immunohistochemical analysis. Conditioned media from MPS-containing boric acid revealed some trace of MUC16.

CONCLUSIONS

The clinical use of MPSs containing boric acid that reduce MUC1 and MUC16 availability should be avoided. Additionally, the presence of MUC16 in the conditioned media suggests that boric acid may have enhanced cleavage of MUC16 at the cell membrane surface.

Antimicrobial compounds in tears

The tear film coats the cornea and conjunctiva and serves several important functions. It provides lubrication, prevents drying of the ocular surface epithelia, helps provide a smooth surface for refracting light, supplies oxygen and is an important component of the innate defense system of the eye providing protection against a range of potential pathogens. This review describes both classic antimicrobial compounds found in tears such as lysozyme and some more recently identified such as members of the cationic antimicrobial peptide family and surfactant protein-D as well as potential new candidate molecules that may contribute to antimicrobial protection. As is readily evident from the literature review herein, tears, like all mucosal fluids, contain a plethora of molecules with known antimicrobial effects. That all of these are active in vivo is debatable as many are present in low concentrations, may be influenced by other tear components such as the ionic environment, and antimicrobial action may be only one of several activities ascribed to the molecule. However, there are many studies showing synergistic/additive interactions between several of the tear antimicrobials and it is highly likely that cooperativity between molecules is the primary way tears are able to afford significant antimicrobial protection to the ocular surface in vivo. In addition to effects on pathogen growth and survival some tear components prevent epithelial cell invasion and promote the epithelial expression of innate defense molecules. Given the protective role of tears a number of scenarios can be envisaged that may affect the amount and/or activity of tear antimicrobials and hence compromise tear immunity. Two such situations, dry eye disease and contact lens wear, are discussed here.

Impact of contact lens materials on multipurpose contact lens solution disinfection activity against Fusarium solani

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effects of eight different soft contact lenses on disinfection efficacy of a multipurpose solution (MPS) containing polyhexamethylene biguanide (PHMB) against Fusarium solani.

METHODS

Six silicone hydrogel lenses (galyfilcon A, senofilcon A, comfilcon A, enfilcon A, balafilcon A, and lotrifilcon B) and two conventional hydrogel lenses (polymacon and etafilcon A) were placed in polypropylene lens cases filled with MPS containing 0.0001% PHMB and soaked for 6, 12, 24, 72, and 168 hours. After each interval, depleted MPS from lens cases were removed and assayed for activity against F. solani according to International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 14729 stand-alone procedure. A portion was aliquoted for chemical analysis.

RESULTS

Soaking etafilcon A, balafilcon A, and polymacon lenses for 6 hours reduced the concentration of PHMB in MPS by more than half the stated labeled concentration, with concentrations below the limit of detection for etafilcon A-depleted and balafilcon A-depleted solutions after 12 and 72 hours of soaking, respectively. Except for comfilcon A-depleted solutions, all others failed to consistently obtain one log reduction of F. solani. The solutions soaked with etafilcon A, balafilcon A, and polymacon lenses for 24 hours or more lost all or almost all fungicidal activity against F. solani.

CONCLUSIONS

Over time, the disinfectant uptake by some lenses can significantly reduce the PHMB concentration and the fungicidal activity of the MPS against F. solani. Current ISO methodology does not address the reduction in microbiocidal efficacy when lenses are soaked in MPS. The ISO committee should consider adding "soaking experiments" to quantify the effect that contact lens materials have on the performance of MPSs.