Considering Early Detection of Relapsed Ovarian Cancer: A Review of the Literature

Characteristics and survival of patients with gynecological cancers who refuse radiotherapy: a retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Radiotherapy improves survival for many cancer patients. However, some patients still refuse radiotherapy despite the recommendations of their physicians. We aimed to investigate the impact of refusing recommended radiotherapy on overall survival in patients with gynecological cancers (GC) and attempted to describe what characteristics are associated with the refusal of radiotherapy.

METHODS

Data were extracted from the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Result (SEER) database for patients who were diagnosed with GC and recommended for radiotherapy between 1988 and 2016. Kaplan-Meier and multivariate Cox regression analyses were utilized to analyze the impact of refusal of radiotherapy on overall survival. Univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses were used to identify characteristics associated with refusal of radiotherapy.

RESULTS

In total, 1,226 of 208,093 patients (0.6%) refused radiotherapy. Multivariate Cox regression analysis showed that refusal of radiotherapy was associated with poorer overall survival in GC patients with stage I/II [hazard ratio (HR) = 1.64; 95% confidence interval (CI), 1.50-1.79], but may not affect overall survival in patients with stage III/IV (HR = 1.03; 95%CI, 0.84-1.25). Multivariate logistic regression analysis demonstrated that factors such as older age (40-65 years, > 65 years), unmarried status (divorced, single, widowed), higher foreign-born rate (1.87-2.82%, 1.51-2.19), refusal of surgery (recommended but not performed), and higher grade (poorly differentiated, undifferentiated/anaplastic) may increase the likelihood of refusing radiotherapy (all P < 0.05). Factors that may reduce the likelihood of refusing radiotherapy include higher income (> 42,810$), lower grade (well-differentiated), primary site of ovarian cancer, and no/unknown chemotherapy (all P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Refusal of radiotherapy is related to worse overall survival in GC patients with stage I/II, and many characteristics may affect a patient's choice of refusal of radiotherapy.

VCAM-1 complements CA-125 in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer

BACKGROUND

Close to three-quarters of ovarian cancer cases are frequently diagnosed at an advanced stage, with more than 70% of them failing to respond to primary therapy and relapsing within 5 years. There is an urgent need to identify strategies for early detection of ovarian cancer recurrence, which may lead to earlier intervention and better outcomes.

METHODS

A customized magnetic bead-based 8-plex immunoassay was evaluated using a Bio-Plex 200 Suspension Array System. Target protein levels were analyzed in sera from 58 patients diagnosed with advanced ovarian cancer (including 34 primary and 24 recurrent tumors) and 46 healthy controls. The clinical performance of these biomarkers was evaluated individually and in combination for their ability to detect recurrent ovarian cancer.

RESULTS

An 8-plex immunoassay was evaluated with high analytical performance suitable for biomarker validation studies. Logistic regression modeling selected a two-marker panel of CA-125 and VCAM-1 that improved the performance of CA-125 alone in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer (AUC: 0.813 versus 0.700). At a fixed specificity of 83%, the two-marker panel significantly improved sensitivity in separating primary from recurrent tumors (70.8% versus 37.5%, P = 0.004), demonstrating that VCAM-1 was significantly complementary to CA-125 in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer.

CONCLUSIONS

A two-marker panel of CA-125 and VCAM-1 showed strong diagnostic performance and improvement over the use of CA-125 alone in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer. The experimental results warrant further clinical validation to determine their role in the early detection of recurrent ovarian cancer.

Pharmacotherapeutic treatment options for recurrent epithelial ovarian cancer

INTRODUCTION

Almost 80% of epithelial ovarian cancer present in advanced stage at diagnosis and despite excellent response to surgery and chemotherapy, more than 70% cancers recur. Subsequent therapies become decreasingly effective in controlling the disease, with each successful therapy being effective for a shorter duration. As a result, there is a need for novel therapeutic strategies to effectively treat recurrence.

AREAS COVERED

In this extensive literature review of high-quality articles, we have focused on surveillance strategy to detect recurrence early, classification of recurrence based on timeline, role of surgery, chemotherapy, and targeted agents such as anti-angiogenetic drugs, PARP inhibitors, and immune checkpoint inhibitors in platinum-sensitive and platinum-resistant disease, respectively.

EXPERT OPINION

Recurrent ovarian cancers (ROC) are represented by a heterogenous group of patient population in terms of platinum-free interval (PFI), histology, molecular characteristics and immune recognition. In today's era of precision medicine, chemotherapy should be combined with appropriate targeted agent in a multipronged approach to prolong survival and provide better quality of life outcomes by minimizing side effects.

British Gynaecological Cancer Society recommendations and guidance on patient-initiated follow-up (PIFU)

The National Cancer Survivorship Initiative through the National Health Service (NHS) improvement in the UK started the implementation of stratified pathways of patient-initiated follow-up (PIFU) across various tumor types. Now the initiative is continued through the Living With and Beyond Cancer program by NHS England. Evidence from non-randomized studies and systematic reviews does not demonstrate a survival advantage to the long-established practice of hospital-based follow-up regimens, traditionally over 5 years. Evidence shows that patient needs are inadequately met under the traditional follow-up programs and there is therefore an urgent need to adapt pathways to the needs of patients. The assumption that hospital-based follow-up is able to detect cancer recurrences early and hence improve patient prognosis has not been validated. A recent survey demonstrates that follow-up practice across the UK varies widely, with telephone follow-up clinics, nurse-led clinics and PIFU becoming increasingly common. There are currently no completed randomized controlled trials in PIFU in gynecological malignancies, although there is a drive towards implementing PIFU. PIFU aims to individualize patient care, based on risk of recurrence and holistic needs, and optimizing resources. The British Gynaecological Cancer Society wishes to provide the gynecological oncology community with guidance and a recommendations statement regarding the value, indications, and limitations of PIFU in endometrial, cervical, ovarian, and vulvar cancers in an effort to standardize practice and improve patient care.

ESMO-ESGO consensus conference recommendations on ovarian cancer: pathology and molecular biology, early and advanced stages, borderline tumours and recurrent disease

The development of guidelines is one of the core activities of the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) and European Society of Gynaecologial Oncology (ESGO), as part of the mission of both societies to improve the quality of care for patients with cancer across Europe. ESMO and ESGO jointly developed clinically relevant and evidence-based recommendations in several selected areas in order to improve the quality of care for women with ovarian cancer. The ESMO-ESGO consensus conference on ovarian cancer was held on April 12-14, 2018 in Milan, Italy, and comprised a multidisciplinary panel of 40 leading experts in the management of ovarian cancer. Before the conference, the expert panel worked on five clinically relevant questions regarding ovarian cancer relating to each of the following four areas: pathology and molecular biology, early-stage and borderline tumours, advanced stage disease and recurrent disease. Relevant scientific literature, as identified using a systematic search, was reviewed in advance. During the consensus conference, the panel developed recommendations for each specific question and a consensus was reached. The recommendations presented here are thus based on the best available evidence and expert agreement. This article presents the recommendations of this ESMO-ESGO consensus conference, together with a summary of evidence supporting each recommendation.

ESMO-ESGO consensus conference recommendations on ovarian cancer: pathology and molecular biology, early and advanced stages, borderline tumours and recurrent disease†

The development of guidelines recommendations is one of the core activities of the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) and European Society of Gynaecologial Oncology (ESGO), as part of the mission of both societies to improve the quality of care for patients with cancer across Europe. ESMO and ESGO jointly developed clinically relevant and evidence-based recommendations in several selected areas in order to improve the quality of care for women with ovarian cancer. The ESMO-ESGO consensus conference on ovarian cancer was held on 12-14 April 2018 in Milan, Italy, and comprised a multidisciplinary panel of 40 leading experts in the management of ovarian cancer. Before the conference, the expert panel worked on five clinically relevant questions regarding ovarian cancer relating to each of the following four areas: pathology and molecular biology, early-stage and borderline tumours, advanced stage disease and recurrent disease. Relevant scientific literature, as identified using a systematic search, was reviewed in advance. During the consensus conference, the panel developed recommendations for each specific question and a consensus was reached. The recommendations presented here are thus based on the best available evidence and expert agreement. This article presents the recommendations of this ESMO-ESGO consensus conference, together with a summary of evidence supporting each recommendation.

Combined Application of Ultrasound and CT Increased Diagnostic Value in Female Patients with Pelvic Masses

Purpose. The current study aimed to evaluate whether combined application of ultrasound and CT had increased Diagnostic Value in Female Patients with Pelvic Masses over either method alone. Patients and Methods. 240 female patients with pelvic masses were detected preoperatively with ultrasound and CT prior to surgery. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of ultrasound, CT, and combined ultrasound/CT application were evaluated, respectively. Results. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of ultrasound were 52.8%, 86.7%, and 68.75%, respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of CT were 80.3%, 90.3%, and 85%, respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of combined application of ultrasound and CT were 89%, 94.7%, and 91.7%. The sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of combined application of ultrasound and CT were higher than those of either ultrasound or CT. Conclusions. The combined application of ultrasound and CT had higher Diagnostic Value in Female Patients with Pelvic Masses than either method alone.

The significance of the change pattern of serum CA125 level for judging prognosis and diagnosing recurrences of epithelial ovarian cancer

Background

Ovarian cancer has the highest mortality rate of the three main malignant tumors of the female reproductive system, with a 5-year overall survival (OS) of only 20–30 %. Approximately 70 % of patients relapse without being cured. To explore the significance of serum CA125 level pre-treatment and the change pattern of CA125 post-treatment for judging prognosis and diagnosing recurrences of epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC).

Methods

A radioimmunoassay was used to continuously monitor levels of serum CA125 in 152 patients with EOC. The first test was done before surgery, then once a month after surgery for more than two consecutive years. The data were analyzed by using Kaplan-Meier curves and the log-rank test, stratified chi-square test, Pearson correlation analysis, and multivariate Cox regression analysis.

Results

(1) There was a relationship between patient outcomes and the serum CA125 levels before treatment and the extent and speed of serum CA125 decrease after treatment. The outcomes of patients with pre-treatment serum CA125 ≤ 35 U/ml were better than those with serum CA125 > 35 U/ml; the outcomes of patients with serum CA125 who had a logarithmic decrease or a decrease to normal within a month after treatment were also better than those with a non-logarithmic decrease or a decrease to normal that took longer than a month. (2) The results of multivariate Cox regression analysis showed that serum CA125 levels before treatment and a decreased speed of decline after treatment were independent prognostic factors; (3) The mean level of serum CA125 at relapse was 116.28 U/ml. The average time from serum CA125 increase to detection of a recurrent lesion by physical or imaging examination was 122 days. The correlation coefficient of serum CA125 level increase and tumor recurrence time was −0.674. (4) The area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curve of serum CA125 for diagnosing EOC recurrence was 0.879, and the sensitivity and specificity were 67.39 and 86.79 %, respectively.

Conclusions

It is important to monitor serum CA125 levels pre-treatment and the change pattern of CA125 post-treatment for judging prognosis and diagnosing recurrences of EOC.

Follow-up in Gynecological Malignancies: A State of Art

Objective

The main purpose of this article is to explore the current practice for follow-up of gynecological cancer, pointing out the different procedures, to determine the most clinically and cost-effective surveillance strategies after the primary treatment.

Materials and Methods

We analyzed the follow up strategies for ovarian, endometrial, and cervical cancer. All of the topics discussed below arose from the “ESGO State of Art Conference—Follow-up in gynaecological malignancies” in Turin, (September 11–13, 2014;http://torino2014.esgo.org/).

Results

Physical but these practices should be integrated with biomarkers or imaging strategies. Currently, most recommendations about follow-up are based on retrospective studies and expert opinion, and there is some disagreement on surveillance strategies due to lack of evidence-based knowledge.

Conclusions

All surveillance procedures should be evidence-based with a clearly defined purpose: there is a need for prospective studies to compare the effectiveness of different follow-up regimens measuring overall survival, detection of recurrence, quality of life (QoL), and costs as outcomes.

A 10-gene expression signature of Notch pathway predicts recurrence in ovarian carcinoma

Patients with ovarian carcinoma are at high risk of tumor recurrence. In the present study, 81 Notch pathway genes were selected to find recurrence-related genes in The Cancer Genome Atlas dataset. A 10-gene signature (FZD4, HES1, PSEN2, JAG2, PPARG, FOS, HEY1, CDC16, MFNG, and EP300) was identified and validated that is associated with recurrence-free survival time, but not with overall survival time, in the TCGA dataset and in other two independent datasets, GSE9891 and GSE30161. This gene signature gave a significant performance in discriminating patients at high risk of recurrence from those at low risk, as measured by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve. Cox proportional hazards regression analyses demonstrated that the prognostic value of this 10-gene set is independent of other clinical variables in all three datasets. The potential as a biomarker for predicting high- and low-risk subgroups for recurrence in ovarian cancer patients deserves further investigation in prospective patient cohorts in the future.

Evaluation of the cost of CA-125 measurement, physical exam, and imaging in the diagnosis of recurrent ovarian cancer

OBJECTIVE

Ovarian cancer accounts for 50% of deaths from gynecologic malignancies. We sought to determine the cost of common methods of surveillance of women with ovarian cancer in first clinical remission. The current standard for post treatment surveillance is the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) guidelines.

METHODS

We retrospectively determined how recurrence was initially detected at our institution and a cost model was created and applied to the United States population to calculate surveillance costs using the Surveillance Epidemiology & End Results (SEER) database.

RESULTS

57% (n=60) of first recurrences were identified by increasing CA 125 level. Routine office visit identified 27% (n=29) of recurrences, and 15% (n=16) were diagnosed initially with CT scan. In 5% (5/105), CT abnormality was the only finding. 95% (100/105) of patients had either elevated CA 125 or office visit findings at time of recurrence. Of the 22,000 women diagnosed with ovarian cancer yearly, 60% (n=13,266) will have advanced disease and are likely to recur. The surveillance cost for this population for 2 years using our model is $32,500,000 using NCCN guidelines and $58,000,000 if one CT scan is obtained.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggests that following NCCN guidelines will detect 95% of recurrences. An additional $26 million will be needed to identify the 5% of women with recurrence seen on CT only. Post treatment surveillance of ovarian cancer patients contributes significantly to health care costs. Use of CT scan to follow these patients largely increases cost with only a small increase in recurrence detection.

Impact of routine follow-up examinations on life expectancy in ovarian cancer patients: a simulation study

OBJECTIVE

The clinical benefit of routine follow-up in patients treated for ovarian cancer is subject to debate. In this study, the magnitude of the potential survival benefit of routine examinations was evaluated by Markov modeling.

METHODS

The clinical course of ovarian cancer was simulated using a 4-state nonstationary Markov model. Risk of recurrence and mortality probabilities were derived from individual patient data and Statistics Netherlands. The life expectancy was simulated for 3 follow-up scenarios: a current, withholding (all recurrences detected symptomatically), and perfect follow-up program (all recurrences detected asymptomatically). The impact of effective recurrence treatment in the future was modeled by varying the mortality ratio between patients with asymptomatically versus symptomatically detected recurrences. The model was validated using empirical data.

RESULTS

The mean life expectancy of patients, aged 58 years and in complete clinical remission after primary treatment, was 10.8 years. Varying the transition probabilities with ±25% changed the life expectancy by up to 1.1 years. The modeled life expectancy for the withholding and perfect follow-up scenarios was also 10.8 years and insensitive to model assumptions. In patients with stages IIB to IV, the life expectancy was 7.0 years, irrespective of follow-up strategy. A mortality ratio of 0.8 for patients with asymptomatically versus symptomatically detected recurrences resulted in a gain in life expectancy of 5 months for withholding versus perfect follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Routine follow-up in ovarian cancer patients is not expected to improve the life expectancy. The timing of detection of recurrent ovarian cancer is immaterial until markedly improved treatment options become available.

Polymorphic thymidylate synthase gene impacts on overall survival of patients with epithelial ovarian cancer after platinum-based chemotherapy

Aim: High levels of TS have been associated with a worse clinical outcome in several cancers including epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC). The TS gene (TYMS) is highly polymorphic and has an effect on mRNA/protein expression. Materials & methods: Six TYMS polymorphisms were investigated for overall survival (OS) in 216 EOC patients: TYMS 1494ins/del, TSER (variable number of tandem repeats of 28 bp), TSER G>C, TYMS 1053C>T, TYMS IVS6-68C>T and TYMS 1122A>G. Results: In a multivariate analysis, TYMS 1494 del/del genotype was associated with a significant increased OS compared with the ins/ins genotype (hazard ratio: 0.36; 95% CI: 0.16–0.82, p = 0.01). Similar results were obtained for the mutant genotypes TYMS 1053TT and TYMS IVS6-68TT. The event-free survival was significantly higher in TYMS 1053TT patients compared with wild-type patients (p = 0.05). Conclusion: TYMS 1494ins/del, 1053C>T and IVS6-68C>T polymorphisms can be prognostic markers for OS in patients with EOC, independently from stage at diagnosis, median age and tumor histotype.

Original submitted 11 May 2012; Revision submitted 10 August 2012

Does HE4 have a role as biomarker in the recurrence of ovarian cancer?

Human epididymis protein 4 (HE4) was recently approved by the Food and Drug Administration to monitor recurrence or progressive disease in epithelial ovarian cancer in conjunction with CA125. This is the first prospective controlled study in literature evaluating the sensitivity and specificity of HE4 and CA125 in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer. Serum samples were obtained 24 h before surgery from 34 patients with suspicious recurrent ovarian cancer and from 34 patients with benign adnexal pathology, operated from November 2010 to November 2011 at University Campus Bio-Medico of Rome. The CA125 normal value is considered less than 35 U/mL. Two HE4 cut-off are considered: less than 70 pmol/L and less than 150 pmol/L. The specificity analysis was performed using the parametric t test to compare the CA125 series and the Mann-Whitney test for the HE4 series. The level of statistical significance is set at p < 0.05. The CA125 sensitivity and specificity in detecting recurrent ovarian cancer is 35.29 and 58.82 %, respectively. The HE4 sensitivity is 73.53 and 26.47 %, for 70 pmol/L and 150 pmol/L cut-off, respectively. The HE4 specificity is 100 %. Combining CA125 and HE4 at cut-off of 70 pmol/L, the sensitivity to detect recurrent ovarian cancer is 76.47 % with a specificity of 100 %. The combination of CA125 and HE4 at cut-off of 70 pmol/L improves the overall sensitivity and specificity of CA125 alone, suggesting a useful application of HE4 in strategies for surveillance of ovarian cancer recurrence.

Molecular imprinted nanoelectrodes for ultra sensitive detection of ovarian cancer marker

The relentless discovery of cancer biomarkers demands improved methods for their detection. In this work, we developed protein imprinted polymer on three-dimensional gold nanoelectrode ensemble (GNEE) to detect epithelial ovarian cancer antigen-125 (CA 125), a protein biomarker associated with ovarian cancer. CA 125 is the standard tumor marker used to follow women during or after treatment for epithelial ovarian cancer. The template protein CA 125 was initially incorporated into the thin-film coating and, upon extraction of protein from the accessible surfaces on the thin film, imprints for CA 125 were formed. The fabrication and analysis of the CA 125 imprinted GNEE was done by using cyclic voltammetry (CV), differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) techniques. The surfaces of the very thin, protein imprinted sites on GNEE are utilized for immunospecific capture of CA 125 molecules, and the mass of bound on the electrode surface can be detected as a reduction in the faradic current from the redox marker. Under optimal conditions, the developed sensor showed good increments at the studied concentration range of 0.5-400 U mL(-1). The lowest detection limit was found to be 0.5 U mL(-1). Spiked human blood serum and unknown real serum samples were analyzed. The presence of non-specific proteins in the serum did not significantly affect the sensitivity of our assay. Molecular imprinting using synthetic polymers and nanomaterials provides an alternative approach to the trace detection of biomarker proteins.