Role of fluorine-18 fluoride PET-CT scan in the assessment of unilateral condylar hyperplasia in faciomandibular asymmetry patients: a preliminary study

Validation of quantitative [18F]NaF PET uptake parameters in bone diseases: a systematic review

PURPOSE

[18F]NaF PET has become an increasingly important tool in clinical practice toward understanding and evaluating diseases and conditions in which bone metabolism is disrupted. Full kinetic analysis using nonlinear regression (NLR) with a two-tissue compartment model to determine the net rate of influx (Ki) of [18F]NaF is considered the gold standard for quantification of [18F]NaF uptake. However, dynamic scanning often is impractical in a clinical setting, leading to the development of simplified semi-quantitative parameters. This systematic review investigated which uptake parameters have been used to evaluate bone disorders and how they have been validated to measure disease activity.

METHODS

A literature search (in PubMed, Embase.com, and Clarivate Analytics/Web of Science Core Collection) was performed up to 28th November 2023, in collaboration with an information specialist. Each database was searched for relevant literature regarding the use of [18F]NAF PET/CT to measure disease activity in bone-related disorders. The main aim was to explore whether the reported semi-quantitative uptake values were validated against full kinetic analysis. A second aim was to investigate whether the chosen uptake parameter correlated with a disease-specific outcome or marker, validating its use as a clinical outcome or disease marker.

RESULTS

The initial search included 1636 articles leading to 92 studies spanning 29 different bone-related conditions in which [18F]NaF PET was used to quantify [18F]NaF uptake. In 12 bone-related disorders, kinetic analysis was performed and compared with simplified uptake parameters. SUVmean (standardized uptake value) and SUVmax were used most frequently, though normalization of these values varied greatly between studies. In some disorders, various studies were performed evaluating [18F]NaF uptake as a marker of bone metabolism, but unfortunately, not all studies used this same approach, making it difficult to compare results between those studies.

CONCLUSION

When using [18F]NaF PET to evaluate disease activity or treatment response in various bone-related disorders, it is essential to detail scanning protocols and analytical procedures. The most accurate outcome parameter can only be obtained through kinetic analysis and is better suited for research. Simplified uptake parameters are better suited for routine clinical practice and repeated measurements.

Diagnostic Efficacy of Bone SPECT Techniques in Differentiating Unilateral and Bilateral Condylar Hyperplasia

Objectives: This analytical cross-sectional study evaluates diagnostic approaches for active condylar hyperplasia using bone SPECT techniques. Methods: it was compared the effectiveness of relative activity assessments between condyles and quantitative analysis using the condyle/clivus ratio. Results: This study's findings reveal that the condyle/clivus ratio method significantly outperforms the relative uptake method, achieving a sensitivity of 90.1% (95% CI: 84.1-94) compared to 40.7% (95% CI: 33.5-48.2), and a specificity of 77.1% (95% CI: 67.4-85) versus 72.9% (95% CI: 62.9-81.5). The condyle/clivus ratio also showed a more favorable negative likelihood ratio of 0.13 compared to 0.82 for relative uptake, and a higher area under the curve (AUC) of 0.8360 versus 0.5679. Statistically significant differences were noted (p = 0.0001). The condyle/clivus ratio method effectively identifies affected condyles in unilateral and bilateral condylar hyperplasia cases. Conclusions: This study emphasizes the importance of incorporating comprehensive clinical evaluations and imaging modalities for assessing condylar growth activity, underscoring the need for tailored reference values in different populations to ensure reliable diagnostic interpretations.

Accuracy of skeletal scintigraphy for the evaluation of mandibular growth disorders: a systematic review

Bone scans, reflecting blood flow and metabolic activity in a region of interest, are frequently used to evaluate mandibular growth disorders. Increased uptake is a non-specific finding and can occur as a result of multiple causes. The correlation between radioactive tracer uptake and growth activity has not been consistently demonstrated. The aim of this study was to assess the accuracy of planar skeletal scintigraphy (SS), single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), and SPECT with computed tomography (CT) images (SPECT/CT) in detecting abnormal mandibular growth activity compared to clinical and radiographic/tomographic methods (reference standard) and histologic findings. A systematic review was conducted following the PRISMA guidelines. Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were calculated for planar SS, SPECT, and SPECT/CT. Compared to the reference standard, SPECT/CT had the best diagnostic accuracy (76.5% sensitivity, 90.4% specificity, 83.2% accuracy), followed by planar SS (81.8% sensitivity, 84.5% specificity, 83.0% accuracy) and SPECT (77.7% sensitivity, 72.4% specificity, 74.5% accuracy). The results of this study indicate that SPECT/CT has the best clinical correlation, but the certainty of the evidence is low. The differences in sensitivity and specificity between the three index tests were not clinically significant. The three tests can be useful, with only a small difference in their diagnostic value. Histopathology was found not to be satisfactory as a reference standard.

Assessment of unilateral condylar hyperplasia with quantitative SPECT/CT

Purpose

The current study aimedto assess condylar activityin patients with unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) with quantitative SPECT/CT.

Patients and methods

This retrospective study included patients with UCH who underwent quantitative SPECT/CT. SPECT analysis and quantification of SPECT/CT were performed, and the maximum count per pixel and SUVmax of either side of the condyles were calculated.

Results

39 patients were included in the analysisand classified into three subgroups according to the percentile differential right-left ratio: inactive group, left active (LA) group, and right active (RA) group. Totally, the SUVmax of the affected side is significantly higher than the unaffected side (active:5.93 ± 2.43 vs inactive:3.62 ± 1.76, P < 0.001), SUVmax-based ratios correlated well with the ratios based on maximum count (R = 0.944, P < 0.001). ROC analysis showed poorSUVmaxperformance in differentiation between theactive condyles and the inactive condyles due to the lower area under the curve (AUC) (0.588). In subgroup analysis, the affected side is significantly higher than the unaffected side in active groups with SUVmax, no significant difference was found between the active sides or the inactive sides of active groups. Interestingly, the SUVmax of the left side was statistically higher than that of the right sidein the inactive group (P = 0.01),while the left side of the right active group has significantlylower activitythan that in the inactive group, meanwhile,the right side showed no significant difference. Furthermore, each side showed no significant difference between the left active group and the inactive group.

Conclusions

SUVmax is not an optimal measurement effectively used to evaluate active condyles. However, SUV ratios correlated well with the count ratios, and the left side of condyles showed a peculiar feature in condyle growth status reflected in radioactivity quantified with SPECT/CT, which needs further study to determine the role in the development of the UCH.

Reference values of mandibular condylar growth activity: a study of SUVmax with quantitative bone SPECT/CT

OBJECTIVE

To assess the condylar growth activity (CGA) with quantitative bone single photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography (SPECT/CT) to establish reference values of maximum standardized uptake value (SUVmax) and cutoff values for identifying active unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) in different ages.

METHODS

We analyzed the CGA of 58 UCH patients and that of 125 volunteers as a control group by SUVmax of quantitative bone SPECT/CT imaging. The SUVmax and the uptake difference between bilateral condyles among different age groups were analyzed. SUVmax cutoff values for detecting active condyle were calculated by receiver operating characteristic curve analysis.

RESULTS

The condylar SUVmax in 10-19, 20-29, 30-39, 40-49 and 50-59 years old groups of volunteers were 6.24 ± 1.39, 4.76 ± 0.98, 3.23 ± 0.64, 3.00 ± 0.61 and 2.90 ± 0.53, respectively. The uptake difference between bilateral condyles in the control group was 3.84% ± 1.71%. The affected condylar SUVmax was significantly higher than that of the contralateral condyle in active UCH patients (6.03 ± 2.85 vs. 3.96 ± 1.07; Z = -5.264; P = 0.000). SUVmax of the affected condyles in active UCH patients was not statistically higher than condylar SUVmax in the corresponding age group (6.03 ± 2.85 vs. 5.50 ± 1.41; Z = -0.173; P = 0.863). SUVmax of the unaffected condyles was significantly lower than condylar SUVmax in the corresponding age group (3.96 ± 1.07 vs. 5.50 ± 1.41; Z = -5.833; P = 0.000). SUVmax cutoff values for identifying active condyle were 6.26 and 4.53 in patients of 13-19 and 20-29 years old, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The condylar SUVmax varied with age. Different cutoff values of condylar SUVmax should be employed for diagnosing active UCH for patients in different ages.

Growth trends analysis of unilateral condylar hyperplasia followed up with planar scintigraphy: Retrospective overview of 249 cases

The current research aimed to retrospectively investigate the trends of the growth of condylar hyperplasia with serial planar scintigraphs.Patients of unilateral condylar hyperplasia with at least one follow-up planar scintigraph were retrospectively included in the study. Patients' age, gender at the initial scan, durations of following scans, and ratios between condylar activities were recorded.The study retrospectively included 111 patients of unilateral condylar hyperplasia. Patients were divided into 3 groups (progressive, relatively stable, regressive) according to ratio variation between initial and last scans. There were 23 (21%) patients fell into the progressive group, 40 (36%) patients into the relatively stable group, and 48 (43%) patients into the regressive group. More female patients were in the progressive group than those in the other groups (P < .01). There were no significant differences among the 3 groups in terms of age or durations of follow-up (P > .05). There were no strong relations between ratio differences and ages. However, a weak relation seems to exist in the regressive group with r = -0.240, (P = .10).Our investigation showed that more than a half of patients with condylar hyperplasia remain constantly or progressively active growth in patients in the follow-up scans. Roughly less than a half of patients showed regressive trends toward normal growth. Patients' age seemly does not play a role in the growth trend pattern, although there are no optimum follow-up periods, regularly follow-up scans are needed to determine the growth status of condylar hyperplasia.

Assessment of relative uptake by mandibular condyles in a "normal" population

Hyperplasia of the mandibular condyle is self-limiting, but can lead to facial asymmetry, malocclusion, pain, and dysfunction of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). Bone scintigraphy, particularly with single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), is effective in assessing relative condylar uptake, but we know of no standardised methods or values. Our aim, therefore was to validate the values currently used to measure relative condylar uptake in our population. Between December 2015 and June 2018 44 patients had skull SPECT (15 male and 29 female patients, whose ages ranged from 4-33 years). They were having bone scans (hydroxydiphosphonate (HDP) -^99MTc, 740 MBq ev) for unrelated reasons and had no known abnormalities of the head, facial asymmetry, or symptoms of the TMJ. Two research workers measured the relative uptake between the condyles using the summed transaxial images. The Hospital Ethics Committee approved the investigation. The maximum difference in condylar uptake was 8.33% with research worker 1 and 8.77% with research worker 2, and the mean (SD) differences were 3.03 (0.17) % and 3.29 (0.18) %, respectively. Data were tested for normality, and the t test and one-way ANOVA were used to assess the significance of differences. None was found in total counts either between sexes or age groups, and there were none between the total counts measured by the two research workers. We conclude that our results are within the published ranges, and the variation in condylar uptake was less than 5% in 37/44 patients, and in none was it 9% or more. When the results indicate less than 10%, but there is a high clinical suspicion of active hyperplasia, surgeons should use their clinical judgement to decide whether condylar surgery is required.

Nuclear Medicine Imaging in the Dentomaxillofacial Region

Nuclear medicine studies evaluate physiology on a molecular level providing earlier detection of lesions before morphologic change is evident. ^99mTc-MDP and ¹⁸F-fluoride bone scans detect osteomyelitis earlier than radiographs and computed tomography (CT); aid in diagnosis of temporomandibular joint disorder; and evaluate activity of condylar hyperplasia, extent of Paget disease, and viability of bone grafts. ¹⁸F-FDG PET/CT distinguish between soft tissue and bone infections and diagnose osteomyelitis complicated by fracture or surgery. FDG PET is more accurate than CT alone and has a major role in staging, restaging, and assessing response to therapy for head and neck malignancies and in detecting sequelae of therapy.

Low dose radiation 18F-fluoride PET/CT in the assessment of Unilateral Condylar Hyperplasia of the mandible: preliminary results of a single centre experience

Background

Unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) of the mandible, or Hypercondylia, is a pathological condition that determines an abnormal growth of the affected condyle.

Bone SPECT with Tc99m-diphosphonates is a successful tool in the diagnosis of UCH. EANM guidelines also suggest the use of 18F–NaF PET/CT, though it leads to a higher radiation exposure.

Aim

As UCH patients are young, we aimed to develop a low dose 18F–Fluoride PET/CT protocol and compare it to a standard injected activity scan, to assess if the image quality remains unchanged.

Materials and methods

We prospectively enrolled 20 patients (7 males, 13 females, mean age 23.2) with UCH, who underwent 18F–NaF PET/CT to assess the hypercondylia. We administered a low activity of 18F–NaF (2.9 MBq/kg) in 15 patients and a standard activity (5.3 MBq/kg) in 5 patients. Activity range was chosen according to 2015 EANM guidelines.

To determine if the scans with low radiotracer activity were “diagnostic” such as those with standard activity, two expert nuclear medicine physicians, unaware of the administered activity, independently reviewed the scans and expressed a final qualitative judgment in terms of “diagnostic”/“non-diagnostic” scan. Furthermore, we compared the effective dose of a low injected activity PET/CT to the standard one and to a Bone SPECT performed with standard injected activity of Tc99m-diphosphonates.

Results

Reviewers classified 19 of 20 scans as “diagnostic”. Only one of them was classified as “non diagnostic” due to condylar arthrosis that disturbed the correct evaluation of condylar radiotracer uptake. The effective dose of a 18F–Fluoride PET/CT, in patient of 70 kg, is about 3.5 mSv in scans performed with 2.9 MBq/kg [0.017 mSv/MBq × 2.9 MBq/kg × 70 kg] and about 6.3 mSv in ones performed with 5.3 MBq/kg [0.017 mSv/MBq × 5.3 MBq/kg × 70 kg]. The effective dose of 99mTc-MDP bone SPECT is about 3.2 mSv [0.0043 mSv/MBq × 740 MBq of 99mTc-MDP].

Discussion

18F–NaF PET/CT performed with a low radiotracer activity allows a good assessment of UCH similar to that performed with an ordinary activity. The effective radiation dose of a low-injected activity PET/CT is significantly lower than an ordinary-injected activity and is not significantly higher than the most used Bone SPECT. Moreover PET/CT is performed in 1.5 h while Bone SPECT requires at least 3.5 h.

Conclusions

The 18F–Fluoride PET/CT procedure could be performed with 2.9 MBq/Kg (minimum 185 MBq, recommended at least 200 MBq) of 18F–NaF to minimize the effective radiation dose received, maintaining the quality of the scan. Further studies including a larger number of patients and clinical follow-up are needed to confirm our preliminary findings.