The clinical value of early extubation

The Practice of Fast-Track Liver Transplant Anesthesia

Prior to the 1990s, prolonged postoperative intubation and admission to the intensive care unit was considered the standard of care following liver transplantation. Advocates of this practice speculated that this time allowed patients to recover from the stress of major surgery and allowed their clinicians to optimize the recipients' hemodynamics. As evidence in the cardiac surgical literature on the feasibility of early extubation grew, clinicians began applying these principles to liver transplant recipients. Further, some centers also began challenging the dogma that patients need to be cared for in the intensive care unit following liver transplantation and instead transferred patients to the floor or stepdown units immediately following surgery, a technique known as "fast-track" liver transplantation. This article aims to provide a history of early extubation for liver transplant recipients and offer practical advice on how to select patients that may be able to bypass the intensive care unit and be recovered in a non-traditional manner.

Enhanced recovery in liver transplantation: A value-based approach to complex surgical care

BACKGROUND

Value-based healthcare focuses on improving outcomes relative to cost. We aimed to study the impact of an enhanced recovery pathway for liver transplant recipients on providing value.

METHODS

In total, 379 liver recipients were identified: pre-enhanced recovery pathway (2017, n = 57) and post-enhanced recovery pathway (2018-2020, n = 322). The enhanced recovery pathway bundle was defined through multidisciplinary efforts and included optimal fluid management, end-of-case extubation, multimodal analgesia, and a standardized care pathway. Pre- and post-enhanced recovery pathway patients were compared with regard to extubation rates, lengths of stay, complications, readmissions, survival, and costs.

RESULTS

Pre- and post-enhanced recovery pathway recipient model for end-stage liver disease score and balance of risk scores were similar, although post-enhanced recovery pathway recipients had a higher median donor risk index (1.55 vs 1.39, P = .003). End-of-case extubation rates were 78% post-enhanced recovery pathway (including 91% in 2020) versus 5% pre-enhanced recovery pathway, with post-enhanced recovery pathway patients having decreased median intraoperative transfusion requirements (1,500 vs 3,000 mL, P < .001). Post-enhanced recovery pathway recipients had shorter median intensive care unit (1.6 vs 2.3 days, P = .01) and hospital stays (5.4 vs 8.0 days, P < .001). Incidence of severe (Clavien-Dindo ≥3) complications during the index hospitalization were similar between pre-enhanced recovery pathway versus post-enhanced recovery pathway groups (33% vs 23%, P = .13), as were 30-day readmissions (26% vs 33%, P = .44) and 1-year survival (93.0% vs 94.5%, P = .58). The post-enhanced recovery pathway cohort demonstrated a significant reduction in median direct cost per case ($11,406; P < .001).

CONCLUSION

Implementation of an enhanced recovery pathway in liver transplantation is feasible, safe, and effective in delivering value, even in the setting of complex surgical care.

Association Between Fast-Track Extubation After Orthotopic Liver Transplant, Postoperative Vasopressor Requirement, and Acute Kidney Injury

OBJECTIVES

Acute kidney injury is a significant cause of morbidity after orthotopic liver transplant. Early extubation after liver transplant may have a beneficial effect on postoperative renal function. This may be the result of reduction in vasopressor-mediated vasoconstriction used to counteract the hypotension associated with sedative use and the effects of positive-pressure ventilation. Previous studies explored advantages of early extubation after liver transplant but focused on resource usage rather than clinical benefit. This study was designed to determine the association between fast-track extubation and reduction in postoperative vasopressor requirement and whether this had any association with acute kidney injury incidence or renal replacement therapy requirement.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data were collected from 144 orthotopic liver transplants. A propensity-matched case-control analysis was conducted on a subgroup of 33 patients who were fast-track extubated and with 33 propensity score-matched control patients who were not. The primary outcome was median days of postoperative vasopressor use, and secondary outcomes included incidence of acute kidney injury, renal replacement therapy requirement, and critical care admission duration.

RESULTS

The fast-track extubation group had a shorter postoperative vasopressor requirement (0 vs 2 days; P < .01) and a reduced need for renal replacement therapy (3% vs 21.2%; P = .05). Median critical care admission duration (3 vs 4 days; P = .03) and hospital admission duration (14 vs 19 days; P = .04) were shorter in the fast-track extubation group.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study to reveal a significant association between fast-track extubation and reduced postoperative vasopressor requirement. Additionally, this was associated with a trend toward reduced renal replacement requirement after liver transplant. It suggests that early extubation may not just be a resource benefit to an institution but may convey a clinical benefit to patients through a reduction in organ failure and requirement for organ support.

The Protective Effect of Magnesium Lithospermate B on Hepatic Ischemia/Reperfusion via Inhibiting the Jak2/Stat3 Signaling Pathway

Acute inflammation is an important component of the pathogenesis of hepatic ischemia/reperfusion injury (HIRI). Magnesium lithospermate B (MLB) has strong neuroprotective and cardioprotective effects. The purpose of this study was to determine whether MLB had underlying protective effects against hepatic I/R injury and to reveal the potential mechanisms related to the hepatoprotective effects. In this study, we first examined the protective effect of MLB on HIRI in mice that underwent 1 h ischemia followed by 6 h reperfusion. MLB pretreatment alleviated the abnormal liver function and hepatocyte damage induced by I/R injury. We found that serum inflammatory cytokines, including IL-6, IL-1β, and TNF-α, were significantly decreased by MLB during hepatic ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) injury, suggesting that MLB may alleviate hepatic I/R injury via inhibiting inflammatory signaling pathways. Second, we investigated the protein level of p-Jak2/Jak2 and p-Stat3/Stat3 using Western blotting and found that MLB could significantly inhibit the activation of the Jak2/Stat3 signaling pathway, which was further verified by AG490 in a mouse model. Finally, the effect of MLB on the Jak2/Stat3 pathway was further assessed in an in vitro model of RAW 264.7 cells; 1 µg/ml LPS induced the secretion of inflammatory mediators, including IL-6, TNF-α, and activation of the Jak2/Stat3 signaling pathway. MLB significantly inhibited the abnormal secretion of inflammatory factors and the activation of the Jak2/Stat3 signaling pathway in RAW264.7 cells. In conclusion, MLB was found for the first time to reduce inflammation induced by hepatic I/R via suppressing the Jak2/Stat3 pathway.

Immediate versus conventional postoperative tracheal extubation for enhanced recovery after liver transplantation: IPTE versus CTE for enhanced recovery after liver transplantation

INTRODUCTION

To systematically compare immediate postoperative tracheal extubation (IPTE) with conventional tracheal extubation (CTE) and to determine whether IPTE can achieve an enhanced recovery for adult patients underwent liver transplantation (LT) without additional risks. We designed a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

The RCTs, cohorts, case-controls, or case series that explored outcomes of IPTE after LT for adults were involved in our study. The Newcastle-Ottawa scale was used to assess the risk of bias.

RESULTS

A total of 15 studies (n = 4144) were included, consisting of 10 studies (retrospective cohorts; n = 3387) for quantitative synthesis and 5 studies (1 prospective cohort, and 4 case series; n = 757) for qualitative synthesis. The pooled estimates suggested IPTE could reduce time to discharge from ICU stay (TDICU) (mean difference [MD] -2.12 days, 95% confidence interval [CI] -3.04 to -1.19 days), time to discharge from the hospital (TDH) (MD -6.43 days, 95% CI -9.53 to -3.33 days), re-intubation rate (RI) (odds ratio [OR] 0.29, 95% CI 0.22-0.39), morbidity rate (MR) (OR 0.15, 95% CI 0.08-0.30) and graft dysfunction rate (GD) (IPTE vs CTE: 0.3% vs 3.8%, P < .01), and had comparable ICU survival rate (ICUS) (OR 6.67 95% CI 1.34-33.35) when compared with CTE after LT.

CONCLUSIONS

IPTE can achieve an enhanced recovery for adult patients underwent LT without additional re-intubation, morbidity, and mortality risks. However, further work needs to be done to establish the extent definitively through carefully designed and conducted RCTs.

Rapid Recovery of Liver Transplantation Recipients by Implementation of Fast-Track Care Steps: What Is Holding Us Back?

A body of scientific studies has shown that early extubation is safe and cost-effective in a large number of liver transplant (LT) recipients including pediatric patients. However, fast-track practices are not universally accepted, and debate still lingers about whether these interventions are safe and serve the patients' best interest. In this article, we focus on reasons why physicians still have a persistent, although diminishing, reluctance to adopt fast-track protocols. We stress the importance of collection/analysis of perioperative data, adoption of a consensus-based standardized protocol for perioperative care, and formation of LT anesthesia focused teams and leadership. We conclude that the practice of early extubation and fast-tracking after LT surgery could help improve anesthesia performance, safety, and cost-effectiveness.

Extubation in the operating room after pediatric liver transplant: A retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Early extubation immediately following liver transplantation is increasingly common in adult practice. Some pediatric institutions have begun to adopt this strategy. Careful patient selection is essential in minimizing risk.

METHODS

This retrospective cohort study evaluated infants and children who underwent liver transplantation between July 2011 and December 2014. Our primary objective was to determine early extubation rate. Secondary objectives were to identify clinical factors associated with successful early extubation compared with delayed extubation and to examine significant postoperative complications, intensive care unit length of stay, and hospital length of stay.

RESULTS

The early extubation rate was 57.8% (37/64, confidence interval [CI] 44.8%-70.1%) over this 3.5-year period, increasing from 42% in 2012 to 58% by the end of 2014. The patients in the early extubation group were more likely to be older than the delayed extubation group (mean [SD], 7 [5.3] years vs 3.5 [5.5] years, difference between the mean [95% CI], 3.5 [0.8, 6.2] years); were to have come from home on the day of surgery (78.4% vs 25.9%); and were less likely to be listed as United Network for Organ Sharing status 1A (2.7% vs 25.9%). The early extubation group received less packed red blood cell volume (mean [SD], 9 [13.2] mL/kg vs 40.6 [48.5] mL/kg, difference between the mean [95% CI], 31.6 [95% CI 14.9, 48.3] mL/kg) and fresh-frozen plasma (mean 2.7 [SD 9.5] vs 13.3 [SD15.1], difference between the mean [95% CI], 10.5 [4.4,16.7] mL/kg). None of the patients in the early extubation group required reintubation in the first 24 hours following transplant and none experienced hepatic artery thrombosis. The early extubation group had a shorter average postoperative PICU stay (mean 3.8 [SD 2.1] days vs 17.6 [SD 31.3] days, difference between the mean [95% CI], 9.5 [4.3, 14.7] days) and a shorter postoperative hospital stay overall (mean 10.7 [SD 4.3] days vs 29.7 [SD 43.1] days, difference between the mean [95% CI], 19.1 [8.6, 29.6] days).

CONCLUSION

More than half of our pediatric liver transplant patients were successfully extubated in the operating room immediately following surgery. We believe early extubation to be safe when employed in selected subpopulations of pediatric patients undergoing liver transplantation.

Perioperative Care of the Liver Transplant Patient

With the evolution of surgical and anesthetic techniques, liver transplantation has become "routine," allowing for modifications of practice to decrease perioperative complications and costs. There is debate over the necessity for intensive care unit admission for patients with satisfactory preoperative status and a smooth intraoperative course. Postoperative care is made easier when the liver graft performs optimally. Assessment of graft function, vigilance for complications after the major surgical insult, and optimization of multiple systems affected by liver disease are essential aspects of postoperative care. The intensivist plays a vital role in an integrated multidisciplinary transplant team.

Critical Care of the Liver Transplant Recipient

Patient survival following orthotopic liver transplantation has greatly increased following improvements in surgical technique, anesthetic care, and immunosuppression. The critical care of the liver transplant recipient has paralleled these improvements, largely thanks to input from multidisciplinary teams and institution-specific protocols guiding management and care. This article provides an overview of the approach to critical care of the postoperative adult liver transplant recipient outlining common issues faced by the intensivist. Approaches to extubation and hemodynamic assessment are described. The provision of appropriate immunosuppression, infection prophylaxis, and nutrition is addressed. To aid prompt diagnosis and treatment, intensivists must be aware of postoperative complications of bleeding, primary nonfunction, delayed graft function, vascular thromboses, biliary complications, rejection, and organ dysfunction.

Factors affecting the duration of mechanical ventilation in patients after intestinal transplantation: preliminary results

OBJECTIVE

Intestinal transplantation (ITx) is a definitive therapy for patients with intestinal failure. However, postoperative respiratory care in such patients remains a clinical challenge. In this study, we investigated the factors affecting the duration of mechanical ventilation in patients who underwent ITx.

METHODS

In this observational study, eight patients who underwent ITx between 2007 and 2013 were studied. They were divided into two groups, with Group E including three patients who could be successfully extubated within 72 hours and Group V including the remaining five, who could not be extubated. The differences in demographical and clinical data between the two groups were evaluated.

RESULTS

The surgery success rate, patient survival rate, and graft survival rate were 100%, 88%, and 75%, respectively. Compared with Group E, postoperative bleeding was significantly higher in Group V (700 ± 420.7 mL vs. 50.0 ± 2.0 mL, p = 0.021). In addition, postoperative respiratory complications including pleural effusion and pneumonia (p = 0.017 and p = 0.0714, respectively) were prone to occur in Group V. Other variables including demographic parameters and clinical data showed no significant differences between the two groups. It was not unexpected that the duration of ventilator use and the length of intensive care unit stay were significantly shorter in Group E.

CONCLUSION

Postoperative blood loss and postoperative respiratory complications might be the factors responsible for delayed extubation in ITx patients. Because the study had few examinees, further studies with a larger population are needed to verify these issues.

Clinical practice of early extubation after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

Anesthetic practices such as early tracheal extubation facilitate postoperative recovery. Early extubation after liver transplantation has been adopted by some centers in the recent two decades. No universal clinical guidelines are used and questions remain. This review aimed to address the current status of early extubation after liver transplantation.

DATA SOURCES

A literature search of MEDLINE and ISI Web of Knowledge databases was performed using terms such as liver transplantation, early extubation, immediate tracheal extubation, fast tracking or fast track anesthesia and postoperative tracheal extubation. Additional papers were identified by a manual search of the references in the key articles.

RESULTS

Review of the available literature provided an insight into the definition, evolution, advantages and risks of early extubation, and anesthetic techniques that prompt early extubation in liver transplant patients. Early extubation has proved to be feasible and safe in these patients, but the outcomes are still uncertain.

CONCLUSIONS

Early extubation after liver transplantation is feasible, safe and cost-effective in the majority of patients and has been increasingly accepted as an option for conventional postoperative ventilation. Comprehensive and individualized evaluation of the patient's condition before extubation by an experienced anesthesiologist is the cornerstone of success. Understanding of its effect on the outcome remains incomplete. In the future, additional trials are required to establish universal early extubation guidelines and to determine its benefits for patients and practitioners.

Liver transplantation: Advances and perioperative care

Liver transplantation is one of the treatments for many-life threatening liver diseases. Numerous advances in liver transplant surgery, anaesthesia and perioperative care have allowed for an increasing number of these procedures. The purpose of this review is to consider some of the important advances in perioperative care of liver transplant patients such as pre-operative evaluation, intraoperative monitoring and management and early extubation. A PubMed and EMBASE search of terms “Anaesthesia” and “Liver Transplantation” were performed with filters of articles in “English”, “Adult” and relevant recent publications of randomised control trial, editorial, systemic review and non-systemic review were selected and synthesized according to the author's personal and professional perspective in the field of liver transplantation and anaesthesia. The article outlines strategies in organ preservation, training and transplant database for further research.

[Anesthesia in the patient with impaired liver function]

We review information on impaired liver function, focusing on concepts relevant to anesthesia and postoperative recovery. The effects of impaired function are analyzed by systems of the body, with attention to the complications the patient with liver cirrhosis may develop according to type of surgery. Approaches to correcting coagulation disorders in the cirrhotic patient are particularly controversial because an increase in volume may be a factor in bleeding owing to increased portal venous pressure and imbalances in the factors that favor or inhibit coagulation. Perioperative morbidity and mortality correlate closely to Child-Pugh class and the score derived from the model for end-stage liver disease (MELD). Patients in Child class A are at moderate risk and surgery is therefore not contraindicated. Patients in Child class C or with a MELD score over 20, on the other hand, are at high risk and should not undergo elective surgical procedures. Abdominal surgery is generally considered to put patients with impaired liver function at high risk because it causes changes in hepatic blood flow and increases intraoperative bleeding because of high portal venous pressures.

[Impact of anaesthesia management on post-surgical ventilation in post-anaesthesia care unit]

INTRODUCTION

Control of residual muscle paralysis and hypothermia reduce postoperative complications rate. Short context sensitive half life anaesthetic agents allow a better adjustment of anaesthesia depth according to surgical requirement and a safe early extubation. Using a large clinical database, impact of these three strategies was assessed on clinical criteria such as use of neostigmine in postanaesthesia care unit (PACU), temperature, sedation score at the arrival into PACU and mechanical ventilation weaning.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study on two separated periods. Since 2001, clinical events are entered into the database during and after anaesthesia in the same file. Agreement of anaesthesia staff to these strategies was assessed by the proportion of patients receiving modern anaesthetic agents (desflurane, sevoflurane and remifentanil) and the use of warming devices. Clinical impact was assessed by the number of patients receiving neostigmine in PACU, sedation score and temperature at the arrival in PACU and number of patients with mechanical ventilation in PACU.

RESULTS

Between the two periods (12,033 and 11,805 patients, respectively), use of sevoflurane, desflurane and remifentanil markedly increased, as well as the use of warming devices. Number of patients with neuromuscular reversal in PACU decreased from 73 to 11 and sedation score improved dramatically. Incidence of postoperative ventilation in PACU decreased from 1.1% (n=132) to 0.2% (n=30). Incidence of postoperative hypothermia was not changed during the two periods but incidence of hypothermia in the mechanically ventilated patient increased from 34.1 to 46.6%. Length of stay in PACU decreased from 122 to 114 minutes (p<0.05).

DISCUSSION

Implementation of new intraoperative protocols induced major effects on postoperative clinical parameters and especially postoperative mechanical ventilation. Failure of our hypothermia prevention associated with a fast return of consciousness lead to wean from mechanical ventilation hypothermic patients. Risks of this strategy were not estimated.