Differences in HIV clinical outcomes amongst heterosexuals in the United Kingdom by ethnicity

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown in women living with HIV who have a Black African and/or Black Caribbean heritage

OBJECTIVE

Treatment, adherence and linkage to care are lower in Black African and Black Caribbean heritage women living with HIV, affected by significant psychosocial challenges compared to other groups. The COVID-19 lockdowns further amplified these inequalities. We aimed to assess its impact on this population across Chelsea and Westminster Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust.

METHODS

We used an online survey and in-depth interviews to collect data between 01-10-2022 and 01-06-2023. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the survey data and thematic analysis was adopted to analyze the qualitative data.

RESULTS

Of 393 women contacted, 36 completed the survey and 22 took part in interviews. The survey found that COVID-19 lockdown restrictions worsened anxiety (48%) and low mood (45%). 54% reported that the experience of COVID-19 triggered the trauma of their initial HIV diagnosis. Interviewed participants discussed how their psychological issues and co-morbidities were not always addressed by their care system. Stigma and being forced to share their HIV information were also prominent issues.

CONCLUSIONS

There is continued institutional stigma and discrimination in health care settings for women living with HIV of African or Caribbean heritage, and there is an urgent need to address the inequity in care to improve patients' experience post-pandemic.

Co-designing interventions with multiple stakeholders to address barriers and promote equitable access to HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) in Black women in England

BACKGROUND

Black women are among the populations most underserved by HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) in England, despite higher risk of HIV acquisition. Previous research mostly focused on men who have sex with men (MSM), often neglecting Black women, and overfocused on patient-level barriers while overlooking provider and system-level factors. This study addresses these gaps by investigating barriers and facilitators to PrEP access by involving multiple stakeholders and exploring co-design strategies to tackle these barriers.

METHODS

The study used a structured two-phased qualitative approach. In Phase 1, focus groups (FG) were undertaken across three stakeholder streams: Black women, healthcare professionals (HCPs), and a group combining Black women and HCPs. FG allowed for consensus-building exercises on key barriers and facilitators to PrEP access, and their transcripts were analysed via thematic framework analysis using the Capability, Opportunity, Motivation and Behaviour model of behaviour change. In Phase 2, co-design workshops were conducted with the same stakeholder groups to develop interventions targeting the barrier identified as most important using the Behaviour Change Wheel framework. Interventions were evaluated against the APEASE criteria.

RESULTS

Phase 1 identified six key barriers: HIV/PrEP knowledge gaps, restrictive policies, cultural stigma, healthcare system distrust, gendered relationship dynamics, and suboptimal PrEP use. Six facilitators emerged, including improved knowledge, increased accessibility, and addressing discrimination. All stakeholder groups voted for lack of awareness and knowledge as the priority barrier to address. All co-designed interventions consisted of a multimodal PrEP awareness campaign tailored to Black communities, with an emphasis on Black women's involvement to foster trust and engagement. However, the workshops produced different approaches, with Black women focusing on community-led initiatives, and HCPs advocating for government-backed, broader strategies despite known distrust of institutions.

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights the importance of co-designing interventions with Black women to address multi-level barriers to PrEP access. It underscores the need for community education, healthcare system reforms, and the inclusion of Black women in decision-making processes to reduce PrEP equity gaps. The co-designed interventions provided a tailored, context-specific strategy that could improve PrEP uptake among Black women in England.

HIV in Latin American migrants in the UK: A neglected population in the 95-95-95 targets

BACKGROUND

The UK has reached the UNAIDS 2025 targets (of 95% of those living with HIV to be diagnosed, 95% to be on treatment and 95% of those on treatment to be virally suppressed). However, it is not known whether this target is met in subgroups such as migrant populations. Latin Americans are a fast-growing migrant group in the UK and have low engagement with healthcare services, yet little is known about the HIV profile in this population. This study aimed to explore the profile of Latin American migrants under HIV care in the UK, and to identify any gaps in the 95-95-95 target in this population.

METHODS

Country of birth- and gender- stratified prevalence of HIV in Latin American migrants in the UK (as of December 2022) was estimated using data from the HIV and AIDS Reporting System and the Office for National Statistics. UNAIDS (2024) estimates from Latin American countries were used as proxies for expected prevalences and applied to Latin American demography in England to calculate expected cases. The ratio of the observed (or diagnosed) cases to the expected cases was calculated to estimate potential underdiagnosis.

RESULTS

A total of 2482 migrants born in Latin American countries were diagnosed with (and under care for) HIV in the UK (observed prevalence 841 per 100 000 population) by the end of 2022. The highest observed prevalence was in men born in Country 3 (2431 per 100 000 population) and the lowest in women born in Country 13 (30 per 100 000 population). Some 89% (n = 2219) of Latin American migrants under care for HIV were men, with 263 women under care with HIV in the whole of the UK. For women born in five of the countries of the region, it was estimated that only 14%, 17%, 25%, 26% and 33% of women living with HIV were under care.

CONCLUSIONS

There may be a significant burden of underdiagnosis of HIV among Latin American women in the UK. Although based on some assumptions (notably the application of national HIV estimates to migrant populations which have a different risk profile), the gender disparity is striking. Community engagement and culturally appropriate targeted awareness raising and testing campaigns are recommended.

Viral rebound on antiretroviral therapy in France according to region of origin, sex, and HIV acquisition group. Results from the French Hospital Database on HIV (ANRS CO4-FHDH)

BACKGROUND

Assessing the potential increased risk of viral rebound (VR) in migrants requires adequate control for sex and acquisition risk groups.

METHODS

People living with HIV1, enrolled in the ANRS CO4-French Hospital Database on HIV, who achieved virological suppression with antiretroviral therapy (ART) initiated between 2006 and 2016 were included. We first compared the risk of VR, with loss to follow-up and death considered as competing events, across origin among the HIV acquisition groups, then across acquisition groups among the different origins, and finally across modality of a variable combining sex, acquisition group, and origin. Models were adjusted for clinical and biological confounding factors.

RESULTS

We included 21 571 French natives (FRA), 10 148 migrants from sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), 1137 migrants from the non-French West Indies (NFWI), and 4205 other migrants (OTHER). The 5-year probability of VR was 19% (95% confidence interval [CI] 19-20) overall, 15% in FRA, 21% in OTHER, 26% in SSA, and 34% in NFWI (p < 0.0001). It was 14% in men who have sex with men (MSM), 23% in heterosexual men, and 23% in women (p < 0.0001). After adjustment, all acquisition groups had a higher risk of VR than MSM from FRA, with men and women from NFWI having the highest risk (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR] 2.46; 95% CI 2.12-2.86 and aHR 2.59; 95% CI 2.20-3.04, respectively). Within each acquisition group, all groups of origin had a higher risk of VR than FRA. Within each region of origin, except the NFWI, heterosexual men had a higher risk of VR than MSM.

CONCLUSIONS

After accounting for sex and acquisition group, migration, especially from NFWI, remains prognostic of VR.

Social determinants of health and long-term conditions in people of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicity living with HIV in London: A qualitative study

BACKGROUND

People living with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) are disproportionately impacted by socioeconomic deprivation and are at increased risk of developing other long-term conditions (LTCs). These illnesses require transformative action to tackle the adverse effects on their health. Data on lived experiences of LTCs among people living with HIV of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicities are sparse, and how people with LTCs are impacted by social determinants of health (SDoH).

METHODS

Through a phenomenological study design this qualitative study, conducted in 2022, comprised four focus group discussions (FGDs) with 20 people of Black ethnicities living with HIV were purposively invited from a community organisation (CO) in London, including four semistructured interviews with CO staff. Following transcription, qualitative data were analysed thematically and measures to validate the findings were implemented.

RESULTS

The findings are presented in terms of the following four levels of SDoH: (1) individual determinants (such as the impact of SDoH on lifestyle modification and self-management); (2) interpersonal determinants (such as positive experiences of accessing healthcare for LTCs); (3) clinical determinants (such as care pathway barriers) and (4) systemic determinants (such as systemic barriers related to race/ethnicity).

CONCLUSIONS

It is necessary to provide ongoing and interactive education to community members who live with HIV, focusing on risks and management of LTCs. Additionally, individuals would benefit from support to navigate increasingly complex and fragmented health services. Health Service staff require cultural competence when caring for patients of Black African and Black Caribbean ethnicities with complex health and psychosocial needs.

PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

The research team collaborated with an HIV CO in South London from the very start of the project to agree the study design and learn about the realities of their daily lived experiences. Community collaborators helped to develop the semistructured interview and FGD topic guides, and were directly involved in the data gathering, analysis and validation.

Associations between social determinants of health and comorbidity and multimorbidity in people of black ethnicities with HIV

OBJECTIVE

Social determinants of health (SDH) are important determinants of long-term conditions and multimorbidity in the general population. The intersecting relationship between SDH and multimorbidity in people with HIV remains poorly studied.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional study investigating the relationships between eight socio-economic parameters and prevalent comorbidities of clinical significance and multimorbidity in adults of African ancestry with HIV aged 18-65 years in South London, UK.

METHODS

Multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to evaluate associations between SDH and comorbidities and multimorbidity.

RESULTS

Between September 2020 and January 2022, 398 participants (median age 52 years, 55% women) were enrolled; 85% reported at least one SDH and 72% had at least one comorbidity. There were no associations between SDH and diabetes mellitus or kidney disease, few associations between SDH (job and food insecurity) and cardiovascular or lung disease, and multiple associations between SDH (financial, food, housing and job insecurity, low educational level, social isolation, and discrimination) and poor mental health or chronic pain. Associations between SDH and multimorbidity mirrored those for constituent comorbidities.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrate strong associations between SDH and poor mental health, chronic pain and multimorbidity in people of black ethnicities living with HIV in the UK. These findings highlight the likely impact of enduring socioeconomic hardship in these communities and underlines the importance of holistic health and social care for people with HIV to address these adverse psychosocial conditions.

Impact of national commissioning of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) on equity of access in England: a PrEP-to-need ratio investigation

OBJECTIVES

HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) is highly effective in preventing HIV acquisition. In England, NHS availability was limited to participants of the PrEP Impact Trial until late 2020. Some key populations at greater risk of HIV were under-represented in the trial suggesting inequities in trial PrEP access. We used the PrEP-to-need ratio (PnR; number of PrEP users divided by new HIV diagnoses) to investigate whether PrEP access improved following routine commissioning in October 2020 and identify populations most underserved by PrEP.

METHODS

Aggregated numbers of people receiving ≥1 PrEP prescription and non-late new HIV diagnoses (epidemiological proxy for PrEP need) were taken from national surveillance data sets. We calculated the PnR across socio-demographics during Impact (October 2017 to February 2020; pre-COVID-19 pandemic) and post-commissioning PrEP era (2021) in England.

RESULTS

PnR increased >11 fold, from 4.2 precommissioning to 48.9 in 2021, due to a fourfold reduction in non-late new HIV diagnoses and near threefold increase in PrEP users. PnR increased across genders, however, the men's PnR increased 12-fold (from 5.4 precommissioning to 63.9 postcommissioning) while the women's increased sevenfold (0.5 to 3.5). This increasing gender-based inequity was observed across age, ethnicity and region of residence: white men had the highest PnR, increasing >13 fold (7.1 to 96.0), while Black African women consistently had the lowest PnR, only increasing slightly (0.1 to 0.3) postcommissioning, suggesting they were the most underserved group. Precommissioning, the PnR was 78-fold higher among white men than Black women, increasing to 278-fold postcommissioning.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the overall increase in PrEP use, substantial PrEP Impact trial inequities widened postcommissioning in England, particularly across gender, ethnicity and region of residence. This study emphasises the need to guide HIV combination prevention based on equity metrics relative to the HIV epidemic. The PnR could support the optimisation of combination prevention to achieve zero new HIV infections in England by 2030.

Factors associated with bacterial sexually transmitted infections among people of South Asian ethnicity in England

OBJECTIVES

Despite being the largest ethnic minority group in England, South Asians have historically had low levels of utilisation of sexual health services (SHS) and sexually transmitted infection (STI) diagnoses, although recent data suggests this may be changing. This study aimed to investigate factors associated with a bacterial STI diagnosis among South Asians attending SHS in England.

METHODS

Using data from the GUMCAD STI Surveillance system, a descriptive analysis of South Asians attending SHS in England in 2019 was carried out. Factors associated with a bacterial STI diagnosis were examined using univariate and multivariable logistic regression models adjusted for age, Asian ethnic subgroup, HIV status, patient's region of residence and Index of Multiple Deprivation quintile. Analyses were stratified by gender and sexual orientation (heterosexual male versus gay, bisexual and other men who have sex with men (GBMSM) versus women of any sexual orientation). Crude and adjusted associations were derived using binary logistic regression.

RESULTS

There were 121 842 attendances by South Asians to SHS in England in 2019. Compared with heterosexual South Asian men, GBMSM had a higher odds of being diagnosed with a bacterial STI (adjusted odds ratio (aOR) 2.32, 95% CI 2.19 to 2.44) and South Asian women had a lower odds (aOR 0.83, 95% CI 0.78 to 0.87). For women and heterosexual South Asian men, a diagnosis was associated with younger age, being of any other Asian background other than Bangladeshi, Indian or Pakistani and not being HIV positive. For heterosexual South Asian men, there was an association with increasing socioeconomic deprivation. For GBMSM, a bacterial STI diagnosis was associated with known HIV-positive status and living in London.

CONCLUSION

People of South Asian ethnicity in England are heterogeneous with regard to their sexual health needs, which should be explored further through focused research and policy.

Study protocol: the ILANA study - exploring optimal implementation strategies for long-acting antiretroviral therapy to ensure equity in clinical care and policy for women, racially minoritised people and older people living with HIV in the UK - a qualitative multiphase longitudinal study design

INTRODUCTION

Cabotegravir and rilpivirine (CAB+RPV long-acting (LA)) is recommended as a treatment for HIV-1 allowing people living with HIV to receive 2 monthly injectable treatment, rather than daily pills. Providing injectable therapy in a system designed to provide and manage study participants on oral treatments poses logistical challenges namely how resources are used to accommodate patient preference within constrained health economies with capacity limitations. In this pragmatic multicentre study, we aim to understand the implementation of CAB-RPV-LA administration in two settings via mixed methods to explore perspectives of participants and the clinical team delivering CAB+RPV LA.

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

Women, racially minoritised people and older people are chronically under-represented in HIV clinical trials so the ILANA trial has set recruitment caps to ensure recruitment of 50% women, 50% ethnically diverse people and 30% over 50 years of age to include a more representative study population. Using a mixed-methods approach, the primary objective is to identify and evaluate the critical implementation strategies for CAB+RPV LA in both hospital and community settings. Secondary objectives include evaluating feasibility and acceptability of CAB+RPV LA administration at UK clinics and community settings from the perspective of HIV care providers, nurses and representatives at community sites, evaluating barriers to implementation, the utility of implementation strategies and adherence.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

Ethical approval has been obtained from the Health Research Authority Research Ethics Committee (REC reference: 22/PR/0318). The dissemination strategy has been formulated with the SHARE Collaborative Community Advisory Board to maximise the impact of this work on clinical care and policy. This strategy draws on and leverages existing resources within the participating organisations, such as their academic infrastructure, professional relationships and community networks. The strategy will leverage the Public Engagement Team and press office to support dissemination of findings.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT05294159.

Replacement feeding and the HIV Diaspora: A case of ontological multiplicity and fluid technologies

Breastmilk is a transmission source of HIV. Therefore, mothers living with HIV are able to avoid exposing their infants to HIV-contaminated breastmilk if they replacement feed them. This article draws on an ethnographic study of an acute National Health Service HIV specialist antenatal clinic in London and explores the ontological multiple HIVs that the practice of replacement feeding takes part in enacting within the fluid space of the HIV diaspora. The term articulates the circumstances of racialised people affected by HIV who are originally from countries where access to life sustaining medication, care and resources-that enable a decoupling of the illness from death-are not readily accessible, and who have (temporarily) relocated themselves to geographical places where these resources are on offer. Arguing that Black African and Caribbean migrant women's ability to benefit from the technologies and care that have turned HIV into a chronic illness in England is delimited by race and their diasporic positionality. In so doing, the article contributes to Sociology by showing how race is part of practice-ethnographic research and medical care even when it is seemingly absent.

What will it take to achieve the sexual and reproductive health and rights of women living with HIV?

This article outlines progress in realizing the sexual and reproductive health and rights of women and girls living with HIV over the last 30 years from the perspective of women living with HIV. It argues that the HIV response needs to go beyond the bio-medical aspects of HIV to achieve our sexual and reproductive health and rights, and considers relevant Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), World Health Organization, United States President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR), Global Fund and other guidelines, what engagement there has been with women living with HIV and whether guidelines/strategies have been adopted. It has been written by women living with HIV from around the world and a few key supporters. Co-authors have sought to collate and cite materials produced by women living with HIV from around the world, in the first known effort to date to do this, as a convergence of evidence to substantiate the points made in the article. However, as the article also argues, research led by women living with HIV is seldom funded and rarely accepted as evidence. Combined with a lack of meaningful involvement of women living with HIV in others' research on us, this means that formally recognized evidence from women's own perspectives is patchy at best. The article argues that this research gap, combined with the ongoing primacy of conventional research methods and topics that exclude those most affected by issues, and the lack of political will (and sometimes outright opposition) in relation to gender equality and human rights, adversely affect policies and programmes in relation to women's rights. Thus, efforts to achieve an ethical, effective and sustainable response to the pandemic are hindered. The article concludes with a call to action to all key stakeholders.