Evaluating batch correction methods for image-based cell profiling

Bridging imaging-based in vitro methods from biomedical research to regulatory toxicology

Imaging technologies are being increasingly used in biomedical research and experimental toxicology to gather morphological and functional information from cellular models. There is a concrete opportunity of incorporating imaging-based in vitro methods in international guidelines to respond to regulatory requirements with human relevant data. To translate these methods from R&D to international regulatory acceptance, the community needs to implement test methods under quality management systems, assess inter-laboratory transferability, and demonstrate data reliability and robustness. This article summarises current challenges associated with image acquisition, image analysis, including artificial intelligence, and data management of imaging-based methods, with examples from the developmental neurotoxicity in vitro battery and phenotypic profiling assays. The article includes considerations on specific needs and potential solutions to design and implement future validation and transferability studies.

A versatile information retrieval framework for evaluating profile strength and similarity

In profiling assays, thousands of biological properties are measured across many samples, yielding biological discoveries by capturing the state of a cell population, often at the single-cell level. However, for profiling datasets, it has been challenging to evaluate the phenotypic activity of a sample and the phenotypic consistency among samples, due to profiles' high dimensionality, heterogeneous nature, and non-linear properties. Existing methods leave researchers uncertain where to draw boundaries between meaningful biological response and technical noise. Here, we developed a statistical framework that uses the well-established mean average precision (mAP) as a single, data-driven metric to bridge this gap. We validated the mAP framework against established metrics through simulations and real-world data applications, revealing its ability to capture subtle and meaningful biological differences in cell state. Specifically, we used mAP to assess both phenotypic activity for a given perturbation (or a sample) as well as consistency within groups of perturbations (or samples) across diverse high-dimensional datasets. We evaluated the framework on different profile types (image, protein, and mRNA profiles), perturbation types (CRISPR gene editing, gene overexpression, and small molecules), and profile resolutions (single-cell and bulk). Our open-source software allows this framework to be applied to identify interesting biological phenomena and promising therapeutics from large-scale profiling data.

A genome-wide atlas of human cell morphology

A key challenge of the modern genomics era is developing empirical data-driven representations of gene function. Here we present the first unbiased morphology-based genome-wide perturbation atlas in human cells, containing three genome-wide genotype-phenotype maps comprising CRISPR-Cas9-based knockouts of >20,000 genes in >30 million cells. Our optical pooled cell profiling platform (PERISCOPE) combines a destainable high-dimensional phenotyping panel (based on Cell Painting) with optical sequencing of molecular barcodes and a scalable open-source analysis pipeline to facilitate massively parallel screening of pooled perturbation libraries. This perturbation atlas comprises high-dimensional phenotypic profiles of individual cells with sufficient resolution to cluster thousands of human genes, reconstruct known pathways and protein-protein interaction networks, interrogate subcellular processes and identify culture media-specific responses. Using this atlas, we identify the poorly characterized disease-associated TMEM251/LYSET as a Golgi-resident transmembrane protein essential for mannose-6-phosphate-dependent trafficking of lysosomal enzymes. In sum, this perturbation atlas and screening platform represents a rich and accessible resource for connecting genes to cellular functions at scale.

Computational Methods for Data Integration and Imputation of Missing Values in Omics Datasets

Molecular profiling of different omic-modalities (e.g., DNA methylomics, transcriptomics, proteomics) in biological systems represents the basis for research and clinical decision-making. Measurement-specific biases, so-called batch effects, often hinder the integration of independently acquired datasets, and missing values further hamper the applicability of typical data processing algorithms. In addition to careful experimental design, well-defined standards in data acquisition and data exchange, the alleviation of these phenomena particularly requires a dedicated data integration and preprocessing pipeline. This review aims to give a comprehensive overview of computational methods for data integration and missing value imputation for omic data analyses. We provide formal definitions for missing value mechanisms and propose a novel statistical taxonomy for batch effects, especially in the presence of missing data. Based on an automated document search and systematic literature review, we describe 32 distinct data integration methods from five main methodological categories, as well as 37 algorithms for missing value imputation from five separate categories. Additionally, this review highlights multiple quantitative evaluation methods to aid researchers in selecting a suitable set of methods for their work. Finally, this work provides an integrated discussion of the relevance of batch effects and missing values in omics with corresponding method recommendations. We then propose a comprehensive three-step workflow from the study conception to final data analysis and deduce perspectives for future research. Eventually, we present a comprehensive flow chart as well as exemplary decision trees to aid practitioners in the selection of specific approaches for imputation and data integration in their studies.

Cell-vision fusion: A Swin transformer-based approach for predicting kinase inhibitor mechanism of action from Cell Painting data

Image-based profiling of the cellular response to drug compounds has proven effective at characterizing the morphological changes resulting from perturbation experiments. As data availability increases, however, there are growing demands for novel deep-learning methods. We applied the SwinV2 computer vision architecture to predict the mechanism of action of 10 kinase inhibitor compounds directly from Cell Painting images. This method outperforms the standard approach of using image-based profiles (IBP)-multidimensional feature set representations generated by bioimaging software. Furthermore, our fusion approach-cell-vision fusion, combining three different data modalities, images, IBPs, and chemical structures-achieved 69.79% accuracy and 70.56% F1 score, 4.20% and 5.49% higher, respectively, than the best-performing IBP method. We provide three techniques, specific to Cell Painting images, which enable deep-learning architectures to train effectively and demonstrate approaches to combat the significant batch effects present in large Cell Painting datasets.

Unleashing the potential of cell painting assays for compound activities and hazards prediction

The cell painting (CP) assay has emerged as a potent imaging-based high-throughput phenotypic profiling (HTPP) tool that provides comprehensive input data for in silico prediction of compound activities and potential hazards in drug discovery and toxicology. CP enables the rapid, multiplexed investigation of various molecular mechanisms for thousands of compounds at the single-cell level. The resulting large volumes of image data provide great opportunities but also pose challenges to image and data analysis routines as well as property prediction models. This review addresses the integration of CP-based phenotypic data together with or in substitute of structural information from compounds into machine (ML) and deep learning (DL) models to predict compound activities for various human-relevant disease endpoints and to identify the underlying modes-of-action (MoA) while avoiding unnecessary animal testing. The successful application of CP in combination with powerful ML/DL models promises further advances in understanding compound responses of cells guiding therapeutic development and risk assessment. Therefore, this review highlights the importance of unlocking the potential of CP assays when combined with molecular fingerprints for compound evaluation and discusses the current challenges that are associated with this approach.

Anomaly detection for high-content image-based phenotypic cell profiling

High-content image-based phenotypic profiling combines automated microscopy and analysis to identify phenotypic alterations in cell morphology and provide insight into the cell's physiological state. Classical representations of the phenotypic profile can not capture the full underlying complexity in cell organization, while recent weakly machine-learning based representation-learning methods are hard to biologically interpret. We used the abundance of control wells to learn the in-distribution of control experiments and use it to formulate a self-supervised reconstruction anomaly-based representation that encodes the intricate morphological inter-feature dependencies while preserving the representation interpretability. The performance of our anomaly-based representations was evaluated for downstream tasks with respect to two classical representations across four public Cell Painting datasets. Anomaly-based representations improved reproducibility, Mechanism of Action classification, and complemented classical representations. Unsupervised explainability of autoencoder-based anomalies identified specific inter-feature dependencies causing anomalies. The general concept of anomaly-based representations can be adapted to other applications in cell biology.

Morphological profiling for drug discovery in the era of deep learning

Morphological profiling is a valuable tool in phenotypic drug discovery. The advent of high-throughput automated imaging has enabled the capturing of a wide range of morphological features of cells or organisms in response to perturbations at the single-cell resolution. Concurrently, significant advances in machine learning and deep learning, especially in computer vision, have led to substantial improvements in analyzing large-scale high-content images at high throughput. These efforts have facilitated understanding of compound mechanism of action, drug repurposing, characterization of cell morphodynamics under perturbation, and ultimately contributing to the development of novel therapeutics. In this review, we provide a comprehensive overview of the recent advances in the field of morphological profiling. We summarize the image profiling analysis workflow, survey a broad spectrum of analysis strategies encompassing feature engineering- and deep learning-based approaches, and introduce publicly available benchmark datasets. We place a particular emphasis on the application of deep learning in this pipeline, covering cell segmentation, image representation learning, and multimodal learning. Additionally, we illuminate the application of morphological profiling in phenotypic drug discovery and highlight potential challenges and opportunities in this field.

A Decade in a Systematic Review: The Evolution and Impact of Cell Painting

High-content image-based assays have fueled significant discoveries in the life sciences in the past decade (2013-2023), including novel insights into disease etiology, mechanism of action, new therapeutics, and toxicology predictions. Here, we systematically review the substantial methodological advancements and applications of Cell Painting. Advancements include improvements in the Cell Painting protocol, assay adaptations for different types of perturbations and applications, and improved methodologies for feature extraction, quality control, and batch effect correction. Moreover, machine learning methods recently surpassed classical approaches in their ability to extract biologically useful information from Cell Painting images. Cell Painting data have been used alone or in combination with other - omics data to decipher the mechanism of action of a compound, its toxicity profile, and many other biological effects. Overall, key methodological advances have expanded Cell Painting's ability to capture cellular responses to various perturbations. Future advances will likely lie in advancing computational and experimental techniques, developing new publicly available datasets, and integrating them with other high-content data types.