Magnetism in 4d-transition metal clusters

Determining the Magnetic Status of Active Sites on Nanocatalysts

Identifying the atomic structure and chemical composition of active sites on nanocatalysts has been a long pursuit in heterogeneous catalysis. Yet, determining the magnetic structure of a well-defined active site is even more challenging. However, explicit morphology and reaction temperature have not been considered in identifying the magnetic behaviors of the nanocatalysts, especially in theoretical studies. Herein, we determined the magnetic status of nanoscale catalysts at finite temperatures by using atomistic spin models. The size dependence of the Curie point and the magnetic premelting have been discussed, indicating that the magnetic properties over a localized active center can greatly differ from the bulk. Therefore, the magnetic phase transitions and its concomitant magneto-catalytic effect can be induced at a considerably low temperature. Our analysis demonstrated that an 8 nm cobalt-based core-shell nanoparticle can achieve the optimal magnetization with Sabatier optimal activity for ammonia synthesis at 523 K, which is in accord with the reaction condition of the Haber-Bosch process. We believe our findings elucidate the importance of determining the localized magnetic configuration for active sites. Furthermore, including this unexcavated dimension in the dynamical simulations of the catalytic process can provide us with a more complete and comprehensive understanding of the reaction mechanism under working conditions.

Applications of metal nanoclusters supported on the two-dimensional material graphene in electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction

Metal nanoclusters (MNCs) have been demonstrated to exhibit superior catalytic performance compared to single nanoparticles. This is attributed to their quantized electronic structure, unique geometrical stacking and abundant active sites. While the exposed metal atoms can markedly enhance the efficiency of catalysis, unfortunately, MNCs are susceptible to agglomeration, which impairs their catalytic activity and stability. Graphene is a two-dimensional material consisting of a single atomic layer formed by the hybridization of the s and p orbitals of carbon atoms. It exhibits stable physical and chemical properties and has an easily controllable structure, making it an ideal carrier for MNCs. When metal nanoclusters (MNCs) are loaded on a graphene substrate, the MNCs can form a stable binding site on the graphene substrate. Furthermore, the construction of a defective structure on the graphene substrate enables the formation of robust interactions between the metal atoms of the MNCs and the substrate, facilitating the rapid establishment of electron conduction pathways and markedly enhancing the electrocatalytic performance. This paper presents a review of the applications of metal nanoclusters supported on graphene skeletons in the field of the electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). Firstly, we briefly introduce the reaction mechanism of the CO2RR, then we systematically discuss the synthesis strategies, properties and applications of metal nanoclusters in electrocatalytic carbon dioxide reduction from both experimental and theoretical perspectives, and lastly, we discuss the opportunities and challenges of metal nanocluster catalysts supported on carbon materials.

Energetic and Kinetic Competition on the Stability of Pd13 Clusters: Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Material stability is the focus on both experiments and calculations, which includes the energetic stability at the static state and the thermodynamic stability at the kinetic state. To show whether energetics or kinetics dominates on material stability, this study focuses on the Pd13 clusters, because of their observable magnetic moment in experiment. Energetically, the CALYPSO searching method and first-principles calculations find that Pd13(C2) is the ground state at 0 K while the static frequency calculations demonstrate that the icosahedron Pd13(Ih) becomes more favorable on free energy as temperature increases. However, their magnetic moments (8 μB) are not in agreement with the experimental value (<5.2 μB). Kinetically, ab initio molecular dynamics simulations reveal that Pd13(C3v) (6 μB) has supreme isomerization temperature and the other 11 low-lying isomers transform to Pd13(C3v) directly or indirectly, demonstrating that Pd13(C3v) has the maximum probability to be observed in experiment. The magnetic moment difference between experiment (<5.2 μB) and this calculation (6 μB) may be due to the spin multiplicities. Our result suggests that the magnetic moment disparity between theory and experiment (in Pd13 clusters) originates from the kinetic stability.

Magnetism of Otherwise Nonmagnetic Elements: From Clusters to Monolayers

Atomic clusters are known to exhibit properties different from their bulk phase. However, when assembled or supported on substrates, clusters often lose their uniqueness. For example, uranium and coinage metals (Cu, Ag, Au) are nonmagnetic in their bulk. Herein, we show that UX6 (X= Cu, Ag, Au) clusters, unlike their nonmagnetic bulk, are not only magnetic but also retain their magnetic character and structure when assembled into a two-dimensional (2D) material. The magnetic moment remains localized at the U site and is found to be 3μB in clusters and about 2μB in the 2D structure. In 2D UX4 (X = Cu, Ag, Au) monolayers, U atoms are found to be coupled antiferromagnetically through an indirect exchange coupling mediated by the coinage metal atoms. Furthermore, hydrogenation of these monolayers can induce a transition from the antiferromagnetic to the ferromagnetic phase. These results, based on density functional theory, have predictive capability and can motivate experiments.

Unravelling the Highest Magnetic Anisotropy Among all the n-Shells in 20 Metallocene

Single-molecule magnets (SMMs) with a large magnetization reversal barrier are predominated by the lanthanide systems due to their strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC). However, the transition metals have also emerged as potential contenders and the largest magnetic anisotropy has been identified for a cobalt system among any d-series-based SMMs (Bunting et al. Science 2018, 362, eaat7319). In this work, we have explored the magnetic anisotropy in highly axial ligand field systems of metallocene, having different d-subshell (3d4, 4d4, and 5d4). The wave function-based multireference methods including static and dynamic electron correlations have been employed to investigate the zero-field splitting (ZFS) parameters. Here, we report exceptionally large magnetic anisotropy for a 5d complex of [WCp2]0 with the highest energy barrier that is nearly twice as high as the previous record value for the Co complex. We have also observed that the axial ZFS parameter (D) is increasing down the group in the order of 3d < 4d < 5d, pertaining to a large SOC.

Magnetic Metal Clusters and Superatoms

Metal clusters with tunable magnetism and chemical activity are ideal models to study magnetic order changes from microstructures to macroscopic substances, to understand the spin effect in diverse catalytic reactions, and to create information carriers of qubits in quantum computation. Precise preparation, reaction, and characterization of magnetic clusters provide a platform to understand spin-exchange interactions and geometrical/electronic structure-property relationships; thus, they are beneficial for the rational design and development of new cluster-genetic materials and spintronics microdevices. Advances in this field have discovered some high-spin magnetic clusters and superatoms, expanding the understanding of magnetism, aromaticity, cluster stability, and electron delocalization. Herein we present a perspective of the experimental and theoretical progress regarding magnetic clusters and superatoms, with the expectation of stimulating more research interest in this field.

Rh19-: A high-spin super-octahedron cluster

Probing atomic clusters with magic numbers is of supreme importance but challenging in cluster science. Pronounced stability of a metal cluster often arises from coincident geometric and electronic shell closures. However, transition metal clusters do not simply abide by this constraint. Here, we report the finding of a magic-number cluster Rh19- with prominent inertness in the sufficient gas-collision reactions. Photoelectron spectroscopy experiments and global-minimum structure search have determined the geometry of Rh19- to be a regular Oh‑[Rh@Rh12@Rh6]- with unusual high-spin electronic configuration. The distinct stability of such a strongly magnetic cluster Rh19- consisting of a nonmagnetic element is fully unveiled on the basis of its unique bonding nature and superatomic states. The 1-nanometer-sized Oh-Rh19- cluster corresponds to a fragment of the face-centered cubic lattice of bulk rhodium but with altered magnetism and electronic property. This cluster features exceptional electron-spin state isomers confirmed in photoelectron spectra and suggests potential applications in atomically precise manufacturing involving spintronics and quantum computing.

Electronic properties and adsorption mechanism of Ru-doped copper clusters towards CH3OH molecule: A DFT investigation

In this study, we have investigated the stability and electronic properties of the Cu_nRu (n = 2-10) nanoclusters and their interaction with the CH₃OH molecule without and with the presence of O₂ molecule by using DFT calculations with TPSS/SDD/6-311g(d,p) level of theory. Based on the second energy difference (Δ²E), the results reveal that the Cu_nRu (n = 4, 6 and 8) clusters are relatively more stable than their neighboring clusters. The values obtained for the Fukui function (f^-) proves that the Ru atom in the Cu_nRu clusters is an excellent adsorption site for the molecules. The interaction of the Cu_nRu clusters with CH₃OH molecule exhibits that the Ru atom is the preferred adsorption site for the CH₃OH molecule, where the O atom of the CH₃OH molecule is strongly chemisorbed onto the Ru site of the clusters, forming a strong bond between the Ru and O atoms. The copper sites of the clusters were found less preferred for the adsorption of CH₃OH, and the complexes formed between both species are less stable than those obtained from the CH₃OH chemisorption over the Ru site of the clusters. The interaction of CH₃OH with the clusters was also evaluated in an oxidizing environment, and the results obtained reveal that the molecule is greatly chemisorbed over the ruthenium site with adsorption energies which vary from - 1.18 to - 2.05 eV. In the presence of the oxygen, the gap energy of the clusters was sharply changed after their interactions with the CH₃OH molecule, suggesting that these clusters can easily detect the above molecule with great sensitivity. Therefore, the presence of the oxygen not only does not prevent the adsorption process, but it considerably promotes the CH₃OH chemisorption onto the ruthenium site of the clusters and therefore significantly rises their sensitivity performance. In conclusion, the Cu_nRu clusters could be employed as effective nanosensors for the CH₃OH molecule detection.

Fourth generation cryogenic neutral cluster beam apparatus for studying fundamental properties of metallic clusters

A cryogenic beam apparatus for studying neutral clusters has been built and tested. The lowest beam temperature reaches less than 9 K at a repetition rate of 20 Hz. Mechanical decoupling from the refrigerator avoids misalignment during temperature ramping. Adopting a permanent magnet based magnetic deflector eliminates the hysteresis and electric noise of the traditional electromagnet and offers excellent reproducibility of the applied magnetic field. The mass spectrometer can operate in either Mass Spectroscopy Time-Of-Flight mode or Position-Sensitive Time-Of-Flight mode with spatial resolution better than 7 μm. Its performance is demonstrated with niobium and cobalt clusters.

First-Principles Study of Irn (n = 3-5) Clusters Adsorbed on Graphene and Hexagonal Boron Nitride: Structural and Magnetic Properties

Magnetic clusters have attracted great attention and interest due to their novel electronic properties, and they have potential applications in nanoscale information storage devices and spintronics. The interaction between magnetic clusters and substrates is still one of the challenging research focuses. Here, by using the density functional theory (DFT), we study the structural stability and magnetic properties of iridium clusters (Ir_n, n = 3–5) adsorbed on two-dimensional (2D) substrates, such as graphene and hexagonal boron nitride (hBN). We find that the most favorable configurations of free Ir_n clusters change when adsorbed on 2D substrates. In the meantime, the magnetic moments of the most stable Ir_n reduce to 53% (graphene) and 23.6% (hBN) compared with those of the free−standing ones. Interestingly, about 12-times enlargement on the magnetic anisotropy energy can be found on hBN substrates. These theoretical results indicate that the cluster–substrate interaction has vital effects on the properties of Ir_n clusters.

Gas Phase Synthesis of Multi-Element Nanoparticles

The advantages of gas-phase synthesis of nanoparticles in terms of size control and flexibility in choice of materials is well known. There is increasing interest in synthesizing multi-element nanoparticles in order to optimize their performance in specific applications, and here, the flexibility of material choice is a key advantage. Mixtures of almost any solid materials can be manufactured and in the case of core-shell particles, there is independent control over core size and shell thickness. This review presents different methods of producing multi-element nanoparticles, including the use of multiple targets, alloy targets and in-line deposition methods to coat pre-formed cores. It also discusses the factors that produce alloy, core-shell or Janus morphologies and what is possible or not to synthesize. Some applications of multi-element nanoparticles in medicine will be described.

Tuning of Structure Evolution and Electronic Properties through Palladium-Doped Boron Clusters: PdB16 as a Motif for Boron-Based Nanotubes

Transition metal-doped electronic deficiency boron clusters have led to a vast variety of electronic bonding properties in chemistry and materials science. We have determined the ground state structures of PdB_n^0/- (n = 10-20) clusters by performing CALYPSO search and density functional theory (DFT) optimization. The identified lowest energy structures for both neutral and anionic Pd-doped boron clusters follow the structure evolution from two dimensional (2D) planar configurations to 3D distorted Pd-centered drum-like or tubular structures. Photoelectron spectra are simulated by time-dependent DFT theoretical calculations, which is a powerful method to validate our obtained ground-state structures. More interestingly, two "magic" number clusters, PdB₁₂ and PdB₁₆, are found with enhanced stability in the middle size regime studied. Subsequently, molecular orbital and adaptive natural density partitioning analyses reveal that the high stability of the PdB₁₆ cluster originates from doubly σ π aromatic and bonding interactions of d-type atomic orbitals of the Pd atom with tubular B₁₆ units. The tubular C_8v PdB₁₆ cluster, with robust relative stability, is an ideal embryo for forming finite and infinite nanotube nanomaterials.

Thermal Stability of Ag13- Clusters Studied by Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Identification of the geometric structures of silver clusters is of great importance in future nanotechnologies due to their superior properties. Nevertheless, some ground-state structures are still in academic debate, partly because the experiments and theoretical calculations are not performed at the same temperatures. For example, silver clusters usually have compact configurations. However, a combined experimental and theoretical study proposed that the most stable structure of Ag₁₃^- had a two-coordinated atom. By using the CALYPSO approach for the global minima search followed by first-principles calculations, we discovered that a more compact trilayer Ag₁₃^- cluster was the ground state, in accordance with another three works published recently. In addition, its O₂ adsorption structure is also energetically favored. By tracing characteristic bond changes in ab initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we confirmed that, compared with other isomers, this trilayer structure and its O₂ adsorption structure also had the highest thermal stability. This work emphasized the thermal stability concept in theoretical calculations, which may be a necessary supplement to explain the experimental observations on cluster science.

The stability, electronic, and magnetic properties of rare-earth doped silicon-based clusters

The rare-earth doped silicon-based clusters exhibit remarkable structural, physical, and chemical properties, which make them attractive candidates as building units in designing of cluster-based materials with special optical, electronic, and magnetic properties. The structural, stability, electronic, and magnetic properties of pure silicon Si_n + 1 (n = 1-9) and rare-earth doped clusters Si_nEu (n = 1-9) are investigated using the "stochastic kicking" (SK) global search technique combined with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. It was found that: 1) the ground state structures of pure silicon clusters tend to form compact structures rather than cages with the increase of cluster size; 2) the ground state structures for doped species were found to be additional or substitutional sites, and the rare-earth atoms tend to locate on the surface of the silicon clusters; 3) the average binding energy of the doped clusters increased gradually and exhibited the final phenomenon of saturation with the increase of clusters size. The average binding energy of doped clusters was slightly higher than that of pure silicon clusters of the same size, which indicated that the rare-earth atom encapsulated by silicon enhanced the stability of the silicon clusters to some degree; 4) the doped clusters have strong total magnetic moments, which mainly originated from the contribution of rare-earth atoms, whereas the contribution of silicon atoms were almost negligible. As the cluster size increased, the total magnetic moments of binary mixed clusters tended to be stable.

The Behavior of Magnetic Properties in the Clusters of 4d Transition Metals

The current focus of material science researchers is on the magnetic behavior of transition metal clusters due to its great hope for future technological applications. It is common knowledge that the 4d transition elements are not magnetic at their bulk size. However, studies indicate that their magnetic properties are strongly dependent on their cluster sizes. This study attempts to identify magnetic properties of 4d transition metal clusters. Using a tight-binding Friedel model for the density of d-electron states, we investigated the critical size for the magnetic-nonmagnetic transition of 4d transition-metal clusters. Approaching to the critical point, the density of states of the cluster near the Fermi level is higher than 1/J and the discrete energy levels form a quasi-continuous band. Where J is correlation integral. In order to determine the critical size, we considered a square shape band and fcc, bcc, icosahedral and cuboctahedral close-packed structures of the clusters. We also investigated this size dependent magnetic behavior using Heisenberg model. Taking some quantum mechanical approximations in to consideration, we determined magnetic behavior of the clusters. For practicality, we considered three clusters of transition metals (Ru, Rh and Pd) and the obtained results are in line with the results of previous studies.

Cryo IR Spectroscopy of N2 and H2 on Ru8+: The Effect of N2 on the H-Migration

We present the cryo IR-PD spectra of the coadsorbed [Ru₈(H₂)₁(N₂)₄]⁺ and [Ru₈(N₂)₄(H₂)₁]⁺ species differing in the adsorption sequence of H₂ and N₂, which we record via application of tandem cryo ion trapping. We observe strong evidence for dissociative H₂ adsorption, and the spectra reveal differences in the Ru-H stretching region, which we assign to distal and proximal hydrogen atom locations on the Ru₈⁺ cluster, their migration likely hindered by preloaded nitrogen molecules and unaffected by subsequent N₂ adsorption.

Structure and magnetism in Cr-embedded Co nanoparticles

We present the results of an investigation into the atomic structure and magnetism of 2 nm diameter Co nanoparticles embedded in an antiferromagnetic Cr matrix. The nanocomposite films used in this study were prepared by co-deposition directly from the gas phase, using a gas aggregation source for the Co nanoparticles and a molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) source for the Cr matrix material. Co K and Cr K edge extended x-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) experiments were performed in order to investigate atomic structure in the embedded nanoparticles and matrix respectively, while magnetism was investigated by means of a vibrating sample magnetometer. The atomic structure type of the Co nanoparticles is the same as that of the Cr matrix (bcc) although with a degree of disorder. The net Co moment per atom in the Co/Cr nanocomposite films is significantly reduced from the value for bulk Co, and decreases as the proportion of Co nanoparticles in the film is decreased; for the sample with the most dilute concentration of Co nanoparticles (4.9% by volume), the net Co moment was 0.25 μ B/atom. After field cooling to below 30 K all samples showed an exchange bias, which was largest for the most dilute sample. Both the structural and magnetic results point towards a degree of alloying at the nanoparticle/matrix interface, leading to a core/shell structure in the embedded nanoparticles consisting of an antiferromagnetic CoCr alloy shell surrounding a reduced ferromagnetic Co core.

Insights into the geometries, electronic and magnetic properties of neutral and charged palladium clusters

We performed an unbiased structure search for low-lying energetic minima of neutral and charged palladium Pd_n^Q (n = 2–20, Q = 0, + 1 and –1) clusters using CALYPSO method in combination with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The main candidates for the lowest energy neutral, cationic and anionic clusters are identified, and several new candidate structures for the cationic and anionic ground states are obtained. It is found that the ground state structures of small palladium clusters are more sensitive to the charge states. For the medium size Pd_n^0/+/– (n = 16–20) clusters, a fcc-like growth behavior is found. The structural transition from bilayer-like structures to cage-like structures is likely to occur at n = 14 for the neutral and cationic clusters. In contrast, for the anionic counterparts, the structural transition occurs at Pd₁₃^–. The photoelectron spectra (PES) of palladium clusters are simulated based on the time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) method and compared with the experimental data. The good agreement between the experimental PES and simulated spectra provides us unequivocal structural information to fully solve the global minimum structures, allowing for new molecular insights into the chemical interactions in the Pd cages.

Substitutional 4d and 5d impurities in graphene

We describe the structural and electronic properties of graphene doped with substitutional impurities of 4d and 5d transition metals.

Structural evolution, electronic and magnetic manners of small rhodium Rhn+/− (n = 2–8) clusters: a detailed density functional theory study

We have evaluated the stable electronic structure and magnetic properties of all neutral and ionic Rh_n (n = 2–8) clusters using density functional theory. This study reveals that Rh₄ is the magic cluster based on the calculated reactivity parameters.

Orbit and spin resolved magnetic properties of size selected [ConRh]⁺ and [ConAu]⁺ nanoalloy clusters

Bi-metallic nanoalloys of mixed 3d-4d or 3d-5d elements are promising candidates for technological applications. The large magnetic moment of the 3d materials in combination with a high spin-orbit coupling of the 4d or 5d materials give rise to a material with a large magnetic moment and a strong magnetic anisotropy, making them ideally suitable in for example magnetic storage devices. Especially for clusters, which already have a higher magnetic moment compared to the bulk, these alloys can profit from the cooperative role of alloying and size reduction in order to obtain magnetically stable materials with a large magnetic moment. Here, the influence of doping of small cobalt clusters on the spin and orbital magnetic moment has been studied for the cations [Co(8-14)Au](+) and [Co(10-14)Rh](+). Compared to the undoped pure cobalt [Co(N)](+) clusters we find a significant increase in the spin moment for specific Co(N-1)Au(+) clusters and a very strong increase in the orbital moment for some Co(N-1)Rh(+) clusters, with more than doubling for Co12Rh(+). This result shows that substitutional doping of a 3d metal with even just one atom of a 4d or 5d metal can lead to dramatic changes in both spin and orbital moment, opening up the route to novel applications.

Trends in magnetism of free Rh clusters via relativistic ab-initio calculations

A fully relativistic ab-initio study on free Rh clusters of 13-135 atoms is performed to identify general trends concerning their magnetism and to check whether concepts which proved to be useful in interpreting magnetism of 3d metals are applicable to magnetism of 4d systems. We found that there is no systematic relation between local magnetic moments and coordination numbers. On the other hand, the Stoner model appears well-suited both as a criterion for the onset of magnetism and as a guide for the dependence of local magnetic moments on the site-resolved density of states at the Fermi level. Large orbital magnetic moments antiparallel to spin magnetic moments were found for some sites. The intra-atomic magnetic dipole Tz term can be quite large at certain sites but as a whole it is unlikely to affect the interpretation of x-ray magnetic circular dichroism experiments based on the sum rules.

Ab initio and anion photoelectron study of AunRhm (n = 1–7, m = 1–2) clusters

Anion photoelectron spectroscopy and DFT calculations study on Au_nRh_m (n = 1–7 and m = 1–2). PES spectra, vertical and adiabatic detachment energies, are compared. The characteristic planarity for gold clusters is preserved for many of the bimetallic clusters.