Swimmer Suspensions on Substrates: Anomalous Stability and Long-Range Order

Interface Dynamics of Wet Active Systems

We study the roughening of interfaces in phase-separated active suspensions on substrates. At both large length and time scales, we show that the interfacial dynamics belongs to the |q|KPZ universality class discussed in Besse et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 187102 (2023)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.130.187102]. This holds despite the presence of long-ranged fluid flows. At early times, however, or for sufficiently small systems, the roughening exponents are the same as those in the presence of a momentum-conserving fluid. Surprisingly, when the effect of substrate friction can be ignored, the interface becomes random beyond a de Gennes-Taupin length scale that depends on the interfacial tension.

Ordering spontaneous flows and aging in active fluids depositing tracks

Growing experimental evidence shows that cell monolayers can induce long-lived perturbations to their environment, akin to footprints, which in turn influence the global dynamics of the system. Inspired by these observations, we propose a comprehensive theoretical framework to describe systems where an active field dynamically interacts with a non-advected footprint field, deposited by the active field. We derive the corresponding general hydrodynamics for both polar and nematic fields. Our findings reveal that the dynamic coupling to a footprint field induces remarkable effects absent in classical active hydrodynamics, such as symmetry-dependent modifications to the isotropic-ordered transition, alterations in spontaneous flow transitions, and initial condition-dependent aging dynamics characterized by long-lived transient states. Our results suggest that footprint deposition could be a key mechanism determining the dynamical phases of cellular systems, or more generally active systems inducing long-lived perturbations to their environment.

Inertia Drives Concentration-Wave Turbulence in Swimmer Suspensions

We discover an instability mechanism in suspensions of self-propelled particles that does not involve active stress. Instead, it is driven by a subtle interplay of inertia, swimmer motility, and concentration fluctuations, through a crucial time lag between the velocity and the concentration field. The resulting time-persistent state seen in our high-resolution numerical simulations consists of self-sustained waves of concentration and orientation, transiting from regular oscillations to wave turbulence. We analyze the statistical features of this active turbulence, including an intriguing connection to the Batchelor spectrum of passive scalars.

Dynamics of packed swarms: Time-displaced correlators of two-dimensional incompressible flocks

We analytically calculate the scaling exponents of a two-dimensional KPZ-like system: coherently moving incompressible polar active fluids. Using three different renormalization group approximation schemes, we obtain values for the roughness exponent χ and anisotropy exponent ζ that are extremely near the known exact results. This implies our prediction for the previously unknown dynamic exponent z is likely to be quantitatively accurate.

Packed Swarms on Dirt: Two-Dimensional Incompressible Flocks with Quenched and Annealed Disorder

We show that incompressible polar active fluids can exhibit an ordered, coherently moving phase even in the presence of quenched disorder in two dimensions. Unlike such active fluids with annealed disorder (i.e., time-dependent random white noise) only, which behave like equilibrium ferromagnets with long-range interactions, this robustness against quenched disorder is a fundamentally nonequilibrium phenomenon. The ordered state belongs to a new universality class, whose scaling laws we calculate using three different renormalization group schemes, which all give scaling exponents within 0.02 of each other, indicating that our results are quite accurate. Our predictions can be quantitatively tested in readily available artificial active systems and imply that biological systems such as cell layers can move coherently in vivo, where disorder is inevitable.

Active nonreciprocal attraction between motile particles in an elastic medium

We show from experiments and simulations on vibration-activated granular matter that self-propelled polar rods in an elastic medium on a substrate turn and move towards each other. We account for this effective attraction through a coarse-grained theory of a motile particle as a moving point-force density that creates elastic strains in the medium that reorient other particles. Our measurements confirm qualitatively the predicted features of the distortions created by the rods, including the |x|^{-1/2} tail of the trailing displacement field and nonreciprocal sensing and pursuit. A discrepancy between the magnitudes of displacements along and transverse to the direction of motion remains. Our theory should be of relevance to the interaction of motile cells in the extracellular matrix or in a supported layer of gel or tissue.

Dense polar active fluids in a disordered environment

We examine the influence of quenched disorder on the flocking transition of dense polar active matter. We consider incompressible systems of active particles with aligning interactions under the effect of either quenched random forces or random dilution. The system displays a continuous disorder-order (flocking) transition, and the associated scaling behavior is described by a new universality class which is controlled by a quenched Navier-Stokes fixed point. We determine the critical exponents through a perturbative renormalization group analysis. We show that the two forms of quenched disorder, random force and random mass (dilution), belong to the same universality class, in contrast with the situation at equilibrium.

Hydrodynamic theory of flocking at a solid-liquid interface: Long-range order and giant number fluctuations

We construct the hydrodynamic theory of coherent collective motion ("flocking") at a solid-liquid interface. The polar order parameter and concentration of a collection of "active" (self-propelled) particles at a planar interface between a passive, isotropic bulk fluid and a solid surface are dynamically coupled to the bulk fluid. We find that such systems are stable, and have long-range orientational order, over a wide range of parameters. When stable, these systems exhibit "giant number fluctuations," i.e., large fluctuations of the number of active particles in a fixed large area. Specifically, these number fluctuations grow as the 3/4th power of the mean number within the area. Stable systems also exhibit anomalously rapid diffusion of tagged particles suspended in the passive fluid along any directions in a plane parallel to the solid-liquid interface, whereas the diffusivity along the direction perpendicular to the plane is nonanomalous. In other parameter regimes, the system becomes unstable.

Strong confinement of active microalgae leads to inversion of vortex flow and enhanced mixing

Microorganisms swimming through viscous fluids imprint their propulsion mechanisms in the flow fields they generate. Extreme confinement of these swimmers between rigid boundaries often arises in natural and technological contexts, yet measurements of their mechanics in this regime are absent. Here, we show that strongly confining the microalga Chlamydomonas between two parallel plates not only inhibits its motility through contact friction with the walls but also leads, for purely mechanical reasons, to inversion of the surrounding vortex flows. Insights from the experiment lead to a simplified theoretical description of flow fields based on a quasi-2D Brinkman approximation to the Stokes equation rather than the usual method of images. We argue that this vortex flow inversion provides the advantage of enhanced fluid mixing despite higher friction. Overall, our results offer a comprehensive framework for analyzing the collective flows of strongly confined swimmers.

Topology of Orientational Defects in Confined Smectic Liquid Crystals

We propose a general formalism to characterize orientational frustration of smectic liquid crystals in confinement by interpreting the emerging networks of grain boundaries as objects with a topological charge. In a formal idealization, this charge is distributed in pointlike units of quarter-integer magnitude, which we identify with tetratic disclinations located at the end points and nodes. This coexisting nematic and tetratic order is analyzed with the help of extensive Monte Carlo simulations for a broad range of two-dimensional confining geometries as well as colloidal experiments, showing how the observed defect networks can be universally reconstructed from simple building blocks. We further find that the curvature of the confining wall determines the anchoring behavior of grain boundaries, such that the number of nodes in the emerging networks and the location of their end points can be tuned by changing the number and smoothness of corners, respectively.

Long-Range Nematic Order in Two-Dimensional Active Matter

Working in two space dimensions, we show that the orientational order emerging from self-propelled polar particles aligning nematically is quasi-long-ranged beyond ℓ_{r}, the scale associated to induced velocity reversals, which is typically extremely large and often cannot even be measured. Below ℓ_{r}, nematic order is long-range. We construct and study a hydrodynamic theory for this de facto phase and show that its structure and symmetries differ from conventional descriptions of active nematics. We check numerically our theoretical predictions, in particular the presence of π-symmetric propagative sound modes, and provide estimates of all scaling exponents governing long-range space-time correlations.

Chiral Active Hexatics: Giant Number Fluctuations, Waves, and Destruction of Order

Active materials, composed of internally driven particles, have properties that are qualitatively distinct from matter at thermal equilibrium. However, the most spectacular departures from equilibrium phase behavior are thought to be confined to systems with polar or nematic asymmetry. In this Letter, we show that such departures are also displayed by more symmetric phases such as hexatics if, in addition, the constituent particles have chiral asymmetry. We show that chiral active hexatics whose rotation rate does not depend on density have giant number fluctuations. If the rotation rate depends on density, the giant number fluctuations are suppressed due to a novel orientation-density sound mode with a linear dispersion which propagates even in the overdamped limit. However, we demonstrate that beyond a finite but large length scale, a chirality and activity-induced relevant nonlinearity invalidates the predictions of the linear theory and destroys the hexatic order. In addition, we show that activity modifies the interactions between defects in the active chiral hexatic phase, making them nonmutual. Finally, to demonstrate the generality of a chiral active hexatic phase we show that it results from the melting of chiral active crystals in finite systems.

Coarsening in the two-dimensional incompressible Toner-Tu equation: Signatures of turbulence

We investigate coarsening dynamics in the two-dimensional, incompressible Toner-Tu equation. We show that coarsening proceeds via vortex merger events, and the dynamics crucially depend on the Reynolds number Re. For low Re, the coarsening process has similarities to Ginzburg-Landau dynamics. On the other hand, for high Re, coarsening shows signatures of turbulence. In particular, we show the presence of an enstrophy cascade from the intervortex separation scale to the dissipation scale.

Size-dependent patterns of cell proliferation and migration in freely-expanding epithelia

The coordination of cell proliferation and migration in growing tissues is crucial in development and regeneration but remains poorly understood. Here, we find that, while expanding with an edge speed independent of initial conditions, millimeter-scale epithelial monolayers exhibit internal patterns of proliferation and migration that depend not on the current but on the initial tissue size, indicating memory effects. Specifically, the core of large tissues becomes very dense, almost quiescent, and ceases cell-cycle progression. In contrast, initially-smaller tissues develop a local minimum of cell density and a tissue-spanning vortex. To explain vortex formation, we propose an active polar fluid model with a feedback between cell polarization and tissue flow. Taken together, our findings suggest that expanding epithelia decouple their internal and edge regions, which enables robust expansion dynamics despite the presence of size- and history-dependent patterns in the tissue interior.

Phases and excitations of active rod-bead mixtures: simulations and experiments

We present a large-scale numerical study, supplemented by experimental observations, on a quasi-two-dimensional active system of polar rods and spherical beads confined between two horizontal plates and energised by vertical vibration. For a low rod concentration Φr, our observations are consistent with a direct phase transition, as bead concentration Φb is increased, from the isotropic phase to a homogeneous flock. For Φr above a threshold value, an ordered band dense in both rods and beads occurs between the disordered phase and the homogeneous flock, in both experiments and simulations. Within the size ranges accessible, we observe only a single band, whose width increases with Φr. Deep in the ordered state, we observe broken-symmetry "sound" modes and giant number fluctuations. The direction-dependent sound speeds and the scaling of fluctuations are consistent with the predictions of field theories of flocking; sound damping rates show departures from such theories, but the range of wavenumbers explored is modest. At very high densities, we see phase separation into rod-rich and bead-rich regions, both of which move coherently.

Relaxation in a phase-separating two-dimensional active matter system with alignment interaction

Via computer simulations, we study kinetics of pattern formation in a two-dimensional active matter system. Self-propulsion in our model is incorporated via the Vicsek-like activity, i.e., particles have the tendency of aligning their velocities with the average directions of motion of their neighbors. In addition to this dynamic or active interaction, there exists passive inter-particle interaction in the model for which we have chosen the standard Lennard-Jones form. Following quenches of homogeneous configurations to a point deep inside the region of coexistence between high and low density phases, as the systems exhibit formation and evolution of particle-rich clusters, we investigate properties related to the morphology, growth, and aging. A focus of our study is on the understanding of the effects of structure on growth and aging. To quantify the latter, we use the two-time order-parameter autocorrelation function. This correlation, as well as the growth, is observed to follow power-law time dependence, qualitatively similar to the scaling behavior reported for passive systems. The values of the exponents have been estimated and discussed by comparing with the previously obtained numbers for other dimensions as well as with the new results for the passive limit of the considered model. We have also presented results on the effects of temperature on the activity mediated phase separation.

Nonmutual torques and the unimportance of motility for long-range order in two-dimensional flocks

As the constituent particles of a flock are polar and in a driven state, their interactions must, in general, be fore-aft asymmetric and nonreciprocal. Within a model that explicitly retains the classical spin angular momentum field of the particles we show that the resulting asymmetric contribution to interparticle torques, if large enough, leads to a buckling instability of the flock. More precisely, this asymmetry also yields a natural mechanism for a difference between the speed of advection of polarization information along the flock and the speed of the flock itself, concretely establishing that the absence of detailed balance, and not merely the breaking of Galilean invariance, is crucial for this distinction. To highlight this we construct a model of asymmetrically interacting spins fixed to lattice points and demonstrate that the speed of advection of polarization remains nonzero. We delineate the conditions on parameters and wave number for the existence of the buckling instability. Our theory should be consequential for interpreting the behavior of real animal groups as well as experimental studies of artificial flocks composed of polar motile rods on substrates.

Active uniaxially ordered suspensions on disordered substrates

Multiple experiments on active systems consider oriented active suspensions on substrates or in chambers tightly confined along one direction. The theories of polar and apolar phases in such geometries were considered in A. Maitra et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 028002 (2020)10.1103/PhysRevLett.124.028002] and A. Maitra et al. [Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115, 6934 (2018)10.1073/pnas.1720607115], respectively. However, the presence of quenched random disorder due to the substrate cannot be completely eliminated in many experimental contexts possibly masking the predictions from those theories. In this paper, I consider the effect of quenched orientational disorder on the phase behavior of both polar and apolar suspensions on substrates. I show that polar suspensions have long-range order in two dimensions with anomalous number fluctuations, while their apolar counterparts have only short-range order, albeit with a correlation length that can increase with activity, and even more violent number fluctuations than active nematics without quenched disorder. These results should be of value in interpreting experiments on active suspensions on substrates with random disorder.

Enhanced Orientational Ordering Induced by an Active yet Isotropic Bath

Can a bath of isotropic but active particles promote ordering of anisotropic but passive particles? In this Letter, we uncover a fluctuation-driven mechanism by which this is possible. Somewhat counterintuitively, we show that the passive particles tend to be more ordered upon increasing the noise strength of the active isotropic bath. We first demonstrate this in a general dynamical model for a nonconserved order parameter (model A) coupled to an active isotropic field and then concentrate on two examples: (i) a collection of polar rods on a substrate in an active isotropic bath and (ii) a passive apolar suspension in a momentum conserved, actively forced but isotropic fluid, which are relevant for current research in active systems. Our theory, which is relevant for understanding ordering transitions in out-of-equilibrium systems can be tested in experiments, for instance, by introducing a low concentration of passive rodlike objects in active isotropic fluids and, since it is applicable to any nonconserved dynamical field, may have applications far beyond active matter.

Spontaneous rotation can stabilise ordered chiral active fluids

Active hydrodynamic theories are a powerful tool to study the emergent ordered phases of internally driven particles such as bird flocks, bacterial suspension and their artificial analogues. While theories of orientationally ordered phases are by now well established, the effect of chirality on these phases is much less studied. In this paper, we present a complete dynamical theory of orientationally ordered chiral particles in two-dimensional incompressible systems. We show that phase-coherent states of rotating chiral particles are remarkably stable in both momentum-conserved and non-conserved systems in contrast to their non-rotating counterparts. Furthermore, defect separation-which drives chaotic flows in non-rotating active fluids-is suppressed by intrinsic rotation of chiral active particles. We thus establish chirality as a source of dramatic stabilisation in active systems, which could be key in interpreting the collective behaviors of some biological tissues, cytoskeletal systems and collections of bacteria.