Hormonal Characterization of Transgenic Tobacco Plants Expressing the rolC Gene of Agrobacterium rhizogenes TL-DNA

Kalanchoë blossfeldiana naturally transformed with Rhizobium rhizogenes exhibits superior root phenotype

Plant transformation with root oncogenic loci (rol) genes and open reading frames (ORFs) from Rhizobium rhizogenes have not yet targeted the underground root phenotype of these transformants. Hence, there is a need to develop plants with more efficient root system architecture (RSA). Here, RSA was assessed in naturally transformed (NT) and single rol/ORF Kalanchoë blossfeldiana 'Molly' lines in an aeroponic growth system combined with gene expression analysis. Three NT lines; 306, 324 and 331; exhibited better-developed RSA with longer roots and increased root biomass. In line 306, longest root was 6.3 ± 0.3 cm while WT had 4.8 ± 0.1 cm. However, root length of all overexpressing lines was ca. 30% shorter than WT. Root fresh weight of NT lines was 4.5-fold higher than WT. The expression of rolB, ∆ORF13a and ORF14 in the leaves of overexpressing lines was many folds higher than in NT lines. Increased expression of ∆ORF13a and ORF14 in leaves and roots may contribute more to a stronger compact phenotype than previously assumed. The moderate compact phenotype of NT lines combined with improved RSA compared to the overexpressing lines and WT strongly indicate that the use of R. rhizogenes has great potential to produce Kalanchoë phenotypes with enhanced RSA.

Compact shoot architecture of Osteospermum fruticosum transformed with Rhizobium rhizogenes

Improved compact shoot architecture of Osteospermum fruticosum Ri lines obtained through Rhizobium rhizogenes transformation reduces the need for chemical growth retardants. Compactness is for many ornamental crops an important commercial trait that is usually obtained through the application of growth retardants. Here, we have adopted a genetic strategy to introduce compactness in the perennial shrub Cape daisy (Osteospermum fruticosum Norl.). To this end, O. fruticosum was transformed using six different wild type Rhizobium rhizogenes strains. The most effective R. rhizogenes strains Arqua1 and ATCC15834 were used to create hairy root cultures from six Cape daisy genotypes. These root cultures were regenerated to produce transgenic Ri lines, which were analyzed for compactness. Ri lines displayed the characteristic Ri phenotype, i.e., reduced plant height, increased branching, shortened internodes, shortened peduncles, and smaller flowers. Evaluation of the Ri lines under commercial production conditions showed that similar compactness was obtained as the original Cape daisy genotypes treated with growth retardant. The results suggest that the use of chemical growth retardants may be omitted or reduced in commercial production systems of Cape daisy through implementation of Ri lines in future breeding programs.

Transgenic Kalanchoë blossfeldiana, Containing Individual rol Genes and Open Reading Frames Under 35S Promoter, Exhibit Compact Habit, Reduced Plant Growth, and Altered Ethylene Tolerance in Flowers

Reduced growth habit is a desirable trait for ornamental potted plants and can successfully be obtained through Rhizobium rhizogenes transformation in a stable and heritable manner. Additionally, it can also be obtained by transformation with Agrobacterium tumefaciens harboring specific genes from R. rhizogenes. The bacterial T-DNA harbors four root oncogenic loci (rol) genes and 14 less known open reading frames (ORFs). The four rol genes, i.e., rolA, rolB, rolC, and rolD, are conceived as the common denominator for the compact phenotype and the other less characterized ORFs seem auxiliary but present a potential breeding target for less aberrant and/or more tailored phenotypes. In this study, Kalanchoë blossfeldiana 'Molly' was transformed with individual rol genes and selected ORFs in 35S overexpressing cassettes to comprehensively characterize growth traits, gene copy and expression, and ethylene tolerance of the flowers. An association of reduced growth habit, e.g. height and diameter, was observed for rolB2 and ORF14-2 when a transgene single copy and high gene expression were detected. Chlorophyll content was reduced in overexpressing lines compared to wild type (WT), except for one ΔORF13a (a truncated ORF13a, where SPXX DNA-binding motif is absent). The flower number severely decreased in the overexpressing lines compared to WT. The anthesis timing showed that WT opened the first flower at 68.9 ± 0.9 days and the overexpressing lines showed similar or up to 24 days delay in flowering. In general, a single or low relative gene copy insertion was correlated to higher gene expression, ca. 3 to 5-fold, in rolB and ΔORF13a lines, while in ORF14 such relation was not directly linked. The increased gene expression observed in rolB2 and ΔORF13a-2 contributed to reducing plant growth and a more compact habit. Tolerance of detached flowers to 0.5 μl L-1 ethylene was markedly higher for ORF14 with 66% less flower closure at day 3 compared to WT. The subcellular localization of rolC and ΔORF13a was investigated by transient expression in Nicotiana benthamiana and confocal images showed that rolC and ΔORF13a are soluble and localize in the cytoplasm being able to enter the nucleus.

The Agrobacterium Phenotypic Plasticity (Plast) Genes

The transfer of T-DNA sequences from Agrobacterium to plant cells is a well-understood process of natural genetic engineering. The expression of T-DNA genes in plants leads to tumors, hairy roots, or transgenic plants. The transformed cells multiply and synthesize small molecules, called opines, used by Agrobacteria for their growth. Several T-DNA genes stimulate or influence plant growth. Among these, iaaH and iaaM encode proteins involved in auxin synthesis, whereas ipt encodes a protein involved in cytokinin synthesis. Growth can also be induced or modified by other T-DNA genes, collectively called plast genes (for phenotypic plasticity). The plast genes are defined by their common ancestry and are mostly found on T-DNAs. They can influence plant growth in different ways, but the molecular basis of their morphogenetic activity remains largely unclear. Only some plast genes, such as 6b, rolB, rolC, and orf13, have been studied in detail. Plast genes have a significant potential for applied research and may be used to modify the growth of crop plants. In this review, I summarize the most important findings and models from 30 years of plast gene research and propose some outlooks for the future.

Biological activity of the Agrobacterium rhizogenes-derived trolC gene of Nicotiana tabacum and its functional relation to other plast genes

Agrobacterium rhizogenes induces hairy roots through the activity of three essential T-DNA genes, rolA, rolB, and rolC, whereas the orf13 gene acts as an accessory root-inducing gene. rolB, rolC, and orf13 belong to the highly diverged plast gene family with remotely related representatives in the endomycorrhizal basidiomycete Laccaria bicolor. Nicotiana glauca and N. tabacum contain A. rhizogenes-derived T-DNAs with active plast genes. Here, we report on the properties of a rolC homolog in N. tabacum, trolC. Dexamethasone-inducible trolC and A4-rolC genes from A. rhizogenes A4 induce comparable, strong growth effects affecting all parts of the plants. Several have not been described earlier and were found to be very similar to the effects of the distantly related plast gene 6b. They include leaf chlorosis and starch accumulation, enations, increase of sucrose-dependent leaf disk expansion, growth of isolated roots on low-sucrose media, and stimulation of sucrose uptake by small root fragments. Collectively, our findings indicate that enhancement of sucrose uptake plays an important role in generating the complex 6b and rolC phenotypes and might be an ancestral property of the plast genes.

The Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolC-gene-induced somatic embryogenesis and shoot organogenesis in Panax ginseng transformed calluses

Expression of the Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolC gene in Panax ginseng callus cells results in formation of tumors that are capable to form roots. The selection of non-root forming tumor clusters yielded the embryogenic 2c3 callus line, which formed somatic embryos and shoots independently of external growth factors. Although the 2c3 somatic embryos developed through a typical embryogenesis process, they terminated prematurely and repeatedly formed adventitious shoot meristems and embryo-like structures. A part of the shoots and somatic embryos formed enlarged and fasciated meristems. This is the first indication of the rolC gene embryogenic effect and, to our knowledge, the first indication that a single gene of non-plant origin can induce somatic embryogenesis in plants.

Suppression of root nodule formation by artificial expression of the TrEnodDR1 (coat protein of White clover cryptic virus 1) gene in Lotus japonicus

TrEnodDR1 (Trifolium repens early nodulin downregulation 1) encodes a coat protein of White clover cryptic virus 1. Its expression in white clover was down-regulated at the time when root nodules formed. We surmised that its artificial expression would interfere with root nodulation. Therefore, we investigated the effects of its artificial expression on the growth and root nodulation of Lotus japonicus (a model legume). Transformants were prepared by Agrobacterium spp.-mediated transformation. The growth of transformants was reduced and the number of root nodules per unit root length was greatly decreased relative to control. The concentration of endogenous abscisic acid (ABA), which controls nodulation, increased in plants containing TrEnodDR1. These phenotypes clearly were canceled by treatment with abamine, a specific inhibitor of ABA biosynthesis. The increase in endogenous ABA concentration explained the reduced stomatal aperture and the deformation of root hairs in response to inoculation of transgenic L. japonicus with Mesorhizobium loti. Transcriptome comparison between TrEnodDR1 transformants and control plants showed clearly enhanced expression levels of various defense response genes in transformants. These findings suggest that TrEnodDR1 suppresses nodulation by increasing the endogenous ABA concentration, perhaps by activating the plant's innate immune response. This is the first report of the suppression of nodulation by the artificial expression of a virus coat protein gene.

Inhibitory effect of the Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolC gene on rabdosiin and rosmarinic acid production in Eritrichium sericeum and Lithospermum erythrorhizon transformed cell cultures

Rabdosiin and related caffeic acid metabolites have been proposed as active pharmacological agents demonstrating potent anti-HIV and antiallergic activities. We transformed Eritrichium sericeum and Lithospermum erythrorhizon seedlings by the rolC gene, which has been recently described as an activator of plant secondary metabolism. Surprisingly, the rolC-transformed cell cultures of both plants yielded two- to threefold less levels of rabdosiin and rosmarinic acid (RA) than respective control cultures. This result establishes an interesting precedent when the secondary metabolites are differently regulated by a single gene. We show that the rolC gene affects production of rabdosiin and RA irrespective of the methyl jasmonate (MeJA)-mediated and the Ca(2+)-dependent NADPH oxidase pathways. Cantharidin, an inhibitor of serine/threonine phosphatases, partly diminishes the rolC-gene inhibitory effect that indicates involvement of the rolC-gene-mediated signal in plant regulatory controls, mediated by protein phosphatases. We also show that the control MeJA-stimulated E. sericeum root culture produces (-)-rabdosiin up to 3.41% dry weight, representing the highest level of this substance for plant cell cultures reported so far.

Influence of rol genes in floriculture

Traditionally, new traits have been introduced into ornamental plants through classical breeding. However, genetic engineering now enables specific alterations of single traits in already successful varieties. New or improved varieties of floricultural crops can be obtained by acting on floral traits, such as color, shape or fragrance, on vase life in cut-flower species, and on rooting potential or overall plant morphology. Overexpression of the rol genes of the Ri plasmid of Agrobacterium rhizogenes in plants alters several of the plant's developmental processes and affects their architecture. Both A. rhizogenes- and rol-transgenic plants display the "hairy-root phenotype", although specific differences are found between species and between transgenic lines. In general, these plants show a dwarfed phenotype, reduced apical dominance, smaller, wrinkled leaves, increased rooting, altered flowering and reduced fertility. Among the rol genes, termed rolA, B, C and D, rolC has been the most widely studied because its effects are the most advantageous in terms of improving ornamental and horticultural traits. In addition to the dwarfness and the increase in lateral shoots that lead to a bushy phenotype, rolC-plants display more, smaller flowers, and advanced flowering; surprisingly, these plants may have better rooting capacity and they show almost no undesirable traits. rolD, the least studied among the rol genes, offers promising applications due to its promotion of flowering. Although the biochemical functions of rol genes remain poorly understood, they are useful tools for improving ornamental flowers, as their expression in transgenic plants yields many beneficial traits.

Engineered sorbitol accumulation induces dwarfism in Japanese persimmon

A cDNA encoding sorbitol-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (S6PDH), which is a key enzyme in sorbitol biosynthesis in Rosaceae, was introduced into the Japanese persimmon (Diospyros kaki) to increase the environmental stress tolerance. Resultant transformants exhibited salt-tolerance with dwarfing phenotypes. Therefore, we studied two transgenic lines to understand the physiological mechanism of this dwarfism: lines PS1 and PS6 accumulated high and moderate levels of sorbitol, respectively. The average length of shoots was significantly shorter as compared with the wild-type in line PS1, while no such decrease was observed in line PS6. The myo-inositol and glucose 6-phosphate (G6P) contents were measured in the transgenic lines because previous work with tobacco transformed with S6PDH had suggested that growth inhibition was due to depletion of these metabolites. Although the myo-inositol content was decreased in PS1 plants, the decrease was much smaller than that observed in transgenic tobacco that accumulates sorbitol. The G6P contents were the same in PS1 plants and phenotypically normal PS6 plants. The level of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), which affects stem elongation, in line PS1 was similar to the levels in the other lines. A decrease in gibberellin (GA) content generally induces dwarfism in plants. However, GA was not decreased in PS1 plants compared with wild-type or control plants. Therefore, we focused on sorbitol accumulation as the most remarkable feature of PS1 plants. As one possibility, the observed growth inhibition was likely caused by an osmotic imbalance between the cytosol and vacuole.

Pleiotropic effect of the insertion of the Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolD gene in tomato ( Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)

The Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolD gene, coding for an ornithine cyclodeaminase involved in the biosynthesis of proline from ornithine, has been inserted in Lycopersicon esculentum cv Tondino with the aim of studying its effects on plant morphological characters including pathogen defense response. The analysis of plants transgenic for rolD did not show major morphological modifications. First generation transgenic plants however were found to flower earlier, and showed an increased number of inflorescences and higher fruit yield. Transformed plants were also analysed for parameters linked to pathogen defense response, i.e. ion leakage in the presence of the toxin produced by the fungus Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici, and expression of the pathogenesis-related PR-1 gene. All the plants harbouring the rolD gene were shown to be more tolerant to the toxin in ion leakage experiments, with respect to the untransformed regenerated controls and the cv Tondino. PR-1 gene expression was quantitated by means of real-time PCR both at the basal level and after treatment with salicylic acid, an inducer of Systemic Acquired Resistance. In both cases the amount of PR-1 mRNA was higher in the transgenic plants. It seems therefore that the transformation of tomato plants with rolD could lead to an increased competence for defense response, as shown by toxin tolerance and increased expression of the Systemic Acquired Resistance marker gene PR-1. The results are finally discussed in view of their possible economic relevance.

The horizontal transfer of Agrobacterium rhizogenes genes and the evolution of the genus Nicotiana

With the aim of understanding better the distribution and evolution of Agrobacterium rhizogenes genes transferred in the genus Nicotiana, 42 species were screened for presence of rolB, rolC, ORF13, and ORF14. The transferred sequences were then compared within the genus and with current bacterial sequences. The results obtained showed the presence of at least one bacterial gene in 15 species belonging to different subgenera. Sequence analyses supported the hypothesis of coevolution of bacterial and plant sequences, thus suggesting a possible role for the transferred genes in the early events of Nicotiana species differentiation. The high level of conservation of Agrobacterium sequences and the dependence of their expression from the plant physiological context along with previous data suggesting their involvement in the determination of the plant hormonal balance were all consistent with this hypothesis. The results are finally discussed also as to their relevance for the hypothesis of mono and multi ancient infection by Agrobacterium.

Reevaluating concepts of apical dominance and the control of axillary bud outgrowth

A large amount of diversity of architectural form is found among flowering plants, and an important aspect of this diversity is the wide variation, ranging from simple to complex, found among branching patterns in plant shoot systems. Historically, the control of bud outgrowth has been attributed to the presence of a growing shoot apex. The term "apical dominance" is used to indicate that the shoot tip exerts an inhibitory control over proximal axillary buds. Through decapitation and/or hormone manipulation experiments, this inhibition has been attributed to the phytohormones auxin and cytokinin. Recent studies with mutants demonstrating increased branching indicate important additional roles for organs apart from those in the shoot tip and for signals other than cytokinin and auxin. This chapter provides a critical review of branching with an emphasis toward bud outgrowth in a developmental context. This review provides a detailed synopsis of physiological, genetic, and molecular studies and approaches for the investigation of branching regulation in plants.

The impact of Ti-plasmid-derived gene vectors on the study of the mechanism of action of phytohormones

The molecular basis of tumor formation on dicotyledonous plants by Agrobacterium relies on the transfer to the plant cell of a unique segment of bacterial DNA, the T-DNA. The T-DNA contains genes that are active in the plant cell and encode hormone biosynthetic enzymes, or proteins that deregulate the cell's response to phytohormones. Study of this process has yielded not only knowledge of how alterations in phytohormone homeostasis can affect plant cell growth, but also has provided the essential tools to study phytohormone signaling in transgenic plants. Furthermore, T-DNA insertion into the plant genome forms the basis of gene tagging, a versatile method for isolating genes involved in phytohormone signal transduction and action.

Expression of the Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolC Gene in a Deciduous Forest Tree Alters Growth and Development and Leads to Stem Fasciation

We have altered the growth and development of a deciduous forest tree by transforming hybrid aspen (Populus tremula x Populus tremuloides) with the Agrobacterium rhizogenes rolC gene expressed under the strong cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter. We demonstrate that the genetically manipulated perennial plants, after a period of dormancy, maintain the induced phenotypical changes during the second growing period. Furthermore, mass-spectrometrical quantifications of the free and conjugated forms of indole-3-acetic acid and cytokinins and several gibberellins on one transgenic line correlate the induced developmental alterations such as stem fasciation to changes in plant hormone metabolism. We also show that the presence of the RolC protein increases the levels of the free cytokinins, but not by a process involving hydrolysis of the inactive cytokinin conjugates.

Attenuation of the Phenotype Caused by the Root-Inducing, Left-Hand, Transferred DNA and Its rolA Gene (Correlations with Changes in Polyamine Metabolism and DNA Methylation)

We present four examples of attenuation of the transformed phenotype caused by the root-inducing, left-hand, transferred DNA from Agrobacterium rhizogenes in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum). The first was associated with a genetic variable (homozygosity for the T-DNA), and the second was induced at the physiological level by putrescine and tyramine, suggesting that the transformed phenotype depends on defective polyamine metabolism. Physiological attenuation is further illustrated in the third example, in which the inhibition of flowering caused by P35S-rolA, a gene from the root-inducing, left-hand, transferred DNA driven by a strong viral promoter, was attenuated by grafting the transformed shoot onto non-transformed rootstock that had been induced to flower. Infertility in the resulting flowers was corrected by a mixture of putrescine and tyramine, indicating that P35S-rolA inhibited flowering through interference with polyamine conjugation and that tyramine was essential to fertility. A fourth example of attenuation of the transformed phenotype occurred in lateral branches of plants expressing rolA under the control of its native promoter. In these branches, reduction in the accumulation of rolA transcripts was correlated with the methylation of a site 3[prime] to the rolA coding sequence; thus, the transformed plant seems capable of recognizing and repressing a gene that interferes with flowering.

Production and identification of somatic hybrids between Solanum tuberosum and S. papita by using the rolC gene as a morphological selectable marker

A successful hybridization of a diploid clone of Solanum tuberosum with a rolC-transgenic, diploid S. papita clone is reported. By using leaf expiants of this S. papita clone, which after transformation expressed kanamycin resistance, intact protoplasts were obtained, but these protoplasts did not develop to microcalli or regenerate to mature plants. However, protoplasts of the S. tuberosum clone showed a high capacity to regenerate plants from isolated protoplasts. On a medium containing Kanamycin only calli regenerated to plants, which revealed a rolC phenotype (reduced apical dominance with a large number of adventitious shoots and a pale green color of leaves) and later on turned out to be true hybrids. Self fusions of S. papita never developed to microcalli and those of S. tuberosum ceased to develop on the kanamycin-containing medium. Identification of somatic hybrids was done by RFLP and RAPD analysis. In the greenhouse, out of four selected hybrids only FK3.1 was successfully crossed with two standard S. tuberosum varieties (Datura, Desirée). Out of all the seeds germinated, only rolC-negative F(1) seedlings were further characterized. Within the seedling population obvious differences were evident in respect of the S. papita and S. tuberosum characteristics.

Expression of Agrobacterium rhizogenes auxin biosynthesis genes in transgenic tobacco plants

Plant oncogenes aux1 and aux2 carried by the TR-DNA of Agrobacterium rhizogenes strain A4 encode two enzymes involved in the auxin biosynthesis pathway in transformed plant cells. The short divergent promoter region between the two aux-coding sequences contains the main regulatory elements. This region was fused to the uidA reporter gene and introduced into Nicotiana tabacum in order to investigate the regulation and the tissue specificity of these genes. Neither wound nor hormone induction could be detected on transgenic leaf discs. However, phytohormone concentration and auxin/cytokinin balance controlled the expression of the chimaeric genes in transgenic protoplasts. The expression was localised in apical meristems, root tip meristems, lateral root primordia, in cells derived from transgenic protoplasts and in transgenic calli. Histological analysis showed that the expression was located in cells reactivated by in vitro culture. Experiments using cell-cycle inhibitors such as hydroxyurea or aphidicolin on transgenic protoplast cultures highly decreased the beta-glucuronidase activity of the chimaeric genes. These results as well as the histological approach suggest a correlation between expression of the aux1 and aux2 genes and cell division.

Bacterial plant oncogenes: the rol genes' saga

The rol genes are part of the T-DNA which is transferred by Agrobacterium rhizogenes in plant cells, causing neoplastic growth and differentiation. Each of these bacterial oncogenes deeply influences plant development and is finely regulated once transferred into the plant host. Both from the study of the effects and biochemical function of the rol genes and from the analysis of their regulation, important insight in plant development can be derived. Some of the most intriguing aspects of past, current and future research on this gene system are highlighted and discussed.

Genetic approaches to auxin action

Answers to long-standing questions concerning the molecular mechanism of auxin action and auxin's exact functions in plant growth and development are beginning to be uncovered through studies using mutant and transgenic plants. We review recent work in this area in vascular plants. A number of conclusions can be drawn from these studies. First, auxin appears essential for cell division and viability, as auxin auxotrophs isolated in tissue culture are dependent on auxin for growth and cannot be regenerated into plants even when auxin is supplied exogenously. Secondly, plants with transgenes that alter auxin levels are able to regulate cellular auxin concentrations by synthesis and conjugation; wild-type plants are probably also capable of such regulation. Thirdly, the phenotypes of transgenic plants with altered auxin levels and of mutant plants with altered sensitivity to auxin confirm earlier physiological studies which indicated a role for auxin in regulation of apical dominance, in development of roots and vascular tissue, and in the gravitropic response. Finally, the cloning of a mutationally identified gene important for auxin action, along with accumulating biochemical evidence, hints at a major role for protein degradation in the auxin response pathway.

Phenotype and hormonal status of transgenic tobacco plants overexpressing the rolA gene of Agrobacterium rhizogenes T-DNA

The rolA gene of the TL-DNA of Agrobacterium rhizogenes Ri-plasmid plays a major role in establishing the hairy root syndrome in transgenic plants. Transgenic tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum L.) expressing constitutively the rolA gene under the transcriptional control of the 35S RNA promoter show pronounced phenotypical alterations. P35S-rolA transgenic tobacco plants are characterized by stunted growth, dark green wrinkled leaves with an altered length-to-width ratio, condensed influorescences, retarded onset of flowering, a reduced number of flowers and shortened styles. To investigate whether the pleiotropic alterations of growth and development are linked to an altered hormonal status we have compared the immunoreactive content of indole-3-acetic acid, cytokinins, abscisic acid, gibberellin and the ethylene precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) of seedlings and different tissues of P35S-rolA transgenic plants, transgenic plants expressing the rolA gene under control of its own phloem-specific promoter and wild-type plants. Multiple tissue-specific alterations of phytohormone concentrations are the consequence of rolA gene activity. Changes of phytohormonal content can explain part of the rolA-induced phenotypic alterations. Most strikingly, in young and fully developed leaves of rolA and P35S-rolA transgenic clones a 40-60% reduction of immunoreactive gibberellin A1 was found, as compared to wild-type leaves. Treatment of wild-type tobacco plants with inhibitors of gibberellin biosynthesis phenotypic alterations similar to those of rolA transgenic plants. This suggests that the reduction of gibberellic acid content is indirectly but causally involved in rolA-induced alterations of stem elongation and planar leaf blade growth.