Cavitation Therapy Monitoring of Commercial Microbubbles With a Clinical Scanner

Size-Controlled Self-Assembly for Bimodal In Vivo Imaging

Contrast agents (CAs) are essential in biomedical imaging to aid in the diagnosis and therapy monitoring of disease. However, they are typically restricted to one imaging modality and have fixed properties such as size, shape, toxicity profile, or photophysical characteristics, which hampers a comprehensive view of biological processes. Herein, rationally designed dye assemblies are introduced as a unique CA platform for simultaneous multimodal and multiscale biomedical imaging. To this end, a series of amphiphilic aza-BODIPY dyes are synthesized with varying hydrophobic domains (C1, C8, C12, and C16) that self-assemble in aqueous media into nanostructures of tunable size (50 nm-1 µm) and photophysical properties. While C1 exhibits oblique-type exciton coupling and negligible emission, C8-C16 bearing longer alkyl chains undergo J-type aggregation with NIR absorption and emission and excellent photoacoustic properties. Given these advantageous features, aza-BODIPY specific, semi-quantitative fluorescence reflectance and photoacoustic imaging both in vitro and in vivo are established. Additionally, in vitro cell viability as well as murine in vivo biodistribution analysis with ex vivo validation showed excellent biocompatibility and a size-dependent biodistribution of nanostructures to different organ beds. These results broaden the scope of aqueous self-assembly to multimodal imaging and highlight its great potential for rationalizing numerous biomedical questions.

Overview of Therapeutic Ultrasound Applications and Safety Considerations: 2024 Update

A 2012 review of therapeutic ultrasound was published to educate researchers and physicians on potential applications and concerns for unintended bioeffects (doi: 10.7863/jum.2012.31.4.623). This review serves as an update to the parent article, highlighting advances in therapeutic ultrasound over the past 12 years. In addition to general mechanisms for bioeffects produced by therapeutic ultrasound, current applications, and the pre-clinical and clinical stages are outlined. An overview is provided for image guidance methods to monitor and assess treatment progress. Finally, other topics relevant for the translation of therapeutic ultrasound are discussed, including computational modeling, tissue-mimicking phantoms, and quality assurance protocols.

Delivery of Cavitation Therapy With a Modified Clinical Scanner: In Vitro Evaluation

In this study, we design and implement pulses [1.67 MHz, 20-1000 cycles, 0.8-2.5 MPa, and 5-100 ms pulse repetition time (PRT)] suitable for microbubble cavitation treatments with a phased array of a clinical ultrasound scanner. A range of acoustic parameters was evaluated in a tissue-mimicking phantom with suspended Sonazoid microbubbles. Hydrophone measurements were used to optimize the transmit beamforming. A passive cavitation detection (PCD) system was designed to measure the microbubble scattered signals over a 1 s exposure. Postprocessing of the scattered signals evaluated frequency content to extract broadband energy and calculate the inertial cavitation dose (ICD). ICD was maximized at 1000 cycles (maximum pulse length), 5 ms (fastest firing rate), and 2.5 MPa peak negative pressure (PNP) (maximum pressure). Inertial cavitation was only sustained for about three pulses (out of hundreds fired) occurring within the first 100 ms of treatment. Temporal analysis of the first 1000-cycle pulse revealed that broadband energy is sustained for the entire pulse. We also demonstrate that while inertial cavitation is possible with clinically available pulse wave Doppler settings, ICD can be significantly increased using the new conditions suggested in this work. We have delivered successful image-guided cavitation treatment after modifying a clinical scanner and monitored the cavitation dose with a PCD system on a gel phantom with suspended microbubbles. We plan to apply this technique in vivo in animal tumor models next. This work demonstrates the first implementation of long, high-pressure pulses on a clinical scanner that users can optimize for cavitation treatments.

Effect of Microbubble Size, Composition, and Multiple Sonication Points on Sterile Inflammatory Response in Focused Ultrasound-Mediated Blood-Brain Barrier Opening

Blood-brain barrier opening (BBBO) using focused ultrasound (FUS) and microbubbles (MBs) has emerged as a promising technique for delivering therapeutics to the brain. However, the influence of various FUS and MB parameters on BBBO and subsequent sterile inflammatory response (SIR) remains unclear. In this study, we investigated the effects of MB size and composition, as well as the number of FUS sonication points, on BBBO and SIR in an immunocompetent mouse model. Using MRI-guided MB + FUS, we targeted the striatum and assessed extravasation of an MRI contrast agent to assess BBBO and RNaseq to assess SIR. Our results revealed distinct effects of these parameters on BBBO and SIR. Specifically, at a matched microbubble volume dose (MVD), MB size did not affect the extent of BBBO, but smaller (1 μm diameter) MBs exhibited a lower classification of SIR than larger (3 or 5 μm diameter) MBs. Lipid-shelled microbubbles exhibited greater BBBO and a more pronounced SIR compared to albumin-shelled microbubbles, likely owing to the latter's poor in vivo stability. As expected, increasing the number of sonication points resulted in greater BBBO and SIR. Furthermore, correlation analysis revealed strong associations between passive cavitation detection measurements of harmonic and inertial MB echoes, BBBO, and the expression of SIR gene sets. Our findings highlight the critical role of MB and FUS parameters in modulating BBBO and subsequent SIR in the brain. These insights inform the development of targeted drug delivery strategies and the mitigation of adverse inflammatory reactions in neurological disorders.

Principle of contrast-enhanced ultrasonography

Sonazoid, an ultrasound contrast agent, has been covered by insurance in Japan since January 2007 for the diagnosis of hepatic mass lesions and is widely used for diagnosing not only primary liver cancer but also liver metastases such as those from breast cancer and colorectal cancer. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound for breast mass lesions has been covered by insurance since August 2012 after phase II and phase III clinical trials showed that the diagnostic performance was significantly superior to that of B-mode and contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. This paper describes the principles of imaging techniques in contrast-enhanced ultrasonography including the filter, pulse inversion, amplitude modulation, and amplitude-modulated pulse inversion methods. The pulse inversion method, which visualizes the second-harmonic component using the nonlinear scattering characteristics of the contrast agent, is widely used regardless of the contrast agent and target organ because of its high resolution. Sonazoid has a stiffer shell and requires a higher acoustic amplitude than Sonovue to generate nonlinear vibrations. The higher transmitted sound pressure generates more tissue harmonic components. Since pulse inversion allows visualization of the tissue harmonic components, amplitude modulation and amplitude-modulated pulse inversion, which include few tissue harmonic components, are primarily used. Amplitude modulation methods detect nonlinear signals from the contrast agent in the fundamental band. The mechanism of the amplitude modulation is considered to be changes in the echo signal's phase depending on the sound pressure. Since the tissue-derived component is minor in amplitude modulation methods, good contrast sensitivity can be obtained.

A new model for bubble cluster dynamics in a viscoelastic media

Bubble cluster dynamics in viscoelastic media is instructive for ultrasound diagnosis and therapy. In this paper, we propose a statistical model for bubble cluster dynamics in viscoelastic media considering the radius distribution of bubble nuclei. By investigating and comparing the response for a bubble in three conditions: single bubble; multi-bubble with the same radius; multi-bubble with different radius, the following rules are found: The promotion or suppression of the bubble cluster on the bubble vibration is not monotonous with the increase of the number of bubbles. The promotion or suppression of the bubble cluster on the bubble vibration varies alternately with the frequency. The effect of bubble cluster on bubble vibration is mostly suppressed when the driving acoustic pressure amplitude pa is high (5000 kPa). Usually, the bubble cluster promotes the vibration of the large bubbles (R0 = 10 μm) more, or suppresses it less.

Effect of Microbubble Size, Composition and Multiple Sonication Points on Sterile Inflammatory Response in Focused Ultrasound-Mediated Blood-Brain Barrier Opening

Blood-brain barrier opening (BBBO) using focused ultrasound (FUS) and microbubbles (MBs) has emerged as a promising technique for delivering therapeutics to the brain. However, the influence of various FUS and MB parameters on BBBO and subsequent sterile inflammatory response (SIR) remains unclear. In this study, we investigated the effects of MB size and composition, as well as the number of FUS sonication points, on BBBO and SIR in an immunocompetent mouse model. Using MRI-guided MB+FUS, we targeted the striatum and assessed extravasation of an MRI contrast agent to assess BBBO and RNAseq to assess SIR. Our results revealed distinct effects of these parameters on BBBO and SIR. Specifically, at a matched microbubble volume dose (MVD), MB size did not affect the extent of BBBO, but smaller (1 μm diameter) MBs exhibited a lower classification of SIR than larger (3 or 5 μm diameter) MBs. Lipid-shelled microbubbles exhibited greater BBBO and a more pronounced SIR compared to albumin-shelled microbubbles, likely owing to the latter's poor in vivo stability. As expected, increasing the number of sonication points resulted in greater BBBO and SIR. Furthermore, correlation analysis revealed strong associations between passive cavitation detection measurements of harmonic and inertial MB echoes, BBBO and the expression of SIR gene sets. Our findings highlight the critical role of MB and FUS parameters in modulating BBBO and subsequent SIR in the brain. These insights inform the development of targeted drug delivery strategies and the mitigation of adverse inflammatory reactions in neurological disorders.

Quantification of Hepatocellular Carcinoma Vascular Dynamics With Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound for LI-RADS Implementation

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to describe a comprehensive contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) imaging protocol and analysis method to implement CEUS LI-RADS (Liver Imaging Reporting and Data System) in a quantifiable manner. The methods that are validated with a prospective single-center study aim to simplify CEUS LI-RADS evaluation, remove observer bias, and potentially improve the sensitivity of CEUS LI-RADS.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This prospective single-center study enrolled patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (April 2021-June 2022; N = 31; mean age ± SD, 67 ± 6 years; 24 men/7 women). For each patient, at least 2 CEUS loops spanning over 5 minutes were collected for different lesion scan planes using an articulated arm to hold the transducer. Automatic respiratory gating and motion compensation algorithms removed errors due to breathing motion. The long axis of the lesion was measured in the contrast and fundamental images to capture nodule size. Parametric processing of time-intensity curve analysis on linearized data provided quantifiable information of the wash-in and washout dynamics via rise time ( RT ) and degree of washout ( DW ) parameters extracted from the time-intensity curve, respectively. A Welch t test was performed between lesion and parenchyma RT for each lesion to confirm statistically significant differences. P values for bootstrapped 95% confidence intervals of the relative degree of washout ( rDW ), ratio of DW between the lesion and surrounding parenchyma, were computed to quantify lesion washout. Coefficient of variation (COV) of RT , DW , and rDW was calculated for each patient between injections for both the lesion and surrounding parenchyma to gauge reproducibility of these metrics. Spearman rank correlation tests were performed among size, RT , DW , and rDW values to evaluate statistical dependence between the variables.

RESULTS

The mean ± SD lesion diameter was 23 ± 8 mm. The RT for all lesions, capturing arterial phase hyperenhancement, was shorter than that of surrounding liver parenchyma ( P < 0.05). All lesions also demonstrated significant ( P < 0.05) but variable levels of washout at both 2-minute and 5-minute time points, quantified in rDW . The COV of RT for the lesion and surrounding parenchyma were both 11%, and the COV of DW and rDW at 2 and 5 minutes ranged from 22% to 31%. Statistically significant relationships between lesion and parenchyma RT and between lesion RT and lesion DW at the 2- and 5-minute time points were found ( P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The imaging protocol and analysis method presented provide robust, quantitative metrics that describe the dynamic vascular patterns of LI-RADS 5 lesions classified as hepatocellular carcinomas. The RT of the bolus transit quantifies the arterial phase hyperenhancement, and the DW and rDW parameters quantify the washout from linearized CEUS intensity data. This unique methodology is able to implement the CEUS-LIRADS scheme in a quantifiable manner for the first time and remove its existing issues of currently being qualitative and suffering from subjective evaluations.

Detection of Individual Microbubbles by Burst-Wave-Aided Contrast-Enhanced Active Doppler Ultrasonography

We propose burst-wave-aided, contrast-enhanced, active Doppler ultrasonography for visualizing lymph vessels. This technique forces ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) to move using the acoustic radiation force induced by burst waves with low amplitude while suppressing their destruction. Using a flow phantom, we measured the average, decrease rate of echo intensity [i.e., pulse intensity integral (PII)], and the velocity of individual contrast agents, which directly affects the performance of imaging and tracking contrast agents under stationary flow conditions. Comparison with pulse-inversion Doppler without exposure to the burst wave demonstrated that the velocity of the contrast agents could be enhanced up to several tens of millimeters per second by the effect of the burst wave, maximizing the echo intensity extracted by a clutter filter. The contrast ratio (CR), defined as the ratio of the contrast echo to the phantom echo outside the channel, did not change appreciably, even when the lower cut-off velocity of the clutter filter was increased up to 10 mm/s. This implies a better robustness against the motion of the tissue. In addition, the performance for detecting contrast agents (i.e., echo intensity) was superior or similar to that of pulse-inversion Doppler, even in undesirable conditions where the flow had a velocity component in the opposite direction to that of the acoustic radiation force. The echo intensity was lower or the same as that in pulse-inversion Doppler, demonstrating the potential for suppressing the destruction of contrast agents and enabling long-term observations. From these results, we expect that the proposed method will be beneficial for visualizing lymph vessels.

Controlled Hyperthermia With High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound and Ultrasound Contrast Agent Microbubbles in Porcine Liver

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this work was to study microbubble-enhanced temperature elevation with high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) at different acoustic pressures and under image guidance. The microbubbles were administered with either local or vascular injections (that mimic systemic injections) in perfused and non-perfused ex vivo porcine liver under ultrasound image guidance.

METHODS

Porcine liver was insonified for 30 s with a single-element HIFU transducer (0.9 MHz, 0.413 ms, 82% duty cycle, focal pressures of 0.6-3.5 MPa). Contrast microbubbles were injected either locally or through the vasculature. A needle thermocouple at the focus measured temperature elevation. Diagnostic ultrasound (Philips iU22, C5-1 probe) guided placement of the thermocouple and delivery of microbubbles and monitored the procedure in real time.

RESULTS

At lower acoustic pressures (0.6 and 1.2 MPa) in non-perfused liver, inertial cavitation of the injected microbubbles led to greater temperatures at the focus compared with HIFU-only treatments. At higher pressures (2.4 and 3.5 MPa) native inertial cavitation in the tissue (without injecting microbubbles) resulted in temperature elevations similar to those after injecting microbubbles. The heated area was larger when using microbubbles at all pressures. In the presence of perfusion, only local injections provided a sufficiently high concentration of microbubbles necessary for significant temperature enhancement.

CONCLUSION

Local injections of microbubbles provide a higher concentration of microbubbles in a smaller area, avoiding acoustic shadowing, and can lead to higher temperature elevation at lower pressures and increase the size of the heated area at all pressures.

Release of liposomally formulated near-infrared fluorescent probes included in giant cluster vesicles by ultrasound irradiation

Detection of tumors and regional lymph nodes during surgery has been proposed in the diagnosis of lymphatic metastasis and the surgical treatment of malignant diseases. Giant cluster vesicles (GCVs), including liposomally formulated indocyanine green (LP-ICG) derivatives, are a possible candidate for agents to realize the two contradictory properties, i.e., retention in tissue for lesion-marking and trace for sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs) identification. We attempted to release the LP-ICG derivatives from GCVs using ultrasound contrast agents (UCAs) under ultrasound irradiation. An absorption spectrophotometer quantitatively evaluated the amounts of released LP-ICG derivatives. As a result, we demonstrated that it depended on conditions for sound pressure, burst length, and number density of UCAs, and had a sound pressure threshold independent of burst length and number density of UCAs. The results will aid to determine appropriate conditions to maximize the released amount of LP-ICG derivatives while keeping safety.

Ultrasound and Microbubbles Mediated Bleomycin Delivery in Feline Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma—An In Vivo Veterinary Study

To investigate the feasibility and tolerability of ultrasound and microbubbles (USMB)-enhanced chemotherapy delivery for head and neck cancer, we performed a veterinary trial in feline companion animals with oral squamous cell carcinomas. Six cats were treated with a combination of bleomycin and USMB therapy three times, using the Pulse Wave Doppler mode on a clinical ultrasound system and EMA/FDA approved microbubbles. They were evaluated for adverse events, quality of life, tumour response and survival. Furthermore, tumour perfusion was monitored before and after USMB therapy using contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS). USMB treatments were feasible and well tolerated. Among 5 cats treated with optimized US settings, 3 had stable disease at first, but showed disease progression 5 or 11 weeks after first treatment. One cat had progressive disease one week after the first treatment session, maintaining a stable disease thereafter. Eventually, all cats except one showed progressive disease, but each survived longer than the median overall survival time of 44 days reported in literature. CEUS performed immediately before and after USMB therapy suggested an increase in tumour perfusion based on an increase in median area under the curve (AUC) in 6 out of 12 evaluated treatment sessions. In this small hypothesis-generating study, USMB plus chemotherapy was feasible and well-tolerated in a feline companion animal model and showed potential for enhancing tumour perfusion in order to increase drug delivery. This could be a forward step toward clinical translation of USMB therapy to human patients with a clinical need for locally enhanced treatment.

Effect of temperature on the acoustic response and stability of size-isolated protein-shelled ultrasound contrast agents and SonoVue

Limited work has been reported on the acoustic and physical characterization of protein-shelled UCAs. This study characterized bovine serum albumin (BSA)-shelled microbubbles filled with perfluorobutane gas, along with SonoVue, a clinically approved contrast agent. Broadband attenuation spectroscopy was performed at room (23 ± 0.5 °C) and physiological (37 ± 0.5 °C) temperatures over the period of 20 min for these agents. Three size distributions of BSA-shelled microbubbles, with mean sizes of 1.86 μm (BSA1), 3.54 μm (BSA2), and 4.24 μm (BSA3) used. Viscous and elastic coefficients for the microbubble shell were assessed by fitting de Jong model to the measured attenuation spectra. Stable cavitation thresholds (SCT) and inertial cavitation thresholds (ICT) were assessed at room and physiological temperatures. At 37 °C, a shift in resonance frequency was observed, and the attenuation coefficient was increased relative to the measurement at room temperature. At physiological temperature, SCT and ICT were lower than the room temperature measurement. The ICT was observed to be higher than SCT at both temperatures. These results enhance our understanding of temperature-dependent properties of protein-shelled UCAs. These findings study may guide the rational design of protein-shelled microbubbles and help choose suitable acoustic parameters for applications in imaging and therapy.

Investigation of the Phase of Nonlinear Echoes From Microbubbles During Amplitude Modulation

Contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) imaging relies on distinguishing between microbubble and tissue echoes. Amplitude modulation (AM), a nonlinear pulsing scheme, has been developed to take advantage of the amplitude-dependent nonlinearity of microbubble echoes. However, with AM, tissue nonlinear propagation can also degrade the image contrast. Segmentation of CEUS images based on amplitude-dependent phase difference in the echoes, defined in this article as [Formula: see text], has been proposed as an additional method of enhancing contrast-to-tissue ratio as tissue is not expected to create the same degree of [Formula: see text]; however, this has not been robustly investigated. In this work, we evaluate the source of [Formula: see text] through simulations of unshelled versus shelled microbubble oscillation and simulations of nonlinear propagation in tissue. We then validate the simulated [Formula: see text] results with experimental [Formula: see text] measurements during in vitro scattering and imaging in a flow phantom. We show that shelled and unshelled microbubbles resulted in a [Formula: see text] with similar overall magnitude with some differences in trends, and that tissue echoes have a small yet detectable degree of [Formula: see text] due to nonlinear propagation. The results from this work can help inform optimal parameter selection for phase segmentation and implementation on a clinical scanner.

The Effect of Microbubble-Assisted Ultrasound on Molecular Permeability across Cell Barriers

The combination of ultrasound and microbubbles (USMB) has been applied to enhance drug permeability across tissue barriers. Most studies focused on only one physicochemical aspect (i.e., molecular weight of the delivered molecule). Using an in vitro epithelial (MDCK II) cell barrier, we examined the effects of USMB on the permeability of five molecules varying in molecular weight (182 Da to 20 kDa) and hydrophilicity (LogD at pH 7.4 from 1.5 to highly hydrophilic). Treatment of cells with USMB at increasing ultrasound pressures did not have a significant effect on the permeability of small molecules (molecular weight 259 to 376 Da), despite their differences in hydrophilicity (LogD at pH 7.4 from -3.2 to 1.5). The largest molecules (molecular weight 4 and 20 kDa) showed the highest increase in the epithelial permeability (3-7-fold). Simultaneously, USMB enhanced intracellular accumulation of the same molecules. In the case of the clinically relevant anti- C-X-C Chemokine Receptor Type 4 (CXCR4) nanobody (molecular weight 15 kDa), USMB enhanced paracellular permeability by two-fold and increased binding to retinoblastoma cells by five-fold. Consequently, USMB is a potential tool to improve the efficacy and safety of the delivery of drugs to organs protected by tissue barriers, such as the eye and the brain.

Ultrasound-Mediated Drug Delivery With a Clinical Ultrasound System: In Vitro Evaluation

Chemotherapy efficacy is often reduced by insufficient drug uptake in tumor cells. The combination of ultrasound and microbubbles (USMB) has been shown to improve drug delivery and to enhance the efficacy of several drugs in vitro and in vivo, through effects collectively known as sonopermeation. However, clinical translation of USMB therapy is hampered by the large variety of (non-clinical) US set-ups and US parameters that are used in these studies, which are not easily translated to clinical practice. In order to facilitate clinical translation, the aim of this study was to prove that USMB therapy using a clinical ultrasound system (Philips iU22) in combination with clinically approved microbubbles (SonoVue) leads to efficient in vitro sonopermeation. To this end, we measured the efficacy of USMB therapy for different US probes (S5-1, C5-1 and C9-4) and US parameters in FaDu cells. The US probe with the lowest central frequency (i.e. 1.6 MHz for S5-1) showed the highest USMB-induced intracellular uptake of the fluorescent dye SYTOX™ Green (SG). These SG uptake levels were comparable to or even higher than those obtained with a custom-built US system with optimized US parameters. Moreover, USMB therapy with both the clinical and the custom-built US system increased the cytotoxicity of the hydrophilic drug bleomycin. Our results demonstrate that a clinical US system can be used to perform USMB therapy as efficiently as a single-element transducer set-up with optimized US parameters. Therefore, future trials could be based on these clinical US systems, including validated US parameters, in order to accelerate successful translation of USMB therapy.

The Role of Ultrasound in Modulating Interstitial Fluid Pressure in Solid Tumors for Improved Drug Delivery

The unique microenvironment of solid tumors, including desmoplasia within the extracellular matrix, enhanced vascular permeability, and poor lymphatic drainage, leads to an elevated interstitial fluid pressure which is a major barrier to drug delivery. Reducing tumor interstitial fluid pressure is one proposed method of increasing drug delivery to the tumor. The goal of this topical review is to describe recent work using focused ultrasound with or without microbubbles to modulate tumor interstitial fluid pressure, through either thermal or mechanical effects on the extracellular matrix and the vasculature. Furthermore, we provide a review on techniques in which ultrasound imaging may be used to diagnose elevated interstitial fluid pressure within solid tumors. Ultrasound-based techniques show high promise in diagnosing and treating elevated interstitial pressure to enhance drug delivery.

Microbubble-Enhanced Heating: Exploring the Effect of Microbubble Concentration and Pressure Amplitude on High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Treatments

High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is a non-invasive tool that can be used for targeted thermal ablation treatments. Currently, HIFU is clinically approved for treatment of uterine fibroids, various cancers, and certain brain applications. However, for brain applications such as essential tremors, HIFU can only be used to treat limited areas confined to the center of the brain because of geometrical limitations (shape of the transducer and skull). A major obstacle to advancing this technology is the inability to treat non-central brain locations without causing damage to the skin and/or skull. Previous research has indicated that cavitation-induced bubbles or microbubble contrast agents can be used to enhance HIFU treatments by increasing ablation regions and shortening acoustic exposures at lower acoustic pressures. However, little research has been done to explore the interplay between microbubble concentration and pressure amplitude on HIFU treatments. We developed an in vitro experimental setup to study lesion formation at three different acoustic pressures and three microbubble concentrations. Real-time ultrasound imaging was integrated to monitor initial microbubble concentration and subsequent behavior during the HIFU treatments. Depending on the pressure used for the HIFU treatment, there was an optimal concentration of microbubbles that led to enhanced heating in the focal area. If the concentration of microbubbles was too high, the treatment was detrimentally affected because of non-linear attenuation by the pre-focal microbubbles. Additionally, the real-time ultrasound imaging provided a reliable method to monitor microbubble activity during the HIFU treatments, which is important for translation to in vivo HIFU applications with microbubbles.