Short stature homeobox-containing gene duplications in 3.7% of girls with tall stature and normal karyotypes

A case of Aicardi syndrome associated with duplication event of Xp22 including SHOX

BACKGROUND

Aicardi syndrome is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by a triad of partial or complete agenesis of the corpus callosum, infantile spasms, and pathognomonic chorioretinal lacunae.

METHODS

Examination, multimodal imaging, and genetic testing were used to guide diagnosis.

RESULTS

We report a case of a pediatric patient who was initially diagnosed with refractory infantile spasms. The patient was unresponsive to conventional antiepileptic therapy, and genetic testing with whole exome and mitochondrial genome sequencing could not identify the underlying cause, so vigabatrin was initiated. The ophthalmic examination under anesthesia for vigabatrin toxicity screening revealed chorioretinal atrophy in the retinal periphery of both eyes, with two 3-disc diameter chorioretinal lacunae superotemporal and inferonasal to the optic nerve in the left eye. Given the neuroimaging findings of corpus callosum hypoplasia with polymicrogyria and ocular findings, the patient was diagnosed with Aicardi syndrome. Genetic testing revealed a novel duplication event at the Xp22 locus.

CONCLUSIONS

Aicardi syndrome, albeit a rare condition, should always be considered in the differential diagnosis when investigating a female child with refractory seizures in early childhood. Genetic testing may help further our understanding of AIS and the search for a genetic etiology.

SHOX Whole Gene Duplications Are Overrepresented in SHOX Haploinsufficiency Phenotype Cohorts

Transcription of SHOX is dependent upon the interaction of the gene with a complex array of flanking regulatory elements. Duplications that contain flanking regulatory elements but not the SHOX gene have been reported in individuals with SHOX haploinsufficiency syndromes, suggesting that alterations to the physical organisation or genomic architecture may affect SHOX transcription. Individuals with tall stature and an additional X or Y chromosome have an extra copy of both the SHOX gene and the entire SHOX regulatory region, so all three copies of SHOX can be expressed fully. However, for a duplication of the SHOX gene that does not include all of the flanking regulatory elements, the potential effect on SHOX expression is difficult to predict. We present nine unpublished individuals with a SHOX whole gene duplication in whom the duplication contains variable amounts of the SHOX regulatory region, and we review 29 similar cases from the literature where phenotypic data were clearly stated. While tall stature was present in a proportion of these cases, we present evidence that SHOX whole gene duplications can also result in a phenotype more typically associated with SHOX haploinsufficiency and are significantly overrepresented in Leri-Weill dyschondrosteosis and idiopathic short stature probands compared to population controls. Although similar-looking duplications do not always produce a consistent phenotype, there may be potential genotype-phenotype correlations regarding the duplication size, regulatory element content, and the breakpoint proximity to the SHOX gene. Although ClinGen does not currently consider SHOX whole gene duplications to be clinically significant, the ClinGen triplosensitivity score does not take into account the context of the duplication, and more is now known about SHOX duplications and the role of flanking elements in SHOX regulation. The evidence presented here suggests that these duplications should not be discounted without considering the extent of the duplication and the patient phenotype, and should be included in diagnostic laboratory reports as variants of uncertain significance. Given the uncertain pathogenicity of these duplications, any reports should encourage the exclusion of all other causes of short stature where possible.

The aetiology of extreme tall stature in a screened Finnish paediatric population

BACKGROUND

Extremely tall children (defined as height SDS (HSDS) ≥+3) are frequently referred to specialized healthcare for diagnostic work-up. However, no systematic studies focusing on such children currently exist. We investigated the aetiology, clinical features, and auxological clues indicative of syndromic tall stature in extremely tall children subject to population-wide growth monitoring and screening rules.

METHODS

Subjects with HSDS ≥+3 after three years of age born between 1990 and 2010 were identified from the Helsinki University Hospital district growth database. We comprehensively reviewed their medical records up to December 2020 and recorded underlying diagnoses, auxological data, and clinical features.

FINDINGS

We identified 424 subjects (214 girls and 210 boys) who fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Underlying growth disorder was diagnosed in 61 (14%) patients, in 36 (17%) girls and 25 (12%) boys, respectively (P=0•15). Secondary causes were diagnosed in 42 (10%) patients and the two most frequent secondary diagnoses, premature adrenarche, and central precocious puberty were more frequent in girls. Primary disorder, mainly Marfan or Sotos syndrome, was diagnosed in 19 (4%) patients. Molecular genetic studies were used as a part of diagnostic work-up in 120 subjects. However, array CGH or next-generation sequencing studies were seldom used. Idiopathic tall stature (ITS) was diagnosed in 363 (86%) subjects, and it was considered familial in two-thirds. Dysmorphic features or a neurodevelopmental disorder were recorded in 104 (29%) children with ITS. The probability of a monogenic primary growth disorder increased with the degree of tall stature and deviation from target height.

INTERPRETATION

A considerable proportion of extremely tall children have an underlying primary or secondary growth disorder, and their risk is associated with auxological parameters. Clinical features related to syndromic tall stature were surprisingly frequent in subjects with ITS, supporting the view that syndromic growth disorders with mild phenotypes may be underdiagnosed in extremely tall children. Our results lend support to comprehensive diagnostic work-up of extremely tall children.

FUNDING

Päivikki and Sakari Sohlberg Foundation, Foundation for Pediatric Research, and Helsinki University Hospital research grants.

Domestication Explains Two-Thirds of Differential-Gene-Expression Variance between Domestic and Wild Animals; The Remaining One-Third Reflects Intraspecific and Interspecific Variation

Belyaev's concept of destabilizing selection during domestication was a major achievement in the XX century. Its practical value has been realized in commercial colors of the domesticated fox that never occur in the wild and has been confirmed in a wide variety of pet breeds. Many human disease models involving animals allow to test drugs before human testing. Perhaps this is why investigators doing transcriptomic profiling of domestic versus wild animals have searched for breed-specific patterns. Here we sequenced hypothalamic transcriptomes of tame and aggressive rats, identified their differentially expressed genes (DEGs), and, for the first time, applied principal component analysis to compare them with all the known DEGs of domestic versus wild animals that we could find. Two principal components, PC1 and PC2, respectively explained 67% and 33% of differential-gene-expression variance (hereinafter: log2 value) between domestic and wild animals. PC1 corresponded to multiple orthologous DEGs supported by homologs; these DEGs kept the log2 value sign from species to species and from tissue to tissue (i.e., a common domestication pattern). PC2 represented stand-alone homologous DEG pairs reversing the log2 value sign from one species to another and from tissue to tissue (i.e., representing intraspecific and interspecific variation).

Evidence That Non-Syndromic Familial Tall Stature Has an Oligogenic Origin Including Ciliary Genes

Human growth is a complex trait. A considerable number of gene defects have been shown to cause short stature, but there are only few examples of genetic causes of non-syndromic tall stature. Besides rare variants with large effects and common risk alleles with small effect size, oligogenic effects may contribute to this phenotype. Exome sequencing was carried out in a tall male (height 3.5 SDS) and his parents. Filtered damaging variants with high CADD scores were validated by Sanger sequencing in the trio and three other affected and one unaffected family members. Network analysis was carried out to assess links between the candidate genes, and the transcriptome of murine growth plate was analyzed by microarray as well as RNA Seq. Heterozygous gene variants in CEP104, CROCC, NEK1, TOM1L2, and TSTD2 predicted as damaging were found to be shared between the four tall family members. Three of the five genes (CEP104, CROCC, and NEK1) belong to the ciliary gene family. All genes are expressed in mouse growth plate. Pathway and network analyses indicated close functional connections. Together, these data expand the spectrum of genes with a role in linear growth and tall stature phenotypes.

Short stature and SHOX (Short stature homeobox) variants-efficacy of screening using various strategies

Background

SHOX mutations have previously been described as causes of Léri-Weill dyschondrosteosis (LWD), Langer mesomelic dysplasia (LMD), and idiopathic short stature. The loss of X chromosome—Turner syndrome or mosaic 45,X/46,XX or 46,XY—also leads to the heterozygous loss of SHOX in patients with short stature only or with features similar to LWD. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of the targeted screening for SHOX variants, which involved different methods in the laboratory analysis of short stature. We determined the significance and positive predictive value of short stature for the detection of SHOX variants.

Methods

Targeted screening for variants in SHOX involving MLPA, sequencing, karyotyping and FISH was performed in the short stature cohort (N = 174) and control cohort (N = 91). The significance of short stature and particular characteristics for the detection of SHOX variants was determined by Fisher’s exact test, and the probability of SHOX mutation occurrence was calculated using a forward/stepwise logistic regression model.

Results

In total, 27 and 15 variants influencing SHOX were detected in the short stature and control cohorts, respectively (p > 0.01). Sex chromosome aberrations and pathogenic CNV resulting in diagnosis were detected in eight (4.6%) and five (2.9%) patients of the short stature group and three (3.3%) and one (1.1%) individuals of the control group. VUS variants were discovered in 14 (8.0%) and 11 (12.1%) individuals of the short stature and control groups, respectively. MLPA demonstrated the detection rate of 13.22%, and it can be used as a frontline method for detection of aberrations involving SHOX. However, only mosaicism of monosomy X with a higher frequency of monosomic cells could be reliably discovered by this method. Karyotyping and FISH can compensate for this limitation; their detection rates in short stature group were 3.55% and 13.46% (N = 52), respectively. FISH proved to be more effective than karyotyping in the study as it could reveal cryptic mosaics in some cases where karyotyping initially failed to detect such a clone. We suggest adding FISH on different tissue than peripheral blood to verify sex-chromosome constitution, especially in cases with karyotypes: 45,X; mosaic 45,X/46,XX or 46,XY; 46,Xidic(Y) detected from blood; in children, where mosaic 45,X was detected prenatally but was not confirmed from peripheral blood. The correlation of short stature with the occurrence of SHOX mutations was insignificant and short stature demonstrates a low positive predictive value-15.5% as unique indicator for SHOX mutations. The typical skeletal signs of LWD, including Madelung deformity and disproportionate growth, positively correlate with the findings of pathogenic SHOX variants (p < 0.01) by Fisher’s exact test but not with the findings of VUS variants in SHOX which are more prevalent in the individuals with idiopathic short stature or in the individuals with normal height.

Novel Clinical Criteria Allow Detection of Short Stature Homeobox-Containing Gene Haploinsufficiency Caused by Either Gene or Enhancer Region Defects

INTRODUCTION

Short stature homeobox-containing gene (SHOX) haploinsufficiency is associated with short stature, Madelung deformity and mesomelia. Current clinical screening tools are based on patients with intragenic variants or deletions. However, recent discoveries showed that deletions of the enhancer elements are quite common. The majority of these patients show less body disproportion and respond better to recombinant human growth hormone treatment. We redefined clinical criteria for genetic analysis to facilitate detection of the full spectrum of SHOX haploinsufficiency.

METHODS

We analyzed 51 children with SHOX variants or deletions and 25 children with a deletion in its enhancer region. Data were compared to 277 children referred for suspicion of growth failure without endocrine or genetic pathology.

RESULTS

Only half of the patients with an enhancer region deletion fulfilled any of the current screening criteria. We propose new clinical criteria based on sitting height to height ratio >1 SDS or arm span ≥3 cm below height, with a sensitivity of 99%. When these criteria are combined with obligatory short stature, the sensitivity to detect SHOX haploinsufficiency is 68.1%, the specificity 80.6%, and the number needed to screen 21 patients.

CONCLUSION

Novel clinical criteria for screening for SHOX haploinsufficiency allow the detection of patients within the full genetic spectrum, that is, intragenic variants and enhancer region deletions.

Rare and de novo duplications containing SHOX in clubfoot

Introduction

Congenital clubfoot is a common birth defect that affects at least 0.1% of all births. Nearly 25% cases are familial and the remaining are sporadic in inheritance. Copy number variants (CNVs) involving transcriptional regulators of limb development, including PITX1 and TBX4, have previously been shown to cause familial clubfoot, but much of the heritability remains unexplained.

Methods

Exome sequence data from 816 unrelated clubfoot cases and 2645 in-house controls were analysed using coverage data to identify rare CNVs. The precise size and location of duplications were then determined using high-density Affymetrix Cytoscan chromosomal microarray (CMA). Segregation in families and de novo status were determined using qantitative PCR.

Results

Chromosome Xp22.33 duplications involving SHOX were identified in 1.1% of cases (9/816) compared with 0.07% of in-house controls (2/2645) (p=7.98×10⁻⁵, OR=14.57) and 0.27% (38/13592) of Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities/the Wellcome Trust Case Control Consortium 2 controls (p=0.001, OR=3.97). CMA validation confirmed an overlapping 180.28 kb duplicated region that included SHOX exons as well as downstream non-coding regions. In four of six sporadic cases where DNA was available for unaffected parents, the duplication was de novo. The probability of four de novo mutations in SHOX by chance in a cohort of 450 sporadic clubfoot cases is 5.4×10^–10.

Conclusions

Microduplications of the pseudoautosomal chromosome Xp22.33 region (PAR1) containing SHOX and downstream enhancer elements occur in ~1% of patients with clubfoot. SHOX and regulatory regions have previously been implicated in skeletal dysplasia as well as idiopathic short stature, but have not yet been reported in clubfoot. SHOX duplications likely contribute to clubfoot pathogenesis by altering early limb development.

SHOX CNE9/10 Knockout in U2OS Osteosarcoma Cells and Its Effects on Cell Growth and Apoptosis

Background

Osteosarcoma is a common malignant tumor of musculoskeletal stromal cells. Osteosarcoma clinical behavior depends mostly on the histologic grade, the site of primary tumor, the response to chemotherapy, and the presence of pulmonary metastases. The aim of this study was to knockout SHOX CNE9/10 in U2OS osteosarcoma cells and to analyze the effects on cell growth and apoptosis.

Material/Methods

U2OS cells with CNE9 knockout and U2OS cells with CNE10 knockout were established via the CRISPR/Cas9 system. Sanger sequencing was used to detect the success of the knockdown experiment. Western blotting and quantitative polymerase chain reaction were used to detect the expression levels of short stature homeobox-containing gene (SHOX) protein and messenger RNA (mRNA) after knockdown of CNE9 and CNE10. The cell viability and apoptotic rate were detected by the Cell Counting Kit-8 method and by flow cytometry.

Results

The Sanger sequencing results showed that the knockdown experiment was successful. The levels of SHOX mRNA and protein were significantly reduced after knocking down CNE9 and CNE10. Knockdown of CNE9 and CNE10 significantly increased the growth and inhibited the apoptosis of U2OS osteosarcoma cells. CNE9/CNE10 knockdown U2OS cells were successfully constructed.

Conclusions

Knockdown of CNE9 and CNE10 promoted U2OS cell growth and inhibited apoptosis by decreasing SHOX expression. This CNE9/CNE10 knockout U2OS cell model could provide a bridge for the research on SHOX and CNEs in osteosarcoma.

Towards a Rational and Efficient Diagnostic Approach in Children Referred for Tall Stature and/or Accelerated Growth to the General Paediatrician

Tall stature and/or accelerated growth (TS/AG) in a child can be the result of a primary or secondary growth disorder, but more frequently no cause can be found (idiopathic TS). The conditions with the most important therapeutic implications are Klinefelter syndrome, Marfan syndrome and secondary growth disorders such as precocious puberty, hyperthyroidism and growth hormone excess. We propose a diagnostic flow chart offering a systematic approach to evaluate children referred for TS/AG to the general paediatrician. Based on the incidence, prevalence and clinical features of medical conditions associated with TS/AG, we identified relevant clues for primary and secondary growth disorders that may be obtained from the medical history, physical evaluation, growth analysis and additional laboratory and genetic testing. In addition to obtaining a diagnosis, a further goal is to predict adult height based on growth pattern, pubertal development and skeletal maturation. We speculate that an improved diagnostic approach in addition to expanding use of genetic testing may increase the diagnostic yield and lower the age at diagnosis of children with a pathologic cause of TS/AG.