Serum complexes between C1INH and C1INH autoantibodies for the diagnosis of acquired angioedema

Clinical and Pathophysiological Tangles Between Allergy and Autoimmunity: Deconstructing an Old Dichotomic Paradigm

Allergic and autoimmune disorders are characterised by dysregulation of the immune responses to otherwise inert environmental substances and autoantigens, leading to inflammation and tissue damage. Their incidence has constantly increased in the last decades, and their co-occurrence defies current standards in patient care. For years, allergy and autoimmunity have been considered opposite conditions, with IgE and Th2 lymphocytes cascade driving canonical allergic manifestations and Th1/Th17-related pathways accounting for autoimmunity. Conversely, growing evidence suggests that these conditions not only share some common inciting triggers but also are subtended by overlapping pathogenic pathways. Permissive genetic backgrounds, along with epithelial barrier damage and changes in the microbiome, are now appreciated as common risk factors for both allergy and autoimmunity. Eosinophils and mast cells, along with autoreactive IgE, are emerging players in triggering and sustaining autoimmunity, while pharmacological modulation of B cells and Th17 responses has provided novel clues to the pathophysiology of allergy. By combining clinical and therapeutic evidence with data from mechanistic studies, this review provides a state-of-the-art update on the complex interplay between allergy and autoimmunity, deconstructing old dichotomic paradigms and offering potential clues for future research.

Angioedema due to Acquired C1-Inhibitor Deficiency Associated With Monoclonal Gammopathies of Undetermined Significance Characteristics of a French National Cohort

BACKGROUND

No specific description of monoclonal gammopathies of undetermined significance (MGUS)-associated angioedema due to acquired C1 inhibitor deficiency (AAE-C1-INH) has been reported yet.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the biological and clinical characteristics, evolution, and response to treatment of MGUS-associated AAE-C1-INH.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a French national retrospective observational study on MGUS-associated acquired angioedema spanning a 30-year period.

RESULTS

Forty-one patients with MGUS-associated AAE-C1-INH at diagnosis were included; 68% displayed anti-C1-INH antibodies. The monoclonal component was an IgM in 24 patients, IgG in 11, and IgA in 6 patients. The mean age at first angioedema attack was 63 years (standard deviation [SD] = 13 years) and at diagnosis 66 years (SD = 11 years). A total of 88% patients benefited from acute attack treatments, and 77% from long-term prophylaxis, either danazol, tranexamic acid, or lanadelumab. Median follow-up was 7 years, during which 14 patients (33%) evolved into well-defined malignant hemopathies. Fifty percent of patients were given a hematological treatment, either rituximab alone, indicated by recurrent attacks of angioedema in patients with AAE-C1-INH with anti-C1-INH antibodies, or validated combinations of chemotherapies, indicated by evolution into a lymphoma in 7 patients and a myeloma in 3 patients. Fifteen patients (35%) were in clinical complete remission of angioedema at last visit, of whom 60% had an undetectable serum monoclonal immunoglobulin.

CONCLUSIONS

Complete remission of AAE-C1-INH is correlated to complete remission of the underlying hematological malignancy, as defined by an undetectable serum monoclonal immunoglobulin. In our MGUS-associated acquired angioedema cohort, we recorded an incidence of evolution into hematological malignancy of 4% per patient-year. It is therefore crucial to conduct full hematological workup during follow-up at an annual rate, and earlier if AAE relapses or if acute attack frequency increases.

Acquired Angioedema Due to C1-Inhibitor Deficiency (AAE-C1-INH)-A Bicenter Retrospective Study on Diagnosis, Course, and Therapy

BACKGROUND

Acquired angioedema with C1-inhibitor deficiency (AAE-C1-INH) is a rare condition resembling hereditary angioedema (HAE), but with late onset and low C1-inhibitor (C1-INH) due to consumption potentially caused by autoimmune diseases and mainly lymphatic malignancies. Being about 10-fold rarer than HAE, there is limited knowledge and no licensed therapy.

OBJECTIVE

To report clinical and biological data from a newly described population of 20 patients with AAE-C1-INH assessing diagnostic delay, AAE-C1-INH:HAE-ratio, underlying conditions, and therapeutic management in Germany.

METHODS

Retrospective data analysis of 20 patients from 2 angioedema centers in southern Germany.

RESULTS

Median age at symptoms' onset was 64 years (60% females), with predominant swellings of the face (85%) and low levels for C1-INH in almost all patients. The ratio AAE-C1-INH:HAE was 1:9.7. From symptoms' onset to diagnosis of AAE-C1-INH, the median delay was 7.5 months, and between AAE-C1-INH symptoms' onset and diagnosis of the underlying hematological condition (n = 9) it was 4 months (median). Four patients had a history of solid neoplasm, 1 had a papillary thyroid carcinoma as the only potential cause for AAE-C1-INH, with treatment of the malignancy resulting in resolution of AAE-C1-INH. All the symptomatic patients were treated with off-label on-demand icatibant subcutaneously or C1-INH concentrate intravenously, and 6 severely affected patients needed off-label long-term prophylaxis with good symptom control.

CONCLUSIONS

AAE-C1-INH is characterized by late-onset swellings mainly involving the face and low C1-INH levels. Diagnostic delay for AAE-C1-INH is further decreasing despite being about 10-fold rarer than HAE. Patients severely affected without underlying condition or no indication for treatment could benefit from off-label therapy.

C1-inhibitor/C1-inhibitor antibody complexes in acquired angioedema due to C1-inhibitor deficiency

BACKGROUND

Autoantibodies against C1-inhibitor (C1-INH-Ab) have a diagnostic value in acquired angioedema due to C1-inhibitor deficiency (C1-INH-AAE), even though antibodies can circulate in complexes, which can be undetectable by proven methods. Our aim was to measure C1-INH/C1-INH-Ab complexes (CAC) and investigate their connection to C1-INH-Ab and the changes in their titer over time.

RESULTS

19 patients were diagnosed with C1-INH-AAE in the Hungarian Angioedema Center of Reference and Excellence; 79% of them had an underlying disease. Samples were examined with a newly developed in-house complex ELISA method. Patients with high C1-INH-Ab titer had a CAC titer which did not exceed the normal level and the ones with high CAC titer had a C1-INH-Ab titer which did not exceed the normal level. In case of those patients who had C1-INH-Ab and CAC of the same type of immunoglobulin, the increasing titer of C1-INH-Ab went together with the decreasing level of CAC and vice versa. CAC titer was already increased before the diagnosis of the underlying disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Free circulating and complex antibodies are in a dynamically changing equilibrium. CAC measurements can help to predict the development of an underlying disease. The efficiency of the treatment for underlying disease can be monitored by the decreasing CAC titers. Our results show that the CAC can be of important additional information besides the complement panel examination in case of C1-INH-AAE. Measurement of CAC is recommended to be done parallelly with C1-INH-Ab, so as to detect both free and bound antibodies.

Angioedema Due to Acquired Deficiency of C1-Inhibitor: A Cohort Study in Spain and a Comparison With Other Series

BACKGROUND

Data on acquired angioedema due to C1-inhibitor deficiency (C1-INH-AAE) from 4 European countries (France, Italy, Germany, and Hungary) were recently published.

OBJECTIVE

To report data from a group of 50 patients with acquired C1-INH deficiency from Spain, of whom 46 had angioedema, and compare them with other European series.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective observational study of 46 patients with C1-INH-AAE and 4 asymptomatic patients. Clinical and biological characteristics and associated diseases were assessed and compared with other European series.

RESULTS

Women accounted for 73.9% of cases. The prevalence of C1-INH-AAE related to hereditary forms was 1/10.1. Overall, 8.7% patients were aged <40 years. Diagnostic delay was 1.1 years. Angioedema mainly affected the face (91.3%), followed by the oropharynx (63%), extremities (50%), and abdomen (37%). Only 1 patient underwent orotracheal intubation. Erythema marginatum was present in 1 patient. A hematologic disorder was recorded in 50% of patients. Angioedema preceded all benign conditions, mostly monoclonal gammopathy of undetermined significance, but appeared very close to or after malignant hematologic diseases (median, 2.2 and 0.29 years). Autoimmune diseases were associated in 50% (autoimmune thyroiditis, 21.5%; systemic lupus erythematosus, 10.9%). Half of them coexisted with hematologic disorders. Anti-C1-INH antibodies were found in 67% of tested patients and were not related to the associated disease. Long-term prophylaxis was necessary in 52.2%, most of whom responded to tranexamic acid.

CONCLUSIONS

This study emphasizes the possibility of C1-INH-AAE in patients younger than 40 and in autoimmune diseases other than systemic lupus erythematosus such as autoimmune thyroiditis.

Angioedema Without Wheals: Challenges in Laboratorial Diagnosis

Angioedema is a prevailing symptom in different diseases, frequently occurring in the presence of urticaria. Recurrent angioedema without urticaria (AE) can be hereditary (HAE) and acquired (AAE), and several subtypes can be distinguished, although clinical presentation is quite similar in some of them. They present with subcutaneous and mucosal swellings, affecting extremities, face, genitals, bowels, and upper airways. AE is commonly misdiagnosed due to restricted access and availability of appropriate laboratorial tests. HAE with C1 inhibitor defect is associated with quantitative and/or functional deficiency. Although bradykinin-mediated disease results mainly from disturbance in the kallikrein–kinin system, traditionally complement evaluation has been used for diagnosis. Diagnosis is established by nephelometry, turbidimetry, or radial immunodiffusion for quantitative measurement of C1 inhibitor, and chromogenic assay or ELISA has been used for functional C1-INH analysis. Wrong handling of the samples can lead to misdiagnosis and, consequently, mistaken inappropriate approaches. Dried blood spot (DBS) tests have been used for decades in newborn screening for certain metabolic diseases, and there has been growing interest in their use for other congenital conditions. Recently, DBS is now proposed as an efficient tool to diagnose HAE with C1 inhibitor deficiency, and its use would improve the access to outbound areas and family members. Regarding HAE with normal C1 inhibitor, complement assays’ results are normal and the genetic sequencing of target genes, such as exon 9 of F12 and PLG, is the only available method. New methods to measure cleaved high-molecular-weight kininogen and activated plasma kallikrein have emerged as potential biochemical tests to identify bradykinin-mediated angioedema. Validated biomarkers of kallikrein–kinin system activation could be helpful in differentiating mechanisms of angioedema. Our aim is to focus on the capability to differentiate histaminergic AE from bradykinin-mediated AE. In addition, we will describe the challenges developing specific tests like direct bradykinin measurements. The need for quality tests to improve the diagnosis is well represented by the variability of results in functional assays.

Where we are with acquired angioedema due to C1 inhibitor deficiency: A systematic literature review

Acquired angioedema due to C1 inhibitor deficiency (C1-INH-AAE) is a rare disease characterized by adult-onset recurrent non-urticarial angioedema with low levels of C1-INH. It is associated with lymphoproliferative disorders, and treatments are off-label with variable success. We conducted a systematic literature review to include patients with C1-INH-AAE identified in PubMed and Embase databases between January 2006 and February 2021. Clinical features of these patients were summarized, and factors associated with disease remission were explored. A total of 121 patients were included in the current study with a median age at diagnosis of 64 years and 45.5% being male. An associated disease was recorded in 94 patients (77.7%), and lymphoproliferative disorder was the most reported (59/94, 62.8%). Anti-C1-INH autoantibodies were present in 45 of 71 patients (63.4%). Factors impacting disease remissions included age (odds ratio [OR] 0.951, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.909-0.994, p = 0.027), male (OR 0.327, 95% CI 0.124-0.866, p = 0.025), presence of monoclonal gammopathy (OR 0.133, 95% CI 0.041-0.429, p = 0.001), requirement of specific on-demand treatment (OR 0.216, 95% CI 0.066-0.709, p = 0.012) and rituximab use (OR 2.865, 95% CI 1.038-7.911, p = 0.042). A total of nine patients (7.4%) died at last follow up and most were unrelated to C1-INH-AAE. Our results imply that C1-INH-AAE is primarily associated with underlying B or plasma cell abnormalities, and clone-directed therapies could be promising options for its long-term management.