Choroidal abnormalities in café-au-lait syndromes: a new differential diagnostic tool?

Histologic correlates of "Choroidal abnormalities" in Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1)

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a rare autosomal dominant disorder characterized by proliferation of cells from neural crest origin. The most common manifestations are cutaneous, neurologic, skeletal and ocular. The distinction of NF1 from other syndromes with multiple café-au-lait macules may be difficult in the pediatric age group, and ocular findings, especially Lisch nodules (i.e., melanocytic hamartomas on the irides), are a useful, early diagnostic tool. In recent years, novel ocular manifestations descriptively referred to as "choroidal abnormalities", choroidal "hyperpigmented spots" and "retinal vascular abnormalities" have been recognized in NF1. Choroidal abnormalities (CA) appear as bright patchy nodules that can be best detected with near-infrared ocular coherence tomography imaging (NIR-OCT). Because of their high specificity and sensitivity for NF1, CA have been added as an ocular diagnostic criterion of NF1 as an alternative to Lisch nodules. Although CA are important ocular diagnostic criteria for NF1, the histologic correlates are controversial. We present the postmortem ocular pathology findings of an NF1 patient for whom clinical notes and ocular imaging were available. Findings in this patient included choroidal hyperpigmented spots on funduscopy and retinal vascular abnormalities, both of which have been reported to be closely associated with CA. Histologic examination of the eyes showed multiple clusters of melanocytes of varying sizes in the choroid. Pathologic review of 12 additional postmortem eyes from 6 NF1 patients showed multiple, bilateral choroidal melanocytic aggregates in all eyes. These findings suggest that the CA seen on NIR-OCT and the hyperpigmented spots seen clinically in NF1 patients are manifestations of multifocal choroidal melanocytic clusters, consistent with choroidal melanocytic hamartomas. Lisch nodules, often multiple, were present in all eyes with morphology that differed from the choroidal hamartomas. As such, although CA and Lisch nodules are melanocytic hamartomas, there are clear phenotypical differences in their morphologies.

Ophthalmologic Findings in Children with Neurofibromatosis Type 1

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the ophthalmologic findings in children with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) and compare these findings in eyes with and without optic pathway gliomas (OPGs). We carried out a retrospective chart review of children with NF1. We recorded demographic characteristics, clinical manifestations of disease, and ophthalmologic findings including visual acuity, intraocular pressure, cup-to-disc ratio, visual field testing, and optical coherence tomography findings. Ophthalmologic findings were examined for the cohort for initial and final appointments. These findings were also compared between eyes with and without OPGs. The study included 119 participants with 238 total eyes. The most common clinical manifestations of NF1 in this cohort were café au lait macules (98%), axillary or inguinal freckling (91%), Lisch nodules (66%), and cutaneous neurofibromas (57%). Thirty-seven participants had imaging that allowed evaluation for choroidal abnormalities, and 28 (76%) had choroidal lesions. Twenty-seven participants (23%) had OPGs, and 44 eyes were affected. On initial assessment, eyes with OPGs had worse visual acuity. On final examination, eyes with OPGs were more likely to have a worse visual acuity and a thinner generalised retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) thickness, inferior RNFL thickness, and temporal RNFL thickness. This study provides longitudinal follow-up of children affected by NF1 with and without OPGs. Eyes with OPGs were found to be associated with worse visual acuity and thinner RNFLs overall on final testing.

Multimodal Imaging of Choroidal Nodules in Neurofibromatosis Type I

AIM

To clarify the possibilities and role of posterior segment imaging in patients with neurofibromatosis type I (NF1), and to show the prevalence of this disease in the pediatric population in Slovakia.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Until recently, ophthalmologic consultations in patients with NF1 were limited mainly to the observation of Lisch nodules of the iris and the presence of optic nerve glioma. However, advances in imaging capabilities have made it possible to investigate and describe new f indings concerning the ocular manifestations of this disease. Between October 2020 and November 2021, we examined the anterior and posterior segment of 76 eyes (38 children – 12 boys and 26 girls) with genetically confirmed NF1 gene mutation at our clinic. The age of the patients ranged from 4 to 18 years. The anterior segment was checked for the presence of Lisch nodules biomicroscopically with a slit lamp. On the posterior segment, the presence of choroidal nodules was checked by various imaging methods – fundus camera, infrared confocal selective laser ophthalmoscopy, MultiColor imaging, OCT, and OCT angiography. All the patients had magnetic resonance imaging performed in order to detect potential optic nerve gliomas for the purpose of diagnosis. We observed the correlation between the patients’ age, presence of Lisch nodules and the presence of choroidal nodules. Eight patients also had other manifestations of the disease – optic nerve gliomas or microvascular changes (so-called “corkscrew” vessels).

RESULTS

Out of 38 patients, Lisch iris nodules were present in 20 patients (53%) and choroidal nodules in 24 patients (63%). There was no positive correlation between the presence of these two manifestations within the same patient or eye, but there is a clear correlation between the presence of choroidal nodules and patient age.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that a previously unknown ocular manifestation of neurofibromatosis type I, namely choroidal nodules, has a higher prevalence than Lisch nodules also in the pediatric population and can be easily visualized using various imaging modalities. It will be important to include follow-up observation of this finding among the standard controls for ocular findings in NF1, and it will be very interesting to correlate this f inding with the exact NF1 mutation

Neurofibromatosis type 1: A comparison of the 1997 NIH and the 2021 revised diagnostic criteria in 75 children and adolescents

PURPOSE

Examining a cohort of patients suspicious of neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) we compared the revised diagnostic criteria with the previous National Institutes of Health (NIH) diagnostic criteria. We asked whether the refinement improved distinguishing between NF1, Legius syndrome, and constitutional mismatch repair deficiency (CMMRD).

METHODS

A database search in the hospital information system of the University Children's Hospital Augsburg between 2017 and 2020 ascertained patients with International Classification of Diseases-10 code Q85.0; their clinical phenotype was evaluated by retrospective chart review.

RESULTS

A total of 75 patients were identified (median age 11.0 years [range 1.1-22.6 years]; 35 female). At first suspicion of NF1, 44 patients met the NIH criteria and 56 met the revised diagnostic criteria. In total, 12 patients were diagnosed with NF1 after performing molecular genetic testing. In 31 patients, only pigmentary findings were present, whereas nonpigmentary NF1 manifestations presented with time in 9 patients. In 1 patient a heterozygous variant of uncertain significance was identified in SPRED1. Requirements for CMMRD testing were fulfilled in another patient. A total of 3 patients presented with segmental clinical findings. Three additional patients did not meet the NIH criteria, 1 of them presented with 1 additional feature of CMMRD without fulfilling requirements for testing.

CONCLUSION

In our pediatric cohort, the revised diagnostic criteria discovered more patients with proven NF1 than the NIH criteria.

Choroidal Abnormalities in Pediatric NF1: A Cohort Natural History Study

The purpose of this study was to assess the long-term natural history of choroidal abnormalities (CAs) in a large pediatric neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) population, quantifying their progression in number and dimensions. Pediatric patients (<16 years old) affected by NF1 with a minimum follow-up of 3 years with at least one CA in one eye were consecutively recruited. Near-infrared (NIR) imaging was performed to identify CAs, which were quantified in number and size. The CAs area and perimeter were normalized for the optic disc dimensions to avoid possible bias related to the growing process of the eye. Ninety-nine eyes of 53 patients were evaluated. The CAs number, area and perimeter significantly increased during follow-up (p < 0.0001 for each parameter). The patient age at baseline was inversely correlated with the CAs number over time (coefficient = −0.1313, p = 0.0068), while no correlation was found between the patient age and CAs progression in size. In conclusion, we provide evidence that, in NF1 pediatric patients, CAs change over time, increasing both in number and dimensions, independently from the physiological growth of the eye. While the increase of the CAs number occurs particularly at an earlier age, the increase in the CAs dimensions is a slow process that remains constant during childhood.

Challenges in the diagnosis of neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) in young children facilitated by means of revised diagnostic criteria including genetic testing for pathogenic NF1 gene variants

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is the most frequent disorder associated with multiple café-au-lait macules (CALM) which may either be present at birth or appear during the first year of life. Other NF1-associated features such as skin-fold freckling and Lisch nodules occur later during childhood whereas dermal neurofibromas are rare in young children and usually only arise during early adulthood. The NIH clinical diagnostic criteria for NF1, established in 1988, include the most common NF1-associated features. Since many of these features are age-dependent, arriving at a definitive diagnosis of NF1 by employing these criteria may not be possible in infancy if CALM are the only clinical feature evident. Indeed, approximately 46% of patients who are diagnosed with NF1 later in life do not meet the NIH diagnostic criteria by the age of 1 year. Further, the 1988 diagnostic criteria for NF1 are not specific enough to distinguish NF1 from other related disorders such as Legius syndrome. In this review, we outline the challenges faced in diagnosing NF1 in young children, and evaluate the utility of the recently revised (2021) diagnostic criteria for NF1, which include the presence of pathogenic variants in the NF1 gene and choroidal anomalies, for achieving an early and accurate diagnosis.

Revidierte Diagnosekriterien für die Neurofibromatose Typ 1 (NF1) ermöglichen eine frühe präzise differenzialdiagnostische Abgrenzung zu anderen RASopathien und erleichtern die Diagnose

Hintergrund

Die Neurofibromatose Typ 1 (NF1) ist eines der häufigsten erblichen Tumorprädispositionssyndrome und zählt zu den RASopathien, einer Gruppe von Erkrankungen mit überlappender Symptomatik, die durch Störungen des RAS-vermittelten Signaltransduktionsweges entstehen. Die diagnostischen Kriterien für NF1 sind 1988 definiert worden. Neue klinische und genetische Erkenntnisse erforderten eine Revision dieser Kriterien. Besonders im frühen Kindesalter ermöglichen die NF1-Diagnosekriterien von 1988 häufig noch keine Diagnose der NF1 und keine differenzialdiagnostische Abgrenzung zu anderen RASopathien wie dem Legius-Syndrom.

Methoden

Es erfolgte eine selektive Literaturrecherche zu Genetik und Symptomatik der NF1. Die Autoren nahmen an einer Delphi-Methode zur Revision der NF1-Diagnosekriterien durch ein internationales Expertengremium teil. Es wurden hierbei auch erstmalig die Diagnosekriterien für das Legius-Syndrom sowie für Mosaikformen beider Erkrankungen erstellt.

Ergebnisse

Die NF1-Diagnosekriterien wurden überarbeitet; dabei wurden neue klinische Merkmale wie choroidale Anomalien aufgenommen, aber auch genetische Befunde wie der Nachweis pathogener NF1-Genvarianten.

Diskussion

Mit den revidierten NF1-Diagnosekriterien und den neu erstellten Diagnosekriterien für das Legius-Syndrom ist es nun möglich, auch bei Kindern die Diagnose einer NF1 mit hoher Sensitivität und Spezifität frühzeitig zu stellen. Diese Diagnosekriterien ermöglichen eine genaue differenzialdiagnostische Abgrenzung von anderen Erkrankungen mit phänotypischen Überlappungen zur NF1, was eine frühe Risikostratifizierung und somit eine zielgerichtete Behandlung und Betreuung der Patienten ermöglicht.

Revised diagnostic criteria for neurofibromatosis type 1 and Legius syndrome: an international consensus recommendation

Purpose

By incorporating major developments in genetics, ophthalmology, dermatology, and neuroimaging, to revise the diagnostic criteria for neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) and to establish diagnostic criteria for Legius syndrome (LGSS).

Methods

We used a multistep process, beginning with a Delphi method involving global experts and subsequently involving non-NF experts, patients, and foundations/patient advocacy groups.

Results

We reached consensus on the minimal clinical and genetic criteria for diagnosing and differentiating NF1 and LGSS, which have phenotypic overlap in young patients with pigmentary findings. Criteria for the mosaic forms of these conditions are also recommended.

Conclusion

The revised criteria for NF1 incorporate new clinical features and genetic testing, whereas the criteria for LGSS were created to differentiate the two conditions. It is likely that continued refinement of these new criteria will be necessary as investigators (1) study the diagnostic properties of the revised criteria, (2) reconsider criteria not included in this process, and (3) identify new clinical and other features of these conditions. For this reason, we propose an initiative to update periodically the diagnostic criteria for NF1 and LGSS.

The presence and progression of choroidal neurofibromas in a predominantly pediatric population with neurofibromatosis type-1

Background: Obtaining a definitive neurofibromatosis type-1 (NF1) diagnosis may take years. The natural history of choroidal neurofibromas in NF1 is unknown. This study evaluates a predominantly pediatric patient cohort for ocular features in NF1, including presence and progression of choroidal abnormalities, to determine their natural history, relationship to other NF1 features, and additive value in NF1 diagnosis.Methods: Retrospective analysis of 106 patients referred for Ophthalmic monitoring or diagnosis of NF1 between January 2012 and December 2018. Clinical records and Near-Infrared Reflectance (NIR) Optical Coherence Tomography imaging were analyzed for prevalence and progression of choroidal neurofibromas on NIR, and relation to other NF1 diagnostic criteria.Results: 54.7% of patients referred had a confirmed NF1 diagnosis, and 45.4% were NF1 suspects. First ophthalmic review resulted in an additional 6.6% patients meeting the diagnostic criteria, and 14.2% later developed sufficient features (total n = 80). Choroidal neurofibromas were present in 75.7% of patients that had NIR imaging and met diagnostic criteria, and detected in the absence of, or prior to Lisch nodules in 13.5%. Progression in the size and number of choroidal neurofibromas occurred in 26 eyes (32.5%) of 14 patients (35.0%), all under 16 years old. Patients without choroidal neurofibromas at first examination never developed them over the study period.Conclusion: Choroidal neurofibromas, detected by NIR imaging, are common in NF1, present early with frequent progression, and represent an additional tool to aid NF1 diagnosis in young children.

Ocular surface involvement in patients with neurofibromatosis type 1 syndrome

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to evaluate ocular surface morphological and functional changes in patients with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1).

METHODS

Twenty-eight patients with NF1 and 14 healthy subjects were included in this study. All participants underwent a medical history collection, a complete ophthalmological examination including slit lamp exam and assessment of best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), corneal sensitivity, and lacrimal function (Schirmer test and fluorescein tear break-up time test). Corneal nerves' morphology and endothelial cells density were evaluated by in vivo corneal confocal microscopy (IVCM). Tear and conjunctiva epithelium samples were collected to evaluate nerve growth factor (NGF) and brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) tear levels and conjunctival expression of their receptors TrkA and p75NTR.

RESULTS

Patients with NF1 showed a significant decrease of FTBUT when compared with healthy subjects (p < 0.001). Corneal sensitivity was ≤ 50 mm in 46% of NF1 patients. IVCM showed a significant increase of corneal nerve branching and of corneal endothelial cells density. No significant difference was observed between the two groups on NGF and BDNF tear levels and conjunctival expression of their receptors.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrated the presence of ocular surface changes in NF-1 patients including decrease of tear stability and of corneal sensitivity. Patients with NF1 also showed changes of corneal endothelial cells' density.

Unusual Case of Indolent Choroidal Alterations Mimicking Neurofibromatosis Type 1

Indolent, non-progressive choroidal alterations can be strongly suggestive of neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) but are also rarely of unknown aetiology. A 63-year-old man presented for a routine examination. Comprehensive ophthalmological examination and retinal imaging was performed. Visual acuity was 20/20. The anterior segment and fundus were unremarkable. Near-infrared reflectance (NIR) with spectral-domain optical coherence tomography showed unilateral hyperreflective areas in the left posterior pole, corresponding to choroidal nodules on enhanced depth imaging and hypofluorescent areas on indocyanine green angiography. Dermatological evaluation and genetic testing for NF1 were negative. Chest computed tomography, liver function, HLA-A29, and angiotensin-converting enzyme level were negative. The patient has remained in good health and the choroidal alterations have remained non-progressive for 3 years. Choroidal alterations observed with NIR could be a manifestation of somatic mosaicism or a variation of a new unclassified correlated condition that may be better elucidated in the future, given the use of novel imaging techniques that are currently available in ophthalmology.