Comparison of the real-world effectiveness of vertical versus lateral functional hemispherotomy techniques for pediatric drug-resistant epilepsy: A post hoc analysis of the HOPS study

The Pediatric Epilepsy Surgery Interest Group (PESIG) under the auspice of the ISPN Research Committee: Availability of relevant technology and geographical distribution

PURPOSE

Epilepsy surgery for pediatric drug-resistant epilepsy has been shown to improve seizure control, enhance patient and family QoL, and reduce mortality. However, diagnostic tools and surgical capacity are less accessible worldwide. The International Society Pediatric Neurosurgery (ISPN) has established a Pediatric Epilepsy Surgery Interest Group (PESIG), aiming to enhance global collaboration in research and educational aspects. The goals of this manuscript are to introduce PESIG and analyze geographical differences of epilepsy surgery and technology availability.

METHODS

PESIG was established (2022) following an ISPN executive board decision. Using a standardized form, we surveyed the PESIG members, collecting and analyzing data regarding geographical distribution, and availability of various epilepsy treatment-related technologies.

RESULTS

Two hundred eighty-two members registered in PESIG from 70 countries, over 6 continents, were included. We categorized the countries by GDP as follows: low, lower-medium, upper-medium, and high income. The most commonly available technology was vagus nerve stimulation 68%. Stereoelectroencephalography was available for 58%. North America had statistically significant greater availability compared to other continents. Europe had greater availability compared to Africa, Asia, and South (Latin) America. Asia had greater availability compared to Africa. High-income countries had statistically significant greater availability compared to other income groups; there was no significant difference between the other income-level subgroups.

CONCLUSION

There is a clear discrepancy between countries and continents regarding access to epilepsy surgery technologies. This strengthens the need for collaboration between neurologists and neurosurgeons from around the world, to enhance medical education and training, as well as to increase technological availability.

Interhemispheric Vertical Hemispherotomy: Technique, Outcome, and Pitfalls-A Bicentric Retrospective Case Series of 39 Cases

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

When seizure onset affects a whole hemisphere, hemispheric disconnections are efficient and safe procedures. However, both lateral peri-insular hemispherotomy and vertical paramedian hemispherotomy approaches report a failure rate around 20%, which can be explained by residual connections giving rise to persistent seizures. In this study, we present the interhemispheric vertical hemispherotomy (IVH), a technical variation of the vertical paramedian hemispherotomy approach, that aims to increase seizure control avoiding residual connections while exposing the corpus callosum.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study of IVH in two centers, with analysis of clinical and MRI data and outcomes. A detailed description of the technique is provided with a video.

RESULTS

IVH was performed in 39 children. The mean age at surgery was 7.2 years, and etiologies were as follows: malformations of cortical development (n = 14), Rasmussen's encephalitis (n = 10), stroke (n = 10), post-traumatic (3), and Sturge-Weber Syndrome (2). Hemispheric disconnection was complete on postoperative MRI in 34 cases. There was no mortality, hydrocephalus occurred in one case, and subdural collection occurred in four cases. A second surgery was performed in four cases because of seizure relapse (n = 3) and/or incomplete disconnection on MRI (n = 4). With a mean follow-up of 3.2 years, International League Against Epilepsy class I epilepsy outcome was obtained for 37/39 patients.

CONCLUSION

IVH is a safe and effective variation of the vertical approaches for hemispheric disconnection. It allows a good exposure and anatomic control of the corpus callosum, which is a frequent site of incomplete disconnection. IVH may be limited by the thalamic volume and the ventricular size, notably in hemimegalencephaly cases.

Hemimegalencephaly: A Systematic Comparison of Functional and Anatomic Hemispherectomy for Drug-Resistant Epilepsy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Hemimegalencephaly (HME) is a rare diffuse malformation of cortical development characterized by unihemispheric hypertrophy, drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE), hemiparesis, and developmental delay. Definitive treatment for HME-related DRE is hemispheric surgery through either anatomic (AH) or functional hemispherectomy (FH). This individual patient data meta-analysis assessed seizure outcomes of AH and FH for HME with pharmacoresistant epilepsy, predictors of Engel I, and efficacy of different FH approaches.

METHODS

PubMed, Web of Science, and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature were searched from inception to Jan 13th, 2023, for primary literature reporting seizure outcomes in >3 patients with HME receiving AH or FH. Demographics, neurophysiology findings, and Engel outcome at the last follow-up were extracted. Postsurgical seizure outcomes were compared through 2-tailed t -test and Fisher exact test. Univariate and multivariate Cox regression analyses were performed to identify independent predictors of Engel I outcome.

RESULTS

Data from 145 patients were extracted from 26 studies, of which 89 underwent FH (22 vertical, 33 lateral), 47 underwent AH, and 9 received an unspecified hemispherectomy with a median last follow-up of 44.0 months (FH cohort) and 45.0 months (AH cohort). Cohorts were similar in preoperative characteristics and at the last follow-up; 77% (n = 66) of the FH cohort and 81% (n = 38) and of the AH cohort were Engel I. On multivariate analysis, only the presence of bilateral ictal electroencephalography abnormalities (hazard ratio = 11.5; P = .002) was significantly associated with faster time-to-seizure recurrence. A number-needed-to-treat analysis to prevent 1 additional case of posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus reveals that FH, compared with AH, was 3. There was no statistical significance for any differences in time-to-seizure recurrence between lateral and vertical FH approaches (hazard ratio = 2.59; P = .101).

CONCLUSION

We show that hemispheric surgery is a highly effective treatment for HME-related DRE. Unilateral ictal electroencephalography changes and using the FH approach as initial surgical management may result in better outcomes due to significantly lower posthemispherectomy hydrocephalus probability. However, larger HME registries are needed to further delineate the predictors of seizure outcomes.

Predicting seizure outcomes and functional outcomes after hemispherotomy: are we any better?

INTRODUCTION

Present study attempted to analyze seizure freedom and detailed functional outcomes after functional hemispherotomy and utility of hemispherotomy outcome prediction scale (HOPS) scores in predicting outcomes.

METHODS

Patients who underwent functional hemispherotomy were analyzed for clinical presentation, neuroimaging, seizure outcomes, and functional outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 76 procedures were performed on 69 patients. Mean age at the surgery was 8 ± 6.1 years. Fourteen patients were < 2 years. Age of onset epilepsy of the cohort was 2.0 ± 3.3 years. All had severe catastrophic epilepsy with multiple daily seizures. All patients had motor deficits with 36 (52%) patients had contralateral dysfunctional hand. Perinatal stroke (49%) was most common substrate followed by cortical malformations (21.7%). Eight patients had contralateral imaging abnormalities. Fifty-nine (86.76%) patients remained seizure free (Engle 1a) at 41 + -20.9 months. HOPS scores were available for 53 patients and lowest seizure outcome was 71% for HOPS score of 4. Lower HOPS scores predicted better seizure outcomes. Cortical malformations operated earlier than 2 years predicted poor seizure outcomes (66.6%). Positive functional outcomes are recorded in 80% of patients with 78% reporting improvement from the pre-surgical level. Five (7.2%) patients underwent shunt surgery. One mortality recorded.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemispherotomy has excellent seizure outcomes. Early surgery in cortical malformations appears to be predictor of poorer seizure outcomes. HOPS score is a good tool to predict the seizure outcomes. Hemispherotomy is perceived to improve the Cognitive and functional performance.

Determinants of Functional Outcome after Pediatric Hemispherotomy

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to evaluate determinants of functional outcome after pediatric hemispherotomy in a large and recent multicenter cohort.

METHODS

We retrospectively investigated the functional outcomes of 455 children who underwent hemispherotomy at 5 epilepsy centers in 2000-2016. We identified determinants of unaided walking, voluntary grasping with the hemiplegic hand, and speaking through Bayesian multivariable regression modeling using missing data imputation.

RESULTS

Seventy-five percent of children were seizure-free, and 44% stopped antiseizure medication at a 5.1-year mean follow-up (range = 1-17.1). Seventy-seven percent of children could walk unaided, 8% could grasp voluntarily, and 68% could speak at the last follow-up. Children were unlikely to walk when they had contralateral magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) abnormalities (40/73, p = 0.04), recurrent seizures following hemispherotomy (62/109, p = 0.04), and moderately (50/61, p = 0.03) or severely impaired (127/199, p = 0.001) postsurgical intellectual functioning, but were likely to walk when they were older at outcome determination (p = 0.01). Children were unlikely to grasp voluntarily with the hand contralateral to surgery when they had Rasmussen encephalitis (0/61, p = 0.001) or Sturge-Weber syndrome (0/32, p = 0.007). Children were unlikely to speak when they had contralateral MRI abnormalities (30/69, p = 0.002) and longer epilepsy duration (p = 0.01), but likely to speak when they had Sturge-Weber syndrome (29/35, p = 0.01), were older at surgery (p = 0.04), and were older at outcome determination (p < 0.001).

INTERPRETATION

Etiology and bilaterality of structural brain abnormalities were key determinants of functional outcome after hemispherotomy. Longer epilepsy duration affected language outcomes. Not surprisingly, walking and talking ability increased with older age at outcome evaluation. ANN NEUROL 2024;95:377-387.

Functional hemispheric disconnection procedures for chronic epilepsy: history, indications, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe. A consensus statement on behalf of the EANS functional neurosurgery section

Introduction

The surgical procedure for severe, drug-resistant, unilateral hemispheric epilepsy is challenging. Over the last decades the surgical landscape for hemispheric disconnection procedures changed from anatomical hemispherectomy to functional hemispherotomy with a reduction of complications and stable good seizure outcome. Here, a task force of European epilepsy surgeons prepared, on behalf of the EANS Section for Functional Neurosurgery, a consensus statement on different aspects of the hemispheric disconnection procedure.

Research question

To determine history, indication, timing, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe for hemispheric disconnection procedures in drug-resistant epilepsy.

Material and methods

Relevant literature on the topic was collected by a literature search based on the PRISMA 2020 guidelines.

Results

A comprehensive overview on the historical development of hemispheric disconnection procedures for epilepsy is presented, while discussing indications, timing, surgical techniques and complications. Current practice for this procedure in European epilepsy surgery centers is provided. At present, our knowledge of long-term seizure outcomes primarily stems from open surgical disconnection procedures. Although minimal invasive surgical techniques in epilepsy are rapidly developing and reported in case reports or small case series, long-term seizure outcome remain uncertain and needs to be reported.

Discussion and conclusion

This is the first paper presenting a European consensus statement regarding history, indications, techniques and complications of hemispheric disconnection procedures for different causes of chronic, drug-resistant epilepsy. Furthermore, it serves as the pioneering document to report a comprehensive overview of the current surgical practices regarding this type of surgery employed in renowned epilepsy surgery centers across Europe.

Development of an online calculator for the prediction of seizure freedom following pediatric hemispherectomy using the Hemispherectomy Outcome Prediction Scale (HOPS)

OBJECTIVES

Although hemispheric surgeries are among the most effective procedures for drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) in the pediatric population, there is a large variability in seizure outcomes at the group level. A recently developed HOPS score provides individualized estimation of likelihood of seizure freedom to complement clinical judgement. The objective of this study was to develop a freely accessible online calculator that accurately predicts the probability of seizure freedom for any patient at 1-, 2-, and 5-years post-hemispherectomy.

METHODS

Retrospective data of all pediatric patients with DRE and seizure outcome data from the original Hemispherectomy Outcome Prediction Scale (HOPS) study were included. The primary outcome of interest was time-to-seizure recurrence. A multivariate Cox proportional-hazards regression model was developed to predict the likelihood of post-hemispheric surgery seizure freedom at three time points (1-, 2- and 5- years) based on a combination of variables identified by clinical judgment and inferential statistics predictive of the primary outcome. The final model from this study was encoded in a publicly accessible online calculator on the International Network for Epilepsy Surgery and Treatment (iNEST) website (https://hops-calculator.com/).

RESULTS

The selected variables for inclusion in the final model included the five original HOPS variables (age at seizure onset, etiologic substrate, seizure semiology, prior non-hemispheric resective surgery, and contralateral fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography [FDG-PET] hypometabolism) and three additional variables (age at surgery, history of infantile spasms, and magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] lesion). Predictors of shorter time-to-seizure recurrence included younger age at seizure onset, prior resective surgery, generalized seizure semiology, FDG-PET hypometabolism contralateral to the side of surgery, contralateral MRI lesion, non-lesional MRI, non-stroke etiologies, and a history of infantile spasms. The area under the curve (AUC) of the final model was 73.0%.

SIGNIFICANCE

Online calculators are useful, cost-free tools that can assist physicians in risk estimation and inform joint decision-making processes with patients and families, potentially leading to greater satisfaction. Although the HOPS data was validated in the original analysis, the authors encourage external validation of this new calculator.

How are they doing as adults? Psychosocial and socioeconomic outcomes 11-30 years after pediatric epilepsy surgery

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery yields cure from epilepsy or complete seizure control with continued medication in many patients early in life. This study aimed to evaluate the long-term (>10 years) psychosocial and socioeconomic outcomes of pediatric epilepsy surgery and examine the role of comorbid disability, type of surgery, seizure freedom, and age at surgery.

METHODS

A novel ad hoc parent/patient questionnaire was used to assess educational and occupational attainment, marital/familial status, mobility, and other outcomes in patients who underwent unilobar or multilobar surgery for drug-refractory epilepsy during their childhood. The questionnaire also captured information on comorbid disability.

RESULTS

Of the 353 eligible patients, 203 could still be contacted and 101 of these (50%) returned appropriately filled-in questionnaires (follow-up intervals: 11-30 [mean: 19.6] years). The cure from epilepsy rate was 53%. Type of surgery was strongly confounded by comorbid disability. Patients with comorbid disabilities had significantly lower rates of regular school degrees, gainful employment, marriage, and driving license (N = 29; 12%, 4%, 0%, 3%) compared with non-disabled patients (N = 69; 89%, 80%, 43%, and 67%, respectively). Patients achieved lower school degrees than their siblings and parents. Non-disabled seizure-free patients had better employment and mobility outcomes compared with non-seizure-free patients. Age at surgery (<10 vs. ≥10 years of age) did not have any effect on any outcome in patients with preschool seizure onset.

SIGNIFICANCE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery can lead to permanent relief from epilepsy in many patients, but comorbid disability strongly impacts adult life achievement. In non-disabled patients, favorable outcomes in academic, occupational, marital, and mobility domains were achieved, approaching respective rates in the German population. Complete seizure freedom had additional positive effects on employment and mobility in this group. However, in case of chronic comorbid disability the overall life prospects may be limited despite favorable seizure outcomes.

Comparison of Hemispheric Surgery Techniques for Pediatric Drug-Resistant Epilepsy: An Individual Patient Data Meta-analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Hemispheric surgery effectively treats unihemispheric pediatric drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE) by resecting and/or disconnecting the epileptic hemisphere. Modifications to the original anatomic hemispherectomy have generated multiple functionally equivalent, disconnective techniques for performing hemispheric surgery, termed functional hemispherotomy. While a myriad of hemispherotomy variants exist, all of them can be categorized according to the anatomic plane they are performed in, which includes vertical approaches at or near the interhemispheric fissure and lateral approaches at or near the Sylvian fissure. This meta-analysis of individual patient data (IPD) aimed to compare seizure outcomes and complications between the hemispherotomy approaches to better characterize their relative efficacy and safety in the modern neurosurgical treatment of pediatric DRE, given emerging evidence that outcomes may differ between them.

METHODS

CINAHL, Embase, PubMed, and Web of Science were searched from inception to September 9, 2020, for studies reporting IPD from pediatric patients with DRE who underwent hemispheric surgery. Outcomes of interest were seizure freedom at last follow-up, time-to-seizure recurrence, and complications including hydrocephalus, infection, and mortality. The χ2 test compared the frequency of seizure freedom and complications. Multivariable mixed-effects Cox regression controlling for predictors of seizure outcome was performed on propensity score-matched patients to compare time-to-seizure recurrence between approaches. Kaplan-Meier curves were made to visualize differences in time-to-seizure recurrence.

RESULTS

Fifty-five studies reporting on 686 unique pediatric patients treated with hemispheric surgery were included for meta-analysis. Among the hemispherotomy subgroup, vertical approaches resulted in a greater proportion of seizure free patients (81.2% vs 70.7%, p = 0.014) than lateral approaches. While there were no differences in complications, lateral hemispherotomy had higher rates of revision hemispheric surgery due to incomplete disconnection and/or recurrent seizures than vertical hemispherotomy (16.3% vs 1.2%, p < 0.001). After propensity score matching, vertical hemispherotomy approaches independently conferred longer time-to-seizure recurrence than lateral hemispherotomy approaches (hazard ratio 0.44, 95% CI 0.19-0.98).

DISCUSSION

Among functional hemispherotomy techniques, vertical hemispherotomy approaches confer more durable seizure freedom than lateral approaches without compromising safety. Future prospective studies are required to definitively determine whether vertical approaches are indeed superior and how it should influence clinical guidelines for performing hemispheric surgery.

Hemispherotomy Revised: A complication overview and a systematic review meta-analysis

Introduction

Hemispherectomy/hemispherotomy has been employed in the management of catastrophic epilepsy. However, initial reports on the associated mortality and morbidity raised several concerns regarding the technique's safety. Their actual, current incidence needs to be systematically examined to redefine hemispherotomy's exact role.

Research question

Our current study examined their incidence and evaluated the association of the various hemispherotomy surgical techniques with the reported complications.

Material & methods

A PRISMA-compliant systematic review and meta-analysis was performed. We searched PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science until December 2022. Fixed- and random-effects models were employed. Egger's regression test was used for estimating the publication bias, while subgroup analysis was utilized for defining the role of the different hemispherotomy techniques.

Results

We retrieved a total of 37 studies. The overall procedure mortality was 5%, with a reported mortality of 7% for hemispherectomy and 3% for hemispherotomy. The reported mortality has decreased over the last 30 years from 32% to 2%. Among the observed post-operative complications aseptic meningitis and/or fever occurred in 33%. Hydrocephalus requiring a shunt insertion occurred in 16%. Hematoma evacuation was necessary in 8%, while subgaleal effusion in another 8%. Infections occurred in 11%. A novel post-operative cranial nerve deficit occurred in 11%, while blood transfusion was necessary in 28% of the cases.

Discussion and conclusion

Our current analysis demonstrated that the evolution from hemispherectomy to hemispherotomy along with neuroanesthesia advances, had a tremendous impact on the associated mortality and morbidity. Hemispherotomy constitutes a safe surgical procedure in the management of catastrophic epilepsies.

Not surgical technique, but etiology, contralateral MRI, prior surgery, and side of surgery determine seizure outcome after pediatric hemispherotomy

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to assess determinants of seizure outcome following pediatric hemispherotomy in a contemporary cohort.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the seizure outcomes of 457 children who underwent hemispheric surgery in five European epilepsy centers between 2000 and 2016. We identified variables related to seizure outcome through multivariable regression modeling with missing data imputation and optimal group matching, and we further investigated the role of surgical technique by Bayes factor (BF) analysis.

RESULTS

One hundred seventy seven children (39%) underwent vertical and 280 children (61%) underwent lateral hemispherotomy. Three hundred forty-four children (75%) achieved seizure freedom at a mean follow-up of 5.1 years (range 1 to 17.1). We identified acquired etiology other than stroke (odds ratio [OR] 4.4, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.1-18.0), hemimegalencephaly (OR 2.8, 95% CI 1.1-7.3), contralateral magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings (OR 5.5, 95% CI 2.7-11.1), prior resective surgery (OR 5.0, 95% CI 1.8-14.0), and left hemispherotomy (OR 2.3, 95% CI 1.3-3.9) as significant determinants of seizure recurrence. We found no evidence of an impact of the hemispherotomy technique on seizure outcome (the BF for a model including the hemispherotomy technique over the null model was 1.1), with comparable overall major complication rates for different approaches.

SIGNIFICANCE

Knowledge about the independent determinants of seizure outcome following pediatric hemispherotomy will improve the counseling of patients and families. In contrast to previous reports, we found no statistically relevant difference in seizure-freedom rates between the vertical and horizontal hemispherotomy techniques when accounting for different clinical features between groups.

Clinical adult outcome 11-30 years after pediatric epilepsy surgery: Complications and other surgical adverse events, seizure control, and cure of epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery promises seizure freedom or even cure of epilepsy. We evaluated the long-term (≥10 years) adult clinical outcome including surgery-related adverse events and complications, which are generally underreported.

METHODS

A monocentric, single-arm, questionnaire study in now adult patients who underwent epilepsy surgery during childhood. A novel ad hoc parental/patient questionnaire, which addressed diverse outcome domains was applied.

RESULTS

From a total of 353 eligible patients, 203 could be contacted (3 patients died of causes unknown) and 101 (50%) returned appropriately filled-in surveys. No evidence for a survey-response bias was found. The rate of surgical complications according to the patient records was 9%. As regards the survey, half of the parents/patients reported surgical adverse events (expected and unexpected issues) and one-third reported permanent aversive sequels. Two-thirds of the patients were seizure-free during the last year before follow-up; 63% were Engel class 1A; favorable seizure outcomes (including auras only) were obtained in 73%; and 54% were seizure-free and off antiseizure medicine (ASM), that is, cured of epilepsy. In non-seizure-free patients, seizure relapse occurred at any time during the follow-up interval but 87% of those with a seizure-free first postoperative year were seizure-free at follow-up. One patient experienced a seizure relapse during the ASM withdrawal trial but became seizure-free again with ASMs. Eleven patients reported an increased number of ASMs as compared to the time before surgery. Earlier focal surgery did not affect the long-term clinical outcome.

SIGNIFICANCE

Pediatric epilepsy surgery was capable of curing epilepsy in about one-half of the children and to significantly control seizures in about three-fourths. Long-term success of focal surgery did not depend on age at surgery or duration of epilepsy. Surgical adverse events including complications may be underreported and must be assessed more thoroughly.

Brain Surgery for Medically Intractable Epilepsy

This review covers the broad topic of brain surgery in the treatment of pediatric intractable epilepsy. The authors review the latest advancements in the presurgical workup as well as the mandatory tests needed to explore the epilepsy workup in these children. They describe the different types of epilepsy from a surgical standpoint (temporal, extratemporal, multifocal, and hemispheric epilepsies) and various surgical procedures that can be proposed depending on the clinical scenario: lesionectomies, lobectomies, hemispherectomies, neuromodulation, and palliative surgeries. They also describe the key differences of the pediatric patient as compared with the adult patient in such pathologic conditions.