Seasonal changes in GPP/SIF ratios and their climatic determinants across the Northern Hemisphere

Disentangling the impact of climate change, human activities, vegetation dynamics and atmospheric CO2 concentration on soil water use efficiency in global karst landscapes

Soil Water Use Efficiency (SWUE), which quantifies the carbon gain against each unit of soil moisture depletion, represents an essential ecological parameter that delineates the carbon-water coupling within terrestrial ecosystems. However, the spatiotemporal dynamics of SWUE, its sensitivity to environmental variables, and the underlying driving mechanisms across various temporal scales in the global karst region are largely uncharted. This study utilized the sensitivity algorithm of partial least squares regression, partial differential equations, and elasticity coefficients to investigate the characteristics of SWUE variations across different climatic zones in the global karst region and their responsiveness to environmental variables. Moreover, the study quantified the individual contributions of climate variability, atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration, human activities, and vegetation changes to SWUE variations. The results indicated that SWUE across different climatic zones in the global karst region demonstrated an increasing trend from 2000 to 2018, with the most notable improvement observed in the humid zone. SWUE presented regular distribution and variation characteristics across different latitudinal zones at a monthly scale. The sensitivity of SWUE to precipitation was significantly higher compared to its responsiveness to other environmental factors. Additionally, the trend in SWUE's sensitivity to precipitation demonstrated the most significant change. The sensitivity of SWUE to various environmental factors and the trend of this sensitivity in the arid zone revealed significant variation compared to other climatic zones. Gross primary productivity and soil moisture were identified as the intrinsic factors influencing SWUE changes, contributing 16 % and - 84 %, respectively. Climate variability and human activities were identified as the primary exogenous factors contributing to the increase in SWUE, accounting for 76 % and 16 %, respectively. This study advances the understanding of carbon-water coupling in karst regions, providing significant insights into the ecological management of global karst environments amidst climate variations.

Methodological advancement in deriving primary productivity and ecosystem respiration fluxes across different biomes

In this paper, we introduce a methodology that can improve the estimations of Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and ecosystem Respiration (Reco) processes at a regional scale. This method is based on a satellite data-driven approach which is suitable for regions like India where there exists a serious shortage of ground-based observations of biospheric carbon fluxes (e.g., Eddy Covariance (EC) flux measurements). We relied on the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) reflectance for capturing vegetation dynamics in the Light-Use Efficiency (LUE)-based vegetation model. Further, we utilised recently available satellite-based Solar-Induced Fluorescence (SIF) and other variables such as Soil Moisture (SM) and Soil Temperature (ST) to refine the predictions of GPP and Reco. The methodology involves establishing a relationship between SIF and GPP for different vegetation classes over India. The SIF-GPP relationship established across the biomes was then used to correct the GPP fluxes simulated by the LUE-based model. Similarly, the ecosystem respiration estimations by the model have undergone refinement by incorporating ST and SM information. This innovative method shows remarkable potential to improve biospheric CO2 uptake and release, especially for in situ data-constrained regions like India. • SIF-based information is introduced to a light-use efficiency-based vegetation model. • SIF-GPP relationship is established for major biomes across India. • SM and ST information is incorporated into the Reco simulations in the model.

The success of ecological engineering projects on vegetation restoration in China strongly depends on climatic conditions

China has implemented extensive ecological engineering projects (EEPs) during recent decades to restore and enhance ecosystem functioning. However, the effectiveness of these interventions can vary due to factors such as local climate and specific project objectives. Here, we used two independent satellite remote sensing datasets, including the Global Inventory Monitoring and Modeling System (GIMMS) Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and vegetation optical depth from Ku-band (Ku-VOD), to investigate the vegetation trends in two hotspot regions of EEPs characterized by different climate conditions, i.e., the xeric/semi-xeric Loess Plateau and mesic southwest China. We found diverging vegetation greenness/biomass trend shift patterns in these two regions as a result of the combined effects of EEPs and climate variations, as indicated by changes in the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI). In the Loess Plateau, where no significant climate variations were observed, NDVI/Ku-VOD increased continuously after the implementation of key EEPs in 2000. Conversely, southwest China has experienced persistent drying since 2000, and vegetation greenness/biomass showed an increasing trend during the initial stages of ecological engineering implementation but subsequently reversed towards a decline due to the continued dry climatic conditions. We used the residual trend method to separate the influence of EEPs from climate variations on vegetation trends and found a positive effect of the ecological management practices in the Loess Plateau, yet a predominantly negative effect in the southwest China region, which means that projects implemented in southwest China did not lead to a long-term improvement in vegetation growth under the given climate conditions in southwest China. This adverse impact suggests that ecological engineering practices could potentially increase the ecosystem's vulnerability to droughts, owing to the increased transpirational water demands introduced by ecological engineering interventions. Our study highlights the importance of considering the expected occurrence and magnitude of climatic variability when implementing large-scale EEPs.

Negative relationship between photosynthesis and late-stage canopy development and senescence over Tibetan Plateau

Canopy greening, which is associated with significant canopy structure changes, is the most notable signal of ecosystem changes in response to anthropogenic climate change. However, our knowledge of the changing pattern of canopy development and senescence, and its endogenous and climatic drivers is still limited. Here, we used the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to quantify the changes in the speed of canopy development and senescence over the Tibetan Plateau (TP) during 2000-2018, and used a solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence dataset as a proxy for photosynthesis, in combination with climate datasets to decipher the endogenous and climatic drivers of the interannual variation in canopy changes. We found that the canopy development during the early green-up stage (April-May) is accelerating at a rate of 0.45-0.8 × 10^-3  month^-1  year^-1 . However, this accelerating canopy development was largely offset by a decelerating canopy development during June and July (-0.61 to -0.51 × 10^-3  month^-1  year^-1 ), leading to the peak NDVI over the TP increasing at a rate of only one fifth of that in northern temperate regions, and less than one tenth of that in the Arctic and boreal regions. During the green-down period, we observed a significant accelerating canopy senescence during October. Photosynthesis was found to be the dominant driver for canopy changes over the TP. Increasing photosynthesis stimulates canopy development during the early green-up stage. However, slower canopy development and accelerated senescence was found with larger photosynthesis in late growth stages. This negative relationship between photosynthesis and canopy development is probably linked to the source-sink balance of plants and shifts in the allocation regime. These results suggest a sink limitation for plant growth over the TP. The impact of canopy greening on the carbon cycle may be more complicated than the source-oriented paradigm used in current ecosystem models.

From remotely-sensed solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence to ecosystem structure, function, and service: Part II-Harnessing data

Although our observing capabilities of solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) have been growing rapidly, the quality and consistency of SIF datasets are still in an active stage of research and development. As a result, there are considerable inconsistencies among diverse SIF datasets at all scales and the widespread applications of them have led to contradictory findings. The present review is the second of the two companion reviews, and data oriented. It aims to (1) synthesize the variety, scale, and uncertainty of existing SIF datasets, (2) synthesize the diverse applications in the sector of ecology, agriculture, hydrology, climate, and socioeconomics, and (3) clarify how such data inconsistency superimposed with the theoretical complexities laid out in (Sun et al., 2023) may impact process interpretation of various applications and contribute to inconsistent findings. We emphasize that accurate interpretation of the functional relationships between SIF and other ecological indicators is contingent upon complete understanding of SIF data quality and uncertainty. Biases and uncertainties in SIF observations can significantly confound interpretation of their relationships and how such relationships respond to environmental variations. Built upon our syntheses, we summarize existing gaps and uncertainties in current SIF observations. Further, we offer our perspectives on innovations needed to help improve informing ecosystem structure, function, and service under climate change, including enhancing in-situ SIF observing capability especially in "data desert" regions, improving cross-instrument data standardization and network coordination, and advancing applications by fully harnessing theory and data.

A stronger advance of urban spring vegetation phenology narrows vegetation productivity difference between urban settings and natural environments

Climate change is posing dramatic effects on terrestrial vegetation dynamics. The links between vegetation phenology or vegetation activity (growth) and climate change have been widely reported, yet, less is known about the impacts of phenological shifts on vegetation growth. Urban settings characterized by urban heat island and CO₂ dome are often used as ideal natural laboratories to understand how vegetation responds to global climate change. Here we assessed the impacts of phenology changes on vegetation growth in China using satellite phenology metrics and gross primary production (GPP) data from 2003 to 2018 and urban-natural contrast analysis. Compared with natural environments, phenological metrics (e.g., start/end of growing season (SOS/EOS), and the length of growing season (GSL), etc.) were observed to change more dramatically in urban environments. Furthermore, we found that GPP in both settings increased over time but with a higher increment in the urban environments, and the urban-natural vegetation productivity gap had been diminishing at a rate of 16.9 ± 6.76 g C m^-2 y^-1. The narrowing of the urban-natural GPP difference over time can be attributed to a more advanced SOS and extended GSL in urban settings than their natural counterparts, particularly SOS shift. These findings suggested that the distinct urban phenological shifts would become increasingly important in offsetting the loss of vegetation productivity induced by urbanization.

Solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence imperfectly tracks the temperature response of photosynthesis in winter wheat

Solar-induced fluorescence (SIF) is a promising proxy for photosynthesis, but it is unclear whether it performs well in tracking the gross primary productivity (GPP) under different environmental conditions. In this study, we investigated the dynamics of the two parameters from October 2020 to June 2021 in field-grown winter wheat (Triticum aestivum) and found that the ability of SIF to track GPP was weakened at low temperatures. Accounting for the coupling of light and temperature at a seasonal scale, we found that SIF yield showed a lower temperature sensitivity and had a lower but broader optimal temperature range compared with light-use efficiency (LUE), although both SIF yield and LUE decreased in low-temperature conditions. The discrepancy between the temperature responses of SIF yield and GPP caused an increase in the ratio of SIF/GPP in winter, which indicated the variation in the relationship between them during this period. The results of our study highlight the impact of low temperature on the relationship between SIF and GPP and show the necessity of reconsidering the dynamics of energy distribution inside plants under changing environments.

Improved estimation of global gross primary productivity during 1981-2020 using the optimized P model

Accurate estimation of terrestrial gross primary productivity (GPP) is essential for quantifying the net carbon exchange between the atmosphere and biosphere. Light use efficiency (LUE) models are widely used to estimate GPP at different spatial scales. However, difficulties in proper determination of maximum LUE (LUE_max) and downregulation of LUE_max into actual LUE result in uncertainties in GPP estimated by LUE models. The recently developed P model, as a LUE-like model, captures the deep mechanism of photosynthesis and simplifies parameterization. Site level studies have proved the outperformance of P model over LUE models. However, the global application of the P model is still lacking. Thus, the effectiveness of 5 water stress factors integrated into the P model was compared. The optimal P model was used to generate a new long-term (1981-2020) global monthly GPP dataset at a spatial resolution of 0.1° × 0.1°, called PGPP. Validation at globally distributed 109 FLUXNET sites indicated that PGPP is better than three widely-used GPP products. R² between PGPP and observed GPP equals to 0.75, the corresponding root mean squared error (RMSE) and mean absolute error (MAE) equal to 1.77 g C m^-2 d^-1 and 1.28 g C m^-2 d^-1. During the period from 1981 to 2020, PGPP significantly increased in 69.02% of global vegetated regions (p < 0.05). Overall, PGPP provides a new GPP product choice for global ecology studies and the comparison of various water stress factors provides a new idea for the improvement of GPP model in the future.

Effects of Low Temperature on the Relationship between Solar-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence and Gross Primary Productivity across Different Plant Function Types

Solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) has been recognized as a proxy of gross primary production (GPP) across various terrestrial biomes. However, the effects of low temperature on SIF and GPP among different plant function types (PFTs) have not yet been well-explored. To gain a better understanding of the relationship between SIF and GPP, we investigated the variation in the GPP/SIF ratio in response to low-temperature conditions using satellite and tower-based datasets. Based on the TROPOMI SIF product and FLUXCOM GPP data, we found that the SIF and GPP exhibited consistent seasonal and spatial patterns, while the GPP/SIF ratio differed for different PFTs. The GPP/SIF ratio for forest types was generally higher than 10 gC·d−1·mw−1·nm·sr, whereas the GPP/SIF ratio for grass and crop types was generally lower than 10 gC·d−1·mw−1·nm·sr. In addition, there were noticeable differences in the seasonal pattern of the GPP/SIF ratio between the selected samples that experienced low-temperature stress (below 10 °C, defined as group A) and those that grew under relatively warm conditions (above 10 °C throughout the year, defined as group B). The GPP/SIF ratio for group A generally exhibited a “hump-shaped” seasonal pattern, and that for group B showed a slightly “bowl-shaped” seasonal pattern, which means it is important to consider the effects of temperature on the SIF-GPP relationship. Through linear regression and correlation analysis, we demonstrate that there was a positive correlation between the GPP/SIF ratio and temperature for group A, with a wide temperature range including low-temperature conditions, indicating that, in this case, temperature affected the SIF–GPP relationship; however, for group B—with a temperature higher than 10 °C throughout the year—the GPP/SIF ratio was not consistently affected by temperature. The response of GPP/SIF to low temperature stress was confirmed by tower-based observations at a C3 cropland (C3CRO) site and a boreal evergreen needleleaf forest (BoENF) site. Although the relationship between the GPP/SIF ratio and temperature differed among PFTs, the GPP/SIF ratio decreased under low-temperature conditions for PFTs. Therefore, the GPP/SIF ratio was not constant and was largely influenced by low temperature for different PFTs, thus highlighting the importance of incorporating temperature into SIF-based GPP estimation.

Investigating the Performance of Red and Far-Red SIF for Monitoring GPP of Alpine Meadow Ecosystems

Alpine meadow ecosystems are extremely vulnerable to climate change and serve an essential function in terrestrial carbon sinks. Accurately estimating their gross primary productivity (GPP) is essential for understanding the global carbon cycle. Solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF), as a companion product directly related to plant photosynthesis process, has become an attractive pathway for estimating GPP accurately. To date, the quantitative SIF-GPP relationship in terrestrial ecosystems is not yet clear. Especially, red SIF and far-red SIF present differences in their ability to track GPP under different environmental conditions. In this study, we investigated the performance of SIF at both red and far-red band in monitoring the GPP of an alpine meadow ecosystem based on continuous tower-based observations in 2019 and 2020. The results show that the canopy red SIF (SIFRed) and far-red SIF (SIFFar-red) were both strongly correlated with GPP. SIFRed was comparable to SIFFar-red for monitoring GPP based on comparisons of both half-hourly averaged and daily averaged datasets. Moreover, the relationship between SIFRed and GPP was linearly correlated, while the relationship between SIFFar-red and GPP tended to be nonlinear. At a diurnal scale, dramatic changes in photosynthetically active radiation (PAR), air temperature (Ta), and vapor pressure deficit (VPD) all had effects on the slope of the linear fitted line with zero intercept for SIFRed-GPP and SIFFar-red-GPP, and the effect on the slope of the linear fitted line with zero intercept for SIFFar-red-GPP was obviously stronger than that for SIFRed-GPP. PAR was the dominant factor among the three environmental factors in determining the diurnal variation of the slope of SIF-GPP. At a seasonal scale, the SIFFar-red/GPP was susceptible to PAR, Ta, and VPD, while the SIFRed/GPP remained relatively stable at different levels of Ta and VPD, and it was only weakly affected by PAR, suggesting that SIFRed was more consistent than SIFFar-red with GPP in response to seasonal variations in environmental factors. These results indicate that SIFRed has more potential than SIFFar-red for monitoring the GPP of alpine meadow ecosystems and can also assist researchers in gaining a more comprehensive understanding of the diversity of SIF-GPP relationships in different ecosystems.