Flow cytometry in the differential diagnosis of myelodysplastic neoplasm with low blasts and cytopenia of other causes

Background

Myelodysplastic neoplasms (MDS) are characterized by cytopenia, morphologic dysplasia, and genetic abnormalities. Multiparameter flow cytometry (FCM) is recommended in the diagnostic work-up of suspected MDS, but alone is not sufficient to establish the diagnosis. Our aim was to investigate the diagnostic power of FCM in a heterogeneous population of patients with cytopenia, excluding cases with increased blast count.

Methods

We analyzed bone marrow samples from 179 patients with cytopenia (58 MDS, 121 non-MDS) using a standardized 8-color FCM method. We evaluated the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of several simple diagnostic approaches, including Ogata score, extended Ogata score, the WHO and ELN iMDSFlow recommended "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method," and the combination of the Ogata score and "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method." The patients were followed until the diagnosis was confirmed, with a median follow-up of 2 months (range 0.2-27).

Results

The combination of Ogata score and "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method" achieved the highest diagnostic accuracy (78%) with sensitivity and specificity 61% and 86%, respectively. When using only the "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method," the accuracy was 77% with a sensitivity of 72% and a specificity of 79%. The most frequently observed etiologies among the false positive cases were substrate deficiencies, inflammation/infection, or toxic effects. MDS can be excluded in all these cases after a thorough clinical evaluation and a relatively short follow-up.

Conclusion

FCM remains an important but supplementary part in an integrated diagnostic process of MDS with low blasts. The combination of the Ogata score and the "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method" slightly improves accuracy compared to the detection of "3 aberrations in two cell compartments method" alone.

Reliability of flow-cytometry in diagnosis and prognostic stratification of myelodysplastic syndromes: correlations with morphology and mutational profile

Diagnosis and prognostic stratification of myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) have been complemented by new techniques, including flow cytometry and NGS. To analyze the relationship between molecular and cytofluorimetric data, we enrolled in this retrospective study, 145 patients, including 106 diagnosed with MDS and 39 controls. At disease onset, immunophenotypic (IF), cytogenetic tests, and cytomorphological (CM) examination on bone marrow were carried out in all patients, while NGS was performed in 58 cases. Ogata score presented a specificity of 100% and a sensitivity of 59%. The detection of at least two phenotypic aberrancies in Ogata negative patients increased the sensitivity to 83% and specificity to 87%. Correlations were identified between IF aberrancies and mutations, including positive Ogata>2 and mutations in SRSF2 (p=0.035), CD15 and U2AF1 (0.032), CD56 and DNMT3A (p=0.042), and CD38 and TP53 (p=0.026). In multivariate analysis, U2AF1 mutations, associated with del(20q) and/or abnormalities of chromosome 7 (group 4 as defined by the EuroMDS score), significantly correlated with an inferior overall survival (p=0.019). These parameters and Ogata score>2 also showed a significant correlation with inferior event-free survival (p=0.023 and p=0.041, respectively). Both CM and FC features correlated with prognosis and mutational patterns. In an integrated MDS work-up, these tools may guide indications for mutational screening for optimal risk stratification.

Multiparameter flow cytometry in the evaluation of myelodysplasia: Analytical issues: Recommendations from the European LeukemiaNet/International Myelodysplastic Syndrome Flow Cytometry Working Group

Multiparameter flow cytometry (MFC) is one of the essential ancillary methods in bone marrow (BM) investigation of patients with cytopenia and suspected myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS). MFC can also be applied in the follow-up of MDS patients undergoing treatment. This document summarizes recommendations from the International/European Leukemia Net Working Group for Flow Cytometry in Myelodysplastic Syndromes (ELN iMDS Flow) on the analytical issues in MFC for the diagnostic work-up of MDS. Recommendations for the analysis of several BM cell subsets such as myeloid precursors, maturing granulocytic and monocytic components and erythropoiesis are given. A core set of 17 markers identified as independently related to a cytomorphologic diagnosis of myelodysplasia is suggested as mandatory for MFC evaluation of BM in a patient with cytopenia. A myeloid precursor cell (CD34⁺ CD19^- ) count >3% should be considered immunophenotypically indicative of myelodysplasia. However, MFC results should always be evaluated as part of an integrated hematopathology work-up. Looking forward, several machine-learning-based analytical tools of interest should be applied in parallel to conventional analytical methods to investigate their usefulness in integrated diagnostics, risk stratification, and potentially even in the evaluation of response to therapy, based on MFC data. In addition, compiling large uniform datasets is desirable, as most of the machine-learning-based methods tend to perform better with larger numbers of investigated samples, especially in such a heterogeneous disease as MDS.

Comparison of flow cytometry with other modalities in the diagnosis of myelodysplastic syndrome

INTRODUCTION

The myelodysplastic syndromes (MDSs) are heterogeneous myeloid malignancies, conventionally diagnosed by cytomorphology and cytogenetics, with an emerging role for flow cytometry. This study compared the performance of a 4-parameter flow cytometry scoring system, the Ogata Score, with other modalities in the diagnosis of MDS.

METHODS

Bone marrow aspirate and trephine biopsies from 238 patients performed to assess for possible MDS were analysed, and the flow cytometry score was retrospectively applied. The sensitivity and specificity of the flow cytometry score, the aspirate microscopy, the trephine microscopy with immunohistochemistry, and cytogenetic and molecular results were determined relative to the final diagnosis.

RESULTS

The medical records of the 238 patients were reviewed to determine the final clinical diagnosis made at the time of the bone marrow examination. This final diagnosis of MDS, possible MDS or not MDS, was based on clinical features and laboratory tests, including all parameters of the bone marrow investigation, except for the flow cytometry score, which was only determined for this study. The flow cytometry score was 67.4% sensitive and 93.8% specific. Aspirate microscopy had higher sensitivity (83.7%) and similar specificity (92.0%), whereas trephine microscopy had similar sensitivity (66.3%) and specificity (89.4%) to flow cytometry. Although the flow cytometry score had a lower sensitivity than aspirate microscopy, in 18 patients (7.6% of the total) the flow cytometry score was positive for MDS, whereas aspirate microscopy was negative or inconclusive.

CONCLUSION

The flow cytometry score and trephine microscopy exhibited reasonable sensitivity and high specificity, and complement aspirate microscopy in the assessment of MDS.

The utility of a single tube 10-color flow cytometry for quantitative and qualitative analysis in myelodysplastic syndrome- a pilot study

INTRODUCTION

Assessment of myelodysplasia (MDS) by flow cytometry (FCM) includes elaborate panels, and interpretation is observer-dependent. This study evaluates single tube 10-color FCM in a test cohort of clinically suspected MDS patients.

METHODS

We analyzed fifty-six bone marrow (BM) samples from clinically suspected MDS patients in a morphology-blinded manner along with controls using a 10-color single tube flow cytometry. We analyzed the reproducibility of Ogata score and modified FCM scores, additionally incorporating the proportion of CD15, CD11b, CD56, and CD38MFI on CD34+CD19-cluster for each patient. Patients were grouped as proven-MDS, suspected-MDS, and non-MDS groups based on morphology and cytogenetics. Optimized multi-axial radar-plots were also used to analyze maturation patterns in the granulocytic, monocytic, and blast progenitor compartments of proven-MDS cases and controls.

RESULTS

Flow cytometric abnormalities ≥3 were present in proven-MDS (n = 23) with a sensitivity and specificity of 78 % and 94 %, respectively, as per Ogata score. The addition of CD38 MFI to the score yielded sensitivity and specificity of 82 % and 88 %, respectively. Additional analysis of aberrant expression of CD15, CD11b, and CD56 increased the diagnostic power of the FCM score. A qualitative analysis of data also showed differences in maturation patterns in proven-MDS compared to the control group.

CONCLUSION

Single tube 10-color FCM scoring, including Ogata score, modified-FCM scores, and radar plots pattern analysis, showed significant abnormalities in proven-MDS cases in this pilot study. Large databases, including FCM-scoring and pattern-based analysis for normal BM maturation, could be further validated and standardized for screening MDS.

The diagnostic and prognostic significance of flow cytometric bone marrow assessment in myelodysplastic syndromes according to the European LeukemiaNet recommendations in single-centre real-life experience

INTRODUCTION

This analysis attempts to determine the diagnostic and prognostic value of bone marrow (BM) evaluation by multiparameter flow cytometry in patients with myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study group consisted of patients who underwent diagnostic process in the years 2008-2017 due to cytopenia and finally were diagnosed with MDS (n = 71). The comparative group included patients with cytopenia diagnosed in the same period, whose definitive diagnosis was other than MDS (n = 39). Flow cytometric evaluation of BM was performed following the recommendations of the European LeukemiaNet (ELN) in all patients.

RESULTS

The median number of immunophenotypic abnormalities found on granulocytes in the MDS group was significantly higher compared to the comparative group [2 (range 0-5) vs 0 (range 0-2); P < .0001]. Similarly, the median Ogata score was significantly higher in the MDS group [2 (range 0-4) vs 1 (range 0-3); P < .0001]. Since the disturbances of the CD11b/HLA-DR and CD11b/CD13 on granulocytes were significantly more common in MDS patients, the Ogata score was extended by these abnormalities, what resulted in its higher diagnostic sensitivity (82%) while preserving high specificity (87%). The positive correlation was found between risk score determined by the Revised International Prognostic Scoring System and the number of the BM immunophenotypic abnormalities (P = .017).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that the diagnostic usefulness of the Ogata score may be increased by including the abnormal expression of CD11b/HLA-DR and CD11b/CD13 on granulocytes. Moreover, our findings suggest the prognostic significance of the number of BM cytometric abnormalities in MDS.

The impact of delayed sample handling and type of anticoagulant on the interpretation of dysplastic signs detected by flow cytometry

Introduction

A growing body of evidence supports the usefulness of dysplastic signs detected by flow cytometry in the diagnosis of myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS). Our aim was to assess the impact of pre-analytical variables (delayed sample handling, type of anticoagulant, and different clones of antibody) in the interpretation of flow cytometric results.

Material and methods

Bone marrow samples were labelled and analysed immediately after aspiration and on two consecutive days. The effect of anticoagulant type was evaluated in 16 bone marrow samples. Thirty-seven different immunophenotypic variables were recorded after eight-colour staining. Furthermore, 8 normal peripheral blood samples collected in K₃-EDTA and Na-heparin were examined with different clones of CD11b antibodies and four parameters were recorded with both anticoagulants on two consecutive days.

Results

Fourteen significant differences were detected in the initial immunophenotype of fresh samples collected in K₃-EDTA and Na-heparin. Regardless of the anticoagulant type, eleven parameters remained stable despite delayed sample handling. Due to delayed sample processing, more alterations were detected in the samples collected in K₃-EDTA than in the samples collected in Na-heparin. The type of CD11b clone influenced the reduction of fluorescence intensity only in samples collected in K₃-EDTA, where the alterations were contrary to the changes observed in Na-heparin.

Conclusions

Delayed sample processing causes considerable immunohenotypic alterations, which can lead to false interpretation of the results. If delayed sample evaluation is unavoidable, markers that remain more stable over time should be considered with more weight in the diagnosis of MDS.