A dose-ranging study of ranitidine and its effect on intragastric and intra-oesophageal acidity in subjects with gastro-oesophageal reflux disease

The role and limitations of H2-receptor antagonists in the treatment of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease

Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GERD) occurs in up to 44% of adults in the USA. Most individuals do not seek medical help, self-medicating with antacids. Manifestations of GERD range from symptoms without oesophagitis, which constitute the bulk of patients who self-medicate, to active oesophagitis and then to complications such as stricture and ulceration. It is the more severe cases who tend to come to the gastroenterologist, but it must be remembered that reflux symptoms are probably around 5-10 times more common than actual oesophagitis. Since acid in the refluxate is responsible for the bulk of the symptoms and mucosal damage, antacids are often used for quick relief--which of course may not be sustained. More prolonged suppression of acid secretion, such as by a histamine H2-receptor antagonist (H2RA) or a proton pump inhibitor (PPI), is required to give long-lasting symptomatic relief and heal any inflammatory change. H2-receptor antagonists inhibit acid secretion with an effect that lasts for 4-8 h with a single dose, decreasing stimulated acid secretion by around 70%. When treating oesophagitis, the H2RAs suffer from the disadvantage of their relatively short duration of action (compared with PPIs), development of tolerance, and incomplete inhibition of acid secretion in response to a meal. Therefore, it is not easy for the H2RAs to achieve optimum conditions for healing the more severe forms of oesophagitis--even very high doses may fail. In mild GERD the H2RAs have been shown to be effective in relieving symptoms.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Standard-dose lansoprazole is more effective than high-dose ranitidine in achieving endoscopic healing and symptom relief in patients with moderately severe reflux oesophagitis. The Dutch Lansoprazole Study Group

BACKGROUND

In the treatment of reflux oesophagitis, H2-receptor antagonists are still widely used in spite of the apparent higher efficacy of proton pump inhibitors. In an attempt to compensate for the lower efficacy, H2-receptor antagonists are now increasingly being used at a higher dose.

OBJECTIVE

To assess whether or not standard-dose lansoprazole (30 mg o.d.) is more effective than high-dose ranitidine (300 mg b.d.) in moderately severe reflux oesophagitis (grades II-III).

METHODS

Lansoprazole or ranitidine was given to 133 patients for 4-8 weeks in a double-blind, randomized, parallel group, multicentre trial.

RESULTS

The percentage of patients with endoscopically-verified healing was significantly higher on lansoprazole than on ranitidine both after 4 weeks (79% vs. 42%) and 8 weeks (91% vs. 66%), though smoking had a negative impact on oesophagitis healing with lansoprazole. Heartburn, retrosternal pain and belching improved significantly better with lansoprazole than with ranitidine, as did the patient-rated overall symptom severity. Relief of heartburn appeared somewhat faster with ranitidine, but was more pronounced with lansoprazole. The number of patients with adverse events was similar in both treatment groups.

CONCLUSION

Standard-dose lansoprazole is better than high-dose ranitidine in moderately severe reflux oesophagitis.

High- versus standard-dose ranitidine for control of heartburn in poorly responsive acid reflux disease: a prospective, controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

H2-receptor antagonists are commonly used as initial therapy in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and are frequently continued at the same or higher doses when symptoms persist after 4-6 wk of therapy. Our objective was to compare the efficacy of twice-daily treatment with either ranitidine 150 mg b.i.d. or 300 mg b.i.d. in resolving heartburn in GERD patients who remained symptomatic after 6 wk of therapy with ranitidine 150 mg b.i.d.

METHODS

This was a two-phase, prospective study. In the first phase, GERD patients with heartburn on > or = 4 of the 7 days before entry were treated with open-label ranitidine 150 mg b.i.d. for 6 wk. In the second phase, patients who were still symptomatic were randomized to 8 wk of double-blind ranitidine therapy at either the same (150 mg b.i.d.) or a higher dose (300 mg b.i.d.). The primary efficacy variable was the resolution of heartburn at wk 4 and 8, as monitored through diary cards.

RESULTS

Of the 481 patients treated for 6 wk in phase I, 285 (59%) were still symptomatic; 271 patients (95% of those still symptomatic) were randomized to double-blind treatment with ranitidine. In phase II, 45% of the patients in each treatment group experienced no more than mild heartburn; complete heartburn resolution was observed in <20% of patients in either group at wk 4 and 8. There were no significant differences in efficacy between the two treatment groups.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that the majority of GERD patients still have symptoms of heartburn after 6 wk of ranitidine therapy. Only a minority of these patients experience complete relief of heartburn after an additional 8 wk of treatment, which demonstrates that doubling the dose of ranitidine is not efficacious.

[Therapeutic principles in gastroesophageal reflux]

Gastroesophageal reflux is a common disease. Its chronic course, even if mild, is sometimes complicated by erosive oesophagitis. Drug therapy acts against gastric acidity and motility disorders. Treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease has three aims: improvement of symptoms and quality of life, healing erosive lesions and prevention of symptomatic and endoscopic relapses. Non-drug measures are always useful, even if their efficacy is not well established. Initial therapy of a symptomatic reflux or mild oesophagitis is most of the time effective (antacids, prokinetics, H2 receptor antagonists). Proton-pump inhibitors are also effective in healing and preventing severe oesophagitis. Questions about long-term treatment adverse events with powerful acid inhibitors, such as hypergastrinemia and the risk of gastric carcinoid tumours seem to be resolved. Studies are requested to define the optimal long-term maintenance treatment with cisapride, H2 receptor antagonists or proton-pump inhibitors at low doses in prevention of symptomatic and mild oesophagitis relapses.