The effectiveness of local child weight management programmes: an audit study

Exploring the evidence base for Tier 3 specialist weight management interventions for children aged 2-18 years in the UK: a rapid systematic review

Background

The impact of specialist weight management services (Tier 3) for children with severe and complex obesity in the UK is unclear. This review aims to examine the impact of child Tier 3 services in the UK, exploring service characteristics and implications for practice.

Methods

Rapid systematic review of any study examining specialist weight management interventions in any UK setting including children (2-18 years) with a body mass index >99.6th centile or >98th centile with comorbidity.

Results

Twelve studies (five RCTs and seven uncontrolled) were included in a variety of settings. Study quality was moderate or low and mean baseline body mass index z-score ranged from 2.7 to 3.6 units. Study samples were small and children were predominantly older (10-14 years), female and white. Multidisciplinary team composition and eligibility criteria varied; dropout ranged from 5 to 43%. Improvements in zBMI over 1-24 months ranged from -0.13 to -0.41 units.

Conclusions

Specialist weight management interventions for children with severe obesity demonstrated a reduction in zBMI, across a variety of UK settings. Studies were heterogeneous in content and thus conclusions on service design cannot be drawn. There is a paucity of evidence for Tier 3 services for children, and further research is required.

Psychosocial Interventions in the Treatment of Severe Adolescent Obesity: The SHINE Program

PURPOSE

Psychosocial interventions (PSIs) are characterized by three phases: (1) an initial in-depth assessment, (2) an intensive multifaceted intervention to stem a condition, and (3) an extensive maintenance program. PSIs are often used for treatment of mental health conditions; however, applicability in the treatment of adolescent obesity is unknown. This article sought to evaluate the service-level outcomes of a PSI for young people (aged 10-17) with severe obesity.

METHODS

A retrospective evaluation of participants attending the Self Help, Independence, Nutrition and Exercise program between 2011 and 2016 (n = 435; age: 13.1 ± 2.1 years, male: 51%, white: 87.4%, body mass index [BMI]: 33.5 ± 7.5 kg/m², standardized BMI [BMI SDS]: 3.1 ± .5 units). Anthropometric measurements (BMI and waist circumference) were collected at baseline, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. Psychosocial measures (anxiety, depression, and self-esteem) were collected at baseline and 3 months. Participant retention was also assessed.

RESULTS

After 3 months, 95% of participants remained with a mean BMI SDS reduction of .19 units (95% confidence interval: .17, .21). Anxiety, depression, and self-esteem improved by 50%, 54%, and 38%, respectively. BMI SDS reductions of .29, .35, and .41 units were found at 6, 9, and 12 months. Fifty-four percent of participants chose to attend the final intervention phase. A higher baseline BMI SDS and a greater reduction in BMI SDS predicted final intervention phase attendance.

CONCLUSIONS

The Self Help, Independence, Nutrition and Exercise PSI demonstrated positive mean reductions in all measurements across all time points. In contrast to other community-based weight management services, these results suggest the utility of, and further exploration of, PSIs in the treatment of severe adolescent obesity.

Service evaluation of the GOALS family-based childhood obesity treatment intervention during the first 3 years of implementation

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the impact of the GOALS (Getting Our Active Lifestyles Started) family-based childhood obesity treatment intervention during the first 3 years of implementation.

DESIGN

Single-group repeated measures with qualitative questionnaires.

SETTING

Community venues in a socioeconomically deprived, urban location in the North-West of England.

PARTICIPANTS

70 overweight or obese children (mean age 10.5 years, 46% boys) and their parents/carers who completed GOALS between September 2006 and March 2009.

INTERVENTIONS

GOALS was a childhood obesity treatment intervention that drew on social cognitive theory to promote whole family lifestyle change. Sessions covered physical activity (PA), diet and behaviour change over 18 2 h weekly group sessions (lasting approximately 6 months). A Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist of intervention components is provided.

PRIMARY AND SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome measure was child body mass index (BMI) z-score, collected at baseline, post-intervention and 12 months. Secondary outcome measures were child self-perceptions, parent/carer BMI and qualitative changes in family diet and PA (parent/carer questionnaire).

RESULTS

Child BMI z-score reduced by 0.07 from baseline to post-intervention (p<0.001) and was maintained at 12 months (p<0.05). There was no change in parent/carer BMI or child self-perceptions, other than an increase in perceived social acceptance from baseline to post-intervention (p<0.05). Parents/carers reported positive changes to family PA and dietary behaviours after completing GOALS.

CONCLUSIONS

GOALS completion was associated with small improvements in child BMI z-score and improved family PA and dietary behaviours. Several intervention modifications were necessary during the implementation period and it is suggested childhood obesity treatment interventions need time to embed before a definitive evaluation is conducted. Researchers are urged to use the TIDieR checklist to ensure transparent reporting of interventions and facilitate the translation of evidence to practice.