The role of synovectomy in the management of a target joint

Diagnosis and treatment of chronic synovitis in patients with haemophilia: consensus statements from the Italian Association of Haemophilia Centres

Although synovitis is recognized as a marker of joint disease activity, its periodic assessment is not included in routine clinical surveillance of patients with haemophilia (PwH). In order to evaluate the current knowledge and to identify controversial issues, a preliminary literature search by the Musculoskeletal Committee of the Italian Association of Haemophilia Centres (AICE) has been conducted. Statements have been established and sent to the Italian AICE members to collect their level of agreement or disagreement by a Delphi process. Thirty‐seven consensus recommendations have been drafted. We found a general agreement on the indication to consider the presence of synovitis as a marker of joint disease activity in PwH. Accordingly, there was agreement on the indication to search for synovitis both in patients reporting joint pain and in asymptomatic ones, recognizing ultrasound as the most practical imaging technique to perform periodic joint screening. Interestingly, after detection of synovitis, there was agreement on the indication to modify the therapeutic approach, suggesting prophylaxis in patients treated on demand and tailoring treatment in patients already under prophylaxis. Whereas the need of an early consultation with a physiotherapist is recommended for PwH affected by chronic synovitis, the exact timing for an orthopaedic surgeon consultation is currently unknown.

Outpatient treatment for haemophilic arthropathy with radiosynovectomy: Radiation dose to family members

One of the key features of good practice in medicine is the doctor-patient communication. Radiation protection standards for radiosynovectomy (RS) is limited. Yttrium-90 is a beta-emitting radioisotope used in RS to treat joint pain from haemophilic arthritis. ICRP 94 states that if a patient is treated with up to 200 MBq, there is no need for further precautions when it comes to public exposure, however, activities can go up to 370 MBq in RS for the knee. This study analysed 119 family members' safety (16.7% pregnant women). The ambient dose equivalent rate was measured within four distances. A survey was carried analysing risk groups and time spent next to patients. Results showed that family members should be advised to remain at 1.0 m from the patient to decrease accumulated dose by 97.6%. The dose per activity factors estimated in this study is also a useful tool during the risk assessment and doctor/patient communication. Pamphlets were distributed with radiation protection recommendations. Ambient dose equivalent was low enough to show that RS is a safe procedure for family members, which is essential to promote adherence to RS in countries where it is needed but not performed due to lack of information on radiation safety.

Risk factors associated with invasive orthopaedic interventions in males with haemophilia enrolled in the Universal Data Collection program from 2000 to 2010

BACKGROUND

Invasive orthopaedic interventions (IOI) are often used to control recurrent haemarthrosis, pain and loss of joint function, in males with haemophilia (Factor VIII and Factor IX deficiency).

AIM

Identify risk factors associated with IOIs in males with haemophilia enrolled in the Universal Data Collection (UDC) surveillance program from 2000 until 2010.

METHODS

Data were collected on IOIs performed on patients receiving care in 130 haemophilia treatment centers in the United States annually by health care providers using standardized forms. IOIs included in this study are as follows: 1) synovectomy and 2) arthrodesis or arthroplasty (A/A). Information about potential risk factors was obtained from the preceding UDC visit if available, or from the same visit if not. Patients with no reported IOI at any of their UDC visits were the reference group for the analysis. Multivariate analyses were conducted to identify independent risk factors for synovectomies and arthrodesis/arthroplasty.

RESULTS

Risk factors significantly associated with the two IOI categories were age, student status, haemophilia severity, number of joint bleeds within the last 6 months, HIV or hepatitis C (HCV) status. Multivariate analyses showed patients on continuous prophylaxis were 50% less likely to have had a synovectomy and were 40% less likely to have an A/A.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows modifiable risk factors, including management of bleeding episodes with a continuous prophylactic treatment schedule are associated with a decreased likelihood of IOIs in males with haemophilia.

Clinical and Radiological Evaluation After Chemical Synovectomy With Rifampicin in Hemophilic Arthropathy: Korean Experience With a 2-Week Interval Protocol

Objective

To assess the clinical outcome of chemical synovectomy with rifampicin in hemophilic arthropathy by using the World Federation of Hemophilia (WFH) scoring system and plain radiograph.

Methods

We performed rifampicin synovectomy (RS) on 30 joints of 28 hemophilic patients diagnosed as hemophilic arthropathy stage I–III (based on Fernandez-Palazzi clinical classification). Clinical status (bleeding frequency, pain, joint physical status) and radiological staging were evaluated as parts of the WFH scoring system before and 1 year after RS. The patients were divided into two groups by the Arnold-Hilgartner scale of the initial X-ray as stage 3 or less for the low-stage group (n=17) and over 3 for the high-stage group (n=13).

Results

Total WFH joint physical scores were reduced after injection, and the number of bleeding episodes and pain showed especially significant improvement. For other subscores of the WFH joint physical score, only swelling, range of motion, and crepitus showed statistically significant improvement. According to the severity of the radiologic finding, the WFH joint physical score of both the low-stage and high-stage groups showed significant improvement. In the radiological aspect, the low-stage group, without joint space narrowing at the initial plain radiograph, showed no further aggravation after injection. However, in the high-stage group, radiology found aggravation regardless of the procedure.

Conclusion

It is suggested that chemical synovectomy with rifampicin may prevent hemarthrosis and improve clinical symptoms. Especially in the early stage of arthropathy without joint-space narrowing, it seems to have an additional benefit that delays radiological aggravation and preserves joint status.

Radiosynovectomy in haemophilic synovitis of elbows and ankles: Is the effectiveness of yttrium-90 and rhenium-186 different?

BACKGROUND

Radiosynovectomy (RS) reduces the number of haemarthroses and the synovial size in chronic haemophilic synovitis. The purpose of this study was to quantitatively compare the effectiveness of two types of RS (yttrium-90 vs. rhenium-186) in terms of the objective improvement of haemarthroses and synovial size.

METHODS

Seventy RSs were performed in 70 joints (44 elbows, 26 ankles) of 70 haemophiliacs diagnosed with chronic synovitis. Yttrium-90 was used in 21 joints and rhenium-186 was used in 49 joints. The mean patient age was 20.61 years.

RESULTS

RS resulted in significant improvement in the three variables studied (six months before RS vs. six months after RS), namely in the number of episodes of haemarthrosis (67.8% improvement); the size of the synovium as measured by means of a clinical scale (43.8% improvement) and imaging techniques in millimetres (26.7% improvement). We did not find significant statistical differences between yttrium-90 and rhenium-186 regarding their efficacy. No correlation was found between the results and other variables: age, joint (ankle or elbow), presence or absence of radiological involvement, type of haemophilia (A or B), grade of haemophilia (mild, moderate or severe), previous haematological treatment (on demand or prophylaxis), and the presence or absence of inhibitor

CONCLUSIONS

Yttrium-90 RS and rhenium-186 RS were equally effective in reducing the number of haemarthroses and the size of the synovium in ankles and elbows in the short-term (6 months). No correlation was found between the results and other patients' characteristics.

Safety of radiation exposure after radiosynovectomy in paediatric patients with haemophilia

Many paediatric patients with haemophilia who might benefit from radiosynovectomy (RS) for the control of synovitis do not undergo the procedure as there is controversy in the literature regarding the safety of radiation exposure after two cases of acute lymphocytic leukaemia in children with haemophilia treated with (32) P RS were reported. The purpose of this review was to analyse the safety of RS in paediatric patients with haemophilia and provide a risk-benefit assessment, which practitioners could apply to their patients. Children undergoing knee RS receive a radiation dose of approximately 0.74 mSv (90 megabecquerels-MBq) and elbow and ankle RSs a dose of approximately 0.32 mSv (30-40 MBq). The radiation dose from natural sources is approximately 2 mSv and the recommended limit for patients (apart from natural sources) is 1 mSv per year. The lifetime cancer risk increases about 0.5% per 100 mSv per year. Considering the risks and benefits of RS, the authors recommend that clinicians consider this procedure in children with inhibitors or in patients without inhibitors when bleeding is recurrent and persistent despite aggressive factor replacement.

Radiosynovectomy in haemophilia: long-term results of 500 procedures performed in a 38-year period

BACKGROUND

Radiosynovectomy (RS) can reduce the number of haemarthroses in chronic haemophilic synovitis. The purpose of this study was to assess the effectiveness of RS in terms of the objective improvement of five parameters (number haemarthroses, articular pain, degree of clinical synovitis, clinical score of the World Federation of Haemophilia (WFH), and radiological score of the WFH.

METHODS

In a 38-year period (1976-2013), five hundred radiosynovectomies were performed in 443 joints of 345 patients with haemophilia diagnosed with chronic synovitis. The mean patient age was 23.7 years (range, 6-53). The mean follow-up was 18.5 years (range: 6 months-38 years). The RS was carried out with either yttrium-90 or rhenium-186. We performed 1 to 3 injections (RS-1, RS-2, RS-3), with a 6-month interval between them.

RESULTS

RS resulted in significant improvement in all the parameters studied, except in the WFH radiologic score that showed no improvement. On average, the number of haemarthroses decreased by 64.1% and articular pain decreased by 69.4%. The degree of synovitis showed a reduction of 31.3%. The WFH clinical score revealed an improvement of 19%. The WFH radiological score showed no improvement. There were four complications (0.9%) of RS. Twenty-eight (6.3%) joints eventually had to be subjected to arthroscopic synovectomy or total knee replacement (TKR). No cancer was observed in this group of patients during the 38-year period.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiosynovectomy (RS) is an effective, safe, minimally invasive, well tolerated procedure in the long-term for the treatment of chronic haemophilic synovitis. Moreover, it is very easy to perform. The knee required more injections than the elbow or the ankle and more severe synoviums required a higher number of RS procedures.

Consecutive radiosynovectomy procedures at 6-monthly intervals behave independently in haemophilic synovitis

BACKGROUND

Previous studies on the same group of patients investigated here demonstrated the effectiveness of radiosynovectomy in the treatment of chronic haemophilic synovitis even if one, two or three radiosynovectomy procedures (RS-1, RS-2, RS-3) may be necessary. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the joints' response to each radiosynovectomy procedure behaved independently or not.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred and fifty-six radiosynovectomies were performed in 104 joints of 78 people diagnosed with chronic haemophilic synovitis. The patient's mean age was 18 years. Fifty-eight patients required radiosynovectomy in a single joint, whereas 20 received treatment in more than one joint. Of the 104 joints subjected to radiosynovectomy, 33 were elbows, 47 knees and 24 ankles. Radiosynovectomy was carried out with either yttrium-90 or rhenium-186 (1-3 injections with 6-month intervals between them). Of the 104 joints, 68 required a single injection of the radioisotope (RS-1), 20 required two injections (RS-2) and 16 required three injections (RS-3). In eight cases (7.6%), the affected joints eventually required surgery.

RESULTS

An analysis of seven variables (number of bleeding episodes, articular pain, range of motion in flexion and extension, muscle strength in flexion and extension, and synovial thickness by imaging) demonstrated that each consecutive radiosynovectomy behaves independently in haemophilic synovitis.

DISCUSSION

Each consecutive radiosynovectomy behaves independently in haemophilic synovitis. This finding had not been documented in the literature before the present study.

Radioactive synovectomy with (90) yttrium and (153) samarium hydroxyapatite in haemophilic joints: preliminary study on radiation safety

Most countries still do not achieve 1 IU of factor VIII/capita sufficient for survival. Although primary prophylaxis prevents synovitis, is not universally used. Chronic synovitis is treated with arthroscopy at expense of considerable amount of coagulation factors, and specialized surgeons. Radioactive synovectomy (RS) is a minimally invasive and cost effective alternative to arthroscopy, often considered first the option for persistent synovitis. Even without established causation with cancer, RS is avoided by some, due to this concern. We aim contributing to the understanding of RS safety regarding malignancy, presenting a large number of treated patients, and a single case of cancer. Three centres in Brazil applied RS with (90) Yttrium Citrate, (90) Yttrium hydroxyapatite or (153) Samarium hydroxyapatite in haemophilic joints and performed a survey addressing cancer in these patients. Four hundred and eighty eight patients (ages 3-51) received 1-3 RS (total 842) and follow-up was 6 months to 9 years. One patient aged 14 years presented Ewing sarcoma, 11 months after RS. The tumour was treated successfully with surgery and chemotherapy. Causality of cancer by RS is improbable in this case. Accordingly, latency here is far below minimum 5-10 years for radio-induction of solid tumours. Moreover, ES is not a typically radio-induced tumour, even at high doses. In agreement with others, though recognizing limitations, this study suggests RS is safe regarding cancer induction. Synovitis is a known burden for patients. The decision of making reasonable usage of RS should be outweighed with the risks of leaving synovitis untreated.

Haemophilia and joint disease: pathophysiology, evaluation, and management

In patients with haemophilia, regular replacement therapy with clotting factor concentrates (prophylaxis) is effective in preventing recurrent bleeding episodes into joints and muscles. However, despite this success, intra-articular and intramuscular bleeding is still a major clinical manifestation of the disease. Bleeding most commonly occurs in the knees, elbows, and ankles, and is often evident from early childhood. The pathogenesis of haemophilic arthropathy is multifactorial, with changes occurring in the synovium, bone, cartilage, and blood vessels. Recurrent joint bleeding causes synovial proliferation and inflammation (haemophilic synovitis) that contribute to end-stage degeneration (haemophilic arthropathy); with pain and limitation of motion severely affecting patients' quality of life. If joint bleeding is not treated adequately, it tends to recur, resulting in a vicious cycle that must be broken to prevent the development of chronic synovitis and degenerative arthritis. Effective prevention and management of haemophilic arthropathy includes the use of early, aggressive prophylaxis with factor replacement therapies, as well as elective procedures, including restorative physical therapy, analgesia, aspiration, synovectomy, and orthopaedic surgery. Optimal treatment of patients with haemophilia requires a multidisciplinary team comprising a haematologist, physiotherapist, orthopaedic practitioner, rehabilitation physician, occupational therapist, psychologist, social workers, and nurses. Journal of Comorbidity 2011;1:51-59.

Radiosynovectomy in hemophilia: quantification of its effectiveness through the assessment of 10 articular parameters

BACKGROUND

Radiosynovectomy (RS) can reduce the number of hemarthroses in chronic hemophilic synovitis. The purpose of this study was to quantitatively assess the effectiveness of RS in terms of the objective improvement of ten articular parameters.

METHODS

One-hundred and fifty-six radiosynovectomies were performed in 104 joints of 78 hemophiliacs diagnosed with chronic synovitis. The mean patient age was 18 years. The RS was carried out with either yttrium-90 or rhenium-186 (1-3 injections with a 6-month interval between them).

RESULTS

RS resulted in significant improvement in nine of the 10 variables studied, namely in the number of episodes of hemarthrosis, articular pain, range of motion (ROM) in flexion. ROM in extension, muscle strength (MS) in flexion, MS in extension, the degree of synovitis detected on clinical examination, the size of the synovium as measured by means of imaging techniques (in millimeters), the clinical scale developed by the World Federation of Haemophilia (WFH), and the radiologic scale of the WFH. The tenth parameter, the WFH radiologic score, showed no improvement. The other nine parameters studied improved independently for each one of the intra-articular injections of the radioisotope.

CONCLUSIONS

Categorization of the variables with regard to the degree of improvement achieved showed that the number of episodes of hemarthrosis and the severity of pain were the variables associated with the greatest improvement, with a 70% decrease in the amount of bleeding and in the level of pain experienced by the patient. The reduction of articular bleeding after RS was 67.6% when RS-1 was used, 62.1% with RS-2 and 61.2% with RS-3. Synovial hypertrophy as assessed clinically and by imaging techniques also showed a reduction of 30% and 39%, respectively. The WFH clinical scale revealed an improvement of around 19%. MS also improved in flexion and extension (7.9% and 8.2% improvement, respectively). ROM showed a slight but non-significant improvement.

What patient, joint and isotope characteristics influence the response to radiosynovectomy in patients with haemophilia?

The literature describes radiosynovectomy (RS) as a good non-surgical option for reducing synovial membrane size and thus the number of haemarthrosis episodes. However, there are still many aspects concerning the beneficial effects of RS that have not been quantified. A total of 156 radiosynovectomies (RS) were performed in 104 joints corresponding to 78 haemophiliacs (yttrium-90, rhenium-186). The mean patient age was 18 years. In another study involving the same group of patients, the parameters that improved most after RS were pain and haemarthrosis, followed by the World Federation of Hemophilia clinical score, muscle strength and range of movement (ROM). Following RS, improvement was seen to be independent of patient age, haemophilia type and grade, previous haematological treatment, the presence or absence of circulating inhibitor, synovial membrane size, the type of joint (elbow, knee and ankle), previous physical activity or lack of activity, the prior presence or absence of radiographic signs of joint degeneration (arthropathy) or the isotope used. RS is effective in treating haemophilic synovitis and may require 1-3 injections (RS-1, RS-2 and RS-3) spaced 6 months apart. Following RS-1, the knee had a 3.4- and 3.2-fold greater risk of not improving in terms of pain, compared with the elbow and ankle, respectively. Regarding ROM, lesser improvement was recorded after RS-1 in cases of severe haemophilia and the ankle. In other words, severe haemophilia implies a 2.1-fold greater risk of no improvement in ROM compared with mild and moderate haemophilia. In addition, the ankle presented a 6-fold greater risk of not improving in terms of ROM compared with the elbow and knee. RS affords effective treatment of chronic haemophilic synovitis. RS is effective in all patient groups, independently of the presence of circulating inhibitor antibody, the type of joint involved, the degree of synovial membrane hypertrophy and the presence of radiographic findings of joint degeneration (arthropathy).

⁹⁰Yttrium-hydroxyapatite: a new therapeutic option for radioactive synovectomy in haemophilic synovitis

Recurrent haemarthroses often lead to chronic synovitis in patients with haemophilia and von Willebrand disease. Radioactive synovectomy with yttrium-90 (⁹⁰Y) citrate is frequently used to treat this complication, usually with good results. Since 2006, the Nuclear Energy Research Institute (IPEN, Sao Paulo, Brazil) has produced hydroxyapatite particles labelled with ⁹⁰Y for radioactive synovectomy. The aim of this study was to compare the results achieved by both forms of ⁹⁰Y in the treatment of haemophilic synovitis. We included 221 joints from 136 patients (age range: 6-20 years), treated by one of the two radiopharmaceuticals, at the Hemocenter of Mato Grosso, Brazil. The outcomes analysed were the annual frequency of haemarthrosis, articular pain and joint range of motion before and 1 year after RS. Similar results were achieved regardless of whether ⁹⁰Y hydroxyapatite or ⁹⁰Y citrate was used, and results were independent of the joint type, age, gender, radiologic stage and presence of inhibitors. ⁹⁰Y hydroxyapatite appears to be equivalent to the reference product ⁹⁰Y citrate in the treatment of chronic synovitis associated with bleeding disorders.